Development of a rat model of toluene-abuse embryopathy

Changes in developmental body weight as a function of toluene exposure: A meta-analysis of animal studies

Inhalant abuse is a globally prevalent health issue with particular concerns about substance-abusing pregnant women. In both animal models and clinical case reports of toluene exposure, the primary physiological outcome measure of prenatal inhalant exposure is low birth weight (BW). However, the effect of prenatal toluene exposure on animal BW varies widely in the literature. To clarify this effect and investigate possible design moderators of pup BW, a systematic review and meta-analytic techniques were applied to the existing peer-reviewed animal literature of prenatal and postnatal exposure models to the inhaled solvent toluene. Of 288 studies screened, 24 studies satisfied the inclusion criteria. Evaluation of these studies indicated that toluene exposure was negatively associated with pup BW (d = -0.39), with external inhaled concentration, route of administration, day of weighing, and toluene exposure magnitude moderating this association. Investigators doing animal studies should be cognizant of these factors before investigating the reproductive and developmental outcomes associated with prenatal and postnatal toluene exposure.

Binge toluene exposure in pregnancy and pre-weaning developmental consequences in rats

Binge Toluene Exposure in Pregnancy and Pre-weaning Developmental Consequences in Rats. Bowen, S.E. and Hannigan, J.H. The persistent rate of abuse of inhaled organic solvents, especially among women of child-bearing age, raises the risk for teratogenic effects of maternal toluene abuse. In this study, timed-pregnant Sprague Dawley rats were exposed from Gestation Day (GD) 8 to GD20 to 12,000 or 8000 parts per million (ppm) toluene, or 0ppm (controls) for 30min twice daily, 60min total daily exposure. Pups were assessed from postnatal day (PN) 4 to PN21 using a developmental battery measuring growth (i.e., body weight), maturational milestones (e.g., eye opening & incisor eruption), and biobehavioral development (e.g., negative geotaxis & surface righting). Pups exposed in utero to 12,000ppm or 8000ppm toluene weighed significantly less than the non-exposed control pups beginning at PN4 and PN12 (respectively) until PN21. Toluene resulted in significant increases in an index of poor perinatal outcome, specifically a composite of malformations, defined "runting" and neonatal death. No significant delays were observed in reaching maturational milestones. The results reveal that brief, repeated, prenatal exposure to high concentrations of toluene can cause growth retardation and malformations in rats. A comparison of the present, conservative results with findings in previous studies implies that binge patterns of toluene exposure in pregnant rats modeling human solvent abuse can result in developmental and morphological deficits in offspring. These results do not exclude the possibility that maternal toxicity as well as teratogenic effects of toluene may contribute to outcomes. The results suggest that abuse of inhaled organic solvents like toluene may result in similar early developmental outcomes in humans.

Teratogenic exposures

A consideration of teratogenic exposures includes not only an agent (chemical, radiation, biologic) but an exposure level and timing of exposure. There are criteria by which exposures are evaluated for a causal connection with an abnormal outcome. We here review some teratogenic exposures and discuss how they were initially described and confirmed. We have limited our discussion to some of the exposures for which a connection to structural malformations has been accepted in some quarters, and we indicate some exposures for which a causal association awaits confirmation. We recommend that counselors find a reliable and updatable source of information on exposures during pregnancy.

Maternal and fetal blood and organ toluene levels in rats following acute and repeated binge inhalation exposure

Inhalation of organic solvents is a persistent form of drug abuse with particular concern being the abuse of inhalants by women of child-bearing age. While studies have begun assessing postnatal outcomes of offspring exposed prenatally to inhalants, relatively little is known about the distribution of toluene in blood and body tissues of pregnant, inhalant-abusing women, or in the fetuses. The present study assessed the tissue toluene levels attained following brief toluene exposures using a pre-clinical rat model of maternal inhalant abuse. Timed-pregnant Sprague-Dawley rats were exposed to toluene at 8000 or 12,000 parts per million (ppm) for 15, 30 or 45 min/exposure. Exposures occurred twice each day from gestational day 8 (GD8) through GD20. Immediately following the second exposure on GD8, GD14 and GD20 blood was taken from the saphenous vein of the dams. Following saphenous vein blood collection on GD20, dams were sacrificed and trunk blood was collected along with maternal tissue specimens from cerebellum, heart, lung, kidney and liver. The placenta, amniotic fluid and fetal brain were also collected. Results demonstrated that maternal saphenous blood toluene levels increased as the inhaled concentration of toluene and duration of exposure increased. The maternal cerebellum, heart, kidney and liver appeared to be saturated after 30 min on GD20 such that toluene levels in those organs were equivalent across all ambient concentrations of inhaled toluene. Toluene levels also increased in fetal brain as the inhaled concentration of toluene increased and in placenta and amniotic fluid as the duration of exposure increased. Toluene levels in all tissues at GD20, except maternal lung and amniotic fluid, were higher than in maternal saphenous blood suggesting that toluene concentrated in those organs. Measurement of toluene levels in blood and other tissues following repeated toluene exposure demonstrated that toluene readily reaches a variety of potential sites of action throughout the maternal-placental-fetal unit.

Developmental toxicity of prenatal exposure to toluene

Organic solvents have become ubiquitous in our environment and are essential for industry. Many women of reproductive age are increasingly exposed to solvents such as toluene in occupational settings (ie, long-term, low-concentration exposures) or through inhalant abuse (eg, episodic, binge exposures to high concentrations). The risk for teratogenic outcome is much less with low to moderate occupational solvent exposure compared with the greater potential for adverse pregnancy outcomes, developmental delays, and neurobehavioral problems in children born to women exposed to high concentrations of abused organic solvents such as toluene, 1,1,1-trichloroethane, xylenes, and nitrous oxide. Yet the teratogenic effects of abuse patterns of exposure to toluene and other inhalants remain understudied. We briefly review how animal models can aid substantially in clarifying the developmental risk of exposure to solvents for adverse biobehavioral outcomes following abuse patterns of use and in the absence of associated health problems and co-drug abuse (eg, alcohol). Our studies also begin to establish the importance of dose (concentration) and critical perinatal periods of exposure to specific outcomes. The present results with our clinically relevant animal model of repeated, brief, high-concentration binge prenatal toluene exposure demonstrate the dose-dependent effect of toluene on prenatal development, early postnatal maturation, spontaneous exploration, and amphetamine-induced locomotor activity. The results imply that abuse patterns of toluene exposure may be more deleterious than typical occupational exposure on fetal development and suggest that animal models are effective in studying the mechanisms and risk factors of organic solvent teratogenicity.

Toluene inhibits muscarinic receptor-mediated cytosolic Ca2+ responses in neural precursor cells

Toluene is widely used as a component in industrial solvents and many toluene-containing products are abused via inhalation. While many studies have demonstrated its inhibitory effects on neuronal activity, the effects of toluene on receptor signaling in proliferating and differentiating neural precursor cells are presently unclear. Here, using digital video microscopy and Ca2+ imaging, we investigated the effects of acute exposure to toluene on the function of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors (mAChRs) expressed in neural precursor cells. The neural precursor cells were isolatedfrom embryonic day 13 (E13) rat cortex and expanded in serum-free medium containing basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF). We found that the acetylcholine (ACh) analog carbachol (CCh) induced a dose-dependent increase in cytosolic Ca2+, which was blocked by the muscarinic receptor antagonist atropine in a reversible manner. Toluene was added to the perfusion medium and concentrations of toluene in the medium were determined by gas chromatographic analysis. Following imaging, the cells were fixed and processed for 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU, cell proliferation marker) and beta-tubulin (TuJ1, neuronal marker) immunostaining. In the 5 day culture, most cells continued to divide (BrdU+), while afew cells differentiated into young neurons (TuJ1-). The CCh-induced Ca2+ elevations in proliferating (BrdU+TuJ1-) neural precursor cells were significantly reduced by acute exposure to 0.15 mM toluene and completely blocked by 10 mM toluene. Toluene's inhibition of muscarinic receptor-mediated Ca2+ signaling was rapid, reversible and dose-dependent with an IC50 value 0.5 mM. Since muscarinic receptors mediate cell proliferation and differentiation during neural precursor cell development, these results suggest that depression of muscarinic signaling may play a role in toluene's teratogenic effect on the developing nervous system.

Developmental toxicity: web resources for evaluating risk in humans

This review presents a brief overview of Internet resources that provides information on developmental toxicity. The advantages and limitations of these resources for evaluating human risk and where each one is useful for informing various stages of the risk assessment process (i.e. hazard characterization, dose-response assessment, exposure assessment and risk characterization) are reviewed. How these Internet resources can be utilized to obtain information on and evaluate the developmental risk associated with exposures during pregnancy will be illustrated using toluene. Translating information derived from laboratory and human population studies into clinical management prescriptions for individual patients is difficult. With the increasing availability of Internet resources that provide information relevant for developmental risk assessments, health care professionals will be better equipped to make more accurate estimations of potential risk for their patients.

Developmental neurotoxicity: do similar phenotypes indicate a common mode of action? A comparison of fetal alcohol syndrome, toluene embryopathy and maternal phenylketonuria

Developmental neurotoxicity can be ascribed to in utero exposure to exogenous substances or to exposure of the fetus to endogenous compounds that accumulate because of genetic mutations. One of the best recognized human neuroteratogens is ethanol. The Fetal Alcohol Syndrome (FAS) is characterized by growth deficiency, particular facial features, and central nervous system (CNS) dysfunctions (mental retardation, microencephaly and brain malformations). Abuse of toluene by pregnant women can lead to an embryopathy (fetal solvent syndrome, (FSS)) whose characteristics are similar to FAS. Phenylketonuria (PKU) is a genetic defect in phenylalanine (Phe) metabolism. Offspring of phenylketonuric mothers not under strict dietary control are born with maternal PKU (mPKU), a syndrome with similar characteristics as FAS and FSS. While ethanol has been shown to cause neuronal death, no such evidence is available for toluene or Phe and/or its metabolites. On the other hand, alterations in astrocyte proliferation and maturation have been found, mostly in in vitro studies, which may represent a potential common mode of action for at least some of the CNS effects found in FAS, mPKU, and FSS. Further in vivo and in vitro studies should validate this hypothesis and elucidate possible molecular targets.

Changes in markers of oxidative stress and membrane properties in synaptosomes from rats exposed prenatally to toluene

The present study was undertaken in order to investigate if toluene induced oxidative stress in brains from rats exposed prenatally to 1800 ppm toluene 6 hr/day at days 7-20 during the pregnancy. 35-42 days after birth the rats were killed and synaptosomal fractions were prepared for the experiments. Synaptosomes from rats exposed prenatally to toluene exhibited an increased level of oxidative stress when incubated with toluene in vitro compared to synaptosomes from unexposed offspring. Also the cell membrane was affected, as the calcium leakage was more increased from exposed synaptosomes than from unexposed. The membrane fluidity increased significantly when synaptosomes were incubated with toluene for 10 min. in vitro but the change in fluidity was identical in both groups of offspring. The results indicate that prenatal exposure to toluene induces long-lasting changes in oxidative status and membrane function.

Prenatal exposure to toluene results in abnormal neurogenesis and migration in rat somatosensory cortex

Toluene inhalant abuse during pregnancy may result in growth-retarded microcephalic newborns who subsequently demonstrate developmental impairment. By using a rat model of toluene-abuse embryopathy, we studied the effects of prenatal toluene exposure on the generation and migration of cortical neurons. Dams were exposed by gavage to either corn oil or toluene diluted in corn oil on d 6-21 of gestation. The time of origin of cortical neurons was determined in the mature pups of dams injected with the thymidine analogue 5'-bromodeoxyuridine on 1 d during the period from d 13-21 of gestation. 5'-Bromodeoxyuridine-labeled neurons were identified by immunohistochemistry in a 400-microm-wide column of somatosensory cortex. The brains of the toluene-exposed pups had a significant reduction in the number of neurons within each cortical layer (p < 0.001). Depending on the cortical layer, the generation of neurons in the toluene-exposed pups was delayed by 1 or 2 d. In addition, the brains of the toluene-exposed pups also showed evidence of abnormal neuronal migration. However, there were no differences in either brain weight or body weight between the control and toluene-exposed pups. These observations suggest that although prenatal toluene exposure results in abnormal neuronal proliferation and migration, brain weight in the toluene-exposed pups may be preserved by enhanced development of glia or the neuropil.

In situ (mesocosm) assessment of immunotoxicity risks to small mammals inhabiting petrochemical waste sites

Oil refineries inadvertently deposit a variety of complex mixtures of organic hydrocarbons and heavy metals in the soil, many of which are thought to be potent immunotoxicants. Terrestrial ecosystems such as this have not been adequately investigated with respect to wild rodent populations. The primary objective of this study was to use mesocosms to assess the immunotoxicity risks to feral small mammal populations associated with soils contaminated with petroleum refinery wastes. A series of 4-week and 8-week exposure trials using laboratory raised cotton rats (Sigmodon hispidus) were conducted in situ on three contaminated and three reference sites on the Oklahoma Refining Company Superfund Waste Site, Cyril, Oklahoma. Cotton rats exposed to these soils showed significant alterations in selected morphological traits, in vivo humoral immune responses, complement activity, and macrophage activity. However, immune alterations were not great, suggesting that resident small mammals may be a better biomonitoring choice than using mesocosms.

Toluene abuse embryopathy: longitudinal neurodevelopmental effects of prenatal exposure to toluene in rats

To determine the longitudinal effects of prenatal exposure to toluene in rats, dams received daily gavage doses of toluene diluted in corn oil on Days 6 through 19 of gestation, whereas control dams received corn oil. Litters were evaluated either on Gestational Day 19, Postnatal Day 10, or Postnatal Day 21; morphometric analysis of brain and measurements of brain DNA, cholesterol, and protein were made. Prenatal toluene exposure produced growth retarded fetuses with smaller brain and caudate-putamen volumes, fewer forebrain cell nuclei (DNA), and a reduction in both hindbrain cell size (protein/DNA) and myelination per cell (cholesterol/DNA). Postnatal catch-up growth occurred in the prenatally toluene-exposed pups, and by Postnatal Day 21 these differences had resolved. However, on Postnatal Day 21, a significant reduction in forebrain myelination/cell was present in the prenatally toluene-exposed pups. Therefore, whereas the effects of toluene administered prior to the time of the brain growth spurt were, for the most part, reversible, these exposures resulted in reduced forebrain myelination that may be permanent.