Fluoromisonidazole. A metabolic marker of myocyte hypoxia

PET Imaging in Cardiac Sarcoidosis: A Narrative Review with Focus on Novel PET Tracers

Sarcoidosis is a multi-system inflammatory disease characterized by the development of inflammation and noncaseating granulomas that can involve nearly every organ system, with a predilection for the pulmonary system. Cardiac involvement of sarcoidosis (CS) occurs in up to 70% of cases, and accounts for a significant share of sarcoid-related mortality. The clinical presentation of CS can range from absence of symptoms to conduction abnormalities, heart failure, arrhythmias, valvular disease, and sudden cardiac death. Given the significant morbidity and mortality associated with CS, timely diagnosis is important. Traditional imaging modalities and histologic evaluation by endomyocardial biopsy often provide a low diagnostic yield. Cardiac positron emission tomography (PET) has emerged as a leading advanced imaging modality for the diagnosis and management of CS. This review article will summarize several aspects of the current use of PET in CS, including indications for use, patient preparation, image acquisition and interpretation, diagnostic and prognostic performance, and evaluation of treatment response. Additionally, this review will discuss novel PET radiotracers currently under study or of potential interest in CS.

Correlation of Tumor Hypoxia Metrics Derived from 18F-Fluoromisonidazole Positron Emission Tomography and Pimonidazole Fluorescence Images of Optically Cleared Brain Tissue

18F-fluoromisonidazole (FMISO) positron emission tomography (PET) is a widely used noninvasive imaging modality for assessing hypoxia. We describe the first spatial comparison of FMISO PET with an ex vivo reference standard for hypoxia across whole tumor volumes. Eighteen rats were orthotopically implanted with C6 or 9L brain tumors and made to undergo FMISO PET scanning. Whole brains were excised, sliced into 1-mm-thick sections, optically cleared, and fluorescently imaged for pimonidazole using an in vivo imaging system. FMISO maximum tumor uptake, maximum tumor-to-cerebellar uptake (TCmax), and hypoxic fraction (extracted 110 minutes after FMISO injection) were correlated with analogous metrics derived from pimonidazole fluorescence images. FMISO SUVmax was not significantly different between C6 and 9L brain tumors (P = .70), whereas FMISO TCmax and hypoxic fraction were significantly greater for C6 tumors (P < .01). FMISO TCmax was significantly correlated with the maximum tumor pimonidazole intensity (ρ = 0.76, P < .01), whereas FMISO SUVmax was not. FMISO tumor hypoxic fraction was significantly correlated with the pimonidazole-derived hypoxic fraction (ρ = 0.78, P < .01). Given that FMISO TCmax and tumor hypoxic fraction had strong correlations with the pimonidazole reference standard, these metrics may offer more reliable measures of tumor hypoxia than conventional PET uptake metrics (SUVmax). The voxel-wise correlation between FMISO uptake and pimonidazole intensity for a given tumor was strongly dependent on the tumor's TCmax (ρ = 0.81, P < .01) and hypoxic fraction (ρ = 0.85, P < .01), indicating PET measurements within individual voxels showed greater correlation with pimonidazole reference standard in tumors with greater hypoxia.

Oxygen Sensing, Hypoxia Tracing and in Vivo Imaging with Functional Metalloprobes for the Early Detection of Non-communicable Diseases

Hypoxia has been identified as one of the hallmarks of tumor environments and a prognosis factor in many cancers. The development of ideal chemical probes for imaging and sensing of hypoxia remains elusive. Crucial characteristics would include a measurable response to subtle variations of pO2 in living systems and an ability to accumulate only in the areas of interest (e.g., targeting hypoxia tissues) whilst exhibiting kinetic stabilities in vitro and in vivo. A sensitive probe would comprise platforms for applications in imaging and therapy for non-communicable diseases (NCDs) relying on sensitive detection of pO2. Just a handful of probes for the in vivo imaging of hypoxia [mainly using positron emission tomography (PET)] have reached the clinical research stage. Many chemical compounds, whilst presenting promising in vitro results as oxygen-sensing probes, are facing considerable disadvantages regarding their general application in vivo. The mechanisms of action of many hypoxia tracers have not been entirely rationalized, especially in the case of metallo-probes. An insight into the hypoxia selectivity mechanisms can allow an optimization of current imaging probes candidates and this will be explored hereby. The mechanistic understanding of the modes of action of coordination compounds under oxygen concentration gradients in living cells allows an expansion of the scope of compounds toward in vivo applications which, in turn, would help translate these into clinical applications. We summarize hereby some of the recent research efforts made toward the discovery of new oxygen sensing molecules having a metal-ligand core. We discuss their applications in vitro and/or in vivo, with an appreciation of a plethora of molecular imaging techniques (mainly reliant on nuclear medicine techniques) currently applied in the detection and tracing of hypoxia in the preclinical and clinical setups. The design of imaging/sensing probe for early-stage diagnosis would longer term avoid invasive procedures providing platforms for therapy monitoring in a variety of NCDs and, particularly, in cancers.

PET Imaging of Cardiac Hypoxia: Hitting Hypoxia Where It Hurts

Purpose of Review

In this review, we outline the potential for hypoxia imaging as a diagnostic and prognostic tool in cardiology. We describe the lead hypoxia PET radiotracers currently in development and propose a rationale for how they should most appropriately be screened and validated.

Recent Findings

While the majority of hypoxia imaging agents has been developed for oncology, the requirements for hypoxia imaging in cardiology are different. Recent work suggests that the bis(thiosemicarbazone) family of compounds may be capable of detecting the subtle degrees of hypoxia associated with cardiovascular syndromes, and that they have the potential to be “tuned” to provide different tracers for different applications.

Summary

New tracers currently in development show significant promise for imaging evolving cardiovascular disease. Fundamental to their exploitation is their careful, considered validation and characterization so that the information they provide delivers the greatest prognostic insight achievable.

Molecular mechanisms of hypoxia in cancer

PURPOSE

Hypoxia is a condition of insufficient oxygen to support metabolism which occurs when the vascular supply is interrupted, or when a tumour outgrows its vascular supply. It is a negative prognostic factor due to its association with an aggressive tumour phenotype and therapeutic resistance. This review provides an overview of hypoxia imaging with Positron emission tomography (PET), with an emphasis on the biological relevance, mechanism of action, highlighting advantages, and limitations of the currently available hypoxia radiotracers.

METHODS

A comprehensive PubMed literature search was performed, identifying articles relating to biological significance and measurement of hypoxia, MRI methods, and PET imaging of hypoxia in preclinical and clinical settings, up to December 2016.

RESULTS

A variety of approaches have been explored over the years for detecting and monitoring changes in tumour hypoxia, including regional measurements with oxygen electrodes placed under CT guidance, MRI methods that measure either oxygenation or lactate production consequent to hypoxia, different nuclear medicine approaches that utilise imaging agents the accumulation of which is inversely related to oxygen tension, and optical methods. The advantages and disadvantages of these approaches are reviewed, along with individual strategies for validating different imaging methods. PET is the preferred method for imaging tumour hypoxia due to its high specificity and sensitivity to probe physiological processes in vivo, as well as the ability to provide information about intracellular oxygenation levels.

CONCLUSION

Even though hypoxia could have significant prognostic and predictive value in the clinic, the best method for hypoxia assessment has in our opinion not been realised.

Molecular Imaging of Hypoxia: Strategies for Probe Design and Application

Tumor hypoxia is a negative prognostic factor and its precise imaging is of great relevance to therapy planning. The present review summarizes various strategies of probe design for imaging hypoxia with a variety of techniques such as PET, SPECT and fluorescence imaging. Synthesis of some important probes that are used for preclinical and clinical imaging and their mechanism of binding in hypoxia are also discussed.

PET imaging of cardiac hypoxia: opportunities and challenges

Myocardial hypoxia is a major factor in the pathology of cardiac ischemia and myocardial infarction. Hypoxia also occurs in microvascular disease and cardiac hypertrophy, and is thought to be a prime determinant of the progression to heart failure, as well as the driving force for compensatory angiogenesis. The non-invasive delineation and quantification of hypoxia in cardiac tissue therefore has the potential to be an invaluable experimental, diagnostic and prognostic biomarker for applications in cardiology. However, at this time there are no validated methodologies sufficiently sensitive or reliable for clinical use. PET imaging provides real-time spatial information on the biodistribution of injected radiolabeled tracer molecules. Its inherent high sensitivity allows quantitative imaging of these tracers, even when injected at sub-pharmacological (≥pM) concentrations, allowing the non-invasive investigation of biological systems without perturbing them. PET is therefore an attractive approach for the delineation and quantification of cardiac hypoxia and ischemia. In this review we discuss the key concepts which must be considered when imaging hypoxia in the heart. We summarize the PET tracers which are currently available, and we look forward to the next generation of hypoxia-specific PET imaging agents currently being developed. We describe their potential advantages and shortcomings compared to existing imaging approaches, and what is needed in terms of validation and characterization before these agents can be exploited clinically.

Molecular imaging of hypoxia

Hypoxia, a condition of insufficient O2 to support metabolism, occurs when the vascular supply is interrupted, as in stroke or myocardial infarction, or when a tumor outgrows its vascular supply. When otherwise healthy tissues lose their O2 supply acutely, the cells usually die, whereas when cells gradually become hypoxic, they adapt by up-regulating the production of numerous proteins that promote their survival. These proteins slow the rate of growth, switch the mitochondria to glycolysis, stimulate growth of new vasculature, inhibit apoptosis, and promote metastatic spread. The consequence of these changes is that patients with hypoxic tumors invariably experience poor outcome to treatment. This has led the molecular imaging community to develop assays for hypoxia in patients, including regional measurements from O2 electrodes placed under CT guidance, several nuclear medicine approaches with imaging agents that accumulate with an inverse relationship to O2, MRI methods that measure either oxygenation directly or lactate production as a consequence of hypoxia, and optical methods with NIR and bioluminescence. The advantages and disadvantages of these approaches are reviewed, along with the individual strategies for validating different imaging methods. Ultimately the proof of value is in the clinical performance to predict outcome, select an appropriate cohort of patients to benefit from a hypoxia-directed treatment, or plan radiation fields that result in better local control. Hypoxia imaging in support of molecular medicine has become an important success story over the last decade and provides a model and some important lessons for development of new molecular imaging probes or techniques.

Novel imaging approaches to head and neck cancer

An inadequate supply of oxygen, hypoxia, is an important factor contributing to resistance to treatment in a number of tumor types, including head and neck cancer. Novel imaging methods have been applied to studies of this important prognostic factor. Mammalian cells need oxygen to live but O2 also participates in the cytotoxic effects of ionizing radiation. Hypoxia is often the result of abnormal blood vessels supplying the tumor, increased diffusion distances to tumor cells, and reduced O2 transport capacity of the blood. Its consequences are mediated by a series of hypoxia-initiated genomic changes activating angiogenesis, glycolysis, and other processes that enable tumor cells to survive or escape the O2-deficient environment. Hypoxia has been shown to be important in overall diminished therapeutic response, malignant progression, increased probability of recurrence, locoregional spread, and distant metastases. Strategies are being developed to surmount the cure-limiting consequences of hypoxia, but methods are needed to select patients most likely to benefit from these new treatments. Even though hypoxia is a common tumor phenotype, it is by no means universal and is often heterogeneous within an individual patient. This review considers the biology of hypoxia, its consequences with respect to treatment, methods for measuring oxygenation in tissues, modern techniques for imaging of regional hypoxia, and how information about the oxygenation status of tumors might impact treatment.

MRI of the tumor microenvironment

The microenvironment within tumors is significantly different from that in normal tissues. A major difference is seen in the chaotic vasculature of tumors, which results in unbalanced blood supply and significant perfusion heterogeneities. As a consequence, many regions within tumors are transiently or chronically hypoxic. This exacerbates tumor cells' natural tendency to overproduce acids, resulting in very acidic pH values. The hypoxia and acidity of tumors have important consequences for antitumor therapy and can contribute to the progression of tumors to a more aggressive metastatic phenotype. Over the past decade, techniques have emerged that allow the interrogation of the tumor microenvironment with high resolution and molecularly specific probes. Techniques are available to interrogate perfusion, vascular distribution, pH, and pO(2) nondestructively in living tissues with relatively high precision. Studies employing these methods have provided new insights into the causes and consequences of the hostile tumor microenvironment. Furthermore, it is quite exciting that there are emerging techniques that generate tumor image contrast via ill-defined mechanisms. Elucidation of these mechanisms will yield further insights into the tumor microenvironment. This review attempts to identify techniques and their application to tumor biology, with an emphasis on nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) approaches. Examples are also discussed using electron MR, optical, and radionuclear imaging techniques.

Synthesis and evaluation of 4-bromo-1-(3-[18F]fluoropropyl)-2-nitroimidazole with a low energy LUMO orbital designed as brain hypoxia-targeting imaging agent

In order to develop new imaging markers for brain hypoxia, 4-bromo-1-(3-fluoropropyl)-2-nitroimidazole (4-BrFPN) was designed based on molecular orbital calculations, synthesized and labeled with fluorine-18 as a lipophilic nitroimidazole analog with a lower energy LUMO orbital than those for fluoromisonidazole (FMISO) and 1-(3-fluoropropyl)-2-nitroimidazole (FPN). In an in vitro radiosensitization study, the sensitizer enhancement ratio for 4-BrFPN was found to be 1.65 at a I mM concentration, in comparison to 1.81 for FMISO. The preparation of 18F-labeled 4-BrFPN (4-Br18FPN) was achieved by [18F]fluoride ion displacement reaction of the tosylate precursor, in a reasonable radiochemical yield (33%, not corrected for decay). Metabolites in tumor and muscle extracts from methylcholanthrene-induced fibrosarcoma mice, as well as the tissue distribution of 4-Br18FPN in normal rats, were studied. The initial uptake into rat brain of 4-Br18FPN was significantly higher relative to 18F-labeled FMISO (18FMISO), followed by a rapid washout from the brain. The tumor uptake of 4-Br18FPN was somewhat enhanced compared to those obtained with 18FMISO and 18F-labeled FPN (18FPN), but with lower tumor localization than 18FMISO. Analyses of tumor and muscle extracts showed metabolites remaining base line on the radio-TLC plates, and they were produced to a greater extent in tumor than muscle. The use of two drugs which increase hypoxic cell fraction in tumor, hydralazine or nitro-L-arginine, produced a significant increase in tumor levels of 4-Br18FPN, suggestive of a hypoxic mechanism of accumulation. The results imply that lowering of the LUMO energy of a molecule alone is not sufficient to improve its biodistribution properties for better imaging of regions of hypoxia.

Dependency of the [18F]fluoromisonidazole uptake on oxygen delivery and tissue oxygenation in the porcine liver

We have previously shown that the accumulation of fluorine-18-labeled fluoromisonidazole ([(18)F]FMISO) is inversely correlated to tissue oxygenation, allowing the quantification of porcine liver tissue hypoxia in vivo. We determined the activity from administered [(18)F]FMISO in relation to the hepatic oxygen availability and the partial pressure of oxygen in tissue (tPO(2)) to define a critical oxygen delivery on a regional basis. [(18)F]FMISO was injected 2 h after onset of regional liver hypoxia due to arterial occlusion of branches of the hepatic artery in 10 domestic pigs. During the experimental procedure the fractional concentration of inspired oxygen (FiO(2)) was set to 0.67 in group A ( N=5) and to 0.21 in group B ( N=5) animals. Immediately before sacrifice, the tPO(2) was determined in normal flow and flow-impaired liver segments. The standardized uptake values (SUV) for [(18)F]FMISO was calculated from 659 single tissue samples obtained 3 h after injection of approximately 10 MBq/kg body weight [(18)F]FMISO and was compared with the regional total hepatic oxygen delivery (DO(2)) calculated from the regional arterial and portal venous flow (based on (141)Ce- and (99m)Tc-microspheres measurements) and the oxygen content of the arterial and portal venous blood. In 121 tPO(2)-measured liver tissue samples, the mean DO(2) was significantly decreased in occluded liver tissue samples [group A: 0.063 (0.044-0.089); group B: 0.046 (0.032-0.066)] compared to normal flow segments [group A: 0.177 (0.124-0.252); group B: 0.179 (0.128-0.25) mL x min(-1) x g(-1); geometric mean (95% confidence limits); p < 0.01 in group A and p < 0.001 in group B]. The tPO(2) of occluded segments [group A: 5.1 (3.2-8.1); group B: 3.9 (2.4-6.2) mm Hg] was significantly decreased compared to normal flow segments [group A: 20.2 (12.6-32.5); group B: 22.4 (14.3-35.2) mm Hg; p < 0.01 in group A and p < 0.001 in group B]. Three hours after [(18)F]FMISO administration, the mean [(18)F]FMISO SUV determined in tPO(2)-measured occluded segments was significantly higher [group A: 4.08 (3.12-5.34), group B: 5.43 (4.14-7.13)] compared to normal liver tissue [group A: 1.57 (1.2-2.06), group B: 1.5 (1.16-1.93); p < 0.001 for both groups]. The [(18)F]FMISO SUV allowed prediction of the tPO(2) with satisfying accuracy in hypoxic regions using the exponential regression curve [[(18)F]FMISO=1.05+6.7((-0.117 tPO(2))); r(2)=0.75; p < 0.001]. In addition, regardless of ventilation conditions, a significant exponential relationship between the DO(2) and the [(18)F]FMISO SUV was found ( r(2)=0.39, p < 0.001). Our results suggest that the reduction of the oxygen delivery below the critical range of 0.1-0.11 mL x min(-1) x g(-1) regularly causes liver tissue hypoxia. The severity of hypoxia is reflected by the [(18)F]FMISO accumulation and allows the in vivo estimation of the tPO(2) in hypoxic regions.

Tracer kinetic modeling in nuclear cardiology

The introduction of tracer kinetic modeling techniques in conjunction with nuclear imaging has allowed the assessment of physiologic processes in the myocardium in a noninvasive and quantitative manner. Alongside the development of novel radiopharmaceuticals for both positron emission tomography and single photon emission computed tomography is the clarification of their pharmacology, pharmacokinetics, and modeling strategies for assessment of physiologic rates from imaging data. Image analysis and tracer kinetic modeling techniques used in nuclear cardiology must address unique considerations related to the heart. The most commonly used tracers and modeling techniques are presently discussed, with particular attention given to methods that allow absolute quantitation of physiologic processes. The applications of these techniques are obvious in research protocols and may find more use in future clinical studies.

The potential for myocardial imaging with hypoxia markers

Direct "hot spot" imaging of myocardial tissue hypoxia is potentially of great clinical importance because available noninvasive approaches for the detection of myocardial ischemia have generally been based on the detection of flow heterogeneity or identification of regional alterations of myocardial metabolism. These existing approaches provide only an indirect assessment of regional myocardial ischemia, and may be affected by either sympathetic activation or substrate availability. The assessment of tissue oxygenation with hypoxic compounds may be the best indicator of the balance of flow and oxygen consumption. These compounds may provide a means of identifying dysfunctional chronically ischemic but viable "hibernating" myocardium and find a critical place in the assessment of angiogenesis. Nitroimidazole compounds hold promise for positive imaging of hypoxia in the heart. However, refinement of these compounds is needed to improve target specificity. The potential of technetium-99m (Tc99m) complexes derived from removal of the nitroimidazole moiety from a nitroimidazole-containing ligand is interesting and warrants further investigation. Experimental studies support the possibility of identifying myocardial hypoxia with the positron-emitting compound F18-fluoromisonidazole noninvasively. The potential of a Tc99m labeled nitroimidazole for positive imaging of myocardial ischemia is tremendous because single-photon imaging is more widely available. The true clinical potential of these nitroimidazole compounds can only be defined with future experimental and clinical studies. Ideally, these studies should include comparisons of tracer uptake with independent measures of regional ischemia or measures of oxygen tension, potentially using magnetic resonance imaging.

Synthesis of [18F]fluoroetanidazole: a potential new tracer for imaging hypoxia

A method has been developed for the synthesis of [18F]fluoroetanidazole, a potential tracer for imaging hypoxia with positron emission tomography. The compound is prepared by an active ester coupling reaction between the 2,3,5,6-tetrafluorophenyl ester of 2-nitroimidazole acetic acid and [18F]fluoroethylamine. [18F]Fluoroethylamine is prepared from N-[2-(toluene-4-sulfonyloxy)-ethyl]-phthalimide and [18F]fluoride and purified by distillation. The overall reaction takes about 90 min and gives a yield, uncorrected, of about 25%. Purification on a reversed-phase column is straightforward.

Contribution of hypoxia to the development of cardiomyopathy in hamsters

OBJECTIVE

It has been hypothesized that microvascular spasms cause cardiomyopathy. To elucidate the contribution of hypoxia to the development of cardiomyopathy, the newly-developed hypoxia tracer, Tc-99m nitroimidazole, was applied to detect myocardial hypoxia in a hamster model.

METHODS

Tc-99m nitroimidazole (180 MBq) and I-125 iodoantipyrine (370 kBq) were injected into cardiomyopathic Syrian hamsters or control hamsters at age 10, 25, and 40 weeks (n = 6 in each group). The myocardial uptake of Tc-99m nitroimidazole was measured and dual tracer autoradiography was performed.

RESULTS

Histologic study revealed that the cardiomyopathic hamsters at age 10, 25 and 40 weeks were in the myocytolytic stage, the fibrotic and healing stage, and the hypertrophy and dilatation stage, respectively. Tc-99m nitroimidazole uptake was significantly greater in the cardiomyopathic hamsters than in the controls at age 25 weeks (cardiomyopathic hamsters, 33.3 +/- 4.7% g dose/g; control, 25.2 +/- 3.1), whereas there were no significant differences between both strains at age 10 and 40 weeks. The quantified concentration of I-125 iodoantipyrine in the cardiomyopathic hamster at age 40 weeks was significantly lower than that in the controls. When the Tc-99m nitroimidazole uptake was normalized by I-125 iodoantipyrine concentrations, the cardiomyopathic hamsters at age 25 and 40 weeks showed significantly greater uptake than the controls.

CONCLUSION

The myocardium in cardiomyopathic hamsters was hypoxic at the fibrotic and healing stage and may be hypoxic at the hypertrophy and dilatation stage. This may contribute to the development of cardiomyopathy.

Uridine: a marker of myocardial viability after coronary occlusion and reperfusion

Tissue accumulation of radiolabeled uridine, a precursor of uracil, reflects ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis and may be a marker of viability. To test this hypothesis, myocardial accumulation of H-3 uridine was compared to deoxyglucose uptake and histopathology in an experimental model of myocardial ischemia. In 18 Wistar rats the left coronary artery was occluded for 5, 10 or 60 minutes followed by reperfusion. Five hours later H-3 uridine and C-14 deoxyglucose were administered intravenously and the animals were sacrificed 45 minutes later. The left ventricle of each animal was divided into 12 segments and myocardial tracer accumulation was determined by measurement of tissue radioactivity. From the results of TTC staining, the animals were divided into 3 groups: Group I--ischemia without infarction (n = 9); Group II--non-transmural infarction (n = 4) and transmural infarction (n = 5). Retention of uridine was observed in ischemic zones with enhanced deoxyglucose accumulation in Group I animals. Uridine accumulation was relatively preserved compared to slightly decreased deoxyglucose accumulation in regions of non-transmural infarction in Group II. In Group III, uridine accumulation decreased in parallel with deoxyglucose in zones of infarction. These result suggest that accumulation of radiolabeled uridine may be a useful indicator of viability in ischemic myocardium.

An efficient radiosynthesis of [18F]fluoromisonidazole

An efficient preparation of the hypoxic cell tracer [18F]3-fluoro-1-(2'-nitro-1'-imidazolyl)-2-propanol ([18F]fluoromisonidazole) is reported. This radiopharmaceutical is of interest to probe hypoxic tissue in infarcts and tumors. One-step radiolabeling and rapid protection group removal provided 55-80% yield in 50 min. The process is similar to common fluorine labeling procedures, simplifying the procedure for most laboratories, and offers an improvement over more difficult previous methods. The labeling precursor was prepared in five steps from readily available materials in a straightforward reaction scheme.

Complementarity of magnetic resonance spectroscopy, positron emission tomography and single photon emission tomography for the in vivo investigation of human cardiac metabolism and neurotransmission

The three techniques allowing the noninvasive study of cardiac metabolism, namely magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS), positron emission tomography (PET) and single photon emission computed tomography (SPET), all use external detection with stable or radioactive isotopes. These techniques yield different information. PET is quantitative and very sensitive, and therefore only tracer amounts of molecules need to be injected. It allows neurotransmitters and receptors to be studied and a global view of metabolism (oxygen consumption, glucose and fatty acid utilization) to be obtained. SPET also has good sensitivity, but uses gamma-emitting isotopes of heteroatoms. Their longer half-lives allow follow-up for hours or days. MRS is based on stable elements with high (hydrogen 1, phosphorus 31, fluorine 19...) or low (carbon 13, Deuterium) natural abundance. It has very low sensitivity and only millimolar concentrations of substrates can be detected, but various parts of metabolism can be studied. The in vivo measurement of myocardial concentration of substances has many problems that are common to all three techniques (measurement of the volume, measurement of the quantity of each molecule, resolution, partial volume effect, improvement of the signal-to-noise ratio, movement of the organ). The complementarity of the techniques is illustrated by their applications to the study of cardiac metabolism. For instance, the energy metabolism can be studied by 31P-MRS, which detects the high-energy compounds ATP and phosphocreatine, and 13C-MRS yields information on the tricarboxylic acid cycle activity. PET and SPET allow the utilization of fatty acids, the normal fuels of the heart, to be studied. During ischaemia, PET with 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose (18FDG) can determine the glucose consumption and 1H-MRS shows the increase in lactic acid, reflecting anaerobic glycolysis. Comparison of the use of acetate labelled with 11C for PET or 13C for MRS shows the potentials and limitations of each technique. Myocardial perfusion can be evaluated directly with various PET tracers or indirectly with thallium 201 or various technetium-99m-labelled tracers by SPET. No MRS marker of perfusion is so far clinically available. Mainly SPET and PET are used clinically for the investigation of ischaemic heart disease as well as cardiomyopathies, but some initial results using 31P-MRS are being obtained.