Modulation of protective T cell immunity by complement inhibitor expression on tumor cells

Complement regulators as novel targets for anti-cancer therapy: A comprehensive review

Cancer remains a formidable global health challenge requiring the continued exploration of innovative therapeutic approaches. While traditional treatment strategies including surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation therapy have had some success, primarily in early-stage disease, the quest for more targeted, personalized, safer, and effective therapies remains an ongoing pursuit. Over the past decade, significant advances in the field of tumor immunology have dramatically shifted a focus towards immunotherapy, although the ability to harness and coopt the immune system to treat cancer is still just beginning to be realized. One important area that has yet to be fully explored is the complement system, an integral part of innate immunity that has gathered attention recently as a source of potential targets for anti-cancer therapy. The complement system has a complex and context dependent role in cancer biology in that it not only contributes to immune surveillance but also may promote tumor progression. Complement regulators, including CD46, CD55, CD59, and complement factor H, exercise defined control over complement activation, and have also been acknowledged for their role in the tumor microenvironment. This review explores the intricate role of complement regulators in cancer development and progression, examining their potential as therapeutic targets, current strategies, challenges, and the evolving landscape of clinical research.

Immunization with alloantibodies-covered melanoma cells induces regional antitumor effects that become systemic when combined with 5-FU treatment

Alloantibodies, in particular immunoglobulin G (allo-IgG), confer a rejection advantage to tumors sharing the same major histocompatibility complex (MHC) in mice. However, when administrated intratumorally, this effect can only be achieved in combination with dendritic cells (DCs) activation. Here, we developed high titer allo-IgG by multiple rounds of immunization with allogenic B16 melanoma cells, which allows for the strong binding with B16 cells. We demonstrate that B16 cells incubated with these allo-IgG (referred to as allo-IgG-B16) become highly immunogenic, which release tumor antigens that are efficiently presented by classic DCs in lymph nodes (LNs). Injection of allo-IgG-B16 turns the tumor into an immune hot one and even elicits a systemic antitumor response when used together with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU). This systemic response is tumor-specific and relies on the critical site - LNs. Our findings provide a rationale for the use of allo-IgG in cancer treatment.

Properdin Is a Modulator of Tumour Immunity in a Syngeneic Mouse Melanoma Model

Background and Objectives: Tumours are often low immunogenic. The role of complement, an innate immune defence system, in tumour control has begun to be elucidated, but findings are conflicting. A role for properdin, an amplifier of complement activation, in tumour control has recently been implicated. Materials and Methods: Properdin-deficient and congenic wildtype mice were injected subcutaneously with B16F10 melanoma cells. Tumour mass and chemokine profile were assessed. The frequencies of CD45⁺CD11b⁺ Gr-1⁺ cells were determined from tumours and spleens, and CD206⁺ F4/80⁺ cells were evaluated in spleens. Sera were analysed for C5a, sC5b-9, and CCL2. Results: Whilst there was no difference in tumour growth at study endpoint, properdin-deficient mice had significantly fewer myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSCs) in their tumours and spleens. Splenic M2 type macrophages and serum levels of C5a, sC5b-9, and CCL2 were decreased in properdin-deficient compared to wildtype mice. Conclusions: The presence of intact complement amplification sustains an environment that lessens potential anti-tumour responses.

CD46 and Oncologic Interactions: Friendly Fire against Cancer

One of the most challenging aspects of cancer therapeutics is target selection. Recently, CD46 (membrane cofactor protein; MCP) has emerged as a key player in both malignant transformation as well as in cancer treatments. Normally a regulator of complement activation, CD46 is co-expressed as four predominant isoforms on almost all cell types. CD46 is highly overexpressed on a variety of human tumor cells. Clinical and experimental data support an association between increased CD46 expression and malignant transformation and metastasizing potential. Further, CD46 is a newly discovered driver of metabolic processes and plays a role in the intracellular complement system (complosome). CD46 is also known as a pathogen magnet due to its role as a receptor for numerous microbes, including several species of measles virus and adenoviruses. Strains of these two viruses have been exploited as vectors for the therapeutic development of oncolytic agents targeting CD46. In addition, monoclonal antibody-drug conjugates against CD46 also are being clinically evaluated. As a result, there are multiple early-phase clinical trials targeting CD46 to treat a variety of cancers. Here, we review CD46 relative to these oncologic connections.

Complement System: a Neglected Pathway in Immunotherapy

Approved for the treatment of autoimmune diseases, hematological malignancies, and solid cancers, several monoclonal antibodies (mAb) make use of complement in their mechanism of action. Such an assessment is based on comprehensive investigations that used mouse models, in vitro studies, and analyses from patients at initiation (basal level to highlight deficiencies) and after treatment initiation (mAb impact on complement), which have further provided key insights into the importance of the complement activation and/or complement deficiencies in mAb activity. Accordingly, new approaches can now be developed with the final objective of increasing the clinical efficacy of mAb. These improvements include (i) the concurrent administration of fresh frozen plasma during mAb therapy; (ii) mAb modifications such as immunoglobulin G subclass switching, Fc mutation, or IgG hexamerization to improve the fixation and activation of C1q; (iii) optimization of the target recognition to induce a higher complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) and/or complement-dependant cellular cytotoxicity (CDCC); and (iv) the control of soluble and cellular complement inhibitors.

Targeting the Complement Pathway as a Therapeutic Strategy in Lung Cancer

Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer death in men and women. Lung adenocarcinoma (LUAD), represents approximately 40% of all lung cancer cases. Advances in recent years, such as the identification of oncogenes and the use of immunotherapies, have changed the treatment of LUAD. Yet survival rates still remain low. Additionally, there is still a gap in understanding the molecular and cellular interactions between cancer cells and the immune tumor microenvironment (TME). Defining how cancer cells with distinct oncogenic drivers interact with the TME and new strategies for enhancing anti-tumor immunity are greatly needed. The complement cascade, a central part of the innate immune system, plays an important role in regulation of adaptive immunity. Initially it was proposed that complement activation on the surface of cancer cells would inhibit cancer progression via membrane attack complex (MAC)-dependent killing. However, data from several groups have shown that complement activation promotes cancer progression, probably through the actions of anaphylatoxins (C3a and C5a) on the TME and engagement of immunoevasive pathways. While originally shown to be produced in the liver, recent studies show localized complement production in numerous cell types including immune cells and tumor cells. These results suggest that complement inhibitory drugs may represent a powerful new approach for treatment of NSCLC, and numerous new anti-complement drugs are in clinical development. However, the mechanisms by which complement is activated and affects tumor progression are not well understood. Furthermore, the role of local complement production vs. systemic activation has not been carefully examined. This review will focus on our current understanding of complement action in LUAD, and describe gaps in our knowledge critical for advancing complement therapy into the clinic.

The dual role of complement in cancer and its implication in anti-tumor therapy

Chronic inflammation has been linked to the initiation of carcinogenesis, as well as the advancement of established tumors. The polarization of the tumor inflammatory microenvironment can contribute to either the control, or the progression of the disease. The emerging participation of members of the complement cascade in several hallmarks of cancer, renders it a potential target for anti-tumor treatment. Moreover, the presence of complement regulatory proteins (CRPs) in most types of tumor cells is known to impede anti-tumor therapies. This review focuses on our current knowledge of complement's potential involvement in shaping the inflammatory tumor microenvironment and its role on the regulation of angiogenesis and hypoxia. Furthermore, we discuss approaches using complement-based therapies as an adjuvant in tumor immunotherapy.

Complement factor H polymorphism rs1061170 and the effect of cigarette smoking on the risk of lung cancer

Aim of the study

Complement factor H (CFH) has been known to inhibit the complement pathway and to contribute to tumour growth by suppressing the anti-tumour cell mediated response in cell lines from several malignancies. We examined the association of Try402His single nucleotide polymorphism in CFH gene with lung cancer and the interaction with cigarette smoking.

Material and methods

This case-control study included 80 primary lung cancer patients and 106 control subjects who were genotyped for Try402His (rs1061170) by polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) analysis.

Results

Variant genotypes (Tyr/His and His/His) were overpresented among patients compared to controls (p = 0.03, OR = 2.510, 95% CI: 1.068–5.899), and the frequency of variant H allele was significantly overexpressed in cases compared to controls (p = 0.021). Tyr/His genotype was identified in 100% of small cell lung cancer (SCLC) patients vs. 34.5% of non-SCLC (NSCLC), while 20.7% of NSCLC patients were homozygous for the variant allele (His/His) (p = 0.001). Binary logistic regression analysis revealed a 2.5 times greater estimated risk for NSCLC than for SCLC among variant allele carriers, and a 7.3-fold increased risk of lung cancer among variant allele smoking carriers vs. 1.3-fold increased risk among wild allele smoking carriers. Moreover, the stage of cancer positively correlated with smoking and pack-years in allele H carriers, and the correlation was stronger among those who were homozygous for it (His/His) than those who were heterozygous (Tyr/His).

Conclusions

CFH 402H variant is a smoking-related risk factor for lung cancer, particularly the NSCLC.

Complement in monoclonal antibody therapy of cancer

Monoclonal antibodies (mAb) have been used as targeted treatments against cancer for more than a decade, with mixed results. Research is needed to understand mAb mechanisms of action with the goal of improving the efficacy of currently used mAbs and guiding the design of novel mAbs. While some mAb-induced tumor cell killing is a result of direct effects on tumor cell signaling, mAb opsonization of tumor cells also triggers activation of immune responses due to complement activation and engagement of antibody receptors on immune effector cells. In fact, complement has been shown to play an important role in modulating the anti-tumor activity of many mAb through complement-dependent cytotoxicity, antibody-dependent cytotoxicity, and through indirect effects by modulating the tumor microenvironment. Complement activity can have both agonistic and antagonistic effects on these processes. How the balance of such effects impacts on the clinical efficacy of mAb therapy remains unclear. In this review, we discuss the mAbs currently approved for cancer treatment and examine how complement can impact their efficacy with a focus on how this information might be used to improve the clinical efficacy of mAb treatment.

Complement anaphylatoxins as immune regulators in cancer

The role of the complement system in innate immunity is well characterized. However, a recent body of research implicates the complement anaphylatoxins C3a and C5a as insidious propagators of tumor growth and progression. It is now recognized that certain tumors elaborate C3a and C5a and that complement, as a mediator of chronic inflammation and regulator of immune function, may in fact foster rather than defend against tumor growth. A putative mechanism for this function is complement-mediated suppression of immune effector cells responsible for immunosurveillance within the tumor microenvironment. This paradigm accords with models of immune dysregulation, such as autoimmunity and infectious disease, which have defined a pathophysiological role for abnormal complement signaling. Several types of immune cells express the cognate receptors for the complement anaphylatoxins, C3aR and C5aR, and demonstrate functional modulation in response to complement stimulation. In turn, impairment of antitumor immunity has been intimately tied to tumor progression in animal models of cancer. In this article, the literature was systematically reviewed to identify studies that have characterized the effects of the complement anaphylatoxins on the composition and function of immune cells within the tumor microenvironment. The search identified six studies based upon models of lymphoma and ovarian, cervical, lung, breast, and mammary cancer, which collectively support the paradigm of complement as an immune regulator in the tumor microenvironment.

Distinct in vivo CD8 and CD4 T cell responses against normal and malignant tissues

Normal tissue and tumour grafts expressing the same alloantigens often elicit distinct immune responses whereby only normal tissue is rejected. To investigate the mechanisms that underlie these distinct outcomes, we compared the responses of adoptively transferred HY-specific conventional (CD8 and CD4) or regulatory T (Treg) cells in mice bearing HY-expressing tumour, syngeneic male skin graft or both. For local T cell priming, T cell re-circulation, graft localization and retention, skin grafts were more efficient than tumours. Skin grafts were also capable of differentiating CD4 T cells into functional Th1 cells. Donor T cell responses were inversely correlated with tumour progression. When skin graft and tumour transplants were performed sequentially, contemporary graft and tumour burden enhanced CD8 but reduced CD4 T cell responses causing accelerated skin-graft rejection without influencing tumour growth. Although both skin grafts and tumours were able to expand HY-specific Treg cells in draining lymph node (dLN), the proportion of tumour-infiltrating Treg cells was significantly higher than that within skin grafts, correlating with accelerated tumour growth. Moreover, there was a higher level of HY antigen presentation by host APC in tumour-dLN than in graft-dLN. Finally, tumour tissues expressed a significant higher level of IDO, TGFβ, IL10 and Arginase I than skin grafts, indicating that malignant but not normal tissue represents a stronger immunosuppressive environment. These comparisons provide important insight into the in vivo mechanisms that conspire to compromise tumour-specific adaptive immunity and identify new targets for cancer immunotherapy.

Communication between host organism and cancer cells is transduced by systemic sphingosine kinase 1/sphingosine 1-phosphate signalling to regulate tumour metastasis

Mechanisms by which cancer cells communicate with the host organism to regulate lung colonization/metastasis are unclear. We show that this communication occurs via sphingosine 1-phosphate (S1P) generated systemically by sphingosine kinase 1 (SK1), rather than via tumour-derived S1P. Modulation of systemic, but not tumour SK1, prevented S1P elevation, and inhibited TRAMP-induced prostate cancer growth in TRAMP^+/+SK1^−/− mice, or lung metastasis of multiple cancer cells in SK1^−/− animals. Genetic loss of SK1 activated a master metastasis suppressor, Brms1 (breast carcinoma metastasis suppressor 1), via modulation of S1P receptor 2 (S1PR2) in cancer cells. Alterations of S1PR2 using pharmacologic and genetic tools enhanced Brms1. Moreover, Brms1 in S1PR2^−/− MEFs was modulated by serum S1P alterations. Accordingly, ectopic Brms1 in MB49 bladder cancer cells suppressed lung metastasis, and stable knockdown of Brms1 prevented this process. Importantly, inhibition of systemic S1P signalling using a novel anti-S1P monoclonal antibody (mAb), Sphingomab, attenuated lung metastasis, which was prevented by Brms1 knockdown in MB49 cells. Thus, these data suggest that systemic SK1/S1P regulates metastatic potential via regulation of tumour S1PR2/Brms1 axis.

A targeted complement-dependent strategy to improve the outcome of mAb therapy, and characterization in a murine model of metastatic cancer

Complement inhibitors expressed on tumor cells provide an evasion mechanism against mAb therapy and may modulate the development of an acquired antitumor immune response. Here we investigate a strategy to amplify mAb-targeted complement activation on a tumor cell, independent of a requirement to target and block complement inhibitor expression or function, which is difficult to achieve in vivo. We constructed a murine fusion protein, CR2Fc, and demonstrated that the protein targets to C3 activation products deposited on a tumor cell by a specific mAb, and amplifies mAb-dependent complement activation and tumor cell lysis in vitro. In syngeneic models of metastatic lymphoma (EL4) and melanoma (B16), CR2Fc significantly enhanced the outcome of mAb therapy. Subsequent studies using the EL4 model with various genetically modified mice and macrophage-depleted mice revealed that CR2Fc enhanced the therapeutic effect of mAb therapy via both macrophage-dependent FcγR-mediated antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity, and by direct complement-mediated lysis. Complement activation products can also modulate adaptive immunity, but we found no evidence that either mAb or CR2Fc treatment had any effect on an antitumor humoral or cellular immune response. CR2Fc represents a potential adjuvant treatment to increase the effectiveness of mAb therapy of cancer.

Complement in cancer and cancer immunotherapy

Recently, there has been an increase of interest in the use of biological or immune-based therapies for patients with malignancies. This has been informed by the deeper understanding of the crosstalk between the host immune system and malignant tumours, as well as the potential advantages of immunotherapy-high specificity and less toxicity compared to standard approaches. The particular emphasis of this article is on the role of the complement system in tumour growth and antibody-based cancer immunotherapy. The functional consequences from overexpression of complement regulators by tumours and the development of strategies for overcoming this are discussed in detail. This review discusses these issues with a view to inspiring the development of new agents that could be useful for the treatment of cancer.

The roles of antigen-specificity, responsiveness to transforming growth factor-β and antigen-presenting cell subsets in tumour-induced expansion of regulatory T cells

In this study we investigated the impact of several factors on the expansion of natural regulatory T (nTreg) cells by tumours, including antigen specificity, transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) signalling and the antigen-presenting cell subsets responsible for expansion. We found that antigen non-specific expansion of nTreg cells is tumour cell line-dependent. Although both antigen-specific and non-specific pathways can contribute to expansion, the migration of activated nTreg cells to tumour tissues is strictly antigen-dependent. Intact TGF-β signalling on nTreg cells is also essential for tumour-induced expansion. Finally, for stimulation of resting antigen-specific CD4 T cells, CD11c(+) cells purified from tumour-draining lymph nodes were more potent than CD11b(+) cells, suggesting that dendritic cells are the key antigen-presenting cell subset involved in cross-presentation of tumour antigens. This study not only provides an in vivo system in which cross-talk between nTreg cells and tumours can be explored but also reveals novel aspects of tumour immune evasion.

[The systemic evaluation and clinical significance of immunological function for advanced lung cancer patients]

背景与目的

真实评价免疫功能对明确肿瘤的发生发展及给予适时治疗具有重要意义。本研究旨在系统评价晚期肺癌患者免疫功能及意义。

方法

计数晚期肺癌患者和健康人外周血免疫细胞数；用流式细胞仪测定免疫细胞亚群比例和细胞内IL-4、INF-γ及穿孔素、颗粒酶水平；用MTT法评价淋巴细胞对肿瘤细胞株的抑制率及其增殖活性。

结果

晚期肺癌患者组T、B、NK细胞绝对数及亚群比例均显著低于健康组（P < 0.05）；但患者组的调节性T细胞（4.00±1.84）%明显高于健康组（1.27±0.78）%（P < 0.05）。患者组的CD8⁺T细胞中IFN-γ、穿孔素及颗粒酶阳性率均显著低于健康组（P < 0.05）；而IL-4正好相反。患者组的免疫细胞增殖能力、PPD阳性率及对瘤细胞株的抑制率显著低于健康组（P < 0.05）。

结论

晚期肺癌患者免疫功能较健康人明显低下。

Targeting neural-restrictive silencer factor sensitizes tumor cells to antibody-based cancer immunotherapy in vitro via multiple mechanisms

Tumor cells escape clearance by complement by abundantly expressing CD59 and other membrane complement regulators. Recently, we designed a peptide derived from the neural-restrictive silencer factor (REST), REST68, which we showed to inhibit expression of CD59 in tumors lacking the full-length REST and proposed a detailed model for regulation of CD59 expression via interplay between REST and nucleolin (NCL) transcription factors. In this paper, we study in detail the mechanisms for sensitization of malignant cells to Ab-based cancer immunotherapy by the REST68 peptide and the implications of the REST/NCL model for the design of treatment resulting in higher tumor susceptibility. REST68 inhibited CD59 expression in malignant cells expressing either truncated or full-length REST, but not in nonmalignant cells. However, activation of protein kinase C (PKC) in nonmalignant cells, a process that contributes to cellular transformation, phosphorylated NCL and enabled suppression of CD59 expression by the REST68. Combined treatment of different tumor types with REST68 and PKC inhibitor synergized to further suppress CD59 expression and reduce resistance to complement lysis. The combined treatment also increased susceptibility of tumors expressing either of the REST isoforms to PBMC-mediated killing, which, at least in part, accounted for the strong promotion of apoptosis by the REST68/PKC inhibitor. These data demonstrate that REST68 sensitizes tumors to Ab-based cancer immunotherapy via multiple mechanisms. Furthermore, the REST/NCL interplay model for regulation of expression of cd59 and other genes involved in cell survival enables the design of treatments for different tumor types to achieve more efficient tumor clearance.

Induction of lymphoidlike stroma and immune escape by tumors that express the chemokine CCL21

Tumor manipulation of host immunity is important for tumor survival and invasion. Many cancers secrete CCL21, a chemoattractant for various leukocytes and lymphoid tissue inducer cells, which drive lymphoid neogenesis. CCL21 expression by melanoma tumors in mice was associated with an immunotolerant microenvironment, which included the induction of lymphoid-like reticular stromal networks, an altered cytokine milieu, and the recruitment of regulatory leukocyte populations. In contrast, CCL21-deficient tumors induced antigen-specific immunity. CCL21-mediated immune tolerance was dependent on host rather than tumor expression of the CCL21 receptor, CCR7, and could protect distant, coimplanted CCL21-deficient tumors and even nonsyngeneic allografts from rejection. We suggest that by altering the tumor microenvironment, CCL21-secreting tumors shift the host immune response from immunogenic to tolerogenic, which facilitates tumor progression.

Comparative proteomical and metalloproteomical analyses of human plasma from patients with laryngeal cancer

Laryngeal cancer is a significant disease worldwide, which presents an increasing incidence. Two contrasting ideas of the immune system role during cancer development are accepted: (1) it fights tumor cells, and (2) it aids tumor progression. Thus, there is no clear understanding about the immune response in laryngeal cancer. Furthermore, since tobacco is the main cause of laryngeal cancer and it contains various carcinogenic components, including metallic elements, these may play a role on cancer development. Plasmas of patients with laryngeal cancer and of healthy smokers were evaluated by 2D gel electrophoresis and mass spectrometry. Proteins were detected on every gel around pH 4.0-10.0 from molecular mass of 10-60 kDa. Few differences were found among cancer and control patients. However, three spots gathered between pI 7.3 and 7.6 with different molecular masses appeared exclusively in cancer profiles. From ten spots identified, six correspond to immune system components, including the three differential ones. The latter were observed only in cancer patients. The presence of several trace elements in the identified proteins was determined by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry, where chromium was increased in all proteins analyzed from patients with cancer. This study reinforces the importance of the immune response as target in the understanding and treatment of laryngeal cancer and the possibility that chromium is important in the carcinogenic progress.

Hypoxia increases susceptibility of non-small cell lung cancer cells to complement attack

The complement system can be specifically targeted to tumor cells due to molecular changes on their surfaces that are recognized by complement directly or via naturally occurring antibodies. However, tumor cells often overexpress membrane-bound complement inhibitors protecting them from complement attack. We have previously shown that non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) cells, additionally to membrane-bound inhibitors, produce substantial amounts of soluble regulators such as factor I (FI) and factor H (FH). Since low oxygen concentration is associated with rapidly growing solid tumors, we studied how NSCLC cells protect themselves from complement attack under hypoxic conditions. Unexpectedly, mRNA levels and secretion of both FI and FH were significantly decreased already after 24 h exposure to hypoxia while cell viability measured by XTT assay and annexin V/7-AAD staining was affected only marginally. Furthermore, we observed decrease of mRNA level and loss of membrane-bound complement inhibitor CD46 and increased deposition of early (C3b) and terminal (C9) complement components on hypoxic NSCLC cells. All three complement pathways (classical, lectin and alternative) were employed to deposit C3b on cell surface. Taken together, our results imply that under hypoxic conditions NSCLC give up some of their available defense mechanisms and become more prone to complement attack.

Is complement good or bad for cancer patients? A new perspective on an old dilemma

Several studies of human cancers have established that chronic and insidious inflammation promotes the process of carcinogenesis and exacerbates the growth of existing tumors. Conversely, acute inflammation seems to have the opposite effect. Recent discoveries indicate that this dualism in the role of inflammation in cancer is mirrored by the effects of the complement system on this disease process. Previous studies have suggested that complement proteins can contribute to the immune surveillance of malignant tumors. However, a very recent study has indicated that complement proteins can also promote tumor growth. Here, we describe our current understanding of the role of complement in tumor development and progression.