Experimental liver preservation with Celsior: a novel alternative to University of Wisconsin and histidine-tryptophan-alpha-ketoglutarate solutions?

A Dual Protective Effect of Intestinal Remote Ischemic Conditioning in a Rat Model of Total Hepatic Ischemia

The present study aimed to investigate the effects of intestinal remote ischemic preconditioning (iRIC) on ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI) and gut barrier integrity in a rat model of total hepatic ischemia (THI). Male Wistar rats (n = 50; 250–300 g) were randomly allocated into two experimental groups: RIC/Control. Thirty minutes of THI was induced by clamping the hepatoduodenal ligament. iRIC was applied as 4-min of ischemia followed by 11-min of reperfusion by clamping the superior mesenteric artery. Animals were sacrificed at 1, 2, 6, 24 h post-reperfusion (n = 5/group/timepoint). RIC of the gut significantly improved microcirculation of the ileum and the liver. Tissue ATP-levels were higher following iRIC (Liver: 1.34 ± 0.12 vs. 0.97 ± 0.20 μmol/g, p = 0.04) and hepatocellular injury was reduced significantly (ALT: 2409 ± 447 vs. 6613 ± 1117 IU/L, p = 0.003). Systemic- and portal venous IL-6 and TNF-alpha levels were markedly lower following iRIC, demonstrating a reduced inflammatory response. iRIC led to a structural and functional preservation of the intestinal barrier. These results suggest that iRIC might confer a potent protection against the detrimental effects of THI in rats via reducing IRI and systemic inflammatory responses and at the same time by mitigating the dramatic consequences of severe intestinal congestion and bacterial translocation.

Luteolin improves heart preservation through inhibiting hypoxia-dependent L-type calcium channels in cardiomyocytes

The current study aimed to evaluate whether luteolin could improve long-term heart preservation; this was achieved by evaluating the heart following long-term storage in University of Wisconsin solution (the control group) and in solutions containing three luteolin concentrations. The effects of different preservation methods were evaluated with respect to cardiac function while hearts were in custom-made ex vivo Langendorff perfusion systems. Different preservation methods were evaluated with respect to the histology, ultrastructure and apoptosis rate of the hearts, and the function of cardiomyocytes. In the presence of luteolin, the rate pressure product of the left ventricle was increased within 60 min of reperfusion following a 12-h preservation, coronary flow was higher within 30 min of reperfusion, cardiac contractile function was higher throughout reperfusion following 12- and 18-h preservations, and the left ventricle peak systolic pressure was significantly higher compared with the control group (all P<0.05). The expression levels of apoptosis regulator Bax and apoptosis regulator Bcl-2 in the luteolin groups were significantly decreased and increased, respectively. Lactate dehydrogenase, creatine kinase and malondialdehyde enzymatic activity was increased following long-term storage, while the activity of superoxide dismutase was significantly decreased. Furthermore, luteolin inhibited L-type calcium currents in ventricular myocytes under hypoxia conditions. Thus, luteolin demonstrated protective effects during long-term heart preservation in what appeared to be a dose-dependent manner, which may be accomplished through inhibiting hypoxia-dependent L-type calcium channels.

Recent insights into mitochondrial targeting strategies in liver transplantation

Ischemia/reperfusion (I/R) injury in liver transplantation can disrupt the normal activity of mitochondria in the hepatic parenchyma. This potential dysfunction of mitochondria after I/R injury could be responsible for the initial poor graft function or primary nonfunction observed after liver transplantation. Thus, determining the mechanisms that lead to human hepatic mitochondrial dysfunction might contribute to improving the outcome of liver transplantation. Furthermore, early identification of novel prognostic factors involved in I/R injury could serve as a key endpoint to predict the outcome of liver grafts and also to promote the early adoption of novel strategies that protect against I/R injury. Here, we briefly review recent advances in the study of mitochondrial dysfunction and I/R injury, particularly in relation to liver transplantation. Next, we highlight various pharmacological therapeutic strategies that could be applied, and discuss their relationship to relevant mitochondrion-related processes and targets. Lastly, we note that although considerable progress has been made in our understanding of I/R injury and mitochondrial dysfunction, further investigation is required to elucidate the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying these processes, thereby identifying biomarkers that can help in evaluating donor organs.

Production of high-quality islets from goettingen minipigs: Choice of organ preservation solution, donor pool, and optimal cold ischemia time

BACKGROUND

The transplantation of porcine islets into man might soon become reality for patients with type 1 diabetes mellitus. Therefore, porcine islets of high quality and quantity, and a scalable isolation process with strict quality control will be an unconditional prerequisite to enable the best possible transplantation graft. In this study, we provide a comparative study evaluating islet isolation outcome and in vitro survival based upon donor age, organ preservation solution (OPS), and cold ischemia time (CIT).

METHODS

Goettingen minipigs of younger age (1 year) and retired breeder animals (3.5 years) were studied. Pancreata were harvested according to the standards of human organ retrieval including in situ cold perfusion with either Custodiol^® -HTK or Belzer^® UW solution. Pancreatic tissue was characterized by quantification of apoptotic cells. Islet isolations were performed according to a modified Ricordi method, and isolation outcome was assessed by determining islet particle numbers (IP), islet equivalents (IEQ), and isolation factor (IF). Isolated islets were cultured for 24 and 48 h for the assessment of in vitro survival.

RESULTS

Islet viability was significantly higher in Custodiol^® -HTK preserved pancreas organs compared to Belzer^® UW. Furthermore, organs harvested from retired breeder preserved in Custodiol^® -HTK resulted in stable islet isolation yields even after prolonged CIT and showed superior survival rates of islets in vitro compared to the Belzer^® UW group. Younger porcine donor organs resulted generally in lower islet yield and survival rates.

CONCLUSIONS

In summary, Custodiol^® -HTK solution should be preferred over Belzer^® UW solution for the preservation of pancreata from porcine origin. Custodiol^® -HTK allows for maintaining islet viability and promotes reproducible isolation outcome and survival even after longer CIT. The usage of retired breeder animals over young animals for islet isolation is highly advisable to yield high quality and quantity.

The application of polymerized porcine hemoglobin (pPolyHb) in the rat small bowel preservation

Small bowel transplantation (SBTx) has become a standard clinical treatment for short bowel syndrome or irreversible intestinal function failure. Optimum preservation of the organ is essential for the success of transplantation. In this study, pPolyHb was used as an additive to hypertonic citrate adenine solution (HCA) to provide oxygen for rat small bowel transplant. Rat small bowels were preserved in HCA, HCA with pPolyHb, and University of Wisconsin solution (UW) for 12, 24, and 36 h, respectively. The results suggested that the preservation effect of HCA with pPolyHb was comparable with the UW solution, and more effective than the HCA solution.

Efficacy and safety of Celsior preservation fluid in liver transplantation: one-year follow up of a prospective, multicenter, non-randomized study

The purpose of this prospective, nine-center, non-randomized study was to assess the efficacy and safety of Celsior preservation fluid in liver transplantation using unselected donors. As data comparing allograft outcomes following liver transplantation using Celsior and University of Wisconsin (UW) preservation fluids are limited, we also compared our cohort with matched controls selected from the European Liver Transplant Registry (ELTR) who received total liver grafts preserved with UW solution during the same period. One hundred and forty patients who received livers preserved with Celsior were included. The primary endpoint, graft loss at one-yr post-transplantation, was observed in 24 patients (17.1%) which was not significantly different from the 20.0% pre-defined threshold rate (95% confidence interval [CI] 10.9, 23.4; p=0.398). Predictive factors for graft loss on univariate analysis were moderate-to-severe steatosis on the donor graft (5/22 patients with graft loss vs. 8/107 patients without, p=0.046) and duration of warm ischemia (1.4±1.1 h in patients with graft loss vs. 0.9±0.5 h in patients without, p=0.034). Hepatic artery thrombosis and stenosis occurred in seven (5.0%) and six (4.3%) patients, respectively. The comparison of our patients to 420 ELTR controls showed that one-yr graft survival rates (Celsior: 82.9%, 95% CI 75.8, 88.2; UW: 78.6%, 95% CI 74.4, 82.2) and Kaplan-Meier one-yr graft survival distributions (p=0.285) were similar. Within the cold ischemia time achieved in our study, liver preservation with Celsior appeared efficient and safe. Comparison with ELTR patients suggested that liver allograft survival was similar using Celsior or UW solution for preservation of unselected donor grafts.

Liver transplantation using University of Wisconsin or Celsior preserving solutions in the portal vein and Euro-Collins in the aorta

INTRODUCTION

Orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) is today the gold standard treatment of the end-stage liver disease. Different solutions are used for graft preservation. Our objective was to compare the results of cadaveric donor OLT, preserved with the University of Wisconsin (UW) or Celsior solutions in the portal vein and Euro-Collins in the aorta.

METHODS

We evaluated retrospectively 72 OLT recipients, including 36 with UW solution (group UW) and 36 with Celsior (group CS). Donors were perfused in situ with 1000 mL UW or Celsior in the portal vein of and 3000 mL of Euro-Collins in the aortia and on the back table managed with 500 mL UW or Celsior in the portal vein, 250 mL in the hepatic artery, and 250 mL in the biliary duct. We evaluated the following variables: donor characteristics, recipient features, intraoperative details, reperfusion injury, and steatosis via a biopsy after reperfusion. We noted grafts with primary nonfunction (PNF), initial poor function (IPF), rejection episodes, biliary duct complications, hepatic artery complications, re-OLT, and recipient death in the first year after OLT.

RESULTS

The average age was 33.6 years in the UW group versus 41 years in the CS group (P = .048). There was a longer duration of surgery in the UW group (P = .001). The other recipient characteristics, ischemia-reperfusion injury, steatosis, PNF, IPF, rejection, re-OLT, and recipient survival were not different. Stenosis of the biliary duct occured in 3 (8.3%) cases in the UW group and 8 (22.2%) in the CS (P = .19) with hepatic artery thrombosis in 4 (11.1%) CS versus none in the UW group (P = .11).

CONCLUSION

Cadaveric donor OLT showed similar results with organs preserved with UW or Celsior in the portal vein and Euro-Collins in the aorta.

Optimising post-conditioning time of marginal donor livers

BACKGROUND

Due to the discrepancy between organ donors and receptors, the use of marginal livers (e.g., non-heart-beating-donor grafts) for transplantation purpose increased. The potential of a short-term aerobic machine perfusion (post-conditioning) for "less than optimal" grafts after cold storage (CS) was recently demonstrated. In our study, the optimal time course of post-conditioning (PC) is to be evaluated.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Livers from male Wistar rats were withdrawn 30 min after cardiac arrest and flushed with histidine tryptophan ketoglutarate (HTK) solution. Then they were stored in HTK at 4 degrees C for 18 h. After 16 h, some livers were put on PC by cold perfusion with HTK for 0.5, 1, 2 or 3 h. Afterwards, the viability of the organs was estimated by warm reperfusion (2 h) in vitro.

RESULTS

After 1 h of PC, a significant increase in bile production and a decrease in enzyme release could be detected in comparison to CS. The adenosine triphosphate content of the PC livers after 1 h of treatment was significant higher than in CS organs. No markers for apoptosis could be detected after 1 h PC.

CONCLUSION

It can be concluded that a PC of 1 h after cold storage can ameliorate the organ viability of marginal livers. The extension or abbreviation of PC time seems to have no further beneficial effects.

Experimental small bowel preservation using Polysol: A new alternative to University of Wisconsin solution, Celsior and histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution?

AIM: To evaluate the potential of Polysol, a newly developed preservation solution, in cold storage of small bowel grafts, compared with the current standards, University of Wisconsin solution (UW), Celsior and histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution (HTK).

METHODS: Male Wistar rats were used as donors. Small bowels were retrieved, flushed and then stored in the respective 4 solutions for 18 h at 4°C. Functional integrity of the grafts was evaluated by isolated reperfusion with oxygenated Krebs-Henseleit buffer at 37°C for 30 min in all 4 groups.

RESULTS: Polysol preservation exhibited the highest tissue ATP concentration and the lowest release of LDH. Malondialdehyde, an index for tissue lipid peroxidation, was also the lowest in Polysol. Tissue oxygen consumption was significantly higher in Polysol than in the others. Of interest, UW-storage promoted 10-fold higher apoptosis than in the others. Moreover, electron microscopy revealed that the mucosal villi/micro-villi formation and the cell organelles, including mitochondria, were both significantly better preserved in Polysol, while deleterious alterations were apparent in the others, most notably in UW. Although Celsior and HTK exhibited the better trend of results than UW in some parameters, but could not reach the over-all superiority to UW.

CONCLUSION: Cold storage using Polysol resulted in significantly better integrity and function of small bowel grafts than UW. Hence, Polysol may be a novel alternative for the small bowel preservation.

Impact of polysol, a newly developed preservation solution, on cold storage of steatotic rat livers

Chronic shortage of donor organs has led to acceptance of steatotic livers as grafts, although there is a higher risk of primary graft dysfunction. We herein report the beneficial impact of Polysol, a newly developed preservation solution, on cold storage of steatotic rat livers. Dietary hepatic steatosis was induced in Wistar rats by 2-day fasting and subsequent 3-day re-feeding with a fat-free, carbohydrate-rich diet. Fatty livers were retrieved, flushed and then stored at 4 degrees C for 24 hours with either HTK or Polysol. Functional integrity of the grafts was evaluated by isolated reperfusion with oxygenated Krebs-Henseleit buffer at 37 degrees C for 45 minutes in both groups. Polysol preservation resulted in significant reductions of not only parenchymal (AST (IU/L); 6728+/-824 in HTK vs. 3107+/-718 in Polysol; P < 0.001) but also mitochondrial (GLDH (IU/L); 3189+/-773 vs. 1282+/-365; P < 0.01) enzyme release throughout reperfusion. Moreover, PVP (16.9+/-2.7 vs. 7.8+/-1.5 mmHg; P < 0.05), hepatic O2 consumption (0.291+/-0.047 vs. 1.056+/-0.053 micromol/g liver/min; P < 0.001), tissue ATP content (0.695+/-0.086 vs. 1.340+/-0.157 micromol/g dry-liver; P < 0.005), bile production (0.79+/-0.11 vs. 4.08+/-0.66 microL/g liver/45-min; P < 0.001), malondialdehyde into the perfusate (1.922+/-0.198 vs. 0.573+/-0.094 nmol/L; P < 0.0001) and wet/dry-weight ratio of the liver tissues (5.20+/-0.31 vs. 3.85+/-0.15; P < 0.005) were all better preserved by Polysol. In line with these benefits, electron microscopy revealed that Polysol preservation substantially suppressed deleterious mitochondrial alterations in steatotic livers. In conclusion, cold storage using Polysol resulted in significantly better integrity and function of steatotic livers. Polysol, therefore, may be a new alternative especially for "marginal" organs.

Low viscosity histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate graft flush improves subsequent extended cold storage in University of Wisconsin solution in an extracorporeal rat liver perfusion and rat liver transplantation model

Adequate flushing for liver donation requires large fluid volumes delivered at a high flow. This can be achieved more effectively with crystalloid solutions than with colloid-based solutions. This study examined the combination of initial histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution (HTK) graft flush and subsequent storage in University of Wisconsin solution (UW) to that of the single use of each solution. Livers from inbred Wistar rats were procured using aortic perfusion with UW or HTK for initial perfusion and reflushed after 30 minutes using either solution. In a third group, after perfusion with HTK, organs were reflushed with UW. A 60-minute in-vitro recirculating perfusion was performed after 24 hours of cold storage in the subsequent solution, as well as allotransplantation after 18 and 24 hours of cold storage. In extracorporeal perfusion, the HTK flush followed by UW storage was superior compared to the single use of either UW or HTK solution, as measured by portal venous pressure, bile flow, liver enzymes released into the effluent perfusate, glycerol leakage, and histological examinations. These data were consistent with the transplantation study. Histological damage and enzyme release after 5-day survival were lowest in the HTK flush and subsequent UW storage groups following 18 hours of cold storage; likewise, the 5-day survival was superior following 24 hours of cold storage. In conclusion, the combined use of HTK solution for initial graft rinse and subsequent storage in UW solution resulted in a cumulative protection. Choosing low-viscosity HTK solution for the initial organ flush may represent a feasible improvement in liver preservation, which also further reduces the required amount of UW solution.

A single solution for multiple organ procurement and preservation

Two or three different solutions may be used to preserve thoracic and abdominal organs during a single procurement. The aim of this prospective, multi-center, noncomparative study was to evaluate the safety and efficacy of Celsior (study solution, solution S) as a flushing and cold storage solution for both thoracic and abdominal organs. Between August 1999 and July 2000, 72 consecutive multiple-organ procurements were performed using solution S as the sole solution for flushing out and cold-storing thoracic and abdominal grafts. Two hundred and sixty-four grafts were implanted into 245 recipients (131 kidneys, 9 kidney-pancreases, 69 livers, 34 hearts and 6 heart-lungs). The mean cold ischemia time was 21 h for kidneys (26%>24 h); 11 h 26 min for pancreases, 9 h 16 min for livers (23%>12 h), and 2 h 58 min for hearts and lungs. No cardiac failure or arrhythmia occurred on graft reperfusion. Fourteen percent of kidney recipients had delayed graft function. The mean serum creatinine level at 3 months was 123 +/- 41 micromol/l. All pancreas recipients were insulin-free at 3 months. Primary graft nonfunction occurred in one liver recipient. Complete hepatic artery thrombosis occurred in six liver recipients during the first month; four of these patients had a risk factor for thrombosis. All but three of the heart recipients were in sinus rhythm on day 1, and 65% were extubated on day 1. Inotropic drugs were necessary during the first 72 h in 25% of heart recipients. Twelve-month patient and graft survival rates were, respectively, 100% and 96% (kidney), 100% and 89% (pancreas), 88% and 83% (liver), 77.5% (heart) and 67% (heart-lung). These results suggest that Celsior, a ready-to-use solution, is safe and effective for multiple organ procurement and preservation.

UW is superior to Celsior and HTK in the protection of human liver endothelial cells against preservation injury

Celsior solution (CS), a new preservation solution in thoracic organ transplantation, was evaluated for its efficacy in cold preservation of human liver endothelial cells (HLEC) and was compared to University of Wisconsin solution (UW) and histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution (HTK, Custodiol). HLEC cultures were preserved at 4 degrees C in CS, UW, and HTK, for 2, 6, 12, 24, and 48 hours, with 6 hours of reperfusion. Levels of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT), and adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) were measured after each interval of ischemia and the respective phase of reperfusion. Preservation injury of HLEC as measured by LDH release, intracellular ATP level, and MTT reduction were overall significantly (P <or= .01, P <or= .01, P < .05, respectively) lower in UW than in CS and HTK. CS demonstrates a modest superiority to HTK in HLEC preservation. Furthermore, cold preservation remains the main cause of preservation injury of HLEC regardless of the preservation solution used. Additionally, the maintenance of a high intracellular ATP level of HLEC after ischemia and reperfusion, as shown by UW, could be taken as a beneficial effect, particularly in long-term ischemia. In conclusion, our cell culture model reveals the order of efficacy to protect HLEC against preservation injury as: UW >> CS > HTK.

Value of energy substrates in HTK and UW to protect human liver endothelial cells against ischemia and reperfusion injury

Adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) depletion is a major cause of cellular injury during ischemia and reperfusion in organ transplantation. Therefore, histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution (HTK; alpha-ketoglutarate) and University of Wisconsin solution (UW; adenosine) were supplied with energy substrates to achieve graft viability. Nevertheless, their efficacy for maintaining the ATP level, particularly in human liver endothelial cells, was uncertain. Furthermore, it is of interest whether a high ATP level is beneficial in human liver endothelial cell viability. We used human liver endothelial cells between the 3rd and 6th passages in a cell culture model. Human liver endothelial cells were exposed to hypothermic preservation (4 degrees C) in HTK and UW for 2, 6, 12, 24 and 48 h with subsequent reperfusion of 6 h. ATP and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) were measured after each interval. In comparison to HTK, UW demonstrates a statistically significantly higher level of ATP after each interval of ischemia (p < 0.001) and reperfusion (p < 0.002). Additionally, UW-preserved human liver endothelial cells exceed the ATP level of the warm control during all intervals of ischemia. The loss of cell viability (LDH) was statistically significantly higher after ischemia (p < 0.01) and reperfusion (p < 0.01) in HTK than in UW except after the interval of 48 h. In conclusion, adenosine was more effective than alpha-ketoglutarate in maintaining a high ATP level in human liver endothelial cells after ischemia and reperfusion. Different pathways of energy substrate utilization were a contributing factor. The beneficial effect of the higher ATP level caused by adenosine to human liver endothelial cell viability was limited to 24 h of ischemia. Beyond this ischemia time we could not prove a favorable impact of adenosine on human liver endothelial cells.

L-carnitine ameliorates abnormal vulnerability of steatotic rat livers to cold ischemic preservation

BACKGROUND

Up to 30% of all livers retrieved for organ transplantation exhibit steatotic transformations. Chronic organ-donor shortage has led to the acceptance of these organs for transplantation, although a higher risk of graft nonfunction is associated with the preservation of steatotic livers.

METHODS

A dietary steatosis was induced in Wistar rats by fasting them for 2 days and feeding them with a fat-free diet. Fatty livers (n=14) were retrieved and flushed with 60 mL of histidine, tryptophane, alpha-ketoglutarate (HTK) solution. In half of the experiments, L-carnitine (5 mM) was added to the HTK. Functional integrity of the livers was evaluated by isolated reperfusion with KHB in a recirculating system at 37 degrees C for 45 minutes.

RESULTS

Addition of L-carnitine to the HTK promoted a significant reduction of the enzyme leakage from the livers upon reperfusion. Release of alanine-aminotransferase was reduced to one third (127+/-22 vs. 423+/-61 U/L), and the loss of glutamate dehydrogenase in the perfusate could be reduced significantly (42+/-7 vs. 542+/-134 U/L) when compared with livers stored without additional medication. Morphologic corroboration of these data was obtained by electron microscopy. Although normal appearance of liver mitochondria was preserved at the end of the cold ischemic storage, reperfusion of cold-stored fatty livers entailed massive alterations and frequent destruction of hepatic mitochondria. However, these morphologic impairments were remarkably mitigated in the carnitine-treated group.

CONCLUSIONS

L-carnitine represents a feasible metabolic adjunct for a safe and more successful preservation of ischemia-reperfusion-sensitive steatotic livers.

Evaluation of rat liver apoptotic and necrotic cell death after cold storage using UW, HTK, and Celsior

BACKGROUND

The benefit of Celsior in liver graft preservation is controversial. In the isolated perfused rat liver model, we compared the effects of Celsior, University of Wisconsin (UW), and histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate (HTK) preservation solutions on liver cell death.

METHODS

Rat livers were stored at 4 degrees C for 0, 8, 16, or 24 hr in either Celsior, UW, or HTK and reperfused for 90 min (37 degrees C). Bile secretion and perfusate levels of liver enzymes and histone-associated DNA fragments were measured. Apoptosis and oncotic necrosis were analyzed in biopsies by DNA gel electrophoresis, hematoxylin and eosin histology, and enzyme histochemistry for lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and 5'-nucleotidase (5'-NT).

RESULTS

Perfusate flow rate through the liver during perfusion did not significantly differ among preservation solutions. Bile secretion was best preserved in UW livers after 16-hr (versus HTK livers) and 24-hr storage (versus HTK and Celsior livers). Enzyme leakage from UW livers was lower compared with HTK livers after 8-hr storage (serum glutamic oxaloacetic transaminase [SGOT], LDH) and with Celsior and HTK livers after 16-hr (SGOT, LDH) and 24-hr storage (SGOT, serum glutamic pyruvic transaminase, LDH, purine nucleoside phosphorylase). In situ LDH and 5'-NT activities were best preserved in UW livers (up to 24 hr), whereas enzyme activities declined remarkably in HTK livers (after 8 hr) and Celsior livers (after 16 hr of cold storage). Although perfusate DNA fragment levels were repeatedly lowest from Celsior livers, apoptotic DNA laddering and the number of fragmented nuclei in hematoxylin and eosin sections was not different among livers after 8, 16, or 24 hr of storage.

CONCLUSIONS

Celsior and UW are equally effective in preventing rat liver cell death after 0-16 hr of cold preservation as compared with the less effective HTK solution. After 24-hr cold storage, rat livers were best preserved in UW. Furthermore, there was no significant difference in mode of cell death (apoptosis or oncotic necrosis) after storage in any of the three solutions.