Minimally invasive, single-stage, multilevel surgery for obstructive sleep apnoea: A systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

Minimally invasive, single-staged multilevel surgery (MISS MLS) could be an optimal treatment for selected patients with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). We aim to systematically review the efficacy of MISS MLS for patients with OSA, as well as the clinical outcomes and possible complications in OSA patients before and after MISS MLS.

DESIGN AND SETTING

Systematic review and meta-analysis. Six databases were searched, and the PRISMA guideline was followed.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients with OSA receiving MISS MLS.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The random-effects model was adopted for the statistical synthesis. The percentage and 95% confidence interval (CI) were adopted as the effect measurements of MISS MLS for OSA. Subgroup analyses and sensitivity analyses were also performed to identify the heterogeneity among the studies.

RESULTS

There were initially 154 articles for identification. Eventually, six studies with a total of 848 OSA patients completely met the inclusion criteria and were further enrolled for analysis. The pooled analysis showed statistically significant lower AHI (apnea/hypopnea index, /hr.; mean difference: -8.931, 95% CI: -11.591 to -6.271, I2  = 87.4%), ESS (mean difference: -2.947, 95% CI: -4.465 to -1.429, I2  = 94.9%), and snoring severity with 0-10 visual analog scale after surgery (mean difference: -4.966, 95% CI: -5.804 to -4.128, I2  = 96.4%). The success rate was 46% in mild/moderate OSA; however, 18% in severe OSA. There were no major complications occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

The acceptable surgical outcomes, esp. in mild/moderate OSA, and rare complications are the major advantages of MISS MLS. The evidence of this study could aid the decision making in selecting suitable treatment programs for OSA patients.

International Consensus Statement on Obstructive Sleep Apnea

BACKGROUND

Evaluation and interpretation of the literature on obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) allows for consolidation and determination of the key factors important for clinical management of the adult OSA patient. Toward this goal, an international collaborative of multidisciplinary experts in sleep apnea evaluation and treatment have produced the International Consensus statement on Obstructive Sleep Apnea (ICS:OSA).

METHODS

Using previously defined methodology, focal topics in OSA were assigned as literature review (LR), evidence-based review (EBR), or evidence-based review with recommendations (EBR-R) formats. Each topic incorporated the available and relevant evidence which was summarized and graded on study quality. Each topic and section underwent iterative review and the ICS:OSA was created and reviewed by all authors for consensus.

RESULTS

The ICS:OSA addresses OSA syndrome definitions, pathophysiology, epidemiology, risk factors for disease, screening methods, diagnostic testing types, multiple treatment modalities, and effects of OSA treatment on multiple OSA-associated comorbidities. Specific focus on outcomes with positive airway pressure (PAP) and surgical treatments were evaluated.

CONCLUSION

This review of the literature consolidates the available knowledge and identifies the limitations of the current evidence on OSA. This effort aims to create a resource for OSA evidence-based practice and identify future research needs. Knowledge gaps and research opportunities include improving the metrics of OSA disease, determining the optimal OSA screening paradigms, developing strategies for PAP adherence and longitudinal care, enhancing selection of PAP alternatives and surgery, understanding health risk outcomes, and translating evidence into individualized approaches to therapy.

Optimal application of soft-palate webbing flap pharyngoplasty combined with nasal surgery for surgical treatment of primary snoring and obstructive sleep apnea

Background

Excessive collapse of the soft palate and lateral pharyngeal wall narrowing are established causes of loud snoring and sleep apnea in subjects with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). Therefore, delicate surgical techniques are needed to reshape the soft palate and create sufficient tension in the lateral pharyngeal wall. This study aimed to determine the therapeutic outcome and favorable indications of soft-palate webbing flap pharyngoplasty in subjects with OSA and primary snoring.

Methods

A total of 174 subjects who underwent soft-palate webbing flap pharyngoplasty combined with uvulopalatal flap and septoturbinoplasty from August 2015 to February 2020 were included in this study. Medical records, including pre- and postoperative sleep parameters, were retrospectively reviewed. The primary outcome measure was the degree of improvement in AHI after surgery. Other outcomes were differences in surgical response rates, subjective visual analog score (VAS) for snoring, sleep quality, and complications.

Results

Polysomnographic results showed that apnea–hypopnea index (AHI) scores were significantly reduced from 39.6 ± 6.1 to 22.9 ± 3.6 following soft-palate webbing flap pharyngoplasty in 59 subjects, and overall success and response rates of this technique were analyzed with 71%. We found that the successful outcomes were observed in 50% of mild (n = 12) and 56% of moderate (n = 16) subjects with OSA subjects due to lateral pharyngeal wall collapse. The success rate of soft-palate webbing flap pharyngoplasty was relatively higher in subjects with mild and moderate OSA than those with severe OSA. Additionally, the mean VAS snoring scale was 4.7 and subjects’ primary snoring intensity significantly improved to 2.9 after soft-palate webbing flap pharyngoplasty. Subjective symptoms such as daytime sleepiness and sleep quality also showed improvement. Most complications were found to be minimal and improved by 1 month after the operation.

Conclusion

Our data demonstrate that soft-palate webbing flap pharyngoplasty is an effective treatment for OSA and primary snoring and may be a promising technique to reduce lateral pharyngeal wall collapse.

Referral of adults with obstructive sleep apnea for surgical consultation: an American Academy of Sleep Medicine systematic review, meta-analysis, and GRADE assessment

INTRODUCTION

This systematic review provides supporting evidence for the accompanying clinical practice guideline on the referral of adults with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) for surgical consultation.

METHODS

The American Academy of Sleep Medicine commissioned a task force of experts in sleep medicine. A systematic review was conducted to identify studies that compared the use of upper airway sleep apnea surgery or bariatric surgery to no treatment as well as studies that reported on patient-important and physiologic outcomes pre- and postoperatively. Statistical analyses were performed to determine the clinical significance of using surgery to treat obstructive sleep apnea in adults. Finally, the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) process was used to assess the evidence for making recommendations.

RESULTS

The literature search resulted in 274 studies that provided data suitable for statistical analyses. The analyses demonstrated that surgery as a rescue therapy results in a clinically significant reduction in excessive sleepiness, snoring, blood pressure (BP), apnea-hypopnea index (AHI), respiratory disturbance index (RDI), and oxygen desaturation index (ODI); an increase in lowest oxygen saturation (LSAT) and sleep quality; and an improvement in quality of life in adults with OSA who are intolerant or unaccepting of positive airway pressure (PAP) therapy. The analyses demonstrated that surgery as an adjunctive therapy results in a clinically significant reduction in optimal PAP pressure and improvement in PAP adherence in adults with OSA who are intolerant or unaccepting of PAP due to side effects associated with high pressure requirements. The analyses also demonstrated that surgery as an initial treatment results in a clinically significant reduction in AHI/RDI, sleepiness, snoring, BP, and ODI and an increase in LSAT in adults with OSA and major anatomical obstruction. Analysis of bariatric surgery data showed a clinically significant reduction in BP, AHI/RDI, sleepiness, snoring, optimal PAP level, BMI, and ODI and an increase in LSAT in adults with OSA and obesity. Analyses of very limited evidence suggested that upper airway surgery does not result in a clinically significant increase in risk of serious persistent adverse events and suggested that bariatric surgery may result in a clinically significant risk of iron malabsorption that may be managed with iron supplements. The task force provided a detailed summary of the evidence along with the quality of evidence, the balance of benefits and harms, patient values and preferences, and resource use considerations.

CITATION

Kent D, Stanley J, Aurora RN, et al. Referral of adults with obstructive sleep apnea for surgical consultation: an American Academy of Sleep Medicine systematic review, meta-analysis, and GRADE assessment. J Clin Sleep Med. 2021;17(12):2507-2531.

Systematic review and updated meta-analysis of multi-level surgery for patients with OSA

OBJECTIVES

To perform an updated systematic review for determining the surgical success rate of multilevel upper airway surgery for patients with obstructive sleep apnea/hypopnea syndrome (OSA).

METHODS

A systematic review was performed to identify English-language studies that evaluated the treatment of adult OSA patients with multilevel OSA surgery up to January, 2018. We used polysomnography as a metric of treatment success. Articles were only included if the surgery intervention involved at least two of the frequently involved anatomic sites: nose, oropharynx and hypopharynx. Eighty-seven studies fit the inclusion criteria and a meta-analysis was performed to determine the overall success.

RESULTS

The meta-analysis included 3931 subjects with a mean age of 46.1 years. The originally reported success rate in the included literature was 59.9%. A meta-analysis was performed to redefine the success rate to be consistent with the commonly agreed upon criteria - namely "a reduction in apnea/hypopnea index (AHI, /hr.) of 50% or more and an AHI of less than 20". The recalculated success rate was 60.2%. Standard meta-analytic techniques for combining p-values between studies after weighting for sample size found significant improvements in AHI, apnea index, % of rapid eye movement sleep, lowest saturation of oxygen (%), and Epworth Sleepiness Scale.

CONCLUSION

This study shows the significant improvement of treatment outcomes with multilevel surgery for OSA patients.

Change in Quality of Life of OSAHS Patients with Minimally Invasive Surgery or CPAP Therapy: A 2-year Retrospective, Single-center Parallel-group Study

BACKGROUND

By including untreated obstructive sleep apnea-hypopnea syndrome (OSAHS) patients as the control group, this study explores the influence of minimally invasive surgical treatment and continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) therapy on OSAHS patients, with the subjective and objective performance. The study also discusses their relationship, determines the effect factor, and provides a simple and practical method for evaluation of clinical efficacy.

METHODS

A total of 90 OSAHS patients, who were diagnosed in the Sleep Disorders Diagnosis and Treatment Center of Sichuan Province from May 2014 to May 2016, were selected for the present study. These patients were divided into three groups: surgery group, CPAP group, and untreated group. These patients were followed up at six months, one year, and two years, respectively. The physiological indicators, clinical symptoms, degree of daytime sleepiness and quality of life were compared among these three groups. The daytime sleepiness and the quality of life before and after minimally invasive surgery and CPAP treatment were evaluated, and the subjective and objective efficacy of surgery and CPAP treatment was explored.

RESULTS

Among these 90 patients, 11 (12.2%) patients had hypertension, while two (2.2%) patients had diabetes. The average AHI score was 50.53±23.39 per hour, and the mean minimum oxygen saturation and mean oxygen saturation was 71.25±14.16% and 90.13±5.90%, respectively. There were statistically significant differences in mouth breathing, morning sore throat and daytime sleepiness in the group having received surgery at 0.5 year and one year. In the CPAP group, there were statistically significant differences in mouth breathing, morning sore throat and daytime sleepiness at 0.5 year, one year and two years. Moreover, there were statistically significant differences in memory loss at one year and two years, and there were statistically significant differences in frequent nocturia at one year. The ESS value in the surgery group decreased at 0.5 year and one year, but increased at two years. The situation was the same in terms of the total points and in each dimension of the SF-36 paramter. The delta values of ESS among the three groups had statistical significance at 0.5 year, one year and two years, in which the CPAP group experienced the most changes, followed by the surgery group and the group received health education.

CONCLUSION

For minimally invasive surgery, CPAP therapy and health education can improve daytime sleepiness and quality of life. CPAP therapy was found to be the most effective, followed by minimally invasive surgery and provision of health education. However, the treatment of OSAHS should be comprehensive.

Indications for and Outcomes of Expansion Sphincter Pharyngoplasty to Treat Lateral Pharyngeal Collapse in Patients With Obstructive Sleep Apnea

Importance

The lateral pharyngeal wall is recognized as an important site of upper airway collapse during sleep in patients with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), and expansion sphincter pharyngoplasty (ESP) may have promising clinical utility in patients with OSA and lateral pharyngeal wall collapse.

Objectives

To evaluate the therapeutic outcomes of ESP in conjunction with other surgical procedures and to investigate indications for ESP in patients with OSA.

Design, Setting, and Participants

Cohort study of 63 patients with OSA diagnosed with lateral pharyngeal collapse under drug-induced sleep endoscopy who underwent ESP combined with tonsillectomy, uvuloplasty, or nasal surgery at Seoul National University Hospital in Seoul, Korea, between March 1, 2015, and December 1, 2016.

Main Outcomes and Measures

The primary outcome measure was the change in the apnea-hypopnea index (AHI) after surgery (AHI represents the number of apnea-hypopnea events per hour). Other outcome measures were differences in the surgical response rates, lowest oxygen saturation, subjective visual analog scale scores for snoring and apnea, and Epworth Sleepiness Scale score.

Results

Fifty of the 63 patients (79%) were male; the mean age was 42.1 (range, 20-54) years, and the mean body mass index (calculated as weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared) was 27.6 (range, 19.0-32.1). Expansion sphincter pharyngoplasty was performed in patients with OSA with an AHI greater than 15 events per hour, more than 75% retropalatal circumferential narrowing when awake, and narrowed oropharynx due to bulky soft tissue around the lateral pharyngeal wall. In 42 of the 63 patients (67%), ESP was objectively successful in correcting lateral pharyngeal collapse; there was a significant reduction in mean AHI from 35.5 to 17.3 (mean difference, 18.1; 95% CI, 16.3-20.0) and improvement of the lowest mean (SD) oxygen saturation measurement from 78.2% (21.3%) to 86.4% (10.6%) (mean difference, 8.60%; 95% CI, 6.60%-10.60%) 6 months after the operation. The rate of postoperative complications, including pain and bleeding, was minimal after ESP, and a few patients reported an abnormal sensation around the soft palate and swallowing difficulty after ESP.

Conclusions and Relevance

Expansion sphincter pharyngoplasty appears to be a promising surgical technique to reduce lateral pharyngeal collapse in patients with moderate or severe OSA. Clinical data suggest that both severe palatal circumferential narrowing and bulky lateral pharyngeal tissue are favorable surgical indications for ESP in patients with OSA.

The clinical efficacy of relocation pharyngoplasty to improve retropalatal circumferential narrowing in obstructive sleep apnea patients

Lateral pharyngeal wall appears to be a critical culprit of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) subjects and relocation pharyngoplasty has been expected to be a promising surgical option to correct retropalatal circumferential narrowing in OSA patients. The purpose of our study is to evaluate the therapeutic outcomes of relocation pharyngoplasty and its clinical effectiveness in OSA patients with retropalatal circumferential narrowing. We performed relocation pharyngoplasty combined with nasal surgery in 133 OSA patients with the following characteristics: apnea-hypopnea index (AHI) over 10, retropalatal circumferential narrowing greater than grade I when awake, and redundant soft tissue around the lateral pharyngeal wall. The analysis of surgical success rate was performed with the data of 68 subjects who underwent pre and postoperative polysomnography. The objective success rate of relocation pharyngoplasty was 52.9%, and significant reduction of mean AHI with improvement of lowest SpO2 was seen in 69% of patients 3 months after the surgery. The median AHI was decreased from preoperative 37.3 to postoperative 21.4. Median lowest SpO2 changed from 78.4 to 84.1%. Total sleep time, daytime sleepiness, and visual analogue scale for snoring showed improvement as well. Postoperative complications including pain or bleeding were minimal in 133 subjects and a few patients complained of subtle taste loss. Our data demonstrate that relocation pharyngoplasty can be a favorable surgical option fighting against retropalatal circumferential narrowing.

Robot-assisted Tongue Base Resection ensures favorable therapeutic outcome to Obstructive Sleep Apnea patients with Lingual tonsil hypertrophy

Tongue base (TB) narrowing is recognized as a significant site of upper airway collapse during sleep in obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) patients and robot technology is expected to have promising clinical utility in OSA patients with TB narrowing. The purpose of our study is to demonstrate the better therapeutic conditions and favorable indications of robot-assisted TB resection (TBR) in OSA. We performed robot-assisted TBR combined with nasal and palatal surgery in 16 OSA patients with any of the following characteristics: severe TB narrowing (over grade II) and moderate or severe OSA. The preoperative median AHI was 48.8/hr and the median lowest SaO₂ was 82.0%. The median AHI decreased to 18.7/hr and ten patients (62.5%) were included in the responder group following robot-assisted TBR combined with nasal and palatal surgery. The lowest SaO₂ improved to 90.5% and the posterior airway space (PAS) was significantly increased following robot-assisted TBR. Cephalometric results showed that wider PAS were observed in responders compared to non-responders prior to robot-assisted TBR. Interestingly, there was greater improvement in the objective parameters including PAS in the OSA patients with lingual tonsilar hypertrophy than they were in those without and all patients with lingual tonsillar hypertrophy (n = 6) responded to robot-assisted TBR. Robot-assisted TBR exhibited minimal morbidity and postoperative complications in OSA patients. Robot-assisted TBR can be considered a promising and innovative surgical option to reduce TB volume and improve sleep parameters in OSA patients with TB narrowing. OSA patient with TB narrowing due to lingual tonsil hypertrophy shows greater therapeutic outcome and lingual tonsil hypertrophy appears to be most favorable surgical indications of robot-assisted TBR.