Interactive effect of hypoxia and otolith organ engagement on cardiovascular regulation in humans

The effect of hypoxemia on muscle sympathetic nerve activity and cardiovascular function: a systematic review and meta-analysis

We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to determine the effect of acute poikilocapnic, high-altitude, and acute isocapnia hypoxemia on muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) and cardiovascular function. A comprehensive search across electronic databases was performed until June 2021. All observational designs were included: population (healthy individuals); exposures (MSNA during hypoxemia); comparators (hypoxemia severity and duration); outcomes (MSNA; heart rate, HR; and mean arterial pressure, MAP). Sixty-one studies were included in the meta-analysis. MSNA burst frequency increased by a greater extent during high-altitude hypoxemia [P < 0.001; mean difference (MD), +22.5 bursts/min; confidence interval (CI) = -19.20 to 25.84] compared with acute poikilocapnic hypoxemia (P < 0.001; MD, +5.63 bursts/min; CI = -4.09 to 7.17) and isocapnic hypoxemia (P < 0.001; MD, +4.72 bursts/min; CI = -3.37 to 6.07). MSNA burst amplitude was only elevated during acute isocapnic hypoxemia (P = 0.03; standard MD, +0.46 au; CI = -0.03 to 0.90), and MSNA burst incidence was only elevated during high-altitude hypoxemia [P < 0.001; MD, 33.05 bursts/100 heartbeats; CI = -28.59 to 37.51]. Meta-regression analysis indicated a strong relationship between MSNA burst frequency and hypoxemia severity for acute isocapnic studies (P < 0.001) but not acute poikilocapnia (P = 0.098). HR increased by the same extent across each type of hypoxemia [P < 0.001; MD +13.81 heartbeats/min; 95% CI = 12.59-15.03]. MAP increased during high-altitude hypoxemia (P < 0.001; MD, +5.06 mmHg; CI = 3.14-6.99), and acute isocapnic hypoxemia (P < 0.001; MD, +1.91 mmHg; CI = 0.84-2.97), but not during acute poikilocapnic hypoxemia (P = 0.95). Both hypoxemia type and severity influenced sympathetic nerve and cardiovascular function. These data are important for the better understanding of healthy human adaptation to hypoxemia.

Vestibular-autonomic interactions: beyond orthostatic dizziness

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review aims to summarize the current literature describing vestibular-autonomic interactions and to describe their putative role in various disorders' clinical presentations, including orthostatic dizziness and motion sensitivity.

RECENT FINDINGS

The vestibular-autonomic reflexes have long been described as they relate to cardiovascular and respiratory function. Although orthostatic dizziness may be in part related to impaired vestibulo-sympathetic reflex (orthostatic hypotension), there are various conditions that may present similarly. A recent clinical classification aims to improve identification of individuals with hemodynamic orthostatic dizziness so that appropriate recommendations and management can be efficiently addressed. Researchers continue to improve understanding of the underlying vestibular-autonomic reflexes with recent studies noting the insular cortex as a cortical site for vestibular sensation and autonomic integration and modulation. Work has further expanded our understanding of the clinical presentation of abnormal vestibular-autonomic interactions that may occur in various conditions, such as aging, peripheral vestibular hypofunction, traumatic brain injury, and motion sensitivity.

SUMMARY

The vestibular-autonomic reflexes affect various sympathetic and parasympathetic functions. Understanding these relationships will provide improved identification of underlying etiology and drive improved patient management.

Greater sensitivity of the vestibulosympathetic reflex in the upright posture in humans

Otolith organs have been shown to activate the sympathetic nervous system in the prone position by head-down rotation (HDR) in humans. To date, otolithic stimulation by HDR has not been comprehensively studied in the upright posture. The purpose of the present study was to determine whether otolithic stimulation increases muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) in the upright posture. It was hypothesized that stimulation of the otolith organs would increase MSNA in the upright posture, despite increased baseline sympathetic activation due to unloading of the baroreceptors. MSNA, arterial blood pressure, heart rate, and degree of head rotation were measured during HDR in 18 volunteers (23 +/- 1 yr) in different postures. Study 1 (n = 11) examined HDR in the prone and sitting positions and study 2 (n = 7) examined HDR in the prone and 60 degrees head-up tilt positions. Baseline MSNA was 8 +/- 4, 15 +/- 4, and 33 +/- 2 bursts/min for prone, sitting, and head-up tilt, respectively. HDR significantly increased MSNA in the prone (Delta4 +/- 1 and Delta105 +/- 37% for burst frequency and total activity, respectively), sitting (Delta5 +/- 1 and Delta43 +/- 12%), and head-up tilt (Delta7 +/- 1 and Delta110 +/- 41%; P < 0.05). Sensitivity of the vestibulosympathetic reflex (%DeltaMSNA/DeltaHDR; degree of head rotation) was significantly greater in the sitting and head-up tilt than prone position (prone = 74 +/- 22; sitting = 109 +/- 30; head-up tilt = 276 +/- 103; P < 0.05). These data indicate that stimulation of the otolith organs can mediate increases in MSNA in the upright posture and suggest a greater sensitivity of the vestibulosympathetic reflex in the upright posture in humans.

Sympathetic responses to vestibular activation in humans

Activation of sympathetic neural traffic via the vestibular system is referred to as the vestibulosympathetic reflex. Investigations of the vestibulosympathetic reflex in humans have been limited to the past decade, and the importance of this reflex in arterial blood pressure regulation is still being determined. This review provides a summary of sympathetic neural responses to various techniques used to engage the vestibulosympathetic reflex. Studies suggest that activation of the semicircular canals using caloric stimulation and yaw rotation do not modulate muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) or skin sympathetic nerve activity (SSNA). In contrast, activation of the otolith organs appear to alter MSNA, but not SSNA. Specifically, head-down rotation and off-vertical axis rotation increase MSNA, while sinusoidal linear accelerations decrease MSNA. Galvanic stimulation, which results in a nonspecific activation of the vestibule, appears to increase MSNA if the mode of delivery is pulse trained. In conclusion, evidence strongly supports the existence of a vestibulosympathetic reflex in humans. Furthermore, attenuation of the vestibulosympathetic reflex is coupled with a drop in arterial blood pressure in the elderly, suggesting this reflex may be important in human blood pressure regulation.

Effect of thermal stress on the vestibulosympathetic reflexes in humans

Both heat stress and vestibular activation alter autonomic responses; however, the interaction of these two sympathetic activators is unknown. To determine the effect of heat stress on the vestibulosympathetic reflex, eight subjects performed static head-down rotation (HDR) during normothermia and whole body heating. Muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA; peroneal microneurography), mean arterial blood pressure (MAP), heart rate (HR), and internal temperature were measured during the experimental trials. HDR during normothermia caused a significant increase in MSNA (Δ5 ± 1 bursts/min; Δ53 ± 14 arbitrary units/min), whereas no change was observed in MAP, HR, or internal temperature. Whole body heating significantly increased internal temperature (Δ0.9 ± 0.1°C), MSNA (Δ10 ± 3 bursts/min; Δ152 ± 44 arbitrary units/min), and HR (Δ25 ± 6 beats/min), but it did not alter MAP. HDR during whole body heating increased MSNA (Δ16 ± 4 bursts/min; Δ233 ± 90 arbitrary units/min from normothermic baseline), which was not significantly different from the algebraic sum of HDR during normothermia and whole body heating (Δ15 ± 4 bursts/min; Δ205 ± 55 arbitrary units/min). These data suggest that heat stress does not modify the vestibulosympathetic reflex and that both the vestibulosympathetic and thermal reflexes are robust, independent sympathetic nervous system activators.

Vestibular activation of sympathetic nerve activity

AIM

The vestibulosympathetic reflex refers to sympathetic nerve activation by the vestibular system. Animal studies indicate that the vestibular system assists in blood pressure regulation during orthostasis. Although human studies clearly demonstrate activation of muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) during engagement of the otolith organs, the role of the vestibulosympathetic reflex in maintaining blood pressure during orthostasis is not well-established. Examination of the vestibulosympathetic reflex with other cardiovascular reflexes indicates that it is a powerful and independent reflex. Ageing, which is associated with an increased risk for orthostatic hypotension, attenuates the vestibulosympathetic reflex. The attenuated reflex is associated with a reduction in arterial pressure.

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest that the vestibulosympathetic reflex assists in blood pressure regulation in humans, but future studies examining this reflex in other orthostatically intolerant populations are necessary to address this hypothesis.

Vestibulosympathetic reflex during mental stress

Increases in sympathetic neural activity occur independently with either vestibular or mental stimulation, but it is unknown whether sympathetic activation is additive or inhibitive when both stressors are combined. The purpose of the present study was to investigate the combined effects of vestibular and mental stimulation on sympathetic neural activation and arterial pressure in humans. Muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA), arterial pressure, and heart rate were recorded in 10 healthy volunteers in the prone position during 1) head-down rotation (HDR), 2) mental stress (MS; using arithmetic), and 3) combined HDR and MS. HDR significantly (P < 0.05) increased MSNA (9 +/- 2 to 13 +/- 2 bursts/min). MS significantly increased MSNA (8 +/- 2 to 13 +/- 2 bursts/min) and mean arterial pressure (87 +/- 2 to 101 +/- 2 mmHg). Combined HDR and MS significantly increased MSNA (9 +/- 1 to 16 +/- 2 bursts/min) and mean arterial pressure (89 +/- 2 to 100 +/- 3 mmHg). Increases in MSNA (7 +/- 1 bursts/min) during the combination trial were not different from the algebraic sum of each trial performed alone (8 +/- 2 bursts/min). We conclude that the interaction for MSNA and arterial pressure is additive during combined vestibular and mental stimulation. Therefore, vestibular- and stress-mediated increases of MSNA appear to occur independently in humans.