Induction of RNA editing at heterologous sites by sequences in apolipoprotein B mRNA

Apobec1 complementation factor (A1CF) and RBM47 interact in tissue-specific regulation of C to U RNA editing in mouse intestine and liver

Mammalian C to U RNA is mediated by APOBEC1, the catalytic deaminase, together with RNA binding cofactors (including A1CF and RBM47) whose relative physiological requirements are unresolved. Although A1CF complements APOBEC1 for in vitro RNA editing, A1cf^-/- mice exhibited no change in apolipoproteinB (apoB) RNA editing, while Rbm47 mutant mice exhibited impaired intestinal RNA editing of apoB as well as other targets. Here we examined the role of A1CF and RBM47 in adult mouse liver and intestine, following deletion of either one or both gene products and also following forced (liver or intestinal) transgenic A1CF expression. There were minimal changes in hepatic and intestinal apoB RNA editing in A1cf^-/- mice and no changes in either liver- or intestine-specific A1CF transgenic mice. Rbm47 liver-specific knockout (Rbm47^LKO ) mice demonstrated reduced editing in a subset (11 of 20) of RNA targets, including apoB. By contrast, apoB RNA editing was virtually eliminated (<6% activity) in intestine-specific (Rbm47^IKO ) mice with only five of 53 targets exhibiting C-to-U RNA editing. Double knockout of A1cf and Rbm47 in liver (AR^LKO ) eliminated apoB RNA editing and reduced editing in the majority of other targets, with no changes following adenoviral APOBEC1 administration. Intestinal double knockout mice (AR^IKO ) demonstrated further reduced editing (<10% activity) in four of five of the residual APOBEC1 targets identified in AR^IKO mice. These data suggest that A1CF and RBM47 each function independently, yet interact in a tissue-specific manner, to regulate the activity and site selection of APOBEC1 dependent C-to-U RNA editing.

RNA Editors, Cofactors, and mRNA Targets: An Overview of the C-to-U RNA Editing Machinery and Its Implication in Human Disease

One of the most prevalent epitranscriptomic modifications is RNA editing. In higher eukaryotes, RNA editing is catalyzed by one of two classes of deaminases: ADAR family enzymes that catalyze A-to-I (read as G) editing, and AID/APOBEC family enzymes that catalyze C-to-U. ADAR-catalyzed deamination has been studied extensively. Here we focus on AID/APOBEC-catalyzed editing, and review the emergent knowledge regarding C-to-U editing consequences in the context of human disease.

The evolution of apolipoprotein B and its mRNA editing complex. Does the lack of editing contribute to hypertriglyceridemia?

The evolution of apolipoprotein B (Apob) has been intensely researched due to its importance during lipid transport. Mammalian full-length apob100 can be post-transcriptionally edited by the enzyme apolipoprotein B mRNA editing enzyme, catalytic polypeptide-like complex-one (Apobec1) resulting in a truncated Apob, known as Apob48. Whilst both full-length and truncated forms of Apob are important for normal lipid homeostasis in mammals, there is no evidence for the presence of apob mRNA editing prior to the divergence of the mammals, yet, non-mammalian vertebrates appear to function normally with only Apob100. To date, the majority of the research carried out in non-mammalian vertebrates has focused on chickens with only a very limited number examining apob mRNA editing in fish. This study focused on the molecular evolution of Apobec1 and Apob in order to ascertain if apob mRNA editing occurs in eels, a basal teleost which represents an evolutionarily important animal group. No evidence for the presence of Apobec1 or the ability for eel apob to be edited was found. However, an important link between mutant mice and the evident hypertriglyceridemia in the plasma of non-mammalian vertebrates was made. This study has provided imperative evidence to help bridge the evolutionary gap between fish and mammals and provides further support for the lack of apob mRNA editing in non-mammalian vertebrates.

RNA editing of the apolipoprotein B gene A mechanism to regulate the atherogenic potential of intestinal lipoproteins?

Apolipoprotein B (apo B) circulates in two distinct isomorphic forms, each the product of a single gene. The larger form, referred to as apo B-100, is the major protein of plasma low-density lipoproteins (LDLs) and is synthesized by the human liver. The smaller form, referred to as apo B-48, is produced in the small intestine as a result of a site-specific cytidine deamination, which alters a CAA codon, encoding glutamine in the unedited (apo B-100) mRNA to UAA, which specifies an in-frame stop codon. Apo B-48 lacks the domains involved in LDL receptor interaction and in complex formation with apolipoprotein(a). DNA sequence analysis of the gene that mediates this site-specific cytidine deamination suggests that apo B mRNA editing is an evolutionary adaptation to limit the atherogenic potential of intestinal lipoproteins.

Hypermutation of ApoB mRNA by rat APOBEC-1 overexpression mimics APOBEC-3 hypermutation

APOBEC-3 proteins induce C-to-U hypermutations in the viral genome of various viruses and have broad antiviral activity. Generally, only a small proportion of viral genomes (<10(-)(2)) are hypermutated by APOBEC-3s, but often many cytidines (up to 40%) are converted into uridine. The mechanism of this unique selective hypermutation remains unknown. We found that rat APOBEC-1 overexpression had a hypermutation pattern similar to that of APOBEC-3s on its substrate apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA. Transient plasmid transfection of rat APOBEC-1 resulted in 0.4% and 1.8% hypermutations with apoB mRNA in HepG2 and McA7777 cells, respectively. The low frequency of hypermutated apoB mRNA targets was enriched by differential DNA denaturation PCR at 72-76 °C, with hypermutation levels increasing up to 67%. Up to 69.6% of cytidines in HepG2 and up to 75.5% of cytidines in McA7777 cells were converted into uridines in the hypermutated apoB mRNA. When rat APOBEC-1 was overexpressed by adenovirus, the hypermutation frequency of apoB mRNA increased from 0.4% to ∼20% and was readily detected by regular PCR. However, this higher expression efficiency only increased the frequency of hypermutation, not the number of affected cytidines in hypermutated targets. Rat APOBEC-1 hypermutation was modulated by cofactors and eliminated by an E181Q mutation, indicating the role of cofactors in hypermutation. The finding of an APOBEC-3 hypermutation pattern with rat APOBEC-1 suggests that cofactors could also be involved in APOBEC-3 hypermutation. Using hepatitis B virus hypermutation, we found that KSRP increased APOBEC-3C and APOBEC-3B hypermutation. These data show that, like rat APOBEC-1 hypermutation, cellular factors may play a regulatory role in APOBEC-3 hypermutation.

APOBEC-1-mediated RNA editing

RNA editing defines a molecular process by which a nucleotide sequence is modified in the RNA transcript and results in an amino acid change in the recoded message from that specified in the gene. We will restrict our attention to the type of RNA editing peculiar to mammals, i.e., nuclear C to U RNA editing. This category of RNA editing contrasts with RNA modifications described in plants, i.e., organellar RNA editing (reviewed in Ref 1). Mammalian RNA editing is genetically and biochemically classified into two groups, namely insertion-deletional and substitutional. Substitutional RNA editing is exclusive to mammals, again with two types reported, namely adenosine to inosine and cytosine to uracil (C to U). This review will examine mammalian C to U RNA editing of apolipoproteinB (apoB) RNA and the role of the catalytic deaminase Apobec-1. We will speculate on the functions of Apobec-1 beyond C to U RNA editing as implied from its ability to bind AU-rich RNAs and discuss evidence that dysregulation of Apobec-1 expression might be associated with carcinogenesis through aberrant RNA editing or altered RNA stability.

Measuring editing activity and identifying cytidine-to-uridine mRNA editing factors in cells and biochemical isolates

Cytidine deaminases with the capacity to act on nucleic acids play a critical role in regulating the proteome through diversification of expressed sequence beyond that encoded in the genome. A family of these enzymes, known as the APOBEC family of cytidine deaminases, has been identified in mammalian cells. APOBEC-1 edits messenger RNA, whereas other family members affect mRNA coding capacity by editing single-stranded DNA in expressed regions of the genomes. Biochemical isolation and analysis of APOBEC proteins and their interacting factors have led to an understanding of the diverse cellular processes including lipoprotein metabolism, antibody production, viral infectivity, and cancer. Practical approaches will be described for the measurement of editing activity and the analysis of proteins involved in C-to-U and dC-to-dU editing.

NMR structure of the apoB mRNA stem-loop and its interaction with the C to U editing APOBEC1 complementary factor

We have solved the NMR structure of the 31-nucleotide (nt) apoB mRNA stem-loop, a substrate of the cytidine deaminase APOBEC1. We found that the edited base located at the 5' end of the octa-loop is stacked between two adenosines in both the unedited (cytidine 6666) and the edited (uridine 6666) forms and that the rest of the loop is unstructured. The 11-nt "mooring" sequence essential for editing is partially flexible although it is mostly in the stem of the RNA. The octa-loop and the internal loop in the middle of the stem confer this flexibility. These findings shed light on why APOBEC1 alone cannot edit efficiently the cytidine 6666 under physiological conditions, the editing base being buried in the loop and not directly accessible. We also show that APOBEC1 does not specifically bind apoB mRNA and requires the auxiliary factor, APOBEC1 complementary factor (ACF), to edit specifically cytidine 6666. The binding of ACF to both the mooring sequence and APOBEC1 explains the specificity of the reaction. Our NMR study lead us to propose a mechanism in which ACF recognizes first the flexible nucleotides of the mooring sequence (the internal loop and the 3' end octa-loop) and subsequently melts the stem-loop, exposing the amino group of the cytidine 6666 to APOBEC1. Thus, the flexibility of the mooring sequence plays a central role in the RNA recognition by ACF.

Optimization of apolipoprotein B mRNA editing by APOBEC1 apoenzyme and the role of its auxiliary factor, ACF

Expression and purification to homogeneity of the apolipoprotein B mRNA editing subunit, APOBEC1, has allowed the demonstration that this apoenzyme has considerable residual enzymatic activity on a minimal apoB mRNA substrate, even in the absence of any auxiliary factors. Assay of this activity as a function of various experimental conditions has led to substantial optimization of assay conditions through the use of incomplete factorial and response surface experiments. Surprisingly, the apoenzyme is thermostable, and has a temperature optimum near 45 degrees C. We have used these optimized conditions, to assess steady-state kinetic parameters for APOBEC1 mRNA editing activity with and without the auxiliary factor, ACF. An important effect of the auxiliary factor is to broaden the temperature range of APOBEC1 activity, lowering the optimal temperature and enabling it to function optimally at lower temperatures. A model consistent with this observation is that at lower temperatures ACF promotes a conformational transition in the RNA substrate that occurs spontaneously at higher temperature. Notably, the substantial RNA editing activity of APOBEC1 alone may be responsible for the "hyperediting" observed upon overexpression of APOBEC1 in transgenic mice.

Molecular regulation, evolutionary, and functional adaptations associated with C to U editing of mammalian apolipoproteinB mRNA

RNA editing encompasses an important class of co- or posttranscriptional nucleic acid modification that has expanded our understanding of the range of mechanisms that facilitate genetic plasticity. Since the initial description of RNA editing in trypanosome mitochondria, a model of gene regulation has emerged that now encompasses a diverse range of biochemical and genetic mechanisms by which nuclear, mitochondrial, and t-RNA sequences are modified from templated versions encoded in the genome. RNA editing is genetically and biochemically distinct from other RNA modifications such as splicing, capping, and polyadenylation although, as discussed in Section I, these modifications may have relevance to the regulation of certain types of mammalian RNA editing. This review will focus on C to U RNA editing, in particular, the biochemical and genetic mechanisms that regulate this process in mammals. These mechanisms will be examined in the context of the prototype model of C to U RNA editing, namely the posttranscriptional cytidine deamination targeting a single nucleotide in mammalian apolipoproteinB (apoB). Other examples of C to U RNA editing will be discussed and the molecular mechanisms--where known--contrasted with those regulating apoB RNA editing.

Apobec-1 transcription in rat colon cancer: decreased apobec-1 protein production through alterations in polysome distribution and mRNA translation associated with upstream AUGs

Apobec-1 catalyzes C to U editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA in the mammalian intestine. Rat apobec-1 is transcribed from three distinct promoters, which contain distinct 5' untranslated regions (5'UTRs) accompanied by variable numbers of in-frame upstream AUGs (uAUGs). We have observed a shift in apobec-1 promoter usage in an experimental model of colon carcinogenesis, resulting in transcripts loaded with 5'AUGs. In colon cancer, apobec-1 protein levels decreased by 90% in the cancer tissue as compared to normal tissue, suggesting an inhibitory effect of the 5'UTR on apobec-1 translation. We investigated the effects of these different 5'UTRs by site-directed mutagenesis coupled with in vitro translation studies. These studies established that the uAUGs within the 5'UTR of the alternative transcripts inhibit apobec-1 translation. This effect was independent of the length of the 5'UTR. Further analysis demonstrated that these uAUGs altered the polysome distribution, shifting the mRNA towards a denser, post-polyribosomal fraction. These findings were confirmed in transient transfection studies in vivo using HepG2 cells, where functional expression of apobec-1 was restored by mutagenesis of the uAUGs. Taken together, these data imply that rat apobec-1 gene expression is downregulated through alternative promoter usage. This dominant translational control of apobec-1 gene expression is most plausibly exerted through uAUGs.

Identification of domains in apobec-1 complementation factor required for RNA binding and apolipoprotein-B mRNA editing

The C-to-U editing of apolipoprotein-B (apo-B) mRNA is catalyzed by an enzyme complex that recognizes an 11-nt mooring sequence downstream of the editing site. A minimal holoenzyme that edits apo-B mRNA in vitro has been defined. This complex contains apobec-1, the catalytic subunit, and apobec-1 complementation factor (ACF), the RNA-binding subunit that binds to the mooring sequence. Here, we show that ACF binds with high affinity to single-stranded but not double-stranded apo-B mRNA. ACF contains three nonidentical RNA recognition motifs (RRM) and a unique C-terminal auxiliary domain. In many multi-RRM proteins, the RRMs mediate RNA binding and an auxiliary domain functions in protein-protein interactions. Here we show that ACF does not fit this simple model. Based on deletion mutagenesis, the RRMs in ACF are necessary but not sufficient for binding to apo-B mRNA. Amino acids in the pre-RRM region are required for complementing activity and RNA binding, but not for interaction with apobec-1. The C-terminal 196 amino acids are not absolutely essential for function. However, further deletion of an RG-rich region from the auxiliary domain abolished complementing activity, RNA binding, and apobec-1 interaction. The auxiliary domain alone did not bind apobec-1. Although all three RRMs are required for complementing activity and apobec-1 interaction, the individual motifs contribute differently to RNA binding. Point mutations in RRM1 or RRM2 decreased the Kd for apo-B mRNA by two orders of magnitude whereas mutations in RRM3 reduced binding affinity 13-fold. The pairwise expression of RRM1 with RRM2 or RRM3 resulted in moderate affinity binding.

C-->U editing of neurofibromatosis 1 mRNA occurs in tumors that express both the type II transcript and apobec-1, the catalytic subunit of the apolipoprotein B mRNA-editing enzyme

C-->U RNA editing of neurofibromatosis 1 (NF1) mRNA changes an arginine (CGA) to a UGA translational stop codon, predicted to result in translational termination of the edited mRNA. Previous studies demonstrated varying degrees of C-->U RNA editing in peripheral nerve-sheath tumor samples (PNSTs) from patients with NF1, but the basis for this heterogeneity was unexplained. In addition, the role, if any, of apobec-1, the catalytic deaminase that mediates C-->U editing of mammalian apolipoprotein B (apoB) RNA, was unresolved. We have examined these questions in PNSTs from patients with NF1 and demonstrate that a subset (8/34) manifest C-->U editing of RNA. Two distinguishing characteristics were found in the PNSTs that demonstrated editing of NF1 RNA. First, these tumors express apobec-1 mRNA, the first demonstration, in humans, of its expression beyond the luminal gastrointestinal tract. Second, PNSTs with C-->U editing of RNA manifest increased proportions of an alternatively spliced exon, 23A, downstream of the edited base. C-->U editing of RNA in these PNSTs was observed preferentially in transcripts containing exon 23A. These findings were complemented by in vitro studies using synthetic RNA templates incubated in the presence of recombinant apobec-1, which again confirmed preferential editing of transcripts containing exon 23A. Finally, adenovirus-mediated transfection of HepG2 cells revealed induction of editing of apoB RNA, along with preferential editing of NF1 transcripts containing exon 23A. Taken together, the data support the hypothesis that C-->U RNA editing of the NF1 transcript occurs both in a subset of PNSTs and in an alternatively spliced form containing a downstream exon, presumably an optimal configuration for enzymatic deamination by apobec-1.

Mutagenesis of apobec-1 complementation factor reveals distinct domains that modulate RNA binding, protein-protein interaction with apobec-1, and complementation of C to U RNA-editing activity

C to U editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) RNA requires a multicomponent holoenzyme complex in which minimal constituents include apobec-1 and apobec-1 complementation factor (ACF). We have examined the predicted functional domains in ACF in binding apoB RNA, interaction with apobec-1, and complementation of RNA editing. We demonstrate that apoB RNA binding and apobec-1-interacting domains are defined by two partially overlapping regions containing the NH(2)-terminal RNA recognition motifs of ACF. Both apoB RNA binding and apobec-1 interaction are required for editing complementation activity. ACF is a nuclear protein that upon cotransfection with apobec-1 results in nuclear colocalization and redistribution of apobec-1 from the cytoplasm. ACF constructs with deletions or mutations in the putative nuclear localization signal (NLS) still localize in the nucleus of transfected cells but do not colocalize with apobec-1, the latter remaining predominantly cytoplasmic. These observations suggest that the putative NLS motif in ACF is not responsible for its nucleo-cytoplasmic trafficking. By contrast, protein-protein interaction is important for the nuclear import of apobec-1. Taken together, these data suggest that functional complementation of C to U RNA editing by apobec-1 involves the NH(2)-terminal 380 residues of ACF.

The many roles of an RNA editor

The availability of complete genome sequences has made it clear that gene number is not the sole determinant of the complexity of the proteome. Additional complexity that is not readily detected by genome analysis is present in the number and types of RNA transcript that can be derived from each locus. Although alternative splicing is a well-recognized method of generating diversity, the more subtle mechanism of RNA editing is less familiar.

Identification of GRY-RBP as an apolipoprotein B RNA-binding protein that interacts with both apobec-1 and apobec-1 complementation factor to modulate C to U editing

C to U editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA involves the interaction of a multicomponent editing enzyme complex with a requisite RNA sequence embedded within an AU-rich context. This enzyme complex includes apobec-1, an RNA-specific cytidine deaminase, and apobec-1 complementation factor (ACF), a novel 65-kDa RNA-binding protein, that together represent the minimal core of the editing enzyme complex. The precise composition of the holo-enzyme, however, remains unknown. We have previously isolated an enriched fraction of S100 extracts, prepared from chicken intestinal cells, that displays apoB RNA binding and which, following supplementation with apobec-1, permits efficient C to U editing. Peptide sequencing of this most active fraction reveals the presence of ACF as well as GRY-RBP, an RNA-binding protein with approximately 50% homology to ACF. GRY-RBP was independently isolated from a two-hybrid screen of chicken intestinal cDNA. GRY-RBP binds to ACF, to apobec-1, and also binds apoB RNA. Experiments using recombinant proteins demonstrate that GRY-RBP binds to ACF and inhibits both the binding of ACF to apoB RNA and C to U RNA editing. This competitive inhibition is rescued by addition of ACF, suggesting that GRY-RBP binds to and sequesters ACF. As further evidence of the role of GRY-RBP, rat hepatoma cells treated with an antisense oligonucleotide to GRY-RBP demonstrated an increase in C to U editing of endogenous apoB RNA. ACF and GRY-RBP colocalize in the nucleus of transfected cells and, in cotransfection experiments with apobec-1, each appears to colocalize in a predominantly nuclear distribution. Taken together, the results indicate that GRY-RBP is a member of the ACF gene family that may function to modulate C to U RNA editing through binding either to ACF or to apobec-1 or, alternatively, to the target RNA itself.

APOLIPOPROTEIN B: mRNA editing, lipoprotein assembly, and presecretory degradation

Apolipoprotein (apo)B circulates in two distinct forms, apoB100 and apoB48. Human liver secretes apoB100, the product of a large mRNA encoding 4536 residues. The small intestine of all mammals secretes apoB48, which arises following C-to-U deamination of a single cytidine base in the nuclear apoB transcript, introducing a translational stop codon. This process, referred to as apoB RNA editing, operates through a multicomponent enzyme complex that contains a single catalytic subunit, apobec-1, in addition to other protein factors that have yet to be cloned. ApoB RNA editing also exhibits stringent cis-acting requirements that include both structural and sequence-specific elements-specifically efficiency elements that flank the minimal cassette, an AU-rich RNA context, and an 11-nucleotide mooring sequence-located in proximity to a suitably positioned (usually upstream) cytidine. C-to-U RNA editing may become unconstrained under circumstances where apobec-1 is overexpressed, in which case multiple cytidines in apoB RNA, as well as in other transcripts, undergo C-to-U editing. ApoB RNA editing is eliminated following targeting of apobec-1, establishing that there is no genetic redundancy in this function. Under physiological circumstances, apoB RNA editing exhibits developmental, hormonal, and nutritional regulation, in some cases related to transcriptional regulation of apobec-1 mRNA. ApoB and the microsomal triglyceride transfer protein (MTP) are essential for the assembly and secretion of apoB-containing lipoproteins. MTP functions by transferring lipid to apoB during its translation and by transporting triglycerides into the endoplasmic reticulum to form apoB-free lipid droplets. These droplets fuse with nascent apoB-containing particles to form mature, very low-density lipoproteins or chylomicrons. In cultured hepatic cells, lipid availability dictates the rate of apoB production. Unlipidated or underlipidated forms of apoB are subjected to presecretory degradation, a process mediated by retrograde transport from the lumen of the endoplasmic reticulum to the cytosol, coupled with multiubquitination and proteasomal degradation. Although control of lipid secretion in vivo is primarily achieved at the level of lipoprotein particle size, regulation of apoB production by presecretory degradation may be relevant in some dyslipidemic states.

RNA editing: cytidine to uridine conversion in apolipoprotein B mRNA

RNA editing is a post-transcriptional process that changes the informational capacity within the RNA. These processes include alterations made by nucleotide deletion, insertion and base conversion. A to I and C to U conversion occurs in mammals and these editing events are catalysed by RNA binding deaminases. C to U editing of apoB mRNA was the first mammalian editing event to be identified. The minimal protein complex necessary for apoB mRNA editing has been determined and consists of APOBEC-1 and ACF. Overexpression of APOBEC-1 in transgenic animals caused liver dysplasia and APOBEC-1 has been identified in neurofibromatosis type 1 tumours, suggesting that RNA editing may be another mechanism for tumourigenesis. Several APOBEC-1-like proteins have been identified, including a family of APOBEC-1-related proteins with unknown function on chromosome 22. This review summarises the different types of RNA editing and discusses the current status of C to U apoB mRNA editing. This knowledge is very important in understanding the structure and function of these related proteins and their role in biology.

Calcium increases apolipoprotein B mRNA editing

ApoB-100 and apoB-48 are major components of chylomicrons, very low-density lipoprotein (VLDL) and low-density lipoprotein (LDL). The two proteins are generated from a single apoB mRNA by apoB mRNA editing which induces an in-frame stop codon in apoB mRNA. Apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing is an important determinant of the proportion of full-length (apoB-100) and truncated (apoB-48) proteins in total apoB metabolism. Calcium is involved in the regulation of secretion and synthesis of VLDL and apoB. In this paper, we demonstrate for the first time that the amount of edited apoB mRNA in the cultured cells Caco-2 and McA7777 is markedly increased by calcium. Increasing extracellular calcium concentration, calcium ionophore (A23187 and ionomycin) treatment, and depleting calcium stores and raising cytoplasmic calcium concentration by thapsigargin increase apoB mRNA editing up to threefold in a dose dependent manner. Calcium has no direct stimulative effect on apoB mRNA editing in an in vitro editing system. The editing increase by extracellular calcium is not related to alterations of APOBEC-1 mRNA expression. These data suggest that calcium is not only involved in the regulation of apolipoprotein metabolism but also apoB mRNA editing.

Phylogenetic analysis of the apolipoprotein B mRNA-editing region. Evidence for a secondary structure between the mooring sequence and the 3' efficiency element

Apolipoprotein (apo) B mRNA editing is the deamination of C(6666) to uridine, which changes the codon at position 2153 from a genomically encoded glutamine (CAA) to an in-frame stop codon (UAA). The apoB mRNA-editing enzyme complex recognizes the editing region of the apoB pre-mRNA with exquisite precision. Four sequence elements spanning 139 nucleotides (nt) on the apoB mRNA have been identified that specify this precision. In cooperation with the indispensable mooring sequence and spacer element, a 5' efficiency element and a 3' efficiency element enhance editing in vitro. A phylogenetic comparison of 32 species showed minor differences in the apoB mRNA sequence, and the apoB mRNA from 31 species was robustly edited in vitro. However, guinea pig mRNA was poorly edited. Compared with the consensus sequences of these 31 species, guinea pig apoB mRNA has three variations in the 3' efficiency element, and the conversion of these to the consensus sequence increased editing to the levels in the other species. From this information, a model for the secondary structure was formulated in which the mooring sequence and the 3' efficiency element form a double-stranded stem. Thirty-one mammalian apoB mRNA sequences are predicted to form this stem positioning C(6666) two nucleotides upstream of the stem. However, the guinea pig apoB mRNA has a mutation in the 3' efficiency element (C(6743) to U) that predicts an extension of the stem and hence the lower editing efficiency. A test of this model demonstrated that a single substitution at 6743 (U to C) in the guinea pig apoB mRNA, that should reduce the stem, enhanced editing, and mutations in the 3' efficiency element that extended the stem for three base pairs dramatically reduced editing. Furthermore, the addition of a 20-nucleotide 3' efficiency element RNA, to a 58-nucleotide guinea pig apoB mRNA lacking the 3' efficiency element more than doubled the in vitro editing activity. Based on these results, a model is proposed in which the mooring sequence and the 3' efficiency element form a double-stranded stem, thus suggesting a mechanism of how the 3' efficiency element enhances editing.

Tissue-specific differences in the role of RNA 3' of the apolipoprotein B mRNA mooring sequence in editosome assembly

Site-specific editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA by the cytidine deaminase, APOBEC-1 is proposed to require interactions of auxiliary protein(s) with an eleven nucleotide element, the mooring sequence, located 3' of the C --> U editing site. An analysis of the RNA sequence dependence for protein-RNA interactions and editosome assembly in rat liver and the small intestine demonstrated that the mooring sequence was a minimal requirement for these interactions. Sequences 3' of the mooring sequence either interacted with 66 kDa and 44 kDa proteins or enhanced the interactions of these proteins with the mooring sequence. The data also suggested tissue-specific differences in the relative importance of the 3' cis-acting 'enhancer' elements in the efficiency or stability of editosome assembly. We propose that the previously demonstrated differences in apoB mRNA editing efficiency and its regulation in liver and intestine may in part be due to differences in auxiliary protein interactions with apoB mRNA 3' of the mooring sequence.

Purification, redox sensitivity, and RNA binding properties of SECIS-binding protein 2, a protein involved in selenoprotein biosynthesis

In mammalian selenoprotein mRNAs, the highly structured 3' UTR contains selenocysteine insertion sequence (SECIS) elements that are required for the recognition of UGA as the selenocysteine codon. Our previous work demonstrated a tight correlation between codon-specific translational read-through and the activity of a 120-kDa RNA-binding protein that interacted specifically with the SECIS element in the phospholipid hydroperoxide glutathione peroxidase mRNA. This study reports the RNA binding and biochemical properties of this protein, SECIS-binding protein 2 (SBP2). We detected SBP2 binding activity in liver, hepatoma cell, and testis extracts from which SBP2 has been purified by anion exchange and RNA affinity chromatography. This scheme has allowed us to identify a 120-kDa polypeptide that co-elutes with SBP2 binding activity from wild-type but not mutant RNA affinity columns. A characterization of SBP2 biochemical properties reveals that SBP2 binding is sensitive to oxidation and the presence of heparin, rRNA, and poly(G). SBP2 activity elutes with a molecular mass of approximately 500 kDa during gel filtration chromatography, suggesting the existence of a large functional complex. Direct cross-linking and competition experiments demonstrate that the minimal phospholipid hydroperoxide glutathione peroxidase 3' UTR binding site is between 82 and 102 nucleotides, which correlates with the minimal sequence necessary for translational read-through. SBP2 also interacts specifically with the minimally functional 3' UTR of another selenoprotein mRNA, deiodinase 1.

C-->U editing of apolipoprotein B mRNA in marsupials: identification and characterisation of APOBEC-1 from the American opossum Monodelphus domestica

The C->U editing of RNA is widely found in plant and animal species. In mammals it is a discrete process confined to the editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA in eutherians and the editing of the mitochondrial tRNA for glycine in marsupials. Here we have identified and characterised apoB mRNA editing in the American opossum Monodelphus domestica. The apoB mRNA editing site is highly conserved in the opossum and undergoes complete editing in the small intestine, but not in the liver or other tissues. Opossum APOBEC-1 cDNA was cloned, sequenced and expressed. The encoded protein is similar to APOBEC-1 of eutherians. Motifs previously identified as involved in zinc binding, RNA binding and catalysis, nuclear localisation and a C-terminal leucine-rich domain are all conserved. Opossum APOBEC-1 contains a seven amino acid C-terminal extension also found in humans and rabbits, but not present in rodents. The opossum APOBEC-1 gene has the same intron/exon organisation in the coding sequence as the eutherian gene. Northern blot and RT-PCR analyses and an editing assay indicate that no APOBEC-1 was expressed in the liver. Thus the far upstream promoter responsible for hepatic expression in rodents does not operate in the opossum. An APOBEC-1-like enzyme such as might be involved in C->U RNA editing of tRNA in marsupial mitochondria was not demonstrated. The activity of opossum APOBEC-1 in the presence of both chicken and rodent auxiliary editing proteins was comparable to that of other mammals. These studies extend the origins of APOBEC-1 back 170 000 000 years to marsupials and help bridge the gap in the origins of this RNA editing process between birds and eutherian mammals.

Sequence elements required for apolipoprotein B mRNA editing enhancement activity from chicken enterocytes

Mammalian intestinal apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA edits codon 2153 from CAA in apoB100 mRNA to a stop codon (UAA) in apoB48 mRNA. By contrast, chicken intestinal apoB mRNA contains a CAA codon at the corresponding site, but is not edited. Chicken enterocyte S100 extracts fail to edit mammalian apoB RNA, but contain factor(s) which enhance the mammalian enterocytes editing activity. By converting the chicken apoB mooring sequences to the conserved mammalian sequences, the study confirmed that this 11-nucleotide stretch was necessary and sufficient for minimal RNA editing. Using rat and chicken apoB chimeric constructs, the study revealed that mammalian apoB sequences were required for editing enhancement. In concert with the 29-nucleotide conserved cassette, the 5' rat apoB element (nucleotides 6615-6629) increased editing at C-6666, and was necessary for editing enhancement of chicken enterocyte S100 extracts. Similarly, the 3' rat apoB element (nucleotides 6726-6752) was required for editing enhancement of chicken enterocyte S100 extracts, but to a lesser extent in efficiency, compared to the 5' region. In conclusion, this study identified the sequences required for editing enhancement activity from chicken enterocyte S100 extracts.

Secondary structure for the apolipoprotein B mRNA editing site. Au-binding proteins interact with a stem loop

The C to U editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA converts a glutamine codon in apoB100 mRNA into a stop translation codon thereby generating apoB48. The catalytic subunit of the editing enzyme, APOBEC-1, is an RNA-binding cytidine deaminase that requires auxiliary factors for the editing of apoB mRNA. Computer modeling and ribonuclease probing of the wild-type and mutant apoB RNA substrates reveal a stem loop at the editing site. This structure incorporates the essential sequence motifs required for editing. The localization of the edited cytidine within the loop suggests how it could be presented to the active site of APOBEC-1 for deamination. We have identified 43/45 kDa proteins from chick enterocytes and show evidence for their involvement in auxiliary editing activity. p43/45 demonstrates preferential binding to AU-rich RNA and to the Caauuug motif that forms the loop and proximal stem of the apoB mRNA.

Inhibition of the apolipoprotein B mRNA editing enzyme-complex by hnRNP C1 protein and 40S hnRNP complexes

The apolipoprotein (apo) B mRNA can be modified by a posttranscriptional base change from cytidine to uridine at nucleotide position 6666. This editing of apo B mRNA is mediated by a specific enzyme-complex of which only the catalytic subunit APOBEC-1 (apo B mRNA editing enzyme component 1) has been cloned and extensively characterized. In this study, two-hybrid selection in yeast identified hnRNP C1 protein to interact with APOBEC-1. Recombinant hnRNP C1 protein inhibited partially purified apo B mRNA editing activity from rat small intestine and bound specifically to apo B sense RNA around the editing site. The inhibition of apo B mRNA editing by hnRNP C1 protein was not due to masking of the RNA substrate as the mutant protein M104 spanning the RNA-binding domain of hnRNP C1 protein bound strongly to the apo B RNA, but did not inhibit the editing reaction. The apo B mRNA editing enzyme-complex of rat liver nuclear extracts sedimented in sucrose density gradients around 22-27S, but did not contain hnRNP C1 protein that was found exclusively within 40S hnRNP complexes. The removal of 40S hnRNP complexes increased the activity of the 22-27S editing enzyme-complex. Adding back 40S hnRNP complexes with hnRNP C1 protein resulted in an inhibition of the 22-27S apo B mRNA editing enzyme-complex, while addition of 18S fractions had no effect. In conclusion, hnRNP C1 protein identified by two-hybrid selection in yeast is a potent inhibitor of the apo B mRNA editing enzyme-complex. The abundant hnRNP C1 protein, which is contiguously deposited on nascent pre-mRNA during transcription and is involved in spliceosome assembly and mRNA splicing, is a likely regulator of the editing of apo B mRNA which restricts the activity of APOBEC-1 to limited and specific editing events.

Analysis of protein complexes assembled on apolipoprotein B mRNA for mooring sequence-dependent RNA editing

Apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing involves a cytidine-to-uridine transition at a select site catalyzed by a cytidine deaminase known as APOBEC-1. This enzyme cannot edit RNA alone but acquires site-specific editing capacity in the context of additional protein factors (auxiliary proteins). These proteins are currently hypothesized to assemble with APBEC-1 as a holoenzyme complex or editosome. Auxiliary proteins are the focus of ongoing research as they presumably serve important structural and regulatory roles in the editosome. The abilities of auxiliary proteins to interact with APOBEC-1 and apoB RNA and to promote RNA editing activity are important endpoints used as proof that proteins are functionally involved in apoB RNA editing. This article reviews the discovery of the editosome and provides detailed protocols for its isolation and subfractionation.

Two efficiency elements flanking the editing site of cytidine 6666 in the apolipoprotein B mRNA support mooring-dependent editing

Normally, apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing deaminates a single cytidine (C6666) in apoB mRNA. However, when the catalytic subunit of the editing enzyme complex, APOBEC-1, was overexpressed in transgenic mice and rabbits, numerous cytidines in the apoB mRNA and in a novel mRNA, NAT1, were aberrantly hyperedited, and the animals developed liver dysplasia and hepatocellular carcinomas. To identify the RNA motifs in the apoB mRNA that support physiological editing and those that support aberrant hyperediting, we constructed rabbit apoB RNA substrates and tested them in vitro for physiological editing and hyperediting. Three previously unrecognized RNA elements that are critical for efficient physiological editing at C6666 were identified. In concert with the mooring sequence (6671-6681), the 5' efficiency element (6609-6628), an A-rich region (6629-6640), and the 3' efficiency element (6717-6747) increased editing at C6666. The 5' efficiency element was the most potent, elevating physiological editing to wild-type levels in combination with the mooring sequence. The 3' efficiency element was somewhat less important but increased physiological editing to levels approaching wild type. These elements encompass 139 nucleotides on the apoB RNA transcript and are sufficient for editing with the efficiency of full-length apoB mRNA. Furthermore, a distal downstream apoB region (6747-6824) may function as a recognition element in the apoB mRNA. Hyperediting at C6802 in the rabbit apoB mRNA is mediated by RNA elements similar to those required for normal physiological editing at C6666. Similarly sized upstream and downstream flanking regions of C6802 are necessary for hyperediting in combination with a degenerate mooring sequence.

Apolipoprotein B RNA sequence 3' of the mooring sequence and cellular sources of auxiliary factors determine the location and extent of promiscuous editing

Apolipoprotein B (apoB) RNA editing involves a cytidine to uridine transition at nucleotide 6666 (C6666) 5' of an essential cis -acting 11 nucleotide motif known as the mooring sequence. APOBEC-1 (apoB editing catalytic sub-unit 1) serves as the site-specific cytidine deaminase in the context of a multiprotein assembly, the editosome. Experimental over-expression of APOBEC-1 resulted in an increased proportion of apoB mRNAs edited at C6666, as well as editing of sites that would otherwise not be recognized (promiscuous editing). In the rat hepatoma McArdle cell line, these sites occurred predominantly 5' of the mooring sequence on either rat or human apoB mRNA expressed from transfected cDNA. In comparison, over-expression of APOBEC-1 in HepG2 (HepG2-APOBEC) human hepatoma cells, induced promiscuous editing primarily 5' of the mooring sequence, but sites 3' of the C6666 were also used more efficiently. The capacity for promiscuous editing was common to rat, rabbit and human sources of APOBEC-1. The data suggested that differences in the distribution of promiscuous editing sites and in the efficiency of their utilization may reflect cell-type-specific differences in auxiliary proteins. Deletion of the mooring sequence abolished editing at the wild type site and markedly reduced, but did not eliminate, promiscuous editing. In contrast, deletion of a pair of tandem UGAU motifs 3' of the mooring sequence in human apoB mRNA selectively reduced promiscuous editing, leaving the efficiency of editing at the wild type site essentially unaffected. ApoB RNA constructs and naturally occurring mRNAs such as NAT-1 (novel APOBEC-1 target-1) that lack this downstream element were not promiscuously edited in McArdle or HepG2 cells. These findings underscore the importance of RNA sequences and the cellular context of auxiliary factors in regulating editing site utilization.

Escherichia coli cytidine deaminase provides a molecular model for ApoB RNA editing and a mechanism for RNA substrate recognition

ApoB RNA-editing enzyme (APOBEC-1) is a cytidine deaminase. Molecular modeling and mutagenesis show that APOBEC-1 is related in quaternary and tertiary structure to Escherichia coli cytidine deaminase (ECCDA). Both enzymes form a homodimer with composite active sites constructed with contributions from each monomer. Significant gaps are present in the APOBEC-1 sequence, compared to ECCDA. The combined mass of the gaps (10 kDa) matches that for the minimal RNA substrate. Their location in ECCDA suggests how APOBEC-1 can be reshaped to accommodate an RNA substrate. In this model, the asymmetrical binding to one active site of a downstream U (equivalent to the deamination product) helps target the other active site for deamination of the upstream C substrate.

Partial characterization of the auxiliary factors involved in apolipoprotein B mRNA editing through APOBEC-1 affinity chromatography

APOBEC-1-catalyzed apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing requires auxiliary factors, but the number and functions of these factors are unknown. We have partially purified the editing activity from extracts of a McArdle cell line overexpressing His6-hemagglutinin-tagged, rat APOBEC-1 using metal-chelating affinity chromatography. The 1,200-fold purification achieved by this approach was partially dependent on exogenously added RNA containing a mooring sequence for editosome assembly. Affinity-purified editing activity could be separated by 300 mM NaCl extraction into two fractions, a salt-resistant fraction (editing fraction 1; EF1) and a salt-soluble fraction (EF2). Neither EF1 nor EF2 alone could edit apoB RNA, but when added together they reconstituted full editing activity. Previously identified candidate auxiliary factors including the p66/p44 apoB RNA binding proteins and the presumptive editosome assembly factor p240 were all present in the affinity-purified editing complex. Moreover, virtually all of p66, p240, and APOBEC-1 were present in EF1, whereas p44 was quantitatively recovered in EF2. This is the first demonstration that p66 and p44 can bind to apoB RNA independently of one another. In addition, 100- and 55-kDa apoB RNA cross-linking proteins have been identified in the APOBEC-1 affinity-purified material. RNA competition studies demonstrated that p100, p66, and p55 bound selectively to apoB RNA, whereas p44 had general RNA cross-linking characteristics. The data underscore the multiplicity of auxiliary factors potentially involved in apoB RNA editing and suggest an editosome far more complicated than may have been previously appreciated.

Apobec-1 interacts with a 65-kDa complementing protein to edit apolipoprotein-B mRNA in vitro

The editing of apolipoprotein-B (apoB) mRNA involves the deamination of cytidine at nucleotide 6666 to uridine. The catalytic subunit of the editing enzyme, apobec-1, is a cytidine deaminase that requires other unidentified proteins to edit apoB mRNA in vitro. We partially purified an activity from baboon kidney that functionally complements apobec-1. The complementing activity was protease-sensitive and micrococcal nuclease-resistant, had a native molecular mass of 65 +/- 10 kDa on size exclusion chromatography, and sedimented at 4.5 S in glycerol gradients. Purified recombinant His6-tagged apobec-1 immobilized on beads depleted >90% of the complementing activity from partially purified extracts. These beads edited apoB mRNA in vitro in the absence of exogenous apobec-1 or complementing activity. A functional holoenzyme containing apobec-1 and the complementing activity was eluted from the apobec-1-affinity resin using 0.5 M imidazole, whereas buffer containing 0.4 M KCl eluted only the complementing activity. The carboxyl-terminal 59 amino acids of apobec-1 were not required for interaction with the complementing activity in vitro. Our results demonstrate that the complementing protein interacts directly with apobec-1 in the absence of apoB mRNA.

Base-modification mRNA editing through deamination--the good, the bad and the unregulated

RNA editing is a co- or post-transcriptional process in which select nucleotide sequences in RNA are altered from that originally encoded in the genome. The mRNAs encoding apolipoprotein B and some glutamate receptor subunits of ionotropic membrane channels are edited by site-specific base-deamination systems. Although these editing systems differ markedly in their mechanism for RNA-substrate binding and in their catalytic subunits, recent results suggest potentially common solutions to the problem of editing-site selectivity. The data suggest that there are multiple editing complexes or 'editosomes', which manifest editing-site preferences due to their macromolecular composition.

Hyperediting of multiple cytidines of apolipoprotein B mRNA by APOBEC-1 requires auxiliary protein(s) but not a mooring sequence motif

An RNA-binding cytidine deaminase (APOBEC-1) and unidentified auxiliary protein(s) are required for apolipoprotein (apo) B mRNA editing. A sequence motif on apoB mRNA ("mooring sequence," nucleotides 6671-6681) is obligatory for the editing of cytidine 6666 (C6666), the only cytidine on apoB mRNA converted to uridine in normal animals. Transgenic animals with hepatic overexpression of APOBEC-1 develop liver tumors, and other non-apoB mRNAs are edited, suggesting a loss of the normally precise specificity. In this study, we examined apoB mRNA from these transgenic animals to determine if cytidines aside from C6666 are edited. Multiple cytidines downstream from C6666 in apoB mRNA were edited extensively by the overexpressed APOBEC-1. This pathophysiological "hyperediting" could be mimicked in vitro by incubating a synthetic apoB RNA substrate with the transgenic mouse liver extracts. Multiple cytidines in the synthetic apoB RNA were edited by recombinant APOBEC-1 but only with supplementation of the auxiliary protein(s). Mutations in the mooring sequence markedly decreased the normal editing of C6666 but, surprisingly, increased the hyperediting of downstream cytidines. Furthermore, cytidines in an apoB RNA substrate lacking the mooring sequence were also edited in vitro. These results indicate that the hyperediting of apoB mRNA by overexpressed APOBEC-1 depends upon auxiliary protein(s) but is independent of the mooring sequence motif. These results suggest that hyperediting may represent the first step in a two-step recognition model for normal apoB mRNA editing.

RNA editing: how a message is changed

Considerable progress has been made in unraveling the mechanistic features of RNA editing processes in a number of genetic systems. Recent highlights include the identification of the catalytic subunit of the mammalian apolipoprotein B mRNA editing enzyme as a zinc-dependent cytidine deaminase that binds to RNA, the demonstration that adenosines in brain glutamate receptor pre-mRNAs are converted into inosines and that double-stranded RNA A deaminase (dsRAD), the candidate enzyme, is another zinc-dependent RNA nucleotide deaminase, and a mounting body of evidence for a cleavage-ligation mechanism for U insertion/deletion editing in kinetoplastid protozoa.

Overexpression of APOBEC-1 results in mooring sequence-dependent promiscuous RNA editing

Apolipoprotein B (apoB) RNA editing involves site-specific deamination of a cytidine to a uridine. A mooring sequence, a spacer region, and a regulator region are components of the apoB RNA editing motif of which only the mooring sequence is both necessary and sufficient for editosome assembly and editing. The catalytic component of the editosome is APOBEC-1. In rat hepatoma, stable cell lines, overexpression of APOBEC-1 resulted in 3 6-fold stimulation of the editing efficiency on either rat endogenous apoB RNA or transiently expressed human apoB RNA. In these cell lines, cytidines in addition to the one at the wild type site were edited. The occurrence and efficiency of this "promiscuous" editing increased with increasing expression of APOBEC-1. Promiscuous editing was restricted to cytidines 5' of the mooring sequence and only occurred on RNAs that had been edited at the wild type site. Moreover, RNAs with mutant editing motifs supported high efficiency but low fidelity editing in the presence of high levels of APOBEC-1. This study demonstrates that overexpression of APOBEC-1 can increase the efficiency of site-specific editing but can also result in promiscuous editing.

The neurofibromatosis type I messenger RNA undergoes base-modification RNA editing

A functional mooring sequence, known to be required for apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing, exists in the mRNA encoding the neurofibromatosis type I (NF1) tumor suppressor. Editing of NF1 mRNA modifies cytidine in an arginine codon (CGA) at nucleotide 2914 to a uridine (UGA), creating an in frame translation stop codon. NF1 editing occurs in normal tissue but was several-fold higher in tumors. In vitro editing and transfection assays demonstrated that apoB and NF1 RNA editing will take place in both neural tumor and hepatoma cells. Unlike apoB, NF1 editing did not demonstrate dependence on rate-limiting quantities of APOBEC-1 (the apoB editing catalytic subunit) suggesting that different trans-acting factors may be involved in the two editing processes.

Rat phospholipid-hydroperoxide glutathione peroxidase. cDNA cloning and identification of multiple transcription and translation start sites

Phospholipid-hydroperoxide glutathione peroxidase (PhGPx) is a selenoenzyme that reduces hydroperoxides of phospholipid, cholesterol, and cholesteryl ester. Previous studies suggested that both the mitochondrial and nonmitochondrial forms of PhGPx are approximately 170 amino acids long. In this study, we isolated a full-length cDNA clone encoding rat testis PhGPx. Based on sequence analysis, the cDNA encodes a protein of 197 amino acids, with translation initiating at AUG61. The additional 27 amino acids at the N terminus contain the features of a mitochondrial targeting sequence. In vitro translation of the full-length PhGPx mRNA initiated predominantly at AUG61. However, translation initiated at AUG141 when AUG61 was deleted. An RNase protection assay was used to map the 5'-ends of PhGPx mRNAs in rat tissues. We identified two major windows of transcription initiation that are tissue-specific. Rat testis predominantly expresses larger transcripts that encode the 197-amino acid protein containing the potential mitochondrial targeting signal. The predominant smaller transcripts in somatic tissues lack AUG61 and encode a 170-amino acid protein, which may represent the nonmitochondrial forms of PhGPx. Our results suggest that the use of alternative transcription and translation start sites determines the subcellular localization of PhGPx in different tissues.

Mechanisms and origins of RNA editing

RNA editing is an essential post-transcriptional process that has been identified in an increasing number of eukaryotic organisms. In the past year, progress has been made in the development of in vitro systems to study the mechanism of RNA editing. Analysis of nucleotide insertion/deletion editing in trypanosome mitochondria has revealed the existence of putative editing intermediates in vivo and in vitro. The development of an in vitro editing system for mammalian apolipoprotein B mRNA has allowed the elucidation of both the sequence requirements and the biochemical mechanism of this form of RNA editing. In addition, recent work has underscored the diversity of RNAs whose structure and function are altered by post-translational editing reactions.