Occupational therapy and physiotherapy interventions in palliative care: a cross-sectional study of patient-reported needs

Alignment of Palliative Care Service Structure and Standards of Care for Adolescents and Young Adults with Cancer: An International Survey of Clinical Practice

Background: Access to timely, age-appropriate palliative care services and end-of-life communication are two standards of care for adolescents and young adults (AYAs) living with cancer where cure is uncertain or unlikely. Health professionals' capacity to facilitate these standards is critical. This study aimed to understand AYA oncology health professionals' experienced practices in, and barriers to, delivering these standards of care across palliative care and end-of-life communication in Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom (UK). Procedure: We invited health professionals to complete a survey examining access, barriers to, and practices around these standards of care. Tailored to local settings, our survey assessed current delivery of palliative care and end-of-life communication services (including advance care planning [ACP]) and barriers to implementation of these. Results: In total, 148 interdisciplinary health professionals participated (89% female overall; 83% female in Australia, 88% female in New Zealand, and 98% female in the UK). Across countries, participants reported that most institutions had an AYA cancer program (74% overall). Introduction to palliative care services was most often prognosis dependent or "not at any uniform time." ACP was less frequently introduced than palliative care. The most endorsed barrier to palliative care team introduction, as well as ACP, was "some team members not knowing how to introduce the topic." Conclusions: Our results indicate that there are common barriers to AYAs receiving palliative care, end-of-life communication, and ACP. Given that health professionals' confidence in this area can enable facilitation of early, age-appropriate communication, resources and training are urgently needed to bridge these practice gaps.

Physiotherapy applied to palliative care patients: a descriptive practice-based study

BACKGROUND

Over the last few years, the presence of physiotherapists in Palliative Care Units (PCU) has considerably grown based on evidence from studies supporting the use of non-pharmacological measures as part of Palliative Care (PC) treatments. However, more accumulated data are needed to definitively establish its added value. The present study describes the type of patients receiving physiotherapy in a PCU and the benefits obtained in relation to their degree of functional dependence.

METHODS

An observational, prospective, descriptive, practice-based study was undertaken involving patients admitted to the PCU of Fundación Instituto San José (Madrid, Spain), who according to the PCU´s clinical practice, met the criteria for physiotherapy intervention. Daily clinical practice was unchanged for study reasons. Participants were assessed prior to initiating and at the end of the physiotherapy program using the following standard scales: the Barthel Index, the Functional Ambulation Categories scale, the Palliative Performance Scale, and the Braden scale. A descriptive analysis was performed and scale scores prior to and after treatment were compared using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test. Significance was set at 0.05.

RESULTS

A total of 63 patients were included (mean age 71.98 ± 12.72; 61.9% males). Fifty-eight patients (92.1%) were oncological patients; of them, 35 (60.3%) had metastases. Prior to treatment, 28 (44.4%) participants had total dependence according to the Barthel index, and 37 (58.7%) were non-functional ambulator according to the FAC scale. At the end of treatment, the number of patients with total dependence decreased to 15 (23.8%) and those non-functional ambulator to 12 (19.0%).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients who benefited from physical therapy during their admission to our PCU were predominantly males with oncological processes, mainly lung cancer. PC including physiotherapy improved their functionality, independence and skills for activities of daily living in this sample of PCU patients.

Integrated Short-term Palliative Rehabilitation to improve quality of life and equitable care access in incurable cancer (INSPIRE): a multinational European research project

Background

Disability related to incurable cancer affects over a million Europeans each year and people with cancer rank loss of function among the most common unmet supportive care needs.

Objectives

To test the clinical and cost-effectiveness of an integrated short-term palliative rehabilitation intervention, to optimise function and quality of life in people affected by incurable cancer.

Design

This is a multinational, parallel group, randomised, controlled, assessor blind, superiority trial.

Methods

The INSPIRE consortium brings together leaders in palliative care, oncology and rehabilitation from partner organisations across Europe, with complementary expertise in health service research, trials of complex interventions, mixed-method evaluations, statistics and economics. Partnership with leading European civil society organisations ensures citizen engagement and dissemination at the highest level. We will conduct a multinational randomised controlled trial across five European countries, recruiting participants to assess the effectiveness of palliative rehabilitation for people with incurable cancer on the primary outcome - quality of life - and secondary outcomes including disability, symptom burden and goal attainment. To support trial conduct and enhance analysis of trial data, we will also conduct: comparative analysis of current integration of rehabilitation across oncology and palliative care services; mixed-method evaluations of equity and inclusivity, processes and implementation for the intervention, at patient, health service and health system levels. Finally, we will conduct an evidence synthesis, incorporating INSPIRE findings, and a Delphi consensus to develop an international framework for palliative rehabilitation practice and policy, incorporating indicators, core interventions, outcomes and integration methods.

Scientific contribution

If positive, the trial could produce a scalable and equitable intervention to improve function and quality of life in people with incurable cancer and reduce the burden of care for their families. It could also upskill the practitioners involved and motivate future research questions. The intervention could be adapted and integrated into different health systems using existing staff and services, with little or no additional cost.

[Physical therapy and occupational therapy in German palliative care: Where do we stand?]

INTRODUCTION

Physical therapy (PT) and occupational therapy (OT) as supportive forms of treatment in palliative care, together with other treatment measures, can create participation for seriously ill patients in the form of a life that is as autonomous as possible until the end of life. However, specially trained staff are needed for the care of palliative patients in order to do justice to the clients' special life situation. In Germany, no corresponding survey on the subject has so far been conducted. So it is unclear to what extent PT and OT are offered in palliative care structures in this country, which tasks are assigned to the respective professional groups, and what the level of knowledge is that caregivers have about treatment options.

AIM

Compilation of an overview of the provision, need and use of PT and OT in the various areas of palliative care in Germany. If there is a lack of provision, the reasons for this will be identified.

METHODS

In this cross-sectional survey, a self-designed 9-item questionnaire was sent out to a total of 260 hospices, 323 palliative care units and 304 specialized outpatient palliative care services (SOPC) listed on the homepage of the German Society for Palliative Medicine (DGP). The respondents' answers were analysed using a purely descriptive approach.

RESULTS

The response rate was 439 (49.5%). A total of 434 questionnaires (49%) were included in the analysis. A heterogeneous distribution of PT and OT offers between outpatient, inpatient, and hospice palliative care can be seen, with the outpatient area showing a significantly fewer offerings. 29% of the SOPC teams can offer neither PT nor OT. This is mostly due to a shortage of skilled workers or a lack of funding opportunities. The different areas of responsibility of physiotherapists and occupational therapists are known to the majority of respondents (hospice 87%, palliative care unit 83%, SOPC 81%) and are also reflected in the distribution of tasks between the two professional groups. Especially palliative care units and SOPC teams state that they would like to offer more PT and OT (palliative care units 42% more PT and 58% more OT; SOPC 65% more PT and 50% more OT).

DISCUSSION

This cross-sectional survey is the first of its kind to provide an overview of the PT and OT offerings in the different sectors of German palliative care. In a comparison of the two forms of therapy, occupational therapists are used less frequently than physiotherapists. An international comparison of the study situation also shows that the use of OT in palliative care, in particular, has not yet been implemented satisfactorily. Outside Germany, the main reasons for this are a shortage of specialists and a lack of knowledge about the tasks of OT.

CONCLUSION

PT and OT are frequently used treatment options in all areas of German palliative care. In order to better classify structural problems in care, further differentiated surveys should be conducted. Furthermore, a better knowledge base should be created through research and information activities of both professional groups in palliative care.

Occupational Therapy Practice in Palliative and End-of-Life Care in Québec

Background. There is an emerging evidence base about the scope of occupational therapy in palliative and end-of-life care, but little is known about this practice in Québec or barriers impeding it. Purpose. To describe Québec occupational therapists’ practice in palliative and end-of-life care and barriers they encounter. Method. Using the Québec regulatory board members list, we invited occupational therapists working in palliative and end-of-life care to answer an online survey comprising 24 closed- and 5 open-ended questions. We analyzed data using descriptive statistics and content analysis. Findings. The 67 survey participants mainly optimized comfort and safety in meaningful occupations such as mobility, transfers, and hygiene. Barriers to their practice included organizational obstacles and unfamiliarity with their role. Implications. Findings highlight the need to improve education and awareness among occupational therapists and other healthcare professionals about the scope of what occupational therapists can do in palliative and end-of-life care.

Project ECHO: Enhancing palliative care for primary care occupational therapists and physiotherapists in Ireland

Project ECHO (Extension for Community Healthcare Outcomes) uses videoconferencing technology to support and train healthcare professionals (HCPs) remotely. A 4-month fortnightly ECHO programme was developed and implemented to enhance palliative care provision by primary care therapists. Teaching and case-based discussions were facilitated by palliative care specialists. A mixed-methods cohort study was used to evaluate the project. ECHO participants completed pre- and post-programme questionnaires regarding their knowledge and skills across key palliative care domains. Focus groups were held before programme commencement to explore participants' attitudes and experiences of palliative care and after programme conclusion to explore their experiences of ECHO. Twenty-six primary care HCPs commenced the ECHO programme. Mean scores in self-rated confidence in knowledge and skill improved significantly (p < .002) following the programme. Twenty-one primary care HCPs completed the post-ECHO surveys and scores of self-rated confidence in knowledge and skills were significantly higher than pre-ECHO scores. Ninety-five percent of participants (n = 19) reported ECHO met their learning needs and was an effective format to enhance clinical knowledge. Eighty-five percent of participants (n = 17) would recommend ECHO to their colleagues. Project ECHO improved palliative care knowledge and skills of primary care HCPs in Ireland, with potential to address the growing need for integrated palliative care services.