Animal models of anxiety

Animal models for anxiety-related behavior are based on the assumption that anxiety in animals is comparable to anxiety in humans. Being anxious is an adaptive response to an unfamiliar environment, especially when confronted with danger or threat. However, pathological variants of anxiety can strongly impede the daily life of those affected. To unravel neurobiological mechanisms underlying normal anxiety as well as its pathologi- cal variations, animal models are indispensable tools. What are the characteristics of an ideal animal model? First, it should display reduced anxiety when treated with anxiolytics (predictive validity). Second, the behavioral response of an animal model to a threatening stimulus should be comparable to the response known for humans (face validity). And third, the mechanisms underlying anxiety as well as the psychological causes should be identical (construct validity). Meeting these three requirements is difficult for any animal model. Since both the physiological and the behavioral response to aversive (threatening) stimuli are similar in humans and animals, it can be assumed that animal models can serve at least two distinct purposes: as (1) behavioral tests to screen for potential anxiolytic and antidepressant effects of new drugs and (2) tools to investigate specific pathogenetic aspects of cardinal symptoms of anxiety disorders. The examples presented in this chapter have been selected to illustrate the potential as well as the caveats of current models and the emerging possibilities offered by gene technology. The main concepts in generating animal models for anxiety-that is, selective breeding of rat lines, experience-related models, genetically engineered mice, and phenotype-driven approaches-are concisely introduced and discussed. Independent of the animal model used, one major challenge remains, which is to reliably identify animal behavioral characteristics. Therefore, a description of behavioral expressions of anxiety in rodents as well as tests assays to measure anxiety-related behavior in these animals is also included in this chapter.

Listening to mutant mice: a spotlight on the role of CRF/CRF receptor systems in affective disorders

Genetically engineered mice were originally generated to delineate the role of a specific gene product in behavioral or neuroendocrine phenotypes, rather than to produce classic animal models of depression. To learn more about the neurobiological mechanisms underlying a clinical condition such as depression, it has proven worthwhile to investigate changes in behaviors characteristic of depressed humans, such as anxiety, regardless of whether or not these alterations may also occur in other disorders besides depression. The majority of patients with mood and anxiety disorders have measurable shifts in their stress hormone regulation as reflected by elevated secretion of central and peripheral stress hormones or by altered hormonal responses to neuroendocrine challenge tests. In recent years, these alterations have been increasingly translated into testable hypotheses addressing the pathogenesis of illness. Refined molecular technologies and the creation of genetically engineered mice have allowed to specifically target individual genes involved in regulation of corticotropin releasing factor (CRF) system elements (e.g. CRF and CRF-related peptides, their receptors, binding protein). Studies performed in such mice have complemented and extended our knowledge. The cumulative evidence makes a strong case implicating dysfunction of these systems in the pathogenesis of depression and leads us beyond the monoaminergic synapse in search of eagerly anticipated strategies to discover and develop better therapies for depression.

Behavioural screening in mutagenised mice—in search for novel animal models of psychiatric disorders

Complementary to the 'gene-driven' analysis of gene function, 'phenotype-driven' approaches can be performed and may be equally important. Despite the current availability of a long list of mouse mutants, there remains an appreciable need for behavioural phenotypes in mouse models permitting to learn more about the aetiology of psychiatric disorders. This lack can be compensated by phenotype-driven ethyl-nitrosourea (ENU)-mutagenesis programs which aim at identifying novel phenotypes without any a priori assumptions, thus, representing a unique possibility to create novel animal models which approximate the underlying genetic aetiology. The power of mouse mutagenesis critically depends on the phenotyping procedures performed. In the case of ENU-mutants, behavioural phenotyping is especially challenging, as behavioural profiles have to be identified in single individuals. For high-throughput screening, approaches have been made to establish standardised screening protocols including a combination of well-validated, easy to perform behavioural tests. Different strategies are being introduced, which are used in ENU-mutagenesis screens to identify behavioural mutants representing possible endophenotypes of psychiatric diseases.

Facilitated glutamatergic transmission in the striatum of D2 dopamine receptor-deficient mice

Dopamine (DA) receptors play an important role in the modulation of excitability and the responsiveness of neurons to activation of excitatory amino acid receptors in the striatum. In the present study, we utilized mice with genetic deletion of D2 or D4 DA receptors and their wild-type (WT) controls to examine if the absence of either receptor subtype affects striatal excitatory synaptic activity. Immunocytochemical analysis verified the absence of D2 or D4 protein expression in the striatum of receptor-deficient mutant animals. Sharp electrode current- and whole cell patch voltage-clamp recordings were obtained from slices of receptor-deficient and WT mice. Basic membrane properties were similar in D2 and D4 receptor-deficient mutants and their respective WT controls. In current-clamp recordings in WT animals, very little low-amplitude spontaneous synaptic activity was observed. The frequency of these spontaneous events was increased slightly in D2 receptor-deficient mice. In addition, large-amplitude depolarizations were observed in a subset of neurons from only the D2 receptor-deficient mutants. Bath application of the K+ channel blocker 4-aminopyridine (100 microM) and bicuculline methiodide (10 microM, to block synaptic activity due to activation of GABA(A) receptors) markedly increased spontaneous synaptic activity in receptor-deficient mutants and WTs. Under these conditions, D2 receptor-deficient mice displayed significantly more excitatory synaptic activity than their WT controls, while there was no difference between D4 receptor-deficient mice and their controls. In voltage-clamp recordings, there was an increase in frequency of spontaneous glutamate receptor-mediated inward currents without a change in mean amplitude in D2 receptor-deficient mutants. In WT mice, activation of D2 family receptors with quinpirole decreased spontaneous excitatory events and conversely sulpiride, a D2 receptor antagonist, increased activity. In D2 receptor-deficient mice, sulpiride had very little net effect. Morphologically, a subpopulation of medium-sized spiny neurons from D2 receptor-deficient mice displayed decreased dendritic spines compared with cells from WT mice. These results provide evidence that D2 receptors play an important role in the regulation of glutamate receptor-mediated activity in the corticostriatal or thalamostriatal pathway. These receptors may function as gatekeepers of glutamate release or of its subsequent effects and thus may protect striatal neurons from excessive excitation.

The staircase test of skilled reaching in mice

The "staircase" test has become established for measurement of side-specific deficits in coordinated paw reaching in rats, and has been shown to reveal impairments on the contralateral side following unilateral lesions in a wide range of motor structures of the brain. As mice become more widely used in behavioural neuroscience, we have scaled down the staircase reaching test for application to this latter species. We here validate the test in C57BL/6J mice by (a) establishing the optimal dimensions of the apparatus, (b) comparing the effects of test parameters including sex, test duration, levels of deprivation and alternative reward pellets, and (c) demonstrating contralateral deficits after aspirative lesions of the motor cortex. Differences between mice and rats in normal performance of the task are noted. The staircase test provides a simple objective test of skilled motor function that allows measurement of lateralised effects without unduly constraining the animal, and which may prove as useful for mice as has previously been demonstrated in rats.

Neuroscience and psychopharmacology into the next millennium

The end of the millennium provides an opportunity to review some of the common practices that were present in psychopharmacology during the 20th century. The author focuses on two approaches that have dominated research and guided the clinical application of psychopharmacologic therapeutics: the unitary clinically-based and single-lesion perspectives. The author expands upon these older formulations of neuropsychiatric disease pathogenesis and describes how the approach to psychopharmacologic research and therapeutics has changed in light of advances in the basic neurosciences. Relevant recent advances in the basic neurosciences that shed light on the pathophysiology of neuropsychiatric disease states and that guide psychopharmacologic practices are described. The use of atypical antipsychotic agents to treat schizophrenia is given as one example of the clinical applications of the approach to psychopharmacology in the next century.

Disrupted allocentric but preserved egocentric spatial learning in transgenic mice with impaired glucocorticoid receptor function

Spatial and non-spatial learning of mice with an incorporated antisense RNA complementary to a fragment of cDNA coding for the glucocorticoid receptor (GR) were evaluated in allocentric and egocentric radial maze and water maze tasks, and in spontaneous object recognition and sensorimotor learning paradigms. Mice with impaired GR function did not acquire two maze paradigms based on allocentric spatial navigation, radial maze non-matching to position and water maze spatial discrimination learning. Comparison of performance in spaced and massed trials indicated that this may be due to a general inability to store information into allocentric reference memory or in retrieval processes. However, both groups of animals learned the rules of an egocentric radial maze task at similar rates and there was no difference in their ability to recognise objects once animals had equal opportunity to explore the sample objects. Sensorimotor performance was impaired in transgenic animals, but it is suggested that this is due to non-specific factors rather than to disrupted sensorimotor learning per se. These results are consistent with a disruption of hippocampal function. Histological examination of the hippocampus revealed no obvious structural abnormalities in transgenic animals. Therefore, the data suggest that functional underactivity of GRs at the level of the hippocampus induces a deficit in allocentric navigation while sparing egocentric navigation and object recognition.

Age- and stimulus-dependent changes in anxiety-related behaviour of transgenic mice with GR dysfunction

Transgenic mice expressing antisense directed against glucocorticoid receptor (GR) mRNA were used for a longitudinal study on the effects of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical dysfunction on anxiety-related behaviour and locomotor activity. Compared with age-matched controls and 5-week-old transgenic animals, 13- and 36-week-old transgenic mice made significantly more entries into and spent significantly more time on the open arms of the elevated plus-maze thereby indicating reduced basal anxiety. In contrast, time spent in the central area of the open field was significantly reduced in transgenic animals indicating an enhanced anxiety under conditions of increased stress. Locomotor activity did not differ between transgenic and control animals. Our results indicate that behavioural changes in transgenic mice differ according to the age of the animals and the behavioural paradigm used. Transgenic animals with an impaired GR function may be of help in studying the interaction of ageing, GR function and the development of behavioural abnormalities.