Genomic discovery of an evolutionarily programmed modality for small-molecule targeting of an intractable protein surface

The vast majority of intracellular protein targets are refractory toward small-molecule therapeutic engagement, and additional therapeutic modalities are needed to overcome this deficiency. Here, the identification and characterization of a natural product, WDB002, reveals a therapeutic modality that dramatically expands the currently accepted limits of druggability. WDB002, in complex with the FK506-binding protein (FKBP12), potently and selectively binds the human centrosomal protein 250 (CEP250), resulting in disruption of CEP250 function in cells. The recognition mode is unprecedented in that the targeted domain of CEP250 is a coiled coil and is topologically featureless, embodying both a structural motif and surface topology previously considered on the extreme limits of "undruggability" for an intracellular target. Structural studies reveal extensive protein-WDB002 and protein-protein contacts, with the latter being distinct from those seen in FKBP12 ternary complexes formed by FK506 and rapamycin. Outward-facing structural changes in a bound small molecule can thus reprogram FKBP12 to engage diverse, otherwise "undruggable" targets. The flat-targeting modality demonstrated here has the potential to expand the druggable target range of small-molecule therapeutics. As CEP250 was recently found to be an interaction partner with the Nsp13 protein of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes COVID-19 disease, it is possible that WDB002 or an analog may exert useful antiviral activity through its ability to form high-affinity ternary complexes containing CEP250 and FKBP12.

Abstract A06: Biophysical and biochemical characterization of KRAS G12C inhibition through the SMARTTM platform

RAS proteins are small GTPases involved in cell proliferation, survival, and differentiation, and are mutationally activated in about a third of all human cancers. These mutations drive cancer by impairing GTPase activity so that the RAS protein is found predominantly in its GTP-bound “on” conformation. Most KRAS isoform mutations are located at codon 12, a glycine in the P-loop of the GTPase active site. KRAS mutations in which the glycine is mutated to a cysteine (G12C) are particularly common in lung cancer. Despite its prevalence as an important oncogene and decades of research, the RAS protein remains an unexploited cancer target. We have developed a novel platform, SMART (Small Molecule Assisted Receptor Targeting), to disrupt the protein-protein interactions of so-called “undruggable” targets. Our compounds bind the immunophilin protein Cyclophilin A (CypA), and subsequently form a ternary complex with the target protein, KRAS. An electrophilic moiety on the ligand selectively forms a covalent bond with the cysteine of GTP-KRAS G12C, thus strengthening the stability of the ternary complex, partially occupying the effector face, and thus occluding the binding of downstream effector proteins, such as RAF. In a separate presentation, we describe a wide breadth of data to support the advancement of a small molecule specifically targeting the activated form of KRAS, with a focus on the cellular pharmacology. In this presentation, we highlight biophysical and biochemical findings that support our novel strategy for targeting GTP-KRAS G12C. SPR reveals the CypA-compound binary KD. A novel SPR protocol method was developed to examine CypA-compound-KRAS ternary complex formation, exploiting the A-B-A injection system of the Biacore 8K. LC-MS is used to characterize the crosslinking of our compounds to KRAS G12C in the presence of CypA, and full kinact/KI analysis is conducted with select compounds; in combination with SPR studies, the noncovalent KD of the ternary complex can be determined. Intrinsic warhead reactivity is measured through GSH adduct formation. TR-FRET studies probe the ability of ternary complexes to inhibit the binding of RAF to KRAS G12C. ITC and BLI are used to confirm ternary complex formation for selected compounds. In addition to guiding SAR, these studies characterize the degree of presenter (CypA) dependence, specificity of compound binding to the G12C mutant and to the GTP nucleotide-bound form of KRAS, and the ability to predict cellular efficacy. Our kinetic crosslinking experiments reveal single-digit micromolar KIs and a good kinact/KI ratio for our compounds relative to published literature on compounds targeting GDP-KRAS G12C. When these values are compared to SPR findings, the noncovalent KD contributes largely to KI, and thus noncovalent interactions play a bigger role in our compound’s interaction with RAS as compared to known GDP-KRAS G12C agents.

Citation Format: Minyun Zhou, Alexander Yuzhakov, Cindy C Benod, Linlong Xue, Alec D Silver, Ganesh Iyer, Sharon A. Townson, Meizhong Jin, Nicholas R. Perl, Anna Kohlmann, Alan S. Mann, Gizem Akcay, Earl W. May. Biophysical and biochemical characterization of KRAS G12C inhibition through the SMARTTM platform [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference on Targeting RAS-Driven Cancers; 2018 Dec 9-12; San Diego, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Mol Cancer Res 2020;18(5_Suppl):Abstract nr A06.

Abstract B37: Development of inhibitors of the activated form of KRAS G12C

Activating mutations in RAS proteins occur in ~1/3 of human cancers. These mutations impair the ability of the protein to hydrolyze GTP to GDP. As a result, mutant RAS proteins exist predominantly in the GTP-bound state, which directly activates aberrant downstream signaling via interaction with effectors such as RAF. Most RAS mutations occur at glycine 12 of the KRAS isoform. One such mutation, KRAS G12C, is particularly common in non-small cell lung cancer where it is found in ~15% of lung adenocarcinomas. Recent efforts have targeted KRAS G12C in the GDP-bound state; however, direct pharmacologic inhibition of active, GTP-bound KRAS G12C has proved challenging. Here, we deployed a novel SMARTTM (Small Molecule Assisted Receptor Targeting) platform to advance covalent compounds that selectively inhibit GTP-bound KRAS G12C. Using a mechanism reminiscent of the natural products rapamycin and cyclosporine, these compounds promote formation of a novel inhibitory ternary complex consisting of cyclophilin A (CypA, an abundant immunophilin present in all human cells), the SMART inhibitor, and GTP-KRAS G12C. Structure-based design of the SMART inhibitor yielded potent covalent inhibitors of GTP-KRAS G12C that exhibit >100-fold selectivity for mutant KRAS G12C over WT KRAS. Structural analysis of the ternary complex revealed that the covalent linkage between the SMART inhibitor and the mutant cysteine of KRAS occurred in the context of extensive interactions between CypA, the SMART inhibitor, and GTP-KRAS G12C that provide significant binding affinity (KI = 2.5 μM). The GTP-KRAS G12C|Inhibitor|CypA complex directly occluded effector binding, and as such, the compounds disrupted the KRAS-RAF interaction in biochemical assays. This activity was dependent on CypA, underlining the importance of the KRAS G12C| CypA protein-protein interaction in driving target engagement. In cell-based studies, SMART inhibitors crosslinked KRAS G12C and potently inhibited ERK phosphorylation and cell growth in G12C mutant tumor cell lines but had no effect on non-G12C bearing tumor cells. CRISPR knockout of cellular CypA confirmed that these activities were dependent on the presence of endogenous CypA. Importantly, SMART inhibitors bind directly to active, GTP-KRAS G12C and thus, their activity does not rely on trapping KRAS G12C in the inactive GDP-bound state. As a result, the cellular potency of SMART inhibitors with respect to crosslinking, pERK inhibition, and growth inhibition was maintained in the presence of growth factor treatments that reduce the cellular GDP-KRAS G12C pool. In contrast, we found that the activity of a previously described GDP-KRAS G12C targeting inhibitor was attenuated by growth factor treatment. To our knowledge, these are the first examples of mutant-selective KRAS inhibitors that target the active, GTP-bound state of KRAS G12C. We are currently optimizing the drug-like properties of these SMART inhibitors and evaluating their activity in in vivo models.

Citation Format: Michelle L. Stewart, Nicholas R. Perl, Seung-Joo Lee, Linlong Xue, Minyun Zhou, Jonah Simon, Kathryn M. Luly, Siminia Grigoriu, Alex Yuzhakov, Alec Silver, Jason T. Lowe, Cindy C. Benod, Alan S. Mann, Gregory L. Verdine, Alan C. Rigby, Mark J. Mulvihill, Earl W. May, Anna Kohlmann, Sharon A. Townson, Roy M. Pollock, Meizhong Jin. Development of inhibitors of the activated form of KRAS G12C [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference on Targeting RAS-Driven Cancers; 2018 Dec 9-12; San Diego, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Mol Cancer Res 2020;18(5_Suppl):Abstract nr B37.

NMR 1H,13C, 15N resonance assignment of the G12C mutant of human K-Ras bound to GppNHp

K-Ras exists in two distinct structural conformations specific to binding of GDP and GTP nucleotides. The cycling between an inactive, GDP-bound state and an active, GTP-bound state is regulated by guanine nucleotide exchange factors and GTPase activating proteins, respectively. The activated form of K-Ras regulates cell proliferation, differentiation and survival by controlling several downstream signaling pathways. Oncogenic mutations that attenuate the GTPase activity of K-Ras result in accumulation of this key signaling protein in its hyperactivated state, leading to uncontrolled cellular proliferation and tumorogenesis. Mutations at position 12 are the most prevalent in K-Ras associated cancers, hence K-Ras^G12C has become a recent focus of research for therapeutic intervention. Here we report ¹H^{N, 15}N, and ¹³C backbone and ¹H, ¹³C side-chain resonance assignments for the 19.3 kDa (aa 1-169) human K-Ras protein harboring an oncogenic G12C mutation in the active GppNHp-bound form (K-Ras^G12C-GppNHp), using heteronuclear, multidimensional NMR spectroscopy at 298K. Triple-resonance data assisted the assignments of the backbone ¹H, ¹⁵N, and ¹³C resonances of 126 out of 165 non-proline residues. The vast majority of unassigned residues are exchange-broadened beyond detection on the NMR time scale and belong to the P-loop and two flexible Switch regions.

NMR 1H,13C, 15N backbone and 13C side chain resonance assignment of the G12C mutant of human K-Ras bound to GDP

K-Ras is a key driver of oncogenesis, accounting for approximately 80% of Ras-driven human cancers. The small GTPase cycles between an inactive, GDP-bound and an active, GTP-bound state, regulated by guanine nucleotide exchange factors and GTPase activating proteins, respectively. Activated K-Ras regulates cell proliferation, differentiation and survival by signaling through several effector pathways, including Raf-MAPK. Oncogenic mutations that impair the GTPase activity of K-Ras result in a hyperactivated state, leading to uncontrolled cellular proliferation and tumorogenesis. A cysteine mutation at glycine 12 is commonly found in K-Ras associated cancers, and has become a recent focus for therapeutic intervention. We report here ¹H^{N, 15}N, and ¹³C resonance assignments for the 19.3 kDa (aa 1-169) human K-Ras protein harboring an oncogenic G12C mutation in the GDP-bound form (K-RAS^G12C-GDP), using heteronuclear, multidimensional NMR spectroscopy. Backbone ¹H-¹⁵N correlations have been assigned for all non-proline residues, except for the first methionine residue.

Specificity and structure of a high affinity activin receptor-like kinase 1 (ALK1) signaling complex

Activin receptor-like kinase 1 (ALK1), an endothelial cell-specific type I receptor of the TGF-β superfamily, is an important regulator of normal blood vessel development as well as pathological tumor angiogenesis. As such, ALK1 is an important therapeutic target. Thus, several ALK1-directed agents are currently in clinical trials as anti-angiogenic cancer therapeutics. Given the biological and clinical importance of the ALK1 signaling pathway, we sought to elucidate the biophysical and structural basis underlying ALK1 signaling. The TGF-β family ligands BMP9 and BMP10 as well as the three type II TGF-β family receptors ActRIIA, ActRIIB, and BMPRII have been implicated in ALK1 signaling. Here, we provide a kinetic and thermodynamic analysis of BMP9 and BMP10 interactions with ALK1 and type II receptors. Our data show that BMP9 displays a significant discrimination in type II receptor binding, whereas BMP10 does not. We also report the crystal structure of a fully assembled ternary complex of BMP9 with the extracellular domains of ALK1 and ActRIIB. The structure reveals that the high specificity of ALK1 for BMP9/10 is determined by a novel orientation of ALK1 with respect to BMP9, which leads to a unique set of receptor-ligand interactions. In addition, the structure explains how BMP9 discriminates between low and high affinity type II receptors. Taken together, our findings provide structural and mechanistic insights into ALK1 signaling that could serve as a basis for novel anti-angiogenic therapies.

Crystallization and preliminary crystallographic analysis of the type IIL restriction enzyme MmeI in complex with DNA

Type IIL restriction enzymes have rejuvenated the search for user-specified DNA binding and cutting. By aligning and contrasting the highly comparable amino-acid sequences yet diverse recognition specificities across the family of enzymes, amino acids involved in DNA binding have been identified and mutated to produce alternative binding specificities. To date, the specificity of MmeI (a type IIL restriction enzyme) has successfully been altered at positions 3, 4 and 6 of the asymmetric TCCRAC (where R is a purine) DNA-recognition sequence. To further understand the structural basis of MmeI DNA-binding specificity, the enzyme has been crystallized in complex with its DNA substrate. The crystal belonged to space group P1, with unit-cell parameters a = 61.73, b = 94.96, c = 161.24 Å, α = 72.79, β = 89.12, γ = 71.68°, and diffracted to 2.6 Å resolution when exposed to synchrotron radiation. The structure promises to reveal the basis of MmeI DNA-binding specificity and will complement efforts to create enzymes with novel specificities.

High-throughput, cell-free, liposome-based approach for assessing in vitro activity of lipid kinases

Lipid kinases are central players in lipid signaling pathways involved in inflammation, tumorigenesis, and metabolic syndrome. A number of these kinase targets have proven difficult to investigate in higher throughput cell-free assay systems. This challenge is partially due to specific substrate interaction requirements for several of the lipid kinase family members and the resulting incompatibility of these substrates with most established, homogeneous assay formats. Traditional, cell-free in vitro investigational methods for members of the lipid kinase family typically involve substrate incorporation of [gamma-32P] and resolution of signal by thin-layer chromatography (TLC) and autoradiograph densitometry. This approach, although highly sensitive, does not lend itself to high-throughput testing of large numbers of small molecules (100 s to 1 MM+). The authors present the development and implementation of a fully synthetic, liposome-based assay for assessing in vitro activity of phosphatidylinositol-5-phosphate-4-kinase isoforms (PIP4KIIbeta and alpha) in 2 commonly used homogeneous technologies. They have validated these assays through compound testing in both traditional TLC and radioactive filterplate approaches as well as binding validation using isothermic calorimetry. A directed library representing known kinase pharmacophores was screened against type IIbeta phosphatidylinositol-phosphate kinase (PIPK) to identify small-molecule inhibitors. This assay system can be applied to other types and isoforms of PIPKs as well as a variety of other lipid kinase targets.

BstYI Bound to Noncognate DNA Reveals a “Hemispecific” Complex: Implications for DNA Scanning

DNA recognition by proteins is essential for specific expression of genes in a living organism. En route to a target DNA site, a protein will often sample noncognate DNA sites through nonspecific protein-DNA interactions, resulting in a variety of conformationally different binding states. We present here the crystal structure of endonuclease BstYI bound to a noncognate DNA. Surprisingly, the structure reveals the enzyme in a "hemispecific" binding state on the pathway between nonspecific and specific recognition. A single base pair change in the DNA abolishes binding of only one monomer, with the second monomer bound specifically. We show that the enzyme binds essentially as a rigid body, and that one end of the DNA is accommodated loosely in the binding cleft while the other end is held tightly. Another intriguing feature of the structure is Ser172, which has a dual role in establishing nonspecific and specific contacts. Taken together, the structure provides a snapshot of an enzyme in a "paused" intermediate state that may be part of a more general mechanism of scanning DNA.

Human DNA polymerase kappa encircles DNA: implications for mismatch extension and lesion bypass

Human DNA polymerase kappa (Pol kappa) is a proficient extender of mispaired primer termini on undamaged DNAs and is implicated in the extension step of lesion bypass. We present here the structure of Pol kappa catalytic core in ternary complex with DNA and an incoming nucleotide. The structure reveals encirclement of the DNA by a unique "N-clasp" at the N terminus of Pol kappa, which augments the conventional right-handed grip on the DNA by the palm, fingers, and thumb domains and the PAD and provides additional thermodynamic stability. The structure also reveals an active-site cleft that is constrained by the close apposition of the N-clasp and the fingers domain, and therefore can accommodate only a single Watson-Crick base pair. Together, DNA encirclement and other structural features help explain Pol kappa's ability to extend mismatches and to promote replication through various minor groove DNA lesions, by extending from the nucleotide incorporated opposite the lesion by another polymerase.

Implications for switching restriction enzyme specificities from the structure of BstYI bound to a BglII DNA sequence

The type II restriction endonuclease BstYI recognizes the degenerate sequence 5'-RGATCY-3' (where R = A/G and Y = C/T), which overlaps with both BamHI (GGATCC) and BglII (AGATCT), and thus raises the question of whether BstYI DNA recognition will be more BamHI-like or BglII-like. We present here the structure of BstYI bound to a cognate DNA sequence (AGATCT). We find the complex to be more BglII-like with similarities mapping to DNA conformation, domain organization, and residues involved in catalysis. However, BstYI is unique in containing an extended arm subdomain, and the mechanism of DNA capture has both BglII-like and BamHI-like elements. Further, DNA recognition is more minimal than BglII and BamHI, where only two residues mediate recognition of the entire core sequence. Taken together, the structure reveals a mechanism of degenerate DNA recognition and offers insights into the possibilities and limitations in altering specificities of closely related restriction enzymes.

The Structure and Dynamics of Tandem WW Domains in a Negative Regulator of Notch Signaling, Suppressor of Deltex

WW domains mediate protein recognition, usually though binding to proline-rich sequences. In many proteins, WW domains occur in tandem arrays. Whether or how individual domains within such arrays cooperate to recognize biological partners is, as yet, poorly characterized. An important question is whether functional diversity of different WW domain proteins is reflected in the structural organization and ligand interaction mechanisms of their multiple domains. We have determined the solution structure and dynamics of a pair of WW domains (WW3-4) from a Drosophila Nedd4 family protein called Suppressor of deltex (Su(dx)), a regulator of Notch receptor signaling. We find that the binding of a type 1 PPPY ligand to WW3 stabilizes the structure with effects propagating to the WW4 domain, a domain that is not active for ligand binding. Both WW domains adopt the characteristic triple-stranded beta-sheet structure, and significantly, this is the first example of a WW domain structure to include a domain (WW4) lacking the second conserved Trp (replaced by Phe). The domains are connected by a flexible linker, which allows a hinge-like motion of domains that may be important for the recognition of functionally relevant targets. Our results contrast markedly with those of the only previously determined three-dimensional structure of tandem WW domains, that of the rigidly oriented WW domain pair from the RNA-splicing factor Prp40. Our data illustrate that arrays of WW domains can exhibit a variety of higher order structures and ligand interaction mechanisms.

Crystal structure of BstYI at 1.85A resolution: a thermophilic restriction endonuclease with overlapping specificities to BamHI and BglII

We report here the structure of BstYI, an "intermediate" type II restriction endonuclease with overlapping sequence specificities to BamHI and BglII. BstYI, a thermophilic endonuclease, recognizes and cleaves the degenerate hexanucleotide sequence 5'-RGATCY-3' (where R=A or G and Y=C or T), cleaving DNA after the 5'-R on each strand to produce four-base (5') staggered ends. The crystal structure of free BstYI was solved at 1.85A resolution by multi-wavelength anomalous dispersion (MAD) phasing. Comparison with BamHI and BglII reveals a strong structural consensus between all three enzymes mapping to the alpha/beta core domain and residues involved in catalysis. Unexpectedly, BstYI also contains an additional "arm" substructure outside of the core protein, which enables the enzyme to adopt a more compact, intertwined dimer structure compared with BamHI and BglII. This arm substructure may underlie the thermostability of BstYI. We identify putative DNA recognition residues and speculate as to how this enzyme achieves a "relaxed" DNA specificity.