Counterpoint: Humans do not demonstrate selective brain cooling during hyperthermia

Effects of sodium bicarbonate ingestion on ventilatory and cerebrovascular responses in resting heated humans

Hyperthermia stimulates ventilation in humans. This hyperthermia-induced hyperventilation may be mediated by the activation of peripheral chemoreceptors implicated in the regulation of respiration in reaction to various chemical stimuli, including reductions in arterial pH. Here, we investigated the hypothesis that during passive heating at rest, the increases in arterial pH achieved with sodium bicarbonate ingestion, which could attenuate peripheral chemoreceptor activity, mitigate hyperthermia-induced hyperventilation. We also assessed the effect of sodium bicarbonate ingestion on cerebral blood flow responses, which are associated with hyperthermia-induced hyperventilation. Twelve healthy men ingested sodium bicarbonate (0.3 g/kg body weight) or sodium chloride (0.208 g/kg). One hundred minutes after the ingestion, the participants were passively heated using hot-water immersion (42°C) combined with a water-perfused suit. Increases in esophageal temperature (an index of core temperature) and minute ventilation (V̇E) during the heating were similar in the two trials. Moreover, when V̇E is expressed as a function of esophageal temperature, there were no between-trial differences in the core temperature threshold for hyperventilation (38.0 ± 0.3 vs. 38.0 ± 0.4°C, P = 0.469) and sensitivity of hyperthermia-induced hyperventilation as assessed by the slope of the core temperature-V̇E relation (13.5 ± 14.2 vs. 15.8 ± 15.5 L/min/°C, P = 0.831). Furthermore, middle cerebral artery mean blood velocity (an index of cerebral blood flow) decreased similarly with heating duration in both trials. These results suggest that sodium bicarbonate ingestion does not mitigate hyperthermia-induced hyperventilation and the reductions in cerebral blood flow index in resting heated humans.NEW & NOTEWORTHY Hyperthermia leads to hyperventilation and associated cerebral hypoperfusion, both of which may impair heat tolerance. This hyperthermia-induced hyperventilation may be mediated by peripheral chemoreceptors, which can be activated by reductions in arterial pH. However, our results suggest that sodium bicarbonate ingestion, which can increase arterial pH, is not an effective intervention in alleviating hyperthermia-induced hyperventilation and cerebral hypoperfusion in resting heated humans.

Cerebral uptake of microvesicles occurs in normocapnic but not hypocapnic passive hyperthermia in young healthy male adults

Passive hyperthermia causes cerebral hypoperfusion primarily from heat-induced respiratory alkalosis. However, despite the cerebral hypoperfusion, it is possible that the mild alkalosis might help to attenuate cerebral inflammation. In this study, the cerebral exchange of extracellular vesicles (microvesicles), which are known to elicit pro-inflammatory responses when released in conditions of stress, were examined in hyperthermia with and without respiratory alkalosis. Ten healthy male adults were heated passively, using a warm water-perfused suit, up to core temperature + 2°C. Blood samples were taken from the radial artery and internal jugular bulb. Microvesicle concentrations were determined in platelet-poor plasma via cells expressing CD62E (activated endothelial cells), CD31+ /CD42b- (apoptotic endothelial cells), CD14 (monocytes) and CD45 (pan-leucocytes). Cerebral blood flow was measured via duplex ultrasound of the internal carotid and vertebral arteries to determine cerebral exchange kinetics. From baseline to poikilocapnic (alkalotic) hyperthermia, there was no change in microvesicle concentration from any cell origin measured (P-values all >0.05). However, when blood CO2 tension was normalized to baseline levels in hyperthermia, there was a marked increase in cerebral uptake of microvesicles expressing CD62E (P = 0.028), CD31+ /CD42b- (P = 0.003) and CD14 (P = 0.031) compared with baseline, corresponding to large increases in arterial but not jugular venous concentrations. In a subset of seven participants who underwent hypercapnia and hypocapnia in the absence of heating, there was no change in microvesicle concentrations or cerebral exchange, suggesting that hyperthermia potentiated the CO2 /pH-mediated cerebral uptake of microvesicles. These data provide insight into a potential beneficial role of respiratory alkalosis in heat stress. KEY POINTS: The hyperthermia-induced hyperventilatory response is observed in most humans, despite causing potentially harmful reductions in cerebral blood flow. We tested the hypothesis that the respiratory-induced alkalosis is associated with lower circulating microvesicle concentrations, specifically in the brain, despite the reductions in blood flow. At core temperature + 2°C with respiratory alkalosis, microvesicles derived from endothelial cells, monocytes and leucocytes were at concentrations similar to baseline in the arterial and cerebral venous circulation, with no changes in cross-brain microvesicle kinetics. However, when core temperature was increased by 2°C with CO2 /pH normalized to resting levels, there was a marked cerebral uptake of microvesicles derived from endothelial cells and monocytes. The CO2 /pH-mediated alteration in cerebral microvesicle uptake occurred only in hyperthermia. These new findings suggest that the heat-induced hyperventilatory response might serve a beneficial role by preventing potentially inflammatory microvesicle uptake in the brain.

Physiological Function during Exercise and Environmental Stress in Humans-An Integrative View of Body Systems and Homeostasis

Claude Bernard's milieu intérieur (internal environment) and the associated concept of homeostasis are fundamental to the understanding of the physiological responses to exercise and environmental stress. Maintenance of cellular homeostasis is thought to happen during exercise through the precise matching of cellular energetic demand and supply, and the production and clearance of metabolic by-products. The mind-boggling number of molecular and cellular pathways and the host of tissues and organ systems involved in the processes sustaining locomotion, however, necessitate an integrative examination of the body's physiological systems. This integrative approach can be used to identify whether function and cellular homeostasis are maintained or compromised during exercise. In this review, we discuss the responses of the human brain, the lungs, the heart, and the skeletal muscles to the varying physiological demands of exercise and environmental stress. Multiple alterations in physiological function and differential homeostatic adjustments occur when people undertake strenuous exercise with and without thermal stress. These adjustments can include: hyperthermia; hyperventilation; cardiovascular strain with restrictions in brain, muscle, skin and visceral organs blood flow; greater reliance on muscle glycogen and cellular metabolism; alterations in neural activity; and, in some conditions, compromised muscle metabolism and aerobic capacity. Oxygen supply to the human brain is also blunted during intense exercise, but global cerebral metabolism and central neural drive are preserved or enhanced. In contrast to the strain seen during severe exercise and environmental stress, a steady state is maintained when humans exercise at intensities and in environmental conditions that require a small fraction of the functional capacity. The impact of exercise and environmental stress upon whole-body functions and homeostasis therefore depends on the functional needs and differs across organ systems.

Rapid and persistent decrease in brain tissue oxygenation in ovine gram-negative sepsis

The changes in brain perfusion and oxygenation in critical illness, which are thought to contribute to brain dysfunction, are unclear due to the lack of methods to measure these variables. We have developed a technique to chronically measure cerebral tissue perfusion and oxygen tension in unanesthetized sheep. Using this technique, we have determined the changes in cerebral perfusion and Po₂ during the development of ovine sepsis. In adult Merino ewes, fiber-optic probes were implanted in the brain, renal cortex, and renal medulla to measure tissue perfusion, oxygen tension (Po₂), and temperature, and flow probes were implanted on the pulmonary and renal arteries. Conscious sheep were infused with live Escherichia coli for 24 h, which induced hyperdynamic sepsis; mean arterial pressure decreased (from 85.2 ± 5.6 to 71.5 ± 8.7 mmHg), while cardiac output (from 4.12 ± 0.70 to 6.15 ± 1.26 L/min) and total peripheral conductance (from 48.9 ± 8.5 to 86.8 ± 11.5 mL/min/mmHg) increased (n = 8, all P < 0.001) and arterial Po₂ decreased (from 104 ± 8 to 83 ± 10 mmHg; P < 0.01). Cerebral perfusion tended to decrease acutely, although this did not reach significance, but there was a significant and sustained decrease in cerebral tissue Po₂ (from 32.2 ± 10.1 to 18.8 ± 11.7 mmHg) after 3 h and to 22.8 ± 5.2 mmHg after 24 h of sepsis (P < 0.02). Sepsis induced large reductions in both renal medullary perfusion and Po₂ but had no effect in the renal cortex. In ovine sepsis, there is an early decrease in cerebral Po₂ that is maintained for 24 h despite minimal changes in cerebral perfusion. Cerebral hypoxia may be one of the factors causing sepsis-induced malaise and lethargy.

Inducing therapeutic hypothermia via selective brain cooling: a finite element modeling analysis

Therapeutic hypothermia is a treatment method to reduce brain injuries after stroke, especially for cerebral ischemia. This study investigates in the temperature distribution of the head within selective brain cooling (SBC). Anatomically accurate geometries based on CT images of head and neck regions are used to develop the 3D geometry and physical model for the finite element modeling. Two cooling methods, the direct head surface cooling strategy and the combination cooling strategy of both head and neck, are evaluated to analyze the inducing hypothermia. The results show that for direct head surface cooling, the scalp and skull temperatures decrease significantly as the blood perfusion rate is constrained, but it is hard to affect the brain core temperature. To achieve a lower cerebral temperature, combination cooling strategy of both head and neck is an effective method in improving deep brain cooling. In normal condition, the cerebral temperature is reduced by about 0.12 °C in 60 min of hypothermia, while the temperature drop is approximately 0.98 °C in ischemic condition. Graphical abstract In this study, the 3D geometry of the head and carotid artery model based on the computed tomography (CT) were derived separately and the corresponding investigations were conducted to validate the reliability of the model. Direct head surface cooling strategy and the combination cooling strategy of both the head and neck were numerically researched.

Yawning, a thermoregulatory mechanism during fever? A study of yawning frequency and its predictors during experimentally induced sickness

Yawning has been proposed to serve both physiological and social functions, the latter likely to have developed later in its evolution. A central hypothesis is that yawning cools the brain but whether yawning is a thermoregulatory mechanism that is activated during hyperthermia (i.e., thermoregulatory failure) or is activated in any instance of brain temperature increase (e.g., also during fever) is unclear and experimental assessments of yawning during fever are lacking. In this study, we determined the effect of experimentally induced fever on yawning frequency. We also explored alternative predictors of yawning during sickness (sleepiness, autonomic nervous system indexes and sickness symptoms). Twenty-two healthy human subjects participated in a randomized, placebo-controlled, cross-over study, where the subjects received an injection of the bacterial endotoxin lipopolysaccharide (LPS) at a dose of 2ng/kg body weight in one condition and placebo in the other. Yawning was scored from video recordings from 30min before to 4h after the injection. Body temperature was measured frequently, alongside with heart rate, blood pressure, nausea and overall sickness symptoms. Yawning frequency was found to significantly increase over time during experimentally induced sickness, but not in the placebo condition. In particular, yawning frequency was increased during the rising phase of body temperature induced by LPS administration, although no significant correlation was found between body temperature increase and yawning frequency. In addition, exploratory analyses showed that a higher yawning frequency was associated with less increase in sickness symptoms and nausea intensity. While the current study adds to previous research showing significant increase in yawning frequency during hyperthermia, further studies are needed if we are to properly characterize the brain cooling role of yawning in humans. The investigation of other functions, such as being a vasovagal inhibitory, may shed stronger light on the functions of yawning.

Cardiopulmonary and arterial baroreceptor unloading during passive hyperthermia does not contribute to hyperthermia-induced hyperventilation

NEW FINDINGS

What is the central question of this study? Does baroreceptor unloading during passive hyperthermia contribute to increases in ventilation and decreases in end-tidal carbon dioxide during that exposure? What is the main finding and its importance? Hyperthermic hyperventilation is not mitigated by expanding central blood volume and reloading the cardiopulmonary baroreceptors via rapid saline infusion or by reloading the arterial baroreceptors via phenylephrine administration. The absence of a reduction in ventilation upon reloading the baroreceptors to pre-hyperthermic levels indicates that cardiopulmonary and arterial baroreceptor unloading with hyperthermia is unlikely to contribute to hyperthermic hyperventilation in humans. This study tested the hypothesis that baroreceptor unloading during passive hyperthermia contributes to increases in ventilation and decreases in end-tidal partial pressure of carbon dioxide (P ET ,CO2) during that exposure. Two protocols were performed, in which healthy subjects underwent passive hyperthermia (increasing intestinal temperature by ∼1.8°C) to cause a sustained increase in ventilation and reduction in P ET ,CO2. Upon attaining hyperthermic hyperventilation, in protocol 1 (n = 10; three females) a bolus (19 ± 2 ml kg(-1) ) of warm (∼38°C) isotonic saline was rapidly (5-10 min) infused intravenously to restore reductions in central venous pressure, whereas in protocol 2 (n = 11; five females) phenylephrine was infused intravenously (60-120 μg min(-1) ) to return mean arterial pressure to normothermic levels. In protocol 1, hyperthermia increased ventilation (by 2.2 ± 1.7 l min(-1) , P < 0.01), while reducing P ET ,CO2 (by 4 ± 3 mmHg, P = 0.04) and central venous pressure (by 5 ± 1 mmHg, P <0.01). Saline infusion increased central venous pressure by 5 ± 1 mmHg (P < 0.01), restoring it to normothermic values, but did not change ventilation or P ET ,CO2 (P > 0.05). In protocol 2, hyperthermia increased ventilation (by 5.0 ± 2.7 l min(-1) , P <0.01) and reduced P ET ,CO2 (by 5 ± 2 mmHg, P < 0.01) and mean arterial pressure (by 9 ± 7 mmHg, P <0.01). Phenylephrine infusion increased mean arterial pressure by 12 ± 3 mmHg (P < 0.01), restoring it to normothermic values, but did not change ventilation or P ET ,CO2 (P > 0.05). The absence of a reduction in ventilation upon reloading the cardiopulmonary and arterial baroreceptors to pre-hyperthermic levels indicates that baroreceptor unloading with hyperthermia is unlikely to contribute to hyperthermic hyperventilation in humans.

Performance in the heat-physiological factors of importance for hyperthermia-induced fatigue

This article presents a historical overview and an up-to-date review of hyperthermia-induced fatigue during exercise in the heat. Exercise in the heat is associated with a thermoregulatory burden which mediates cardiovascular challenges and influence the cerebral function, increase the pulmonary ventilation, and alter muscle metabolism; which all potentially may contribute to fatigue and impair the ability to sustain power output during aerobic exercise. For maximal intensity exercise, the performance impairment is clearly influenced by cardiovascular limitations to simultaneously support thermoregulation and oxygen delivery to the active skeletal muscle. In contrast, during submaximal intensity exercise at a fixed intensity, muscle blood flow and oxygen consumption remain unchanged and the potential influence from cardiovascular stressing and/or high skin temperature is not related to decreased oxygen delivery to the skeletal muscles. Regardless, performance is markedly deteriorated and exercise-induced hyperthermia is associated with central fatigue as indicated by impaired ability to sustain maximal muscle activation during sustained contractions. The central fatigue appears to be influenced by neurotransmitter activity of the dopaminergic system, but inhibitory signals from thermoreceptors arising secondary to the elevated core, muscle and skin temperatures and augmented afferent feedback from the increased ventilation and the cardiovascular stressing (perhaps baroreceptor sensing of blood pressure stability) and metabolic alterations within the skeletal muscles are likely all factors of importance for afferent feedback to mediate hyperthermia-induced fatigue during submaximal intensity exercise. Taking all the potential factors into account, we propose an integrative model that may help understanding the interplay among factors, but also acknowledging that the influence from a given factor depends on the exercise hyperthermia situation.

Influence of intranasal and carotid cooling on cerebral temperature balance and oxygenation

The present study evaluated the influence of intranasal cooling with balloon catheters, increased nasal ventilation, or percutaneous cooling of the carotid arteries on cerebral temperature balance and oxygenation in six healthy male subjects. Aortic arch and internal jugular venous blood temperatures were measured to assess the cerebral heat balance and corresponding paired blood samples were obtained to evaluate cerebral metabolism and oxygenation at rest, following 60 min of intranasal cooling, 5 min of nasal ventilation, and 15 min with carotid cooling. Intranasal cooling induced a parallel drop in jugular venous and arterial blood temperatures by 0.30 ± 0.08°C (mean ± SD), whereas nasal ventilation and carotid cooling failed to lower the jugular venous blood temperature. The magnitude of the arterio-venous temperature difference across the brain remained unchanged at −0.33 ± 0.05°C following intranasal and carotid cooling, but increased to −0.44 ± 0.11°C (P < 0.05) following nasal ventilation. Calculated cerebral capillary oxygen tension was 43 ± 3 mmHg at rest and remained unchanged during intranasal and carotid cooling, but decreased to 38 ± 2 mmHg (P < 0.05) following increased nasal ventilation. In conclusion, percutaneous cooling of the carotid arteries and intranasal cooling with balloon catheters are insufficient to influence cerebral oxygenation in normothermic subjects as the cooling rate is only 0.3°C per hour and neither intranasal nor carotid cooling is capable of inducing selective brain cooling.

Effect of menstrual cycle phase on the ventilatory response to rising body temperature during exercise

To examine the effect of menstrual cycle on the ventilatory sensitivity to rising body temperature, ten healthy women exercised for ∼60 min on a cycle ergometer at 50% of peak oxygen uptake during the follicular and luteal phases of their cycle. Esophageal temperature, mean skin temperature, mean body temperature, minute ventilation, and tidal volume were all significantly higher at baseline and during exercise in the luteal phase than the follicular phase. On the other hand, end-tidal partial pressure of carbon dioxide was significantly lower during exercise in the luteal phase than the follicular phase. Plotting ventilatory parameters against esophageal temperature revealed there to be no significant menstrual cycle-related differences in the slopes or intercepts of the regression lines, although minute ventilation and tidal volume did significantly differ during exercise with mild hyperthermia. To evaluate the cutaneous vasodilatory response, relative laser-Doppler flowmetry values were plotted against mean body temperature, which revealed that the mean body temperature threshold for cutaneous vasodilation was significantly higher in the luteal phase than the follicular phase, but there were no significant differences in the sensitivity or peak values. These results suggest that the menstrual cycle phase influences the cutaneous vasodilatory response during exercise and the ventilatory response at rest and during exercise with mild hyperthermia, but it does not influence ventilatory responses during exercise with moderate hyperthermia.

Validity of infrared tympanic temperature for the evaluation of heat strain while wearing impermeable protective clothing in hot environments

The purpose of this study was to investigate the validity of infrared tympanic temperature (IR T(ty)) as a thermal index to evaluate the heat strain of workers in hot environments, in comparison with rectal temperatures at various depths (T(re-4, -8, and -16) for 4, 8 and 16 cm from the anal sphincter). Eight males underwent twelve experimental conditions: two activities (rest and exercise) × three clothing levels [Control, HDPE (high-density polyethylene coverall) and PVC (polyvinyl chloride coverall) condition] × two air temperatures (25 and 32℃ with 50%RH). The results showed that 1) in the conditions with most heat strain (HDPE or PVC condition at 32℃), IR T(ty) was equal to or even higher than T(re); 2) during exercise, physiological strain index (PSI) using IR T(ty) did not underestimate PSI-values using T(re-16), and overestimated those PSI-values from T(re-16) in HDPE and PVC conditions at 32℃; 3) during exercise, the relationships between IR T(ty) and heart and total sweat rate were stronger than those between T(re-16) and heart and total sweat rate. These results indicated that IR T(ty) is valid as a thermal index to evaluate the heat strain of workers wearing impermeable protective coveralls in hot environments. However, the application of IR T(ty) is limited only for strenuous works wearing encapsulated personal protective clothing with a hood in heat.

Human paranasal sinuses and selective brain cooling: a ventilation system activated by yawning?

The function of the paranasal sinuses has been a controversial subject since the time of Galen, with many different theories advanced about their biological significance. For one, the paranasal sinuses have been regarded as warmers of respiratory air, when in actuality these structures appear to function in cooling the blood. In fact, human paranasal sinuses have been shown to have higher volumes in individuals living in warmer climates, and thus may be considered radiators of the brain. The literature suggests that the transfer of cool venous blood from the paranasal sinuses to the dura mater may provide a mechanism for the convection process of cooling produced by the evaporation of mucus within human sinuses. In turn, the dura mater may transmit these temperature changes, initiated by the cool venous blood from the heat-dissipating surfaces of the sinuses, to the cerebrospinal fluid compartments. Furthermore, it has recently been demonstrated in cadaveric dissections that the thin bony posterior wall of the maxillary sinus serves as an origin for both medial and lateral pterygoid muscle segments, an anatomic finding that had been previously underappreciated in the literature. The present authors hypothesize that the thin posterior wall of the maxillary sinus may flex during yawning, operating like a bellows pump, actively ventilating the sinus system, and thus facilitating brain cooling. Such a powered ventilation system has not previously been described in humans, although an analogous system has been reported in birds.