Peripheral chemoreceptor control of cardiovascular function at rest and during exercise in heart failure patients

A Methodological Perspective on the Function and Assessment of Peripheral Chemoreceptors in Heart Failure: A Review of Data from Clinical Trials

Augmented peripheral chemoreceptor sensitivity (PChS) is a common feature of many sympathetically mediated diseases, among others, and it is an important mechanism of the pathophysiology of heart failure (HF). It is related not only to the greater severity of symptoms, especially to dyspnea and lower exercise tolerance but also to a greater prevalence of complications and poor prognosis. The causes, mechanisms, and impact of the enhanced activity of peripheral chemoreceptors (PChR) in the HF population are subject to intense research. Several methodologies have been established and utilized to assess the PChR function. Each of them presents certain advantages and limitations. Furthermore, numerous factors could influence and modulate the response from PChR in studied subjects. Nevertheless, even with the impressive number of studies conducted in this field, there are still some gaps in knowledge that require further research. We performed a review of all clinical trials in HF human patients, in which the function of PChR was evaluated. This review provides an extensive synthesis of studies evaluating PChR function in the HF human population, including methods used, factors potentially influencing the results, and predictors of increased PChS.

Inhibition of peripheral chemoreceptors improves ventilatory efficiency during exercise in heart failure with preserved ejection fraction − a role of tonic activity and acute reflex response

Peripheral chemoreceptors (PChRs) play a significant role in maintaining adequate oxygenation in the bloodstream. PChRs functionality comprises two components: tonic activity (PChT) which regulates ventilation during normoxia and acute reflex response (peripheral chemosensitivity, PChS), which increases ventilation following a specific stimulus. There is a clear link between augmented PChS and exercise intolerance in patients with heart failure with reduced ejection fraction. It has been also shown that inhibition of PChRs leads to the improvement in exercise capacity. However, it has not been established yet: 1) whether similar mechanisms take part in heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) and 2) which component of PChRs functionality (PChT vs. PChS) is responsible for the benefit seen after the acute experimental blockade. To answer those questions we enrolled 12 stable patients with HFpEF. All participants underwent an assessment of PChT (attenuation of minute ventilation in response to low-dose dopamine infusion), PChS (enhancement of minute ventilation in response to hypoxia) and a symptom-limited cardiopulmonary exercise test on cycle ergometer. All tests were placebo-controlled, double-blinded and performed in a randomized order. Under resting conditions and at normoxia dopamine attenuated minute ventilation and systemic vascular resistance (p = 0.03 for both). These changes were not seen with placebo. Dopamine also decreased ventilatory and mean arterial pressure responses to hypoxia (p < 0.05 for both). Inhibition of PChRs led to a decrease in V˙E/V˙CO₂ comparing to placebo (36 ± 3.6 vs. 34.3 ± 3.7, p = 0.04), with no effect on peak oxygen consumption. We found a significant relationship between PChT and the relative decrement of V˙E/V˙CO₂ on dopamine comparing to placebo (R = 0.76, p = 0.005). There was a trend for correlation between PChS (on placebo) and V˙E/V˙CO₂ during placebo infusion (R = 0.56, p = 0.059), but the relative improvement in V˙E/V˙CO₂ was not related to the change in PChS (dopamine vs. placebo). We did not find a significant relationship between PChT and PChS. In conclusion, inhibition of PChRs in HFpEF population improves ventilatory efficiency during exercise. Increased PChS is associated with worse (higher) V˙E/V˙CO₂, whereas PChT predicts an improvement in V˙E/V˙CO₂ after PChRs inhibition. This results may be meaningful for patient selection in further clinical trials involving PChRs modulation.

Exercise intolerance in volume overload heart failure is associated with low carotid body mediated chemoreflex drive

Mounting an appropriate ventilatory response to exercise is crucial to meeting metabolic demands, and abnormal ventilatory responses may contribute to exercise-intolerance (EX-inT) in heart failure (HF) patients. We sought to determine if abnormal ventilatory chemoreflex control contributes to EX-inT in volume-overload HF rats. Cardiac function, hypercapnic (HCVR) and hypoxic (HVR) ventilatory responses, and exercise tolerance were assessed at the end of a 6 week exercise training program. At the conclusion of the training program, exercise tolerant HF rats (HF + EX-T) exhibited improvements in cardiac systolic function and reductions in HCVR, sympathetic tone, and arrhythmias. In contrast, HF rats that were exercise intolerant (HF + EX-inT) exhibited worse diastolic dysfunction, and showed no improvements in cardiac systolic function, HCVR, sympathetic tone, or arrhythmias at the conclusion of the training program. In addition, HF + EX-inT rats had impaired HVR which was associated with increased arrhythmia susceptibility and mortality during hypoxic challenges (~ 60% survival). Finally, we observed that exercise tolerance in HF rats was related to carotid body (CB) function as CB ablation resulted in impaired exercise capacity in HF + EX-T rats. Our results indicate that: (i) exercise may have detrimental effects on cardiac function in HF-EX-inT, and (ii) loss of CB chemoreflex sensitivity contributes to EX-inT in HF.

The need for specificity in quantifying neurocirculatory vs. respiratory effects of eucapnic hypoxia and transient hyperoxia

KEY POINTS

The carotid chemoreceptor mediates the ventilatory and muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) responses to hypoxia and contributes to tonic sympathetic and respiratory drives. It is often presumed that both excitatory and inhibitory tests of chemoreflex function show congruence in the end-organ responses. Ventilatory and neurocirculatory (MSNA, blood pressure and heart rate) responses to chemoreflex inhibition elicited by transient hyperoxia and to chemoreflex excitation produced by steady-state eucapnic hypoxia were measured in a cohort of 82 middle-aged individuals. Ventilatory and MSNA responsiveness to hyperoxia and hypoxia were not significantly correlated within individuals. It was concluded that ventilatory responses to hypoxia and hyperoxia do not predict MSNA responses and it is recommended that tests using the specific outcome of interest, i.e. MSNA or ventilation, are required. Transient hyperoxia is recommended as a sensitive and reliable means of quantifying tonic chemoreceptor-driven levels of sympathetic nervous system activity and respiratory drive.

ABSTRACT

Hypersensitivity of the carotid chemoreceptor leading to sympathetic nervous system activation and ventilatory instability has been implicated in the pathogenesis and consequences of several common clinical conditions. A variety of treatment approaches aimed at lessening chemoreceptor-driven sympathetic overactivity are now under investigation; thus, the ability to quantify this outcome variable with specificity and precision is crucial. Accordingly, we measured ventilatory and neurocirculatory responses to chemoreflex inhibition elicited by transient hyperoxia and chemoreflex excitation produced by exposure to graded, steady-state eucapnic hypoxia in middle-aged men and women (n = 82) with continuous positive airway pressure-treated obstructive sleep apnoea. Progressive, eucapnic hypoxia produced robust and highly variable increases in ventilation (+83 ± 59%) and muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) burst frequency (+55 ± 31%), whereas transient hyperoxia caused marked reductions in these variables (-35 ± 14% and -42 ± 16%, respectively). Coefficients of variation for ventilatory and MSNA burst frequency responses, indicating test-retest reproducibility, were respectively 9% and 24% for hyperoxia and 35% and 28% for hypoxia. Based on statistical measures of rank correlation or even comparisons across quartiles of corresponding ventilatory and MSNA responses, we found that the magnitudes of ventilatory inhibition with hyperoxia or excitation with eucapnic hypoxia were not correlated with corresponding MSNA responses within individuals. We conclude that, in conscious, behaving humans, ventilatory sensitivities to progressive, steady-state, eucapnic hypoxia and transient hyperoxia do not predict MSNA responsiveness. Our findings also support the use of transient hyperoxia as a reliable, sensitive, measure of the carotid chemoreceptor contribution to tonic sympathetic nervous system activity and respiratory drive.

The Effect of Carotid Chemoreceptor Inhibition on Exercise Tolerance in Chronic Heart Failure

Purpose

Chronic heart failure (CHF) is characterized by heightened sympathetic nervous activity, carotid chemoreceptor (CC) sensitivity, marked exercise intolerance and an exaggerated ventilatory response to exercise. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of CC inhibition on exercise cardiovascular and ventilatory function, and exercise tolerance in health and CHF.

Methods

Twelve clinically stable, optimally treated patients with CHF (mean ejection fraction: 43 ± 2.5%) and 12 age- and sex-matched healthy controls were recruited. Participants completed two time-to-symptom-limitation (TLIM) constant load cycling exercise tests at 75% peak power output with either intravenous saline or low-dose dopamine (2 μg⋅kg^–1⋅min^–1; order randomized). Ventilation was measured using expired gas data and operating lung volume data were determined during exercise by inspiratory capacity maneuvers. Cardiac output was estimated using impedance cardiography, and vascular conductance was calculated as cardiac output/mean arterial pressure.

Results

There was no change in TLIM in either group with dopamine (CHF: saline 13.1 ± 2.4 vs. dopamine 13.5 ± 1.6 min, p = 0.78; Control: saline 10.3 ± 1.2 vs. dopamine 11.5 ± 1.3 min, p = 0.16). In CHF patients, dopamine increased cardiac output (p = 0.03), vascular conductance (p = 0.01) and oxygen delivery (p = 0.04) at TLIM, while ventilatory parameters were unaffected (p = 0.76). In controls, dopamine improved vascular conductance at TLIM (p = 0.03), but no other effects were observed.

Conclusion

Our findings suggest that the CC contributes to cardiovascular regulation during full-body exercise in patients with CHF, however, CC inhibition does not improve exercise tolerance.

Carotid chemoreflex and muscle metaboreflex interact to the regulation of ventilation in patients with heart failure with reduced ejection fraction

Synergism among reflexes probably contributes to exercise hyperventilation in patients with heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF). Thus, we investigated whether the carotid chemoreflex and the muscle metaboreflex interact to the regulation of ventilation ( V ˙ E ) in HFrEF. Ten patients accomplished 4-min cycling at 60% peak workload and then recovered for 2 min under either: (a) 21% O2 inhalation (tonic carotid chemoreflex activity) with legs' circulation free (inactive muscle metaboreflex); (b) 100% O2 inhalation (suppressed carotid chemoreflex activity) with legs' circulation occluded (muscle metaboreflex activation); (c) 21% O2 inhalation (tonic carotid chemoreflex activity) with legs' circulation occluded (muscle metaboreflex activation); or (d) 100% O2 inhalation (suppressed carotid chemoreflex activity) with legs' circulation free (inactive muscle metaboreflex) as control. V ˙ E , tidal volume (VT ) and respiratory frequency (fR ) were similar between each separated reflex (protocols a and b) and control (protocol d). Calculated sum of separated reflexes effects was similar to control. Oppositely, V ˙ E (mean ± SEM: Δ vs. control = 2.46 ± 1.07 L/min, p = .05) and fR (Δ = 2.47 ± 0.77 cycles/min, p = .02) increased versus control when both reflexes were simultaneously active (protocol c). Therefore, the carotid chemoreflex and the muscle metaboreflex interacted to V ˙ E regulation in a fR -dependent manner in patients with HFrEF. If this interaction operates during exercise, it can have some contribution to the HFrEF exercise hyperventilation.

The effect of carotid chemoreceptor inhibition on exercise tolerance in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: A randomized-controlled crossover trial

BACKGROUND

Patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) have an exaggerated ventilatory response to exercise, contributing to exertional dyspnea and exercise intolerance. We recently demonstrated enhanced activity and sensitivity of the carotid chemoreceptor (CC) in COPD which may alter ventilatory and cardiovascular regulation and negatively affect exercise tolerance. We sought to determine whether CC inhibition improves ventilatory and cardiovascular regulation, dyspnea and exercise tolerance in COPD.

METHODS

Twelve mild-moderate COPD patients (FEV₁ 83 ± 15 %predicted) and twelve age- and sex-matched healthy controls completed two time-to-symptom limitation (T_LIM) constant load exercise tests at 75% peak power output with either intravenous saline or low-dose dopamine (2 μg·kg^-1·min^-1, order randomized) to inhibit the CC. Ventilatory responses were evaluated using expired gas data and dyspnea was evaluated using a modified Borg scale. Inspiratory capacity maneuvers were performed to determine operating lung volumes. Cardiac output was estimated using impedance cardiography and vascular conductance was calculated as cardiac output/mean arterial pressure (MAP).

RESULTS

At a standardized exercise time of 4-min and at T_LIM; ventilation, operating volumes and dyspnea were unaffected by dopamine in COPD patients and controls. In COPD, dopamine decreased MAP and increased vascular conductance at all time points. In controls, dopamine increased vascular conductance at T_LIM, while MAP was unaffected.

CONCLUSION

There was no change in time to exhaustion in either group with dopamine. These data suggest that the CC plays a role in cardiovascular regulation during exercise in COPD; however, ventilation, dyspnea and exercise tolerance were unaffected by CC inhibition in COPD patients.

Peripheral chemoreceptor deactivation attenuates the sympathetic response to glucose ingestion

Acute increases in blood glucose are associated with heightened muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA). Animal studies have implicated a role for peripheral chemoreceptors in this response, but this has not been examined in humans. Heart rate, cardiac output (CO), mean arterial pressure, total peripheral conductance, and blood glucose concentrations were collected in 11 participants. MSNA was recorded in a subset of 5 participants via microneurography. Participants came to the lab on 2 separate days (i.e., 1 control and 1 experimental day). On both days, participants ingested 75 g of glucose following baseline measurements. On the experimental day, participants breathed 100% oxygen for 3 min at baseline and again at 20, 40, and 60 min after glucose ingestion to deactivate peripheral chemoreceptors. Supplemental oxygen was not given to participants on the control day. There was a main effect of time on blood glucose (P < 0.001), heart rate (P < 0.001), CO (P < 0.001), sympathetic burst frequency (P < 0.001), burst incidence (P = 0.01), and total MSNA (P = 0.001) for both days. Blood glucose concentrations and burst frequency were positively correlated on the control day (r = 0.42; P = 0.03) and experimental day (r = 0.62; P = 0.003). There was a time × condition interaction (i.e., normoxia vs. hyperoxia) on burst frequency, in which hyperoxia significantly blunted burst frequency at 20 and 60 min after glucose ingestion only. Given that hyperoxia blunted burst frequency only during hyperglycemia, our results suggest that the peripheral chemoreceptors are involved in activating MSNA after glucose ingestion.

The carotid chemoreceptor contributes to the elevated arterial stiffness and vasoconstrictor outflow in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

KEY POINTS

The reason(s) for the increased central arterial stiffness in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are not well understood. In this study, we inhibited the carotid chemoreceptor with both low-dose dopamine and hyperoxia, and observed a decrease in central arterial stiffness and muscle sympathetic nervous activity in COPD patients, while no change was observed in age- and risk-matched controls. Carotid chemoreceptor inhibition increased vascular conductance, secondary to reduced arterial blood pressure in COPD patients. Findings from the current study suggest that elevated carotid chemoreceptor activity may contribute to the increased arterial stiffness typically observed in COPD patients.

ABSTRACT

Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) patients have increased central arterial stiffness and muscle sympathetic nervous activity (MSNA), both of which contribute to cardiovascular (CV) dysfunction and increased CV risk. Previous work suggests that COPD patients have elevated carotid chemoreceptor (CC) activity/sensitivity, which may contribute to the elevated MSNA and arterial stiffness. Accordingly, the effect of CC inhibition on central arterial stiffness, MSNA and CV function at rest in COPD patients was examined in a randomized placebo-controlled study. Thirteen mild-moderate COPD patients (forced expired volume in 1 s (FEV₁ ) predicted ± SD: 83 ± 18%) and 13 age- and risk-matched controls completed resting CV function measurements with either i.v. saline or i.v. dopamine (2 μg kg^-1  min^-1 ) while breathing normoxic or hyperoxic air (100% O₂ ). On a separate day, a subset of COPD patients and controls completed MSNA measurements while breathing normoxic or hyperoxic air. Arterial stiffness was determined by pulse-wave velocity (PWV) and MSNA was measured by microneurography. Brachial blood flow was determined using Doppler ultrasound, cardiac output was estimated by impedance cardiography, and vascular conductance was calculated as flow/mean arterial pressure (MAP). CC inhibition with dopamine decreased central and peripheral PWV, and MAP (P < 0.05) while increasing vascular conductance in COPD. No change in CV function was observed with dopamine in controls. CC inhibition with hyperoxia decreased peripheral PWV and MSNA (P < 0.05) in COPD, while no change was observed in controls. CC inhibition decreased PWV and MSNA, and improved vascular conductance in COPD, suggesting that tonic CC activity is elevated at rest and contributes to the elevated arterial stiffness in COPD.

Reductions in carotid chemoreceptor activity with low-dose dopamine improves baroreflex control of heart rate during hypoxia in humans

The purpose of the present investigation was to examine the contribution of the carotid body chemoreceptors to changes in baroreflex control of heart rate with exposure to hypoxia. We hypothesized spontaneous cardiac baroreflex sensitivity (scBRS) would be reduced with hypoxia and this effect would be blunted when carotid chemoreceptor activity was reduced with low-dose dopamine. Fifteen healthy adults (11 M/4 F) completed two visits randomized to intravenous dopamine or placebo (saline). On each visit, subjects were exposed to 5-min normoxia (~99% SpO2), followed by 5-min hypoxia (~84% SpO2). Blood pressure (intra-arterial catheter) and heart rate (ECG) were measured continuously and scBRS was assessed by spectrum and sequence methodologies. scBRS was reduced with hypoxia (P < 0.01). Using the spectrum analysis approach, the fall in scBRS with hypoxia was attenuated with infusion of low-dose dopamine (P < 0.01). The decrease in baroreflex sensitivity to rising pressures (scBRS "up-up") was also attenuated with low-dose dopamine (P < 0.05). However, dopamine did not attenuate the decrease in baroreflex sensitivity to falling pressures (scBRS "down-down"; P > 0.05). Present findings are consistent with a reduction in scBRS with systemic hypoxia. Furthermore, we show this effect is partially mediated by the carotid body chemoreceptors, given the fall in scBRS is attenuated when activity of the chemoreceptors is reduced with low-dose dopamine. However, the improvement in scBRS with dopamine appears to be specific to rising blood pressures. These results may have important implications for impairments in baroreflex function common in disease states of acute and/or chronic hypoxemia, as well as the experimental use of dopamine to assess such changes.

Chemosensitivity, Cardiovascular Risk, and the Ventilatory Response to Exercise in COPD

COPD is associated with elevated cardiovascular risk and a potentiated ventilatory response to exercise. Enhanced carotid chemoreceptor (CC) activity/sensitivity is present in other clinical conditions, has been shown to contribute to sympathetic vasoconstrictor outflow, and is predictive of mortality. CC activity/sensitivity, and the resulting functional significance, has not been well examined in COPD. We hypothesized that CC activity/sensitivity would be elevated in COPD, and related to increased pulse wave velocity (a marker of CV risk) and the ventilatory response to exercise.

METHODS

30 COPD patients and 10 healthy age-matched controls were examined. Participants performed baseline cardiopulmonary exercise and pulmonary function testing. CC activity was later evaluated by the drop in ventilation with breathing 100% O2, and CC sensitivity was then assessed by the ventilatory response to hypoxia (ΔVE/ΔSpO2). Peripheral arterial stiffness was subsequently evaluated by measurement of pulse wave velocity (PWV) using applanation tonometry while the subjects were breathing room air, and then following chemoreceptor inhibition by breathing 100% O2 for 2 minutes.

RESULTS

CC activity, CC sensitivity, PWV and the ventilatory response to exercise were all increased in COPD relative to controls. CC sensitivity was related to PWV; however, neither CC activity nor CC sensitivity was related to the ventilatory response to exercise in COPD. CC inhibition by breathing 100% O2 normalized PWV in COPD, while no effect was observed in controls.

CONCLUSION

CC activity and sensitivity are elevated in COPD, and appear related to cardiovascular risk; however, CC activity/sensitivity does not contribute to the potentiated ventilatory response to exercise.

Interindividual variability in the dose-specific effect of dopamine on carotid chemoreceptor sensitivity to hypoxia

Human studies use varying levels of low-dose (1-4 μg·kg(-1)·min(-1)) dopamine to examine peripheral chemosensitivity, based on its known ability to blunt carotid body responsiveness to hypoxia. However, the effect of dopamine on the ventilatory responses to hypoxia is highly variable between individuals. Thus we sought to determine 1) the dose response relationship between dopamine and peripheral chemosensitivity as assessed by the ventilatory response to hypoxia in a cohort of healthy adults, and 2) potential confounding cardiovascular responses at variable low doses of dopamine. Young, healthy adults (n = 30, age = 32 ± 1, 24 male/6 female) were given intravenous (iv) saline and a range of iv dopamine doses (1-4 μg·kg(-1)·min(-1)) prior to and throughout five hypoxic ventilatory response (HVR) tests. Subjects initially received iv saline, and after each HVR the dopamine infusion rate was increased by 1 μg·kg(-1)·min(-1). Tidal volume, respiratory rate, heart rate, blood pressure, and oxygen saturation were continuously measured. Dopamine significantly reduced HVR at all doses (P < 0.05). When subjects were divided into high (n = 13) and low (n = 17) baseline chemosensitivity, dopamine infusion (when assessed by dose) reduced HVR in the high group only (P < 0.01), with no effect of dopamine on HVR in the low group (P > 0.05). Dopamine infusion also resulted in a reduction in blood pressure (3 μg·kg(-1)·min(-1)) and total peripheral resistance (1-4 μg·kg(-1)·min(-1)), driven primarily by subjects with low baseline chemosensitivity. In conclusion, we did not find a single dose of dopamine that elicited a nadir HVR in all subjects. Additionally, potential confounding cardiovascular responses occur with dopamine infusion, which may limit its usage.

Dopamine receptor blockade improves pulmonary gas exchange but decreases exercise performance in healthy humans

Pulmonary gas exchange, as evaluated by the alveolar-arterial oxygen difference (A-aDO2), is impaired during intense exercise, and has been correlated with recruitment of intrapulmonary arteriovenous anastomoses (IPAVA) as measured by agitated saline contrast echocardiography. Previous work has shown that dopamine (DA) recruits IPAVA and increases venous admixture (Q̇s/Q̇t) at rest. As circulating DA increases during exercise, we hypothesized that A-aDO2 and IPAVA recruitment would be decreased with DA receptor blockade. Twelve healthy males (age: 25 ± 6 years, V̇O2 max : 58.6 ± 6.5 ml kg(-1) min(-1) ) performed two incremental staged cycling exercise sessions after ingestion of either placebo or a DA receptor blocker (metoclopramide 20 mg). Arterial blood gas, cardiorespiratory and IPAVA recruitment (evaluated by agitated saline contrast echocardiography) data were obtained at rest and during exercise up to 85% of V̇O2 max . On different days, participants also completed incremental exercise tests and exercise tolerance (time-to-exhaustion (TTE) at 85% of V̇O2 max ) with or without dopamine blockade. Compared to placebo, DA blockade did not change O2 consumption, CO2 production, or respiratory exchange ratio at any intensity. At 85% V̇O2 max , DA blockade decreased A-aDO2, increased arterial O2 saturation and minute ventilation, but did not reduce IPAVA recruitment, suggesting that positive saline contrast is unrelated to A-aDO2. Compared to placebo, DA blockade decreased maximal cardiac output, V̇O2 max and TTE. Despite improving pulmonary gas exchange, blocking dopamine receptors appears to be detrimental to exercise performance. These findings suggest that endogenous dopamine is important to the normal cardiopulmonary response to exercise and is necessary for optimal high-intensity exercise performance.