Suppressor and cytolytic cell function in multiple sclerosis. Effects of cyclosporine A and interleukin 2

CD8(+) T-Cells as Immune Regulators of Multiple Sclerosis

The vast majority of studies regarding the immune basis of MS (and its animal model, EAE) have largely focused on CD4(+) T-cells as mediators and regulators of disease. Interestingly, CD8(+) T-cells represent the predominant T-cell population in human MS lesions and are oligoclonally expanded at the site of pathology. However, their role in the autoimmune pathologic process has been both understudied and controversial. Several animal models and MS patient studies support a pathogenic role for CNS-specific CD8(+) T-cells, whereas we and others have demonstrated a regulatory role for these cells in disease. In this review, we describe studies that have investigated the role of CD8(+) T-cells in MS and EAE, presenting evidence for both pathogenic and regulatory functions. In our studies, we have shown that cytotoxic/suppressor CD8(+) T-cells are CNS antigen-specific, MHC class I-restricted, IFNγ- and perforin-dependent, and are able to inhibit disease. The clinical relevance for CD8(+) T-cell suppressive function is best described by a lack of their function during MS relapse, and importantly, restoration of their suppressive function during quiescence. Furthermore, CD8(+) T-cells with immunosuppressive functions can be therapeutically induced in MS patients by glatiramer acetate (GA) treatment. Unlike CNS-specific CD8(+) T-cells, these immunosuppressive GA-induced CD8(+) T-cells appear to be HLA-E restricted. These studies have provided greater fundamental insight into the role of autoreactive as well as therapeutically induced CD8(+) T-cells in disease amelioration. The clinical implications for these findings are immense and we propose that this natural process can be harnessed toward the development of an effective immunotherapeutic strategy.

Immune regulation of multiple sclerosis by CD8+ T cells

The role of CD8+ T cells in the process of autoimmune pathology has been both understudied and controversial. Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an inflammatory, demyelinating disorder of the central nervous system (CNS) with underlying T cell-mediated immunopathology. CD8+ T cells are the predominant T cells in human MS lesions, showing oligoclonal expansion at the site of pathology. It is still unclear whether these cells represent pathogenic immune responses or disease-regulating elements. Through studies in human MS and its animal model, experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), we have discovered two novel CD8+ T cell populations that play an essential immunoregulatory role in disease: (1) MHC class Ia-restricted neuroantigen-specific "autoregulatory" CD8+ T cells and (2) glatiramer acetate (GA/Copaxone(®)) therapy-induced Qa-1/HLA-E-restricted GA-specific CD8+ T cells. These CD8+ Tregs suppress proliferation of pathogenic CD4+ CD25- T cells when stimulated by their cognate antigens. Similarly, CD8+ Tregs significantly suppress EAE when transferred either pre-disease induction or during peak disease. The mechanism of disease inhibition depends, at least in part, on an antigen-specific, contact-dependent process and works through modulation of CD4+ T cell responses as well as antigen-presenting cells through a combination of cytotoxicity and cytokine-mediated modulation. This review provides an overview of our understanding of CD8+ T cells in immune-mediated disease, focusing particularly on our findings regarding regulatory CD8+ T cells both in MS and in EAE. Clinical relevance of these novel CD8-regulatory populations is discussed, providing insights into a potentially intriguing, novel therapeutic strategy for these diseases.

Role of CD8 T cell subsets in the pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an immune-mediated disease of the central nervous system leading to demyelination and axonal/neuronal loss. Cumulating evidence points to a key role for CD8 T cells in this disabling disease. Oligoclonal CD8 T cells reside in demyelinating plaques where they are likely to contribute to tissue destruction. Histopathological analyses and compelling observations from animal models indicate that cytotoxic CD8 T cells target neural cell populations with the potential of causing lesions reminiscent of MS. However, CD8 T cell differentiation results in several subsets of effector CD8 T cells that could be differentially implicated in the mechanisms contributing to tissue damage. Moreover CD8 regulatory T cells arise as important populations involved in restoring immune homoeostasis and in maintaining immune privileged sites. Here we examine the current literature pertaining to the role of CD8 effector and regulatory T cell subsets in the pathogenesis of MS.

The role of CD8 suppressors versus destructors in autoimmune central nervous system inflammation

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an inflammatory demyelinating disease of the central nervous system (CNS) of putative autoimmune origin. Recent evidence indicates that MS autoimmunity is linked to defects in regulatory T-cell function, which normally regulates immune responses to self-antigens and prevents autoimmune diseases. MS and its animal model, experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), have long been regarded as a CD4(+) T-cell-mediated autoimmune disease. Studies addressing the role of CD8(+) T cells, however, have only recently begun to emerge. Pathogenic function was attributed to CD8(+) T cells because of their abundant presence or oligoclonal repertoire within MS lesions. However, CD8(+) T cells appeared to have important regulatory functions, as demonstrated in EAE or human MS studies. We here review the contribution of CD8(+) T cells to inflammation and immune regulation in CNS autoimmunity. The knowledge of distinct CD8(+) T-cell populations exerting destructive versus beneficial functions is summarized. The long-term goal is to delineate the exact phenotypic and functional characteristics of regulatory CD8(+) T-cell populations (natural as well as inducible) in humans. This knowledge may help to further develop concepts of reconstituting or enhancing endogenous mechanisms of immune tolerance in future therapeutic concepts for MS.

Isolation and characterization of CD8+ regulatory T cells in multiple sclerosis

To investigate CD8+ regulatory T cell influence on multiple sclerosis development, peripheral blood and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) CD8+ T cell clones (TCCs) recognizing MBP(83-102) and MOG(63-87)-specific CD4+ T cells were isolated from 20 patients during acute exacerbations, 15 in remission and 15 controls. Blood and CSF CD8+ regulatory TCC cloning frequency decreased more during exacerbations than remissions or controls. Target cell pre-activation significantly enhanced CD8+ T granule-mediated cell killing of CD4+ targets, and was restricted by HLA-E. During exacerbations, killer-inhibitory receptor CD94/NKG2A expression was significantly higher in CD8+ TCCs, limiting their cytotoxic activity. Moreover, IL-15 and IFN-gamma significantly increased CD94 and NKG2A expression. These data provide evidence that CD94/NKG2A receptors play an important role in regulating T cell activity during the course of MS.

Phenotypic and functional characteristics of activated CD8+ cells: a CD11b-CD28- subset mediates noncytolytic functional suppression

Freshly isolated human CD8+ cells can be divided into mutually exclusive subsets bearing the phenotypes CD11b+(CD28-) or CD28+(CD11b-). We found that activation of CD8+ cells with anti-CD3 mAb and IL-2 preferentially expanded the CD11b-(CD28+) subset. This subset, when separated and activated independently, mediated both functional suppression and lectin-dependent cell cytotoxicity (LDCC). CD28- cells, prepared by elimination of the CD 28+ cells from expanded unfractionated CD8+ cell cultures, retained functional suppressor activity but demonstrated reduced LDCC compared to either the CD28+(CD11b-)-enriched fraction or the unfractionated CD8+ population. The majority of the CD28- cells were also CD11b-, reflecting the observation that initially CD11b+ cells lose CD11b expression following activation with anti-CD3 mAb and IL-2. Our results therefore indicate that CD8+ cells deriving from the CD11b+CD28- subset, but expressing neither CD11b nor CD28 after activation, represent the main noncytotoxic functional suppressor cell in the mitogen "activated" suppressor assay. The preferential expansion of CD8+CD28+ cells relative to CD8+CD28- cells, if occurring in vivo in the central nervous system (CNS) compartment, would be consistent with observed phenotypic analysis of cerebrospinal fluid-derived T cells and might contribute to the reduced functional suppressor activity previously found for CNS compared to peripheral blood-derived lymphocytes.

CD21+ (B2 antigen+) cell decrement and CD4+CD29+ (helper-inducer) cell increment suggest an activation of cell immune reactivity in multiple sclerosis

Two-color flow cytometric analysis on peripheral blood lymphocytes of 35 untreated multiple sclerosis (MS) patients, 17 other medical disease (OMD) patients and 14 healthy control (HC) subjects was performed to evaluate the levels of different T and B cell subpopulations. In MS patients we observed an increase in CD4+CD29+ helper-inducer cells but this increase was not related to the different phases of the disease. We hypothesize that this change is related to the reduction of CD21+ cells expressing B2 antigen, a 140 kDa molecule disappearing after B cell activation. An increased level of CD4+CD45RA- (helper-inducer-like cells) and a reduction of CD4+CD29- (suppressor-inducer-like cells) were also present in our patients. These findings demonstrate an immune 'disequilibrium' in MS, which is linked with an increased level of CD25+ cells expressing the interleukin-2 (IL-2) receptor. IL-2, besides being a T cell growth factor, is also a B cell growth factor. These data let us hypothesize that an activation of the immune response is present in MS.

Serial studies of serum interleukin-2 in chronic progressive multiple sclerosis patients: occurrence of 'bursts' and effect of cyclosporine

Serum levels of immunoreactive interleukin-2 (IL-2) were determined at monthly intervals from a group of placebo- and drug-treated chronic progressive multiple sclerosis patients before and during a cyclosporine A therapeutic trial. Significantly elevated levels of the lymphokine in active patients confirmed earlier studies. The magnitude of the initial levels varied inversely with the duration of disease and predicted subsequent worsening in chronic progressive patients. In addition, the occurrence of periodic bursts of serum IL-2 was noted. Although in some patients there appeared to be a sudden drop in serum IL-2 levels with the onset of cyclosporine A medication, no effect of this drug was noted on group analysis.

Correlation of immunological studies and disease progression in chronic progressive multiple sclerosis

Thirty untreated patients with clinically definite chronic progressive multiple sclerosis were matched with 10 patients with clinically stable definite multiple sclerosis and 16 patients with other neurological diseases. A group of 12 normal control (NC) volunteers was matched to these groups. All patients with chronic progressive multiple sclerosis and normal control subjects were analyzed for the concanavalin A suppressor assay, mitogen stimulation, and phenotyping of peripheral blood mononuclear cells. In addition, serum was analyzed for interleukin-2 levels. Results of mitogen stimulation studies did not distinguish the groups. Concanavalin A-induced suppression was significantly decreased in the patients with chronic progressive multiple sclerosis (p less than 0.01). Phenotyping of fresh cells showed an elevated CD4: CD8 ratio in the patients with chronic progressive multiple sclerosis. Neither phenotyping nor concanavalin A-induced suppression correlated with or predicted the degree of disability, but the serum levels of interleukin-2 correlated inversely with disability (p less than 0.01) and directly with a poor prognosis after 18 months of observation (p less than 0.05). Serum levels of interleukin-2 decreased as the disease progressed.

Activated suppressor cell function in severely disabled patients with multiple sclerosis

Defective suppressor cell function has previously been demonstrated in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS) with progressive disease and moderate degrees of disability. In the present study activated suppressor cell function was assessed in patients with documented progressive disease who, at the time of study, had experienced severe disability (Kurtzke score greater than or equal to 6.5) for at least 2 years. We found that mean suppressor levels were significantly increased in this patient group compared with the suppressor levels in the MS patient group with progressive disease but only moderate disability (Kurtzke score of less than or equal to 6.0 within 2 years of study) (59 +/- 8% vs 19 +/- 7%, respectively, p less than 0.01). The mean value in the latter group was significantly reduced compared with the mean value for normal control subjects (47 +/- 4%, p less than 0.01), a finding consistent with previous reports. The results of this study indicate that suppressor cell function, as measured by our assay system, need not be defective in MS patients who have become severely disabled from the progressive form of the disease. Whether the patients who are now severely disabled from progressive MS passed through a phase of disease associated with the same suppressor defects as found in the progressive patients currently with moderate disability will remain speculative until long-term longitudinal studies are performed.

Hypertension in cyclosporine-treated renal transplant recipients is sodium dependent

PURPOSE

Physicians increasingly prescribe cyclosporine as an immunosuppressive agent for both organ-transplant and non-organ-transplant recipients. Investigators have reported a high incidence of drug-induced hypertension even when clinical nephrotoxicity was not present. We wanted to determine the reason.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A comparison was made of hypertension in 15 cyclosporine-treated transplant recipients with that in a similar group of 15 azathioprine-treated transplant recipients.

RESULTS

Hypertension in the cyclosporine group responded differently from that seen in the azathioprine group and from previously described forms of post-transplantation hypertension. Hypertensive cyclosporine-treated patients show a sodium acquisitive renal state that responds to sodium restriction. Unlike rat models, which suggest cyclosporine-induced stimulation of the renin-angiotensin system, or previous forms of post-transplant hypertension in humans, plasma renin levels were not elevated and blood pressure did not respond to a test dose of captopril.

CONCLUSION

Hypertension in cyclosporine-treated patients is an iatrogenic form of hypertension that may be associated with an early, subtle, renal defect in sodium excretion, a genesis of hypertension that is consistent with Guyton's view of essential hypertension.

Serial immune evaluation of cyclosporine- and placebo-treated multiple sclerosis patients

During an ongoing clinical trial of cyclosporine (CsA) immunosuppression therapy for chronic progressive multiple sclerosis (MS), a comparison was made of the immune responses of 18 CsA- and 18 placebo (P)-treated MS patients. Patients randomized to receive either CsA or P had identical entry immune profiles. However, these MS patients displayed significantly increased T-helper:T-suppressor (TH:TS) ratios (P less than 0.01), percentage (%) active-T (P less than 0.01), % Ia+-T (P less than 0.05) and % Ta1+-T (P less than 0.01) cell phenotypes when compared to age-matched normal controls. Further, the MS-P-treated patients displayed significant increases (all P less than 0.01) in % pan-T, % helper-T, % active-T and % Ta1+-T cell phenotypes as well as panel mixed lymphocyte culture (panel MLC) functional responsiveness from entry to cumulative 12-month study data. In contrast, the MS-CsA-treated patients only displayed an increased % pan-T cell phenotype. The cumulative 12-month follow-up data showed that the MS-P-treated patients displayed significantly higher immune parameters than the MS-CsA-treated patients for % pan-T (P less than 0.05), % helper-T (P less than 0.01), TH:TS ratio (P less than 0.05), % active-T (P less than 0.01), % Ta1+-T cells (P less than 0.01) and panel MLC stimulation index (P less than 0.01). Thus, MS-CsA-treated patients did not display the progressive immune activation seen on serial evaluation during the follow-up time period that characterized the placebo-treated MS group.