Examination of the DNA-binding ability of estrogen receptor in whole cells: implications for hormone-independent transactivation and the actions of antiestrogens

Mechanistic Investigation of Site-specific DNA Methylating Agents Targeting Breast Cancer Cells

We previously described the development of a DNA-alkylating compound that showed selective toxicity in breast cancer cells. This compound contained an estrogen receptor α (ERα)-binding ligand and a DNA-binding/methylating component that could selectively methylate the N3-position of adenines at adenine-thymine rich regions of DNA. Herein, we describe mechanistic investigations that demonstrate that this class of compounds facilitate the translocation of the ERα-compound complex to the nucleus and induce the expression of ERα target genes. We confirm that the compounds show selective toxicity in ERα-expressing cells, induce ERα localization in the nucleus, and verify the essential role of ERα in modulating the toxicity. Minor alterations in the compound structure significantly affects the DNA binding ability, which correlates to the DNA-methylating ability. These studies demonstrate the utility of DNA-alkylating compounds to accomplish targeted inhibition of the growth of specific cancer cells; an approach that may overcome shortcomings of currently used chemotherapy agents.

Synergistic effects of parabens on the induction of calbindin-D9k gene expression act via a progesterone receptor-mediated pathway in GH3 cells

Although the endocrine-disrupting bioactivity of parabens is weakly estrogenic (parabens are xenoestrogens), their combined synergistic effect is unknown. The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of methyl paraben (MP), ethyl paraben (EP), propyl paraben (PP), isopropyl paraben (IPP), butyl paraben (BP), and isobutyl paraben (IBP), either alone or in combination (MP + EP + PP + BP; PP + IPP; and BP + IBP) on the induction of the estrogenic biomarker gene, calbindin-D9k( CaBP-9k), in rat pituitary lactosomatotrophic GH3 cells. The expression of CaBP-9k mRNA and protein was analyzed using real-time PCR and Western blot analysis, respectively. After 24 h of treatment, a significant increase in CaBP-9k expression was observed. This was dependent upon the length of the paraben alkyl chains (shortest in MP and longest in IBP). Interestingly, the synergistic effects of these paraben combinations were observed at a dose (10−5 M) of these parabens, which induced the highest expression of CaBP-9k mRNA and protein. To investigate the involvement of estrogen receptors (ERs) and progesterone receptors (PRs), through which parabens exert their effects, the expression levels of ERα and PR-B were also examined. The expression of ERα mRNA and protein fluctuated after paraben treatment in GH3 cells, which was not significant. However, the expression level of ERα gene was induced when cotreated with 17β-estradiol (E2) and ICI 182, 780 (estrogen receptor antagonist). The different combinations of parabens induced the expression of the PR-B gene, which was abolished by cotreatment with ICI 182,780. The expression patterns of CaBP-9k and PR-B genes appeared to be similar in response to paraben treatments. This implied that CaBP-9k expression in GH3 cells may be induced by parabens via a PR-mediated pathway. Taken together, these results suggest that exposure to multiple parabens at low concentrations may increase their synergistic estrogenic activities in GH3 cells through a PR-mediated pathway.

What are comparative studies telling us about the mechanism of ERbeta action in the ERE-dependent E2 signaling pathway?

Estrogen hormone (E2) signaling is primarily conveyed by the estrogen receptors (ER) alpha and beta. ERs are encoded by two distinct genes and share varying degrees of domain-specific structural/functional similarities. ERs mediate a complex array of nuclear and non-nuclear events critical for the homeodynamic regulation of various tissue functions. The canonical nuclear signaling involves the interaction of ERalpha and ERbeta with specific DNA sequences, the so-called estrogen responsive elements (EREs). This interaction constitutes the initial step in ERE-dependent signaling in which ERbeta is a weaker transcription factor than ERalpha in response to E2. However, it remains unclear why transactivation potencies of ER subtypes differ. Studies suggest that the amino-terminus, the least conserved structural region, of ERbeta, but not that of ERalpha, impairs the ability of the receptor to bind to ERE independent of E2. Although the impaired ERbeta-ERE interaction contributes, it is not sufficient to explain the weak transactivation potency of the receptor. It appears that the lack of transactivation ability and of the capability of the amino-terminus of ERbeta, as opposed to that of ERalpha, to functionally interact with the carboxyl-terminal hormone-dependent activation domain is also critical for the receptor-specific activity. Thus, the structurally distinct amino-termini of ERs are important determinants in defining the function of ER-subtypes in the ERE-dependent pathway. This could differentially affect the physiology and pathophysiology of E2 signaling.

Chaperoning steroid hormone action

Those that efface themselves in the action tend to be forgotten. But molecular chaperones are always there, often serving as equal partners. Because of their intrinsic functional frailty, a large number of signaling molecules have come to depend on molecular chaperones, notably the Hsp90 chaperone machine. This applies to the subset of nuclear receptors that converts steroid hormone signals to transcriptional outputs. Steroid receptors appear to rely on the Hsp90 machine for folding, regulation of the allosteric switch and recycling. This review discusses the complexities of the chaperone machinery and the diversity of regulatory options afforded by this assistance for hormone action.

Interactions between the cytomegalovirus promoter and the estrogen response element: implications for design of estrogen-responsive reporter plasmids

We aimed to produce an estrogen-responsive reporter plasmid that would permit monitoring of estrogen receptor function in the uterus in vivo. The plasmid pBL-tk-CAT(+)ERE was induced by estrogen in bovine endometrial stromal cells. When the CAT gene was replaced by the secreted alkaline phosphatase SeAP, the resulting construct pBL-tk-SeAP(+)ERE remained estrogen responsive. However when the tk promoter was replaced by the cytomegalovirus (cmv) promoter, the resulting plasmid (pBL-cmv-SeAP(+)ERE) was not estrogen responsive. Inhibition of ERE function was not due to an effect in trans or due to lack of estrogen receptor. It was not due to an interaction between the cmv promoter and the SeAP gene. cmv promoter function was dependent on NF-kappaB, and mutagenesis in the NF-kappaB sites reduced basal reporter expression without imparting responsiveness to estrogen. A mutation in the TATA box also failed to impart estrogen responsiveness. Modeling of DNA accessibility indicated the ERE was inserted at a site accessible to transcription factors. We conclude that the cmv promoter inhibits ERE function in cis when the two sequences are located in the same construct, and that this effect does not involve an interaction between cmv and reporter gene, NF-kappaB sites or the TATA box, or DNA inaccessibility.

Binding of estrogen receptor beta to estrogen response element in situ is independent of estradiol and impaired by its amino terminus

The functions of 17beta-estradiol (E2) are mediated by estrogen receptor (ER) alpha and beta. ERs display similar DNA- and ligand-binding properties in vitro. However, ERbeta shows lower transcriptional activity than ERalpha from the estrogen response element (ERE)-dependent signaling. We predicted that distinct amino termini contribute to differences in transcription efficacies of ERs by affecting in situ ER-ERE interactions. We used chromatin immunoprecipitation and a novel in situ ERE competition assay, which is based on the ability of ER to compete for ERE binding with a designer activator that constitutively induces transcription from an ERE-driven reporter construct. Interference of activator-mediated transcription by unliganded or liganded ERs was taken as an indication of ER-ERE interaction. Results revealed that ERs interacted with ERE similarly in the absence of E2. However, E2 enhanced the ERE binding of ERalpha but not that of ERbeta. The removal of the amino terminus increased the ERbeta-ERE interaction independent of E2. The ERbeta amino terminus also prevented E2-mediated enhancement of the chimeric ERalpha-ERE interaction. Thus, the amino terminus of ERbeta impairs the binding of ERbeta to ERE. The abrogation of ligand-dependent activation function 2 of the amino-terminally truncated ERbeta resulted in the manifestation of E2 effect on ERbeta-ERE interaction. This implies that E2-mediated enhancement of ERbeta-ERE interaction is masked by the activation function 2, whereas the intact amino terminus is a dominant region that decreases the binding of ERbeta to ERE. Thus, ERbeta-ERE interaction is independent of E2 and is impaired by its amino terminus. These findings provide an additional explanation for differences between ERalpha and ERbeta functions that could differentially affect the physiology and pathophysiology of E2 signaling.

Rush hour at the promoter: how the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway polices the traffic flow of nuclear receptor-dependent transcription

Nuclear receptor-dependent transcription requires the functional activities of many proteins in order to achieve proper gene expression. Progress in understanding transcription mechanisms has revealed the unexpected involvement of the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway in the transcriptional process. In some instances, stabilization of the transcription protein augments the functional role or activation state of that protein, but other evidence supports the hypothesis that degradation of that factor may be required in order for transcription to proceed. Perhaps most peculiar is the observation that several yeast models support the uncoupling of ubiquitylation from concomitant proteasome-mediated degradation, with the former responsible for regulating posttranslational modification of histones and controlling differential recruitment of a transcription factor to distinct promoters. Additionally, the ATPases of the 19S proteasome regulatory cap have been shown to function in transcription elongation, independently of their role in proteolysis. This review summarizes and discusses progress thus far in integrating the disparate fields of ubiquitylation and proteasome-mediated protein degradation with gene transcription.

Estrogen receptor mutations in human disease

As early as the 1800s, the actions of estrogen have been implicated in the development and progression of breast cancer. The estrogen receptor (ER) was identified in the late 1950s and purified a few years later. However, it was not until the 1980s that the first ER was molecularly cloned, and in the mid 1990s, a second ER was cloned. These two related receptors are now called ERalpha and ERbeta, respectively. Since their discovery, much research has focused on identifying alterations within the coding sequence of these receptors in clinical samples. As a result, a large number of naturally occurring splice variants of both ERalpha and ERbeta have been identified in normal epithelium and diseased or cancerous tissues. In contrast, only a few point mutations have been identified in human patient samples from a variety of disease states, including breast cancer, endometrial cancer, and psychiatric diseases. To elucidate the mechanism of action for these variant isoforms or mutant receptors, experimental mutagenesis has been used to analyze the function of distinct amino acid residues in the ERs. This review will focus on ERalpha and ERbeta alterations in breast cancer.

Proliferation-stimulating effects of icaritin and desmethylicaritin in MCF-7 cells

Icariin, icaritin and desmethylicaritin are constituents of Epimedium with a similar structure to genistein and daidzein. Using the modified MCF-7 cell proliferation assay (E-SCREEN assessment system), these compounds were tested for their estrogen-like activities. Icaritin and desmethylicaritin, but not icariin, strongly stimulated the proliferation of MCF-7/BUS cells. Cell cycle analysis revealed that the proliferation stimulatory effect was associated with a marked increase in the number of MCF-7/BUS cells in S phase and a significant increase in the G2/M population, with effects similar to those of estradiol. These actions were dose dependent (range from 1 nM to 10 microM) and could be significantly inhibited by the specific estrogen receptor antagonist ICI 182,780 [7 alpha-[9(4,4,5,5,5-pentafluoropentyl)sulfinyl]nonyl)-estra-1,3,5(10)-triene-3,17beta-diol)]. The estrogen receptor-regulated progesterone receptor and PS2 mRNA levels were increased by treatment with icaritin or desmethylicaritin within 24 h and the effects were also reversed by ICI 182,780. It was concluded that icaritin and desmethylicaritin are novel phytoestrogens and that the estrogenic effects of icaritin and desmethylicaritin are mediated by the estrogen receptor.

Plant 2-arylobenzofurans demonstrate a selective estrogen receptor modulator profile

We have isolated from the plant Onobrychis ebenoides three novel arylobenzofurans with binding affinity for the estrogen receptor. In this study, we evaluated these arylobenzofurans, namely ebenfuran I, ebenfuran II and ebenfuran III for their potential selective estrogen receptor modulator (SERM)-like properties. We examined their ability, (1) to induce the insulin growth factor binding protein-3 (IGFBP-3) in MCF-7 breast cancer cells, (2) to stimulate differentiation and mineralization of osteoblastic cell culture by histochemical staining for alkaline phosphatase, Alizarin Red-S staining and calcium levels in the supernatants and (3) to inhibit cell proliferation of cervical adenocarcinoma (Hela) cells by use of the MTT assay. An estrogen receptor mediated effect was investigated by carrying out chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) assay on transient MCF-7 transfectants. Estradiol and the "pure" antiestrogen ICI 182780 were included to serve as control samples of the estrogenic and antiestrogenic effect respectively. Our data reveal that ebenfuran II is a highly potent SERM, exhibiting antiestrogenic activity in breast cancer cells via the estrogen receptor, estrogenic effect on osteoblasts and no stimulatory effect on cervix adenocarcinoma cells. In conclusion, our study is the first to demonstrate that plant derived arylobenzofurans show a SERM profile and may be considered for the prevention and treatment of diseases such as breast cancer, cervical cancer and osteoporosis.

Current status of estrogen receptors

Increasing knowledge on structure and function of estrogen receptors is providing information on the mechanism of action of estrogen agonists, as well as antagonists, and in understanding their tissue-selective action. However, there are still many factors associated with estrogen response which are poorly understood. Therefore, the task of designing a tissue-selective estrogen for use as a pharmaceutical in estrogen-dependent disorders remains an uncertain game. This review provides information on the current status of estrogen receptors for a better understanding.

Differential SERM effects on corepressor binding dictate ERalpha activity in vivo

Selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) show differential effects upon ERalpha activation function 1 (AF-1). Tamoxifen allows strong ERalpha AF-1 activity, whereas raloxifene allows less and ICI 182,780 (ICI) allows none. Here, we show that blockade of corepressor histone de-acetylase (HDAC) activity reverses the differential inhibitory effect of SERMs upon AF-1 activity in MCF-7 cells. This suggests that differential SERM repression of AF-1 involves HDAC-dependent corepressors. Consistent with this, ICI and raloxifene are more potent than tamoxifen in promoting ERalpha-dependent sequestration of progesterone receptor-associated corepressors. Moreover, ICI and raloxifene are more efficient than tamoxifen in promoting ERalpha binding to the corepressor N-CoR in vivo and in vitro. An ERalpha mutation (537X) that increases N-CoR binding in the presence of all SERMs blocks AF-1 activity. An ERalpha mutation (L379R) that decreases N-CoR binding increases AF-1 activity in the presence of ICI and raloxifene and reverses the effect of the 537X mutation. The 537X and L379R mutations also alter the ligand preference of ERalpha action at AP-1 sites and C3 complement, an action that also involves AF-1. Together, our results suggest that differential SERM effects on corepressor binding can explain differences in SERM effects on ERalpha activity. We propose a model for differential effects of SERMs on N-CoR binding.

Regulation of nuclear receptor transcriptional activity by a novel DEAD box RNA helicase (DP97)

We have identified a novel DEAD box RNA helicase (97 kDa, DP97) from a breast cancer cDNA library that interacts in a hormone-dependent manner with nuclear receptors and represses their transcriptional activity. DP97 has RNA-dependent ATPase activity, and mapping studies localize the interacting regions of DP97 and nuclear receptors to the C-terminal region of DP97 and the hormone binding/activation function-2 region of estrogen receptors (ER), as well as several other nuclear receptors. Repression by DP97 maps to a small region (amino acids 589-631) that has homology to a repression domain in the corepressor protein NCoR2/SMRTe. This region of DP97 is necessary and sufficient for its intrinsic repression activity. The N-terminal helicase region of DP97 is, however, dispensable for its transcriptional repressor activity. The knockdown of endogenous cellular DP97 by antisense DP97 or RNA interference (siRNA for DP97) results in significant enhancement of the expression of estradiol-ER-stimulated genes and attenuation of the repression of genes inhibited by the estradiol-ER. This implies that endogenous DP97 normally dampens stimulation and intensifies repression of estradiol-ER-regulated genes. Our findings add to the growing evidence that RNA helicases can associate with nuclear receptors and function as coregulators to modulate receptor transcriptional activity.

Kinetic analysis of estrogen receptor homo- and heterodimerization in vitro

The coexistence of ERalpha and ERbeta suggests that active receptor complexes are present as homo- or heterodimers. In addition each of three forms of active receptors may trigger different cellular responses. A real-time biosensor based on surface plasmon resonance was used as instrument to determine binding kinetics of homo- and heterodimerization of estrogen receptor alpha and beta. Partially purified full-length estrogen receptor alpha was expressed intracellularly as a C-terminal fusion to a hexa-histidine tag using the baculovirus-expression system. Purified estrogen receptor alpha and beta without tags were used as partners in the dimerization process. An association rate constant of 3.6 x 10(3) to 1.5 x 10(4)M(-1)s(-1) for the homodimer formation of ERalpha and 5.7 x 10(3) to 1.5 x 10(4)M(-1)s(-1) for the heterodimer formation was found assuming a pseudo first-order reaction kinetic. The equilibrium dissociation constant for homodimerization of ERalpha was 2.2 x 10(-8) to 5.4 x 10(-8) and 1.8 x 10(-8) to 2.6 x 10(-8)M for the heterodimer formation. The homo- and heterodimer formation was characterized by a slow association kinetics and kinetic rate constants were within the same range.

Functional interaction of estrogen receptor alpha and caveolin isoforms in neuronal SK-N-MC cells

Estrogen receptors (ERs) are expressed in neuronal cells and exhibit a wide variety of activities in the central nervous system. The actions of ERs are regulated in a hormone-dependent manner as well as by a number of co-activators and -repressors. A recently identified co-activator of ERalpha is caveolin-1 which has been shown to mediate the ligand-independent activation of this steroid receptor. In the present study we have demonstrated that neuronal SK-N-MC cells lacking functional ERalpha show high levels of caveolin-1/-2 specific transcripts and proteins. Ectopic expression of ERalpha in SK-N-MC cells leads to the transcriptional suppression of caveolin-1 and -2 genes. This silencing event is accompanied by changes in the methylation pattern of the caveolin-1 promoter. Certain CpG dinucleotides were methylated in the caveolin-1 promoter region of the SK-ERalpha cells whereas the same sites were non-methylated in control SK-N-MC cells, implicating a gene silencing mechanism including hypermethylation of DNA. In addition, inhibitors of methyltransferases or histone deacetylases, enzymes involved in the establishment and maintenance of silenced chromatin status, partially restored caveolin transcription in SK-ERalpha cells. In conclusion, our observations provide a possible mechanism of negative feedback regulation of ERalpha co-activator caveolin by the steroid receptor itself in this cellular model.

High level expression of full-length estrogen receptor in Escherichia coli is facilitated by the uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation, CCCP

The expression of high levels of full-length human estrogen receptor alpha (hERalpha) in Escherichia coli has proven difficult. We found that expression of the ER DNA binding domain is highly toxic to E. coli, resulting in rapid loss of the expression plasmid. Using a tightly regulated arabinose expression system and the antibiotic Timentin, we were able to overcome ER toxicity and express substantial levels of ER. The expressed ER exhibited protease cleavage at a single site near the N-terminus of the hinge region. Of the many measures we tested to eliminate ER cleavage, only addition of carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenyl-hydrazone (CCCP), an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation, completely blocked intracellular proteolysis of the ER. Using CCCP and our expression methods, full-length FLAG epitope-tagged hERalpha (fER) was expressed in E. coli at approximately 1 mg/l. The fER was purified to homogeneity in a single step by immunoaffinity chromatography with anti-FLAG monoclonal antibody. Purified full-length bacterial fER binds 17beta-estradiol with the same affinity as hER expressed in human cells (K(D) approximately 0.5 nM). At high concentrations of fER (20 nM), a bell-shaped estrogen binding curve with a Hill coefficient of 1.7 was seen. Bacterially-expressed fER exhibits a reduced affinity for the estrogen response element (ERE). Anti-FLAG antibody restores high affinity binding of the fER to the ERE, suggesting that impaired dimerization may be responsible for the reduced affinity of bacterially-expressed fER for the ERE. The use of Timentin and CCCP may provide a general method for high level bacterial expression of steroid/nuclear receptors and other proteins important in hormone action.

Identification and characterization of a novel factor that regulates quinone reductase gene transcriptional activity

The regulation of the quinone reductase (QR) gene as well as other genes involved in detoxification is known to be mediated by an electrophile/antioxidant response element (EpRE/ARE). We have previously observed that QR is up-regulated by the antiestrogen trans-hydroxytamoxifen in breast cancer cells. QR gene regulation by the antiestrogen-occupied estrogen receptor (ER) is mediated by the EpRE-containing region of the human QR gene, and the ER is one of the complex of proteins that binds to the EpRE. In an effort to further understand the mechanism for ER regulation of QR gene we identified other protein factors that regulate QR gene transcriptional activity in breast cancer cells. One of these protein factors, hPMC2 (human homolog of Xenopus gene which prevents mitotic catastrophe), directly binds to the EpRE and interacts with the ER in yeast genetic screening and in vitro assays. Interestingly hPMC2 interacts more strongly to ER beta when compared with ER alpha. In transient transfection assays using reporter constructs containing the EpRE, hPMC2 alone can slightly activate reporter in ER-negative MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells. The activation of QR gene activity by hPMC2 is enhanced in the presence of ER beta.

Mechanical strain activates estrogen response elements in bone cells

The involvement of the estrogen receptor in the early responses of bone cells to mechanical strain was investigated by subjecting subconfluent monolayer cultures of ROS.SMER #14 cells (ROS 17/2.8 cells stably transfected with additional ER alpha) to 17 beta-estradiol or a single short period of dynamic mechanical strain (600 cycles, 1 Hz). The basal proliferation rate of ROS.SMER #14 cells was similar to ROS 17/2.8 cells, whose proliferative responsiveness to strain and estrogen is similar to that of primary cultures of rat long bone-derived osteoblasts. At peak strains of 3400 mu epsilon, strain-related proliferation in ROS.SMER #14 cells was 1.4 times that of ROS 17/2.8 cells. At 10(-8) mol/L, 17 beta-estradiol-related proliferation was nearly twice greater. The ROS.SMER #14 cells were transiently transfected with an estrogen-responsive reporter, 2ERE-pS2-CAT, containing two consensus estrogen response elements (ERE) linked to a chloroamphenicol acetyl transferase gene. Strain increased normalized ERE-CAT activity threefold and estradiol (10(-8) mol/L) sixfold. Both strain-related and estradiol-related increases in proliferation and ERE-CAT activity were blocked by the estrogen antagonist ICI 182,780 (10(-6) mol/L). These data show that strain as well as estrogen stimulates increased proliferation in ROS 17/2.8 cells and increased ER alpha-related ERE activity in ROS cells transfected with ER alpha. Proliferation is greater in the cells with more estrogen receptors. Both strain- and estrogen-related proliferation and ERE activity are blocked by the estrogen antagonist ICI 182,780. This indicates that ROS cells' early responses to mechanical strain involve ER alpha and estrogen-responsive genes.

Estrogen receptor-KRAB chimeras are potent ligand-dependent repressors of estrogen-regulated gene expression

As an approach to targeted repression of genes of interest, we describe the development of human estrogen receptor (ER) alpha-KRAB repressor domain chimeras that are potent ligand-dependent repressors of the transcription of estrogen response element (ERE)-containing promoters and analyze their mechanisms of action. Repression by the KRAB domain was dominant over transactivation mediated by ER AF1 and AF2. An ERE and an ER ligand (estrogen or antiestrogen) were required for repression. Studies with several promoters and cell lines demonstrated that the presence of EREs, rather than the capacity for estrogen induction, determines the potential for repression of a gene by the KRAB-ERalpha-KRAB (KERK) chimera. A single consensus ERE was sufficient for repression, but the KERK chimera was unable to suppress transcription from the imperfect ERE in the native pS2 promoter. We recently reported mutations that enhance binding of a steroid receptor DNA-binding domain to the ERE. Introducing these mutations into wild-type ER enhanced transactivation from the pS2 ERE. Insertion of these mutations into KERK created the novel repressor KERK-3M, which is a potent repressor of both ER-induced and basal transcription on a promoter containing the pS2 ERE. These modified ER-KRAB chimeras should prove useful as new tools for the functional analysis and repression of ER-regulated genes.

Tamoxifen-bound estrogen receptor (ER) strongly interacts with the nuclear matrix protein HET/SAF-B, a novel inhibitor of ER-mediated transactivation

The estrogen receptor (ER) is a ligand-dependent transcription factor that acts in a cell- and promoter-specific manner. Evidence suggests that the activity of the ER can be regulated by a number of other stimuli (e.g. growth factors) and that the effects of the ER are modulated by nuclear factors termed coregulators. While the interplay among these factors may in part explain the pleiotropic effects elicited by the ER, there are several other less well described mechanisms of control, such as interactions with the nuclear matrix. Here we report that the nuclear matrix protein/scaffold attachment factor HET/SAF-B is an ER-interacting protein. ER and HET/SAF-B interact in in vitro binding assays, with HET binding to both the ER DNA-binding domain and the hinge region. Coimmunoprecipitation experiments reveal that HET/SAF-B and ER associate in cell lines in the presence or absence of estradiol, but binding is increased by the antiestrogen tamoxifen. HET/SAF-B enhances tamoxifen antagonism of estrogen-induced ER-mediated transactivation, but at high concentrations can inhibit both estrogen and tamoxifen-induced ER activity. HET/SAF-B-mediated repression of ER activity is dependent upon interaction with the ER-DBD. While the existence of high-affinity binding sites for the ER in the nuclear matrix has been known for some time, we now provide evidence of a specific nuclear matrix protein binding to the ER. Furthermore, our data showing that HET/SAF-B binds to ER particularly strongly in the presence of tamoxifen suggests that it may be important for the antagonist effect of tamoxifen.

BCAR1, a human homologue of the adapter protein p130Cas, and antiestrogen resistance in breast cancer cells

BACKGROUND

Treatment of breast cancer with the antiestrogen tamoxifen is effective in approximately one half of the patients with estrogen receptor-positive disease, but tumors recur frequently because of the development of metastases that are resistant to tamoxifen. We have previously shown that mutagenesis of human estrogen-dependent ZR-75-1 breast cancer cells by insertion of a defective retrovirus genome caused the cells to become antiestrogen resistant. In this study, we isolated and characterized the crucial gene at the breast cancer antiestrogen resistance 1 (BCAR1) locus.

METHODS/RESULTS

Transfer of the BCAR1 locus from retrovirus-mutated, antiestrogen-resistant cells to estrogen-dependent ZR-75-1 cells by cell fusion conferred an antiestrogen-resistant phenotype on the recipient cells. The complete coding sequence of BCAR1 was isolated by use of exon-trapping and complementary DNA (cDNA) library screening. Sequence analysis of human BCAR1 cDNA predicted a protein of 870 amino acids that was strongly homologous to rat p130Cas-adapter protein. Genomic analysis revealed that BCAR1 consists of seven exons and is located at chromosome 16q23.1. BCAR1 transcripts were detected in multiple human tissues and were similar in size to transcripts produced by retrovirus-mutated ZR-75-1 cells. Transfection of BCAR1 cDNA into ZR-75-1 cells again resulted in sustained cell proliferation in the presence of antiestrogens, confirming that BCAR1 was the responsible gene in the locus.

CONCLUSIONS

Overexpression of the BCAR1 gene confers antiestrogen resistance on human ZR-75-1 breast cancer cells. Overexpression of BCAR1 in retrovirus-mutated cells appears to result from activation of the gene's promoter. The isolation and characterization of this gene open new avenues to elucidating mechanisms by which the growth of human breast cancer becomes independent of estrogen.

Role of estrogen receptor ligand and estrogen response element sequence on interaction with chicken ovalbumin upstream promoter transcription factor (COUP-TF)

Estrogen-responsive genes are regulated by altering the balance of estrogen receptor (ER) interaction with transcription activators and inhibitors. Here we examined the role of ER ligand on ER interaction with the Chicken Ovalbumin Upstream Promoter Transcription Factor (COUP-TF) orphan nuclear receptor. COUP-TF binding to half-site estrogen response elements (EREs) was increased by the addition of estradiol (E2) -liganded ER (E2-ER), but not by ER liganded with the antiestrogens 4-hydroxytamoxifen (4-OHT-ER) or tamoxifen aziridine (TAz-ER). ER did not bind to single half-sites. Conversely, COUP-TF enhanced the ERE binding of purified E2-ER, but did not affect TAz-ER-ERE binding. In contrast, only antiestrogens enhanced direct interaction between ER and COUP-TF as assessed by GST pull-down assays. Identical results were obtained using either purified bovine or recombinant human ERalpha. Co-immunoprecipitation assays showed that ER and COUP-TF interact in extracts from MCF-7 and ERalpha-transfected MDA-MB-231 cells. Here we document that ER ligand impacts COUP-TF-ER interaction. COUP-TF interaction is mediated by the DNA binding and ligand-binding domains of ER. We suggest that changes in ER conformation induced by DNA binding reduce ER-COUP-TF interaction. Transient transfection of human MCF-7 breast cancer cells with a COUP-TFI expression vector repressed E2-induced luciferase reporter gene expression from single or multiple tandem copies of a consensus ERE. COUP-TFI stimulated 4-OHT-induced luciferase activity from a minimal ERE. Alone, COUP-TFI increased transcription from ERE half-sites or a single ERE in a sequence-dependent manner. These data provide evidence that the ERE sequence and its immediate flanking regions influence whether COUP-TF enhances, inhibits, or has no effect on ER ligand-induced ERE reporter gene expression and that COUP-TFI activates gene transcription from ERE half-sites. We suggest that COUP-TFI plays a role in mitigating estrogen-responsive gene expression.

Coactivator peptides have a differential stabilizing effect on the binding of estrogens and antiestrogens with the estrogen receptor

The effectiveness of estrogens in stimulating gene transcription mediated by the estrogen receptor (ER) appears to depend on ER interactions with coactivator proteins. These coactivators bind to ER when it is liganded with an estrogen agonist, but not when it is liganded with an estrogen antagonist. Because estrogen agonists are known to induce a conformation in ER that stabilizes coactivator binding, we asked whether coactivator binding to ER causes a reciprocal stabilization of agonist ligand binding. We used a fluorescent ligand for ER, tetrahydrochrysene-ketone, to monitor the rates of ligand dissociation from ERalpha and ERbeta, and to see how this process is affected by the p160-class coactivator, steroid receptor coactivator-1 (SRC-1). We used a 15-amino acid peptide corresponding to the second nuclear receptor box LXXLL motif in SRC-1 (NR-2 peptide), which is known to interact with the ER ligand-binding domain, a mutant peptide with an LXXAL sequence (NR-2A peptide), and a 203-amino acid fragment of SRC-1, termed the nuclear receptor domain (SRC1-NRD), embodying all three of the internal NR boxes of this protein. Both the NR-2 peptide and the SRC1-NRD fragment markedly slow the rate of dissociation of the agonist ligands tetrahydrochrysene-ketone, estradiol, and diethylstilbestrol, increasing the half-life of the ER-agonist complex by up to 50- to 60-fold. The SRC1-NRD has much higher potency in retarding ligand dissociation than does the NR-2 peptide; it is maximally effective at 30 nM, and it appears to bind with the stoichiometry of one SRC1-NRD per ER dimer. The peptides had little effect on the dissociation rate of antagonist ligands. Consistent with these results, we find that increasing the concentration of SRC-1 in cells by transfection of an expression plasmid encoding SRC-1 causes a 17-fold increase in the potency of estradiol in an estrogen-responsive reporter gene transcription assay. Thus, there is multifactorial control over receptor-coactivator interaction, its strength being determined by the agonist vs. antagonist nature of the ligand and the particular structure of the agonist ligand, and by the receptor subtype and the NR box sequence. The stabilizing effect of coactivator on ER-agonist ligand complexes may be important in determining the potency of estrogen agonists in a cell and may also underlie the tissue-selective pharmacology of certain synthetic estrogens.

The estrogen receptor enhances AP-1 activity by two distinct mechanisms with different requirements for receptor transactivation functions

Estrogen receptors (ERs alpha and beta) enhance transcription in response to estrogens by binding to estrogen response elements (EREs) within target genes and utilizing transactivation functions (AF-1 and AF-2) to recruit p160 coactivator proteins. The ERs also enhance transcription in response to estrogens and antiestrogens by modulating the activity of the AP-1 protein complex. Here, we examine the role of AF-1 and AF-2 in ER action at AP-1 sites. Estrogen responses at AP-1 sites require the integrity of the ERalpha AF-1 and AF-2 activation surfaces and the complementary surfaces on the p160 coactivator GRIP1 (glucocorticoid receptor interacting protein 1), the NID/AF-1 region, and NR boxes. Thus, estrogen-liganded ERalpha utilizes the same protein-protein contacts to transactivate at EREs and AP-1 sites. In contrast, antiestrogen responses are strongly inhibited by ERalpha AF-1 and weakly inhibited by AF-2. Indeed, ERalpha truncations that lack AF-1 enhance AP-1 activity in the presence of antiestrogens, but not estrogens. This phenotype resembles ERbeta, which naturally lacks constitutive AF-1 activity. We conclude that the ERs enhance AP-1 responsive transcription by distinct mechanisms with different requirements for ER transactivation functions. We suggest that estrogen-liganded ER enhances AP-1 activity via interactions with p160s and speculate that antiestrogen-liganded ER enhances AP-1 activity via interactions with corepressors.

Analysis of estrogen response element binding by genetically selected steroid receptor DNA binding domain mutants exhibiting altered specificity and enhanced affinity

To analyze the role of amino acids in the steroid receptor DNA binding domain (DBD) recognition helix in binding of the receptor to the estrogen response element (ERE), we adapted the powerful P22 challenge phage selection system for use with a vertebrate protein. We used the progesterone receptor DNA binding domain and selected for mutants that gained the ability to bind to the ERE. We used a mutagenesis protocol based on degenerate oligonucleotides to create a large and diverse pool of mutants in which 10 nonconsensus amino acids in the DNA recognition helix of the progesterone receptor DNA binding domain were randomly mutated. After a single cycle of modified P22 challenge phage selection, 37 mutant proteins were identified, all of which lost the ability to bind to the progesterone response element. In gel mobility shift assays, approximately 70% of the genetically selected mutants bound to the consensus ERE with a >4-fold higher affinity than the naturally occurring estrogen receptor DBD. In the P-box region of the DNA recognition helix, the selected mutants contained the amino acids found in the wild-type estrogen receptor DBD, as well as other amino acid combinations seen in naturally occurring steroid/nuclear receptors that bind the aGGTCA half-site. We also obtained high affinity DBDs with Trp(585) as the first amino acid of the P-box, although this is not found in the known steroid/nuclear receptors. In the linker region between the two zinc fingers, G597R was by far the most common mutation. In transient transfections in mammalian cells using promoter interference assays, the mutants displayed enhanced affinity for the ERE. When linked to an activation domain, the transfected mutants activated transcription from ERE-containing reporter genes. We conclude that the P-box amino acids can display considerable variation and that the little studied linker amino acids play an important role in determining affinity for the ERE. This work also demonstrates that the P22 challenge phage genetic selection system, modified for use with a mammalian protein, provides a novel, single cycle selection for steroid/nuclear receptor DBDs with altered specificity and greatly enhanced affinity for their response elements.

The evolving role of specific estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs)

Estrogens are the most effective therapy for women with postmenopausal problems. However, relatively few women use estrogen and then often for a limited time because of the fear of its carcinogenic effects on the uterus and breast; in addition, estrogen is not advised for women who have had breast cancer. Selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) are agents with antagonist action on the uterus and breast and agonist action on the bones, cardiovascular system, and brain. Unlike estrogens, however, existing SERMs do not help alleviate the vasomotor and urogenital problems associated with menopause. A comprehensive review of the literature published from January 1995 to June 1999 was conducted. Reports were identified using Medline and Cancer Lit. The effect of menopausal problems on the health of women and the socioeconomic effects of menopause are discussed. All currently available and investigational SERMs are reviewed and discussed, including their mechanism of action, metabolism, dose scheduling, antitumor activity, and potential role in maintaining the health of menopausal women and in preventing breast cancer.

Estrogen receptor regulation of the Na+/H+ exchange regulatory factor

To better understand the actions of estrogens and antiestrogens in estrogen target cells, we have searched for estrogen-regulated genes in human breast cancer cells, in which the number of genes known to be directly activated by estrogen is quite small. Using differential display RNA methods, we have identified the human homolog of the Na+ -H+ exchanger regulatory factor (NHE-RF), an approximately 50-kDa protein that is also an ezrin-radixin-moesin-binding phosphoprotein, as being under rapid and direct regulation by estrogen in estrogen receptor (ER)-containing breast cancer cells. Stimulation by estrogen of NHE-RF RNA is rapid, being near maximal (approximately 6-fold) by 1 h, and is not blocked by cycloheximide, indicating that it is a primary response. Stimulation is selective for estrogen ligands, with no stimulation by other classes of steroid hormones, and stimulation by estrogen is suppressed by the antiestrogens tamoxifen and ICI 182,780. Induction is shown to require an active ER through several approaches, including the use of ER-negative breast cancer cells containing a stably integrated ER. NHE-RF protein levels, monitored using antibodies specific for this protein, increase after estrogen and reach maximal levels at 24-48 h. Interestingly, NHE-RF is a PDZ domain-containing protein that is enriched in polarized epithelia, where it is known to be localized in microvilli. Among various human tissues we have examined, we found that NHE-RF is expressed at a fairly high level in mammary tissue. NHE-RF regulates protein kinase A inhibition of the Na+ -H+ exchanger and may serve as a scaffold adaptor protein that contributes to the specificity of signal transduction events. Our findings suggest that the early, known effects of estrogen on cell cytoarchitecture (e.g. increasing microvilli on breast cancer cells) and on some cell signaling pathways (e.g. those involving cAMP) may involve rapid estrogen-mediated changes in the production of NHE-RF.

Chromatin structure of the regulatory regions of pS2 and cathepsin D genes in hormone-dependent and -independent breast cancer cell lines

We have compared the DNase I hypersensitivity of the regulatory region of two estrogen-regulated genes, pS2 and cathepsin D in hormone-dependent and -independent breast carcinoma cell lines. This strategy allowed the identification of two important control regions, one in pS2 and the other in cathepsin D genes. In the hormone-dependent MCF7 cell line, within the pS2 gene 5'-flanking region, we detected two major DNase I hypersensitive sites, induced by estrogens and/or IGFI: pS2-HS1, located in the proximal promoter and pS2-HS4, located -10.5 Kb from the CAP site, within a region that has not been cloned. The presence of these two DNase I hypersensitive sites correlates with pS2 expression. Interestingly in MCF7 cells, estrogens and IGFI induced indistinguishable chromatin structural changes over the pS2 regulatory region, suggesting that the two transduction-pathways converge to a unique chromatin target. In two cell lines that do not express pS2, MDA MB 231, a hormone-independent cell line that lacks the estrogen receptor alpha, and HE5, a cell line derived from MDA MB 231 by transfection that expresses estrogen receptor alpha, there was only one hormone-independent DNase I hypersensitive site. This site, pS2-HS2, was located immediately upstream of pS2-HS1. In MCF7 cells, two major DNase I hypersensitive sites were present in the 5'-flanking sequences of the cathepsin D gene, which is regulated by estrogens in these cells. These sites, catD-HS2 and catD-HS3, located at positions -2.3 Kb and -3.45 Kb, respectively, were both hormone-independent. A much weaker site, catD-HS1, covered the proximal promoter. In MDA MB 231 cells, that express cathepsin D constitutively, we detected an additional strong hormone-independent DNase I hypersensitive site, catD-HS4, located at position -4.3 Kb. This region might control the constitutive over-expression of cathepsin D in hormone-independent breast cancer cells. All together, these data demonstrate that a local reorganization of the chromatin structure over pS2 and cathepsin D promoters accompanies the establishment of the hormone-independent phenotype of the cells.

Mutations in the AF-2/hormone-binding domain of the chimeric activator GAL4.estrogen receptor.VP16 inhibit hormone-dependent transcriptional activation and chromatin remodeling in yeast

GAL4.estrogen receptor.VP16 (GAL4.ER.VP16), which contains the GAL4 DNA-binding domain, the human ER hormone binding (AF-2) domain, and the VP16 activation domain, functions as a hormone-dependent transcriptional activator in yeast (Louvion, J.-F., Havaux-Copf, B., and Picard, D. (1993) Gene (Amst.) 131, 129-134). Previously, we showed that this activator can remodel chromatin in yeast in a hormone-dependent manner. In this work, we show that a weakened VP16 activation domain in GAL4.ER.VP16 still allows hormone-dependent chromatin remodeling, but mutations in the AF-2 domain that abolish activity in the native ER also eliminate the ability of GAL4.ER.VP16 to activate transcription and to remodel chromatin. These findings suggest that an important role of the AF-2 domain in the native ER is to mask the activation potential of the AF-1 activation domain in the unliganded state; upon ligand activation, a conformational change releases AF-2-mediated repression and transcriptional activation ensues. We also show that the AF-2 domain, although inactive at simple promoters on its own in yeast, can enhance transcription by the MCM1 activator in hormone-dependent manner, consistent with its having a role in activation as well as repression in the native ER.

Classification of breast cancer cells on the basis of a functional assay for estrogen receptor

BACKGROUND

The receptor (ER) for estrogen (E2) is routinely assayed as a marker to determine the feasibility of anti-hormone therapy against breast cancer because ER-positive (ER+) tumors are much more likely to respond to anti-hormone therapy than are ER-negative (ER-). However 40% of ER+ breast cancer patients do not respond to anti-hormone therapy. We suggest that this unpredictability of therapeutic responses lies in the current ER assays, which measure only an initial component of the E2-responsive pathway, and that the difference depends upon altered downstream processes. We propose a functional criterion that subclassifies breast cancers on the basis of specific binding of ER to its cognate DNA sequence, the estrogen response element (ERE).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

ER was identified in breast cancer cell lines by immunofluorescence assay, Western blot analysis, identification of ER-specific mRNA, and by interaction of the ER-ERE complex with three different ER-specific antibodies. ER-ERE complex formation was measured by electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA). Transactivation of the E2-responsive gene was studied by transfection of cells with fusion gene construct with the promoter-containing ERE sequence and assay of reporter gene activity in the cell extracts.

RESULTS

The growth of ER+ T47D cells was sensitive to tamoxifen, ICI-182,780, and ethynyl estradiol (EE2), whereas another ER+ breast cancer cell line, 21 PT, was resistant to these compounds. The estrogen receptor (ER) in the nuclear extracts of MCF-7 and T47D demonstrated hormone-dependent interaction with the response element (ERE) and also downstream transactivation of the E2-responsive PS2 promoter. But in the 21 PT cell line that was designated as ER- on the basis of ligand-binding assay and was found to be ER+ by all the other ER assays, ER-ERE interaction and PS2 promoter transactivation were independent of hormone.

CONCLUSIONS

On the basis of the downstream functional assay of ER interaction with ERE, ER+ breast tumor cells can be subclassified into two categories. The first is E2-dependent (ERd+) and these cells should respond to anti-hormone therapy. The second type of ER interacts with ERE independent of E2 (ERi+) and constitutively transactivates responsive genes. It is predicted that the latter type of breast cancers will not respond to antihormone therapy.

The antagonists RU486 and ZK98299 stimulate progesterone receptor binding to deoxyribonucleic acid in vitro and in vivo, but have distinct effects on receptor conformation

Three types of transfection experiments were used to detect the abilities of different classes of antagonists to stimulate binding of progesterone receptor (PR) to progesterone response elements (PRE) in intact mammalian cells. These included a promoter interference assay, in which PR binding to PREs positioned between the TATA box and the start of transcription is detected as a reduction of expression of a constitutively active reporter gene, competition of PR antagonist and glucocorticoid receptor agonist for a common glucocorticoid response element/PRE-controlled reporter construct, and activation of a chimeric receptor (PR-VP16) containing the constitutive trans-activation domain derived from the VP16 protein of herpes simplex virus. By each approach, all antagonists tested were equally effective in stimulating PR binding to PREs in the cell. This included previously designated type I (ZK98299) and type II (RU486, ZK98734, and ZK112993) 11beta-aryl substituted steroid analogs. Stimulation of PR binding to PREs in the cell by ZK98299 was of interest because this antagonist has been reported to lack the ability to stimulate PR-DNA binding in vitro by electrophoretic gel mobility shift assay compared with RU486, which promotes efficient binding of PR to PREs. To clarify the apparent discrepancy between intact cell and in vitro results with ZK98299, we altered electrophoretic gel mobility shift assay conditions to allow detection of less stable DNA complexes. Under these conditions, ZK98299 induced the formation of specific PR-PRE complexes. Further analysis of the ZK98299-induced DNA complexes revealed that they exhibited an electrophoretic mobility different from that of the complexes induced by RU486, and the off-rate of PR from DNA was faster than that of the PR bound to agonist. This suggests that ZK98299 promotes a conformational change within PR distinct from that induced by RU486. The present results are consistent with the conclusions that ZK98299 stimulates PR binding to target DNA sequences and that ZK98299 and RU486 represent two mechanistic classes of antagonists based on inducing different conformational changes in PR.

Equilibrium binding of estrogen receptor with DNA using fluorescence anisotropy

Interaction of estrogen receptor (ER) with DNA sequences known as estrogen response elements (ERE) is required for estrogen regulation of the expression of target genes. To characterize the affinity and specificity of ER interaction with ERE sequences in vitro under equilibrium conditions, fluorescence anisotropy assays were performed using recombinant, purified ER and a fluorescein-labeled 35-base pair oligonucleotide bearing an idealized palindromic ERE. In buffer containing 100 mM KCl, the baculovirus-expressed, purified human ER bound with similar affinity to the consensus ERE and a mutant ERE with a single base pair change per half-site. Above 225 mM KCl, ER exhibited discrimination between the consensus and mutated ERE targets. Between 225 and 275 mM KCl, binding to the consensus ERE was independent of salt concentration and occurred with an equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) of 1.8 +/- 0.6 nM, whereas binding to the mutant ERE was not detected at ER concentrations below 100 nM under the same conditions. At 300 mM KCl, the Kd for the consensus ERE increased approximately 25-fold, suggesting complex salt concentration dependence. Both estrogen-occupied and unoccupied ER bound to the consensus ERE sequence with similar affinity, indicating that estrogen affects ER activity at a step other than DNA binding. Unlike the full-length ER, the recombinant DNA binding domain of ER did not discriminate between the consensus and mutated ERE sequences even at buffer salt concentrations greater than 200 mM NaCl, suggesting that ER sequences outside the DNA binding domain may be important in promoting specific binding.

Long-term inhibitory effects of a novel anti-estrogen on the growth of ZR-75-1 and MCF-7 human breast cancer tumors in nude mice

The effects of the novel anti-estrogen EM-343 on the growth of 2 hormone-responsive human breast cancer tumors have been examined in athymic nude mice. At the low daily dose of 5 microg, EM-343 administered subcutaneously for 6 months completely blocked the stimulatory effect of endogenous estrogens on the growth of ZR-75-1 and MCF-7 tumors implanted in nude mice. In addition, uterine weight decreased by 60% while ovarian weight increased by 37%. Estrogen receptor (ER) levels measured by [3H]-labeled estrogen binding were markedly reduced (by 96%, 96% and 92%) in ZR-75-1 and MCF-7 tumors, and in the mouse uterus, respectively. Accompanying the decrease in ER, progesterone receptor levels were reduced by 79%, 87% and 76%, respectively, in the above-mentioned tissues following EM-343 treatment. Our data show the pure anti-estrogenic properties of EM-343 and its high potency as an inhibitor of growth of human ZR-75-1 and MCF-7 breast tumors in nude mice.

Molecular and kinetic basis for the mixed agonist/antagonist activity of estriol

Estriol acts as a weak estrogen when administered in a single dose into immature or ovariectomized laboratory animals, but produces full estrogenic responses upon chronic administration. However, when estriol is injected together with estradiol it acts as an antiestrogen. We studied the dual agonist/antagonist properties of estriol, using recombinant human estrogen receptor (hER) in ligand-binding assay, cell-free transcription assay, electrophoretic mobility shift assay with cVitII estrogen response element (ERE), and ERE-Sepharose chromatography. We show that the weak estrogenic activity of estriol results from impaired hER-ERE interaction. The antiestrogenic activity of estriol was demonstrated in a cell-free transcription assay where it reduced estradiol-dependent transcription in a dose-dependent manner. Estriol interfered with estradiol-induced positive cooperative binding and receptor dimerization, and binding of hER complexes to ERE. These effects of estriol were maximal at a 10-fold molar excess over estradiol; under these conditions estradiol-dependent transcription was decreased by 85%, although [3H]estradiol binding was reduced by only 50%. We propose that when hER, estradiol, and estriol are coequilibrated, several receptor species are formed: unliganded hER monomers and dimers; estradiol-hER monomers and dimers, estriol-hER monomers and dimers; and presumably mixed estradiol-estriol dimers. Since estrogen-hER complexes bind cooperatively to ERE sequences, the concentrations of transcriptionally active complexes (estriol- and estradiol-hER dimers) are reduced to low levels that fail to bind cooperatively with ERE and initiate transcription. We discuss our results in relation to the massive estriol production during pregnancy and to the "Estriol Hypothesis" on the protective role for estriol in opposing carcinogenic effects of estradiol.

Human estrogen receptor beta binds DNA in a manner similar to and dimerizes with estrogen receptor alpha

The cloning of a novel estrogen receptor beta (denoted ERbeta) has recently been described (Kuiper, G. G. J. M., Enmark, E., Pelto-Huikko, M., Nilsson, S., and Gustafsson, J-A. (1996) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 93, 5925-5930 and Mosselman, S., Polman, J. , and Dijkema, R. (1996) FEBS Lett. 392, 49-53). ERbeta is highly homologous to the "classical" estrogen receptor alpha (here referred to as ERalpha), has been shown to bind estrogens with an affinity similar to that of ERalpha, and activates expression of reporter genes containing estrogen response elements in an estrogen-dependent manner. Here we describe functional studies comparing the DNA binding abilities of human ERalpha and beta in gel shift assays. We show that DNA binding by ERalpha and beta are similarly affected by elevated temperature in the absence of ligand or in the presence of 17beta-estradiol and the partial estrogen agonist 4-hydroxy-tamoxifen. In the absence of ligand, DNA binding by ERalpha and beta is rapidly lost at 37 degrees C, while in the presence of 17beta-estradiol and 4-hydroxy-tamoxifen, the loss in DNA binding at elevated temperature is much more gradual. We show that the loss in DNA binding is not due to degradation of the receptor proteins. However, while the complete antagonist ICI 182, 780 does not "protect" human ERalpha (hERalpha) from loss of DNA binding at elevated temperature in vitro, it does appear to protect human ERbeta (hERbeta), suggestive of differences in the way ICI 182, 780 acts on hERalpha and beta. We further report that ERalpha and beta can dimerize with each other, the DNA binding domain of hERalpha being sufficient for dimerization with hERbeta. Cell and promoter-specific transcription activation by ERalpha has been shown to be dependent on the differential action of the N- and C-terminal transcription activation functions AF-1 and AF-2, respectively. The existence of a second estrogen receptor gene and the dimerization of ERalpha and beta add greater levels of complexity to transcription activation in response to estrogens.

Interaction of androgen receptors with androgen response element in intact cells. Roles of amino- and carboxyl-terminal regions and the ligand

Promoter interference assay was employed to examine in intact cells the roles of the functional domains of androgen receptor (AR) and the ligand for specific DNA interactions using a cytomegalovirus-(androgen response element)-chloramphenicol acetyltransferase reporter (pCMV-ARE2-CAT). Native rat and human ARs interfered with pCMV-ARE2-CAT expression in a hormone-dependent fashion. Low steroid-independent interference seemed to occur because of the ligand binding domain (LBD), which was transcriptionally inhibitory also in a heterologous context. AR devoid of LBD (rARDelta641-902) decreased pCMV-ARE2-CAT activity by 50%. The rARDelta46-408 mutant devoid of the NH2-terminal transcription activation region exhibited ligand-dependent promoter interference of a similar magnitude. Ligand and DNA binding-deficient mutants (hARM807R and rARC562G, respectively) did not influence pCMV-ARE2-CAT expression, although hARM807R binds to ARE in vitro. Non-steroidal anti-androgens casodex and hydroxyflutamide antagonized agonist-dependent promoter interference, whereas cyproterone acetate, RU 56187, RU 57073, and RU 59063 were partial agonists/antagonists. Collectively, interaction of ARs with ARE in intact cells does not require the presence of the COOH-terminal or NH2-terminal domain and/or their interaction. In the context of native AR, however, the androgen-induced conformational change in LBD is mandatory for generation of a transcriptionally competent receptor that binds to DNA in intact cells.

Coactivator and corepressor regulation of the agonist/antagonist activity of the mixed antiestrogen, 4-hydroxytamoxifen

Mixed antiestrogens, such as 4-hydroxytamoxifen (4HT), act as either partial agonists or antagonists of estrogen receptor (ER) function in a tissue-, cell-, and promoter-specific manner, suggesting that intracellular factors modulate their ability to regulate transcription. To determine whether coactivators and corepressors have the capacity to modulate the relative agonist/antagonist activity of 4HT, ER-dependent gene expression was measured in the absence or presence of expression vectors for SRC-1 (steroid receptor coactivator-1) or SMRT (silencing mediator of retinoic acid and thyroid hormone receptors). In Hep G2 cells in which 4HT is an agonist, exogenous SRC-1 enhanced estradiol (E2)- and 4HT-stimulated transcription in a dose-dependent manner, while SMRT overexpression strongly reduced basal and 4HT-stimulated gene expression with no effect on E2 activity. These observations were not cell- or promoter-specific inasmuch as similar results were obtained in HeLa cells under conditions in which 4HT is an antagonist. A protein-protein interaction assay indicated that the full-length ER binds to SMRT in vitro. To assess whether relative coactivator and corepressor expression within a given cell could modulate the balance of 4HT agonist/antagonist activity, SRC-1 and SMRT were coexpressed. SMRT overexpression blocked SRC-1 coactivation of 4HT-stimulated gene expression and preferentially inhibited 4HT agonist activity whether or not exogenous SRC-1 was present. The cumulative data in this model system indicate that the relative expression of coactivators and corepressors can modulate 4HT regulation of ER transcriptional activity and suggest they could contribute to the tissue-specific ability of mixed antiestrogens to activate or inhibit ER-mediated gene expression.

Chromatin remodeling by transcriptional activation domains in a yeast episome

We examine the generality of transcription factor-mediated chromatin remodeling by monitoring changes in chromatin structure in a yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) episome outside of the context of a natural promoter. The episome has a well defined chromatin structure and a binding site for the transcription factor GAL4 but lacks a nearby functional TATA element or transcription start site, so that changes in chromatin structure are unlikely to be caused by transcription. To separate changes caused by binding and by activation domains, we use both GAL4 and a chimeric, hormone-dependent activator consisting of the GAL4 DNA-binding domain, an estrogen receptor (ER) hormone-binding domain, and a VP16 activation domain (Louvion, J.-F., Havaux-Copf, B. and Picard, D. (1993) Gene (Amst.) 131, 129-134). Both GAL4 and GAL4.ER.VP16 show very little perturbation of chromatin structure in their nonactivating configurations. Substantial additional perturbation occurs upon activation. This additional perturbation is marked by changes in micrococcal nuclease cleavage patterns, restriction endonuclease accessibility, and DNA topology and is not seen with the nonactivating derivative GAL4.ER. Remodeling by GAL4.ER.VP16 is detectable within 15 min following hormone addition and is complete within 45 min, suggesting that replication is not required. We conclude that activation domains can exert a major influence on chromatin remodeling by increasing binding affinity and/or by recruitment of other chromatin remodeling activities and that this remodeling can occur outside the context of a bona fide promoter.

Estrogen receptor ligands modulate its interaction with DNA

The estrogen receptor (ER) belongs to a superfamily of ligand-inducible transcription factors. Functions of these proteins (dimerization, DNA binding, and interaction with other transcription factors) are modulated by binding of their corresponding ligands. It is, however, controversial whether various ER ligands affect the receptor's ability to bind its specific DNA element (ERE). By using real time interaction analysis we have investigated the kinetics of human (h)ER binding to DNA in the absence and presence of 17beta-estradiol, 17alpha-ethynyl estradiol, analogs of tamoxifen, raloxifene, and ICI-182,780. We show that ligand binding dramatically influences the kinetics of hER interaction with specific DNA. We have found that binding of estradiol induces the rapid formation of a relatively unstable ER.ERE complex, and binding of ICI-182,780 leads to slow formation (ka is approximately 10 times lower) of a stable receptor-DNA complex (kd is almost 2 orders of magnitude lower). Therefore, binding of estradiol accelerates the frequency of receptor-DNA complex formation more than 50-fold, compared with unliganded ER, and more than 1000-fold compared with ER liganded with ICI-182,780. We hypothesize that a correlation exists between the rate of gene transcription and the frequency of receptor-DNA complex formation. We further show that a good correlation exists between the kinetics of hER-ERE interaction induced by a ligand and its biological effect.

Direct study of DNA-protein interactions in repressed and active chromatin in living cells

Current methods for analysis of chromatin architecture are invasive, utilizing chemicals or nucleases that damage DNA, making detection of labile constituents and conclusions about true in vivo structure problematic. We describe a sensitive assay of chromatin structure which is performed in intact, living yeast. The approach utilizes expression of SssI DNA methyltransferase (MTase) in Saccharomyces cerevisiae to provide an order-of-magnitude increase in resolution over previously introduced MTases. Combining this resolution increase with the novel application of a PCR-based, positive chemical display of modified cytosines provides a significant advance in the direct study of DNA-protein interactions in growing cells that enables quantitative footprinting. The validity and efficacy of the strategy are demonstrated in mini-chromosomes, where positioned nucleosomes and a labile, operator-bound repressor are detected. Also, using a heterologous system to study gene activation, we show that in vivo hormone occupancy of the estrogen receptor is required for maximal site-specific DNA binding, whereas, at very high receptor-expression levels, hormone-independent partial occupancy of an estrogen-responsive element was observed. Receptor binding to a palindromic estrogen-responsive element leads to a footprint with strand-specific asymmetry, which is explicable by known structural information.

Response-specific antiestrogen resistance in a newly characterized MCF-7 human breast cancer cell line resulting from long-term exposure to trans-hydroxytamoxifen

To understand better the antiestrogen-resistant phenotype that frequently develops in breast cancer patients receiving tamoxifen, we cultured MCF-7 breast cancer cells long-term (>1 yr) in the presence of the antiestrogen trans-hydroxytamoxifen (TOT) to generate a subline refractory to the growth-suppressive effects of TOT. This subline (designated MCF/TOT) showed growth stimulation, rather than inhibition, with TOT and diminished growth stimulation with estradiol (E2), yet remained as sensitive as the parental cells to growth suppression by another antiestrogen, ICI 164,384. Estrogen receptor (ER) levels were maintained at 40% of that in parent MCF-7 cells, but MCF/TOT cells failed to show an increase in progesterone receptor content in response to E2 or TOT treatment. In contrast, the MCF/TOT subline behaved like parental cells in terms of E2 and TOT regulation of ER and pS2 expression and transactivation of a transiently transfected estrogen-responsive gene construct. DNA sequencing of the hormone binding domain of the ER from both MCF-7 and MCF/TOT cells confirmed the presence of wild-type ER and exon 5 and exon 7 deletion splice variants, but showed no point mutations. Compared to the parental cells, the MCF/TOT subline showed reduced sensitivity to the growth-suppressive effects of retinoic acid and complete resistance to exogenous TGF-beta1. The altered growth responsiveness of MCF/TOT cells to TOT and TGF-beta1 was partly to fully reversible following TOT withdrawal for 16 weeks. Our findings underscore the fact that antiestrogen resistance is response-specific; that loss of growth suppression by TOT appears to be due to the acquisition of weak growth stimulation; and that resistance to TOT does not mean global resistance to other more pure antiestrogens such as ICI 164,384, implying that these antiestrogens must act by somewhat different mechanisms. The association of reduced retinoic acid responsiveness and insensitivity to exogenous TGF-beta with antiestrogen growth resistance in these cells supports the increasing evidence for interrelationships among cell regulatory pathways utilized by these three growth-suppressive agents in breast cancer cells. In addition, our findings indicate that one mechanism of antiestrogen resistance, as seen in MCF/TOT cells, may involve alterations in growth factor and other hormonal pathways that affect the ER response pathway.

Different regions in activation function-1 of the human estrogen receptor required for antiestrogen- and estradiol-dependent transcription activation

The human estrogen receptor (ER) is a ligand-inducible transcription factor that contains two transcriptional activation functions, one located in the NH2-terminal region of the protein (AF-1) and the second in the COOH-terminal region (AF-2). Antiestrogens, such as trans-hydroxytamoxifen (TOT), have partial agonistic activity in certain cell types, and studies have implied that this agonism is AF-1-dependent. We have made progressive NH2-terminal and other segment deletions and ligations in the A/B domain, and studied the transcriptional activity of these mutant ERs in ER-negative MDA-MB-231 human breast cancer and HEC-1 human endometrial cancer cells. Using several estrogens and several partial agonist/antagonist antiestrogens, we find that estrogens and antiestrogens require different regions of AF-1 for transcriptional activation. Deletion of the first 40 amino acids has no effect on receptor activity. Antiestrogen agonism is lost upon deletion to amino acid 87, while estrogen agonism is not lost until deletions progress to amino acid 109. Antiestrogen agonism has been further defined to require amino acids 41-64, as deletion of only these amino acids results in an ER that exhibits 100% activity with E2, but no longer shows an agonist response to TOT. With A/B-modified receptors in which antiestrogens lose their agonistic activity, the antiestrogens then function as pure estrogen antagonists. Our studies show that in these cellular contexts, hormone-dependent transcription utilizes a range of the amino acid sequence within the A/B domain. Furthermore, the agonist/antagonist balance and activity of antiestrogens such as TOT are determined by specific sequences within the A/B domain and thus may be influenced by differences in levels of specific factors that interact with these regions of the ER.

Effect of growth factors on estrogen receptor mediated gene expression

The proliferation of mammary carcinoma cells can be stimulated by estrogens and various growth factors such as EGF and IGF-I. Steroid hormones and growth factors are understood to exert their effects via different receptors and signal transduction pathways. Recently, it has been shown that growth factors can utilize the unliganded estrogen receptor (ER) as a transcription factor. This study was aimed at identifying the growth factors that can act via the estrogen receptor, and finding new estrogen antagonists that block this activity. Originally, a transcription assay was used in which HeLa cells had been transiently co-transfected with the expression vector for the human ER and a reporter plasmid EREwtc luc. EGF and, to a lesser extent, insulin stimulated the expression of the reporter gene in the absence of estradiol (E2), whereas IGF-I was inactive. The stimulatory effect of E2 and insulin was suppressed when the ER was blocked by the pure antiestrogen ICI 182,780. In ER-positive MCF-7 cells, transfected transiently with the reporter plasmid, EGF had no stimulatory effect on luciferase expression. IGF-I stimulated the transcription to about 50% of the E2 value. Similar activity was found for insulin. The effect of both growth factors was only partly reversed by the addition of a pure antiestrogen. The combination of E2 and IGF-I or insulin led to a synergistic activation of transcription. Because transiently transfected cells do not allow one to study the influence of chromatin structure on gene expression, an MCF-7 subline (MCF-7/2a) was established, in which the reporter construct had been integrated in the genome. IGF-I stimulated luciferase expression in these cells, but showed no overadditive effect with E2. The effects of both agents were completely suppressed by the pure antiestrogen ICI 182,780. These data suggest the existence of an ER-independent mechanism for the activation of the reporter gene in transiently transfected cells, but not in stable transfectants.

Nuclear hormone receptors: ligand-activated regulators of transcription and diverse cell responses

Signal transduction via nuclear hormone receptors is unusual in that the hormone ligand forms an integral part of the protein complex involved in DNA binding and transcriptional activation. New structural and biochemical results have begun to unravel how these receptors produce different effects in different cells, and the structural changes involved in transcriptional activation.