The "Transport Specificity Ratio": a structure-function tool to search the protein fold for loci that control transition state stability in membrane transport catalysis

Determinants of substrate and cation transport in the human Na+/dicarboxylate cotransporter NaDC3

Metabolic intermediates, such as succinate and citrate, regulate important processes ranging from energy metabolism to fatty acid synthesis. Cytosolic concentrations of these metabolites are controlled, in part, by members of the SLC13 gene family. The molecular mechanism underlying Na(+)-coupled di- and tricarboxylate transport by this family is understood poorly. The human Na(+)/dicarboxylate cotransporter NaDC3 (SLC13A3) is found in various tissues, including the kidney, liver, and brain. In addition to citric acid cycle intermediates such as α-ketoglutarate and succinate, NaDC3 transports other compounds into cells, including N-acetyl aspartate, mercaptosuccinate, and glutathione, in keeping with its dual roles in cell nutrition and detoxification. In this study, we construct a homology structural model of NaDC3 on the basis of the structure of the Vibrio cholerae homolog vcINDY. Our computations are followed by experimental testing of the predicted NaDC3 structure and mode of interaction with various substrates. The results of this study show that the substrate and cation binding domains of NaDC3 are composed of residues in the opposing hairpin loops and unwound portions of adjacent helices. Furthermore, these results provide a possible explanation for the differential substrate specificity among dicarboxylate transporters that underpin their diverse biological roles in metabolism and detoxification. The structural model of NaDC3 provides a framework for understanding substrate selectivity and the Na(+)-coupled anion transport mechanism by the human SLC13 family and other key solute carrier transporters.

Transmembrane helix 7 in the Na+/dicarboxylate cotransporter 1 is an outer helix that contains residues critical for function

Citric acid cycle intermediates, including succinate and citrate, are absorbed across the apical membrane by the NaDC1 Na+/dicarboxylate cotransporter located in the kidney and small intestine. The secondary structure model of NaDC1 contains 11 transmembrane helices (TM). TM7 was shown previously to contain determinants of citrate affinity, and Arg-349 at the extracellular end of the helix is required for transport. The present study involved cysteine scanning mutagenesis of 26 amino acids in TM7 and the associated loops. All of the mutants were well expressed on the plasma membrane, but many had low or no transport activity: 6 were inactive and 7 had activity less than 25% of the parental. Three of the mutants had notable changes in functional properties. F336C had increased transport activity due to an increased Vmax for succinate. The conserved residue F339C had very low transport activity and a change in substrate selectivity. G356C in the putative extracellular loop was the only cysteine mutant that was affected by the membrane-impermeant cysteine reagent, MTSET. However, direct labeling of G356C with MTSEA-biotin gave a weak signal, indicating that this residue is not readily accessible to more bulky reagents. The results suggest that the amino acids of TM7 are functionally important because their replacement by cysteine had large effects on transport activity. However, most of TM7 does not appear to be accessible to the extracellular fluid and is likely to be an outer helix in contact with the lipid bilayer.

Role of isoleucine-554 in lithium binding by the Na+/dicarboxylate cotransporter NaDC1

Sodium-coupled transport of citric acid cycle intermediates, such as succinate and citrate, is mediated by the NaDC1 transporter located on the apical membrane of kidney proximal tubule and small intestine cells. Our previous study showed that transmembrane helix (TM) 11 of NaDC1 is important for sodium and lithium binding, as well as for determining citrate affinity [Kahn and Pajor (1999) Biochemistry 38, 6151]. In the present study, 21 amino acids in TM11 and the extracellular loop of NaDC1 were mutated one at a time to cysteine. All of the mutants were well expressed on the plasma membrane, but many of them had decreased transport activity. The G550C, W561C, and L568C mutants were inactive, suggesting that these residues may be critical for function. None of the cysteine mutants was sensitive to inhibition by the membrane-impermeant cysteine reagents, MTSET or MTSES, suggesting that the helix is inaccessible to the extracellular solvent. Although NaDC1 is inhibited by low concentrations of lithium in the presence of sodium, the I554C mutant was stimulated by lithium with a K(0.5) of 4.8 mM. The I554C mutant also had decreased affinity for sodium. We conclude that TM11 is likely to be an outer helix in NaDC1 that contains several residues critical for transport. Ile-554 in the middle of the helix may be an important determinant of cation affinity and selectivity, in particular the high affinity cation binding site that recognizes lithium.

Single nucleotide polymorphisms in the human Na+-dicarboxylate cotransporter affect transport activity and protein expression

The sodium-coupled transport of citric acid cycle intermediates in the intestine and kidney is mediated by the Na(+)-dicarboxylate cotransporter, NaDC1. In the kidney, NaDC1 plays an important role in regulating succinate and citrate concentrations in the urine, which may have physiological consequences including the development of kidney stones. In the present study, the impact of nonsynonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) on NaDC1 expression and function was characterized using the COS-7 cell heterologous expression system. The I550V variant had an increased sensitivity to lithium inhibition although there were no significant effects on protein abundance. The L44F variant had no significant effects on expression or function. The membrane protein abundance of the M45L, V117I, and F254L variants was decreased, with corresponding decreases in transport activity. The A310P variant had decreased protein abundance as well as a change in substrate selectivity. The P385S variant had a large decrease in succinate transport V(max), as well as altered substrate selectivity, and a change in the protein glycosylation pattern. The most damaging variant was V477M, which had decreased affinity for both succinate and sodium. The V477M variant also exhibited stimulation by lithium, indicating a change in the high-affinity cation binding site. We conclude that most of the naturally occurring nonsynonymous SNPs affect protein processing of NaDC1, and several also affect functional properties. All of these mutations are predicted to decrease transport activity in vivo, which would result in decreased intestinal and renal absorption of citric acid cycle intermediates.

Sodium-dependent extracellular accessibility of Lys-84 in the sodium/dicarboxylate cotransporter

The Na(+)/dicarboxylate cotransporter transports Na(+) with citric acid cycle intermediates such as succinate and citrate. The present study focuses on transmembrane helix 3, which is highly conserved among the members of the SLC13 family. Fifteen amino acids in the extracellular half of transmembrane helix (amino acids 98-112) as well as Lys-84, previously shown to affect substrate affinity, were mutated individually to cysteine and expressed in the human retinal pigment epithelial cell line. Transport specificity ratio analysis shows that determinants for distinguishing succinate and citrate are found at amino acids Lys-84, Glu-101, Trp-103, His-106, and Leu-111. All of the mutants were tested for sensitivity to the membrane-impermeant cysteine-specific reagent (2-sulfonatoethyl) methanethiosulfonate (MTSES), but only K84C was sensitive to MTSES inhibition. The sensitivity of K84C to MTSES was greatest in the presence of sodium, and the inhibition could be prevented by addition of substrate or replacement of sodium, indicating that the accessibility of Lys-84 changes with conformational state. The substrate protection of MTSES inhibition of K84C appears to occur early in the transport cycle, before the large-scale conformational change associated with translocation of substrate. The results point to a new location for Lys-84 within the substrate access pore of the Na(+)/dicarboxylate cotransporter, either in a transmembrane helix or a reentrant loop facing a water-filled pore.

Independent and simultaneous translocation of two substrates by a nucleotide sugar transporter

Nucleotide sugar transporters play an essential role in protein and lipid glycosylation, and mutations can result in developmental phenotypes. We have characterized a transporter of UDP-N-acetylglucosamine and UDP-N-acetylgalactosamine encoded by the Caenorhabditis elegans gene C03H5.2. Surprisingly, translocation of these substrates occurs in an independent and simultaneous manner that is neither a competitive nor a symport transport. Incubations of Golgi apparatus vesicles of Saccharomyces cerevisiae expressing C03H5.2 protein with these nucleotide sugars labeled with (3)H and (14)C in their sugars showed that both substrates enter the lumen to the same extent, whether or not they are incubated alone or in the presence of a 10-fold excess of the other nucleotide sugar. Vesicles containing a deletion mutant of the C03H5.2 protein transport UDP-N-acetylglucosamine at rates comparable with that of wild-type transporter, whereas transport of UDP-N-acetylgalactosamine was decreased by 85-90%, resulting in an asymmetrical loss of substrate transport.

Transport catalysis

Carrier linked solute transport through biomembranes is analysed with the viewpoint of catalysis. Different from enzymes, in carriers the unchanged substrate induces optimum fit in the transition state. The enhanced intrinsic binding energy pays for the energy required of the global conformation changes, thus decreasing the activation energy barrier. This "induced transition fit" (ITF) explains several phenomena of carrier transport, e.g., high or low affinity substrate requirements for unidirectional versus exchange, external energy requirement for "low affinity" transport, the existence of side specific inhibitors to ground states of the carrier, the requirement of external energy in active transport to supplement catalytic energy in addition to generate electrochemical gradients.

Role of conserved prolines in the structure and function of the Na+/dicarboxylate cotransporter 1, NaDC1

The Na+/dicarboxylate cotransporter 1 (NaDC1) is a low-affinity transporter for citric acid cycle intermediates such as succinate and citrate. The sequence of NaDC1 contains a number of conserved proline residues in predicted transmembrane helices (TMs) 7 and 10. These transmembrane domains are of particular importance because they may be involved in determining the substrate or cation-binding affinity in NaDC1. Four conserved proline residues in TMs 7 and 10 of rabbit NaDC1 were replaced with alanine to promote ideal alpha helix or glycine to promote free conformation, and the mutant transporters were expressed in the HRPE cell line. Mutations of prolines in TM 10 produced decreased protein expression and activity, whereas mutations of prolines in TM 7 completely abolished protein expression and activity. The chemical chaperone glycerol was found to improve the expression of the Pro-351 mutants in TM 7, suggesting that these mutants had defects in trafficking. The inactive mutant transporters at position 351 could also be rescued by the addition of a proline at a second site. For example, the P351A-F347P mutant had restored activity, although its substrate specificity was altered. We conclude that, in TM 7, Pro-327 may be of particular importance in the function of the transporter, whereas Pro-351 may affect protein targeting. The prolines in TM 10, at positions 523 and 524, may not be directly involved in the transporter function but may be necessary for maintaining structure.

Transmembrane helices 3 and 4 are involved in substrate recognition by the Na+/dicarboxylate cotransporter, NaDC1

The Na(+)/dicarboxylate cotransporters (NaDC1) from mouse (m) and rabbit (rb) differ in their ability to handle glutarate. Substrate-dependent inward currents, measured using two-electrode voltage clamp, were similar for glutarate and succinate in Xenopus oocytes expressing mNaDC1. In contrast, currents evoked by glutarate in rbNaDC1 were only about 5% of the succinate-dependent currents. To identify domains involved in glutarate transport, we constructed a series of chimeric transporters between mouse and rabbit NaDC1. Although residues found in multiple transmembrane helices (TM) participate in glutarate transport, the most important contribution is made by TM 3 and 4 and the associated loops. The R(M3-4) chimera, consisting of rbNaDC1 with substitution of TM 3-4 from mNaDC1, had a decreased K(0.5)(glutarate) of 4 mM compared with 15 mM in wild-type rbNaDC1 without any effect on K(0.5)(succinate). The chimeras were also characterized using dual-label competitive uptakes with (14)C-glutarate and (3)H-succinate to calculate the transport specificity ratio (TSR), a measure of relative catalytic efficiency with the two substrates. The TSR analysis provides evidence for functional coupling in the transition state between TM 3 and 4. We conclude that TM 3 and 4 contain amino acid residues that are important determinants of substrate specificity and catalytic efficiency in NaDC1.

Phospholipids as Determinants of Membrane Protein Topology

Evidence is accumulating that the topological organization and hence function of some membrane proteins are not solely determined by the amino acid sequence of the protein but are also influenced by the lipid composition of the membrane. The gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) permease (GabP) of Escherichia coli has been found in this study to be affected both topologically and kinetically by membrane lipids. Using single cysteine accessibility methods with viable E. coli strains of natural lipid composition and those lacking phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), we have shown that the N-terminal hairpin of GabP is inverted relative to the membrane in PE-lacking cells, with a hinge point in transmembrane domain III. The rate of GABA transport is reduced by more than 99% in PE-lacking cells. The Michaelis constant for GABA transport is not greatly affected nor is the dependence of transport on energy. However, "transport specificity ratio" analysis demonstrated a clear transition state stability difference for GABA and nipecotic acid between the protein in PE-containing and PE-lacking cells. The patterns of observed effects are similar to those seen with the phenylalanine transporter of E. coli (Zhang, W., Bogdanov, M. Pi, J. Pittard, A. J., and Dowhan, W. (2003) J. Biol. Chem. 278, 50128-50135), also an amino acid/polyamine/organocation family member but quite distinct from those observed with lactose permease (Bogdanov, M., Heacock, P. N., and Dowhan, W. (2002) EMBO J. 21, 2107-2116), a major facilitator superfamily member. Therefore, by extending the studies of similarities and differences in lipid responses among and between family groups, we may identify elements within the proteins that facilitate lipid responsiveness.