Dopamine 2 Receptor Signaling Controls the Daily Burst in Phagocytic Activity in the Mouse Retinal Pigment Epithelium

Gas6 and Protein S Ligands Cooperate to Regulate MerTK Rhythmic Activity Required for Circadian Retinal Phagocytosis

Among the myriad of existing tyrosine kinase receptors, the TAM family-abbreviated from Tyro3, Axl, and Mer tyrosine kinase (MerTK)-has been extensively studied with an outstanding contribution from the team of Prof. Greg Lemke. MerTK activity is implicated in a wide variety of functions involving the elimination of apoptotic cells and has recently been linked to cancers, auto-immune diseases, and atherosclerosis/stroke. In the retina, MerTK is required for the circadian phagocytosis of oxidized photoreceptor outer segments by the retinal-pigment epithelial cells, a function crucial for the long-term maintenance of vision. We previously showed that MerTK ligands carry the opposite role in vitro, with Gas6 inhibiting the internalization of photoreceptor outer segments while Protein S acts conversely. Using site-directed mutagenesis and ligand-stimulated phagocytosis assays on transfected cells, we presently demonstrate, for the first time, that Gas6 and Protein S recognize different amino acids on MerTK Ig-like domains. In addition, MerTK's function in retinal-pigment epithelial cells is rhythmic and might thus rely on the respective stoichiometry of both ligands at different times of the day. Accordingly, we show that ligand bioavailability varies during the circadian cycle using RT-qPCR and immunoblots on retinal and retinal-pigment epithelial samples from control and beta5 integrin knockout mice where retinal phagocytosis is arrhythmic. Taken together, our results suggest that Gas6 and Protein S might both contribute to refine the acute regulation of MerTK in time for the daily phagocytic peak.

Clearance phagocytosis by the retinal pigment epithelial during photoreceptor outer segment renewal: Molecular mechanisms and relation to retinal inflammation

Mammalian photoreceptor outer segment renewal is a highly coordinated process that hinges on timed cell signaling between photoreceptor neurons and the adjacent retinal pigment epithelial (RPE). It is a strictly rhythmic, synchronized process that underlies in part circadian regulation. We highlight findings from recently developed methods that quantify distinct phases of outer segment renewal in retinal tissue. At light onset, outer segments expose the conserved "eat-me" signal phosphatidylserine exclusively at their distal, most aged tip. A coordinated two-receptor efferocytosis process follows, in which ligands bridge outer segment phosphatidylserine with the RPE receptors αvβ5 integrin, inducing cytosolic signaling toward Rac1 and focal adhesion kinase/MERTK, and with MERTK directly, additionally inhibiting RhoA/ROCK and thus enabling F-actin dynamics favoring outer segment fragment engulfment. Photoreceptors and RPE persist for life with each RPE cell in the eye servicing dozens of overlying photoreceptors. Thus, RPE cells phagocytose more often and process more material than any other cell type. Mutant mice with impaired outer segment renewal largely retain functional photoreceptors and retinal integrity. However, when anti-inflammatory signaling in the RPE via MERTK or the related TYRO3 is lacking, catastrophic inflammation leads to immune cell infiltration that swiftly destroys the retina causing blindness.

Dopamine modulates the retinal clock through melanopsin-dependent regulation of cholinergic waves during development

BACKGROUND

The mammalian retina contains an autonomous circadian clock that controls various aspects of retinal physiology and function, including dopamine (DA) release by amacrine cells. This neurotransmitter plays a critical role in retina development, visual signalling, and phase resetting of the retinal clock in adulthood. Interestingly, bidirectional regulation between dopaminergic cells and melanopsin-expressing retinal ganglion cells has been demonstrated in the adult and during development. Additionally, the adult melanopsin knockout mouse (Opn4 ^-/-) exhibits a shortening of the endogenous period of the retinal clock. However, whether DA and / or melanopsin influence the retinal clock mechanism during its maturation is still unknown.

RESULTS

Using wild-type Per2 ^Luc and melanopsin knockout (Opn4 ^-/-::Per2 ^Luc) mice at different postnatal stages, we found that the retina generates self-sustained circadian rhythms from postnatal day 5 in both genotypes and that the ability to express these rhythms emerges in the absence of external time cues. Intriguingly, only in wild-type explants, DA supplementation lengthened the endogenous period of the clock during the first week of postnatal development through both D1- and D2-like dopaminergic receptors. Furthermore, the blockade of spontaneous cholinergic retinal waves, which drive DA release in the early developmental stages, shortened the period and reduced the light-induced phase shift of the retinal clock only in wild-type retinas.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that DA modulates the molecular core of the clock through melanopsin-dependent regulation of acetylcholine retinal waves, thus offering an unprecedented role of DA and melanopsin in the endogenous functioning and the light response of the retinal clock during development.

Circadian clock organization in the retina: From clock components to rod and cone pathways and visual function

Circadian (24-h) clocks are cell-autonomous biological oscillators that orchestrate many aspects of our physiology on a daily basis. Numerous circadian rhythms in mammalian and non-mammalian retinas have been observed and the presence of an endogenous circadian clock has been demonstrated. However, how the clock and associated rhythms assemble into pathways that support and control retina function remains largely unknown. Our goal here is to review the current status of our knowledge and evaluate recent advances. We describe many previously-observed retinal rhythms, including circadian rhythms of morphology, biochemistry, physiology, and gene expression. We evaluate evidence concerning the location and molecular machinery of the retinal circadian clock, as well as consider findings that suggest the presence of multiple clocks. Our primary focus though is to describe in depth circadian rhythms in the light responses of retinal neurons with an emphasis on clock control of rod and cone pathways. We examine evidence that specific biochemical mechanisms produce these daily light response changes. We also discuss evidence for the presence of multiple circadian retinal pathways involving rhythms in neurotransmitter activity, transmitter receptors, metabolism, and pH. We focus on distinct actions of two dopamine receptor systems in the outer retina, a dopamine D4 receptor system that mediates circadian control of rod/cone gap junction coupling and a dopamine D1 receptor system that mediates non-circadian, light/dark adaptive regulation of gap junction coupling between horizontal cells. Finally, we evaluate the role of circadian rhythmicity in retinal degeneration and suggest future directions for the field of retinal circadian biology.

Regulation of the rhythmic diversity of daily photoreceptor outer segment phagocytosis in vivo

Outer segment phagocytosis (OSP) is a highly-regulated, biological process wherein photoreceptor outer segment (OS) tips are cyclically phagocytosed by the adjacent retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) cells. Often an overlooked retinal process, rhythmic OSP ensures the maintenance of healthy photoreceptors and vision. Daily, the photoreceptors renew OS at their base and the most distal, and likely oldest, OS tips, are phagocytosed by the RPE, preventing the accumulation of photo-oxidative compounds by breaking down phagocytosed OS tips and recycling useful components to the photoreceptors. Light changes often coincide with an escalation of OSP and within hours the phagosomes formed in each RPE cell are resolved. In the last two decades, individual molecular regulators were elucidated. Some of the molecular machinery used by RPE cells for OSP is highly similar to mechanisms used by other phagocytic cells for the clearance of apoptotic cells. Consequently, in the RPE, many molecular regulators of retinal phagocytosis have been elucidated. However, there is still a knowledge gap regarding the key regulators of physiological OSP in vivo between endogenous photoreceptors and the RPE. Understanding the regulation of OSP is of significant clinical interest as age-related macular degeneration (AMD) and inherited retinal diseases (IRD) are linked with altered OSP. Here, we review the in vivo timing of OSP peaks in selected species and focus on the reported in vivo environmental and molecular regulators of OSP.

Differences in Diurnal Rhythm of Rod Outer Segment Renewal between 129T2/SvEmsJ and C57BL/6J Mice

In all mammalian species tested to date, rod photoreceptor outer segment renewal is a circadian process synchronized by light with a burst of outer segment fragment (POS) shedding and POS phagocytosis by the adjacent retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) every morning at light onset. Recent reports show that RPE phagocytosis also increases shortly after dark onset in C57BL/6 (C57) mice. Genetic differences between C57 mice and 129T2/SvEmsJ (129) mice may affect regulation of outer segment renewal. Here, we used quantitative methods to directly compare outer segment renewal in C57 and 129 mouse retina. Quantification of rhodopsin-positive phagosomes in the RPE showed that in 129 mice, rod POS phagocytosis after light onset was significantly increased compared to C57 mice, but that 129 mice did not show a second peak after dark onset. Cone POS phagosome content of RPE cells did not differ by mouse strain with higher phagosome numbers after light than after dark. We further quantified externalization of the "eat me" signal phosphatidylserine by outer segment tips, which precedes POS phagocytosis. Live imaging of retina ex vivo showed that rod outer segments extended PS exposure in both strains but that frequency of outer segments with exposed PS after light onset was lower in C57 than in 129 retina. Taken together, 129 mice lacked a burst of rod outer segment renewal after dark onset. The increases in rod outer segment renewal after light and after dark onset in C57 mice were attenuated compared to the peak after light onset in 129 mice, suggesting an impairment in rhythmicity in C57 mice.

The Circadian Clock in the Retinal Pigment Epithelium Controls the Diurnal Rhythm of Phagocytic Activity

The diurnal peak of phagocytosis by the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) of photoreceptor outer segments (POS) is under circadian control and believed that this process involves interactions from the retina and RPE. Previous studies have demonstrated that a functional circadian clock exists within multiple retinal cell types and RPE. Thereby, the aim of this study was to determine whether the clock in the retina or RPE controls the diurnal phagocytic peak and whether disruption of the circadian clock in the RPE would affect cellular function and the viability during aging. To that, we generated and validated an RPE tissue-specific KO of the essential clock gene, Bmal1, and then determined the daily rhythm in phagocytic activity by the RPE in mice lacking a functional circadian clock in the retina or RPE. Then, using electroretinography, spectral domain-optical coherence tomography, and optomotor response of visual function we determined the effect of Bmal1 removal in young (6 months) and old (18 months) mice. RPE morphology and lipofuscin accumulation was determined in young and old mice. Our data shows that the clock in the RPE, rather than the retina clock, controls the diurnal phagocytic peak. Surprisingly, absence of a functional RPE clock and phagocytic peak does not result in any detectable age-related degenerative phenotype in the retina or RPE. Thus, our results demonstrate that the circadian clock in the RPE controls the daily peak of phagocytic activity. However, the absence of the clock in the RPE does not result in deterioration of photoreceptors or the RPE during aging.

Probing Photoreceptor Outer Segment Phagocytosis by the RPE In Vivo: Models and Methodologies

In the vertebrate retina, the light-sensitive photoreceptor rods and cones constantly undergo renewal by generating new portions of the outer segment and shedding their distal, spent tips. The neighboring RPE provides the critical function of engulfing the spent material by phagocytosis. RPE phagocytosis of shed rod outer segment fragments is a circadian process that occurs in a burst of activity shortly after daily light onset with low activity at other times, a rhythm that has been reported for many species and over 50 years. In this review, we compare studies on the rhythm and quantity of RPE phagocytosis using different in vivo model systems and assessment methods. We discuss how measurement methodology impacts the observation and analysis of RPE phagocytosis. Published studies on RPE phagocytosis investigating mice further suggest that differences in genetic background and housing conditions may affect results. Altogether, a comparison between RPE phagocytosis studies performed using differing methodology and strains of the same species is not as straightforward as previously thought.

Circadian Regulation of Retinal Pigment Epithelium Function

The retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) is a single layer of cells located between the choriocapillaris vessels and the light-sensitive photoreceptors in the outer retina. The RPE performs physiological processes necessary for the maintenance and support of photoreceptors and visual function. Among the many functions performed by the RPE, the timing of the peak in phagocytic activity by the RPE of the photoreceptor outer segments that occurs 1-2 h. after the onset of light has captured the interest of many investigators and has thus been intensively studied. Several studies have shown that this burst in phagocytic activity by the RPE is under circadian control and is present in nocturnal and diurnal species and rod and cone photoreceptors. Previous investigations have demonstrated that a functional circadian clock exists within multiple retinal cell types and RPE cells. However, the anatomical location of the circadian controlling this activity is not clear. Experimental evidence indicates that the circadian clock, melatonin, dopamine, and integrin signaling play a key role in controlling this rhythm. A series of very recent studies report that the circadian clock in the RPE controls the daily peak in phagocytic activity. However, the loss of the burst in phagocytic activity after light onset does not result in photoreceptor or RPE deterioration during aging. In the current review, we summarized the current knowledge on the mechanism controlling this phenomenon and the physiological role of this peak.

Core circadian clock genes Per1 and Per2 regulate the rhythm in photoreceptor outer segment phagocytosis

Retinal photoreceptors undergo daily renewal of their distal outer segments, a process indispensable for maintaining retinal health. Photoreceptor outer segment (POS) phagocytosis occurs as a daily peak, roughly about 1 hour after light onset. However, the underlying cellular and molecular mechanisms which initiate this process are still unknown. Here we show that, under constant darkness, mice deficient for core circadian clock genes (Per1 and Per2) lack a daily peak in POS phagocytosis. By qPCR analysis, we found that core clock genes were rhythmic over 24 hours in both WT and Per1, Per2 double mutant whole retinas. More precise transcriptomics analysis of laser capture microdissected WT photoreceptors revealed no differentially expressed genes between time points preceding and during the peak of POS phagocytosis. In contrast, we found that microdissected WT retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) had a number of genes that were differentially expressed at the peak phagocytic time point compared to adjacent ones. We also found a number of differentially expressed genes in Per1, Per2 double mutant RPE compared to WT ones at the peak phagocytic time point. Finally, based on STRING analysis, we found a group of interacting genes that potentially drive POS phagocytosis in the RPE. This potential pathway consists of genes such as: Pacsin1, Syp, Camk2b, and Camk2d among others. Our findings indicate that Per1 and Per2 are necessary clock components for driving POS phagocytosis and suggest that this process is transcriptionally driven by the RPE.

Photoreceptor Degeneration in Homozygous Male Per2luc Mice During Aging

The Per2^luc mouse model developed by Takahashi laboratory is one of the most powerful models to study circadian rhythms in real time. In this study, we report that photoreceptors degenerate in male Per2^luc mice during aging. Young (2.5- to 5-month-old) and aged (11- to 13.5-month-old) homozygous male Per2^luc mice and C57BL/6J mice were used for this study. Retina structure and function were investigated via spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT), fundus imaging, and electroretinography (ERG). Zonula occludens-1 (ZO-1) immunofluorescence was used to analyze the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) morphology. Fundus examination revealed no difference between young Per2^luc and wild-type (WT) mice. However, the fundus of aged Per2^luc mice showed white deposits, suggestive of age-related drusen-like formation or microglia, which were absent in age-matched WT mice. No differences in retinal structure and function were observed between young Per2^luc and WT mice. However, with age, Per2^luc mice showed a significant reduction in total retinal thickness with respect to C57BL/6J mice. The reduction was mostly confined to the photoreceptor layer. Consistent with these results, we observed a significant decrease in the amplitude of a- and b-waves of the ERG in aged Per2^luc mice. Analysis of the RPE morphology revealed that in aged Per2^luc mice there was an increase in compactness and eccentricity with a decrease in solidity with respect to the values observed in WT, pointing toward signs of aging in the RPE of Per2^luc mice. Our data demonstrate that homozygous Per2^luc mice show photoreceptor degeneration during aging and a premature aging of the RPE.

A Re-Appraisal of Pathogenic Mechanisms Bridging Wet and Dry Age-Related Macular Degeneration Leads to Reconsider a Role for Phytochemicals

Which pathogenic mechanisms underlie age-related macular degeneration (AMD)? Are they different for dry and wet variants, or do they stem from common metabolic alterations? Where shall we look for altered metabolism? Is it the inner choroid, or is it rather the choroid–retinal border? Again, since cell-clearing pathways are crucial to degrade altered proteins, which metabolic system is likely to be the most implicated, and in which cell type? Here we describe the unique clearing activity of the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and the relevant role of its autophagy machinery in removing altered debris, thus centering the RPE in the pathogenesis of AMD. The cell-clearing systems within the RPE may act as a kernel to regulate the redox homeostasis and the traffic of multiple proteins and organelles toward either the choroid border or the outer segments of photoreceptors. This is expected to cope with the polarity of various domains within RPE cells, with each one owning a specific metabolic activity. A defective clearance machinery may trigger unconventional solutions to avoid intracellular substrates’ accumulation through unconventional secretions. These components may be deposited between the RPE and Bruch’s membrane, thus generating the drusen, which remains the classic hallmark of AMD. These deposits may rather represent a witness of an abnormal RPE metabolism than a real pathogenic component. The empowerment of cell clearance, antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and anti-angiogenic activity of the RPE by specific phytochemicals is here discussed.

Circadian analysis of the mouse retinal pigment epithelium transcriptome

The presence of a phagocytic peak of photoreceptor outer segments by the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) one or 2 h after the onset of light has been reported for several diurnal and nocturnal species. This peak in phagocytic activity also persists under constant lighting conditions (i.e., constant light or dark) thus demonstrating that the timing of this peak is driven by a circadian clock. The aim of this study was to investigate the change in RPE whole transcriptome at two different circadian times (CT; 1 h before (CT23) and 1 h after (CT1) subjective light onset). C57BL/6J male mice were maintained in constant dark conditions for three days and euthanized under red light (<1 lux) at CT23 and CT1. RPE was isolated from whole eyes for RNA library preparation and sequencing on an Illumina HiSeq4000 platform. 14,083 mouse RPE transcripts were detected in common between CT23 and CT1. 12,005 were protein coding transcripts and 2078 were non-protein coding transcripts. 2421 protein coding transcripts were significantly upregulated whereas only 3 transcripts were significantly downregulated and 12 non-protein coding transcripts were significantly upregulated and 31 non-protein coding transcripts were significantly downregulated at CT1 when compared to CT23 (p < 0.05, fold change ≥ ±2.0). Of the protein coding transcripts, most of them were characterized as: enzymes, kinases, and transcriptional regulators with a large majority of activity in the cytoplasm, nucleus, and plasma membrane. Non-protein coding transcripts included biotypes such as long-non coding RNAs and pseudogenes. Gene ontology analysis and ingenuity pathway analysis revealed that differentially expressed transcripts were associated with integrin signaling, oxidative phosphorylation, protein phosphorylation, and actin cytoskeleton remodeling suggesting that these previously identified phagocytic pathways are under circadian control. Our analysis identified new pathways (e.g., increased mitochondrial respiration via increased oxidative phosphorylation) that may be involved in the circadian control of phagocytic activity. In addition, our dataset suggests a possible regulatory role for the identified non-protein coding transcripts in mediating the complex function of RPE phagocytosis. Finally, our results also indicate, as seen in other tissues, about 20% of the whole RPE transcriptome may be under circadian clock regulation.