Correction of ureagenesis after gene transfer in an animal model and after liver transplantation in humans with ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency

A simple dried blood spot-method for in vivo measurement of ureagenesis by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry using stable isotopes

BACKGROUND

Clinical management of inherited or acquired hyperammonemia depends mainly on the plasma ammonia level which is not a reliable indicator of urea cycle function as its concentrations largely fluctuate. The gold standard to assess ureagenesis in vivo is the use of stable isotopes.

METHODS

Here we developed and validated a simplified in vivo method with [¹⁵N]ammonium chloride ([¹⁵N]H₄Cl) as a tracer. Non-labeled and [¹⁵N]urea were quantified by GC-MS after extraction and silylation.

RESULTS

Different matrices were evaluated for suitability of analysis. Ureagenesis was assessed in ornithine transcarbamylase (OTC)-deficient spf^ash mice with compromised urea cycle function during fasted and non-fasted feeding states, and after rAAV2/8-vector delivery expressing the murine OTC-cDNA in liver. Blood (5μL) was collected through tail vein puncture before and after [¹⁵N]H₄Cl intraperitoneal injections over a two hour period. The tested matrices, blood, plasma and dried blood spots, can be used to quantify ureagenesis. Upon [¹⁵N]H₄Cl challenge, urea production in spf^ash mice was reduced compared to wild-type and normalized following rAAV2/8-mediated gene therapeutic correction. The most significant difference in ureagenesis was at 30min after injection in untreated spf^ash mice under fasting conditions (19% of wild-type). Five consecutive injections over a period of five weeks had no effect on body weight or ureagenesis.

CONCLUSION

This method is simple, robust and with no apparent risk, offering a sensitive, minimal-invasive, and fast measurement of ureagenesis capacity using dried blood spots. The stable isotope-based quantification of ureagenesis can be applied for the efficacy-testing of novel molecular therapies.

In vivo monitoring of urea cycle activity with (13)C-acetate as a tracer of ureagenesis

BACKGROUND

The hepatic urea cycle is the main metabolic pathway for detoxification of ammonia. Inborn errors of urea cycle function present with severe hyperammonemia and a high case fatality rate. Long-term prognosis depends on the residual activity of the defective enzyme. A reliable method to estimate urea cycle activity in-vivo does not exist yet. The aim of this study was to evaluate a practical method to quantify (13)C-urea production as a marker for urea cycle function in healthy subjects, patients with confirmed urea cycle defect (UCD) and asymptomatic carriers of UCD mutations.

METHODS

(13)C-labeled sodium acetate was applied orally in a single dose to 47 subjects (10 healthy subjects, 28 symptomatic patients, 9 asymptomatic carriers).

RESULTS

The oral (13)C-ureagenesis assay is a safe method. While healthy subjects and asymptomatic carriers did not differ with regards to kinetic variables for urea cycle flux, symptomatic patients had lower (13)C-plasma urea levels. Although the (13)C-ureagenesis assay revealed no significant differences between individual urea cycle enzyme defects, it reflected the heterogeneity between different clinical subgroups, including male neonatal onset ornithine carbamoyltransferase deficiency. Applying the (13)C-urea area under the curve can differentiate between severe from more mildly affected neonates. Late onset patients differ significantly from neonates, carriers and healthy subjects.

CONCLUSION

This study evaluated the oral (13)C-ureagenesis assay as a sensitive in-vivo measure for ureagenesis capacity. The assay has the potential to become a reliable tool to differentiate UCD patient subgroups, follow changes in ureagenesis capacity and could be helpful in monitoring novel therapies of UCD.

AAV2/8-mediated correction of OTC deficiency is robust in adult but not neonatal Spf(ash) mice

Ornithine transcarbamylase (OTC) deficiency, the most common urea cycle disorder, is associated with severe hyperammonemia accompanied by a high risk of neurological damage and death in patients presenting with the neonatal-onset form. Contemporary therapies, including liver transplantation, remain inadequate with considerable morbidity, justifying vigorous investigation of alternate therapies. Clinical evidence suggests that as little as 3% normal enzyme activity is sufficient to ameliorate the severe neonatal phenotype, making OTC deficiency an ideal model for the development of liver-targeted gene therapy. In this study, we investigated metabolic correction in neonatal and adult male OTC-deficient Spf(ash) mice following adeno-associated virus (AAV)2/8-mediated delivery of the murine OTC complementary DNA under the transcriptional control of a liver-specific promoter. Substantially supraphysiological levels of OTC enzymatic activity were readily achieved in both adult and neonatal mice following a single intraperitoneal (i.p.) injection, with metabolic correction in adults being robust and life-long. In the neonates, however, full metabolic correction was transient, although modest levels of OTC expression persisted into adulthood. Although not directly testable in Spf(ash) mice, these levels were theoretically sufficient to prevent hyperammonemia in a null phenotype. This loss of expression in the neonatal liver is the consequence of hepatocellular proliferation and presents an added challenge to human therapy.

Complex management of a patient with a contiguous Xp11.4 gene deletion involving ornithine transcarbamylase: a role for detailed molecular analysis in complex presentations of classical diseases

A male infant was diagnosed prenatally with a partial ornithine transcarbamylase (OTC) gene deletion and managed from birth. However, he displayed neurological abnormalities and developed pleural effusions, ascites and anasarca not solely explained by OTC deficiency (OTCD). Further evaluation of the gene locus using exon-specific PCR and high-density SNP array copy number analysis revealed a 3.9-Mb deletion from Xp11.4 to Xp21.1 including five additional gene deletions, three causing the known genetic diseases: Retinitis pigmentosa (RP3), X-linked chronic granulomatous disease (CGD) and McLeod syndrome. The case illustrates (1) the complexities of managing a patient with neonatal onset OTCD, CGD, RP3 and McLeod syndrome, (2) the need for detailed evaluation in seemingly "isolated" gene deletions and (3) the clinical utility of high-density copy number analysis for rapidly characterizing chromosomal lesions.

Urea-cycle disorders as a paradigm for inborn errors of hepatocyte metabolism

Urea-cycle disorders (UCDs) are a group of inborn errors of hepatocyte metabolism that are caused by the loss of enzymes involved in the process of transferring nitrogen from ammonia to urea, via the urea cycle (UC). Recent genetic analyses of inherited disorders that present with hyperammonemia demonstrate the function of cellular transporters that regulate the availability of UC intermediates. The regulation of UC intermediates, such as arginine, could have far reaching implications on nitric-oxide synthesis and vascular tone. Hence, each UCD and UC-related disorder constitutes a unique gene-nutrient interaction that is crucial for postnatal homeostasis. Recent advances in the diagnosis and management of UCDs include the application of in vivo metabolic-flux measurements. Cumulative morbidity is still high despite dietary and pharmacological therapies and, hence, both cell and gene therapies are being pursued as possible long-term corrective treatments. Although gene-replacement therapy has suffered recent clinical setbacks, new vector developments offer hope for the treatment of cell-autonomous defects of hepatocyte metabolism.

Long-term correction of urea cycle disorders

Long-term correction of urea cycle disorders is achieved by correction of the enzymatic defect in hepatocytes. Currently, orthotopic liver transplantation is the primary means of achieving this correction. In the United States most liver transplantations for urea cycle disorders have been restricted to patients with ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency and argininosuccinic aciduria. However, patients with citrullinemia have also received transplants, but more so in Europe and Japan. Recent advances in organ procurement, surgical technique, and immunosuppression have significantly decreased morbidity and mortality. However, unique short-term complications associated with surgery and long-term complications associated with chronic immunosuppression have spurred continued efforts to develop gene replacement therapies for management of acute metabolic decompensations as intercurrent therapy until liver transplantation, and ultimately, for long-term correction. The pathophysiology of urea cycle disorders requires gene vector delivery systems that are highly efficient for liver transduction and transgene expression. To date, adenoviral vectors are unique in fulfilling these criteria, and significant data have been gained in both animal and human studies with early versions of adenoviral vectors. Ultimately, the development of helper-dependent adenoviral vectors may offer the long-term expression and increased margin of safety necessary for adjunctive therapies.

Urea cycle disorders

Deficiency of any of the five enzymes in the urea cycle results in the accumulation of ammonia and leads to encephalopathy. Episodes of encephalopathy and associated symptoms are unpredictable and, if untreated, are lethal or produce devastating neurologic sequelae in long-term survivors. Although these disorders do not produce liver disease, the consequences of hyperammonemia resemble those seen in patients with hepatic failure or in a transient interference with the urea cycle, as seen in some forms of organic acidemias. Therefore, investigation for hyperammonemia in any infant or child with altered mental status (in the absence of obvious causes, such as trauma, infection, or poisoning) is essential for prompt diagnosis of urea cycle disorders and institution of treatment to avoid brain damage and death. This article addresses the function of the urea cycle and the diagnosis and management of urea cycle disorders.

Evidence for forebrain cholinergic neuronal loss in congenital ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency

Congenital ornithine transcarbamylase (OTC) deficiency in humans results in failure to thrive, hypotonia, seizures and mental retardation. Neuropathologic evaluation reveals significant cerebral cortical atrophy, delayed myelination and Alzheimer type II astrocytosis. Using an animal model of congenital OTC deficiency, the sparse fur (spf) mouse, studies reveal convincing evidence of a loss of forebrain cholinergic neurons in this condition. Evidence includes (i) reduced activities of the cholinergic nerve terminal enzyme choline acetyltransferase (ChAT), (ii) a 25% loss of ChAT immunostaining, (iii) reduced high affinity transport of [3H]choline by cortical synaptosomes and (iv) a selective reduction in densities of presynaptic muscarinic M2 binding sites, in spf mouse brain compared to controls. A partial correction of the cholinergic deficit was observed following treatment with acetyl-L-carnitine. Possible mechanisms responsible for cholinergic neuronal loss in congenital OTC deficiency include decreased synthesis of the ChAT substrate acetyl CoA, impaired cerebral energy metabolism and NMDA receptor-mediated excitotoxicity. Loss of forebrain cholinergic neurons is consistent with the severe cognitive impairment characteristic of congenital OTC deficiency.