Nanopore analysis of the interaction of metal ions with prion proteins and peptides

Lysenin Channels as Sensors for Ions and Molecules

Lysenin is a pore-forming protein extracted from the earthworm Eisenia fetida, which inserts large conductance pores in artificial and natural lipid membranes containing sphingomyelin. Its cytolytic and hemolytic activity is rather indicative of a pore-forming toxin; however, lysenin channels present intricate regulatory features manifested as a reduction in conductance upon exposure to multivalent ions. Lysenin pores also present a large unobstructed channel, which enables the translocation of analytes, such as short DNA and peptide molecules, driven by electrochemical gradients. These important features of lysenin channels provide opportunities for using them as sensors for a large variety of applications. In this respect, this literature review is focused on investigations aimed at the potential use of lysenin channels as analytical tools. The described explorations include interactions with multivalent inorganic and organic cations, analyses on the reversibility of such interactions, insights into the regulation mechanisms of lysenin channels, interactions with purines, stochastic sensing of peptides and DNA molecules, and evidence of molecular translocation. Lysenin channels present themselves as versatile sensing platforms that exploit either intrinsic regulatory features or the changes in ionic currents elicited when molecules thread the conducting pathway, which may be further developed into analytical tools of high specificity and sensitivity or exploited for other scientific biotechnological applications.

Nanopore detection of metal ions: Current status and future directions

In this review, we highlight recent research efforts that aimed at developing nanopore sensors for detection of metal ions, which play a crucial role in environmental safety and human health. Protein pores use three stochastic sensing-based strategies for metal ion detection. The first strategy is to construct engineered nanopores with metal ion binding sites, so that the interaction between the target analytes and the nanopore can slow the movement of metal ions in the nano-channel. Second, large molecules such as nucleic acids and especially peptides could be utilized as external selective molecular probes to detect metal ions based on the conformational change of the ligand molecules induced by the metal ion-ligand chelation / coordination interaction. Third, enzymatic reactions can also be used as an alternative to the molecule probe strategy in the situation that a sensitive and selective probe molecule for the target analyte is difficult to obtain. On the other hand, by taking advantage of steady-state analysis, synthetic nanopores mainly use two strategies (modification and modification-free) to detect metals. Given the advantages of high sensitivity & selectivity, and label-free detection, nanopore-based metal ion sensors should find useful application in many fields, including environmental monitoring, medical diagnosis, and so on.

DNA nanotechnology assisted nanopore-based analysis

Nanopore technology is a promising label-free detection method. However, challenges exist for its further application in sequencing, clinical diagnostics and ultra-sensitive single molecule detection. The development of DNA nanotechnology nonetheless provides possible solutions to current obstacles hindering nanopore sensing technologies. In this review, we summarize recent relevant research contributing to efforts for developing nanopore methods associated with DNA nanotechnology. For example, DNA carriers can capture specific targets at pre-designed sites and escort them from nanopores at suitable speeds, thereby greatly enhancing capability and resolution for the detection of specific target molecules. In addition, DNA origami structures can be constructed to fulfill various design specifications and one-pot assembly reactions, thus serving as functional nanopores. Moreover, based on DNA strand displacement, nanopores can also be utilized to characterize the outputs of DNA computing and to develop programmable smart diagnostic nanodevices. In summary, DNA assembly-based nanopore research can pave the way for the realization of impactful biological detection and diagnostic platforms via single-biomolecule analysis.

Improved Measurement of Proteins Using a Solid-State Nanopore Coupled with a Hydrogel

Although resistive pulse sensing using solid-state nanopores is capable of single-molecule sensitivity, previous work has shown that nanoparticles, such as proteins, pass through nanopores too quickly for accurate detection with typical measurement apparatus. As a result, nanopore measurements of these particles significantly deviate from theoretically estimated current amplitudes and detection rates. Here, we show that a hydrogel placed on the distal side of a nanopore can increase the residence time of nanoparticles within the nanopore, significantly increasing the detection rate and allowing improved resolution of blockage currents. The method is simple and inexpensive to implement while being label-free and applicable to a wide range of nanoparticle targets. Using hydrogel-backed nanopores, we detected the protein IgG with event frequencies several orders of magnitude higher than those in the absence of the hydrogel and with larger measured currents that agree well with theoretical models. We also show that the improved measurement also enables discrimination of IgG and bovine serum albumin in a mixed solution. Finally, we show that measurements of IgG with the hydrogel-backed nanopores can also yield current amplitude distributions that can be analyzed to infer its approximate shape.

Enzymatic reaction-based nanopore detection of zinc ions

We report a label-free nanopore sensor for the detection of Zn2+ ions. By taking advantage of the cleavage of a substrate peptide by zinc-dependent enzymes, nanomolar concentrations of Zn2+ ions could be detected within minutes. Furthermore, structurally similar transition metals such as Ni2+, Co2+, Hg2+, Cu2+, and Cd2+ did not interfere with their detection. The enzymatic reaction-based nanopore sensing strategy developed in this work may find potential applications in environmental monitoring and medical diagnosis.

The applications of nanopores in studies of proteins

Nanopores are a label-free platform with the ability to detect subtle changes in the activities of individual biomolecules under physiological conditions. Here, we comprehensively review the technological development of nanopores, focusing on their applications in studying the physicochemical properties and dynamic conformations of peptides, individual proteins, protein-protein complexes and protein-DNA complexes. This is followed by a brief discussion of the potential challenges that need to be overcome before the technology can be widely accepted by the scientific community. We believe that with continued refinement of the technology, significant understanding can be gained to help clarify the role of protein activities in the regulation of cellular physiology and pathogenesis.

Nanopore-Based, Rapid Characterization of Individual Amyloid Particles in Solution: Concepts, Challenges, and Prospects

Aggregates of misfolded proteins are associated with several devastating neurodegenerative diseases. These so-called amyloids are therefore explored as biomarkers for the diagnosis of dementia and other disorders, as well as for monitoring disease progression and assessment of the efficacy of therapeutic interventions. Quantification and characterization of amyloids as biomarkers is particularly demanding because the same amyloid-forming protein can exist in different states of assembly, ranging from nanometer-sized monomers to micrometer-long fibrils that interchange dynamically both in vivo and in samples from body fluids ex vivo. Soluble oligomeric amyloid aggregates, in particular, are associated with neurotoxic effects, and their molecular organization, size, and shape appear to determine their toxicity. This concept article proposes that the emerging field of nanopore-based analytics on a single molecule and single aggregate level holds the potential to account for the heterogeneity of amyloid samples and to characterize these particles-rapidly, label-free, and in aqueous solution-with regard to their size, shape, and abundance. The article describes the concept of nanopore-based resistive pulse sensing, reviews previous work in amyloid analysis, and discusses limitations and challenges that will need to be overcome to realize the full potential of amyloid characterization on a single-particle level.

Computation-Assisted Nanopore Detection of Thorium Ions

Thorium is a well-known radioactive and chemically toxic contaminant in the environment. The continuous exposure to thorium may cause an increased risk of developing lung and liver diseases as well as lung, pancreas, and bone cancer. Due to its use in nuclear industry and other industrial applications, thorium may be accidentally released to the environment from its mining and processing plants. In this work, we developed a rapid, real-time, and label-free nanopore sensor for Th⁴⁺ detection by using an aspartic acid containing peptide as a chelating agent and tuning the electrolyte solution pH to control the net charges of the peptide ligand and its metal ion complex. The method is highly sensitive with a detection limit of 0.45 nM. Furthermore, the sensor is selective: other metal ions (e.g., UO₂²⁺, Pb²⁺, Cu²⁺, Ni²⁺, Hg²⁺, Zn²⁺, As³⁺, Mg²⁺, and Ca²⁺) with concentrations of up to 3 orders of magnitude greater than that of Th⁴⁺ would not interfere with Th⁴⁺detection. In addition, simulated water samples were successfully analyzed. Our developed computation-assisted sensing strategy should find useful applications in the development of nanopore sensors for other metal ions.

Peptide-Mediated Nanopore Detection of Uranyl Ions in Aqueous Media

Uranium is one of the most common radioactive contaminants in the environment. As a major nuclear material in production, environmental samples (like soil and groundwater) can provide signatures on uranium production activity inside the facility. Thus, developing a new and portable analytical technology for uranium in aqueous media is significant not only for environmental monitoring, but also for nonproliferation. In this work, a label-free method for the detection of uranyl (UO₂²⁺) ions is developed by monitoring the translocation of a peptide probe in a nanopore. Based on the difference in the number of peptide events in the absence and presence of uranyl ions, nanomolar concentration of UO₂²⁺ ions could be detected in minutes. The method is highly selective; micromolar concentrations of Cd²⁺, Cu²⁺, Zn²⁺, Ni²⁺, Pb²⁺, Hg²⁺, Th⁴⁺, Mg²⁺, and Ca²⁺ would not interfere with the detection of UO₂²⁺ ions. In addition, simulated water samples were successfully analyzed.

Superposition of an AC field improves the discrimination between peptides in nanopore analysis

In standard nanopore analysis a constant DC voltage is used to electrophoretically drive small molecules and peptides towards a pore. Superposition of an AC voltage at particular frequencies causes molecules to oscillate as they approach the pore which can alter the event parameters, the blockade current (I) and blockade time (T). Four peptides with similar structures were studied. Alpha-helical peptides A10 (FmocDDA10KK), A14, A18 and retro-inverso A10. It was shown that the ratio of translocations to bumping events could be manipulated by a combination of AC voltages and frequencies. In particular, A10 could be studied without interference from retro-inverso A10. Similarly, a large, intrinsically disordered protein of 140 amino acids, α-synuclein, which translocates the pore readily in a DC field could be prevented from doing so by application of an AC field of 200 mV at 100 MHz.

Single molecule analysis by biological nanopore sensors

Nanopore sensors provide a highly innovative technique for a rapid and label-free single molecule analysis, which holds a great potential in routing applications. Biological nanopores have been used as ultra-sensitive sensors over a wide range of single molecule analysis including DNA sequencing, disease diagnosis, drug screening, environment monitoring and the construction of molecule machines. This mini review will focus on the current strategies for the identification and characterization of an individual analyte, especially based on our recent achievements in biological nanopore biosensors.

Real-time label-free measurement of HIV-1 protease activity by nanopore analysis

A label-free method for the measurement of the activity of HIV-1 protease is developed by real-time monitoring of the cleavage of a peptide substrate by HIV-1 protease in a nanopore. The method is rapid and sensitive: picomolar concentrations of HIV-1 protease could be detected in ~10 min. Simulated clinical samples are analyzed, and the activity of HIV-1 protease could be accurately detected. Our developed nanopore sensor design strategy should find useful applications in the development of stochastic sensors for other proteases of medical, pharmaceutical, and biological importance.

Nanopore biosensor for label-free and real-time detection of anthrax lethal factor

We report a label-free real-time nanopore sensing method for the detection of anthrax lethal factor, a component of the anthrax toxin, by using a complementary single-stranded DNA as a molecular probe. The method is rapid and sensitive: sub-nanomolar concentrations of the target anthrax lethal factor DNA could be detected in ∼1 min. Further, our method is selective, which can differentiate the target DNA from other single-stranded DNA molecules at the single-base resolution. This sequence-specific detection approach should find useful application in the development of nanopore sensors for the detection of other pathogens.

Cu(II) and dopamine bind to α-synuclein and cause large conformational changes

α-Synuclein (AS) is an intrinsically disordered protein that can misfold and aggregate to form Lewy bodies in dopaminergic neurons, a classic hallmark of Parkinson's disease. The binding of Cu(II) and dopamine to AS was evaluated by nanopore analysis with α-hemolysin. In the absence of Cu(II), wild-type AS (1 μM) readily translocated through the pore with a blockade current of--85 pA, but mostly bumping events were observed in the presence of 25 μM Cu(II). A binding site in the N-terminus was confirmed, because Cu(II) had no effect on the event profile of a peptide consisting of the C-terminal 96-140 residues. In the presence of dopamine (25 μM), the translocation events at--85 pA shifted to--80 pA, which also represents translocation events, because the event time decreases with increasing voltage. Events at--80 pA were also observed for the mutant A30P AS in the presence of dopamine. Event profiles for an N-terminal 1-60-residue peptide and a C-terminal 96-140-residue peptide were both altered in the presence of 25 μM dopamine. In contrast, dopamine had little effect on the CD spectrum of AS, and a single binding site with a Ka of 3.5 × 10(3) m(-1) was estimated by isothermal titration calorimetry. Thus, dopamine can interact with both the N-terminus and the C-terminus. Two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy of AS in the presence of dopamine showed that there were significant changes in the spectra in all regions of the protein. According to these findings, a model is presented in which dopamine induces folding between the N-terminus and C-terminus of AS. Partially folding conformations such as this may represent important intermediates in the misfolding of AS that leads to fibrillization.

Antioxidant and Metal Chelation-Based Therapies in the Treatment of Prion Disease

Many neurodegenerative disorders involve the accumulation of multimeric assemblies and amyloid derived from misfolded conformers of constitutively expressed proteins. In addition, the brains of patients and experimental animals afflicted with prion disease display evidence of heightened oxidative stress and damage, as well as disturbances to transition metal homeostasis. Utilising a variety of disease model paradigms, many laboratories have demonstrated that copper can act as a cofactor in the antioxidant activity displayed by the prion protein while manganese has been implicated in the generation and stabilisation of disease-associated conformers. This and other evidence has led several groups to test dietary and chelation therapy-based regimens to manipulate brain metal concentrations in attempts to influence the progression of prion disease in experimental mice. Results have been inconsistent. This review examines published data on transition metal dyshomeostasis, free radical generation and subsequent oxidative damage in the pathogenesis of prion disease. It also comments on the efficacy of trialed therapeutics chosen to combat such deleterious changes.

Watching single proteins using engineered nanopores

Recent studies in the area of single-molecule detection of proteins with nanopores show a great promise in fundamental science, bionanotechnology and proteomics. In this mini-review, I discuss a comprehensive array of examinations of protein detection and characterization using protein and solid-state nanopores. These investigations demonstrate the power of the single-molecule nanopore measurements to reveal a broad range of functional, structural, biochemical and biophysical features of proteins, such as their backbone flexibility, enzymatic activity, binding affinity as well as their concentration, size and folding state. Engineered nanopores in organic materials and in inorganic membranes coupled with surface modification and protein engineering might provide a new generation of sensing devices for molecular biomedical diagnostics.

RNase A does not translocate the alpha-hemolysin pore

The application of nanopore sensing utilizing the α-hemolysin pore to probe proteins at single-molecule resolution has expanded rapidly. In some studies protein translocation through the α-hemolysin has been reported. However, there is no direct evidence, as yet, that proteins can translocate the α-hemolysin pore. The biggest challenge to obtaining direct evidence is the lack of a highly sensitive assay to detect very low numbers of protein molecules. Furthermore, if an activity based assay is applied then the proteins translocating by unfolding should refold back to an active confirmation for the assay technique to work. To overcome these challenges we selected a model enzyme, ribonuclease A, that readily refolds to an active conformation even after unfolding it with denaturants. In addition we have developed a highly sensitive reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction based activity assay for ribonuclease A. Initially, ribonuclease A, a protein with a positive net charge and dimensions larger than the smallest diameter of the pore, was subjected to nanopore analysis under different experimental conditions. Surprisingly, although the protein was added to the cis chamber (grounded) and a positive potential was applied, the interaction of ribonuclease A with α-hemolysin pore induced small and large blockade events in the presence and the absence of a reducing and/or denaturing agent. Upon measuring the zeta potential, it was found that the protein undergoes a charge reversal under the experimental conditions used for nanopore sensing. From the investigation of the effect of voltage on the interaction of ribonuclease A with the α-hemolysin pore, it was impossible to conclude if the events observed were translocations. However, upon testing for ribonuclease A activity on the trans chamber it was found that ribonuclease A does not translocate the α-hemolysin pore.

Nanopore analysis reveals differences in structural stability of ovine PrP(C) proteins corresponding to scrapie susceptible (VRQ) and resistance (ARR) genotypes

Species, as well as individuals within species, have unique susceptibilities to prion infection that are likely based on sequence differences in cellular prion protein (PrP(C)). Species barriers to transmission also reflect PrP(C) sequence differences. Defining the structure-activity relationship of PrP(C)/PrP(Sc) with respect to infectivity/susceptibility will benefit disease understanding and assessment of transmission risks. Here, nanopore analysis is employed to investigate genotypes of sheep PrP(C) corresponding to differential susceptibilities to scrapie infection. Under non-denaturing conditions scrapie resistant (ARR) and susceptible (VRQ) genotypes display similar, type I (bumping) predominant event profiles, suggesting a conserved folding pattern. Under increasingly denaturing conditions both proteins shift to type II (intercalation/translocation) events but with different sensitivities to unfolding. Specifically, when pre-incubated in 2M Gdn-HCl, the VRQ variant had more of type II events as compared with the ARR protein, suggesting a more flexible unfolding pattern. Addition of PrP(Sc)-specific polyclonal antibody (YML) to the ARR variant, pre-incubated in 2M Gdn-HCl, reduced the number of type II events with no clear intercalation/translocation peak, whereas for VRQ, type II events above blockades of 90 pA bound YML. A second PrP(Sc)-specific antibody (SN6b) to a different cryptic epitope reduced type II events for VRQ but not the ARR variant. Collectively, the event patterns associated with sequential denaturation, as well as interactions with PrP(Sc)-specific antibodies, support unique patterns and/or propensities of misfolding between the genotypes. Overall, nanopore analysis identifies intermediate conformations that occur during the unfolding pathways of ARR and VRQ genotypes and may help to understand the correlation of structural properties that induce protein misfolding.

Nanopore detection of copper ions using a polyhistidine probe

We report a stochastic nanopore sensing method for the detection of Cu(2+) ions. By employing a polyhistidine molecule as a chelating agent, and based on the different signatures of the events produced by the translocation of the chelating agent through an α-hemolysin pore in the absence and presence of target analytes, trace amounts of copper ions could be detected with a detection limit of 40 nM. Importantly, although Co(2+), Ni(2+), and Zn(2+) also interacts with the polyhistidine molecule, since the event residence times and/or blockage amplitudes for these metal chelates are significantly different from those of copper chelates, these metal ions do not interfere with Cu(2+) detection. This chelating reaction approach should find useful application in the development of nanopore sensors for other metal ions.

Binding of bovine T194A PrP(C) by PrP(Sc)-specific antibodies: potential implications for immunotherapy of familial prion diseases

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) are fatal neurodegenerative diseases that are based on the misfolding of a cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) into an infectious, pathological conformation (PrP(Sc)). There is proof-of-principle evidence that a prion vaccine is possible but this is tempered with concerns of the potential dangers associated with induction of immune responses to a widely-expressed self-protein. By targeting epitopes that are specifically exposed upon protein misfolding, our group developed a vaccine that induces PrP(Sc)-specific antibody responses. Here we consider the ability of this polyclonal antibody (SN6b) to bind to a mutant of PrP(C) associated with spontaneous prion disease. Polyclonal antibodies were selected to mimic the vaccination outcome and also explore all possible protein conformations of the recombinant bovine prion protein with mutation T194A [bPrP(T194A)]. This mutant is a homolog of the human T183A mutation of PrP(C) that is associated with early onset of familial dementia. With nanopore analysis, under non-denaturing conditions, we observed binding of the SN6b antibody to bPrP(T194A). This interaction was confirmed through ELISAs as well as immunoprecipitation of the recombinant and cellularly expressed forms of bPrP(T194A). This interaction did not promote formation of a protease resistant conformation of PrP in vitro. Collectively, these findings support the disease-specific approach for immunotherapy of prion diseases but also suggest that the concept of conformation-specific immunotherapy may be complicated in individuals who are genetically predisposed to PrP(C) misfolding.

Sensing proteins through nanopores: fundamental to applications

Proteins subjected to an electric field and forced to pass through a nanopore induce blockades of ionic current that depend on the protein and nanopore characteristics and interactions between them. Recent advances in the analysis of these blockades have highlighted a variety of phenomena that can be used to study protein translocation and protein folding, to probe single-molecule catalytic reactions in order to obtain kinetic and thermodynamic information, and to detect protein-antibody complexes, proteins with DNA and RNA aptamers, and protein-pore interactions. Nanopore design is now well controlled, allowing the development of future biotechnologies and medicine applications.

Copper Sensing with a Prion Protein Modified Nanopipette

Protein-metal interactions determine and regulate many biological functions. Nanopipettes functionalized with peptide moieties can be used as sensors for metal ions in solution.

Nanopore analysis: An emerging technique for studying the folding and misfolding of proteins

Nanopore analysis is an emerging technique that enables the investigation of the conformation of a single peptide or protein molecule. Briefly, a pore is inserted into a membrane under voltage clamp conditions. When a molecule interacts with the pore there is a change in the current, I, for a time, T. Small unfolded molecules can translocate the pore whereas folded or large molecules tend to simply bump into the pore and then diffuse away. Therefore, the parameters, I and T, are dependent on the conformation of the molecule at the instant at which it encounters the pore. Thus, multiple conformations can be detected simultaneously in a single sample. As well, the analysis can be performed under dilute conditions so that folding or dimerization of a peptide can be followed in real time, which is generally difficult to study for proteins that are prone to aggregate. In this report, we describe our initial analysis of (1) Aβ peptides, which are deposited as amyloid plaques in Alzheimer disease, (2) α-synuclein, which is implicated in Parkinson disease and (3) prion proteins whose misfolding is evident in transmissable spongiform encephalopathies. In each case conformational information can be obtained which may help in understanding the early steps in the misfolding pathways.