Prospective and longitudinal long-term employment outcomes after resective epilepsy surgery

Individuals' invisible work continues after epilepsy surgery: A qualitative interview study

OBJECTIVE

How do persons with epilepsy (PWE) experience their everyday lives after epilepsy surgery?

METHODS

Qualitative thematic interviews were conducted with eight PWEs (30 to 60 years old). They were recruited when coming for post-operative control 1 to 5 years after epilepsy surgery. The interviews were transcribed. They were analysed by thematic analysis and inspired by Goffman who examines everyday life activities as a theatre play.

RESULTS

Before surgery, a substantial invisible and hidden work of adjustments was performed to prevent seizures, to secure help from others if seizures occurred, and to protect oneself from others' gaze during a seizure. This invisible work continued after surgery even for those who became seizure-free; but now for the purpose of protecting oneself from relapse of epilepsy. From the participants perspective there was no or minor change in daily activities among those not becoming seizure-free after surgery. In contrast, those who became seizure-free enjoyed the freedom to participate in social activities without planning or restrictions.

CONCLUSIONS

A striking finding was that daily life after surgery comprises considerably invisible work to protect a social self, and this preventive and protective invisible work continued, although those who became seizure-free were living an ordinary socially healthy life.

How are they doing as adults? Psychosocial and socioeconomic outcomes 11-30 years after pediatric epilepsy surgery

OBJECTIVE

Pediatric epilepsy surgery yields cure from epilepsy or complete seizure control with continued medication in many patients early in life. This study aimed to evaluate the long-term (>10 years) psychosocial and socioeconomic outcomes of pediatric epilepsy surgery and examine the role of comorbid disability, type of surgery, seizure freedom, and age at surgery.

METHODS

A novel ad hoc parent/patient questionnaire was used to assess educational and occupational attainment, marital/familial status, mobility, and other outcomes in patients who underwent unilobar or multilobar surgery for drug-refractory epilepsy during their childhood. The questionnaire also captured information on comorbid disability.

RESULTS

Of the 353 eligible patients, 203 could still be contacted and 101 of these (50%) returned appropriately filled-in questionnaires (follow-up intervals: 11-30 [mean: 19.6] years). The cure from epilepsy rate was 53%. Type of surgery was strongly confounded by comorbid disability. Patients with comorbid disabilities had significantly lower rates of regular school degrees, gainful employment, marriage, and driving license (N = 29; 12%, 4%, 0%, 3%) compared with non-disabled patients (N = 69; 89%, 80%, 43%, and 67%, respectively). Patients achieved lower school degrees than their siblings and parents. Non-disabled seizure-free patients had better employment and mobility outcomes compared with non-seizure-free patients. Age at surgery (<10 vs. ≥10 years of age) did not have any effect on any outcome in patients with preschool seizure onset.

SIGNIFICANCE

Pediatric epilepsy surgery can lead to permanent relief from epilepsy in many patients, but comorbid disability strongly impacts adult life achievement. In non-disabled patients, favorable outcomes in academic, occupational, marital, and mobility domains were achieved, approaching respective rates in the German population. Complete seizure freedom had additional positive effects on employment and mobility in this group. However, in case of chronic comorbid disability the overall life prospects may be limited despite favorable seizure outcomes.

A procedure for predicting, illustrating, communicating, and optimizing patient-centered outcomes of epilepsy surgery using nomograms and Bayes' theorem

Clinicians have an ethical obligation to obtain and convey relevant information about possible treatment outcomes in a manner that can be comprehended by patients. This contributes to the processes of informed consent and shared prospective decision-making. In epilepsy neurosurgery, there has historically been an emphasis on studying clinician-centered (e.g., seizure- and cognition-related) outcomes and using these data to inform recommendations and, by extension, to frame pre-surgical counseling with respect to patients' decisions about elective neurosurgery. In contrast, there is a relative dearth of available data related to patient-centered outcomes of epilepsy neurosurgery, such as functional (e.g., employment) status, and there is also a lack of methods to communicate these data to patients. Here, illustrated using a hypothetical case scenario, we present a potential solution to the latter of these problems using principles of evidence-based neuropsychology; published data on patient employment status before and after epilepsy neurosurgery; and Bayes' theorem. First, we reviewed existing literature on employment outcomes following epilepsy neurosurgery to identify and extract data relevant to our hypothetical patient, clinical question, and setting. Then, we used the base rate (prior probability) of post-surgical unemployment, contingency tables (to derive likelihood ratios), and Bayes' theorem to compute the conditional (posterior) probability of post-surgical employment status for our hypothetical patient scenario. Finally, we translated this information to an intuitive visual format (Bayesian nomogram) that can support evidence-based pre-surgical counseling. We propose that the application of our patient-centered decision-support process and visual aid will improve clinician-patient communication about prospective risks and benefits of epilepsy neurosurgery and will empower clinicians and patients to make informed decisions about whether or not to pursue elective neurosurgery with a greater degree of confidence and with more realistic and concrete expectations about possible outcomes. We further propose that clinicians and patients would benefit from incorporating this evidence-based framework into a broader sequence of function-focused epilepsy treatment that includes pre-surgical assessments and interventions ("prehabilitation"), neurosurgery, and post-surgical cognitive/vocational rehabilitation.

Clinical adult outcome 11-30 years after pediatric epilepsy surgery: Complications and other surgical adverse events, seizure control, and cure of epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

Pediatric epilepsy surgery promises seizure freedom or even cure of epilepsy. We evaluated the long-term (≥10 years) adult clinical outcome including surgery-related adverse events and complications, which are generally underreported.

METHODS

A monocentric, single-arm, questionnaire study in now adult patients who underwent epilepsy surgery during childhood. A novel ad hoc parental/patient questionnaire, which addressed diverse outcome domains was applied.

RESULTS

From a total of 353 eligible patients, 203 could be contacted (3 patients died of causes unknown) and 101 (50%) returned appropriately filled-in surveys. No evidence for a survey-response bias was found. The rate of surgical complications according to the patient records was 9%. As regards the survey, half of the parents/patients reported surgical adverse events (expected and unexpected issues) and one-third reported permanent aversive sequels. Two-thirds of the patients were seizure-free during the last year before follow-up; 63% were Engel class 1A; favorable seizure outcomes (including auras only) were obtained in 73%; and 54% were seizure-free and off antiseizure medicine (ASM), that is, cured of epilepsy. In non-seizure-free patients, seizure relapse occurred at any time during the follow-up interval but 87% of those with a seizure-free first postoperative year were seizure-free at follow-up. One patient experienced a seizure relapse during the ASM withdrawal trial but became seizure-free again with ASMs. Eleven patients reported an increased number of ASMs as compared to the time before surgery. Earlier focal surgery did not affect the long-term clinical outcome.

SIGNIFICANCE

Pediatric epilepsy surgery was capable of curing epilepsy in about one-half of the children and to significantly control seizures in about three-fourths. Long-term success of focal surgery did not depend on age at surgery or duration of epilepsy. Surgical adverse events including complications may be underreported and must be assessed more thoroughly.

Associations between cognition and employment outcomes after epilepsy surgery

OBJECTIVES

Previous studies have shown that younger age, higher education, and seizure freedom after epilepsy surgery are associated with employment. However, very few studies have investigated associations with cognition and employment status in epilepsy surgery patients.

METHODS

This retrospective study consists of 46 adult patients, who underwent resective epilepsy surgery in the Helsinki University Hospital between 2010 and 2018 and who had been assessed by a neuropsychologist prior to surgery and 6 months after surgery using a systematic test battery. In addition to neuropsychological evaluation, neurologists assessed the patients prior to surgery and followed up the patients up to 24 months after the surgery and evaluated work status of the patients. Logistic regression models were used to assess the effects of cognition on changes in employment status, while controlling for age and education.

RESULTS

Out of the 46 patients 38 (82.6%) were seizure free and 7 (15.2%) had their seizures reduced 2 years postsurgically. From prior to surgery to 2 years postsurgery, use of antiseizure medication was reduced in most of the patients, mean reduction of the dosage being 26.9%. Employment status improved in 10 (21.7%) patients, remained unchanged in 27 (58.7%) and worsened in 3 (6.5%). An additional 6 patients were already not working prior to surgery. Subsequent analyses are based on the subsample of 37 patients whose employment status improved or remained unchanged. Mistakes in executive function tasks (p = 0.048) and working memory performance (p = 0.020) differentiated between the group whose employment status remained similar and those who were able to improve their employment status. Epilepsy surgery outcome or changes in antiseizure medication (ASM) use were not associated with changes in employment status.

CONCLUSIONS

In the subsample of 37 patients, errors in executive function tasks and poorer working memory differentiated patients whose employment status did not change from those patients who could improve their employment status. Problems in executive function and working memory tasks might hinder performance in a complex work environment. When assessing the risks and opportunities in returning to work after surgery, difficulties in working memory and executive function performance should be taken into consideration as they may predispose the patient to challenges at work.

The effect of epilepsy surgery on productivity: A systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

An important but understudied benefit of resective epilepsy surgery is improvement in productivity; that is, people's ability to contribute to society through participation in the workforce and in unpaid roles such as carer duties. Here, we aimed to evaluate productivity in adults with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) pre- and post-resective epilepsy surgery, and to explore the factors that positively influence productivity outcomes.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis using four electronic databases: Medline (Ovid), EMBASE (Ovid), EBM Reviews - Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), and Cochrane Library. All studies over the past 30 years reporting on pre- and post-resective epilepsy surgical outcomes in adults with DRE were eligible for inclusion. Meta-analysis was performed to assess the post-surgery change in employment outcomes.

RESULTS

A total of 1005 titles and abstracts were reviewed. Seventeen studies, comprising 2056 unique patients, were suitable for the final quantitative synthesis and meta-analysis. Resective epilepsy surgery resulted in a 22% improvement in overall productivity (95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.07-1.40). The factors associated with increased post-surgery employment risk ratios were lower pre-surgical employment in the workforce (relative risk ratio [RRR] =0.34; 95% CI: 0.15-0.74), shorter follow-up duration (RRR = 0.95; 95% CI: 0.90-0.99), and lower mean age at time of surgery (RRR= 0.97; 95% CI: 0.94-0.99). The risk of bias of the included studies was assessed using Risk Of Bias In Non-randomised Studies - of Interventions and was low for most variables except "measurement of exposure."

SIGNIFICANCE

There is clear evidence that resective surgery in eligible surgical DRE patients results in improved productivity. Future work may include implementing a standardized method for collecting and reporting productivity in epilepsy cohorts and focusing on ways to reprioritize health care resource allocation to allow suitable candidates to access surgery earlier. This will ultimately benefit individuals with DRE, their families, our communities, and the wider health care system.

Predictors of longitudinal seizure outcomes after epilepsy surgery in childhood

•

Long term seizure outcome in children following epilepsy surgery is favorable.

•

Histopathology is an independent determinant of long-term seizure outcome.

•

Long-term seizure outcome remains stable in children with tumours and FCD type 2b, whereas seizure freedom declines with time in children with other types of FCD and cortical malformations.

•

Children with moderate to severe developmental disability and younger age of seizure onset have higher seizure recurrence reflecting broader epileptic networks.

There is a paucity of data on longitudinal seizure outcome of children undergoing epilepsy surgery. All children (n = 132) who underwent resective epilepsy surgery from January 1998 to December 2015 were identified. Relevant clinical, neurophysiological, imaging, surgical and seizure outcome data were extracted. Multivariable logistic regression analysis and Kaplan-Meier survival with Cox proportional hazard modelling were performed. The mean age at surgery was 7.8 years (range 0.2–17.9). 71% were seizure-free at a mean follow up of 5.3 ± 2.7 years. Of those who were seizure-free, 65 patients were able to completely wean off anti- seizure medications successfully. Using survival analysis, the probability of Engel Class I outcome at one year after surgery was 81% (95% confidence interval [CI] 87%–75%). This dropped to 73% at two years (95% CI 81%–65%), 58% at five years (95% CI 67.8%–48%), and 47% at ten years. Proportional hazard modelling showed that the presence of moderate to severe developmental disability (HR 6.5; p = 0.02) and lack of complete resection (HR 0.4; p = 0.02) maintain association as negative predictors of seizure-free outcome. Our study demonstrates favorable long-term seizure control following pediatric epilepsy surgery and highlights important predictors of seizure outcome guiding case selection and counseling of expectations prior to surgery.

Seizure and social outcomes in patients with non-surgically treated temporal lobe epilepsy

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the seizure outcome with medical treatment in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) and its associated factors. We also investigated the social outcome of the patients.

METHODS

This was a retrospective study of a prospectively built electronic database of patients with epilepsy. All patients with a diagnosis of TLE were studied at the outpatient epilepsy clinic at Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran, from 2008 until 2019. In a phone call to the patients, at least 24 months after their diagnosis at our center, we investigated their current seizure control and social status.

RESULTS

Two hundred and twenty-two patients were studied; 101 patients (45.5%) were seizure free. A lower number of the prescribed drugs was the only factor with a significant association with the seizure-free outcome (Odds Ratio: 1.460; p = 0.001). At the time of the phone call, 76 patients (37.6%) reported having a college education, 103 patients (51%) were employed, 146 patients (72.3%) were married, and 81 patients (40%) reported driving a motor vehicle. The employment status, college education, and driving a motor vehicle were significantly associated with a seizure-free outcome status. The social achievements of the patients, who were partially responsive to medical therapy, were significantly worse than those who were seizure free.

CONCLUSION

Many patients with TLE may suffer from drug-resistant seizures. Ongoing seizures in these patients may affect their social lives substantially. Seizure reduction (not freedom) is not good enough to help the patients with TLE enjoy a healthy life with satisfactory social achievements.

Encephalocele-Associated Drug-Resistant Epilepsy of Adult Onset: Diagnosis, Management, and Outcomes

Epileptogenic encephaloceles, most frequently located in the temporal lobe, are a known lesional cause of focal epilepsy. Data are limited regarding diagnosis, management, and outcomes of patients with epilepsy in the setting of an encephalocele, because the literature mostly comprises case reports, case series, and retrospective studies. We conducted a broad literature review for articles related to encephaloceles and epilepsy regardless of level of evidence. Hence, this review provides a summary of all available literature related to the topic. Thirty-six scientific reports that fulfilled our inclusion criteria were reviewed. Most reported patients presented with focal impaired awareness seizures and/or generalized tonic-clonic seizures. Although most of the encephaloceles were located in the temporal lobe, we found 5 cases of extratemporal encephaloceles causing epilepsy. More patients who underwent either lesionectomy or lobectomy were seizure free at time of follow-up. In the temporal lobe, there is no clear consensus on the appropriate management for epileptic encephaloceles and further studies are warranted to understand the associated factors and long-term outcomes associated with epilepsy secondary to encephaloceles. Reported data suggest that these patients could be manageable with surgical procedures including lesionectomy or lobectomy. In addition, because of data suggesting similar results between procedures, a more conservative surgery with lesionectomy and defect repair rather than a lobectomy may have lower surgical risks and similar seizure freedom.

Freedom From Seizures Might Be Key to Continuing Occupation After Epilepsy Surgery

Introduction: We hypothesized that epilepsy surgery for adult patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) who obtained freedom from seizures could provide opportunities for these patients to continue their occupation, and investigated continuity of occupation to test this postulation.

Methods: Data were obtained from patients who had undergone resective surgery for medically intractable TLE between October 2009 and April 2019 in our hospital. Inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) ≥16 years old at surgery; (2) post-operative follow-up ≥12 months; (3) seizure-free period ≥12 months. As a primary outcome, we evaluated employment status before and after surgery, classified into three categories as follows: Level 0, no job; Level 1, students or homemakers (financially supported by a family member); and Level 2, working. Neuropsychological status was also evaluated as a secondary outcome.

Results: Fifty-one (87.9%) of the 58 enrolled TLE patients who obtained freedom from seizures after surgery continued working as before or obtained a new job (employment status: Level 2). A significant difference in employment status was identified between before and after surgery (p = 0.007; Wilcoxon signed-rank test). Twenty-eight patients (48.3%) were evaluated for neuropsychological status both before and after surgery. Significant differences in Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-III scores were identified between before and after surgery (p < 0.05 each; paired t-test).

Conclusion: Seizure freedom could be a factor that facilitates job continuity, although additional data are needed to confirm that possibility. Further investigation of job continuity after epilepsy surgery warrants an international, multicenter study.

Long-term outcomes after epilepsy surgery, a retrospective cohort study linking patient-reported outcomes and routine healthcare data

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to assess the long-term outcomes of epilepsy surgery between 1995 and 2015 in South Wales, UK, linking case note review, postal questionnaire, and routinely collected healthcare data.

METHOD

We identified patients from a departmental database and collected outcome data from patient case notes, a postal questionnaire, and the QOLIE-31-P and linked with Welsh routinely collected data in the Secure Anonymised Information Linkage (SAIL) databank.

RESULTS

Fifty-seven patients were included. Median age at surgery was 34 years (11-70), median: 24 years (2-56) after onset of habitual seizures. Median follow-up was 7 years (2-19). Twenty-eight (49%) patients were free from disabling seizures (Engel Class 1), 9 (16%) experienced rare disabling seizures (Class 2), 13 (23%) had worthwhile improvements (Class 3), and 7 (12%) had no improvement (Class 4). There was a 30% mean reduction in total antiepileptic drug (AED) load at five years postsurgery. Thirty-eight (66.7%) patients experienced tonic-clonic seizures presurgery verses 8 (14%) at last review. Seizure-free patients self-reported a greater overall quality of life (QOL; QOLIE-31-P) when compared with those not achieving seizure freedom. Seizure-free individuals scored a mean of 67.6/100 (100 is best), whereas those with continuing seizures scored 46.0/100 (p < 0.006). There was a significant decrease in the median rate of hospital admissions for any cause after epilepsy surgery (9.8 days per 1000 patient days before surgery compared with 3.9 after p < 0.005).

SIGNIFICANCE

Epilepsy surgery was associated with significant improvements in seizures, a reduced AED load, and an improved QOL that closely correlated with seizure outcomes and reduced hospital admission rates following surgery. Despite this, there was a long delay from onset of habitual seizures to surgery. The importance of long-term follow-up is emphasized in terms of evolving medical needs and health and social care outcomes.

Epilepsy Surgery in Childhood Versus Adulthood: What Are We Waiting for?

Long-Term Employment Outcomes After Epilepsy Surgery in Childhood

Reinholdson J, Olsson I, Edelvik Tranberg A, Malmgren K. Neurology. 94;2020:e205-e216. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000008681

Objective:

To analyze long-term employment outcomes in a population-based cohort of adults who underwent epilepsy surgery in childhood or adolescence and to compare the results to general population reference data.

Methods:

Prospective data on epilepsy surgery procedures performed on patients <19 years of age between 1995 and 2012 were extracted from the Swedish National Epilepsy Surgery Register. Five-, 10-, 15- and 20-year follow-up data were analyzed. Patients aged ≥19 years at follow-up were eligible for inclusion. Educational attainment and employment status were analyzed in relation to seizure outcome. Education and employment outcomes of seizure-free patients with a preoperative IQ of ≥70 were compared to general population reference data.

Results:

A total of 203 patients were included. The mean age at surgery was 13.6 years and 66% had IQ ≥70. Of these, a majority had attained at least high school education 5 years after surgery. Employment rates were 44%, 69%, 71%, and 77% at the 5-, 10-, 15-, and 20-year follow-ups, respectively. Seizure-free patients were significantly more likely to work full-time. Educational attainment and rates of full-time employment of seizure-free patients were similar to the general population. A majority of patients with IQ <70 had attended special education and were reliant on social benefits.

Conclusion:

Long-term overall employment rates were higher compared to most previous studies on surgery in adults. Seizure-free patients with a preoperative IQ ≥70 showed rates of full-time employment similar to the general population. Further research is needed to determine whether this also applies for occupational complexity and wages.

Social functioning and health-related quality of life trajectories in people with epilepsy after epilepsy surgery

OBJECTIVE

An improvement in quality of life (QoL) over time after epilepsy surgery has been demonstrated in people with epilepsy; however, social functioning has been less investigated. We conducted this study to examine whether postsurgical improvement is parallel between QoL and social functioning in patients with epilepsy.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed patients who underwent epilepsy surgery. All participants completed a comprehensive neuropsychological assessment, the Quality of Life in Epilepsy Inventory (QOLIE-89) questionnaire, and the Social and Occupational Functioning Scale for Epilepsy (SOFSE) before surgery and at 3 months, 6 months, and 1 year after surgery. Demographic and epilepsy-related information was also collected. Generalized estimating equations with identity links were used to model the QOLIE-89 and SOFSE over time and possible associated factors. A p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

A total of 76 patients, including 36 males and 43 females aged 18 to 62 years were collected. Both total QOLIE-89 and overall SOFSE improved over time after epilepsy surgery (adjusted p value < 0.001 and 0.002, respectively, with Bonferroni's correction). Total QOLIE-89 improved 3 months after surgery, while overall SOFSE showed no significant improvement until 6 months after surgery. The presurgical Full-Scale Intelligence Quotient (FSIQ) of the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-III and years of education were significantly associated with time-dependent improvement for both total QOLIE-89 and overall SOFSE (p value < 0.001). At one year after surgery, overall SOFSE and total QOLIE-89 scores were significantly higher in the seizure-free group than in the nonseizure-free group (p value = 0.040 and 0.032, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Social functioning significantly improved in people with epilepsy after surgery as QoL, but it took more time to exhibit improvement. People with better FSIQ and more years of education had better improvement in social functioning over time. The early intervention of rehabilitation programs after epilepsy surgery might be necessary to facilitate the improvement in social functioning.

Long-term employment outcomes after epilepsy surgery in childhood

Objective

To analyze long-term employment outcomes in a population-based cohort of adults who underwent epilepsy surgery in childhood or adolescence and to compare the results to general population reference data.

Methods

Prospective data on epilepsy surgery procedures performed on patients <19 years of age between 1995 and 2012 were extracted from the Swedish National Epilepsy Surgery Register. Five-, 10-, 15- and 20-year follow-up data were analyzed. Patients aged ≥19 years at follow-up were eligible for inclusion. Educational attainment and employment status were analyzed in relation to seizure outcome. Education and employment outcomes of seizure-free patients with a preoperative IQ of ≥70 were compared to general population reference data.

Results

A total of 203 patients were included. The mean age at surgery was 13.6 years and 66% had IQ ≥70. Of these, a majority had attained at least high school education 5 years after surgery. Employment rates were 44%, 69%, 71%, and 77% at the 5-, 10-, 15-, and 20-year follow-ups, respectively. Seizure-free patients were significantly more likely to work full-time. Educational attainment and rates of full-time employment of seizure-free patients were similar to the general population. A majority of patients with IQ <70 had attended special education and were reliant on social benefits.

Conclusion

Long-term overall employment rates were higher compared to most previous studies on surgery in adults. Seizure-free patients with a preoperative IQ ≥70 showed rates of full-time employment similar to the general population. Further research is needed to determine whether this also applies for occupational complexity and wages.

[Epilepsy as a social problem]

The article considers the problem of social restrictions caused by epilepsy. Information on historical aspects and discrimination of patients with epilepsy is presented. The authors consider factors influencing marital status of patients in different countries and present information on the differences in medical restrictions to driving in different countries and in the Russian Federation. Employment status of patients with epilepsy, restrictions related to objective reasons and attitudes of patients and others toward epilepsy are elucidated.

Psychosocial outcome in epilepsy after extratemporal surgery

OBJECTIVE

Only limited data exist on psychosocial long-term outcome after epilepsy surgery in patients with extratemporal epilepsy. The aim of this study was to investigate psychosocial outcome after extratemporal epilepsy surgery and to assess factors predicting favorable outcome.

METHOD

Sixty-five out of 104 eligible patients who had undergone extratemporal epilepsy surgery at our epilepsy center between 1990 and 2015 (mean age: 42.2. years; 75% of the resections in the frontal lobe) completed a questionnaire asking about seizure status, employment status, marital and living situation, driving status, depressive symptoms, and quality of life (QOL). Follow-up was on average 9.2years after surgery (range: 1-26years).

RESULTS

Thirty-eight (58%) patients were free of disabling seizures (Engel class I), and 28 (43%) have not experienced any seizures after surgery (Engel class IA). Employment rate in the primary labor market remained at 45%, but more patients lost employment (14%) than gained employment (8%). Postoperative employment was predicted by preoperative employment (p=.007), seizure freedom (p=.025), older age at seizure onset (p=.018), younger age at follow-up (p=.035), and female gender (p=.048). Seizure-free patients were more likely to be driving; have a partner, particularly in males; and have lower depressive scores. Quality of life at follow-up was best predicted by employment (p=.012), partnership (p=.025), and seizure freedom (p=.025). In contrast, recurrence of seizures and early seizure onset were associated with poor psychosocial outcome, particularly in men.

CONCLUSION

The study provides support that extratemporal surgery can lead to improved QOL and favorable psychosocial outcome. Seizure freedom is important but not the only determinant of good psychosocial outcome.

Health-related quality of life and emotional well-being after epilepsy surgery: A prospective, controlled, long-term follow-up

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate health-related quality of life (HRQOL) and emotional well-being in resective epilepsy surgery and nonoperated patients at long-term follow-up.

METHODS

This is a prospective cohort study where patients undergoing presurgical work-up during 1995-1998 completed the Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36) and the Hospital Anxiety and Depression scale (HAD) at baseline, and 2 and 14 years after resective surgery or presurgical evaluation (nonoperated patients). SF-36 scores were compared to a normative population. Proportions of patients reaching HRQOL changes of minimum clinically important difference (MCID) were calculated.

RESULTS

At 14-year follow-up, operated patients scored equal to or better than the normative sample on all SF-36 domains except Social Functioning and Mental Health. Physical component summary (PCS) was better and mental component summary (MCS) was worse than for the normative sample. Nonoperated patients scored worse than the normative sample on five of eight domains, and on PCS and MCS. Change in seizure status from 2 to 14 years did not affect PCS or MCS means. Improvement reaching MCID from baseline to long-term was seen in 50% (PCS) and 47% (MCS) of operated and in 33% (PCS) and 38% (MCS) of nonoperated patients. Worsening was seen in 18% (PCS) and 22% (MCS) of operated and in 38% (PCS) and 38% (MCS) of nonoperated patients. Differences between groups were nonsignificant. HAD scores did not differ between groups, and the numbers of possible or probable cases were low. Patient satisfaction with surgery was higher in operated seizure-free patients. Only 5% of all operated patients considered surgery not to be overall beneficial.

SIGNIFICANCE

At the group level, HRQOL was stable 14 years after surgery compared to after 2 years. Social Functioning and Mental Health were still below, but other domains were similar to the normative sample. Individual patterns did not follow seizure outcome changes, indicating that multiple factors are important for long-term HRQOL.

Long-term outcomes of epilepsy surgery in 85 pediatric patients followed up for over 10 years: a retrospective survey

OBJECTIVE The aim of this study was to investigate the treatment outcomes and social engagement of patients who had undergone pediatric epilepsy surgery more than 10 years earlier. METHODS Between 1983 and 2005, 110 patients younger than 16 years underwent epilepsy surgery at the National Epilepsy Center, Shizuoka Institute of Epilepsy and Neurological Disorders. The authors sent a questionnaire to 103 patients who had undergone follow-up for more than 10 years after surgery; 85 patients (82.5%) responded. The survey contained 4 categories: seizure outcome, use of antiepileptic drugs, social participation, and general satisfaction with the surgical treatment (resection of the epileptic focus, including 4 hemispherectomies). The mean patient age at the time of surgery was 9.8 ± 4.2 (SD) years, and the mean duration of postoperative follow-up was 15.4 ± 5.0 years. Of the 85 patients, 79 (92.9%) presented with a lesional pathology, such as medial temporal sclerosis, developmental/neoplastic lesions, focal cortical dysplasia, and gliosis in a single lobe. RESULTS For 65 of the 85 responders (76.5%), the outcome was recorded as Engel Class I (including 15 [93.8%] of 16 patients with medial temporal sclerosis, 20 [80.0%] of 25 with developmental/neoplastic lesions, and 27 [73.0%] of 37 with focal cortical dysplasia). Of these, 29 (44.6%) were not taking antiepileptic drugs at the time of our survey, 29 (44.6%) held full-time jobs, and 33 of 59 patients (55.9%) eligible to drive had a driver's license. Among 73 patients who reported their degree of satisfaction, 58 (79.5%) were very satisfied with the treatment outcome. CONCLUSIONS The seizure outcome in patients who underwent resective surgery in childhood and underwent followup for more than 10 years was good. Of 85 respondents, 65 (76.5%) were classified in Engel Class I. The degree of social engagement was relatively high, and the satisfaction level with the treatment outcome was also high. From the perspective of seizure control and social adaptation, resective surgery yielded longitudinal benefits in children with intractable epilepsy, especially those with a lesional pathology in a single lobe.

Long-term outcomes of surgical treatment for epilepsy in adults with regard to seizures, antiepileptic drug treatment and employment

PURPOSE

There is Class I evidence for short-term efficacy of epilepsy surgery from two randomized controlled studies of temporal lobe resection. Long-term outcome studies are observational. The aim of this narrative review was to summarise long-term outcomes taking the study methodology into account.

METHODS

A PubMed search was conducted identifying articles on long-term outcomes of epilepsy surgery in adults with regard to seizures, antiepileptic drug treatment and employment. Definitions of seizure freedom were examined in order to identify the proportions of patients with sustained seizure freedom. The quality of the long-term studies was assessed.

RESULTS

In a number of high-quality studies 40-50% of patients had been continuously free from seizures with impairment of consciousness 10 years after resective surgery, with a higher proportion seizure-free at each annual follow-up. The proportion of seizure-free adults in whom AEDs have been withdrawn varied widely across studies, from 19-63% after around 5 years of seizure freedom. Few long-term vocational outcome studies were identified and results were inconsistent. Some investigators found no postoperative changes, others found decreased employment for patients with continuing seizures, but no change or increased employment for seizure-free patients. Having employment at baseline and postoperative seizure freedom were the strongest predictors of employment after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term studies of outcomes after epilepsy surgery are by necessity observational. There is a need for more prospective longitudinal studies of both seizure and non-seizure outcomes, considering individual patient trajectories in order to obtain valid outcome data needed for counselling patients about epilepsy surgery.