Topological requirements for homologous recombination among DNA molecules transfected into mammalian cells

Genome engineering with TALENs and ZFNs: repair pathways and donor design

Genome engineering with targetable nucleases depends on cellular pathways of DNA repair after target cleavage. Knowledge of how those pathways work, their requirements and their active factors, can guide experimental design and improve outcomes. While many aspects of both homologous recombination (HR) and nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) are shared by a broad range of cells and organisms, some features are specific to individual situations. This article reviews the influence of repair mechanisms on the results of gene targeting experiments, with an emphasis on lessons learned from experiments with Drosophila.

Kinetics of DSB rejoining and formation of simple chromosome exchange aberrations

PURPOSE

To investigate the role of kinetics in the processing of DNA double strand breaks (DSB), and the formation of simple chromosome exchange aberrations following X-ray exposures to mammalian cells based on an enzymatic approach.

METHODS

Using computer simulations based on a biochemical approach, rate-equations that describe the processing of DSB through the formation of a DNA-enzyme complex were formulated. A second model that allows for competition between two processing pathways was also formulated. The formation of simple exchange aberrations was modelled as misrepair during the recombination of single DSB with undamaged DNA. Non-linear coupled differential equations corresponding to biochemical pathways were solved numerically by fitting to experimental data.

RESULTS

When mediated by a DSB repair enzyme complex, the processing of single DSB showed a complex behaviour that gives the appearance of fast and slow components of rejoining. This is due to the time-delay caused by the action time of enzymes in biomolecular reactions. It is shown that the kinetic- and dose-responses of simple chromosome exchange aberrations are well described by a recombination model of DSB interacting with undamaged DNA when aberration formation increases with linear dose-dependence. Competition between two or more recombination processes is shown to lead to the formation of simple exchange aberrations with a dose-dependence similar to that of a linear quadratic model.

CONCLUSIONS

Using a minimal number of assumptions, the kinetics and dose response observed experimentally for DSB rejoining and the formation of simple chromosome exchange aberrations are shown to be consistent with kinetic models based on enzymatic reaction approaches. A non-linear dose response for simple exchange aberrations is possible in a model of recombination of DNA containing a DSB with undamaged DNA when two or more pathways compete for DSB repair.

Bleomycin enhances random integration of transfected DNA into a human genome

In mammalian cells, nonhomologous (illegitimate) recombination is a predominant pathway to repair DNA double-strand breaks. We have shown that DNA topoisomerase II inhibitors are capable of enhancing random integration of foreign DNA via nonhomologous recombination. Since this enhancement is likely due to stabilized DNA strand breaks, we examined the effect of a radiomimetic antitumor drug, bleomycin (BLM), on nonhomologous recombination. We found that BLM greatly enhances the random integration of transfected plasmids into human cells. Importantly, this enhancement was independent of the molecular form of the plasmid, the cell type or the transfection method, suggesting that the BLM effect is intrinsically general. Transient expression analysis revealed no stimulation of reporter gene expression by the drug, suggesting that the effect is not attributable to increased uptake and/or accumulation of transfected DNA in the drug-treated cell nuclei. In addition, the comet assay and flow cytometric analyses revealed the occurrence of low but significant strand breaks in cells treated with the BLM concentration which maximally enhanced the integration. These results strongly suggest that BLM acts directly at a nonhomologous recombination reaction that is initiated through DNA strand breaks, promoting the integration process of transfected plasmids into human chromosomes. Our findings will facilitate the understanding of DNA integration events through nonhomologous recombination and the development of transfection protocols with higher efficiencies.

A comparison of calcium phosphate coprecipitation and electroporation. Implications for studies on the genetic effects of DNA damage

Plasmid-based transfection assays provide a rapid means to measure homologous and nonhomologous recombination in mammalian cells. Often it is of interest to examine the stimulation of recombination by DNA damage induced by radiation, genotoxic chemicals, or nucleases. Transfection is frequently performed by using calcium phosphate coprecipitation (CPP), because this method is well suited for handling large sample sets, and it does not require expensive reagents or equipment. Alternative transfection methods include lipofection, microinjection, and electroporation. Since DNA strand breaks are known to stimulate both homologous and nonhomologous recombination, the induction of nonspecific damage during transfection would increase background recombination levels and thereby reduce the sensitivity of assays designed to detect the stimulation of recombination by experimentally induced DNA damage. In this article, we compare the stimulatory effects of nuclease-induced double-strand breaks (DSBs) on homologous and nonhomologous recombination for molecules transfected by CPP and by electroporation. Although electroporation yielded fewer transfectants, both nonhomologous and homologous recombination were stimulated by nuclease-induced DSBs to a greater degree than with CPP. Ionizing radiation is an effective agent for inducing DNA strand breaks, but previous studies using CPP generally showed little or no stimulation of homologous recombination among plasmids damaged with ionizing radiation. By contrast, we found clear dose-dependent enhancement of recombination with irradiated plasmids transfected using electroporation. Thus, electroporation provides a higher signal-to-noise ratio for transfection-based studies of damage-induced recombination, possibly reflecting less nonspecific damage to plasmid DNA during transfection of mammalian cells.

Biased short tract repair of palindromic loop mismatches in mammalian cells

Mismatch repair of palindromic loops in the presence or absence of single-base mismatches was investigated in wild-type and mismatch-binding defective mutant Chinese hamster ovary cells. Recombination intermediates with a maximum heteroduplex DNA (hDNA) region of 697 bp contained a centrally located, phenotypically silent 12-base palindromic loop mismatch, and/or five single-base mismatches. In wild-type cells, both loops and single-base mismatches were efficiently repaired (80-100%). When no other mismatches were present in hDNA, loops were retained with a 1.6-1.9:1 bias. However, this bias was eliminated when single-base mismatches were present, perhaps because single-base mismatches signal nick-directed repair. In the multiple marker crosses, most repair tracts were long and continuous, with preferential loss of markers in cis to proximal nicks, consistent with nicks directing most repair in this situation. However, approximately 25% of repair tracts were discontinuous as a result of loop-specific repair, or from segregation or short tract repair of single-base mismatches. In mutant cells, single-base mismatches were repaired less frequently, but the loop was still repaired efficiently and with bias toward loop retention, indicating that the defect in these cells does not affect loop-specific repair. Repair tracts in products from mutant cells showed a wide variety of mosaic patterns reflecting short regions of repair and segregation consistent with reduced nick-directed repair. In mutant cells, single-base mismatches were repaired more efficiently in the presence of the loop than in its absence, a likely consequence of corepair initiated at the loop.

Rescue of polyomavirus DNA after co-transfection of recombinant plasmids with viral DNA fragments

Plasmid DNA bearing a single copy of the mouse polyomavirus (Py) genome (template A) was transfected into murine cells together with another DNA (template B) carrying intact the viral sequence interrupted in template A. Rescue of unit-length Py DNA including markers from both templates was observed as long as the viral DNA in B overlapped that split in A by one kbp or more. Such rescue was not detectably enhanced by linearizing either or both template(s), and occurred in the absence of template replication. These findings are suggestive of an intermolecular recombination process taking place soon after transfection and starting with homologous pairing between A and B. Such pairing would facilitate removal of vector DNA from one template (A), followed by closure of the resulting break or gap through recombination with the other template (B). Since B may consist of a PCR-synthesized DNA fragment, these observations could conceivably serve as the basis for a method of generating mutant viral genomes.

Characterisation of a DNA pairing activity copurifying with DNA ligase in a partially purified extract from rat testis

Rat testicular nuclear extracts were fractionated sequentially on phosphocellulose, heparin-agarose and ssDNA-cellulose columns, in order to isolate and characterise a strand-transfer activity from a mammalian meiotic tissue. A partially purified fraction, eluting at 0.6 M KCl from ssDNA-cellulose column, catalyzed the formation of two classes of products migrating slowly on an agarose gel. The formation of one of these classes of products-the aggregates-was dependent on the presence of both the substrates (M13mp19 RF III and M13mp19 ssDNA) and on homology. The presence of ATP was essential for the formation of aggregates, though its hydrolysis was not required. EM analysis of the products indicated the presence of structures which resembled paired DNA molecules: duplex-duplex paired (Y-shaped and ds-ds paired structures) and ss-ds paired (duplex DNA paired with the single-stranded DNA) structures, indicating the presence of a pairing protein in the fraction. However, alpha- and sigma-structures were not observed. The other class of products, seen as discrete bands, were identified biochemically and by electron microscopy as ligated products. A DNA ligase-adenylate adduct of molecular weight 100 kDa was formed by the fraction. Both 5' to 3' and 3' to 5' exonucleases were absent and hence did not contribute to the formation of the products.

DNA topoisomerase II inhibitors enhance random integration of transfected vectors into human chromosomes

To study the involvement of DNA topoisomerase (topo) II on nonhomologous (illegitimate) recombination, we examined the effect of topo II inhibitors on random integration of exogenous vectors into human chromosomes. We transfected human cell lines PA1, HeLa and EJ-1 with linearized plasmid pSV2neo by electroporation, treated with topo II inhibitors and determined the frequency of Geneticin-resistant (G418r) colonies. We found that three topo II inhibitors, etoposide (VP-16), ICRF-193 and amsacrine (m-AMSA), greatly enhanced the frequency of G418r colonies. These effects were maximally expressed by as little as 12 hrs treatment with the drugs. Similar enhancements were found with different vectors (closed-circular and linear), different cell types, or by different transfection methods (calcium precipitation and lipofection). In contrast, the inhibitor treatments did not affect the transient expression of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase and beta-galactosidase activity following transfection with pSV2CAT and pCH110, respectively. Southern blot analysis revealed that the integration pattern of transfected pSV2neo into PA1 chromosomes was random and not characteristic for each inhibitor. These results suggest that topo II inhibitors directly act at a nonhomologous recombination reaction, promoting the integration process of transfected vectors into human chromosomes. We discuss the enhancement mechanism with a special emphasis on DNA strand breaks induced by the inhibitors.

End joining of genomic DNA and transgene DNA in fertilized mouse eggs

A linear 5.2-kb HS2/beta-globin construct with an upstream KpnI terminus (4-nucleotide (nt) 3' protruding single strand, PSS) and a downstream SalI terminus (4-nt 5' PSS) was microinjected into fertilized mouse eggs. The injected DNA fragments integrated into the mouse genome primarily as a head-to-tail tandem array. Chromosome/transgene junctions were obtained from seven of eight transgenic animals. All of the junctions occurred in the proximity of a transgene KpnI end; a maximum loss of 8 nt from the transgene terminus was observed. Two of these junctions completely preserved the 4-nt KpnI 3' PSS. Transgene/transgene junctions from two animals were analyzed. SalI/KpnI junctions that completely preserved both the SalI 5' PSS and the KpnI 3' PSS were found in each animal. These are the first examples of complete nt preservation at junctions formed between a 5' PSS terminus and a 3' PSS terminus in transgenic mice. The data are consistent with the fill-in model of Thode et al. [Cell 60 (1990) 921-928] in which alignment proteins juxtapose 5' PSS and 3' PSS termini; DNA polymerase then utilizes the recessed 3'-OH of the 5' PSS terminus as a primer to synthesize DNA across the gap. This mechanism results in the formation of junctions with no loss of sequence. The results described in the present paper suggest that this mechanism may be involved in the formation of junctions in transgenic mice.

Cis-acting effects of sequences within 2.4-kb upstream of the human c-myc gene on autonomous plasmid replication in HeLa cells

We have used density shift analysis to monitor the autonomous replicating sequence (ARS) activity of plasmids containing various DNA fragments from the 5'-flanking region of the human c-myc gene. The ARS activity of certain of these plasmids implied that structures in the c-myc DNA could be recognized for the initiation of replication in the absence of chromosomal integration. The plasmid pNeo.Myc-2.4 contains 2.4 contains 2.4 kb of c-myc 5'-flanking DNA, and replicated semiconservatively as a circular extrachromosomal element. Deletion derivatives of pNeo.Myc-2.4 containing either of two nonoverlapping regions of c-myc DNA semiconservatively incorporated bromodeoxyuridine into discrete populations of heavy-light supercoiled molecules to roughly the same extent as the chromosomal DNA in the same cultures. Some constructs displayed lower ARS activity, implying that distinct cis-acting sequences in the c-myc 5'-flanking DNA may independently affect DNA replication. The ARS activity of two separate c-myc sequences suggests that replication initiation signals are redundant in the c-myc origin. The smallest c-myc insert that displayed substantial ARS activity was 930 bp long and contained three 10/11 matches to the yeast ARS consensus and several additional features found in eukaryotic replication origins.

Gene-targeting and the p53 tumor-suppressor gene

Gene-targeting techniques are now frequently applied to embryonic stem (ES) cells to introduce mutations of endogenous genes in mice. Modifications introduced into tumor-suppressor genes by this technology have produced mice and cell lines with unique tumorigenic and growth characteristics, respectively. A number of strategies have been developed to enhance the efficiency of homologous recombination between targeting vectors and endogenous genes. This review describes recent advances in the techniques used to construct mice with a variety of genetic alterations. In addition, an application of gene-targeting is illustrated in the study of a class of genes with tumor-suppressor function. Recent findings from experiments using gene targeted mice to study the p53 tumor-suppressor gene are discussed and the potential of gene-targeting for the discovery and study of novel tumor-suppressor genes are explored.

One-sided invasion events in homologous recombination at double-strand breaks

Two classes of homologous recombination mechanism for repair of double-strand breaks (DSBs) have been described in eukaryotes so far. One is conservative and has been explained by the double-strand break repair model (Szostak et al., 1983), whereas the other one is non-conservative and has been explained by the single-strand annealing model (Lin et al., 1984). Here, we will review data supporting the existence of another homologous recombination mechanism for double-strand break repair. We will present the one-sided invasion model that we have proposed to explain this mechanism and discuss its potential implication in various homologous recombination events.

Multiple tandem integrations of transforming DNA sequences in yeast chromosomes suggest a mechanism for integrative transformation by homologous recombination

In yeast, the fate of linear DNA molecules upon transformation is determined by the existence of sequence homology between chromosomes and the ends of the transforming molecule. To understand the mechanism of integration of transforming DNA, we have studied the influence of DNA concentration on the frequency and type of transformants obtained, using either non-replicative or replicative plasmids. In both cases, increasing DNA concentration results in multiple tandem repeats integrated into the chromosome containing the homologous target sequence. When a diploid strain is transformed, multiple tandem repeats occur in only one of the two homologous chromosomes at a time. The frequency distribution of the different types of integrants observed indicates non-independent integration events likely to result from plasmid-plasmid interaction prior to chromosome integration. In addition, our results define the proper conditions for optimized gene targetting or gene rescue experiments.

Targeting vector configuration and method of gene transfer influence targeted correction of the APRT gene in Chinese hamster ovary cells

A 21-bp deletion in the third exon of the APRT gene in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells was corrected by transfection with a plasmid containing hamster APRT sequences. Targeted correction frequencies in the range of 0.3-3.0 x 10(-6) were obtained with a vector containing 3.2 kb of APRT sequence homology. To examine the influence of vector configuration on targeted gene correction, a double-strand break was introduced at one of two positions in the vector prior to transfection by calcium phosphate-DNA coprecipitation or electroporation. A double-strand break in the region of APRT homology contained in the vector produced an insertion-type vector, while placement of the break just outside the region of homology produced a replacement-type vector. Gene targeting with both linear vector configurations yielded equivalent ratios of targeted recombinants to nontargeted vector integrants; however, targeting with the two different vector configurations resulted in different distributions of targeted recombination products. Analysis of 66 independent APRT+ recombinant clones by Southern hybridization showed that targeting with the vector in a replacement-type configuration yielded fewer targeted integrants and more target gene convertants than did the integration vector configuration. Targeted recombination was about fivefold more efficient with electroporation than with calcium phosphate-DNA coprecipitation; however, both gene transfer methods produced similar distributions of targeted recombinants, which depended only on targeting vector configuration. Our results demonstrate that insertion-type and replacement-type gene targeting vectors produce similar overall targeting frequencies in gene correction experiments, but that vector configuration can significantly influence the yield of particular recombinant types.

Repair and misrepair of site-specific DNA double-strand breaks by human cell extracts

The rejoining by human cell extracts of a double-strand break induced by endonuclease treatment at one of several sites within a small DNA molecule was studied. Rejoining was found at each of 8 sites tested, but the rejoin efficiency varied with the nature of the break (e.g., breaks with cohesive ends were rejoined more efficiently than blunt-ended breaks). Extracts from primary and immortalized cell lines, as well as those from individuals with ataxia telangiectasia (A-T), showed the same pattern of relative rejoin efficiencies. However, mis-rejoining varied with the cell extract used, and was particularly elevated with two immortalized A-T cell lines. Mixing experiments showed that the mis-rejoining property of extracts could act in a semi-dominant fashion, depending on the individual efficiencies of the component extracts. The mis-rejoin mechanism involved deletion at sites of short direct repeats at various distances from the initial break site. A model of deletion formation (the strand-exposure and repair model) is restated to explain the sequence repeat dependence found, and is compared to models of homologous DNA recombination.

Construction of a new universal vector for insertional mutagenesis by homologous recombination

We describe here the construction of a vector (pSSC-9) which can be used for the insertional mutagenesis of any gene for which genomic sequences have been cloned. This vector contains a neomycin-resistance-encoding gene (neoR) which is driven by a modified thymidine kinase (tk) promoter for positive selection. Flanking neoR are two tk genes driven by their own promoters for negative selection of nonhomologous insertions. The neoR and tk cassettes are separated by four unique cloning sites on the right-hand side of the neoR cassette and three unique sites on the left-hand side. The vector also includes two SfiI sites, one on each side of the tk cassettes, for the excision of the cloned genomic DNA fragments along with the selectable markers. Electroporation of pSSC-9 into mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells and cultured diploid mouse adrenal Y-1 cells conferred resistance to G418 and sensitivity to ganciclovir in both cell lines. These results illustrate the expression of the positive and negative selectable markers in two different cell lines and thus suggest that the vector could be used in ES cells, as well as in cultured somatic cells.

V(D)J recombination in mouse thymocytes: double-strand breaks near T cell receptor delta rearrangement signals

In the murine T cell receptor delta locus, V(D)J recombination events frequently involve the D2 and J1 elements. Here we report the presence of double-strand breaks at recombination signals flanking D2 in approximately 2% of thymus DNA. An excised linear species containing the sequences between D2 and J1 and a circular product of the joining of D2 and J1 recombination signals were also found. Although broken molecules with signal ends were detected, no species with coding ends could be identified. Observation of these broken molecules in thymus, but not in liver or spleen, provides the first direct evidence for an association between specific cleavage of chromosomal DNA and recombination in mammalian cells, and supports a breakage-reunion model of V(D)J recombination.

Reconstitution of an episomal mouse aprt gene as a consequence of recombination

When a functional murine adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (aprt) gene linked to bovine papilloma virus (BPV) DNA is transfected into Aprt- L cells, the cells are rendered Aprt+ and the aprt gene persists as an episome. Cotransfection with two BPV vectors, one containing the 5' half of the aprt gene and the other the 3' half of the gene, that share about 300 bp of common sequence in intron 2, produces Aprt+ cells with functional aprt as an episome. Southern blot analysis of low molecular weight DNA derived from Hirt extracts revealed the regeneration of a diagnostic SmaI fragment, consistent with establishment of an episome with functional aprt that was reconstituted as a consequence of recombination. To establish cells with an episomal target for recombination, BPV vectors containing a G418 resistance marker and either the 5' half or 3' half of aprt were transfected into Aprt- L cells. Stably transfected cells, selected by their growth in G418, were in turn transfected with DNA containing the other half of the aprt gene. Following selection of Aprt+ cells, Southern blot and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of low molecular weight DNA confirmed the presence of a complete episomal aprt gene. The region of DNA shared by the episomal aprt fragment and the transfected aprt half was sequenced after PCR amplification of the reconstituted, episomal gene and was found to be wild type. The region of overlap that serves as the substrate for recombination lies entirely within an intron and can, therefore, tolerate nucleotide substitutions and deletions. The absence of such errors in the sequences examined is consistent with recombination events that are not error prone.

Targeted homologous recombination in mammalian cells

This article presents a review of recent progress in the field of targeted homologous recombination in mammalian cells. Beginning with an introduction of basic terminology and why 'gene targeting' is potentially such a powerful genetic tool, the article explores some of the obstacles that must be overcome in order for targeting to be generally useful. In particular, the different ways in which investigators have been able to work around the great inefficiency of gene targeting is covered in some detail. When possible, insights into the mechanisms(s) of gene targeting are extracted from the published literature. The use of targeted gene 'knockout' in mouse embryonic stems cells to create animal disease models is discussed. The need for systematic studies into the mechanisms(s) of targeting to make gene targeting useful for human gene therapy is recognized, and some suggestions are made.

Extrachromosomal recombination is deranged in the rec2 mutant of Ustilago maydis

Transformation of a leu1 auxotroph of Ustilago maydis to prototrophy with an autonomously replicating plasmid containing the selectable LEU1 gene was found to be efficient regardless of whether the transforming DNA was circular or linear. When pairs of autonomously replicating plasmids bearing noncomplementing leu1 alleles were used to cotransform strains deleted entirely for the genomic copy of the LEU1 gene, Leu+ transformants were observed to arise by extrachromosomal recombination. The frequency of recombination increased severalfold when one plasmid of the pair was made linear by cleavage at one end of the leu1 gene, but increased 10-100-fold when both plasmids were first made linear. The increase in recombination noted in wild-type and rec1 strains was not apparent in the rec2 mutant unless the members of the pair of plasmids were cut at opposite ends of the leu1 gene to yield linear molecules offset in only one of the two possible configurations. Use of a pair of plasmid substrates designed to measure nonreciprocal and multiple exchange events revealed only a minor fraction of the total events arise through these modes, and further that no stimulation occurred when the plasmid DNA was linear. It is unlikely that the defect in rec2 lies in a mismatch correction step since a high yield of Leu+ recombinants was obtained from the rec2 mutant when it was transformed with heteroduplex DNA constructed from plasmids with the two different leu1 alleles.

Homologous recombination between plasmid DNA molecules in maize protoplasts

The requirements for homologous recombination between plasmid DNA molecules have been studied using the PEG (polyethylene glycol)-mediated transformation system of maize (Zea mays L.) protoplasts coupled with the transient expression assay for beta-glucuronidase (GUS). Two plasmids were introduced into maize protoplasts; one plasmid (pB x 26) contained a genomic clone of the Adh1 maize gene; the other plasmid (piGUS) was a promoterless construction containing part of intron A of the Adh1 gene fused to the gusA coding sequence. Thus, the two vectors shared an effective homologous region consisting of a 459 bp (HindIII-PvuII) fragment of the Adh1 intron A sequence. An active gusA fusion gene would result upon homologous recombination between the plasmids within the intron A sequence, and indeed GUS activity was observed in extracts following co-transformation of maize protoplasts with the two plasmids. The presence of recombinant DNA molecules in protoplast DNA isolated 1 day after co-transformation was verified using polymerase chain reactions (PCR) and Southern blots. For efficient homologous recombination, both plasmids had to be linearized. The recombination reaction was induced by restriction of the plasmid molecules either inside the effective homologous region or at the borders of the intron sequence. However, the presence of even small, terminal, nonhomologous sequences at the 3' end of the pB x 26 fragment inhibited the recombination reaction. Also, both ends of the linearized piGUS DNA molecules were involved in the recombination reaction. The results revealed some features of homologous recombination reactions occurring in plant cells which cannot be accommodated by mechanisms postulated for similar reactions in animal system and in lower eukaryotes.

The mechanism of extrachromosomal homologous DNA recombination in plant cells

By cotransfecting plasmids carrying particular mutations in the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) gene into Nicotiana plumbaginifolia protoplasts and by monitoring the recombination rates using a recently developed transient assay, we were able to obtain insights into the mechanism of extrachromosomal recombination operating in plant cells. An exchange of flanking markers takes place in over 90% of the recombination events. In most of the remaining cases two consecutive, independent single crossover events occur. These events involve the same DNA substrate and lead to two successive exchanges of flanking markers, thus mimicking a presumed double crossover intermediate. A comparison of the outcome of our experiments with the predictions of two recombination models originally proposed for mammalian cells indicates that extrachromosomal recombination in plant cells is best described by the single strand annealing model. According to this model all recombination events result in an exchange of flanking markers. Our results rule out the double strand break repair model which predicts that flanking markers are exchanged in only half of all events.

T-DNA integration: a mode of illegitimate recombination in plants

Transferred DNA (T-DNA) insertions of Agrobacterium gene fusion vectors and corresponding insertional target sites were isolated from transgenic and wild type Arabidopsis thaliana plants. Nucleotide sequence comparison of wild type and T-DNA-tagged genomic loci showed that T-DNA integration resulted in target site deletions of 29-73 bp. In those cases where integrated T-DNA segments turned out to be smaller than canonical ones, the break-points of target deletions and T-DNA insertions overlapped and consisted of 5-7 identical nucleotides. Formation of precise junctions at the right T-DNA border, and DNA sequence homology between the left termini of T-DNA segments and break-points of target deletions were observed in those cases where full-length canonical T-DNA inserts were very precisely replacing plant target DNA sequences. Aberrant junctions were observed in those transformants where termini of T-DNA segments showed no homology to break-points of target sequence deletions. Homology between short segments within target sites and T-DNA, as well as conversion and duplication of DNA sequences at junctions, suggests that T-DNA integration results from illegitimate recombination. The data suggest that while the left T-DNA terminus and both target termini participate in partial pairing and DNA repair, the right T-DNA terminus plays an essential role in the recognition of the target and in the formation of a primary synapsis during integration.

Homologous recombination in bovine papillomavirus shuttlevecter; effect of relative orientation of substrate sequences

Relative orientation of recombination substrates, neo gene, strongly influenced homologous recombination events in a bovine papillomavirus shuttle vector. Between direct repeats, recombination occurred at a high frequency while between inverted repeats, it was rare. Double strand break near the mutation site increased the recombination frequency between inverted repeats but not between direct repeats. Formation of long heteroduplex as a recombination intermediate may explain this apparently paradoxical phenomenon.

Extrachromosomal homologous recombination and gene targeting in plant cells after Agrobacterium mediated transformation

We determined whether T-DNA molecules introduced into plant cells using Agrobacterium are suitable substrates for homologous recombination. For the detection of such recombination events different mutant versions of a NPTII construct were used. In a first set of experiments protoplasts of Nicotiana tabacum SR1 were cocultivated with two Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains. Each strain contained a different T-DNA, one carrying a 5' deleted NPTII gene and the other a NPTII gene with a 3' deletion. A restored NPTII gene was found in 1-4% of the protoplasts that had been cotransformed with both T-DNAs. Restoration of the NPTII gene could only be the consequence of homologous recombination between the two different T-DNAs in the plant cell, since the possibility of recombination in Agrobacterium was excluded in control experiments. In subsequent experiments was investigated the potential use of Agrobacterium for gene targeting in plants. A transgenic tobacco line with a T-DNA insertion carrying a defective NPTII gene with a 3' deletion was transformed via Agrobacterium with a T-DNA containing a defective NPTII repair gene. Several kanamycin resistant plant lines were obtained with an intact NPTII gene integrated in their genome. In one of these lines the defective NPTII gene at the target locus had been properly restored. Our results show that in plants recombination can occur between a chromosomal locus and a homologous T-DNA introduced via A. tumefaciens. This opens the possibility of using the Agrobacterium transformation system for site directed mutagenesis of the plant genome.

Development of RD-tat cell lines: use in HIV recombination studies

The transactivator (tat) gene of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) plays an essential role in the replication cycle of HIV. Previous studies have evaluated the extent and mechanistic aspects of tat-mediated transactivation using lymphoid and adherent non-lymphoid cells. We have exploited the transactivation property of the tat gene to achieve high levels of hybrid HIV resulting from recombination between HIV DNAs. For this purpose, we have generated stably transformed human rhabdomyosarcoma (RD) cell lines expressing tat gene product of HIV-1. Functional analysis of the cell lines for the presence of tat protein by transfecting HIV-long terminal repeat (LTR) linked to chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) revealed low, moderate, and high tat producer cell lines. RD-tat cell lines also showed enhanced virus production upon transfection of HIV-1 proviral DNA. Further, tat producer cell lines showed a high amount of hybrid virus in comparison to the control RD cells upon transfection of truncated viral DNAs. Thus, RD-tat cell lines would be valuable target cells for generating homogeneous viruses upon transfection of viral DNA.

Homologous recombination in a mammalian plasmid

Bovine papillomavirus (BPV) shuttle vectors replicate as a circular plasmid in mouse cell nuclei without impairing host cell viability. We used these vectors to analyze homologous recombination in mammalian cells. When several BPV-based plasmids carrying direct repeats were introduced into C127 cells, we detected many recombinant plasmid molecules that have lost the sequence between the repeats. Many recombinant type molecules as well as parental type molecules were detected in all the cell clones isolated for analysis. Sequencing after rescue of the plasmid in Escherichia coli showed that most of the recombinants were from accurate homologous recombination. When the repeats on the plasmid were in inverted orientation, no crossing-over type products were detected. We discuss possible mechanisms that explain these features.

Relative frequencies of homologous recombination between plasmids introduced into DNA repair-deficient and other mammalian somatic cell lines

Twelve mammalian somatic cell lines, some of them DNA damage-sensitive mutants paired with their respective wild-type parental lines, were assayed for their ability to catalyze extrachromosomal, intermolecular homologous recombination between pSV2neo plasmid recombination substrates. All of the somatic cell lines analyzed are capable of catalyzing homologous recombination; however, there is a wide range of efficiencies with which they do so. Five human cell lines display a fourfold range of recombination frequencies, and six hamster cell lines vary almost 20-fold. Linearizing one of the recombination substrates stimulates recombination in all but one of the cell lines. Two of the three paired mutant cell lines display a threefold reduction in their ability to catalyze homologous recombination when compared to their respective parental cell lines, indicating that the mutations that render them sensitive to DNA damaging agents might also play a role in homologous recombination.

A genetic investigation of the mechanism of adenovirus marker rescue

We have developed quantitative and segregational methods for investigating the mechanism of genetic exchange in adenovirus marker rescue. Estimates of "marker rescue frequency" (m.r.f.) were used to show that marker rescue increases linearly with increasing dose of fragment up to equimolarity with the full-length genome. The m.r.f. is also affected by the size of the rescuing fragment and the position of the wild-type allele within it, regardless of whether the fragment is terminal or internal. This is compatible with marker rescue being based on homologous exchange between the recombining partners. Examination of individually transfected cells showed that there is very wide variability in the values of the m.r.f.'s. This suggests that marker transfer can occur after replication of the full-length genome has begun, and can occur late into the infectious cycle. Unselected markers on the rescuing fragment were shown to be co-inherited frequently. This suggests that physical linkage is accompanied by genetic linkage. To examine this more closely, a multifactorial marker rescue was performed. The data show unequivocally that markers resident on the same fragment as the selected allele are inherited at high frequency, with a gradient of transfer in which markers closest to the selected marker are transferred most frequently. Markers up to 13 and perhaps as many as 17 kb apart can be inherited together. There are very few examples of the inheritance of distal markers in the absence of proximal ones. These data suggest that large pieces of DNA are transferred in a concerted reaction during marker rescue.

Primary cells and established cell lines join DNA ends with the same efficiency relative to homologous recombination

The joining of DNA ends was compared in the established CV1 cell line and in African green monkey kidney primary cells, from which the CV1 cell line was established. Using a linear SV40 genome that carries a terminal repeat of 526 nucleotide pairs, we measured the efficiency of circularization by end joining relative to circularization by homologous recombination between the terminal repeats. The ratios of end joining to homologous recombination were identical in the two types of cells regardless of whether the DNA ends were sticky, blunt, or mismatched. These studies demonstrate that the efficient end joining observed in established cell lines is not a peculiar adaptation to life in culture, but rather reflects a normal aspect of DNA metabolism in mammalian cells. Furthermore, the similar results in primary and established cells support the general validity of using data from studies of cultured cells to formulate models of recombinational processes in primary cells and potentially in multicellular organisms as well.

Intermolecular plasmid recombination in fibroblasts from humans with DNA damage-processing defects

We have evaluated the ability of immortalized human fibroblasts to recombine transfected plasmid DNA. A number of cell lines from normal individuals and from patients with DNA damage-processing defects were examined. Two plasmid recombination substrates were derived from pSV2neo and contained nonoverlapping deletions in the aminoglycoside phosphotransferase II gene. Intermolecular recombination was assessed by two methods after cotransfection. In a short-term, extrachromosomal recombination assay, low molecular weight DNA was extracted from the human cells 48 h after transfection, and recombinant plasmids were detected by transformation into appropriate indicator bacteria. In a long-term stable recombination assay the fibroblasts were cotransfected and G418-resistant colonies allowed to form. By the former assay all but two cultures were recombination-proficient, whereas all were recombination-proficient by the latter assay. The efficiency of transfection of human cells with plasmids appears to be a major variable affecting recombination. Recombination can be stimulated by uv irradiation of plasmid DNA prior to transfection. Cells from patients with Fanconi anemia, ataxia telangiectasia, and xeroderma pigmentosum complementation groups A, C, D, E, and G are not defective at intermolecular plasmid recombination.

The new mouse genetics: altering the genome by gene targeting

Gene targeting (homologous recombination between DNA sequences residing in the chromosome and newly introduced DNA sequences) in pluripotent, mouse embryo-derived stem (ES) cells promises to provide the means to generate mice of any desired genotype. This review describes some of the background and current advances of gene targeting in mouse ES cells.

Recombinational repair of hydrogen peroxide-induced damages in DNA of phage T4

Recently, hydrogen peroxide and its free-radical product, the hydroxyl radical (OH.) have been identified as major sources of DNA damage in living organisms. They occur as ubiquitous metabolic by-products and, in humans, cause several thousand damages in a cell's DNA per day. They are thought to be a major source of DNA damage leading to aging and cancer in multicellular organisms. This raises two questions. First, what pathways are used in repair of DNA damages caused by H2O2 and OH.? Second, a new theory has been proposed that sexual reproduction (sex) evolved to promote repair of DNA in the germ line of organisms. If this theory is correct, then the type of repair specifically available during the sexual process should be able to deal with important natural lesions such as those produced by H2O2 and OH. . Does this occur? We examined repair of hydrogen peroxide damage to DNA, using a standard bacteriophage T4 test system in which sexual reproduction is either permitted or not permitted. Post-replication recombinational repair and denV-dependent excision repair are not dependent on sex. Both of these processes had little or no effect on lethal H2O2 damage. Also, an enzyme important in repair of H2O2-induced DNA damage in the E. coli host cells, exonuclease III, was not utilized in repair of lethal H2O2 damage to the phage. However, multiplicity reactivation, a recombinational form of repair depending on the sexual interaction of two or more of the bacteriophage, was found to repair lethal H2O2 damages efficiently. Our results lend support to the repair hypothesis of sex. Also the homology-dependent recombinational repair utilized in the phage sexual process may be analogous to the homology-dependent recombination which is widespread in diploid eucaryotes. The recombinational repair pathway found in phage T4 may thus be a widely applicable model for repair of the ubiquitous DNA damage caused by endogenous oxidative reactions.

The creation of adenovirus genomes with viable, stable, internal redundancies centered about the E2b region

During the course of constructing new adenoviral strains by overlap recombination, we have discovered that internally redundant viable genomes can be created by end-to-end joining of the input DNA molecules. The cellular functions responsible for the end-joining activity frequently ligated the overhanging single strands of the complementary ends to form a novel restriction site at the junction. In 2 of the 17 cases analyzed in detail by restriction digestion, and some sequence determinations, the cellular functions had repaired the ends, presumably prior to end-joining. Four of the isolates had suffered deletions at the junction ranging in size from 13 to 532 bp. The isolate with the largest deletion also had an insertion of 14 bp of unknown origin at the site of the deletion. All of the redundant isolates replicated as efficiently as isogenic unit length strains, and plaque dilution titrations obeyed one-hit kinetics, showing that the redundant genomes were nondefective. Nevertheless unit-length genomes were observed at a low level (some 5 to 10% of the total) in stocks of each isolate before and after plaque purification. They presumably arose by recombination between the redundant sequences either intra- or intermolecularly. Evidence from Southern blot analysis showed that molecules with three copies of the redundant sequences also arose and could be detected both in intracellular and in capsid viral DNA. These species would arise by unequal crossing-over between redundant genomes. The efficient replication of the redundant species demonstrates that the precise spatial relationships between splice donors and acceptors on either strand, in this region of the genome, do not have to be rigidly maintained. These data suggest that it may be possible to place other genetic information between the DNA polymerase and terminal protein precursor genes and have it expressed from the major late promoter in its normal location.