Preferential repair of UV damage in highly transcribed DNA diminishes UV-induced intrachromosomal recombination in mammalian cells

Transcription-coupled repair and apoptosis provide specific protection against transcription-associated mutagenesis by ultraviolet light

Recent data reveal that gene transcription affects genome stability in mammalian cells. For example, transcription of DNA that is damaged by the most prevalent exogenous genotoxin, UV light, induces nucleotide substitutions and chromosomal instability, collectively called UV-induced transcription-associated mutations (UV-TAM). An important class of UV-TAM consists of nucleotide transitions that are caused by deamination of cytosine-containing photolesions to uracil, presumably occurring at stalled transcription complexes. Transcription-associated deletions and recombinational events after UV exposure may be triggered by collisions of replication forks with stalled transcription complexes. In this Point-of-View we propose that mammalian cells possess two tailored mechanisms to prevent UV-TAM in dermal stem cells. First, the transcription-coupled nucleotide excision repair (TCR) pathway removes lesions at transcribed DNA strands, forming the primary barrier against the mutagenic consequences of transcription at a damaged template. Second, when TCR is absent or when the capacity of TCR is exceeded, persistently stalled transcription complexes induce apoptosis, averting the generation of mutant cells following replication. We hypothesize that TCR and the apoptotic response in conjunction reduce the risk of skin carcinogenesis.

Transcription-associated recombination in eukaryotes: link between transcription, replication and recombination

Homologous recombination (HR) is an important DNA repair pathway and is essential for cellular survival. It plays a major role in repairing replication-associated lesions and is functionally connected to replication. Transcription is another cellular process, which has emerged to have a connection with HR. Transcription enhances HR, which is a ubiquitous phenomenon referred to as transcription-associated recombination (TAR). Recent evidence suggests that TAR plays a role in inducing genetic instability, for example in the THO mutants (Tho2, Hpr1, Mft1 and Thp2) in yeast or during the development of the immune system leading to genetic diversity in mammals. On the other hand, evidence also suggests that TAR may play a role in preventing genetic instability in many different ways, one of which is by rescuing replication during transcription. Hence, TAR is a double-edged sword and plays a role in both preventing and inducing genetic instability. In spite of the interesting nature of TAR, the mechanism behind TAR has remained elusive. Recent advances in the area, however, suggest a link between TAR and replication and show specific genetic requirements for TAR that differ from regular HR. In this review, we aim to present the available evidence for TAR in both lower and higher eukaryotes and discuss its possible mechanisms, with emphasis on its connection with replication.

TCDD-induced homologous recombination: the role of the Ah receptor versus oxidative DNA damage

The environmental toxicant 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) elicits numerous biological responses including carcinogenicity. The molecular mechanism by which TCDD exerts its tumorigenic effects is unclear, since it does not directly damage DNA. TCDD-initiated toxicity can be mediated by the aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR) pathway and/or via increased oxidative stress. DNA damage, including DNA oxidation, can induce DNA double-strand breaks, which can be repaired through homologous recombination. Excessive DNA double-strand breaks may promote aberrant DNA recombination, which can lead to detrimental genetic changes and ultimately to carcinogenesis. TCDD has been shown to induce homologous recombination but the molecular mechanism mediating these events are unknown. To investigate the role of the AhR and oxidative DNA damage in mediating TCDD-induced homologous recombination we used a Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell line containing a neo direct repeat recombination substrate (CHO 3-6). CHO 3-6 cells were exposed to TCDD (50, 500 or 1000 pM) in the presence or absence of an AhR antagonists (0.1 microM alpha-naphthoflavone (alpha-NF)) for 6 or 24 h and 2 weeks later homologous recombination frequencies were determined by counting the number of neo expressing, G418-resistant colonies per live cells plated. TCDD-initiated DNA oxidation was determined by measuring the formation of 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine via HPLC and electrochemical detection. Exposure to 500 pM TCDD for 24 h significantly increased the frequency of homologous recombination. Southern blot analysis on G418-resistant colonies determined that TCDD induced both conservative gene conversion events and deletion events. DNA oxidation was not increased in cells exposed to TCDD for either 6 or 24 h. However, alpha-naphthoflavone exposure resulted in a significant decrease in TCDD-induced homologous recombination frequency. These results suggest that TCDD-initiated homologous recombination in CHO 3-6 cells is mediated by the AhR and not via increased oxidative stress.

Abnormal kinetics of induction of UV-stimulated recombination in human DNA repair disorders

Recombination can result in genetic instability, and thus constitutes an important factor in the carcinogenic conversion of mammalian cells. Here we describe the occurrence of UV-stimulated recombination called enhanced recombination (EREC), measured with the use of Herpes Simplex Viruses type 1 mutants. In normal diploid human cells, EREC is induced by UV-C, mitomycin C and ENU, but not by X-ray or MMS. The kinetics of induction of EREC is similar to that of other SOS-like responses such as enhanced reactivation (ER) and enhanced mutagenesis (EM). In contrast to the latter responses, EREC is induced to higher levels and persists for longer periods in DNA repair deficient fibroblasts derived from xeroderma pigmentosum (XP), Cockayne syndrome (CS) and Trichothiodystrophy (TTD) patients. This observation indicates that EREC is a distinct SOS-like response. Apparently, the presence of unrepaired DNA lesions in the host genome is a strongly inducing signal for EREC. On the other hand, in cells derived from patients suffering from Bloom, Werner or Rothmund-Thomson syndrome (RTS) the EREC response is absent. These data indicate that determining EREC is a useful assay to investigate diploid human fibroblasts for abnormalities in UV-stimulated recombination.

Oxidative stress-induced homologous recombination as a novel mechanism for phenytoin-initiated toxicity

Although the mechanism(s) of phenytoin-initiated toxicity is unknown, phenytoin can be enzymatically bioactivated to a reactive intermediate leading to increased formation of reactive oxygen species, which can damage essential macromolecules, including DNA. The oxidation of DNA can induce DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), which may be repaired through homologous recombination. Increased levels of DSBs may induce hyper-recombination, leading to deleterious genetic changes. We hypothesize that these genetic changes mediate phenytoin-initiated toxicity. To investigate this hypothesis we used a Chinese hamster ovary cell line containing a neo direct repeat recombination substrate to determine whether phenytoin-initiated DNA oxidation increases homologous recombination. Cells were treated with 0 to 800 microM phenytoin for 5 or 24 h, and homologous recombination frequencies and recombinant product structures were determined. Phenytoin-initiated DNA oxidation was determined by measuring the formation of 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine. We demonstrate that phenytoin increases both DNA oxidation and homologous recombination in a concentration- and time-dependent manner. All recombination products analyzed arose via gene conversion without associated crossover. Our data demonstrate that phenytoin-initiated DNA damage can induce homologous recombination, which may be a novel mechanism mediating phenytoin-initiated toxicity.

Spontaneous and ultraviolet light-induced direct repeat recombination in mammalian cells frequently results in repeat deletion

Recombination is enhanced by transcription and by DNA damage caused by ultraviolet light (UV). Recombination between direct repeats can occur by gene conversion without an associated crossover, which maintains the gross repeat structure. There are several possible mechanisms that delete one repeat and the intervening sequences (gene conversion associated with a crossover, unequal sister chromatid exchange, and single-strand annealing). We examined transcription-enhanced spontaneous recombination, and UV-induced recombination between neomycin (neo) direct repeats. One neo gene was driven by the inducible MMTV promoter. Multiple (silent) markers in the second neo gene were used to map conversion tracts. These markers are thought to inhibit spontaneous recombination, and our data suggest that this inhibition is partially overcome by high level transcription. Recombination was stimulated by transcription and by UV doses of 6-12J/m(2), but not by 18J/m(2). About 70% of spontaneous and UV-induced products were deletions. In contrast, only 3% of DSB-induced products were deletions. We propose that these product spectra differ because spontaneous and UV-induced recombination is replication-dependent, whereas DSB-induced recombination is replication-independent.

Transcriptional effects on double-strand break-induced gene conversion tracts

Transcription stimulates spontaneous homologous recombination, but prior studies have not investigated the effects of transcription on double-strand break (DSB)-induced recombination in yeast. We examined products of five ura3 direct repeat substrates in yeast using alleles that were transcribed at low or high levels. In each strain, recombination was stimulated by DSBs created in vivo at an HO site in one copy of ura3. Increasing transcription levels in donor or recipient alleles did not further stimulate DSB-induced recombination, nor did it alter the relative frequencies of conversion and deletion (pop-out) events. This result is consistent with the idea that transcription enhances spontaneous recombination by increasing initiation. Gene conversion tracts were measured using silent restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) at approximately 100bp intervals. Transcription did not alter average tract lengths, but increased transcription in donor alleles increased both the frequency of promoter-proximal (5') unidirectional tracts and conversion of 5' markers. Increased transcription in recipient alleles increased the frequency of bidirectional tracts. We demonstrate that these effects are due to transcription per se, and not just transcription factor binding. These results suggest that transcription influences aspects of gene conversion after initiation, such as strand invasion and/or mismatch repair (MMR).

DNA damaging agents improve stable gene transfer efficiency in mammalian cells

Gene therapy is an evolving discipline which today relies primarily on viral systems for gene transfer. The primary reason that plasmid vectors have not been widely used for gene therapy trials is their relatively low rate of stable gene transfer. We show here that both ionizing irradiation and hydrogen peroxide can each increase the gene transfer efficiency of plasmids. Hydrogen peroxide improves gene transfer in a linear dose-dependent manner. At equitoxic doses, hydrogen peroxide improves gene transfer by 20-fold over untreated cells and approximately 5 times above that seen for radiation, and this improvement correlates with both the total amount of DNA damage induced and the amount of residual damage after 4 hr of repair. These data suggest that DNA damaging agents may be useful to improve human gene therapy.

Analysis of intrachromosomal homologous recombination in mammalian cell, using tandem repeat sequences

In all the organisms, homologous recombination (HR) is involved in fundamental processes such as genome diversification and DNA repair. Several strategies can be devised to measure homologous recombination in mammalian cells. We present here the interest of using intrachromosomal tandem repeat sequences to measure HR in mammalian cells and we discuss the differences with the ectopic plasmids recombination. The present review focuses on the molecular mechanisms of HR between tandem repeats in mammalian cells. The possibility to use two different orientations of tandem repeats (direct or inverted repeats) in parallel constitutes also an advantage. While inverted repeats measure only events arising by strand exchange (gene conversion and crossing over), direct repeats monitor strand exchange events and also non-conservative processes such as single strand annealing or replication slippage. In yeast, these processes depend on different pathways, most of them also existing in mammalian cells. These data permit to devise substrates adapted to specific questions about HR in mammalian cells. The effect of substrate structures (heterologies, insertions/deletions, GT repeats, transcription) and consequences of DNA double strand breaks induced by ionizing radiation or endonuclease (especially the rare-cutting endonuclease ISce-I) on HR are discussed. Finally, transgenic mouse models using tandem repeats are briefly presented.

Strand bias of ultraviolet light-induced mutations in a transcriptionally active gene in human cells

Ultraviolet (UV)-induced repair and mutational spectra were analyzed in an inducible marker gene, the metallothionein-l/guamine-xanthine phosphoribosyl transferase (gpt) fusion gene, carried by an Epstein-Barr virus-derived shuttle vector episomically maintained in human cells. The repair rate of UV photodimers from the shuttle-vector molecules was typical of transcriptionally active sequences, 70% of the dimers being removed within 8 h after irradiation. The spectrum obtained under basal gene transcription was compared with that obtained under induced transcription. In both cases, base substitutions at dipyrimidine sequences predominated. Multiple mutations and deletions probably due to recombinational events induced by UV damage were also observed. Most of the UV-mutated dipyrimidine sites were located in the transcribed strand and were independent of the transcriptional activity of the target gene. In contrast, the distribution of mutations throughout the coding region of the gpt gene was affected by transcription, with a preferential clustering of mutations occurring in the 3' half of the gene after transcription induction. The strand bias observed in the UV spectra most likely reflects selection for nonfunctional gpt protein.

Phorbol ester abrogates up-regulation of DNA polymerase beta by DNA-alkylating agents in Chinese hamster ovary cells

Mammalian DNA polymerase beta (beta-pol), a DNA repair polymerase, is known to be constitutively expressed in cultured cells, but treatment of cells with the DNA-alkylating agents MNNG or methyl methanesulfonate has been shown to up-regulate beta-pol mRNA level. To further characterize this response, we prepared a panel of monoclonal antibodies and used one of them to quantify beta-pol in whole cell extracts by immunoblotting. We found that treatment of Chinese hamster ovary cells with either DNA-alkylating agent up-regulated the beta-pol protein level 5-10-fold. This induction appeared to be secondary to DNA alkylation, as induction was not observed with a genetically altered cell line overexpressing the DNA repair enzyme O6-methylguanine-methyltransferase. We also found that 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA) treatment of wild type Chinese hamster ovary cells increased expression of beta-pol protein (approximately 10-fold). Any interrelationship between this TPA response and the DNA-alkylation response was studied by treatment with combinations of MNNG and TPA. The beta-pol up-regulation observed with MNNG treatment was abrogated by TPA, and conversely the up-regulation observed with TPA treatment was abrogated by MNNG.