The Role of Schlemm's Canal Endothelium Cellular Connectivity in Giant Vacuole Formation: A 3D Electron Microscopy Study

ECM biomaterials for modeling of outflow cell biology in health and disease

This review highlights the importance of extracellular matrix (ECM) biomaterials in understanding the biology of human trabecular meshwork (TM) and Schlemm's canal (SC) cells under normal and simulated glaucoma-like conditions. We provide an overview of recent progress in the development and application of state-of-the-art 3D ECM biomaterials including cell-derived ECM, ECM scaffolds, Matrigel, and ECM hydrogels for studies of TM and SC cell (patho)biology. Such bioengineered platforms enable accurate and reliable modeling of tissue-like cell-cell and cell-ECM interactions. They bridge the gap between conventional 2D approaches and in vivo/ex vivo models, and have the potential to aid in the identification of the causal mechanism(s) for outflow dysfunction in ocular hypertensive glaucoma. We discuss each model's benefits and limitations, and close with an outlook on future directions.

Implementing new computational methods for the study of JCT and SC inner wall basement membrane biomechanics and hydrodynamics

PURPOSE

The conventional aqueous outflow pathway, which includes the trabecular meshwork (TM), juxtacanalicular tissue (JCT), and the inner wall endothelium of Schlemm's canal (SC), regulates intraocular pressure (IOP) by controlling the aqueous humor outflow resistance. Despite its importance, our understanding of the biomechanics and hydrodynamics within this region remains limited. Fluid-structure interaction (FSI) offers a way to estimate the biomechanical properties of the JCT and SC under various loading and boundary conditions, providing valuable insights that are beyond the reach of current imaging techniques.

METHODS

In this study, a normal human eye was fixed at a pressure of 7 mm Hg, and two radial wedges of the TM tissues, which included the SC inner wall basement membrane and JCT, were dissected, processed, and imaged using 3D serial block-face scanning electron microscopy (SBF-SEM). Four different sets of images were used to create 3D finite element (FE) models of the JCT and inner wall endothelial cells of SC with their basement membrane. The outer JCT portion was carefully removed as the outflow resistance is not in that region, leaving only the SCE inner wall and a few µm of the tissue, which does contain the resistance. An inverse iterative FE algorithm was then utilized to calculate the unloaded geometry of the JCT/SC complex at an aqueous humor pressure of 0 mm Hg. Then in the model, the intertrabecular spaces, pores, and giant vacuole contents were replaced by aqueous humor, and FSI was employed to pressurize the JCT/SC complex from 0 to 15 mm Hg.

RESULTS

In the JCT/SC complex, the shear stress of the aqueous humor is not evenly distributed. Areas proximal to the inner wall of SC experience larger stresses, reaching up to 10 Pa, while those closer to the JCT undergo lower stresses, approximately 4 Pa. Within this complex, giant vacuoles with or without I-pore behave differently. Those without I-pores experience a more significant strain, around 14%, compared to those with I-pores, where the strain is roughly 9%.

CONCLUSIONS

The distribution of aqueous humor wall shear stress is not uniform within the JCT/SC complex, which may contribute to our understanding of the underlying selective mechanisms in the pathway.

Biomechanics of the JCT and SC Inner Wall Endothelial Cells with Their Basement Membrane Using 3D Serial Block-Face Scanning Electron Microscopy

BACKGROUND

More than ~70% of the aqueous humor exits the eye through the conventional aqueous outflow pathway that is comprised of the trabecular meshwork (TM), juxtacanalicular tissue (JCT), the inner wall endothelium of Schlemm's canal (SC). The flow resistance in the JCT and SC inner wall basement membrane is thought to play an important role in the regulation of the intraocular pressure (IOP) in the eye, but current imaging techniques do not provide enough information about the mechanics of these tissues or the aqueous humor in this area.

METHODS

A normal human eye was perfusion-fixed and a radial wedge of the TM tissue from a high-flow region was dissected. The tissues were then sliced and imaged using serial block-face scanning electron microscopy. Slices from these images were selected and segmented to create a 3D finite element model of the JCT and SC cells with an inner wall basement membrane. The aqueous humor was used to replace the intertrabecular spaces, pores, and giant vacuoles, and fluid-structure interaction was employed to couple the motion of the tissues with the aqueous humor.

RESULTS

Higher tensile stresses (0.8-kPa) and strains (25%) were observed in the basement membrane beneath giant vacuoles with open pores. The volumetric average wall shear stress was higher in SC than in JCT/SC. As the aqueous humor approached the inner wall basement membrane of SC, the velocity of the flow decreased, resulting in the formation of small eddies immediately after the flow left the inner wall.

CONCLUSIONS

Improved modeling of SC and JCT can enhance our understanding of outflow resistance and funneling. Serial block-face scanning electron microscopy with fluid-structure interaction can achieve this, and the observed micro-segmental flow patterns in ex vivo perfused human eyes suggest a hypothetical mechanism.

Topographic distribution and phenotypic heterogeneity of Schlemm's canal endothelium in human donor eyes

Endothelium phenotype is known to be closely associated with flow shear stress. This study is to determine the topographic distribution of endothelial cells and the phenotype of different quadrants and regions of Schlemm's canal using human donor eyes. This study infers differences in flow dynamics based on cell shape and intracellular structure. The Schlemm's canal from 15 human donor eyes were either perfusion labelled using silver stain or dissected for float labeling with Phalloidin to enable visualization of endothelial cell border and intracellular structure. Data were acquired for endothelial cells from the outer and inner wall of Schlemm's canal and grouped according to quadrant of origin. Measurements included endothelial cell length, width, area, and aspect ratio and compared between quadrants. Endothelial cells are mostly spindle-shape and the cell size on the outer wall are larger and longer than those from the inner wall. Significant differences in endothelial cell size and shape were seen in different quadrants. The endothelial cells have varied shapes and orientations close to large ostia in the outer wall and remarkably long endothelial cells were found in the walls of collector channels. F-actin aggregation was found at all endothelial cell borders, and inside some of the endothelial cytoplasm. The presence of various spindle shapes, significant phenotype heterogeneity and F-actin aggregation of endothelial cells indicates aqueous humor flow likely creates variations in shear stress within Schlemm's canal. Further investigation of the relationship between the phenotype heterogeneity and hydrodynamics of aqueous flow may help us understand the mechanisms of outflow resistance changes in glaucoma.

Intracameral Injection of AAV-DJ.COMP-ANG1 Reduces the IOP of Mice by Reshaping the Trabecular Outflow Pathway

Purpose

The angiopoietin-1 (ANG1)-TIE signaling pathway orchestrates the development and maintenance of the Schlemm's canal (SC). In this study, we investigated the impact of adeno-associated virus (AAV)-mediated gene therapy with cartilage oligomeric matrix protein-ANG1 (COMP-ANG1) on trabecular outflow pathway.

Methods

Different serotypes of AAVs were compared for transduction specificity and efficiency in the anterior segment. The selected AAVs encoding COMP-ANG1 or ZsGreen1 (control) were delivered into the anterior chambers of wild-type C57BL/6J mice. The IOP and ocular surface were monitored regularly. Ocular perfusion was performed to measure the outflow facility and label flow patterns of the trabecular drainage pathway. Structural features of SC as well as limbal, retinal, and skin vessels were visualized by immunostaining. Ultrastructural changes in the SC and trabecular meshwork were observed under transmission electron microscopy.

Results

AAV-DJ could effectively infect the anterior segment. Intracameral injection of AAV-DJ.COMP-ANG1 lowered IOP in wild-type C57BL/6J mice. No signs of inflammation or angiogenesis were noticed. Four weeks after AAV injection, the conventional outflow facility and effective filtration area were increased significantly (P = 0.005 and P = 0.04, respectively). Consistently, the area of the SC was enlarged (P < 0.001) with increased density of giant vacuoles in the inner wall (P = 0.006). In addition, the SC endothelia lay on a more discontinuous basement membrane (P = 0.046) and a more porous juxtacanalicular tissue (P = 0.005) in the COMP-ANG1 group.

Conclusions

Intracamerally injected AAV-DJ.COMP-ANG1 offers a significant IOP-lowering effect by remodeling the trabecular outflow pathway of mouse eyes.

Schlemm's canal: the outflow 'vessel'

In a healthy eye, the aqueous humour (AH) flows via the ciliary body and trabecular meshwork into the collector channels, which carry it to the episcleral veins. In glaucoma, a heterogeneous group of eye disorders affecting approximately 60 million individuals worldwide, the juxtacanalicular meshwork offers greater resistance to the outflow of the AH, leading to an increase in outflow resistance that gradually results in elevated intraocular pressure (IOP). The present review comprehensively covers the morphology of Schlemm’s canal (SC) and AH pathways. The path of the AH from the anterior chamber through the trabeculum into suprascleral and conjunctival veins via collector channels is described, and the role of SC in the development of glaucoma and outflow resistance is discussed. Finally, channelography is presented as a precise method of assessing the conventional drainage pathway and facilitating localization of an uncollapsed collector and aqueous veins. Attention is also given to the relationship between aqueous and episcleral veins and heartbeat. Possible directions of future research are proposed.

Schlemm’s Canal Endothelium Cellular Connectivity in Giant Vacuole and Pore Formation in Different Flow-type Areas: A Serial Block-Face Scanning Electron Microscopy Study

Glaucoma is associated with increased resistance in the conventional aqueous humor (AH) outflow pathway of the eye. The majority of resistance is thought to reside in the juxtacanalicular connective tissue (JCT) region of the trabecular meshwork and is modulated by the inner wall (IW) endothelial cells of Schlemm’s canal (SC). The IW cells form connections with the underlying JCT cells/matrix, and these connections are thought to modulate outflow resistance. Two ways by which AH crosses the IW endothelium are through: 1) the formation of outpouchings in IW cells called giant vacuoles (GVs) and their intracellular pores (I-pores), and 2) intercellular pores between two adjacent IW cells (B-pores). AH outflow is segmental with areas of high-, low-, and non-flow around the circumference of the eye. To investigate whether changes in cellular connectivity play a role in segmental outflow regulation, we used global imaging, serial block-face scanning electron microscopy (SBF-SEM), and 3D reconstruction to examine individual IW cells from different flow areas of ex vivo perfused normal human donor eyes. Specifically, we investigated the differences in cellular dimensions, connections with JCT cells/matrix, GVs, and pores in SC IW cells between high-, low-, and non-flow areas. Our data showed that: 1) IW cell-JCT cell/matrix connectivity was significantly decreased in the cells in high-flow areas compared to those in low- and non-flow areas; 2) GVs in the cells of high-flow areas had significantly fewer connections beneath them compared to GVs in the cells of low- and non-flow areas; 3) Type IV GVs (with I-pores and basal openings) had significantly fewer connections beneath them compared to Type I GVs (no I-pore or basal opening). Our results suggest that a decreased number of cellular connections between the IW and JCT in high-flow areas is associated with increased numbers of GVs with I-pores and larger Type IV GVs observed in previous studies. Therefore, modulating the number of cellular connections may affect the amount of high-flow area around the eye and thereby modulate AH outflow.

Normal and glaucomatous outflow regulation

Glaucoma remains only partially understood, particularly at the level of intraocular pressure (IOP) regulation. Trabecular meshwork (TM) and Schlemm's canal inner wall endothelium (SCE) are key to IOP regulation and their characteristics and behavior are the focus of much investigation. This is becoming more apparent with time. We and others have studied the TM and SCE's extracellular matrix (ECM) extensively and unraveled much about its functions and role in regulating aqueous outflow. Ongoing ECM turnover is required to maintain IOP regulation and several TM ECM manipulations modulate outflow facility. We have established clearly that the outflow pathway senses sustained pressure deviations and responds by adjusting the outflow resistance correctively to keep IOP within an appropriately narrow range which will not normally damage the optic nerve. The glaucomatous outflow pathway has in many cases lost this IOP homeostatic response, apparently due at least in part, to loss of TM cells. Depletion of TM cells eliminates the IOP homeostatic response, while restoration of TM cells restores it. Aqueous outflow is not homogeneous, but rather segmental with regions of high, intermediate and low flow. In general, glaucomatous eyes have more low flow regions than normal eyes. There are distinctive molecular differences between high and low flow regions, and during the response to an IOP homeostatic pressure challenge, additional changes in segmental molecular composition occur. In conjunction with these changes, the biomechanical properties of the juxtacanalicular (JCT) segmental regions are different, with low flow regions being stiffer than high flow regions. The JCT ECM of glaucomatous eyes is around 20 times stiffer than in normal eyes. The aqueous humor outflow resistance has been studied extensively, but neither the exact molecular components that comprise the resistance nor their exact location have been established. Our hypothetical model, based on considerable available data, posits that the continuous SCE basal lamina, which lies between 125 and 500 nm beneath the SCE basal surface, is the primary source of normal resistance. On the surface of JCT cells, small and highly controlled focal degradation of its components by podosome- or invadopodia-like structures, PILS, occurs in response to pressure-induced mechanical stretching. Sub-micron sized basement membrane discontinuities develop in the SCE basement membrane and these discontinuities allow passage of aqueous humor to and through SCE giant vacuoles and pores. JCT cells then relocate versican with its highly charged glycosaminoglycan side chains into the discontinuities and by manipulation of their orientation and concentration, the JCT and perhaps the SCE cells regulate the amount of fluid passage. Testing this outflow resistance hypothesis is ongoing in our lab and has the potential to advance our understanding of IOP regulation and of glaucoma.

Morphological factors associated with giant vacuoles with I-pores in Schlemm's canal endothelial cells of human eyes: A serial block-face scanning electron microscopy study

Increased intraocular pressure (IOP) is the main risk factor for primary open-angle glaucoma and results from impaired drainage of aqueous humor (AH) through the trabecular outflow pathway. AH must pass the inner wall (IW) endothelium of Schlemm's canal (SC), which is a monolayer held together by tight junctions, to exit the eye. One route across the IW is through giant vacuoles (GVs) with their basal openings and intracellular pores (I-pores). AH drainage through the trabecular outflow pathway is segmental. Whether more GVs with both basal openings and I-pores are present in the active flow areas and factors that may influence formation of GVs with I-pores have not been fully elucidated due to limitations in imaging methods. In this study, we applied a relatively new technique, serial block-face scanning electron microscopy (SBF-SEM), to investigate morphological factors associated with GVs with I-pores in different flow areas. Two normal human donor eyes were perfused at 15 mmHg with fluorescent tracers to label the outflow pattern followed by perfusion-fixation. Six radial wedges of trabecular meshwork including SC (2 each from high-, low-, and non-flow areas) were imaged using SBF-SEM (total: 9802 images). Total GVs, I-pores, basal openings, and four types of GVs were identified. Percentages of GVs with I-pores and basal openings and number of I-pores/GV were determined. Overall, 14.4% (477/3302) of GVs had I-pores. Overall percentage of GVs with both I-pores and basal openings was higher in high- (15.7%), than low- (12.6%) or non-flow (7.3%) areas. Of GVs with I-pores, 83.2% had a single I-pore; 16.8% had multiple I-pores (range: 2-6). Additionally, 180 GVs (90 with I-pores and 90 without I-pores) were randomly selected, manually segmented, and three-dimensionally (3D) reconstructed to determine size, shape, and thickness of the cellular lining. Size of GVs (including median volume, surface area, and maximal cross-sectional area) with I-pores (n = 90) was significantly larger than GVs without I-pores (n = 90) using 3D-reconstructed GVs (P ≤ 0.01). Most I-pores (73.3%; 66/90) were located on or close to GV's maximal cross-sectional area with significant thinning of the cellular lining. Our results suggest that larger size and thinner cellular lining of GVs may contribute to formation of GVs with I-pores. More GVs with I-pores and basal openings were observed in high-flow areas, suggesting these GVs do provide a channel through which AH passes into SC and that increasing this type of GV may be a potential strategy to increase aqueous outflow for glaucoma treatment.

Progress in the basic and clinical research on the Schlemm's canal

Glaucoma is a leading cause of irreversible blindness in the world. Intraocular pressure (IOP) plays a key role in glaucoma development and progression. Schlemm's canal (SC), an important structure of the anterior chamber angle, regulates the flow of aqueous humor and maintains IOP. Because of its special function of aqueous outflow, the SC has been intensive investigated recently. Several characteristics of SC in anatomy, physiology and pathophysiology have been revealed. Compare to normal, glaucomatous SC cells are more sensitive to substrate stiffness, have higher stiffness and and lower porosity leading to higher outflow resistance. And SC collapse caused by acute IOP increase is partially or totally reversal. With advanced inspection techniques, high-quality images of the SC can be obtained in vivo, which facilitates SC quantitative measurements clinically and allows us to investigate a new therapy paradigm for glaucoma. In this review, we summarize the basic and clinical research that focused on mechanisms of aqueous outflow resistance and SC changes in physiological, pathological, and post-treatment states.

In Vivo Imaging of Schlemm's Canal and Limbal Vascular Network in Mouse Using Visible-Light OCT

Purpose

To validate the ability of visible-light optical coherence tomography (vis-OCT) in imaging the full Schlemm's canal (SC) and its surrounding limbal vascular network in mice in vivo through a compound circumlimbal scan.

Methods

We developed an anterior segment vis-OCT system and a compound circumlimbal scanning method, which montages eight rotated raster scans. We calibrated the circumlimbal scan geometry using a three-dimensional printed phantom eyeball before imaging wild-type C57BL/6J mice. We measured SC size by segmenting SC cross sections from vis-OCT B-scan images and imaged the limbal microvascular network using vis-OCT angiography (vis-OCTA). To introduce changes in SC size, we used a manometer to adjust the intraocular pressure (IOP) to different levels. To create additional optical scattering contrast to enhance SC imaging, we surgically increased the episcleral venous pressure (EVP) and caused blood reflux into SC.

Results

Using the compound circumlimbal scan, our anterior segment vis-OCT noninvasively imaged the full SC and limbal microvascular network in mouse for the first time. We observed an average 123% increase in SC volume when we decreased the IOP by 10 mm Hg from the baseline IOP of 7 to 10 mm Hg and an average 72% decrease in SC volume when the IOP level was elevated by 10 mm Hg from the baseline IOP. We also observed location-dependent SC size responses to IOP changes. Blood reflux caused by increased EVP enabled vis-OCTA to directly visualize SC, which matched well with the segmented SC.

Conclusions

Vis-OCT and vis-OCTA can accurately image the entire SC and limbal microvascular network in vivo using the compound circumlimbal scan. Vis-OCT is also able to quantitatively measure SC responses to changing IOP levels.

Increased stiffness and flow resistance of the inner wall of Schlemm's canal in glaucomatous human eyes

The cause of the elevated outflow resistance and consequent ocular hypertension characteristic of glaucoma is unknown. To investigate possible causes for this flow resistance, we used atomic force microscopy (AFM) with 10-µm spherical tips to probe the stiffness of the inner wall of Schlemm's canal as a function of distance from the tissue surface in normal and glaucomatous postmortem human eyes, and 1-µm spherical AFM tips to probe the region immediately below the tissue surface. To localize flow resistance, perfusion and imaging methods were used to characterize the pressure drop in the immediate vicinity of the inner wall using giant vacuoles that form in Schlemm's canal cells as micropressure sensors. Tissue stiffness increased with increasing AFM indentation depth. Tissues from glaucomatous eyes were stiffer compared with normal eyes, with greatly increased stiffness residing within ∼1 µm of the inner-wall surface. Giant vacuole size and density were similar in normal and glaucomatous eyes despite lower flow rate through the latter due to their higher flow resistance. This implied that the elevated flow resistance found in the glaucomatous eyes was localized to the same region as the increased tissue stiffness. Our findings implicate pathological changes to biophysical characteristics of Schlemm's canal endothelia and/or their immediate underlying extracellular matrix as cause for ocular hypertension in glaucoma.

Ultrastructural variability of the juxtacanalicular tissue along the inner wall of Schlemm's canal

Purpose

Increased resistance of aqueous humor drainage from the eye through Schlemm's canal (SC) is the basis for elevated intraocular pressure in glaucoma. Experimental evidence suggests that the bulk of outflow resistance lies in the vicinity of the inner wall endothelial lining of SC and the adjacent juxtacanalicular tissue (JCT). However, there is little understanding of how this resistance is generated, and a detailed understanding of the structure-function relationship of the outflow pathway has not been established yet. In the present study, regional variations in the ultrastructure of the JCT and the inner wall of SC were investigated in three dimensions.

Methods

With the use of serial block face scanning electron microscopy (SBF-SEM), the volume occupied by the electron lucent spaces of the JCT compared to that occupied by the cellular and extracellular matrix was investigated and quantified. The distribution of giant vacuoles (GVs) and pores in the inner wall endothelium of SC was further examined.

Results

With increasing distance from the inner wall of SC, the volume of the electron lucent spaces increased above 30%. In contrast, the volume of these spaces in immediate contact with the inner wall endothelium was minimal (<10%). Circumferential variability in the type and distribution of GVs was observed, and the percentage of GVs with pores varied between 3% and 27%.

Conclusions

These studies provide a detailed quantitative analysis of the ultrastructure of JCT and the distribution of GVs along the circumference of SC in three dimensions, supporting the non-uniform or segmental aqueous outflow.