Selection of reference genes for the quantitative real-time PCR normalization of gene expression in Isatis indigotica fortune

Interrelationship among substrate utilization, metabolic productions, and housekeeping-related gene expression levels in Mortierella alpine CBS 754.68

The impacts of Magnesium oxide nanoparticles (MgONPs) on the expression of 10 potential housekeeping genes of Mortierella alpine were assayed. Actin emerged as the good candidate when Mortierella alpine entered the death phase subsequent to the growth phase while Dihydropteridine reductase and 28 s were identified as suitable candidates when Mortierella alpine remained in the growth phase.

Identification and validation of stable reference genes for RT-qPCR analyses of Kobresia littledalei seedlings

BACKGROUND

Kobreisa littledalei, belonging to the Cyperaceae family is the first Kobresia species with a reference genome and the most dominant species in Qinghai-Tibet Plateau alpine meadows. It has several resistance genes which could be used to breed improved crop varieties. Reverse Transcription Quantitative Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction (RT-qPCR) is a popular and accurate gene expression analysis method. Its reliability depends on the expression levels of reference genes, which vary by species, tissues and environments. However, K.littledalei lacks a stable and normalized reference gene for RT-qPCR analysis.

RESULTS

The stability of 13 potential reference genes was tested and the stable reference genes were selected for RT-qPCR normalization for the expression analysis in the different tissues of K. littledalei under two abiotic stresses (salt and drought) and two hormonal treatments (abscisic acid (ABA) and gibberellin (GA)). Five algorithms were used to assess the stability of putative reference genes. The results showed a variation amongst the methods, and the same reference genes showed tissue expression differences under the same conditions. The stability of combining two reference genes was better than a single one. The expression levels of ACTIN were stable in leaves and stems under normal conditions, in leaves under drought stress and in roots under ABA treatment. The expression of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) expression was stable in the roots under the control conditions and salt stress and in stems exposed to drought stress. Expression levels of superoxide dismutase (SOD) were stable in stems of ABA-treated plants and in the roots under drought stress. Moreover, RPL6 expression was stable in the leaves and stems under salt stress and in the stems of the GA-treated plants. EF1-alpha expression was stable in leaves under ABA and GA treatments. The expression levels of 28 S were stable in the roots under GA treatment. In general, ACTIN and GAPDH could be employed as housekeeping genes for K. littledalei under different treatments.

CONCLUSION

This study identified the best RT-qPCR reference genes for different K. littledalei tissues under five experimental conditions. ACTIN and GAPDH genes can be employed as the ideal housekeeping genes for expression analysis under different conditions. This is the first study to investigate the stable reference genes for normalized gene expression analysis of K. littledalei under different conditions. The results could aid molecular biology and gene function research on Kobresia and other related species.

Melatonin delayed senescence by modulating the contents of plant signalling molecules in postharvest okras

Okra has been widely cultivated worldwide. Consumers appreciate its nutritional value and delicious taste. However, okra is very perishable after harvest because of rapid senescence and high susceptibility to mechanical injuries, which limits its storage life and reduces consumer acceptance. This study examined the influence of melatonin treatment on senescence process and endogenous plant signalling molecules in postharvest okras. The results indicated that melatonin treatment delayed senescence by increasing the endogenous melatonin content through upregulation of its biosynthetic genes. In addition, the treatment increased the contents of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and gibberellin (GA) due to the positive modulation of their metabolic and signalling genes. Furthermore, treated okras exhibited higher levels of γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) but lower abscisic acid (ABA) content, contributing to the delayed senescence process compared to control. Overall, the findings suggested that melatonin postponed senescence in okras fruit by positively regulating endogenous signalling molecules such as melatonin, IAA, GABA, GA, and ABA.

Identification and Validation of Reference Genes for RT-qPCR Analysis in Reed Canary Grass during Abiotic Stress

Reed canary grass (Phalaris arundinacea L.) is known for its tolerance to drought, heavy metals, and waterlogging, making it a popular choice for forage production and wetland restoration in the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau (QTP). To accurately assess gene expression in reed canary grass under different abiotic stresses, suitable reference genes need to be identified and validated. Thirteen candidate reference gene sequences were selected and screened using RT-qPCR to detect their expression levels in reed canary grass leaves under drought, salt, cadmium, and waterlogging stresses. Four algorithms were used to assess the stability of the expression levels of the candidate reference genes. The most stably expressed genes were UBC and H3 under drought Cd, ETF and CYT under salt stress, and ETF and TUB under waterlogging stress. GAPDH was found to be less stable under abiotic stresses. PIP-1, PAL, NAC 90, and WRKY 72A were selected as response genes for quantitative expression assessment under drought, salt, Cd, and waterlogging stresses to confirm the accuracy of the selected stable reference genes. These results provide a theoretical reference for assessing gene expression in reed canary grass under abiotic stresses.

Selection and Validation of Optimal RT-qPCR Reference Genes for the Normalization of Gene Expression under Different Experimental Conditions in Lindera megaphylla

Lindera megaphylla, a broad-leaved evergreen that is used as a landscape ornamental plant and medicinal plant, is an ecologically important and dominant tree species. However, little is known about the molecular mechanisms of its growth, development, and metabolism. The selection of suitable reference genes is critical for molecular biological analyses. To date, no research on reference genes as a foundation for gene expression analysis has been undertaken in L. megaphylla. In this study, 14 candidate genes were selected from the transcriptome database of L. megaphylla for RT-qPCR assay under different conditions. Results showed that helicase-15 and UBC28 were most stable in different tissues of seedlings and adult trees. For different leaf developmental stages, the best combination of reference genes was ACT7 and UBC36. UBC36 and TCTP were the best under cold treatment, while PAB2 and CYP20-2 were the best under heat treatment. Finally, a RT-qPCR assay of LmNAC83 and LmERF60 genes were used to further verify the reliability of selected reference genes above. This work is the first to select and evaluate the stability of reference genes for the normalization of gene expression analysis in L. megaphylla and will provide an important foundation for future genetic studies of this species.

Evaluation of reference genes for qRT-PCR studies in the colchicine producing Gloriosa superba L

The flame lily, Gloriosa superba L., is one of the two primary sources of the anti-inflammatory drug, colchicine. Previous studies have shown that a higher level of colchicine production occurs in the rhizomes than in leaves and roots. Earlier precursor feeding and transcriptome analysis of G. superba have provided a putative pathway and candidate genes involved in colchicine biosynthesis. Comparative analysis of expression levels of candidate pathway genes in different tissues of G. superba using quantitative real-time reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR) can reveal highly expressed genes in the rhizome compared to other tissues which could suggest roles of the gene products in colchicine biosynthesis. Normalization is an important step in effectively analyzing differential gene expression by qRT-PCR with broader applications. The current study selected candidate reference genes from the transcriptome datasets and analyzed them to determine the most stable genes for normalization of colchicine biosynthesis-related genes. Using RefFinder, one stable reference gene, UBC22, was selected to normalize gene expression levels of candidate methyltransferase (MT) genes in the leaves, roots, and rhizomes of G. superba. With UBC22 as reference gene, the methyltransferases, GsOMT1, GsOMT3, and GsOMT4 showed significantly higher expression levels in the rhizome of G. superba, while MT31794 was more highly expressed in the roots. In conclusion, the current results showed a viable reference gene expression analysis system that could help elucidate colchicine biosynthesis and its exploitation for increased production of the drug in G. superba.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s11816-023-00840-x.

Genome-wide identification of the NAC transcription factor family and regulation of metabolites under salt stress in Isatis indigotica

NAC (NAM, ATAF1/2 and CUC2) transcription factors (TFs) are a class of TFs families unique to plants, which not only play an important role in the growth and developmental stages of plants but also function in response to stress and regulation of secondary metabolite biosynthesis. However, there are few studies on NAC genes in the medicinal plant Isatis indigotica. In this study, 96 IiNAC genes were identified based on the whole-genome data of I. indigotica, distributed in seven chromosomes and three contigs. IiNAC genes were structurally conserved and divided into 15 subgroups. Cis-elements were identified in the promoter region of the IiNAC gene in response to plant growth and development, abiotic stresses and hormones. In addition, transcriptome and metabolome data of I. indigotica leaves under salt stress were analyzed to construct a network of IiNAC gene co-expression and metabolite association. Ten differentially expressed IiNAC genes were co-expressed with 109 TFs, and Gene Ontology (GO) and Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) enrichment analyses revealed that most of these genes were associated with plant growth and development and abiotic stress responses. Eleven IiNAC genes were positively associated with 72 metabolites. Eleven IiNAC genes were positively or negatively associated with 47 metabolites through 37 TFs. Commonly associated secondary metabolites include two terpenoids, abscisic acid and bilobalide, two flavonoids, dihydrokaempferol and syringaldehyde, a coumarin, 7-methoxycoumarin, an alkaloid, lupinine, and quinone dihydrotanshinone I. This study provides important data to support the identification of the NAC gene family in I. indigotica and the regulatory functions of IiNAC genes in metabolites under salt stress.

Evaluation of Candidate Reference Genes for Gene Expression Analysis in Wild Lamiophlomis rotata

Lamiophlomis rotata (Benth.) Kudo is a perennial and unique medicinal plant of the Qinghai–Tibet Plateau. It has the effects of diminishing inflammation, activating blood circulation, removing blood stasis, reducing swelling, and relieving pain. However, thus far, reliable reference gene identifications have not been reported in wild L. rotata. In this study, we identified suitable reference genes for the analysis of gene expression related to the medicinal compound synthesis in wild L. rotata subjected to five different-altitude habitats. Based on the RNA-Seq data of wild L. rotata from five different regions, the stability of 15 candidate internal reference genes was analyzed using geNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and RefFinder. TFIIS, EF-1α, and CYP22 were the most suitable internal reference genes in the leaves of L. rotata from different regions, while OBP, TFIIS, and CYP22 were the optimal reference genes in the roots of L. rotata. The reference genes identified here would be very useful for gene expression studies with different tissues in L. rotata from different habitats.

Systematic Identification and Validation of Suitable Reference Genes for the Normalization of Gene Expression in Prunella vulgaris under Different Organs and Spike Development Stages

The quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR) is an efficient and sensitive method for determining gene expression levels, but the accuracy of the results substantially depends on the stability of the reference gene (RG). Therefore, choosing an appropriate reference gene is a critical step in normalizing qRT-PCR data. Prunella vulgaris L. is a traditional Chinese medicine herb widely used in China. Its main medicinal part is the fruiting spike which is termed Spica Prunellae. However, thus far, few studies have been conducted on the mechanism of Spica Prunellae development. Meanwhile, no reliable RGs have been reported in P. vulgaris. The expression levels of 14 candidate RGs were analyzed in this study in various organs and at different stages of Spica Prunellae development. Four statistical algorithms (Delta Ct, BestKeeper, NormFinder, and geNorm) were utilized to identify the RGs' stability, and an integrated stability rating was generated via the RefFinder website online. The final ranking results revealed that eIF-2 was the most stable RG, whereas VAB2 was the least suitable as an RG. Furthermore, eIF-2 + Histon3.3 was identified as the best RG combination in different periods and the total samples. Finally, the expressions of the PvTAT and Pv4CL2 genes related to the regulation of rosmarinic acid synthesis in different organs were used to verify the stable and unstable RGs. The stable RGs in P. vulgaris were originally identified and verified in this work. This achievement provides strong support for obtaining a reliable qPCR analysis and lays the foundation for in-depth research on the developmental mechanism of Spica Prunellae.

Identification of the bZIP gene family and regulation of metabolites under salt stress in isatis indigotica

The bZIP transcription factor family plays important roles in plant growth and development, response to stress, and regulation of secondary metabolite biosynthesis. The identification and molecular function of bZIP gene have been deeply studied in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana, but it has not been reported in the medicinal plant Isatis indigotica. In this study, 65 IibZIP genes were identified in the genome of I. indigotica, which were distributed on seven chromosomes, were highly conserved, could be classified into 11 subgroups. Transcriptomic and metabolomic data for leaves of I. indigotica exposed to salt stress were analyzed to construct an IibZIP gene co-expression network and metabolite correlation network. Seventeen IibZIP genes were co-expressed with 79 transcription factors, and GO and KEGG enrichment analysis showed that most of these genes were associated with abiotic stress and hormone responses of plants. 17 IibZIP genes regulated 110 metabolites through 92 transcription factor associations. In addition, IibZIP23, IibZIP38 and IibZIP51 were associated with six metabolites including three alkaloids (quinoline alkaloid stylopine, indole alkaloids tabersonine and indole-3-acetic acid), flavonoid myricetin 3-O-galactoside, and two primary metabolites 2-hydroxy-6-aminopurine, 3-dehydroshikimic acid were strongly correlated. This study provides data for identification of the IibZIP gene family and their regulation of metabolites in response to salt stress.

Genome-wide identification and expression analysis response to GA3 stresses of WRKY gene family in seed hemp (Cannabis sativa L)

WRKY transcription factor is one of the largest transcription factor families in higher plants. However, the investigations of the WRKY gene family have not yet been reported in seed hemp. In the present study, we identified 39 CasWRKYs at the genome-wide level and analyzed phylogenetic relationship, chromosome location, cis-acting elements, gene structure, conserved motif, and expression pattern. Based on the gene structure and phylogenetic analyses, CasWRKY proteins were divided into 3 groups and 7 subgroups. The gene duplication investigation revealed that 6 and 5 pairs of CasWRKY genes underwent tandem and segmental duplication events, respectively. These events may contribute to the diversity and expansion of the CasWRKY gene family. The regulatory elements in the promoter regions of CasWRKYs contained diverse cis-regulatory elements, among which P-box cis-regulatory elements showed high frequency, indicating that CasWRKYs can respond to the regulation of gibberellin. The expression profiles derived from RNA-seq and qRT-PCR showed that 13 CasWRKY genes could respond to GA₃ stress and affect fiber development, as well as play significant roles in stem growth and development. This study will serve as molecular basis and practical reference for further exploring the genetic evolution and biological function of CasWRKY genes in seed hemp.

Selection and validation of reference genes for quantitative real-time PCR of Quercus mongolica Fisch. ex Ledeb under abiotic stresses

Quercus mongolica Fisch. ex Ledeb is the main species of coniferous and broadleaved mixed forests in northeast and north China, which has high ornamental, economic, and ecological value. The appropriate reference genes must be selected for quantitative real-time PCR to reveal the molecular mechanisms of stress responses and their contribution to breeding of Q. mongolica. In the present study, we chose 11 candidate reference genes (TUA, CYP18, HIS4, RPS13, ACT97, TUB1, UBQ10, UBC5, SAND, PP2A, and SAMDC) and used four programs (GeNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and RefFinder) to assess the expression stability of the above genes in roots, stems, and leaves under five abiotic stress factors (cold, salt, drought, weak light, and heavy metal). The findings revealed that under various experimental environments, the most stable genes were different; CYP18, ACT97, and RPS13 ranked the highest under most experimental environments. Moreover, two genes induced by stress, CMO and P5CS2, were chosen to demonstrate the reliability of the selected reference genes in various tissues under various stress conditions. Our research provides a significant basis for subsequent gene function studies of Q. mongolica.

Selection and Validation of Reference Genes for Quantitative Real-Time PCR Analysis of Development and Tissue-Dependent Flower Color Formation in Cymbidium lowianum

The development and tissue-dependent color formation of the horticultural plant results in various color pattern flowers. Anthocyanins and carotenoids contribute to the red and yellow colors, respectively. In this study, quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR) is used to analyze the expression profiles of anthocyanin and carotenoids biosynthesis genes in Cymbidium lowianum (Rchb.f.) Rchb.f. Appropriate reference gene selection and validation are required before normalization of gene expression in qRT-PCR analysis. Thus, we firstly selected 12 candidate reference genes from transcriptome data, and used geNorm and Normfinder to evaluate their expression stability in lip (divided into abaxial and adaxial), petal, and sepal of the bud and flower of C. lowianum. Our results show that the two most stable reference genes in different tissues of C. lowianum bud and flower are EF1δ and 60S, the most unstable reference gene is 26S. The expression profiles of the CHS and BCH genes were similar to FPKM value profiles after normalization to the two most stable reference genes, EF1δ and 60S, with the upregulated CHS and BCH expression in flower stage, indicating that the ABP and CBP were activated across the stages of flower development. However, when the most unstable reference gene, 26S, was used to normalize the qRT-PCR data, the expression profiles of CHS and BCH differed from FPKM value profiles, indicating the necessity of selecting stable reference genes. Moreover, CHS and BCH expression was highest in the abaxial lip and adaxial lip, respectively, indicating that the ABP and CBP were activated in abaxial and adaxial lip, respectively, resulting in a presence of red or yellow segments in abaxial and adaxial lip. This study is the first to provide reference genes in C. lowianum, and also provide useful information for studies that aim to understand the molecular mechanisms of flower color formation in C. lowianum.

Transcriptome analysis reveals important candidate gene families related to oligosaccharides biosynthesis in Morindaofficinalis

Morinda officinalis How (MO) is one of the best-known traditional herbs and is widely cultivated in subtropical and tropical areas for many years, especially in southern China. Oligosaccharides are the major constituents in the roots of MO, which is well known for its therapeutic effects with anti-depression, anti-osteoporosis, memory-enhancing, ect. To date, the main gene families that regulate the biosynthetic pathway of MO oligosaccharides metabolism yet have been published. In our study, six cDNA libraries generated from six plants of MO were sequenced utilizing an Illumina HiSeq 4000 platform. Corresponding totals of more than 132.60 million clean reads were obtained from the six libraries and assembled into 25,812 unigenes with an average length of 1288 bp. Moreover, 6036 unigenes were found to be allocated to 26 pathways maps using several public databases, and 2538 differential expression genes (DEGs) were screened. Among them, 25 genes from three families were selected as the mainly candidate genes related to MO oligosaccharides biosynthesis. Then, the expression patterns of six DEGs closely related to MO oligosaccharides biosynthesis were verified by quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR). Besides, the MO was clustered more closely to Coffea arabica of Rubiaceae. In summary, the transcriptomic analysis was used to investigate the differences in expression genes of oligosaccharides biosynthesis, with the notable outcome that several key gene families were closely linked to oligosaccharides biosynthesis.

Isatis indigotica: a review of phytochemistry, pharmacological activities and clinical applications

OBJECTIVES

Isatis indigotica Fort. (I. indigotica) is an herbaceous plant belonging to Cruciferae family. Its leaf (IIL) and root (IIR) are commonly used in traditional Chinese medicines (TCMs) with good clinical efficacies such as clearing away heat and detoxification, cooling blood and reducing swelling. This review aimed to provide a systematic summary on the phytochemistry, pharmacology and clinical applications of I. indigotica.

KEY FINDINGS

This plant contains alkaloids, organic acids, flavonoids, lignans, nucleosides, amino acids, and steroids. Previous pharmacological researches indicated that I. indigotica possesses promising antivirus, antibacterial, immunoregulatory, anti-inflammation, and cholagogic effects. Importantly, it can inhibit various viruses, such as influenza, hepatitis B, mumps, herpes simplex, cytomegalovirus, and coxsachievirus. Clinically, it is frequently used to treat various viral diseases like viral influenza, parotitis and viral hepatitis. Consequently, I. indigotica may be beneficial for the prevention and treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19).

SUMMARY

This paper reviewed the chemical constituents, pharmacological effects and clinical applications of I. indigotica which may guide further research and application of this plant.

Identification and Validation of Reference Genes for Gene Expression Analysis in Schima superba

Real-time quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) is a reliable and high-throughput technique for gene expression studies, but its accuracy depends on the expression stability of reference genes. Schima superba is a fast-growing timber species with strong resistance. However, thus far, reliable reference gene identifications have not been reported in S. superba. In this study, 19 candidate reference genes were selected and evaluated for their expression stability in different tissues of S. superba. Three software programs (geNorm, NormFinder, and BestKeeper) were used to evaluate the reference gene transcript stabilities, and comprehensive stability ranking was generated by the geometric mean method. Our results show that SsuACT was the most stable reference gene and that SsuACT + SsuRIB was the best reference gene combination for different tissues. Finally, the stable and less stable reference genes were verified using SsuSND1 expression in different tissues. To our knowledge, this is the first report to verify appropriate reference genes for normalizing gene expression in S. superba for different tissues, which will facilitate the future elucidation of gene regulations in this species and useful references for relative species.

Identification and expression analysis of the WRKY gene family in Isatis indigotica

The WRKY proteins, which represent one of the largest families of transcriptional regulators in plants, play pivotal roles in regulating multiple processes of growth and development, particularly in diverse stress responses. Isatis indigotica is widely used in Traditional Chinese Medicine and is famous for its use as a dye for the color indigo. However, reports of the WRKY gene family in I. indigotica are limited. In this study, 64 IiWRKY genes encoding proteins with the complete WRKY domain were identified from genome of I. indigotica. Based on their structure and phylogenetic relationships of this gene family in I. indigotica, the IiWRKY genes were classified into three groups: Group I (n = 13), Group II (n = 35) and Group III (n = 16). Sequence alignment revealed that IiWRKY proteins harbored two variants, WRKYRQK and WRKYGKK, of the highly conserved WRKYGQK motif. The number of exons in IiWRKY genes varied from two to 14, with most of IiWRKY genes containing three exons. Investigation of gene duplication demonstrated that 10 and 14 IiWRKY genes were incorporated in tandem and segmental duplication events, respectively. Finally, the expression profiles derived from transcriptome data and quantitative real-time PCR analysis showed distinct expression patterns of these IiWRKY gene in five different organs or in response to four abiotic stresses. Taken together, our results will contribute to functional analysis of IiWRKY genes, and also provide a basis for further clarification of the molecular mechanism of stress responses in this important herb.

Selection and validation of reference genes for measuring gene expression in Toona ciliata under different experimental conditions by quantitative real-time PCR analysis

BACKGROUND

Before studying gene expression of different organisms, it is important to determine the best reference gene. At present, the most accurate method of detecting gene expression is quantitative real-time PCR (RT-qPCR). With this method, reference genes that are stable in different biological systems and under different conditions can be obtained. Toona ciliata Roem (T. ciliata). is a valuable and fast-growing timber specie. In this study, 20 reference genes were identified using RT-qPCR, as a primary prerequisite for future gene expression analysis. Four different methods, geNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and RankAggreg were used to evaluate the expression stability of the 20 candidate reference genes in various tissues under different conditions.

RESULTS

The experimental results showed that TUB-α was the most stably expressed reference gene across all samples and UBC17 was the most stable in leaves and young stems under Hypsipyla robusta (H. robusta) and methyl jasmonate (MeJA) treatments. In addition, PP2C59 and UBC5B were the best-performing genes in leaves under H. robusta treatment, while HIS1 and ACT7 were the best reference genes in young stems. The two best reference genes were 60S-18 and TUB-α after treatment at 4 °C. The expression of HIS6 and MUB1 was the most stable under PEG6000 treatment. The accuracy of the selected reference genes was verified using the transcription factor MYB3 (TcMYB3) gene.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first report to verify the best reference genes for normalizing gene expression in T. ciliata under different conditions, which will facilitate future elucidation of gene regulations in this species.

Systematic selection and validation of suitable reference genes for quantitative real-time PCR normalization studies of gene expression in Nitraria tangutorum

Suitable reference genes can be used to calibrate the error in quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) experiments, making the results more credible. However, there are no reference genes suitable for multiple species and under different experimental conditions. Nitraria tangutorum Bobr. is a typical plant native to desert areas. It is drought-resistant, saline-alkali resistant, extreme temperatures-resistant, and has strong adaptability. To date, the importance of this germplasm has not been sufficiently understood; therefore, it is still unclear which genes can be used as reference genes to calibrate qPCR data of N. tangutorum. In this study we analyzed the expression levels of 10 candidate reference genes (ACT, GAPDH, TUA, TUB, CYP, UBC, His, PP2A, HSP, and EF1-α) in N. tangutorum seedlings under a series of experimental conditions, including in different organs (root, stem, and leaf) and under abiotic stresses (salt, drought, heat, and cold) and hormone stimuli (abscisic acid) by qPCR. Three software programs (geNorm, NormFinder, and BestKeeper) were used to evaluate the expression stability of the ten genes. Comprehensive analysis showed that EF1-α and His had the best expression stability, whereas HSP was the least suitable as a reference gene. The expression profile of NtCER7, a gene related to the regulation of cuticular wax biosynthesis in N. tangutorum, verified the accuracy of the experimental results. Based on this study, we recommend EF1-α and His as suitable reference genes for N. tangutorum. This paper provides the first data on stable reference genes in N. tangutorum, which will be beneficial to studying the gene expression of N. tangutorum and other Nitraria species in the future.

Selection of suitable reference genes for qRT-PCR expression analysis of Codonopsis pilosula under different experimental conditions

Codonopsis pilosula is a well-known medicinal plant. Although its transcriptome sequence has been published, suitable reference genes have not been systematically identified for conducting expression analyses via quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR). To screen appropriate genes for use with this species, we applied four different methods-GeNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and RefFinder-to evaluate the stability of 13 candidates: CpiEF1Bb, CpiCACS, CpiF-Box, Cpiβ-Tubulin, CpiGAPDH, CpiActin2, CpiAPT1, CpiActin7, CpiActin8, CpiRPL6, CpiHAF1, CpiTubulin6, and CpiUBQ12. Expression was examined by qRT-PCR for various tissue types, chemical treatments, and developmental stages. For all tested samples, CpiGAPDH proved to be the most stable. Comprehensive analysis indicated that the most stable internal reference genes were CpiF-Box and CpiCACS in different tissues and at different developmental stages, respectively. Under NaCl stress, CpiAPT1 was the best internal reference gene. For methyl jasmonate and abscisic acid treatments, CpiGAPDH and CpiF-Box, respectively, presented the highest degree of expression stability. Based on these findings, we chose CpiSPL9 as the target gene for validating the suitability of these selected reference genes. All of these results provide a foundation for accurate quantification of expression levels by genes of interest in C. pilosula.

Identification and Validation of Reference Genes for Quantitative Gene Expression Analysis in Ophraella communa

Ophraella communa is an effective bio-control agent of the invasive common weed. By now, the reference genes in O. communa have not yet been screened and validated. The aim of this study was to screen for the most stable reference genes in different backgrounds, such as different developmental stages, sexes, tissues, and male reproductive system with different body sizes. We selected 12 common housekeeping genes involved in different biological processes, including GAPDH, ACT1, ACT2, ARF1, ARF4, SDH, βTUBC, RPL4, RPL19, RPS18, EF1α, and COX as the candidate reference genes. To analyze the stability of the candidate reference genes, we first used three dedicated algorithms, GeNorm, NormFinder, and BestKeeper, and further comprehensive ranking was provided by ReFinder. The results showed that RPL19 and RPL4 exhibited the least variation in different developmental stages/sexes and in male reproductive systems with different body sizes. COX proved to be most suitable for normalizing the gene expression levels in different tissues, and coincidentally, RPL19 was also found to be second in terms of stability in this study. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to identify suitable reference genes for analyzing gene expression in O. communa; thus, this study would lay the foundation for future research on the molecular physiology and biochemistry of O. communa and other insects.