Antigen-independent selection of T15 idiotype during B-cell ontogeny in mice

Developmental changes in the rules for B cell selection

The autoimmune checkpoint during B cell maturation eliminates self-antigen reactive specificities from the mature B cell repertoire. However, an exception to this rule is illustrated by B-1 cells, an innate-like self-reactive B cell subset that is positively selected into the mature B cell pool in a self-antigen-driven fashion. The mechanisms by which B-1 cells escape central tolerance have puzzled the field for decades. A key clue comes from their restricted developmental window during fetal and neonatal life. Here we use B-1 cells as a prototypic early life derived B cell subset to explore developmental changes in the constraints of B cell selection. We discuss recent advancements in the understanding of the molecular program, centered around the RNA binding protein Lin28b, that licenses self-reactive B-1 cell output during ontogeny. Finally, we speculate on the possible link between the unique rules of early life B cell tolerance and the establishment of B cell - microbial mutualism to propose an integrated model for how developmental and environmental cues come together to create a protective layer of B cell memory involved in neonatal immune imprinting.

Long-term Immunotoxic Effects of Oral Prenatal and Neonatal Atrazine Exposure

Atrazine and its metabolites are present at high concentrations in many water supplies in agro-intensive areas. Because residents in these areas drink water from sources fed from these contaminated supplies, we investigated the long-term immunotoxicity of combined prenatal and neonatal (perinatal) exposure to atrazine via drinking water, on the immune system in mice. At 6 months of age, upon immunization with heat-killed Streptococcus pneumoniae, the serum IgG antibody response against the T independent antigen phosphorylcholine was significantly higher in male, but not female, atrazine-exposed mice as compared with that in untreated controls. No alterations were present in all offspring in the serum antibody response against the T-dependent antigen pneumococcal surface protein A (PspA). ELISpot analysis showed only a small, insignificant reduction in PspA-specific IgG producing splenocytes in atrazine-treated male offspring. Interestingly, upon ex vivo stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies, significant decreases in interleukin (IL)-2, tumor necrosis factor-α, interferon-γ, and IL-17A and a decreasing trend in IL-10 were observed in splenocytes from atrazine-exposed male, but not female mice. Analysis of thymic and splenic cell populations showed no effects of atrazine exposure in either sex. This is the first time that long-term changes in the immune response were observed after a perinatal exposure to atrazine and it demonstrates that these early life exposures can result in permanent changes to the immune system as well as a male bias in these effects.

Pulmonary α-1,3-Glucan-Specific IgA-Secreting B Cells Suppress the Development of Cockroach Allergy

There is a higher incidence of allergic conditions among children living in industrialized countries than those in developing regions. One explanation for this is reduced neonatal exposure to microbes and the consequent lack of immune stimulation. Sensitivity to cockroach allergen is highly correlated with the development of severe asthma. In this study, we determined that an Ab to microbial α-1,3-glucan binds an Enterobacter species and cockroach allergen. Neonatal, but not adult, mice immunized with this α-1,3-glucan-bearing Enterobacter (MK7) are protected against cockroach allergy. Following exposure to cockroach allergen, α-1,3-glucan-specific IgA-secreting cells are present in the lungs of mice immunized with MK7 as neonates but not in the lungs of those immunized as adults. Mice that are unable to generate anti-α-1,3-glucan IgA Abs were immunized with MK7 as neonates and were no longer protected against cockroach allergy. Thus, neonatal, but not adult, exposure to α-1,3-glucan results in suppressed development of cockroach allergy via pulmonary α-1,3-glucan-specific IgA-secreting cells.

Atherosclerosis Susceptibility in Mice Is Independent of the V1 Immunoglobulin Heavy Chain Gene

Supplemental Digital Content is available in the text.

The V1 (V_HS107.1.42) immunoglobulin heavy chain gene is thought to be critical in producing IgM natural antibodies of the T15-idiotype that protect against both atherosclerosis and infection from Streptococcus pneumoniae. Our aim was to determine whether genetic loss of the V1 gene increased atherosclerotic plaque burden in vivo because of a reduction in the T15-idiotype or other atheroprotective antibodies.

Protective natural autoantibodies to apoptotic cells: evidence of convergent selection of recurrent innate-like clones

During murine immune development, recurrent B cell clones arise in a predictable fashion. Among these B cells, an archetypical clonotypic set that recognizes phosphorylcholine (PC) antigens and produces anti-PC IgM, first implicated for roles in microbial protection, was later found to become expanded in hyperlipidemic mice and in response to an increased in vivo burden of apoptotic cells. These IgM natural antibodies can enhance clearance of damaged cells and induce intracellular blockade of inflammatory signaling cascades. In clinical populations, raised levels of anti-PC IgM correlate with protection from atherosclerosis and may also downmodulate the severity of autoimmune disease. Human anti-PC-producing clones without hypermutation have been isolated that can similarly discriminate apoptotic from healthy cells. An independent report on unrelated adults has described anti-PC-producing B cells with IgM genes that have conserved CDR3 motifs, similar to stereotypic clonal sets of B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia. Taken together, emerging evidence suggests that, despite the capacity to form an effectively limitless range of Ig receptors, the human immune system may often recurrently generate lymphocytes expressing structurally convergent B cell receptors with protective and homeostatic roles.

Neonatal exposure to pneumococcal phosphorylcholine modulates the development of house dust mite allergy during adult life

Currently, ∼20% of the global population suffers from an allergic disorder. Allergies and asthma occur at higher rates in developed and industrialized countries. It is clear that many human atopic diseases are initiated neonatally and herald more severe IgE-mediated disorders, including allergic asthma, which is driven by the priming of Th2 effector T cells. The hygiene hypothesis attempts to link the increased excessively sanitary conditions early in life to a default Th2 response and increasing allergic phenomena. Despite the substantial involvement of IgE Abs in such conditions, little attention has been paid to the effects of early microbial exposure on the B cell repertoire prior to the initiation of these diseases. In this study, we use Ab-binding assays to demonstrate that Streptococcus pneumoniae and house dust mite (HDM) bear similar phosphorylcholine (PC) epitopes. Neonatal C57BL/6 mice immunized with a PC-bearing pneumococcal vaccine expressed increased frequencies of PC-specific B cells in the lungs following sensitizing exposure to HDM as adults. Anti-PC IgM Abs in the lung decreased the interaction of HDM with pulmonary APCs and were affiliated with lowered allergy-associated cell infiltration into the lung, IgE production, development of airway hyperresponsiveness, and Th2 T cell priming. Thus, exposure of neonatal mice to PC-bearing pneumococci significantly reduced the development of HDM-induced allergic disease during adult life. Our findings demonstrate that B cells generated against conserved epitopes expressed by bacteria, encountered early in life, are also protective against the development of allergic disease during adult life.

Natural antibody repertoires: development and functional role in inhibiting allergic airway disease

In this review we discuss the effects of microbial exposure on the B cell repertoire. Neonatal exposure to conserved bacterial carbohydrates and phospholipids permanently reprograms the natural antibody repertoire directed toward these antigens by clonal expansion, alterations in clonal dominance, and increased serum antibody levels. These epitopes are present not only in bacterial cell walls, but also in common environmental allergens. Neonatal immunization with bacterial polysaccharide vaccines results in attenuated allergic airway responses to fungi-, house dust mite-, and cockroach-associated allergens in mouse models. The similarities between mouse and human natural antibody repertoires suggest that reduced microbial exposure in children may have the opposite effect, providing a potential mechanistic explanation for the hygiene hypothesis. We propose that understanding the effects of childhood infections on the natural antibody repertoire and the mechanisms of antibody-mediated immunoregulation observed in allergy models will lead to the development of prevention/interventional strategies for treatment of allergic asthma.

Antibodies generated against conserved antigens expressed by bacteria and allergen-bearing fungi suppress airway disease

There has been a sharp rise in allergic asthma and asthma-related deaths in the developed world, in contrast to many childhood illnesses that have been reduced or eliminated. The hygiene hypothesis proposes that excessively sanitary conditions early in life result in autoimmune and allergic phenomena because of a failure of the immune system to receive proper microbial stimulation during development. We demonstrate that Abs generated against conserved bacterial polysaccharides are reactive with and dampen the immune response against chitin and Aspergillus fumigatus. A reduction in Ag uptake, cell influx, cell activation, and cytokine production occurred in the presence of anti-polysaccharide Abs, resulting in a striking decrease in the severity of allergic airway disease in mice. Overall, our results suggest that Ag exposure--derived from environmental sources, self-antigens, or vaccination--during the neonatal period has dramatic effects on the adult Ab response and modifies the development of allergic airway disease.

Adaptive immunity and adipose tissue biology

Studies of immunity typically focus on understanding how hematopoietic cells interact within conventional secondary lymphoid tissues. However, immune reactions and their regulation occur in various environments within the body. Adipose tissue is one tissue that can influence and be influenced by adjacent and embedded lymphocytes. Despite the abundance and wide distribution of such tissue, and despite a growing obesity epidemic, studies of these interactions have been only marginally appreciated in the past. Here, we review advances in understanding of lymphoid structures within adipose tissue, the relationship between adipose tissue and adaptive immune function, and evidence for how this relationship contributes to obesity-associated diseases.

Omental milky spots develop in the absence of lymphoid tissue-inducer cells and support B and T cell responses to peritoneal antigens

The omentum is a site of B1 cell lymphopoiesis and immune responsiveness to T cell-independent antigens. However, it is unknown whether it supports immune responses independently of conventional lymphoid organs. We showed that the omentum collected antigens and cells from the peritoneal cavity and supported T cell-dependent B cell responses, including isotype switching, somatic hypermutation, and limited affinity maturation, despite the lack of identifiable follicular dendritic cells. The omentum also supported CD4+ and CD8+ T cell responses to peritoneal antigens and recruited effector T cells primed in other locations. Unlike conventional lymphoid organs, milky spots in the omentum developed in the absence of lymphoid tissue-inducer cells, but required the chemokine CXCL13. Although the lymphoid architecture of milky spots was disrupted in lymphotoxin-deficient mice, normal architecture was restored by reconstitution with lymphotoxin-sufficient hematopoietic cells. These results indicate that the milky spots of the omentum function as unique secondary lymphoid organs that promote immunity to peritoneal antigens.

The 1F7 idiotype is selectively expressed on CD5+ B cells and elevated in chronic hepatitis C virus infection

Antibodies against different chronic viruses, including hepatitis C virus (HCV), express a public cross-reactive idiotype (Id) designated as 1F7. The prominence of this Id may reflect selective engagement of B1 B cells by chronic pathogens. We investigated this by comparing 1F7 Id expression on CD5(+) and CD5(-) B cells, total IgG, total IgM and anti-HCV core antibodies in different HCV exposure settings. By flow cytometry, we observed a selective increase in 1F7 Id(+)CD5(+) B cells in chronic HCV infection. 1F7 Id levels in different immunoglobulin compartments were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. 1F7 Id expression was prominent in anti-HCV core antibodies of approximately 90% of 141 HCV-exposed individuals tested. In the Canadian and Armenian study groups, participants who spontaneously cleared HCV infection had lower median 1F7 Id levels on total plasma IgG and anti-HCV core antibodies. Armenian spontaneous clearers, who were younger and more recently infected than their Canadian counterparts, also had had lower median 1F7 Id levels on total plasma IgM. Engagement by HCV of B-cell receptors within, or overlapping with the CD5(+) B1 B-cell repertoire is reflected in the production of 1F7 Id(+) anti-HCV antibodies and expansion of 1F7 Id(+)CD5(+) B cells. Higher 1F7 Id expression levels are associated with chronic infection.

The autoreactivity of anti-phosphorylcholine antibodies for atherosclerosis-associated neo-antigens and apoptotic cells

Abs specific for phosphorylcholine (PC) are known to contribute to the immune defense against a variety of microbial infections. To assess for other types of binding interactions, we performed surveys of anti-PC Abs of diverse biologic origins and structural diversity and demonstrated a common autoreactivity for oxidatively modified low density lipoprotein and other oxidation-specific structures containing PC-Ags. We also found that cells undergoing apoptosis sequentially express a range of oxidation-specific neo-self PC determinants. Whereas natural Abs to PC recognized cells at early stages of apoptosis, by contrast, an IgG anti-PC Ab, representative of a T cell-dependent response, recognized PC determinants primarily associated with late stages of apoptosis. Cumulatively, these results demonstrate a fundamental paradigm in which Abs from both the innate and the T cell-dependent tiers of the B cell compartment recognize a minimal molecular motif arrayed both on microbes and as neo-self Ags linked to atherosclerosis and autoimmune disease.

The potential for using protein vaccines to protect against otitis media caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae

Potential vaccine strategies against otitis media are to prevent (1) symptomatic infections in the middle ear and/or (2) carriage of pneumococci and thereby subsequent middle ear infections. The possibility of using immunity to virulence proteins of pneumococci to elicit immunity against pneumococci has been examined. PspA has been found to have efficacy against otitis media in animals. Vaccination with a mixture of PsaA and PspA has been observed to offer better protection against nasal carriage in mice, than vaccination with either protein alone. PspA and pneumolysin have been shown to elicit protection against invasive infections. The inclusion of a few of these proteins into the polysaccharide-protein conjugate vaccines may be able to enhance their efficacy against otitis media and might be able to constitute a successful all-protein pneumococcal vaccine.

The potential to use PspA and other pneumococcal proteins to elicit protection against pneumococcal infection

Pneumococcal proteins, alone, in combination with each other, or in combination with capsular polysaccharide-protein conjugates may be useful pneumococcal vaccine components. Four proteins with a potential for use in vaccines are PspA, pneumolysin, PsaA, and PspC. In a mouse model of carriage, PsaA and PspC were the most efficacious vaccine proteins. Of these, PsaA was the best at eliciting protection against carriage. However, a combination of PspA and pneumolysin may elicit stronger immunity to pulmonary infection and possibly sepsis than either protein alone. Recently, a phase one trial of a recombinant family 1 PspA was completed in man. PspA was observed to be safe and immunogenic. Injection of 0.1 ml of immune serum diluted to 1/400 was able to protect mice from fatal infection with S. pneumoniae. Under these conditions, pre-immune serum was not protective. The immune human serum protected mice from infections with pneumococci expressing either of the major PspA families (1 and 2) and both of the pneumococcal capsular types tested: 3 and 6.

Pneumococcal diversity: considerations for new vaccine strategies with emphasis on pneumococcal surface protein A (PspA)

Streptococcus pneumoniae is a problematic infectious agent, whose seriousness to human health has been underscored by the recent rise in the frequency of isolation of multidrug-resistant strains. Pneumococcal pneumonia in the elderly is common and often fatal. Young children in the developing world are at significant risk for fatal pneumococcal respiratory disease, while in the developed world otitis media in children results in substantial economic costs. Immunocompromised patients are extremely susceptible to pneumococcal infection. With 90 different capsular types thus far described, the diversity of pneumococci contributes to the challenges of preventing and treating S. pneumoniae infections. The current capsular polysaccharide vaccine is not recommended for use in children younger than 2 years and is not fully effective in the elderly. Therefore, innovative vaccine strategies to protect against this agent are needed. Given the immunogenic nature of S. pneumoniae proteins, these molecules are being investigated as potential vaccine candidates. Pneumococcal surface protein A (PspA) has been evaluated for its ability to elicit protection against S. pneumoniae infection in mouse models of systemic and local disease. This review focuses on immune system responsiveness to PspA and the ability of PspA to elicit cross-protection against heterologous strains. These parameters will be critical to the design of broadly protective pneumococcal vaccines.

Antiidiotype antibodies as surrogates for polysaccharide vaccines

In past studies we demonstrated that monoclonal antibody 6F9 is a surrogate image of the meningococcal C capsular polysaccharide. These studies indicated that immunization with this anti-id resulted in a T-dependent antibody response. In the studies reported in this paper, we show that the response which is elicited is protective. Using a model of meningococcal infection in BALB/c mice in which the animals are rendered susceptible with iron dextran, we studied the ability of this anti-id to protect adult mice against challenge. These studies encompassed the ability of 6F9 to prime neonatal mice and provide them with protection to later challenge. Adult BALB/c mice immunized with 6F9 had a 100% survival and a significantly reduced level of bacteremia at 24 hours. Neonatal mice primed within 24 hours of birth and immunized at 4 weeks of age with 6F9 had a 100% survival and cleared their bacteremia by 8 hours. Neonatal mice primed with 6F9 and challenged at 5 weeks had a 90% survival. These data indicate that anti-id 6F9 is a surrogate antigen for the meningococcal C polysaccharide and is capable of inducing protective immunity in immunologically mature as well as immature animals.

Idiotypic regulation of development of the B-cell repertoire

The mouse B-cell repertoire develops from a restricted set to an extremely diverse set of specificities. Establishment of some of the B-cell clones that constitute the adult repertoire is facilitated and guided by idiotype-directed interactions among complementary sets of B cells early during ontogeny. Through in vivo experiments described here and reported elsewhere, we have shown that the program of B-cell development involving idiotypic interactions is obligatory in the development of certain B cells that provide immunity against bacterial infections. Furthermore, this program of B-cell development is facilitated in newborn mice and not in adult mice that have been transplanted with progenitor cells from adult bone marrow. Thus the idiotype-directed selection of the adult B-cell repertoire appears to be limited to fetal-neonatal stages of development.

Mouse antibody to phosphocholine can protect mice from infection with mouse-virulent human isolates of Streptococcus pneumoniae

Previous studies have demonstrated that mouse antibodies to phosphocholine (PC) can protect mice against fatal infection caused by several, but not all, mouse-virulent laboratory strains of Streptococcus pneumoniae. Because the pneumococcal strains used in previous studies had been mouse passed and were propagated for many years outside of humans, it was not known whether antibody to PC would be able to protect mice against S. pneumoniae freshly isolated from humans. In the present study, we examined the ability of an immunoglobulin G (IgG) monoclonal antibody (MAb) to PC to protect against infections in mice caused by 14 pneumococcal strains of capsular types 3, 4, 6A, and 6B. Nine of these strains were selected as the most virulent strains for mice from a group of 69 fresh clinical isolates. Five were mouse-passed laboratory strains. Mouse IgG3 MAb to PC was able to exhibit protective effects (survival or increased time to death) against infection with virtually all of the strains injected intravenously and against infection with 70% of the strains injected intraperitoneally. The protective effects of antibody to PC appeared to be partially dependent on capsular type. MAb to PC was most effective against capsular type 3 strains and least effective against type 4 strains. With type 3 and type 4 strains, MAb to PC could frequently protect against larger numbers of CFU injected intravenously than intraperitoneally. For capsular type 6A and 6B strains the reverse was true.

Interrelating B cell subpopulations and environmental regulation with the expression of three tiers of repertoire diversity

The B cell repertoire consists of three tiers of clonotype diversity. One tier, which is the product of H chain V region rearrangements in the absence of N additions, is of limited diversity (less than 10(8) clonotypes) so that clonotypes of this tier would be expected to recur within and among B cells of individuals of an inbred strain. These clonotypes, therefore, could be subjected to, and conserved by, evolutionary selective pressures such as those imposed by ubiquitous bacterial pathogens. The second tier of clonotypes is created by H chain V region rearrangements that include N additions, and is, therefore, exceedingly diverse. Clonotypes of this tier would be unlikely to recur; however, by providing maximal diversity they would ensure protection against a wide spectrum of pathogens. The third tier of diversity is that which is generated by the superimposition of somatic mutations on clonotypes of the other two tiers. This tier of clonotypes is reflective of the refinement of specificities that are destined for expression in memory B cells. B cells exists as three distinct subpopulations, Ly-1 B cells, conventional primary B cells and memory B cells. These subpopulations differ functionally, developmentally, and by the extent to which they are impacted by immunoregulatory processes. Furthermore, B cells of these subpopulations differentially express the three tiers of clonotype diversity.

Development and function of the early B cell repertoire

The early B cell repertoire is characterized by extensive interconnectivity, autoreactivity and multispecificity. Our preliminary sequence analysis of some of the idiotype specific antibodies is beginning to provide molecular clues to explain the observed multireactivity and the expression of shared idiotypic determinants on immunoglobulins of early B cells. The VH gene rearrangements analyzed are typical of the early pre-B cell and CD5 B cell repertoire. Some of these include shared or identical CDR3 regions resulting from the use of germline VH, D and JH gene segments in the absence of N region addition. As previously described, the most D proximal VH genes are also used most frequently. Collectively these genetic restrictions, together with the lack of somatic mutation, suggest that the characteristic self reactivity of the early B cell repertoire is related to the expression of germline gene segments and limited use of diversification mechanisms. It has also been possible for the first time to isolate hybridomas secreting functional IgM molecules which use the most D proximal VH gene, VH81X. These antibodies and another example from the VH7183 family have a broad multireactivity pattern possibly because of the presence of an unusually high number of charged amino acid groups present in the VH region. These findings are preliminary and more extensive studies are needed to establish if these groups are responsible for the highly cross-reactive nature of these antibodies. Nevertheless, these unusual characteristics signify a unique role for antibodies expressing this VH gene during B cell development. It is also clear that the observed anti-lymphocyte reactivity, another feature of the newborn repertoire, is the result of the prevalence of B cells using similar if not identical VHDJH genes and DJH joins. The development of these B cells appears to occur consistently in early ontogeny and, again, are not found in conventional splenic B cells obtained from the normal adult. Understanding the functional significance of the early appearance of these antibodies may help to clarify and understand their role during development as well as in autoimmunity. We propose that the unique self reactive nature of the early repertoire provides a pattern within which self-assertiveness develops and results in the establishment of the adult repertoire. In doing so, dominant clones are established which may or may not be within, but whose selection and differentiation is directed by the CD5 B cell subset.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Anti-idiotype induced protection against Neisseria meningitidis serogroup C bacteremia

We have developed a monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody, designated 6F9, which acts as the surrogate image of the meningococcal group C capsular polysaccharide (MCP). Murine immunization with 6F9 results in a T-dependent anti-MCP antibody response. To examine the protective nature of the antibody response elicited by 6F9 we performed a series of live challenge studies using a murine model for meningococcal infection in which mice were iron dextran treated and challenged with 10 x LD50 of meningococcal group C strain 35E. Adult BALB/c mice immunized with 6F9 had a 100% survival and a significantly reduced level of bacteremia at 24 h. Mice immunized with MCP had an 80% survival rate, all survivors were bacteremic at 24 h. Neonatal mice primed within 24 h of birth and immunized at 4 weeks of age with 6F9 had a 100% survival and cleared their bacteremia by 8 h, which was significantly faster than the MCP primed and immunized mice. Neonatal mice primed with 6F9 and challenged at 5 weeks of age had a survival rate of 90% which was significantly higher than mice primed with MCP and the control group (60% and 50% survival, respectively). Mice primed at birth and immunized at 8 days had a 100% survival and 90% of these mice had sterile blood cultures by 8 h. Mice primed and immunized with MCP all remained bacteremic at 24 h. These data indicate that the anti-Id 6F9 which mimics the capsular polysaccharide of group C meningococci is capable of inducing protective immunity in immunologically mature as well as immature animals.