Hibernated human fetal striatal tissue: successful transplantation in a rat model of Huntington's disease

Derivation of Neural Stem Cells from the Developing and Adult Human Brain

Neural stem cells isolated from the developing and adult brain are an ideal source of cells for use in clinical applications such as cell replacement therapy. The clear advantage of these cells over the more commonly utilised embryonic and pluripotent stem cells is that they are already neurally committed. Of particular importance is the fact that these cells don't require the same level of in vitro culture that can be cost and labour intensive. Foetal neural stem cells can be readily derived from the foetal brain and expand in culture over time. Similarly, adult stem cells have been explored for their potential in vitro and in vivo animal models. In this chapter we identify the progress made in developing these cells as well as the advantages of taking them forward for clinical use.

Dissection and Preparation of Human Primary Fetal Ganglionic Eminence Tissue for Research and Clinical Applications

Here, we describe detailed dissection and enzymatic dissociation protocols for the ganglionic eminences from the developing human brain to generate viable quasi-single cell suspensions for subsequent use in transplantation or cell culture. These reliable and reproducible protocols can provide tissue for use in the study of the developing human brain, as well as for the preparation of donor cells for transplantation in Huntington's disease (HD). For use in the clinic as a therapy for HD, the translation of these protocols from the research laboratory to the GMP suite is described, including modification to reagents used and appropriate monitoring and tissue release criteria.

Neural Transplantation in Huntington's Disease: The NEST-UK Donor Tissue Microbiological Screening Program and Review of the Literature

Neural transplantation of human fetal tissue for Huntington's disease (HD) is now entering the clinical arena. The safety of the procedure has now been demonstrated in a number of studies, although the efficacy of such an approach is still being investigated. Stringent but practicable screening of the donor tissue for potential pathogens is an essential prerequisite for successful implementation of any novel transplant program that uses human fetal tissue. In this article we summarize the UK-NEST protocol for the screening of human fetal tissue being grafted to patients with mild to moderate HD. We describe the results of microbiological screening of 87 potential tissue donors in a pilot study, and of the first four donor–recipient patients included in the UK-NEST series. The rationale for the adoption and interpretation of the various tests is described and our methodology is compared with those previously used by other centers. This article therefore presents a comprehensive, logical yet pragmatic screening program that could be employed in any clinical studies that use human fetal tissue for neurotransplantation.

Is there a place for human fetal-derived stem cells for cell replacement therapy in Huntington's disease?

Huntington's disease (HD) is a neurodegenerative disease that offers an excellent paradigm for cell replacement therapy because of the associated relatively focal cell loss in the striatum. The predominant cells lost in this condition are striatal medium spiny neurons (MSNs). Transplantation of developing MSNs taken from the fetal brain has provided proof of concept that donor MSNs can survive, integrate and bring about a degree of functional recovery in both pre-clinical studies and in a limited number of clinical trials. The scarcity of human fetal tissue, and the logistics of coordinating collection and dissection of tissue with neurosurgical procedures makes the use of fetal tissue for this purpose both complex and limiting. Alternative donor cell sources which are expandable in culture prior to transplantation are currently being sought. Two potential donor cell sources which have received most attention recently are embryonic stem (ES) cells and adult induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells, both of which can be directed to MSN-like fates, although achieving a genuine MSN fate has proven to be difficult. All potential donor sources have challenges in terms of their clinical application for regenerative medicine, and thus it is important to continue exploring a wide variety of expandable cells. In this review we discuss two less well-reported potential donor cell sources; embryonic germ (EG) cells and fetal neural precursors (FNPs), both are which are fetal-derived and have some properties that could make them useful for regenerative medicine applications.

Insights in spatio-temporal characterization of human fetal neural stem cells

Primary human fetal cells have been used in clinical trials of cell replacement therapy for the treatment of neurodegenerative disorders such as Huntington's disease (HD). However, human fetal primary cells are scarce and difficult to work with and so a renewable source of cells is sought. Human fetal neural stem cells (hfNSCs) can be generated from human fetal tissue, but little is known about the differences between hfNSCs obtained from different developmental stages and brain areas. In the present work we characterized hfNSCs, grown as neurospheres, obtained from three developmental stages: 4-5, 6-7 and 8-9weeks post conception (wpc) and four brain areas: forebrain, cortex, whole ganglionic eminence (WGE) and cerebellum. We observed that, as fetal brain development proceeds, the number of neural precursors is diminished and post-mitotic cells are increased. In turn, primary cells obtained from older embryos are more sensitive to the dissociation process, their viability is diminished and they present lower proliferation ratios compared to younger embryos. However, independently of the developmental stage of derivation proliferation ratios were very low in all cases. Improvements in the expansion rates were achieved by mechanical, instead of enzymatic, dissociation of neurospheres but not by changes in the seeding densities. Regardless of the developmental stage, neurosphere cultures presented large variability in the viability and proliferation rates during the initial 3-4 passages, but stabilized achieving significant expansion rates at passage 5 to 6. This was true also for all brain regions except cerebellar derived cultures that did not expand. Interestingly, the brain region of hfNSC derivation influences the expansion potential, being forebrain, cortex and WGE derived cells the most expandable compared to cerebellar. Short term expansion partially compromised the regional identity of cortical but not WGE cultures. Nevertheless, both expanded cultures were multipotent and kept the ability to differentiate to region specific mature neuronal phenotypes.

Neonatal desensitization for the study of regenerative medicine

Cell replacement is a therapeutic option for numerous diseases of the CNS. Current research has identified a number of potential human donor cell types, for which preclinical testing through xenotransplantation in animal models is imperative. Immune modulation is necessary to promote donor cell survival for sufficient time to assess safety and efficacy. Neonatal desensitization can promote survival of human donor cells in adult rat hosts with little impact on the health of the host and for substantially longer than conventional methods, and has subsequently been applied in a range of studies with variable outcomes. Reviewing these findings may provide insight into the method and its potential for use in preclinical studies in regenerative medicine.

Producing striatal phenotypes for transplantation in Huntington's disease

Neural transplantation as a therapeutic strategy in neurodegenerative disorders offers to replace cells lost during the disease process, with the potential to reconstruct dysfunctional circuitry, thus alleviating associated disease symptoms. The focal loss of striatal cells, specifically medium-sized spiny neurons (MSN) in Huntington's disease (HD), makes transplantation a therapeutic option. Here, we review the progress made in generating striatal MSN phenotypes for transplantation in HD. We discuss the use of primary fetal tissue as a donor source in both preclinical and clinical studies and assess the options for renewable cell sources. We evaluate progress in directing the differentiation of renewable cells towards a striatal MSN phenotype for HD.

Clinical trials of neural transplantation in Huntington's disease

Clinical neural transplantation in Huntington's disease has moved forward as a series of small studies, which have provided some preliminary proof of principle that neural transplantation can provide benefit. However, to date, such benefits have not been robust, and there are a number of important issues that need to be addressed. These include defining the optimum donor tissue conditions and host characteristics in order to produce reliable benefit in transplant recipients, and whether, and for how long, immunosuppression is needed. Further clinical studies will be required to address these, and other issues, in order to better understand the processes leading to a properly functioning neural graft. Such studies will pave the way for future clinical trials of renewable donor sources, in particular, stem cell-derived neuronal progenitor grafts.

Medical Terminations of Pregnancy: A Viable Source of Tissue for Cell Replacement Therapy for Neurodegenerative Disorders

“Proof-of-principle” that cell replacement therapy works for neurodegeneration has been reported, but only using donor cells collected from fetal brain tissue obtained from surgical terminations of pregnancy. Surgical terminations of pregnancy represent an increasingly limited supply of donor cells due to the tendency towards performing medical termination in much of Europe. This imposes a severe constraint on further experimental and clinical cell transplantation research. Therefore, we explore here the feasibility of using medical termination tissue as a donor source. Products of conception were retrieved from surgical terminations over the last 7 years and from medical terminations over the last 2.5 years. The number of collections that yielded fetal tissue, viable brain tissue, and identifiable brain regions (ganglionic eminence, ventral mesencephalon, and neocortex) were recorded. We studied cell viability, cell physiological properties, and differentiation potential both in vitro and following transplantation into the central nervous system of rodent models of neurodegenerative disease. Within equivalent periods, we were able to collect substantially greater numbers of fetal remains from medical than from surgical terminations of pregnancy, and the medical terminations yielded a much higher proportion of identifiable and dissectible brain tissue. Furthermore, we demonstrate that harvested cells retain the capacity to differentiate into neurons with characteristics appropriate to the region from which they are dissected. We show that, contrary to widespread assumption, medical termination of pregnancy-derived fetal brain cells represent a feasible and more readily available source of human fetal tissue for experimental cell transplantation with the potential for use in future clinical trials in human neurodegenerative disease.

Cell transplantation for Huntington’s disease: practical and clinical considerations

Huntington’s disease is a dominantly inherited neurodegenerative disorder, usually starting in mid-life and leading to progressive disability and early death. There are currently no disease-modifying treatments available. Cell transplantation is being considered as a potential therapy, following proof of principle that cell transplantation can improve outcomes in another basal ganglia disorder, namely Parkinson’s disease. The principle aim is to replace the striatal medium spiny neurons lost in Huntington’s disease with new cells that are able to take over their function and reconnect the circuitry. This article reviews the experimental background and evidence from clinical studies that suggest that cell transplantation may improve function in Huntington’s disease, reviews the current status of the field and considers the current challenges to taking this experimental strategy forward to becoming a reliable therapeutic option.

[Biotherapies and Parkinson's disease]

In the last years, several experimental biotherapies have been developed to treat Parkinson's disease. Initially, fetal dopaminergic transplants were proposed. Although a proof of concept and encouraging results have been provided, limitations of this treatment emerged over the years and the failure of controlled trials have conducted to a pause in the development of strategies based on fetal cells. Alternative approaches such as the use of retinal pigmented cells recently provided disappointing results in patients and much hope has now been reported on other sources of dopaminergic neurons such as those originating from stem cells. This strategy is however not yet ready for clinical trials in patients. Eventually, gene therapy is a new original experimental technique which has elicited several trials in the last few years some of them being promising.

Cell therapy in Huntington disease

Huntington disease (HD), caused by polyglutamate expansions in the huntingtin protein, is a progressive neurodegenerative disease resulting in cognitive and motor impairments and death. Neuronal dysfunction and degeneration contribute to progressive physiological, motor, cognitive, and emotional disturbances characteristic of HD. A major impetus for research into the treatment of HD has centered on cell therapy strategies to protect vulnerable neuronal cell populations or to replace dysfunctional or dying cells. The work underlying 3 approaches to HD cell therapy includes the potential for self-repair through the manipulation of endogenous stem cells and/or neurogenesis, the use of fetal or stem cell transplantation as a cell replacement strategy, and the administration of neurotrophic factors to protect susceptible neuronal populations. These approaches have shown some promising results in animal models of HD. Although striatal transplantation of fetal-derived cells has undergone clinical assessment since the 1990s, many cell therapy strategies have yet to be applied in the clinic environment. A more thorough understanding of the pathophysiologies underlying HD as well as the response of both endogenous and exogenous cells to the degenerating brain will inform their merit as potential therapeutic agents and enhance the framework by which the success of such strategies are determined.

Aging and neurodegeneration. Molecular mechanisms of neuronal loss in Huntington's disease

Huntington's disease (HD) is a fatal, genetically based late-onset neurodegenerative disorder in which a loss of neostriatal neurons is a main characteristic. The CAG trinucleotide repeat expansion encoding polyglutamine tract induces progressive deficits in intra- and inter-cellular signalling, and subsequent clinical signs developed with aging process. CAG-induced neurodegeneration and disease-onset shows aging-dependent pattern. Proposed mechanism of neurodegeneration includes intranuclear or intracellular protein aggregates, proteolytic cleavage of huntingtin (cf. caspase, calpain), altered transcription or other neurotransmitter signalling deficits. Recently, stem cell transplantation is of benefit to protect neurons against neurodegeneration and recover the functional deficit in the experimental HD model. This review focuses on current knowledge of molecular mechanisms in neurodegeneration and potential therapeutic targets in HD.

Pharmaceutical, cellular and genetic therapies for Huntington's disease

HD (Huntington's disease) is a devastating neurodegenerative disorder caused by a polyglutamine expansion in the gene encoding the huntingtin protein. Presently, there is no known cure for HD and existing symptomatic treatments are limited. However, recent advances have identified multiple pathological mechanisms involved in HD, some of which have now become the focus of therapeutic intervention. In this review, we consider progress made towards developing safe and effective pharmaceutical-, cell- and genetic-based therapies, and discuss the extent to which some of these therapies have been successfully translated into clinical trials. These new prospects offer hope for delaying and possibly halting this debilitating disease.

Intravenous administration of human neural stem cells induces functional recovery in Huntington's disease rat model

An animal model induced by striatal quinolinic acid (QA) injection shows ongoing striatal degeneration mimicking Huntington's disease. To study the migratory ability and the neuroprotective effect of human neural stem cells (NSCs) in this model, we transplanted NSCs (5 x 10(6)) or saline intravenously at 7 days after unilateral QA injection. NSCs-group exhibited the reduced apomorphine-induced rotation and the reduced striatal atrophy compared to the control. PCR analysis for the human-specific ERV-3 gene supported an evidence of the engraftment of human NSCs in the rat brain. X-gal+ cells were found in and around the damaged striatum and migrated NSCs differentiated into neurons and glias. This result indicates that intravenously injected human NSCs can migrate into the striatal lesion, decrease the following striatal atrophy, and induce long-term functional improvement in a glutamate toxicity-induced striatal degeneration model.

Cell therapy in Huntington's disease

Huntington's disease is an autosomal dominant genetic disease, which results in progressive neuronal degeneration in the neostriatum and neocortex, and associated functional impairments in motor, cognitive, and psychiatric domains. Although the genetic mutation is identified, involving an abnormal CAG expansion within the htt gene on chromosome 4, the mechanism by which this leads to neuronal cell death and the question of why striatal neurones are targeted both remain unknown. Thus, in addition to the search for molecular and genetic strategies to inhibit development of the disease, we still need to identify effective strategies for cellular repair in affected individuals. Aspects of the human neuropathology can be well modeled by excitotoxic or metabolic lesions in experimental animals, and in transgenic mice carrying the htt mutation, providing the basis for testing alternative therapeutic strategies. The rationale and efficacy of alternative cell therapies are reviewed, including transplantation repair with embryonic striatal tissues, expansion and differentiation of striatal-like cells from stem cells, and in vivo and ex vivo gene therapy for delivery of neuroprotective growth factor molecules. Pilot and experimental clinical trials of several approaches are now also underway, and the alternative strategies are compared.

Is there a future for neural transplantation?

Traditionally neural transplantation has had as its central tenet the replacement of missing neurons that have been lost because of neurodegenerative processes, as exemplified by diseases such as Parkinson disease (PD). However, the effectiveness and widespread application of this approach clinically has been limited, primarily because of the poor donor supply of human fetal neural tissue and the incomplete neurobiological understanding of the circuit reconstruction required to normalize function in these diseases. So, in PD the progress from promising neural transplantation in animal models to proof-of-principle, open-labeled clinical transplants, to randomized, placebo-controlled studies of neural transplantation has not been straightforward. The emergence of previously undescribed adverse effects and lack of significant functional advantage in recent clinical studies has been disappointing and has served to cast a new, and perhaps more realistic, perspective on this treatment approach. In fact, there have been calls by some involved in neural transplantation to return to the drawing board before pressing on with further clinical trials, and the return to basic experimentation. This therefore precipitates the question - is there a future for neural transplantation? It is important to remember that there are a number of possible explanations for the disappointing results from the recent clinical trials in PD, ranging from the mode of transplantation to patient selection. Nevertheless, almost irrespective of these reasons for the current trial results, there have always been significant practical and ethical problems with using human fetal tissue, and so a number of alternative cell sources have been investigated. These alternative sources include stem cells, which are attractive for cell-based therapies because of their potential ease of isolation, propagation and manipulation, and their ability in some cases to migrate to areas of pathology and differentiate into specific and appropriate cell types. Furthermore, the availability of stem cells derived from non-embryonic sources (e.g. adult stem cells derived from the sub-ventricular zone) has removed some of the ethical limitations associated with the use of embryonic human tissue. These potentially beneficial aspects of stem cells means that there is a future for neural transplantation as a means of treating patients with a range of neurological disorders, although whether this will ever translate into a truly effective, widely available therapy remains unknown.

Long-term hibernation of human fetal striatal tissue does not adversely affect its differentiation in vitro or graft survival: implications for clinical trials in Huntington's disease

Transplantation of human fetal CNS tissue is a promising therapy for neurodegenerative conditions such as Huntington's disease (HD), but its widespread adoption is limited by restricted tissue availability. One method of overcoming this problem would be to store the tissue in hibernation medium, an approach that we reported previously for human fetal striatal tissue stored for up to 24 h. We now demonstrate the feasibility of storing such tissue for up to 8 days in hibernation medium. When either fresh or 8-day hibernated striatal cells were cultured under standard conditions for 4 days, the proportion of DARPP-32-positive neurons did not differ significantly, although the total number of cells was significantly less from tissue that had been hibernated. Six weeks after transplantation into cyclosporin A-immunosuppressed unilateral quinolinic acid-lesioned rats, there was no significant difference between fresh and hibernated grafts, both in terms of graft volume and extent of striatal phenotypic markers. This study therefore clearly demonstrates that hibernation of human fetal striatal tissue for up to 8 days is not deleterious to its differentiation in culture or survival following transplantation, and is therefore an appropriate method of storage for this tissue.

Staging and preparation of human fetal striatal tissue for neural transplantation in Huntington's disease

Transplantation of human fetal central nervous system tissue has been shown to be of benefit in Parkinson's disease, and is currently being explored as a therapeutic option in Huntington's disease. The success of a neural transplant is dependent on a number of factors, including the requirement that donor cells are harvested within a given developmental window and that the cell preparation protocols take account of the biological parameters identified in animal models. Although many of the criteria necessary for a successful neural transplant have been defined in animal models, ultimately they must be validated in human studies, and some issues can only ever be addressed in human studies. Furthermore, because neural transplantation of human fetal tissue is limited to small numbers of patients in any one surgical center, largely due to practical constraints, it is crucial that tissue preparation protocols are clearly defined and reproducible, so that (i) multicenter trials are possible and are based on consistent tissue preparation parameters, and (ii) results between centers can be meaningfully analyzed. Here we describe the preparation of human fetal striatum for neural transplantation in Huntington's disease, and report on the validation of a method for estimating the developmental stage of the fetus based on direct morphometric measurements of the embryonic tissue.

Neural transplantation in patients with Huntington's disease

The gene for Huntington's disease was identified in 1993 as being a CAG repeat expansion in exon 1 of a gene now known as huntingtin on chromosome 4. Although many of the downstream effects of this mutant gene were identified in the subsequent years, a more detailed understanding of these events will be necessary in order to design specific interventions to interfere with the disease process and slow disease progression. In parallel, a number of groups have been investigating alternative approaches to treatment of Huntington's disease, including cell and tissue transplantation. As the brunt of cell dysfunction and loss is borne by the striatum, at least in the early to mid-stages of disease, the goal is to identify methods for replacing lost cells with fetal neuroblasts that can develop, integrate into the host circuitry and thereby restore lost function. Clinical studies in which primary fetal neuroblasts were transplanted into the brains of patients with advanced Parkinson's disease have demonstrated benefit when the transplant methodology closely follows the biological principles established in animal experiments. On the basis of demonstrated benefit following striatal cell transplantation in animal models of Huntington's disease, a small number of studies have now commenced in patients with Huntington's disease. To date, these clinical studies have demonstrated the feasibility and safety of transplantation in this condition, but it will require several more years yet before the efficacy of the procedure can be confidently established.

Identification of human cells in brain xenografts and in neural co-cultures of rat by in situ hybridisation with Alu probe

Transplantation of human cells into animal models of neurodegenerative disorders is an important scientific application to analyse the survival and developmental capacity of grafted human cells under in vivo conditions. It is critical, therefore, to have a reliable method to distinguish between human and animal cells. In the present study, we describe a combined in situ hybridisation and immunocytochemistry method for the identification of human cells in cultured rat brain cells and xenografts. The specific Alu probe we utilised, which corresponds to the consensus sequence of human Alu repeats was evaluated by southern blot hybridisation of zoo blot and by in situ hybridisation of primary and neoplastic cells from man, rat, mouse, and hamster. This method allows a definite identification of human cells in neural xenografts and, in combination with additional in situ techniques, a further detection of grafted cells.

Unilateral transplantation of human primary fetal tissue in four patients with Huntington's disease: NEST-UK safety report ISRCTN no 36485475

OBJECTIVES

Huntington's disease (HD) is an inherited autosomal dominant condition in which there is a CAG repeat expansion in the huntingtin gene of 36 or more. Patients display progressive motor, cognitive, and behavioural deterioration associated with progressive cell loss and atrophy in the striatum. Currently there are no disease modifying treatments and current symptomatic treatments are only partially effective in the early to moderate stages. Neural transplantation is effective in animal models of HD and offers a potential strategy for brain repair in patients. The authors report a safety study of unilateral transplantation of human fetal striatal tissue into the striatum of four patients with HD.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Stereotaxic placements of cell suspensions of human fetal ganglionic eminence were made unilaterally into the striatum of four patients with early to moderate HD. All patients received immunotherapy with cyclosporin A, azathioprine, and prednisolone for at least six months postoperatively. Patients were assessed for safety of the procedure using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), regular recording of serum biochemistry and haematology to monitor immunotherapy, and clinical assessment according to the Core Assessment Protocol For Intrastriatal Transplantation in HD (CAPIT-HD).

RESULTS

During the six month post-transplantation period, the only adverse events related to the procedure were associated with the immunotherapy. MRI demonstrated tissue at the site of implantation, but there was no sign of tissue overgrowth. Furthermore, there was no evidence that the procedure accelerated the course of the disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Unilateral transplantation of human fetal striatal tissue in patients with HD is safe and feasible. Assessment of efficacy will require longer follow up in a larger number of patients.