Dose gradient analyses in Linac-based intracranial stereotactic radiosurgery using Paddick's gradient index: consideration of the optimal method for plan evaluation

Non-coplanar Arc-Involved Beam Arrangement With Sufficient Arc Rotations Is Suitable for Volumetric-Modulated Arc-Based Radiosurgery for Single Brain Metastasis

Introduction In linac-based stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) leveraging a multileaf collimator (MLC) for brain metastasis (BM), volumetric-modulated arcs (VMAs) enable the generation of a suitable dose distribution with efficient planning and delivery. However, the arc arrangement, including the number of arcs, allocation, and rotation ranges, varies substantially among devices and facilities. Some modalities allow coplanar arc(s) (CA(s)) or beam(s) alone, and some facilities only use them intentionally despite the availability of non-coplanar arcs (NCAs). The study was conducted to examine the significance of NCAs and the optimal arc rotation ranges in VMA-based SRS for a single BM. Materials and methods This was a planning study for the clinical scenario of a single BM, including 20 clinical cases with a gross tumor volume (GTV) of 0.72-44.30 cc. Three different arc arrangements were compared: 1) reciprocating double CA alone of each 360º rotation with different collimator angles of 0 and 90º, 2) one CA and two NCAs of each 120º rotation with the shortest beam path lengths to the irradiation isocenter (NCA_L), and 3) one CA of 360º rotation and two NCAs of each 180º rotation (NCA_F). The three arcs were allocated similarly to equally divide the cranial hemisphere with different collimator angles of 0, 45, and 90º. Three VMA-based SRS plans were generated for each GTV using a 5 mm leaf-width MLC with the identical optimization method that prioritized the steepness of dose gradient outside the GTV boundary without any constraints to the GTV internal dose. A prescribed dose was uniformly assigned to the GTV D V-0.01 cc, the minimum dose of GTV minus 0.01 cc. The GTV dose conformity, the steepness of dose gradients both outside and inside the GTV boundary, the degree of concentric lamellarity of the dose gradients, and the appropriateness of the dose attenuation margin outside the GTV boundary were evaluated using metrics appropriate for each. Results The arc arrangements including NCAs showed significantly steeper dose gradients both outside and inside the GTV boundary with smaller dose attenuation margins than the CAs alone, while NCAs showed no significant advantage on the GTV dose conformity. In the NCA-involved arc arrangements, the NCA_F was significantly superior to the NCA_L in terms of the GTV dose conformity, the steepness of dose gradient outside the GTV, the degree of concentric lamellarity of the dose gradients outside and inside the GTV boundary, and the appropriateness of dose attenuation margin. However, the NCA_F showed no significant advantage on the steepness of dose increase inside the GTV boundary over the NCA_L. The dose increase just inside the prescribed isodose surface to the GTV boundary was significantly steeper with the NCA_L than the NCA_F. Conclusions In VMA-based SRS for a single BM, an arc arrangement including NCAs is indispensable, and sufficient arc rotations are suitable for achieving a dose distribution that maximizes therapeutic efficacy and safety in comparison to limited ones which are appropriate for dynamic conformal arcs. Although VMA with CAs alone can provide a non-inferior GTV dose conformity to NCAs, CA(s) alone should be applied only to situations where shorter irradiation time is prioritized over efficacy and safety.

Proposal of an Alternative Near-Minimum Isodose Surface DV-0.01 cc Equally Minimizing Gross Tumor Volume Below the Relevant Dose as the Basis for Dose Prescription and Evaluation of Stereotactic Radiosurgery for Brain Metastases

Introduction In stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for brain metastasis (BM), the prescribed dose is generally reported as a minimum dose to cover a specific percentage (e.g. D98%) of the gross tumor volume (GTV) with or without a margin or an unspecified intended marginal dose to the GTV boundary. In dose prescription to a margin-added planning target volume (PTV), the GTV marginal dose is likely variable and unclear. This study aimed to reveal major flaws of dose prescription to a fixed % coverage of a target volume (TV), such as GTV D98% or PTV D95%, and to propose an alternative. Materials and methods Seven quasi-spherical models with volumes ranging from 1.00 to 15.00 cc were assumed as GTVs. The GTVs and the volumes generated by adding isotropic 1- and 2-mm margins to the GTV boundaries (GTV + 1 and 2 mm) were used for SRS planning, dose prescription, and evaluation. Volumetric-modulated arcs with a 5-mm leaf-width multileaf collimator were used to optimize each SRS plan to ensure the steepest dose gradient outside each TV boundary. In dose prescription to the GTV D98%, 0.02-0.3 cc of the GTV is below the prescribed dose, and the volume increases with larger GTVs. The volume below the prescribed dose should be less than the equivalent of a 3-mm-diameter lesion, i.e. 0.01 cc. Therefore, DV-0.01 cc was defined as an alternative near-minimum dose for which the TV below a relevant dose is less than 0.01 cc. Four different dose prescriptions, including the GTV DV-0.01 cc, were compared using specific doses in 1, 3, and 5 fractions, equivalent to 80, 60, and 50 Gy, respectively, as biologically effective doses (BEDs) to the boundaries of GTV, GTV + 1 mm, and GTV + 2 mm, respectively. Results Dose prescription to the GTV DV-0.01 cc corresponds to 95.0, 98.0, and 99.0-99.93% coverages for the GTV of 0.20, 0.50, and 1.00-15.00 cc, respectively. The GTV DV-0.01 cc varied substantially and decreased significantly as the GTV increased in dose prescriptions to the GTV D98%, GTV + 1 mm D95%, and GTV + 2 mm D95%. The GTV + 2 mm DV-0.01 cc increased significantly as the GTV increased, except for the dose prescription to the GTV + 2 mm D95% with a decreasing tendency. When comparing BED-based specific dose prescriptions, dose prescription to the GTV DV-0.01 cc was optimal in terms of the following: 1) consistency of the near-minimum dose of GTV; 2) the highest BED at 2 mm outside the GTV, except for 1.00 cc GTV, and the rational increase with increasing GTV; and 3) the highest BED at 2 mm inside the GTV. In dose prescription with the BED of 80 Gy in 1 fraction and 5 fractions to the GTV DV-0.01 cc, the GTV limits were ≤1.40 and ≤8.46 cc, respectively, in order for the irradiated isodose volume not to exceed the proposed thresholds for minimizing the risk of brain radionecrosis. Conclusions Dose prescription to a fixed % coverage of a GTV with or without a margin leads to the substantially varied near-minimum dose at the GTV boundary, which significantly decreases with increasing GTV. Alternatively, GTV DV-0.01 cc with a variable coverage (D>95%) for >0.20 cc GTV and fixed D95% for ≤0.20 cc GTV is recommended as the basis for dose prescription and evaluation, along with supplemental evaluation of the marginal dose of the GTV plus a margin (e.g. GTV + 2 mm) to demonstrate the appropriateness of dose attenuation outside the GTV boundary.

Application of dose-gradient function in reducing radiation induced lung injury in breast cancer radiotherapy

OBJECTIVE

Try to create a dose gradient function (DGF) and test its effectiveness in reducing radiation induced lung injury in breast cancer radiotherapy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Radiotherapy plans of 30 patients after breast-conserving surgery were included in the study. The dose gradient function was defined as DGH=VDVp3, then the area under the DGF curve of each plan was calculated in rectangular coordinate system, and the minimum area was used as the trigger factor, and other plans were triggered to optimize for area reduction. The dosimetric parameters of target area and organs at risk in 30 cases before and after re-optimization were compared.

RESULTS

On the premise of ensuring that the target dose met the clinical requirements, the trigger factor obtained based on DGF could further reduce the V5, V10, V20, V30 and mean lung dose (MLD) of the ipsilateral lung in breast cancer radiotherapy, P < 0.01. And the D2cc and mean heart dose (MHD) of the heart were also reduced, P < 0.01. Besides, the NTCPs of the ipsilateral lung and the heart were also reduced, P < 0.01.

CONCLUSION

The trigger factor obtained based on DGF is efficient in reducing radiation induced lung injury in breast cancer radiotherapy.

Robotic Radiosurgical Boost After Whole-Brain Radiotherapy for 12 Brain Metastases: En Bloc Consecutive Irradiation With Comprehensively Optimized Single Plan for Eight Lesions Totaling 118 cc

General radiotherapeutic management for >10 brain metastases (BMs) totaling >100 cm3, including multiple large lesions (>10-30 cm3) in close proximity, demonstrated limited efficacy and/or safety. We describe a case of 12 BMs, summating 122.2 cm3, including a 39.6 cm3 maximum lesion and adjacent ones. The patient had an 8.1-year treatment history for recurrent/metastatic breast cancer refractory to endocrine and chemotherapy. BMs were treated with conventional whole-brain radiotherapy (WBRT) with 30 Gy/10 fractions (fr), followed by an immediate stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) boost with 27 Gy/5 fr (52-64% isodoses) which covers the gross tumor boundaries of selected eight lesions (total 118.4 cm3). The SRS dose was defined to ensure the cumulative biologically effective dose (BED10) of just ≥80 Gy while minimizing the risk of radiation injury. The SRS was performed using a CyberKnife (CK) robotic system (Accuray Incorporated, Sunnyvale, California, United States) with a variable-sized collimator (10-40 mm), for which en bloc consecutive irradiation, using 215 beams based on a comprehensively optimized single plan (path), was adopted. The treatment time per fraction was ≤45 min (mean 5.6 min per lesion). Afterward, BMs demonstrated remarkable regression over six months, causing the total residual visible lesions of 12.6 cm3 (10.3%) at 11.4 months, despite the absence of obvious lesion shrinkage during the radiotherapy. WBRT, followed by an immediate 5-fr SRS boost with a total BED10 of 80 Gy to large and/or culprit lesions, can be an efficacious and safe treatment option for multiple BMs, totaling >120 cm3. En bloc consecutive irradiation with a single path provides overwhelmingly more efficient delivery for treating multiple lesions using CK in terms of irradiation time and comprehensive reduction of normal brain dose compared to individual planning. Volumetric-modulated arc-based >10-fr SRS with simultaneously integrated reduced-dose WBRT may be an alternative to further enhance efficacy and safety.

Extracting the gradient component of the gamma index using the Lie derivative method

Objective. The gamma index (γ) has been extensively investigated in the medical physics and applied in clinical practice. However,γhas a significant limitation when used to evaluate the dose-gradient region, leading to inconveniences, particularly in stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT). This study proposes a novel evaluation method combined withγto extract clinically problematic dose-gradient regions caused by irradiation including certain errors.Approach. A flow-vector field in the dose distribution is obtained when the dose is considered a scalar potential. Using the Lie derivative from differential geometry, we definedL,S, andUto evaluate the intensity, vorticity, and flow amount of deviation between two dose distributions, respectively. These metrics multiplied byγ(γL,γS,γU), along with the threshold valueσ, were verified in the ideal SRT case and in a clinical case of irradiation near the brainstem region using radiochromic films. Moreover, Moran's gradient index (MGI), Bakai's χ factor, and the structural similarity index (SSIM) were investigated for comparisons.Main results. A highL-metric value mainly extracted high-dose-gradient induced deviations, which was supported by highSandUmetrics observed as a robust deviation and an influence of the dose-gradient, respectively. TheS-metric also denotes the measured similarity between the compared dose distributions. In theγdistribution,γLsensitively detected the dose-gradient region in the film measurement, despite the presence of noise. The thresholdσsuccessfully extracted the gradient-error region whereγ> 1 analysis underestimated, andσ= 0.1 (plan) andσ= 0.001 (film measurement) were obtained according to the compared resolutions. However, the MGI, χ, and SSIM failed to detect the clinically interested region.Significance. Although further studies are required to clarify the error details, this study demonstrated that the Lie derivative method provided a novel perspective for the identifying gradient-induced error regions and enabled enhanced and clinically significant evaluations ofγ.

Cleaning the dose falloff with low modulation in SBRT lung plans

Purpose.This dosimetric study is intended to lower the modulation factor in lung SBRT plans generated in the Eclipse TPS that could replace highly modulated plans that are prone to the interplay effect.Materials and methods.Twenty clinical lung SBRT plans with high modulation factors (≥4) were replanned in Varian Eclipse TPS version 15.5 utilizing 2 mm craniocaudal and 1 mm axial block margins followed by light optimization in order to reduce modulation. A unique plan optimization methodology, which utilizes a novel shell structure (OptiForR₅₀) for R_50%optimization in addition to five consecutive concentric 5 mm shells, was utilized to control dose falloff according to RTOG 0813 and 0915 recommendations. The prescription varied from 34-54 Gy in 1-4 fractions, and the dose objectives were PTV D_95%= Rx, PTV D_max< 140% of Rx, and minimizing the modulation factor. Plan evaluation metrics included modulation factor, CI_RTOG, homogeneity index (HI), R_50%, D_2cm, V_105%, and lung V_8-12.8Gy(Timmerman Constraint). A random-intercept linear mixed effects model was used with a p ≤ 0.05 threshold to test for statistical significance.Results.The retrospectively generated plans had significantly lower modulation factors (3.65 ± 0.35 versus 4.59 ± 0.54; p < 0.001), lower CI_RTOG(0.97 ± 0.02 versus 1.02 ± 0.06; p = 0.001), higher HI (1.35 ± 0.06 versus 1.14 ± 0.04; p < 0.001), lower R_50%(4.09 ± 0.45 versus 4.56 ± 0.56; p < 0.001), and lower lungs V_8-12.8Gy(Timmerman) (4.61% ± 3.18% versus 4.92% ± 3.37%; p < 0.001). The high dose spillage V_105%was borderline significantly lower (0.44% ± 0.49% versus 1.10% ± 1.64%; p = 0.051). The D_2cmwas not statistically different (46.06% ± 4.01% versus 46.19% ± 2.80%; p = 0.835).Conclusion.Lung SBRT plans with significantly lower modulation factors can be generated that meet the RTOG constraints, using our planning strategy.

Helical tomotherapy and two types of volumetric modulated arc therapy: dosimetric and clinical comparison for several cancer sites

Radiotherapy accelerators have undergone continuous technological developments. We investigated the differences between Radixact™ and VMAT treatment plans. Sixty patients were included in this study. Dosimetric comparison between the Radixact™ and VMAT plans was performed for six cancer sites: whole-brain, head and neck, lymphoma, lung, prostate, and rectum. The VMAT plans were generated with two Elekta linear accelerators (Synergy^® and Versa HD™). The planning target volume (PTV) coverage, organs-at-risk dose constraints, and four dosimetric indexes were considered. The deliverability of the plans was assessed using quality assurance (gamma index evaluation) measurements; clinical judgment was included in the assessment. The mean AAPM TG218 (3%-2 mm, global normalization) gamma index values were 99.4%, 97.8%, and 96.6% for Radixact™, Versa HD™, and Synergy®, respectively. Radixact™ performed better than Versa HD™ in terms of dosimetric indexes, hippocampi D_100%, spinal cord D_max, rectum V_{38.4  Gy}, bladder V_{30 Gy}, and V_{40 Gy}. Versa HD™ saved more of the (lungs-PTV) V_{5 Gy} and (lungs-PTV) D_mean, heart D_mean, breasts V_{4 Gy}, and bowel V_{45 Gy}. Regarding Synergy^®, the head and neck Radixact™ plan saved more of the parotid gland, oral cavity, and supraglottic larynx. From a clinical point of view, for the head and neck, prostate, and rectal sites, the Radixact™ and Versa HD™ plans were similar; Radixact™ plans were preferable for the head and neck and rectum to Synergy^® plans. The quality of linac plans has improved, and differences with tomotherapy have decreased. However, tomotherapy continues to be an essential add-on in multi-machine departments.

Five-Fraction Stereotactic Radiosurgery With Non-Contrast-Enhanced MRI-Based Target Definition and Moderate Dose Spillage Margin for Limited Brain Metastases With Impaired Renal Function

In stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) planning for brain metastases (BMs), the target volume is usually defined as an enhancing lesion based on contrast-enhanced (CE) magnetic resonance images (MRI) and/or computed tomography (CT) images. However, contrast media (CM) are unsuitable for certain patients with impaired renal function. Herein, we describe two limited BM cases not amenable to CM, which were treated with five-fraction (fr) SRS, without whole brain radiotherapy (WBRT), through a target definition based on non-CE-MRI. These included synchronous and partly symptomatic four BMs from esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (Case 1) and one presymptomatic regrowing lesion after WBRT for BMs from lung adenocarcinoma (Case 2). In both cases, all BMs were visualized as well-demarcated mass lesions almost distinguishable from the affected parenchyma on non-CE-MRI, particularly on T2-weighted images (WI). The gross tumor volume (GTV) was defined mainly based on T2-WI under a comprehensive comparison of non-CE-T1/T2-WIs and CT for SRS planning under image co-registration and fusion. Stereotactic radiosurgery was implemented with volumetric modulated arcs using a 5-mm leaf width multileaf collimator, for both of which 5 fr was selected, considering the maximum tumor volume and the effects from WBRT, respectively. Dose distribution was designed to ensure a moderate dose attenuation margin outside the GTV boundary and a concentrically-laminated steep dose increase inside the GTV boundary. Specifically, the peripheries of the GTV and 2 mm outside the GTV boundary were covered by ≥43 Gy with <70% isodose relative to the maximum dose and ≥31 Gy, respectively. The not-too-steep dose spillage margin can cover potentially invisible tumor invasion outside the GTV and other inherent uncertainties regarding target definition and irradiation accuracy. Post-SRS tumor responses were excellent clinically and/or radiographically with mild adverse radiation effects in Case 2. In limited BM cases unsuitable to CM, multi-fraction SRS with non-CE-MRI-based GTV definition and sufficient GTV dose along with moderate dose spillage margin would be a valuable treatment option for selected cases, with the entire GTV boundaries being almost visible on non-CE-MRI.

An Extremely Inhomogeneous Gross Tumor Dose is Suitable for Volumetric Modulated Arc-Based Radiosurgery with a 5-mm Leaf-Width Multileaf Collimator for Single Brain Metastasis

Introduction Single or multi-fraction (mf) stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is an indispensable treatment option for brain metastases (BMs). The integration of volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) into linac-based SRS is expected to further enhance efficacy and safety and to expand the indications for the challenging type of BMs. However, the optimal treatment design and relevant optimization method for volumetric modulated arc-based radiosurgery (VMARS) remain unestablished with substantial inter-institutional differences. Therefore, this study was conducted to determine the optimal dose distribution suitable for VMARS of BMs, especially regarding dose inhomogeneity of the gross tumor volume (GTV). The GTV boundary, not margin-added planning target volume, was regarded as a basis for planning optimization and dose prescription. Materials and methods This was a planning study for the clinical scenario of a single BM. Eight sphere-shaped objects with diameters of 5-40 mm in 5-mm increments were assumed as GTVs. The treatment system included a 5-mm leaf width multileaf collimator (MLC) Agility® (Elekta AB, Stockholm, Sweden) and a dedicated planning system Monaco® (Elekta AB). The prescribed dose (PD) was uniformly assigned to just cover 98% of the GTV (D_98%). Three VMARS plans with different dose inhomogeneities of the GTV were generated for each GTV: the % isodose surfaces (IDSs) of GTV D_98%, normalized to 100% at the maximum dose (D_max), were ≤70% (extremely inhomogeneous dose, EIH); ≈80% (inhomogeneous dose, IH); and ≈90% (rather homogeneous dose, RH). VMARS plans were optimized using simple and similar cost functions. In particular, no dose constraint to the GTV D_max was assigned to the EIH plans. Results Intended VMARS plans fulfilling the prerequisites were generated without problems for all GTVs of ≥10 mm, whereas 86.4% was the lowest IDS for the D_98% for 5-mm GTV. Therefore, additional plans for 9- and 8-mm GTVs were generated, which resulted in 68.6% and 75.1% being the lowest IDSs for the D_98% values of 9- and 8-mm GTVs, respectively. The EIH plans were the best in terms of the following: 1) dose conformity, i.e., minimum spillage of PD outside the GTV; 2) moderate, not too excessive, dose attenuation outside the GTV, i.e., appropriate marginal dose 2-mm outside the GTV boundary as a function of GTV size; and 3) lowest dose of the surrounding normal tissue outside the GTV. In contrast, the RH plans were the worst based on all of the aforementioned measures. Conclusions On the assumption of uniform dose assignment to the GTV margin, a very inhomogeneous GTV dose is basically the most suitable for SRS of BMs in terms of 1) superior dose conformity; 2) minimizing the dose of the surrounding normal tissue outside the GTV; and 3) moderate dose spillage margin outside the GTV with a tumor volume-dependent rational increase, i.e., appropriate dose of the common PTV boundary. The concentrically laminated steep dose increase inside the GTV boundary for the EIH plan may also be advantageous for achieving superior tumor response, although early and excessive GTV shrinkage caused by the EIH plan during mfSRS can lead to surrounding brain injury.

Analysis of CyberKnife intracranial treatment plans using ICRU 91 dose reporting: A retrospective study

ICRU 91, published in 2017, is an international standard for prescribing, recording, and reporting stereotactic treatments. Since its release, there has been limited research published on the implementation and impact of ICRU 91 on clinical practice. This work provides an assessment of the recommended ICRU 91 dose reporting metrics for their use in clinical treatment planning. A set of 180 intracranial stereotactic treatment plans for patients treated by the CyberKnife (CK) system were analyzed retrospectively using the ICRU 91 reporting metrics. The 180 plans comprised 60 trigeminal neuralgia (TGN), 60 meningioma (MEN), and 60 acoustic neuroma (AN) cases. The reporting metrics included the planning target volume (PTV) near-minimum dose ( D near - min ${D}_{{\rm{near}} - {\rm{min}}}$ ), near-maximum dose ( D near - max ${D}_{{\rm{near}} - {\rm{max}}}$ ), and median dose ( D 50 % ${D}_{50{\rm{\% }}}$ ), as well as the gradient index (GI) and conformity index (CI). The metrics were assessed for statistical correlation with several treatment plan parameters. In the TGN plan group, owing to the small targets, D near - min ${D}_{{\rm{near}} - {\rm{min}}}$ was greater than D near - max ${D}_{{\rm{near}} - {\rm{max}}}$ in 42 plans, whereas both metrics were not applicable in 17 plans. The D 50 % ${D}_{50{\rm{\% }}}$ metric was predominantly influenced by the prescription isodose line (PIDL). The GI was significantly dependent on target volume in all analyses performed, where the variables were inversely related. The CI was only dependent on target volume in treatment plans for small targets. The ICRU 91 D near - min ${D}_{{\rm{near}} - {\rm{min}}}$ and D near - max ${D}_{{\rm{near}} - {\rm{max}}}$ metrics breakdown in plans for small target volumes below 1 cm³ ; the Min and Max pixel should be reported in such cases. The D 50 % ${D}_{50{\rm{\% }}}$ metric is of limited use for treatment planning. Given their volume dependence, the GI and CI metrics could potentially serve as plan evaluation tools in the planning of the sites analyzed in this study, which would ultimately improve treatment plan quality.

Correlation of Brain Metastasis Shrinking and Deviation During 10-Fraction Stereotactic Radiosurgery With Late Sequela: Suggesting Dose Ramification Between Tumor Eradication and Symptomatic Radionecrosis

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) with >5 fraction (fr) has been increasingly adopted for brain metastases (BMs), given the current awareness of limited brain tolerance for ≤5 fr. The target volume/configuration change and/or deviation within the cranium during fractionated SRS can be unpredictable and critical uncertainties affecting treatment accuracy, plus the effect of these events on the long-term outcome remains uncertain. Herein, we describe a case of two challenging BMs treated by 10 fr SRS with a unique dose-gradient optimization strategy, in which the large cystic tumor revealed an intriguing correlation of such inter-fractional change with late radiographic sequela, suggesting a dose threshold for attaining long-term local tumor control and being immune to symptomatic brain necrosis. A 63-year-old man presented with two cystic lesions located in the left parietal lobe (19.9 cm³) and pons (1.1 cm³) one month after surgery for esophageal squamous cell carcinoma. The principles for 10 fr SRS were as follows: (1) very inhomogeneous gross tumor volume (GTV) dose covered by 53 Gy, biologically effective dose with an alpha/beta ratio of 10 (BED₁₀) of ≥80 Gy; (2) moderate dose spillage margin outside the GTV boundary: 2-2.5 mm outside the GTV margin was covered by 37 Gy, BED₁₀ of ≈50 Gy; (3) concentrically-laminated, steep dose increase inside the GTV boundary: 2 mm inside the GTV margin was covered by ≥62 Gy, BED₁₀ of ≥100 Gy. At the completion of SRS, the parietal lesion showed significant shrinking and dorsomedial shifting with slight evisceration of the GTV, followed by marked regression of the parietal lesion within four months. At 13.5 months, a cystic change was noted at the dorsal part of the remnant. At 16.7 months, ventral enhancement gradually expanded without enlargement of the dorsal cystic component. On the T2-weighted images, the dorsal low-intensity remnant and ventral iso-intensity blurry-demarcated component were contrasting. Pathological examinations during and after lesionectomy at 17.4 months revealed necrosis only. At 30.5 months, the patient had a left visual field defect without recurrence. In contrast, the pons lesion showed no notable change during 10 fr SRS and nearly complete remission over six months with its sustainment without radiation injury at 30.5 months. Taken together, 10 fr SRS with a sufficient BED₁₀ can provide superior tumor response and safety for BM that is not amenable to ≤5 fr SRS. Although a very inhomogeneous GTV dose can contribute to early and adequate tumor shrinkage and subsequent local tumor eradication, significant tumor shrinkage during fractionated SRS (fSRS) inevitably results in unnecessary higher dose exposure to the surrounding brain, which could lead to late radiation injury requiring intervention. The optimum dose should be determined through further investigation, in consideration of the dynamic and unpredictable nature of the actual absorbed doses to both the tumor and the surrounding brain.

Normal tissue objective (NTO) tool in Eclipse treatment planning system for dose distribution optimization

Introduction: The purpose of this study was to determine the best normal tissue objective (NTO) values based on the dose distribution from brain tumor radiation therapy.

Material and methods: The NTO is a constraint provided by Eclipse to limit the dose to normal tissues by steepening the dose gradient. The multitude of NTO setting combinations necessitates optimal NTO settings. The Eclipse supports manual and automatic NTOs. Fifteen patients were re-planned using NTO priorities of 1, 50, 100, 150, 200, and 500 in combination with dose fall-offs of 0.05, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.5, 1 and 5 mm-1. NTO distance to planning target volume (PTV), start dose, and end dose were 1 mm, 105%, and 60%, respectively, for all plans. In addition, planning without the NTO was arranged to find out its effect on planning. The prescription dose covered 95% of the PTV. Planning was evaluated using several indices: conformity index (CI), homogeneity index (HI), gradient index (GI), modified gradient index (mGI), comprehensive quality index (CQI), and monitor unit (MU). Differences among automatic NTO, manual NTO, and without NTO were evaluated using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test.

Results: Comparisons obtained without and with manual NTO were: CI of 0.77 vs. 0.96 (p = 0.002), GI of 4.52 vs. 4.69 (p = 0.233), mGI of 4.93 vs. 3.95 (p = 0.001), HI of 1.10 vs. 1.10 (p = 0.330), and MU/cGy of 3.44 vs. 3.42 (p = 0.460). Planning without NTO produced a poor conformity index. Comparisons of automatic and manual NTOs were: CI of 0.92 vs. 0.96 (p = 0.035), GI of 5.25 vs. 4.69 (p = 0.253), mGI of 4.46 vs. 3.95 (p = 0.001), HI of 1.09 vs. 1.10 (p = 0.004), MU/cGy of 3.31 vs. 3.42 (p = 0.041).

Conclusions: Based on these results, manual NTO with a priority of 100 and dose fall-off 0.5 mm-1 was optimal, as indicated by the high dose reduction in normal tissue.

Investigating the number of radiation fields in intensity-modulated radiotherapy plans of optic nerve sheath meningioma patients using dose gradient index

Purpose:In optic nerve radiotherapy, vital organs are very close to the target volume, they are highly sensitive to radiation and have low dose tolerance. In this regard, evaluating dose fall-off steepness around the target volume is required to assess various intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) plans in the treatment of the optic nerve sheath meningioma (ONSM) patients.Materials and Methods:Thirteen ONSM patients were analyzed with three IMRT techniques, including three (IMRT-3F), five (IMRT-5F), and seven fields (IMRT-7F). These plans were studied using D_mean, D_max, D_2%, D_98%, V_100%, uniformity index (UI), homogeneity index (HI), conformity index (CI), and specifically the dose gradient indices (DGIs). Results: The values of D_maxand D_meanfor IMRT-3F, IMRT-5F and IMRT-7F were (5637.42 ± 57.08, 5322.84 ± 83.86), (5670.51 ± 67.87, 5383.00 ± 58.45), and (5692.99 ± 31.65, 5405.72 ± 51.73), respectively, which were increased with increment in the number of IMRT fields from 3 to 7. The UI and HI indices were significantly different between IMRT-3F and IMRT-7F (p=0.010 and p=0.005, respectively), and CI was close to the ideal value (0.99±0.01) in IMRT-7F. The significant findings of the dose gradient indices represented smaller values in IMRT-7F, which led to a faster dose fall-off, particularly at the 70%-85% isodose levels around the target. Conclusion: Increasing the number of radiation fields in IMRT treatment plans of ONSM patients had a considerable difference in both the dosimetric parameters of the target volume and at-risk organs, as well as the dose gradient indices. Overall, IMRT-7F could be considered as a preferred technique in the treatment of this meningioma.

Accelerated hypofractionated radiotherapy for chest wall and nodal irradiation using hybrid techniques

Aim:

This study compares three different hybrid plans, for left-sided chest wall (CW) and nodal stations irradiation using a hypofractionated dose regimen.

Materials and methods:

Planning target volumes (PTVs) of 25 breast cancer patients that included CW, supraclavicular (SCL) and internal mammary node (IMN) were planned with 3 different hybrid techniques: 3DCRT+IMRT, 3DCRT+VMAT and IMRT+VMAT. All hybrid plans were generated with a hypofractionated dose prescription of 40·5 Gy in 15 fractions. Seventy per cent of the dose was planned with the base-dose component and remaining 30% of the dose was planned with the hybrid component. All plans were evaluated based on the PTVs and organs at risk (OARs) dosimetric parameters.

Results:

The results for PTVs parameters have shown that the 3DCRT+IMRT and 3DCRT+VMAT plans were superior in uniformity index to the IMRT+VMAT plan. The OARs dose parameters were comparable between hybrid plans. The IMRT+VMAT plan provided a larger low dose volume spread to the heart and ipsilateral lung (p < 0·001). The 3DCRT+VMAT plan required less monitor units and treatment time (p = 0·005) than other plans.

Conclusion:

The 3DCRT+VMAT hybrid plan showed superior results with efficient treatment delivery and provide clinical benefit by reducing both low and high dose levels.

Analysis of R50% location dependence on LINAC-based VMAT cranial stereotactic treatments

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) and stereotactic radiation therapy (SRT) techniques are used to deliver high doses per fraction to various types of intra-cranial targets. LINAC-based solutions are growing in prevalence due to recent advances in technologies such as high-definition multi-leaf collimators and volumetric arc therapy radiation delivery. A wide variety of clinical pathologies including intracranial metastases, meningioma, glioblastoma, arteriovenous malformation, acoustic neuroma, and trigeminal neuralgia have been successfully treated using SRS/SRT techniques. These lesions can be in virtually at any location within the cranium. Several publications have shown a wide dispersion of intermediate dose conformality (intermediate dose spill) indices such as the Paddick Gradient Index or R50% for lesions of a specific volume. A complete explanation of this dispersion is lacking but location has been suggested as a contributing factor. While prior studies of PTV location in SRS/SRT are retrospective in nature, we have conducted a prospective study to ascertain the potential effects of location within the cranium on plan intermediate dose conformality as measured by R50% while controlling for lesion volume, lesion shape, prescription (Rx) dose, and Rx isodose surface. Lesion volumes utilized in this study are consistent with metastatic disease presentation. Results indicate only a weak relationship between intermediate dose conformality as measured by R50% and the lesion location when considering nine different, strategically placed lesions. Close proximity to critical structures can reduce the degree of conformality, but the effect appears to be minimal. Single isocenter multiple target cases were studied in addition to single target plans. All critical structure doses observed in this study were found to be within the recommendations of AAPM Task Group report 101. Lesion location does not appear to be a significant contributing factor to the observed variation of dose conformality seen in several SRS/SRT publications.

A systematically compiled set of quantitative metrics to describe spatial characteristics of radiotherapy dose distributions and aid in treatment planning

PURPOSE

Many quantitative metrics have been proposed in literature for characterization of spatial dose properties. The aim of this study is to work towards much-needed consensus in the radiotherapy community on which of these metrics to use. We do this by comparing characteristics of the metrics and providing a systematically selected set of metrics to comprehensively quantify properties of the spatial dose distribution.

METHODS

We searched the literature for metrics to quantitatively evaluate dose conformity, homogeneity, gradient (overall and directional), and distribution and location of over- and under-dosed sub-volumes. For each spatial dose property, we compared the responses of its corresponding metrics to simulated dose variations in a virtual water phantom. Selection criteria were a metric's ability to describe simulated scenarios robustly and to be visualized in an intuitive way.

RESULTS

We saw substantial differences in the responses of metrics to the simulated dose variations. Some conformity and homogeneity metrics were unable to quantify certain types of changes (e.g. target under-coverage). Others showed a large dependency on the shape and volume of targets and isodoses. Metric values differed between calculations in a static plan and in simulated full treatment courses including setup errors, especially for metrics quantifying distribution and location of hot and cold spots. We provide an Eclipse plugin script to calculate and visualize selected metrics.

CONCLUSION

The selected set of metrics provides complementary and comprehensive quantitative information about the spatial dose distribution. This work serves as a step towards broader consensus on the use of spatial dose metrics.

The surface area effect: How the intermediate dose spill depends on the PTV surface area in SRS

PURPOSE

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is rapidly becoming the standard of care for many intracranial targets. The characteristics of the planning target volume (PTV) can affect the intermediate dose spill and thus normal brain volume dose which is correlated with brain toxicity. R50% (volume receiving 50% of prescription dose divided by PTV volume) is a useful metric to quantify the intermediate dose spill. We propose a novel understanding of how the PTV surface area (SAPTV ) affects the intermediate dose spill of SRS treatments.

METHODS

Using a phantom model provided by a computed tomography (CT) of the IROC Head Phantom® and Eclipse® Treatment Planning System, we investigate the relationship of R50% and SAPTV in single-target SRS treatments. The planning studies are conducted for SRS treatments on a Varian TrueBeam® linear accelerator with high-definition MLC and a 6 MVFFF beam mode. These data are analyzed to ascertain trends in R50% related to SAPTV . Since SAPTV is not available as a structure property in the Eclipse RTPS, we introduce an Eclipse script to extract PTV surface area of arbitrary-shaped PTVs. We compare a physically reasonable theoretical prediction of R50%, R50%Analytic , to the R50% achieved in treatment planning studies.

RESULTS

The SRS phantom study indicates good correlation between the plan R50% and SAPTV . A near-linear relationship of plan R50% vs SAPTV is observed as predicted by the R50%Analytic model. Agreement between plan R50% values and R50%Analytic predictions is good for all but the very smallest PTV volumes.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrate dependence of the intermediate dose spill measured by R50% on the SAPTV . We call that dependence the surface area effect. This dependence is explicit in the R50%Analytic prediction model. The predicted value of R50%Analytic for a given PTV could be used for guidance during SRS treatment plan optimization, and plan evaluation for that PTV.

A physically meaningful relationship between R50% and PTV surface area in lung SBRT

Purpose

We propose a novel understanding of two characteristics of the planning target volume (PTV) that affect the intermediate‐dose spill in lung stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) as measured by R50%. This phantom model research investigates two characteristics of the PTV that have a marked effect on the value of R50%: the mean dose deposited within the PTV (D_av) and the surface area of the PTV (SA_PTV).

Methods

Using a phantom model provided by a CT of the IROC Thorax‐Lung Phantom® (IROC Houston QA Center, Houston, TX) and Eclipse® Treatment Planning System (Varian Medical Systems, Palo Alto, CA), we investigate the two characteristics for spherical and cylindrical PTVs. A total of 135 plans with tightly controlled PTV characteristics are employed. A lower bound for R50% (R50%min_∆r) is derived and clearly establishes a relationship between R50% and SA_PTV that has not been fully appreciated previously.

Results

The study of PTV D_av revealed a local minimum for R50% as a function of the PTV D_av at D_av ≈ 110% of Rx dose. As PTV D_av increases above this local minimum, R50% increases; while for PTV D_av less than this local minimum, the R50% value also increases. The study of PTV surface area (SA_PTV) demonstrated that as the SA_PTV increases, the R50% increases if the PTV volume stays the same. The SA_PTV result is predicted by the theoretical investigation that yields the R50% lower bound, R50%min_∆r.

Conclusions

This research has identified two characteristics of the PTV that have a marked influence on R50%: PTV D_av and SA_PTV. These characteristics have not been clearly articulated in the vast body of previous research in SBRT. These results could help explain plans that cannot meet the RTOG criteria for R50%. With further development, these concepts could be extended to provide additional guidance for creating acceptable SBRT plans.

Hybrid planning techniques for hypofractionated whole-breast irradiation using flattening filter-free beams

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility of flattening filter-free (FFF) photon beams in hybrid intensity-modulated radiation therapy (H-IMRT) and hybrid volumetric modulated arc therapy (H-VMAT) for left-sided whole-breast radiation therapy with a boost volume (RT) using a hypofractionated dose regimen.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

RT plans of 25 patients with left-sided early-stage breast cancer were created with H‑IMRT and H‑VMAT techniques under breath-hold conditions using 6‑MV FFF beams. In hybrid techniques, three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3DCRT) plans were kept as base-dose plans for the VMAT and IMRT plans. In addition, H‑IMRT in step-and-shoot mode was also calculated to assess its achievability with FFF beams.

RESULTS

All hybrid plans achieved the expected target coverage. H‑VMAT showed better coverage and homogeneity index results for the boost target (p < 0.002), while H‑IMRT presented better results for the whole-breast target (p < 0.001). Mean doses to normal tissues were comparable between both plans, while H‑IMRT reduced the low-dose levels to heart and ipsilateral lung (p < 0.05). H‑VMAT revealed significantly better results with regard to monitor units (MU) and treatment time (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

The 6‑MV FFF beam technique is feasible for large-field 3DCRT-based hybrid planning in whole-breast and boost planning target volume irradiation. For breath-hold patients, the H‑VMAT plan is superior to H‑IMRT for hypofractionated dose regimens, with reduced MU and treatment delivery time.

The superficially averaged dose gradient at the target volume's boundary: A two-dimensional formulation and solution of anisotropic dose gradient problems

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Dose conformity and steepness of dose fall-off at a target volume's boundary are important quality criteria in treatment planning to predict complication rates in normal tissue and critical structures. Several dose gradient measures are in use; ICRU Report 91 recommends one of two gradient metrics for reporting. All of the common gradient indices are one-dimensional, although dose gradient problems are at least two-dimensional and anisotropic. Four of ten investigated gradient indices show false characteristics on the mean value of the physical dose gradients. Anisotropic dose gradient measures can be the basis of clinical therapeutic decisions if tumours are surrounded by organs at risk with various tolerance dose values. To close this information gap, the author presents a mathematical description and solution of anisotropic dose gradient problems.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The new two-dimensional dose gradient measure is called the superficially averaged dose gradient (SADG). The particular informative content of the ten common dose gradient indices was assessed by classification and analysing their properties. The correlations between all of the dose gradient measures were investigated for linac-based stereotactic radiosurgery of 13 brain metastases.

RESULTS

From all of the one-dimensional dose gradient indices, the approximated SADG* showed the best correlation on the SADG. Here, Pearson's correlation coefficient was 1.000 and the relative errors were in a range of -0.2 to 2.9%. Distributions of anisotropic dose gradients were graphically represented by dose gradient-solid angle histograms.

CONCLUSIONS

Two-dimensional dose gradient measures such as the SADG are urgently required for lesions that are located in non-homogeneous normal tissue. The quality of each present and future dose gradient measure concerning the description of anisotropic dose gradient problems is now verifiable by use of the SADG. Through the SADG, the influences of collimation types on the dose fall-off at the target volume's boundary can be investigated. The algorithm for determining the SADG should be implemented in treatment planning systems to utilise the formalism for all users. The dose gradient indices recommended in ICRU Report 91 overestimate and underestimate physical dose gradients, respectively.

A novel index for assessing treatment plan quality in stereotactic radiosurgery

OBJECTIVE

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is characterized by high levels of conformity and steep dose gradients from the periphery of the target to surrounding tissue. Clinical studies have backed up the importance of these factors through evidence of symptomatic complications. Available data suggest that there are threshold doses above which the risk of symptomatic radionecrosis increases with the volume irradiated. Therefore, radiosurgical treatment plans should be optimized by minimizing dose to the surrounding tissue while maximizing dose to the target volume. Several metrics have been proposed to quantify radiosurgical plan quality, but all present certain weaknesses. To overcome limitations of the currently used metrics, a novel metric is proposed, the efficiency index (η50%), which is based on the principle of calculating integral doses: η50% = integral doseTV/integral dosePIV50%.

METHODS

The value of η50% can be easily calculated by dividing the integral dose (mean dose × volume) to the target volume (TV) by the integral dose to the volume of 50% of the prescription isodose (PIV50%). Alternatively, differential dose-volume histograms (DVHs) of the TV and PIV50% can be used. The resulting η50% value is effectively the proportion of energy within the PIV50% that falls into the target. This value has theoretical limits of 0 and 1, with 1 being perfect. The index combines conformity, gradient, and mean dose to the target into a single value. The value of η50% was retrospectively calculated for 100 clinical SRS plans.

RESULTS

The value of η50% for the 100 clinical SRS plans ranged from 37.7% to 58.0% with a mean value of 49.0%. This study also showed that the same principles used for the calculation of η50% can be adapted to produce an index suitable for multiple-target plans (Gη12Gy). Furthermore, the authors present another adaptation of the index that may play a role in plan optimization by calculating and minimizing the proportion of energy delivered to surrounding organs at risk (OARη50%).

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed efficiency index is a novel approach in quantifying plan quality by combining conformity, gradient, and mean dose into a single value. It quantifies the ratio of the dose “doing good” versus the dose “doing harm,” and its adaptations can be used for multiple-target plan optimization and OAR sparing.

Plan quality comparison between 4-arc and 6-arc noncoplanar volumetric modulated arc stereotactic radiotherapy for the treatment of multiple brain metastases

To compare the plans of 4-arc and 6-arc noncoplanar volumetric modulated arc stereotactic radiotherapy (VMA-SRT) for multiple brain metastases and to investigate the cutoff value for the tumor number and volume for 6-arc rather than 4-arc VMA-SRT. We identified 24 consecutive multiple-target cases (3 to 19 targets in each case) with 189 total targets. We constructed plans using both 4- and 6-arc noncoplanar VMA-SRT. The prescribed dose was 36 Gy/6 fr, and it was delivered to 95% of the planning target volume (PTV). The plans were evaluated for the dose conformity using the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group and Paddick conformity indices (RCI and PCI), fall-off (Paddick gradient index [PGI]), and the normal brain dose. The median (range) RCI, PCI, and PGI was 0.94 (0.92 to 0.99), 0.89 (0.77 to 0.94), and 3.75 (2.24 to 6.54) for the 4-arc plan and 0.94 (0.91 to 0.98), 0.89 (0.76 to 0.94), and 3.65 (2.24 to 6.5) for the 6-arc plan, respectively. The median (range) of the normal brain dose was 910.3 cGy (381.4 to 1268.9) for the 4-arc plan and 898.8 cGy (377 to 1252.9) for the 6-arc plan. The PGI of the 6-arc plan was significantly superior to that of the 4-arc plan (p = 0.0076), and the optimal cutoff values for the tumor number and volume indicative of 6-arc (and not 4-arc) VMA-SRT were cases with ≥ 5 metastases and a PTV of ≥ 12.9 mL, respectively. The PCI values, however, showed no significant difference between the 2 plans. We believe these results will help in considering the use of 6-arc VMA-SRT for multiple brain metastases.

Gamma Knife and volumetric modulated arc therapy stereotactic radiosurgery plan quality and OAR sparing comparison for pituitary adenomas and vestibular schwannomas

PURPOSE

To compare the plan quality and organs at risk (OAR) sparing of auto-planned volumetric modulated art therapy (VMAT) and Gamma Knife (GK) for stereotactic radiosurgery of pituitary adenomas (PA) and vestibular schwannomas (VS).

METHODS

VMAT radiosurgery plans were made using auto planning tool for eight vestibular schwannoma and eight pituitary adenoma patients previously treated with GK. VMAT plans were made with three non-coplanar arcs using 315, 0 and 45 degrees angles, 6MV FFF energy at 1400 MU/min dose rate and 2.5 mm thick MLC leaves. Both GK and VMAT plans were prescribed to similar isodose lines (50% - 60%).

RESULTS

Respectively for GK and VMAT, the mean Paddick conformity index (PCI) was 0.62 ± 0.08 and 0.67 ± 0.10 (p > 0.05) for PA and 0.72 ± 0.09 and 0.660 ± 0.13 (p > 0.05) for VS; the mean gradient index (GI) was 2.76 ± 0.14 and 3.14 ± 0.40 Gy (p < 0.05) for PA and 3.71 ± 1.83 and 3.60 ± 0.84 Gy (p > 0.05) for VS; mean brainstem maximum dose was 9.13 ± 3.50 Gy and 7.31 ± 2.01 Gy (p > 0.05) for PA and 11.67 ± 4.56 Gy and 12.22 ± 4.55 Gy (p > 0.05) for VS; mean optic nerve maximum dose was 9.66 ± 1.0 Gy and 7.67 ± 2.58 Gy (p < 0.05); mean cochlea mean dose was 7.31 ± 2.7 Gy and 7.23 ± 3.13 Gy (p > 0.05); and mean treatment time was 68 min and 5 min for PA and 40 min and 3 min for VS.

CONCLUSIONS

Auto planning with standard template simplified the planning stage for VMAT and provided clinically acceptable plans. Comparison of GK and VMAT for plan quality and OAR sparing varied across patients but both were overall comparable.

Dosimetric comparison of different treatment modalities for stereotactic radiotherapy

Background

The modalities for performing stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) on the brain include the cone-based linear accelerator (linac), the flattening filter-free (FFF) volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) linac, and tomotherapy. In this study, the cone-based linac, FFF-VMAT linac, and tomotherapy modalities were evaluated by measuring the differences in doses delivered during brain SRT and experimentally assessing the accuracy of the output radiation doses through clinical measurements.

Methods

We employed a homemade acrylic dosimetry phantom representing the head, within which a thermoluminescent dosimeter (TLD) and radiochromic EBT3 film were installed. Using the conformity/gradient index (CGI) and Paddick methods, the quality of the doses delivered by the various SRT modalities was evaluated. The quality indicators included the uniformity, conformity, and gradient indices. TLDs and EBT3 films were used to experimentally assess the accuracy of the SRT dose output.

Results

The dose homogeneity indices of all the treatment modalities were lower than 1.25. The cone-based linac had the best conformity for all tumors, regardless of the tumor location and size, followed by the FFF-VMAT linac; tomography was the worst-performing treatment modality in this regard. The cone-based linac had the best gradient, regardless of the tumor location and size, whereas the FFF-VMAT linac had a better gradient than tomotherapy for a large tumor diameter (28 mm). The TLD and EBT3 measurements of the dose at the center of tumors indicated that the average difference between the measurements and the calculated dose was generally less than 4%. When the 3% 3-mm gamma passing rate metric was used, the average passing rates of all three treatment modalities exceeded 98%.

Conclusions

Regarding the dose, the cone-based linac had the best conformity and steepest dose gradient for tumors of different sizes and distances from the brainstem. The results of this study suggest that SRT should be performed using the cone-based linac on tumors that require treatment plans with a steep dose gradient, even as the tumor is slightly irregular, we should also consider using a high dose gradient of the cone base to treat and protect the normal tissue. If normal tissues require special protection exist at positions that are superior or inferior to the tumor, we can consider using tomotherapy or Cone base with couch at 0° for treatment.

A prediction model of radiation-induced necrosis for intracranial radiosurgery based on target volume

PURPOSE

This study aims to extend the observation that the 12 Gy-radiosurgical-volume (V12Gy) correlates with the incidence of radiation necrosis in patients with intracranial tumors treated with radiosurgery by using target volume to predict V12Gy. V12Gy based on the target volume was used to predict the radiation necrosis probability (P) directly. Also investigated was the reduction in radiation necrosis rates (ΔP) as a result of optimizing the prescription isodose lines for linac-based SRS.

METHODS

Twenty concentric spherical targets and 22 patients with brain tumors were retrospectively studied. For each case, a standard clinical plan and an optimized plan with prescription isodose lines based on gradient index were created. V12Gy were extracted from both plans to analyze the correlation between V12Gy and target volume. The necrosis probability P as a function of V12Gy was evaluated. To account for variation in prescription, the relation between V12Gy and prescription was also investigated.

RESULTS

A prediction model for radiation-induced necrosis was presented based on the retrospective study. The model directly relates the typical prescribed dose and the target volume to the radionecrosis probability; V12Gy increased linearly with the target volume (R²  > 0.99). The linear correlation was then integrated into a logistic model to predict P directly from the target volume. The change in V12Gy as a function of prescription was modeled using a single parameter, s (=-1.15). Relatively large ΔP was observed for target volumes between 7 and 28 cm³ with the maximum reduction (8-9%) occurring at approximately 18 cm³ .

CONCLUSIONS

Based on the model results, optimizing the prescription isodose line for target volumes between 7 and 28 cm³ results in a significant reduction in necrosis probability. V12Gy based on the target volume could provide clinicians a predictor of radiation necrosis at the contouring stage thus facilitating treatment decisions.

Isotoxic radiosurgery planning for brain metastases

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE(S)

Radionecrosis (RN) has previously been correlated with radiosurgery (RS) dose, lesion volume, and the volume of the brain receiving specific doses, i.e. V10-14Gy. A knowledge-based individualized estimation of the optimum RS dose has been derived based on lesional volume and brain toxicity parameters.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A prediction model for brain toxicity parameters and estimation of the optimum RS dose was derived using 30 historical linac-based dynamic conformal arc RS plans for single brain metastases (BM) (0.2-20.3cc) with risk-adapted dose prescription ranging from 15 to 24Gy. Derivation of the model followed a three-step process: (1) Derivation of formulas for the prediction of brain toxicity parameters V10-18Gy; (2) Establishing the relationship of the coefficients used for the prediction of V12Gy with prescription dose; (3) Derivation of the optimum prescription dose for a given maximum V12Gy as a function of a given lesion volume. Model validation was performed on 65 new patients with 138 lesions (44 with multiple BM) treated with non-coplanar volumetric modulated stereotactic arc treatment (VMAT).

RESULTS

A linear dependence with the PTV size was found for all investigated brain toxicity parameters (V10-18Gy). Individualized RS prescription doses can be calculated for any given PTV size based on a linear relationship between V12Gy and PTV size, according to the formula PD=[V12Gy+0.96+(1.44×PTV)]/[0.12+(0.12×PTV)]. A very good correlation (R(2)=0.991) was found between the predicted V12Gy and the resulting V12Gy in 65 new patients with 138 lesions treated with non-coplanar VMAT technique in our clinic.

CONCLUSIONS

A simple formula is proposed for estimation of the optimal individual RS dose for any given lesion volume for patients with (multiple) BM. This formula is based on calculation of the brain toxicity parameter, V12Gy, for the normal brain minus PTV.

Investigation of Dose Falloff for Intact Brain Metastases and Surgical Cavities Using Hypofractionated Volumetric Modulated Arc Radiotherapy

INTRODUCTION

Intact brain metastases tend to be small and spherical compared to postsurgery brain cavities, which tend to be large and irregular shaped and, as a result, a challenge with respect to treatment planning. The purpose of the present study is to develop guidelines for normal brain tissue dose and to investigate whether there is a dependence on target type for patients treated with hypofractionated volumetric modulated arc radiotherapy (HF-VMAT).

METHODS

Treatment plans from a total of 100 patients and 136 targets (55 cavity and 81 intact) were retrospectively reviewed. All targets were treated with HF-VMAT with total doses ranging between 20 and 30 gray (Gy) in 5 fractions. All plans met institutional objectives for organ-at-risk constraints and were clinically delivered. Dose falloff was quantified using gradient index (GI) and distance between the 100% and 50% isodose lines (R50). Additionally, the dose to normal brain tissue (brain contour excluding all gross tumor or clinical target volumes) was assessed using volume receiving specific doses (Vx) where x ranged from 5 to 30 Gy. Best-fit curves using power law relationships of the form y = ax(b) were generated for GI, R50, and Vx (normal brain tissue) versus target volume.

RESULTS

There was a statistically significant difference in planning target volume (PTV) for cavities versus intact metastases with mean volumes of 37.8 cm(3) and 9.5 cm(3), respectively (P < .0001). The GI and R50 were statistically different: 3.4 and 9.8 mm for cavities versus 4.6 and 8.3 mm for intact metastases (P < .0001). The R50 increased with PTV with power law coefficients (a, b) = (6.3, 0.12) and (5.9, 0.15) for cavities and intact, respectively. GI decreased with PTV with coefficients (a, b) = (5.9, -0.18) and (5.7, -0.14) for cavities and intact, respectively. The normal brain tissue Vx also exhibited power law relationships with PTV for x = 20 to 28.8 Gy. In conclusion, target volume is the main predictor of dose falloff. The results of the present study can be used for determining target volume-based thresholds for dose falloff and normal brain tissue dose-volume constraints.

Feasibility of single-isocenter, multi-arc non-coplanar volumetric modulated arc therapy for multiple brain tumors using a linear accelerator with a 160-leaf multileaf collimator: a phantom study

The feasibility of single isocenter, multi-arc non-coplanar volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) for multiple brain tumors was studied using an Elekta Synergy linear accelerator with an Agility multileaf collimator and a Monaco treatment planning system. Two VMAT radiosurgery plans consisting of a full arc and three half arcs were created with a prescribed dose of 20 Gy in a single fraction. After dose delivery to a phantom, ionization chambers and radiochromic films were used for dose measurement. The first VMAT radiosurgery plan had nine targets inside the phantom, and the doses were measured by the chambers at two different points and by the films on three sagittal and three coronal planes. The differences between the calculated dose and the dose measured by a Farmer ionization chamber and a pinpoint ionization chamber were <1.00% and <2.30%, respectively, and the average pass rates of gamma indices among the six planes under each of 3%/3 mm and 2%/2 mm criteria were 98.6% and 92.6%, respectively. The second VMAT radiosurgery plan was based on a clinical 14 brain metastases. Differences between calculated and film-measured doses were evaluated on two sagittal planes. The average pass rates of the gamma indices on the planes under each of 3%/3 mm and 2%/2 mm criteria were 97.8% and 88.8%, respectively. It was confirmed that single-isocenter, non-coplanar multi-arc VMAT radiosurgery for multiple brain metastases was feasible using Elekta Synergy with Agility and Monaco treatment planning systems. It was further shown that film dosimetry was accurately performed for a dose of up to nearly 25 Gy.

Target volume geometric change and/or deviation from the cranium during fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for brain metastases: potential pitfalls in image guidance based on bony anatomy alignment

INTRODUCTION

This study sought to evaluate the potential geometrical change and/or displacement of the target relative to the cranium during fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (FSRT) for treating newly developed brain metastases.

METHODS

For 16 patients with 21 lesions treated with image-guided frameless FSRT in 5 or 10 fractions using a 6-degree-of-freedom image guidance system-integrated platform, the unenhanced computed tomography or T2-weighted magnetic resonance images acquired until the completion of FSRT were fused to the planning image datasets for comparison. Significant change was defined as ≥3-mm change in the tumour diameter or displacement of the tumour centroid.

RESULTS

FSRT was started 1 day after planning image acquisition. Tumour shrinkage, deviation and both were observed in 2, 1 and 1 of the 21 lesions, respectively, over a period of 7-13 days. Tumour shrinkage or deviation resulted in an increase or decrease in the marginal dose to the tumour, respectively, and a substantial increase in the irradiated volume for the surrounding tissue irrespective of the pattern of alteration. No obvious differences in the clinical and treatment characteristics were noted among the populations with or without significant changes in tumour volume or position.

CONCLUSION

Target deformity and/or deviation can unexpectedly occur even during relatively short-course FSRT, inevitably leading to a gradual discrepancy between the planned and actually delivered doses to the tumour and surrounding tissue. To appropriately weigh the treatment outcome against the planned dose distribution, target deformity and/or deviation should also be considered in addition to the immobilisation accuracy, as image guidance with bony anatomy alignment does not necessarily guarantee accurate target localisation until completion of FSRT.

Cerebral cyst formation following stereotactic ablative irradiation for non-nasopharyngeal head and neck malignancies: imaging findings and relevant dosimetric parameters

OBJECTIVE

To describe the clinical characteristics, imaging findings and relevant dosimetric parameters of cases presenting with cerebral cyst formation (CCF) after single or oligo-fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) for non-nasopharyngeal head and neck malignancies (HNMs).

METHODS

We identified four cases with the follow-up duration of 5.7-9.1 years from SRT. The irradiated sites included the middle ear in one case and the ethmoid sinus in three cases, two of the latter possessed brain invasion. The chronological changes in MR images and the dose-volume histogram of the adjacent brain tissue were evaluated.

RESULTS

CCF with or without multiple septi presented with a latency of 29-86 months (median, 45.5 months), which was preceded by either non-specific parenchymal enhancement or typical radiation necrosis. In three cases, CCF adjacent to the frontal base resultantly caused mass effect, and two of these three cases required surgical intervention at 38 and 54 months, respectively, after SRT for alleviation of symptoms. The relation of the irradiated brain volumes to the biological equivalent dose based on the linear-quadratic (LQ) and LQ-cubic models was represented as a threshold.

CONCLUSION

When contemplating SRT for HNM cases, caution should be exercised to the dose-volume relation-ship of the adjacent brain tissue, especially the frontal base, as well as other critical structures, and long-term vigilant follow-up is also mandatory.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE

CCF can occur as an unusual consequence of late brain injury with variable but mostly long latency following SRT for non-nasopharyngeal HNMs adjacent to the brain, even superficial parts that were previously irradiated via conventional radiotherapy.

Clinical outcomes of single or oligo-fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for head and neck tumors using micromultileaf collimator-based dynamic conformal arcs

PURPOSE

To assess the clinical outcomes of single or oligo-fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) using dynamic conformal arcs (DCA) for head and neck tumors (HNTs).

METHODS

Thirty-four consecutive patients with 35 lesions treated between 2005 and 2009 were retrospectively evaluated, of whom 85.7 % had recurrent or metastatic disease, and 45.7 and 34.3 % had previous radiotherapy and surgery, respectively. The median SRT dose was 22.3 Gy (11.2-32.8) in 2-4 fractions with a median interval of 7 days and 10.4 Gy (9.2-12.4) in one fraction. SRT was combined with upfront conventionally fractionated RT in 48.6 % of patients.

RESULTS

The median follow-up periods were 18.4 months (2-84.1) for the entire cohort and 49.6 months for the survivors. The 1- and 2-year local control (LC) rates were 84.3 and 70.5 %, with the 1- and 2-year overall survival (OS) rates of 78.6 and 51.6 %. LC was significantly better for tumor volumes <25.6 cm(3) (p = 0.001). OS was significantly longer in patients without any disease outside the SRT site (p < 0.001), whereas LC after the SRT did not affect the OS. Late adverse events occurred in 9 patients, including cranial nerve (CN) injury (grade 3/4) in 2, brain radionecrosis in 5 (grade 1), and fatal bleeding in 2 patients harboring uncontrolled lesions abutting the carotid artery.

CONCLUSIONS

DCA-based SRT can confer relatively long-term LC with acceptable toxicity in selected patients with HNTs. The patients with CN involvement or tumor volume ≥25.6 cm(3) were deemed unsuitable for this treatment regimen.

Consideration of optimal isodose surface selection for target coverage in micro-multileaf collimator-based stereotactic radiotherapy for large cystic brain metastases: comparison of 90%, 80% and 70% isodose surface-based planning

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to compare dynamic conformal arc (DCA) plans based on different-percentage isodose surfaces (IDSs), normalised to 100% at the isocentre, for target coverage (TC; dose prescription) in stereotactic radiotherapy for large cystic brain metastases.

METHODS

The DCA plans were generated for 15 targets (5 spherical models and 10 metastatic brain lesions) based on 90%, 80% and 70% IDSs for dose prescription to attain ≥99% TC values using the Novalis Tx platform. These plans were optimised mainly by leaf margin and/or collimator angle adjustment, while similar arc arrangements were used.

RESULTS

TC values were equivalent among the three plans. Conformity index values were similar between the 80% and 70% plans, while they were worse in the 90% plans. Mean doses (D(mean)) of the interior 3 mm rind structure were highest in the 70% plans, followed by the 80% plans and lowest in the 90% plans. D(mean) of the exterior 3 mm rind structure and the ratio of 50%/100% isodose volumes (Paddick's gradient index values) were highest in the 90% plans, followed by 80% and lowest in the 70% plans.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that the 70% IDS plans might be beneficial for both tumour control and reducing toxicity to surrounding normal tissue if appropriate dose conformity and precise treatment set-up are ensured. The 90% IDS plans are unfavourable in view of inferior dose gradient outside the target and should be limited to cases in which the target dose homogeneity is given the highest priority.