A versatile high-throughput screen for inhibitors of lipid kinase activity: development of an immobilized phospholipid plate assay for phosphoinositide 3-kinase gamma

Structure and ligand-based design of mTOR and PI3-kinase inhibitors leading to the clinical candidates VS-5584 (SB2343) and SB2602

Phosphoinositide 3-kinases (PI3Ks) and the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) act as critical effectors in a commonly deregulated cell signaling pathway in human cancers. The abnormal activation of the PI3K/mTOR pathway has been shown to play a role in initiation, progression, and metastasis of human tumors. Being one of the most frequently activated pathways in cancer, much effort has been directed toward inhibition of the PI3K/mTOR pathway as a novel oncology therapy. Previous work by a number of groups has revealed several selective PI3K and dual mTOR/PI3K inhibitors. However, there are few reports of therapeutic agents with a pan-PI3K/mTOR inhibitory profile within a narrow concentration range. We therefore initiated a drug discovery project with the aim of discovering dual mTOR/PI3K inhibitors which would equipotently inhibit the 4 isoforms of PI3K, α, β, γ, and δ, and mTOR a compelling profile for powerful blockage of the PI3K/mTOR pathway. A pharmacophore model was generated and used for designing a series of novel compounds, based on a purine scaffold, which potently inhibited mTOR and PI3Ks. These compounds contained a phenol headgroup essential for binding to the target proteins. Early efforts concentrated on finding replacements for the phenol as it was rapidly conjugated resulting in a short half-life in vivo. Compounds with a variety of headgroups were docked into the PI3Kα and mTOR ATP-binding sites, and aminopyrimidine and aminopyrazine were found to make excellent phenol replacements. Further structure guided optimization of side chains in the 8- and 9-positions of the purine resulted in potent inhibitors with good PKDM properties. As the PI3 kinases play a role in insulin signaling, it is believed that targeting mTOR selectively may give the benefit of blocking the AKT-pathway while avoiding the potential side effects associated with PI3K inhibition. As a result we designed a further series of selective mTOR kinase inhibitors. The project was successfully concluded by progressing both a dual mTOR/PI3K inhibitor, SB2343, and a selective mTOR inhibitor, SB2602, into preclinical development. SB2343 has since entered phase 1 clinical development as VS-5584.

Development of phosphocellulose paper-based screening of inhibitors of lipid kinases: case study with PI3Kβ

The phosphatidylinositol 3-kinases (PI3Ks) are lipid kinases that regulate the cellular signal transduction pathways involved in cell growth, proliferation, survival, apoptosis, and adhesion. Deregulation of these pathways are common in oncogenesis, and they are known to be altered in other metabolic disorders as well. Despite its huge potential as an attractive target in these diseases, there is an unmet need for the development of a successful inhibitor. Unlike protein kinase inhibitors, screening for lipid kinase inhibitors has been challenging. Here we report, for the first time, the development of a radioactive lipid kinase screening platform using a phosphocellulose plate that involves transfer of radiolabeled [γ-(32)P]ATP to phosphatidylinositol 4,5-phosphate forming phosphatidylinositol 3,4,5-phosphate, captured on the phosphocellulose plate. Enzyme kinetics and inhibitory properties were established in the plate format using standard inhibitors, such as LY294002, TGX-221, and wortmannin, having different potencies toward PI3K isoforms. ATP and lipid apparent Km for both were determined and IC50 values generated that matched the historical data. Here we report the use of a phosphocellulose plate for a lipid kinase assay (PI3Kβ as the target) as an excellent platform for the identification of novel chemical entities in PI3K drug discovery.

A novel selective small-molecule PI3K inhibitor is effective against human multiple myeloma in vitro and in vivo

Developing effective therapies against multiple myeloma (MM) is an unresolved challenge. Phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase (PI3K) activation may be associated with tumor progression and drug resistance, and inhibiting PI3K can induce apoptosis in MM cells. Thus, targeting of PI3K is predicted to increase the susceptibility of MM to anticancer therapy. The lead compound of a novel class of PI3K inhibitors, BAY80-6946 (IC50=0.5 nM against PI3K-α), was highly efficacious in four different MM cell lines, where it induced significant antitumoral effects in a dose-dependent manner. The compound inhibited cell cycle progression and increased apoptosis (P<0.001 compared with controls). Moreover, it abrogated the stimulation conferred by insulin-like growth-factor-1, a mechanism relevant for MM progression. These cellular effects were paralleled by decreased Akt phosphorylation, the main downstream target of PI3K. Likewise, profound antitumoral activity was observed ex vivo, as BAY80-6946 significantly inhibited proliferation of freshly isolated myeloma cells from three patients (P<0.001 compared with vehicle). In addition, BAY80-6946 showed convincing in vivo activity against the human AMO-1 and MOLP-8 myeloma cell lines in a preclinical murine xenograft model, where treatment with 6 mg/kg every other day for 2 weeks reduced the cell numbers by 87.0% and 69.3%, respectively (P<0.001 compared with vehicle), without overt toxicity in treated animals.

Current status of HTRF(®) technology in kinase assays

BACKGROUND

Homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence (HTRF) is a fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based technology used to measure bimolecular interactions. It has been applied successfully to kinase assays and has become an important tool in kinase drug discovery.

OBJECTIVE

This article reviews the current status of HTRF technology in biochemical and cellular kinase assays.

METHODS

Recent literature and meeting reports on HTRF kinase assays are reviewed, and their principles, advantages and drawbacks, current status and the potential applications in kinase drug discovery are discussed.

RESULTS/CONCLUSION

HTRF kinase assays are homogeneous, robust, sensitive, easy to miniaturize and high-throughput. This assay format is versatile, as both peptide and protein substrates can be used, and high ATP concentrations are tolerated, which enables the assay to be performed under conditions mimicking the physiological environment. HTRF kinase assays have been applied to both high-throughput screening and compound mechanistic studies. Besides protein kinases, the technology has now been expanded into the lipid kinase family. Furthermore, the utility of HTRF technology in cellular assays is emerging. HTRF kinase assays are a great addition to the toolbox for kinase drug discovery.

A homogeneous, high-throughput assay for phosphatidylinositol 5-phosphate 4-kinase with a novel, rapid substrate preparation

Phosphoinositide kinases regulate diverse cellular functions and are important targets for therapeutic development for diseases, such as diabetes and cancer. Preparation of the lipid substrate is crucial for the development of a robust and miniaturizable lipid kinase assay. Enzymatic assays for phosphoinositide kinases often use lipid substrates prepared from lyophilized lipid preparations by sonication, which result in variability in the liposome size from preparation to preparation. Herein, we report a homogeneous 1536-well luciferase-coupled bioluminescence assay for PI5P4Kα. The substrate preparation is novel and allows the rapid production of a DMSO-containing substrate solution without the need for lengthy liposome preparation protocols, thus enabling the scale-up of this traditionally difficult type of assay. The Z’-factor value was greater than 0.7 for the PI5P4Kα assay, indicating its suitability for high-throughput screening applications. Tyrphostin AG-82 had been identified as an inhibitor of PI5P4Kα by assessing the degree of phospho transfer of γ-³²P-ATP to PI5P; its inhibitory activity against PI5P4Kα was confirmed in the present miniaturized assay. From a pilot screen of a library of bioactive compounds, another tyrphostin, I-OMe tyrphostin AG-538 (I-OMe-AG-538), was identified as an ATP-competitive inhibitor of PI5P4Kα with an IC₅₀ of 1 µM, affirming the suitability of the assay for inhibitor discovery campaigns. This homogeneous assay may apply to other lipid kinases and should help in the identification of leads for this class of enzymes by enabling high-throughput screening efforts.

Identification and characterization of NVP-BKM120, an orally available pan-class I PI3-kinase inhibitor

Following the discovery of NVP-BEZ235, our first dual pan-PI3K/mTOR clinical compound, we sought to identify additional phosphoinositide 3-kinase (PI3K) inhibitors from different chemical classes with a different selectivity profile. The key to achieve these objectives was to couple a structure-based design approach with intensive pharmacologic evaluation of selected compounds during the medicinal chemistry optimization process. Here, we report on the biologic characterization of the 2-morpholino pyrimidine derivative pan-PI3K inhibitor NVP-BKM120. This compound inhibits all four class I PI3K isoforms in biochemical assays with at least 50-fold selectivity against other protein kinases. The compound is also active against the most common somatic PI3Kα mutations but does not significantly inhibit the related class III (Vps34) and class IV (mTOR, DNA-PK) PI3K kinases. Consistent with its mechanism of action, NVP-BKM120 decreases the cellular levels of p-Akt in mechanistic models and relevant tumor cell lines, as well as downstream effectors in a concentration-dependent and pathway-specific manner. Tested in a panel of 353 cell lines, NVP-BKM120 exhibited preferential inhibition of tumor cells bearing PIK3CA mutations, in contrast to either KRAS or PTEN mutant models. NVP-BKM120 shows dose-dependent in vivo pharmacodynamic activity as measured by significant inhibition of p-Akt and tumor growth inhibition in mechanistic xenograft models. NVP-BKM120 behaves synergistically when combined with either targeted agents such as MEK or HER2 inhibitors or with cytotoxic agents such as docetaxel or temozolomide. The pharmacological, biologic, and preclinical safety profile of NVP-BKM120 supports its clinical development and the compound is undergoing phase II clinical trials in patients with cancer.

A Simple and robust automated kinase profiling platform using luminescent ADP accumulation technology

Kinases continue to be one of the most important targets in today's drug discovery efforts. Following the identification of lead compounds through screening efforts, it is important to profile these leads against other kinases within that family, as well as from other families, to ascertain potential off-target effects. Because many kinase assays require the use of different substrates, optimization time and costs during profiling can be prohibitive. Here we demonstrate the versatility of a luminescent ADP accumulation assay, where one set of reagents can be used for a wide variety of kinases with differing K(m app) for ATP and substrates. Assay sensitivity allows for the use of low enzyme concentrations and small percent ATP conversion levels while still maintaining high signal:background ratios. We have used a simple, inexpensive automated pipetting system to automate the entire process from enzyme optimization through generation of compound IC(50) values. Agreement with literature values proves this combination of chemistry and instrumentation provides a simple, yet robust solution for automated kinase profiling.

High-throughput, cell-free, liposome-based approach for assessing in vitro activity of lipid kinases

Lipid kinases are central players in lipid signaling pathways involved in inflammation, tumorigenesis, and metabolic syndrome. A number of these kinase targets have proven difficult to investigate in higher throughput cell-free assay systems. This challenge is partially due to specific substrate interaction requirements for several of the lipid kinase family members and the resulting incompatibility of these substrates with most established, homogeneous assay formats. Traditional, cell-free in vitro investigational methods for members of the lipid kinase family typically involve substrate incorporation of [gamma-32P] and resolution of signal by thin-layer chromatography (TLC) and autoradiograph densitometry. This approach, although highly sensitive, does not lend itself to high-throughput testing of large numbers of small molecules (100 s to 1 MM+). The authors present the development and implementation of a fully synthetic, liposome-based assay for assessing in vitro activity of phosphatidylinositol-5-phosphate-4-kinase isoforms (PIP4KIIbeta and alpha) in 2 commonly used homogeneous technologies. They have validated these assays through compound testing in both traditional TLC and radioactive filterplate approaches as well as binding validation using isothermic calorimetry. A directed library representing known kinase pharmacophores was screened against type IIbeta phosphatidylinositol-phosphate kinase (PIPK) to identify small-molecule inhibitors. This assay system can be applied to other types and isoforms of PIPKs as well as a variety of other lipid kinase targets.

PI3K inhibitors for cancer treatment: where do we stand?

In contrast with cytotoxic agents that do not differentiate between normal proliferating and tumour cells, targeted therapies primarily exert their actions in cancer cells. Initiation and maintenance of tumours are due to genetic alterations in specific loci. The identification of the genes in which these alterations occur has opened new opportunities for cancer treatment. The PI3K (phosphoinositide 3-kinase) pathway is often overactive in human cancers, and various genetic alterations have been found to cause this. In all cases, PI3K inhibition is considered to be one of the most promising targeted therapies for cancer treatment. The present mini-review provides an update on new PI3K inhibitors currently in or entering clinical development. Recent discoveries, challenges and future prospects will be discussed.

A high-throughput liposome substrate assay with automated lipid extraction process for PI 3-kinase

The signaling pathways involving lipid kinase class I phosphatidylinositol 3-kinases (PI 3-kinases) regulate cell growth, proliferation, and survival. Class I PI 3-kinases catalyze the conversion of PI (4,5)P(2) to PI (3,4,5)P(3), which acts as a lipid second messenger to activate mitogenic signaling cascades. Recently, p110alpha, a class IA PI 3-kinase, was found to be mutated frequently in many human cancers. Therefore, it is increasingly studied as an anticancer drug target. Traditionally, PI 3-kinase activities have been studied using liposome substrates. This method, however, is hampered significantly by the labor-intensive manual lipid extraction followed by a low-throughput thin-layer chromatography analysis. The authors describe a high-throughput liposome substrate-based assay based on an automated lipid extraction method that allows them to study PI 3-kinase enzyme mechanism and quantitatively measure inhibitor activity using liposome substrates in a high-throughput mode. This improved assay format can easily be extended to study other classes of phosphoinositide lipid kinases.

Evaluating PI3 kinase isoforms using Transcreener ADP assays

Development of drugs targeting lipid kinases has been delayed by the lack of robust screening assays. Methods are needed that can accommodate the presentation of different acceptor substrates in the optimal lipid environment. The Transcreener ADP Assay relies on homogeneous immunodetection of adenosine diphosphate (ADP), using either fluorescence polarization (FP) or time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) as a signal output. Detection of ADP--the invariant product of all kinase reactions--provides complete flexibility for varying lipid substrate parameters. The authors used this assay to optimize dispersal methods for C8 and C16 phosphatidylinositol 4,5 bisphosphate substrates and to assess the effects of chain length on the activity and inhibition of phosphoinositide-3-kinase (PI3K) isoforms. The nonphysiological C8 substrate supported the highest activity. Known inhibitors were profiled using both the FP- and TR-FRET-based assays, and there was excellent concordance (r(2)=0.93) in the IC(50) values. The overall rank order of inhibitors was the same using the C8 and C16 substrates, except for minor deviations. Adenosine triphosphate (ATP) hydrolysis in the absence of substrate was detected with the PI3Kalpha isoform, and inhibitors affected PI3Kalpha intrinsic ATP hydrolysis activity similarly to lipid phosphorylation.

A Robust Screen for Inhibitors and Enhancers of Phosphoinositide-3 Kinase (PI3K) Activities by Ratiometric Fluorescence Superquenching

Aberrant regulation of phosphoinositide 3-kinase (PI3K) activity is implicated in various diseases such as cancer and diabetes. Thus, high-throughput screening (HTS) of small-molecule inhibitors for PI3 kinases is an appealing strategy for drug development. Despite the attractiveness of lipid kinases as drug targets, screening for inhibitors for PI3K activities has been hampered by limited assay formats adaptable for HTS. The authors describe a homogeneous, direct, and nonradioactive assay for highly sensitive detection of PI3Kα, β, δ, and γ activities, which is suitable for HTS. The assay is based on fluorescence superquenching of a conjugated polymer upon metal-ion-mediated association of phosphorylated and dye-labeled substrates. As a result of phosphorylation, quencher and polymer are brought into proximity, and fluorescent energy transfer occurs. This event can be monitored as either fluorescence quench of the polymer or as enhanced emission from the quencher. Ratiometric analysis of the wavelengths eliminates interferences from autofluorescing compounds, which are present in HTS libraries. The platform has been adapted for the 384-well microplate format and delivers Z factors of > 0.6 at substrate conversions as low as 7%. Using this assay platform, several unreported inhibitors and activators of PI3Ks were identified in an 84- compound screen.

Identification of kinase inhibitors by an ATP depletion method

ATP is one of the substrates of luciferase. ATP concentrations can be measured by quantitating the light output from a luciferase reaction. As kinases also use ATP, it is possible to assay kinase activity through the loss of luminescence in a coupled luciferase reaction. We have applied this luminescence-based ATP depletion approach to a model serine/threonine kinase. We find that the method may be run as an endpoint assay, in which ATP detection reagents (containing luciferase and luciferin) are added at the end of the reaction, or in a kinetic mode, where the ATP detection reagents are present throughout the reaction. The ATP depletion approach is capable of detecting kinase inhibitors. Six inhibitors of the model kinase, previously identified using other screening methods, are also active in the luminescence-based approach and display a similar rank order of potency. An advantage of the method is that kinase inhibitors, because they increase luminescence (by reversing the enzyme-dependent loss of signal), are immediately distinguishable from compounds such as luciferase inhibitors and luminescence quenchers, which further reduce the luminescence. The compound collections that we screened were rich in compounds that reduced luminescence. Compounds that have dual kinase and luciferase inhibitory activity, or kinase inhibitory activity combined with luminescence quenching, might be missed by being classified as false negatives. We show that the kinetic form of the assay can be used to minimize this possibility.

Phosphoinositide Signaling

Lipid signaling by phosphoinositides (PIP(n)s) involves an array of proteins with lipid recognition, kinase, phosphatase, and phospholipase functions. Understanding PIP(n) pathway signaling requires identification and characterization of PIP(n)-interacting proteins. Moreover, spatiotemporal localization and physiological function of PIP(n)-protein complexes must be elucidated in cellular and organismal contexts. For protein discovery to functional elucidation, reporter-linked phosphoinositides or tethered PIP(n)s have been essential. The phosphoinositide 3-kinase (PI 3-K) signaling pathway has recently emerged as an important source of potential "druggable" therapeutic targets in human pathophysiology in both academic and pharmaceutical environments. This review summarizes the chemistry of PIP(n) affinity probes and their use in identifying macromolecular targets. The process of target validation will be described, i.e., the use of tethered PIP(n)s in determining PIP(n) selectivity in vitro and in establishing the function of PIP(n)-protein complexes in living cells.