Infection-free rates and Sequelae predict factors in bone transportation for infected tibia: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Clinical features of chronic tibial osteomyelitis: a single-center retrospective study of 282 cases in Xinjiang, China

BACKGROUND

Chronic osteomyelitis is a highly prevalent and severe orthopaedic complication, representing a critical unresolved issue. The clinical symptoms of osteomyelitis are influenced by various factors, including geography, lifestyle, and pre-existing medical conditions.This study aims to provide theoretical basis for treatment and prevention of osteomyelitis by investigating and analyzing clinical features and pathogen distribution among 282 patients with chronic tibial osteomyelitis in xinjiang.

METHODS

A total of 282 patients with chronic tibial osteomyelitis from January 1, 2012 to January 1, 2022 in the First Affiliated Hospital of Xinjiang Medical University were retrospectively analyzed. All data were collected from electronic medical record (EMR) system including demographics, etiology, risk factors, osteomyelitis location and clinical classification.

RESULTS

Farmers, students, unemployed and retirees accounted for a relatively large proportion of the 282 patients. There were 233 males and 49 females with a gender ratio of 4.75:1. The average age was 40.21 ± 15.68 years and was mainly concentrated in 41-50 years, specifically, the mean age of females was slightly older than that of males. Education level was mostly primary and secondary school education, and illiteracy. Risk factors of chronic tibial osteomyelitis included history of smoking and drinking, history of multiple repeated surgeries, and impaired immunity. Frequent clinical symptoms were in the order of pain, local swelling, pus discharge and skin ulceration. Among all inflammatory markers, proportion of positive results were 30.85%, 59.93% and 53.90% for white blood cell (WBC), erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) and C-reactive protein (CRP), respectively. Positive rate of pathogenic microorganism culture was low and the three most common bacteria were Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus), Pseudomonas aeruginosa (P. aeruginosa) and Escherichia coli (E. coli). The most frequent site of infection was middle tibia. According to Cierny-Mader osteomyelitis classification, the most common types were type IIIA, IVA and IIA.

CONCLUSION

Number of visits due to chronic osteomyelitis increased year by year, with young and middle-aged male farmers and low education level as the main groups. Smoking and drinking were two considerable risk factors that should be attached to a great importance. No significant increase was found in inflammatory markers and lower positive rate of pathogenic microorganism culture was observed. Multi-drug resistant bacteria were common and S. aureus remained the most frequent pathogen. Elevated ESR had certain diagnostic value for osteomyelitis. Type III and type IV osteomyelitis accounted for a large proportion which posed great challenges for clinical diagnosis and treatment.

Analysis of risk factors and development of a nomogram-based prediction model for defective bony non-union

Objective

To explore risk factors for defective non-union of bone and develop a nomogram-based prediction model for such an outcome.

Methods

This retrospective study analysed the case data of patients with defective bony non-unions who were treated at the authors' hospital between January 2010 and December 2020. Patients were divided into the union and non-union groups according to their Radiographic Union Score for Tibia scores 1 year after surgery. Univariate analysis was performed to assess factors related to demographic characteristics, laboratory investigations, surgery, and trauma in both groups. Subsequently, statistically significant factors were included in the multivariate logistic regression analysis to identify independent risk factors. A nomogram-based prediction model was established using statistically significant variables in the multivariate analysis. The accuracy and stability of the model were evaluated using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) and calibration curves. The clinical applicability of the nomogram model was evaluated using decision curve analysis.

Results

In total, 204 patients (171 male, 33 female; mean [±SD] age, 39.75 ± 13.00 years) were included. The mean body mass index was 22.95 ± 3.64 kg/m2. Among the included patients, 29 were smokers, 18 were alcohol drinkers, and 21 had a previous comorbid systemic disease (PCSD). Univariate analysis revealed that age, occupation, PCSD, smoking, drinking, interleukin-6, C-reactive protein (CRP), procalcitonin, alkaline phosphatase, glucose, and uric acid levels; blood calcium ion concentration; and bone defect size (BDS) were correlated with defective bone union (all P < 0.05). Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that PCSD, smoking, interleukin-6, CRP, and glucose levels; and BDS were associated with defective bone union (all P < 0.05), and the variables in the multivariate analysis were included in the nomogram-based prediction model. The value of the area under the ROC curve for the predictive model for bone defects was 0.95.

Conclusion

PCSD, smoking, interleukin-6, CRP, and glucose levels; and BDS were independent risk factors for defective bony non-union, and the incidence of such non-union was predicted using the nomogram. These findings are important for clinical interventions and decision-making.

The Outcomes of Distraction Osteogenesis over an Intramedullary Nail for the Treatment of Bone Defects in Infectious Nonunions

Objectives

The concurrent utilization of an external fixator and intramedullary nail (IMN) for segment transportation may potentially decrease the duration of external fixator implementation and reduce associated complications. This study aimed to report the outcomes of bone transport utilizing a combination of IMN and Ilizarov frame in a cohort of individuals who had tibia or femur critical-sized bone deficiency resulting from nonunion.

Methods

The present research used a single-arm clinical trial design to enroll a series of patients presenting with critical-sized bone defects resulting from infectious nonunion of the tibia or femur. The study was conducted during the period of 2017-2020 in a referral Orthopedic Surgery Center located in Tehran, Iran. The management of patients with infectious nonunion was carried out through two main stages, including infection eradication and bone transportation. The process of bone healing and segment transportation was evaluated by radiographic assessment throughout the follow-up period.

Results

A total of 39 patients with bone defects in the tibia (19 cases) or femur (20 cases) with a mean age of 31.44 (±11.95, range=18-60) were included in this study. Twenty-nine (74.3%) patients had open fractures. The bone defect exhibited an average size of 6.31 ± 1.95 cm. The mean of the consolidation index (CI) was 0.97 (range=0.51-1.32) mo/cm, and the mean of the external fixator index was 0.67 (range=0.41-1.10). Although the CI was longer in patients with open fracture compared to those with closed fracture, the difference was not statistically significant (P=0.353). After the end of the two-year follow-up, complete union was observed in 35 patients (89.7%).

Conclusion

Intercalary segmental bone transportation using the Ilizarov technique over an IMN, as well as preserving the advantages of the conventional callotasis method, reduces the complications of long-term use of the Ilizarov frame and increases patient adherence to treatment.

Septic Tibial Nonunions on Proximal and Distal Metaphysis-A Systematic Narrative Review

BACKGROUND

Infected nonunion of the tibia represents a challenging complication for orthopedic surgeons and poses a major financial burden to healthcare systems. The situation is even more compounded when the nonunion involves the metaphyseal region of long bones, a rare yet demanding complication due to the poor healing potential of infected cancellous bone; this is in addition to the increased likelihood of contamination of adjacent joints. The purpose of this study was to determine the extent and level of evidence in relation to (1) available treatment options for the management of septic tibial metaphyseal nonunions; (2) success rates and bone healing following treatment application; and (3) functional results after intervention.

METHODS

We searched the MEDLINE, Embase, and CENTRAL databases for prospective and retrospective studies through to 25 January 2021. Human-only studies exploring the efficacy of various treatment options and their results in the setting of septic, quiescent, and metaphyseal (distal or proximal) tibia nonunions in the adult population were included. For infection diagnosis, we accepted definitions provided by the authors of source studies. Of note, clinical heterogeneity rendered data pooling inappropriate.

RESULTS

In terms of the species implicated in septic tibial nonunions, staphylococcus aureus was found to be the most commonly isolated microorganism. Many authors implemented the Ilizarov external fixation device with a mean duration of treatment greater than one year. Exceptional or good bone and functional results were recorded in over 80% of patients, although the literature is scarce and possible losses of the follow-up were not recorded.

CONCLUSION

A demanding orthopedic condition that is scarcely studied is infected metaphyseal tibial nonunion. External fixation seems promising, but further research is needed.

SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION

PROSPERO No. CRD42020205781.

Treatment of Infected Tibial Metaphyseal Nonunions Using the Ilizarov Method: Protocol for a Prospective Nonrandomized Study

BACKGROUND

The management of infected metaphyseal nonunion of the tibia is devastating, especially when associated with significant bone loss, poor soft tissues, draining sinuses, axial deformity, knee or ankle joint stiffness, limb discrepancy, and multiresisted pathogens. A systematic review, performed recently by the primary investigators but not yet published, yielded the lack of studies in the field and the huge heterogeneity of the presented results. We found several bias and controversies such as no clear definition of the exact part of the tibia where the nonunion was located, the pathogen causing the fracture-related infection, the number of previous interventions and time to presentation, and the exact type of treatment methods including the use of muscle flaps or bone grafting. Time to final union as a functional score is another important but missing data.

OBJECTIVE

The proposed study is designed to evaluate a sufficient number of patients with infected metaphyseal tibial nonunions using various general health, functional, and bone scores.

METHODS

This prospective clinical trial study, with a minimum follow-up period of 36 months, focuses on the effectiveness of the Ilizarov method after radical nonunion debridement and targeted antibiotic therapy in patients with infected metaphyseal tibial nonunions. The primary outcomes would be the definite healing of nonunion and infection-free results. Secondary outcomes would be limb alignment and discrepancy, alteration in the patient's quality of life, and functional results. A power analysis calculated a minimum of 11 patients to obtain statistical power, but we aim to include at least 25 patients. Limb discrepancy, clinical validation of infection eradication and fracture healing, radiographic validation, and patient-reported outcome measures will be highlighted and correlated. Statistical analysis of the results will offer data missing from the literature so far. Measurements are scheduled at specific times for each patient: preoperatively, 3 and 6 months postoperatively, 1 month after Ilizarov frame removal, and once per semester afterward until the end of the follow-up period (minimum 36 months). Laboratory evaluation will be assessed once per month. Any complication will be reported and treated when it occurs.

RESULTS

The trial has already started. It was funded in June 2020. As of May 2022, 19 participants have been recruited and no major complications have been noticed yet. Data analysis will be performed after data collection ends, and results will be published afterward.

CONCLUSIONS

An infected metaphyseal tibial nonunion is a rare condition with limited treatment options and many controversies. There is no consensus in the literature about the best treatment strategy, and this lack of evidence should be fulfilled.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

International Standard Randomized Controlled Trial Number (ISRCTN) 30905788; https://www.isrctn.com/ISRCTN30905788.

INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID)

DERR1-10.2196/39319.

Comparative analysis of clinical outcome and quality of life between amputations and combined bone and flap reconstructions at the lower leg

PURPOSE

At the lower leg, soft tissue defects with exposed bones, tendons, or hardware require flap coverage. In this retrospective study, we analyzed combined bone and soft tissue reconstructions compared to amputations of the lower leg in a civilian setting.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patients who underwent combined bone and flap reconstruction (LR) or amputation (LA) of the lower leg were eligible for the study. Bone conditions included fractures and bony defects due to posttraumatic osteomyelitis and non-union. Besides the analysis of the medical history, the study included clinical examination including extremity functional scale (LEFS) and SF-36-questionnaire.

RESULTS

LEFS score was significantly higher in the LR group compared to the LA group. Importantly, 42% in the LR group as opposed to 80% in the LA group could not return to their occupation. Mean hospitalization was 119 in the LR and 49 days in the LA group. SF-36 body item scores were significantly higher in the LR group as compared to LA.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients undergoing complex extremity reconstructions, including flap transfer to the lower leg have better functionality and higher quality of life than amputated patients. These data emphasize the advantages of these procedures and justify reconstructive efforts for limb salvage. Level of Evidence III.Implications for RehabilitationAmputation and combined bone and flap reconstruction in severe injuries of the lower leg can imply functional disabilities even after successful treatment.Albeit longer hospitalizations, patients with complex reconstructions showed better functional outcomes and had a higher quality of life.Limb salvage showed better functional outcomes and a higher rate in reintegration to work as compared to limb amputation.These data emphasize the importance of complex bone and soft tissue reconstruction in this patient cohort.

Prospective randomized comparison of bone transport versus Masquelet technique in infected gap nonunion of tibia

AIM

The present prospective randomized study compared the bone transport technique (BT) and Masquelet technique (MT) in the treatment of infected gap non-union of the tibia.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Total 25 patients with infected gap non-union of the tibia with bone gap upto 6 cm were randomised into BT group (group I, 13 patients) and MT (group II, 12 patients). The mean age was 31.77 years in group I and 39.67 years in group II. The mean intra-operative bone gap was 3.92 cm in group I and 3.79 cm in group II. Monolateral fixator was applied in nine patients each in both groups, while four and three fractures were stabilized with ring fixators in group I and II, respectively. Mean follow-up was 31.62 months and 30.42 months in group I and II, respectively. Bone and functional results were compared using the association for the study and application of the method of Ilizarov (ASAMI) criteria.

RESULTS

The average fixator period was 9.42 and 16.33 months in group I and II, respectively (p < 0.001). Union was achieved in 12 (92%) patients and 6 (50%) patients in group I and II, respectively. The functional results were excellent (eight and two), good (four and six), fair (zero and three) and poor (one and one) in group I and II respectively, (p 0.23). The Bone results were excellent, good and poor in nine, three and one patients in group I, and three, three and six patients in group II respectively, (p 0.109).

CONCLUSIONS

The functional and bone results were comparable but more reliable in bone transport than the Masquelet technique. The fixator duration and incidence of non-union were higher in MT group. Ilizarov bone transport technique should be preferred in infected non-union of the tibia with bone loss upto 6 cm.

Antibiotic cement plate composite structure internal fixation after debridement of bone infection

An internal fixation composite structure of antibiotic cement plates was created. The aim of this study was to analyse the infection control effect of this structure when applied to treat a bone infection. We retrospectively analysed patients with bone infection admitted to our hospital between January 2013 and June 2019. After debridement, an antibiotic cement plate composite structure was used to fill and stabilize the defects. The treatment effect was evaluated at six months after surgery, and the infection control rate, factors associated with the recurrence of infection, and complications were analysed. If the patients had bone defects, the defect was repaired after infection control, and the infection control rate of all of the patients was re-evaluated at 12 months after surgery. A total of 548 patients were treated with this technique, including 418 men and 130 women. The infection sites included 309 tibias, 207 femurs, 16 radii and ulnae, 13 humeri, and 3 clavicles. After at least 6 months of follow-up, 92 patients (16.79%) had an infection recurrence and needed further treatment. The recurrence rate of the tibia was higher than that of the femur (P = 0.025). Eighty-nine out of 92 patients who relapsed underwent a second debridement with the same method, and the infection control rate after the second debridement was 94.71%. Complications included 8 cases of epidermal necrosis around the incision, 6 cases of internal fixation failure, and 30 cases of lower limb swelling. By the follow-up time of 12 months, another 6 patients had experienced recurrence of infection, and 4 cases were controlled after debridement. Finally, among all 548 cases, 7 patients remained persistently infected, and 6 underwent amputation. The infection control rate was 97.6% at the 1-year follow-up. The clinical efficacy of this new antibiotic cement plate composite structure for internal fixation after debridement of bone infection is stable and reliable.

Risk factors associated with infection recurrence of posttraumatic osteomyelitis treated with Ilizarov bone transport technique-a retrospective study of 149 cases

BACKGROUND

Post-traumatic tibial osteomyelitis is considered as complex clinical problem due to its unique characteristics such as prolonged course, multi-staged treatment and high recurrence rate. The purpose of this study is to identify and analyze the causes and risk factors associated with infection recurrence of tibial osteomyelitis treated with Ilizarov technique.

METHODS

From January 2011 to January 2019, a total of 149 patients with post-traumatic tibial osteomyelitis treated with Ilizarov bone transport technique were included in this study. Demographic and clinical data were collected and analyzed. Univariate analysis and logistic regression analysis were used to analyze the factors that may affect the recurrence or reinfection of post-traumatic tibial osteomyelitis after treated with Ilizarov bone transport technique.

RESULTS

All included patients were successfully followed up with an average of 37.5 month (18-78 month), among them, 17 patients (11.4%) occurred with recurrence or reinfection of tibial osteomyelitis in which 2 cases were in distraction area and 15 cases in docking site. Among them, 5 patients were treated successfully with appropriate intravenous antibiotic, the remaining 12 patients were intervened by surgical debridement or bone grafting after debridement. Univariate analysis showed that Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection, bone exposure, number of previous operations (> 3 times), blood transfusion during bone transport surgery, course of osteomyelitis > 3 months, diabetes was associated with recurrence or reinfection of postoperative tibial osteomyelitis. According to the results of logistic regression analysis, Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection, bone exposure, and the number of previous operations (> 3 times) are risk factors for recurrence or reinfection of posttraumatic tibial osteomyelitis treated with Ilizarov bone transport technique, with odds ratios (OR) of 6.055, 7.413, and 1.753, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The number of previous operations (> 3 times), bone exposure, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection are risk factors for infection recurrence of posttraumatic tibial osteomyelitis treated with Ilizarov bone transport technique.

Ilizarov bone transport using an intramedullary cable transportation system in the treatment of tibial bone defects

INTRODUCTION

Segmental tibia defects remain challenging for orthopedic surgeons to treat. The aim of this study was to demonstrate bone-related and functional outcomes after treatment of complex tibial bone defects using Ilizarov bone transport with a modified intramedullary cable transportation system (CTS).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We conducted a single-center, retrospective study including all 42 patients treated for tibial bone loss via Ilizarov bone transport with CTS between 2005 and 2018. Bone-related and functional results were evaluated according to the Association for the Study and Application of Methods of Ilizarov (ASAMI) scoring system. Complication and failure rates were determined by the patients' medical files.

RESULTS

Patients had a mean age of 45.5 ± 15.1 years. The mean bone defect size was 7.7 ± 3.4 cm, the average nonunion scoring system (NUSS) score was 59 ± 9.5 points, and the mean follow-up was 40.8 ± 24.4 months (range, 13-139 months). Complete bone and soft tissue healing occurred in 32/42 patients (76.2%). These patients had excellent (10), good (17), fair (2), and poor (3) results based on the ASAMI functional score. Regarding bone stock, 19 patients had excellent, 10 good, and 3 fair results. In total, 37 minor complications and 62 major complications occurred during the study. In 7 patients, bone and soft tissue healing occurred after CTS failure with either an induced membrane technique or classic bone transport; 3 patients underwent lower leg amputation. Patients with treatment failure were significantly older (57.6 vs. 41.8 years; p = 0.003). Charlson score and treatment failure had a positive correlation (Spearman's rho 0.43; p = 0.004).

CONCLUSION

Bone transport using both intramedullary CTS and Ilizarov ring fixation is viable for treating patients with bone loss of the tibia and complex infection or soft tissue conditions. However, a high number of complications and surgical revisions are associated with the treatment of this severe clinical entity and should be taken into account.

Role of the Ilizarov non-free bone plasty in the management of long bone defects and nonunion: Problems solved and unsolved

BACKGROUND

Ilizarov non-free bone plasty is a method of distraction osteogenesis using the Ilizarov apparatus for external fixation which originated in Russia and was disseminated across the world. It has been used in long bone defect and nonunion management along with free vascularized grafting and induced membrane technique. However, the shortcomings and problems of these methods still remain the issues which restrict their overall use.

AIM

To study the recent available literature on the role of Ilizarov non-free bone plasty in long bone defect and nonunion management, its problems and the solutions to these problems in order to achieve better treatment outcomes.

METHODS

Three databases (PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science) were searched for literature sources on distraction osteogenesis, free vascularized grafting and induced membrane technique used in long bone defect and nonunion treatment within a five-year period (2015-2019). Full-text clinical articles in the English language were selected for analysis only if they contained treatment results, complications and described large patient samples (not less than ten cases for congenital, post-tumor resection cases or rare conditions, and more than 20 cases for the rest). Case reports were excluded.

RESULTS

Fifty full-text articles and reviews on distraction osteogenesis were chosen. Thirty-five clinical studies containing large series of patients treated with this method and problems with its outcome were analyzed. It was found that distraction osteogenesis techniques provide treatment for segmental bone defects and nonunion of the lower extremity in many clinical situations, especially in complex problems. The Ilizarov techniques treat the triad of problems simultaneously (bone loss, soft-tissue loss and infection). Management of tibial defects mostly utilizes the Ilizarov circular fixator. Monolateral fixators are preferable in the femur. The use of a ring fixator is recommended in patients with an infected tibial bone gap of more than 6 cm. High rates of successful treatment were reported by the authors that ranged from 77% to 100% and depended on the pathology and the type of Ilizarov technique used. Hybrid fixation and autogenous grafting are the most applicable solutions to avoid after-frame regenerate fracture or deformity and docking site nonunion.

CONCLUSION

The role of Ilizarov non-free bone plasty has not lost its significance in the treatment of segmental bone defects despite the shortcomings and treatment problems encountered.

Comparison of Ilizarov Bifocal, Acute Shortening and Relengthening with Bone Transport in the Treatment of Infected, Segmental Defects of the Tibia

This prospective study compared bifocal acute shortening and relengthening (ASR) with bone transport (BT) in a consecutive series of complex tibial infected non-unions and osteomyelitis, for the reconstruction of segmental defects created at the surgical resection of the infection. Patients with an infected tibial segmental defect (>2 cm) were eligible for inclusion. Patients were allocated to ASR or BT, using a standardized protocol, depending on defect size, the condition of soft tissues and the state of the fibula (intact or divided). We recorded the Weber-Cech classification, previous operations, external fixation time, external fixation index (EFI), follow-up duration, time to union, ASAMI bone and functional scores and complications. A total of 47 patients (ASR: 20 patients, BT: 27 patients) with a median follow-up of 37.9 months (range 16-128) were included. In the ASR group, the mean bone defect size measured 4.0 cm, and the mean frame time was 8.8 months. In the BT group, the mean bone defect size measured 5.9cm, and the mean frame time was 10.3 months. There was no statistically significant difference in the EFI between ASR and BT (2.0 and 1.8 months/cm, respectively) (p = 0.223). A total of 3/20 patients of the ASR and 15/27 of the BT group needed further unplanned surgery during Ilizarov treatment (p = 0.006). Docking site surgery was significantly more frequent in BT; 66.7%, versus ASL; 5.0% (p < 0.0001). The infection eradication rate was 100% in both groups at final follow-up. Final ASAMI functional rating scores and bone scores were similar in both groups. Segmental resection with the Ilizarov method is effective and safe for reconstruction of infected tibial defects, allowing the eradication of infection and high union rates. However, BT demonstrated a higher rate of unplanned surgeries, especially docking site revisions. Acute shortening and relengthening does not reduce the fixator index. Both techniques deliver good functional outcome after completion of treatment.