The Problem of Visual Excitation*

The discovery of the ability of rod photoreceptors to signal single photons

A retrospective on the scientific importance and impact of Hecht, Shlaer, and Pirenne’s classic 1942 paper, “Energy, Quanta, and Vision.”

Vertebrate rod photoreceptors evolved the astonishing ability to respond reliably to single photons. In parallel, the proximate neurons of the visual system evolved the ability to reliably encode information from a few single-photon responses (SPRs) as arising from the presence of an object of interest in the visual environment. These amazing capabilities were first inferred from measurements of human visual threshold by Hecht et al. (1942), whose paper has since been cited over 1,000 times. Subsequent research, in part inspired by Hecht et al.’s discovery, has directly measured rod SPRs, characterized the molecular mechanism responsible for their generation, and uncovered much about the specializations in the retina that enable the reliable transmission of SPRs in the teeth of intrinsic neuronal noise.

S-opsin knockout mice with the endogenous M-opsin gene replaced by an L-opsin variant

Specific variants of human long-wavelength (L) and middle-wavelength (M) cone opsin genes have recently been associated with a variety of vision disorders caused by cone malfunction, including red-green color vision deficiency, blue cone monochromacy, myopia, and cone dystrophy. Strikingly, unlike disease-causing mutations in rhodopsin, most of the cone opsin alleles that are associated with vision disorders do not have deleterious point mutations. Instead, specific combinations of normal polymorphisms that arose by genetic recombination between the genes encoding L and M opsins appear to cause disease. Knockout/knock-in mice promise to make it possible to study how these deleterious cone opsin variants affect the structure, function, and viability of the cone photoreceptors. Ideally, we would like to evaluate different variants that cause vision disorders in humans against a control pigment that is not associated with vision disorders, and each variant should be expressed as the sole photopigment in each mouse cone, as is the case in humans. To evaluate the feasibility of this approach, we created a line of mice to serve as the control in the analysis of disease-causing mutations by replacing exon 2 through 6 of the mouse M-opsin gene with the corresponding cDNA for a human L-opsin variant that is associated with normal vision. Experiments reported here establish that the resulting pigment, which differs from the endogenous mouse M opsin at 35 amino acid positions, functions normally in mouse cones. This pigment was evaluated in mice with and without coexpression of the mouse short wavelength (S) opsin. Here, the creation and validation of two lines of genetically engineered mice that can be used to study disease-causing variants of human L/M-opsins, in vivo, are described.

Modeling the flexural rigidity of rod photoreceptors

In vertebrate eyes, the rod photoreceptor has a modified cilium with an extended cylindrical structure specialized for phototransduction called the outer segment (OS). The OS has numerous stacked membrane disks and can bend or break when subjected to mechanical forces. The OS exhibits axial structural variation, with extended bands composed of a few hundred membrane disks whose thickness is diurnally modulated. Using high-resolution confocal microscopy, we have observed OS flexing and disruption in live transgenic Xenopus rods. Based on the experimental observations, we introduce a coarse-grained model of OS mechanical rigidity using elasticity theory, representing the axial OS banding explicitly via a spring-bead model. We calculate a bending stiffness of ∼10(5) nN⋅μm2, which is seven orders-of-magnitude larger than that of typical cilia and flagella. This bending stiffness has a quadratic relation to OS radius, so that thinner OS have lower fragility. Furthermore, we find that increasing the spatial frequency of axial OS banding decreases OS rigidity, reducing its fragility. Moreover, the model predicts a tendency for OS to break in bands with higher spring number density, analogous to the experimental observation that transgenic rods tended to break preferentially in bands of high fluorescence. We discuss how pathological alterations of disk membrane properties by mutant proteins may lead to increased OS rigidity and thus increased breakage, ultimately contributing to retinal degeneration.

Rod/cone rivalry in pigment regeneration

1. The rod branch of the dark-adaptation curve was studied at two regions 1(1/4) degrees from the foveal centre (see inset, Fig. 2).2. One region had been bleached by red light, the other by blue of equal scotopic value.3. This equality was established by finding the rod increment threshold against the red or blue backgrounds: they were judged equal when they raised the rod threshold equally.4. If the bleaching exposure lasted 4 min or less, the rod dark-adaptation curves coincided, though the cone branches did not (since red bleached cones 80%, blue 20%, but rods were bleached equally).5. If the bleaching exposure was prolonged to 16 min the rods recovered more slowly from the red bleach. And this difference was enhanced by a preliminary intense white exposure that bleached everything.6. The effect was due to the presence of cones since repeating the experiment at 15 degrees from the fovea where cones are scarce virtually gave coincident rod dark-adaptation curves.7. It follows that where cones are regenerating fast (from the 80% red bleach) they extract from the space outside the cone cells some ingredient needed for rod regeneration, and after pronounced and prolonged bleaching, the lack of this ingredient slows rod recovery.8. Most probably the ingredient is 11-cis retinol returning from the pigment epithelium.

Three-dimensional architecture of murine rod outer segments determined by cryoelectron tomography

The rod outer segment (ROS) of photoreceptor cells houses all components necessary for phototransduction, a set of biochemical reactions that amplify and propagate a light signal. Theoretical approaches to quantify this process require precise information about the physical boundaries of the ROS. Dimensions of internal structures within the ROS of mammalian species have yet to be determined with the precision required for quantitative considerations. Cryoelectron tomography was utilized to obtain reliable three-dimensional morphological information about this important structure from murine retina. Vitrification of samples permitted imaging of the ROS in a minimally perturbed manner and the preservation of substructures. Tomograms revealed the characteristic highly organized arrangement of disc membranes stacked on top of one another with a surrounding plasma membrane. Distances among the various membrane components of the ROS were measured to define the space available for phototransduction to occur. Reconstruction of segments of the ROS from single-axis tilt series images provided a glimpse into the three-dimensional architecture of this highly differentiated neuron. The reconstructions revealed spacers that likely maintain the proper distance between adjacent discs and between discs and the plasma membrane. Spacers were found distributed throughout the discs, including regions that are distant from the rim region of discs.

The C terminus of peripherin/rds participates in rod outer segment targeting and alignment of disk incisures

Protein targeting is essential for domain specialization in polarized cells. In photoreceptors, three distinct membrane domains exist in the outer segment: plasma membrane, disk lamella, and disk rim. Peripherin/retinal degeneration slow (rds) and rom-1 are photoreceptor-specific members of the transmembrane 4 superfamily of transmembrane proteins, which participate in disk morphogenesis and localize to rod outer segment (ROS) disk rims. We examined the role of their C termini in targeting by generating transgenic Xenopus laevis expressing green fluorescent protein (GFP) fusion proteins. A GFP fusion containing residues 317-336 of peripherin/rds localized uniformly to disk membranes. A longer fusion (residues 307-346) also localized to the ROS but exhibited higher affinity for disk rims than disk lamella. In contrast, the rom-1 C terminus did not promote ROS localization. The GFP-peripherin/rds fusion proteins did not immunoprecipitate with peripherin/rds or rom-1, suggesting this region does not form intermolecular interactions and is not involved in subunit assembly. Presence of GFP-peripherin/rds fusions correlated with disrupted incisures, disordered ROS tips, and membrane whorls. These abnormalities may reflect competition of the fusion proteins for other proteins that interact with peripherin/rds. This work describes novel roles for the C terminus of peripherin/rds in targeting and maintaining ROS structure and its potential involvement in inherited retinal degenerations.

THE ROLE OF CARBONIUM IONS IN COLOR RECEPTION

It is a fundamental property of conjugated systems to accept a proton or Lewis acid and form a stable carbonium ion. Polyenes that are protonated or add Lewis acids in this manner undergo substantial red shifts. For example, vitamin A₁ acetate absorbs at 350 mµ in neutral and at 650 mµ in acidic benzene solution. The fundamental basis for absorption of polyene systems was described in detail in quantum mechanical terms. Applying the carbonium ion treatment to the visual chromophores retinal₁ and retinal₂ gives a very satisfactory explanation why these polyenes can be made to absorb in the visual region. Furthermore, by proper placement of the Lewis acid several absorption maxima can be gained from the carbonium ions which result. This treatment can be applied to explain experimental results. Individual cones from the frog are now known to absorb at 455, 537, and 625 mµ. If the value for the green cone (537 mµ) is used to calculate the V_o value in Kuhn's equation, the other two wave lengths may then be calculated. The calculated values are 460 and 600 mµ; this is in good agreement with the results from experiment.

VISUAL PIGMENTS IN SINGLE RODS AND CONES OF THE HUMAN RETINA. DIRECT MEASUREMENTS REVEAL MECHANISMS OF HUMAN NIGHT AND COLOR VISION

Difference spectra of the visual pigments have been measured in single rods and cones of a parafoveal region of the human retina. Rods display an absorption maximum (lambdamax) at about 505 mmicro associated with rhodopsin. Three kinds of cones were measured: a blue-sensitive cone with Amaxe about 450 mpf; two green-sensitive cones with Xmaa about 525 mumicro; and a red-sensitive cone with lambdamax about 555 mmicro These are presumably samples of the three types of cone responsible for human color vision.

FINE STRUCTURE OF THE EYE OF A CHAETOGNATH

Electron microscopy reveals a star-like pigment cell at the center of the eye of the arrow-worm, Sagitta scrippsae. Between the arms of the pigment cell are clusters of photoreceptor cell processes, each process consisting of: (1) a tubular segment containing longitudinally arranged microtubules about 500 A in diameter and 20 µ in length; (2) a remarkable conical body, composed of cords and large granules, situated at the base of the tubular segment; and (3) a connecting piece which, like that of rods and cones, connects the process with the sensory cell proper and through which runs a fibrillar apparatus consisting of nine peripheral double tubules. Beneath the connecting piece lies a typical centriole with a striated rootlet. The receptor cell process is deeply recessed into the sensory cell which may possess a corona of microvilli at its inner surface. A nerve fiber arises from the outer end of the cell and passes into the optic nerve. Additional features are some supporting cells, an external layer of flattened epithelial cells, and an over-all investment of basement membrane and thick fibrous capsule. The fine structure and function of these elements of the eye are discussed in relation to earlier studies with the light microscope. The ciliary nature of the photoreceptor cell process in S. scrippsae points to a probable evolutionary relationship of chaetognaths to echinoderms and chordates.

THE VISUAL CELLS AND VISUAL PIGMENT OF THE MUDPUPPY, NECTURUS

Electron microscopy of the visual cells of the mudpuppy Necturus have revealed several new or hitherto neglected features of organization: (a) A system of deeply staining micelles in virtually crystalline array, probably located in the lamellae of the rod outer segments. These particles may contain the visual pigment, porphyropsin. Counts of the micelles, and microspectrophotometric measurements of porphyropsin in the retina and single rods yield the estimate that each lamellar micelle may contain about 50 molecules of porphyropsin. (b) Systems of about 30 cytoplasmic filaments (here called dendrites), continuous with the cytoplasm of the inner segment, and standing like a palisade about the outer segments of the rods and cones. In the rods, one such filament stands in the mouth of each of the approximately 30 deep fissures that carve the outer segment into a radial array of lobules. (c) A system of deeply staining particles in the membranes of the dendrites, and another in the membranes of the pigment epithelial processes. It is suggested that these may have a part in interchanges of material with the outer segments. The ciliary process is found to penetrate more deeply than is commonly supposed into the outer segments of the rods and cones. The edge of each double-membrane disc in rods forms a differentiated rim structure, both around the disc circumference and bordering the fissures. These anatomical arrangements are summarized in Figs. 13 and 14, and the relevant measurements in Table I. The dilution of visual pigment in Necturus rods and cones and a general consideration of their microstructures make it seem unlikely that such typically solid state processes as exciton migration or photoconduction can transport the effects of light far from the site of absorption. Excitation must, therefore, be conveyed to the receptor as a whole by some axial structure. Among axial structures, the plasma membrane is most likely to be the site of nervous excitation. The ciliary process probably plays its main role in the embryogenesis and regeneration of outer segments; and the dendrites and pigment epithelial processes in exchanges of material with the outer segments and perhaps with one another.

Long-term rod dark adaptation in man. Threshold measurements, rhodopsin regeneration and allosteric sensitivity regulation. An evaluation

Recent evidence strongly suggests that the relationship between threshold elevation (T) and fraction of bleached rhodopsin (B), obtained during a major, middle period of long-term rod dark adaptation in man, is well described by a power function, i.e., T = k.Bn, where k is a multiplicative constant and n is the exponent. Due primarily to the low reliability of measurements of rhodopsin regeneration, however, the exponent n of the power function cannot, at present, be given an exact value. Available information indicates that the value of the exponent ranges between 2.4 and 4. Implications of this uncertainty are discussed within the framework of the allosteric, tetrameric model of rod dark adaptation. It is concluded that this model in its simplest form may only offer a first approximation of the real system implicated in the process.

Dark-adaptation mechanisms of the long-wave foveal cones

The ordinary long-term rod and cone dark-adaptation curves have generally been assumed to follow a single exponential rate of recovery. However, in two previous papers on rod dark-adaptation (Stabell et al., 1986a, b), the recovery curve was found to consist of three different sections. The results of the present paper show the same type of recovery function with three different sections for the long-term dark-adaptation curve of the long-wave cone system. During the major, middle section log cone threshold, like log rod threshold, is linearly related to the logarithm of the concentration of bleached photopigment. Presupposing that the bleached cone photopigment acts as a ligand, the change in threshold level obtained during the middle section of the dark-adaptation curve is well described by the change in activity rate of an allosteric, postively cooperative enzyme built as a dimer.

Lack of interaction of rhodopsin chromophore with membrane lipids. An electron-electron double resonance study using 14N:15N pairs

Electron-electron double resonance (ELDOR) has been applied to the study of specific interactions of 15N-spin-labeled stearic acid with the retinal chromophore of a rhodopsin analogue containing a 14N spin-labeled retinal. Both the 5 and 16 spin-labeled stearic acids were incorporated into the lipid bilayer of rod outer segment membranes containing the spin-labeled pigment. No interaction between the 15N and 14N spin-labels was observed in rhodopsin or the metarhodopsin II state with either of these labeled stearic acids. Therefore in this system the ring portion of the chromophore must be highly sequestered from the phospholipid bilayer in both the rhodopsin and metarhodopsin II forms.

The opsin family of proteins

Images

Constraints imposed on taste physiology by human taste reaction time data

The speed with which an organism responds to stimulus events is reaction time (RT): the minimum time interval between stimulus arrival at a receptor organ, and an overt response by the organism. This time interval specifies maximum duration of all processes necessary for the RT sequence. Responses to any change in taste have RT less than 1 sec for suprathreshold concentrations. Therefore, constituent events at taste receptors, in the central nervous system (CNS), and at the response organ, must have sufficient durations less than 1 sec (Constraint 1). Taste stimulus durations of 50 msec, and therefore taste receptor events of approximately 50 msec, are sufficient for these responses (Constraint 2), as well as for taste quality identification responses (Constraint 3). Taste receptor latencies, neural conduction times, and RT response organ events are even briefer. Thus, 60% to 90% of human taste RT is CNS events. Taste receptor events remain crucial, but CNS processing is important, and apparently time limiting, in all human taste judgments.

Transient dichroism in photoreceptor membranes indicates that stable oligomers of rhodopsin do not form during excitation

If a photoexcited rhodopsin molecule initiates the formation of rhodopsin oligomers during the process of visual excitation, the rate of rotational diffusion of the rhodopsin molecules involved should change markedly. Using microsecond-flash photometry, we have observed the rotational diffusion of rhodopsin throughout the time period of visual excitation and found that no detectable change occurs in its rotational diffusion rate. Partial chemical cross-linking of the retina yields oligomers of rhodopsin and causes a significant decrease in the rotational diffusion rate of rhodopsin even when as little as 20% of rhodopsin is dimeric. Moreover, the pattern of oligomers formed by cross-linking, taken together with the magnitude of decreases in rotational diffusion rate accompanying the cross-linking reaction, suggests that rhodopsin is a monomer in the dark-adapted state. The experiments reported here show that photoexcited rhodopsin molecules do not irreversibly associate with unbleached neighbors during the time course of the receptor response. Hence, it is not likely that stable oligomers of rhodopsin trigger the excitation of the photoreceptor cell.

Spectral sensitivity of a novel photoreceptive system mediating entrainment of mammalian circadian rhythms

Environmental light cycles are the dominant synchronizers of circadian rhythms in the field, and artificial light cycles and pulses are the major tools used in the laboratory to analyse properties of circadian systems. It is therefore surprising that few studies have analysed the physical parameters of light stimuli that affect circadian rhythms. There have previously been no spectral sensitivity measurements for phase shifting the circadian rhythms of mammals and only two preliminary reports on the wavelength dependence of this response exist. Using the magnitude of phase shift caused by a single 15-min pulse of monochromatic light given 6 h after activity onset, we have now characterized the spectral sensitivity of the photoreceptors responsible for phase shifting the locomotor rhythm of the hamster (Mesocricetus auratus). The sensitivity curve for this response has a maximum near 500 nm and is similar to the absorption spectrum for rhodopsin. Although the spectral sensitivity is consistent with a rhodopsin-based photopigment, two features of the photoreceptive system that mediates entrainment are unusual: the threshold of the response is high, especially for a predominantly rod retina like that of the hamster, and the reciprocal relationship between intensity and duration holds for extremely long durations (up to 45 min). These results suggest that the photoreceptive system mediating entrainment is markedly different from that involved in visual image formation.

Phospholipid domains in bovine retinal rod outer segment disk membranes

Phospholipid behavior in bovine retinal rod outer segment disk membranes and in phosphatidylcholine membranes containing the photopigment rhodopsin is explored. 31P NMR spectra of these systems show two distinguishable resonances. One resembles closely the 31P NMR resonance normally obtained from phospholipid bilayers. The other resonance is much broader. Thus, there appear to be two phospholipid head-group domains in this retinal membrane. Each environment confers different properties on the head groups. Phosphatidylcholine membranes containing the disk photopigment also show two phospholipid domains. Therefore, the environment in the retinal rod outer segment disk membranes characterized by the broad resonance may arise from the influence of the integral membrane protein rhodopsin on the membrane phospholipid bilayer.

Rhodopsin in reconstituted phospholipid vesicles. 1. Structural parameters and light-induced conformational changes detected by resonance energy transfer and fluorescence quenching

The structure of purified rhodopsin was investigated by steady-state resonance energy transfer and fluorescence quenching techniques: (1) Fluorescence parameters and relative distances between rhodopsin sites labeled with fluorescent probes and the endogenous chromophore 11-cis-retinal were measured in micellar detergent solution and in reconstituted phospholipid vesicles. (2) The accessibility of the labeled rhodopsin sites in reconstituted vesicles to N-methyl- and N-benzylpicolinium was studied in the dark and subsequent to rhodopsin bleaching. Fluorescent-labeled rhodopsin was affinity purified in octyl glucoside from rod outer segments which were previously reacted with either the sulfhydryl-specific reagents, pyrenylmaleimide or monobromobimane, or reagents specific to amino groups, dansyl chloride or fluorescein isothiocyanate. The purified protein was recombined with phospholipids, and vesicles were formed by detergent dialysis. All four fluorophores appear to react greater than or equal to 30 A away from the endogenous chromophore as estimated from the efficiency of energy transfer and presumably probe rhodopsin domains exposed at the membrane surface. The maximal fraction of quenchable fluorescence and the mean quenching constant were determined in dark and bleached vesicles: bleaching did not affect the quenching of the fluorophores attached to sulfhydryl groups but markedly decreased the quenching constants of the fluorophores coupled to amino groups. The apparent collisional rate constant decreased by 20- and 4-fold for dansyl and fluorescein, respectively. The results suggest that bleaching reduced the accessibility of these sites which, in turn, may reflect light-induced displacements of rhodopsin domains at the membrane surface. Such structural changes may regulate rhodopsin-rhodopsin as well as rhodopsin-enzyme interactions.

Interactions among rods in the isolated retina of Bufo marinus

1. The existence and extent of interactions among rods were analysed in the isolated retina of Bufo marinus. Intracellular recordings were made from the outer segments with micropipettes. Stimuli of precisely measured geometry were delivered to the outer segments using a compound microscope. 2. To demonstrate the existence of interactions two rods were simultaneously impaled; current injected into one rod resulted in a current-induced potential of like sign in the other rod. 3. When the diameter of a circular stimulus was increased from 30 to 500 micrometer the mean sensitivity of the rods increased by 1.2 +/- 0.3 log units (S.D.), though the illuminance measured through the impaled rod was adjusted to be constant. 4. The extent of interactions was examined by presenting a dim, slit-shaped stimulus at each of several displacements from an impaled rod. This stimulus either passed through the retina before coming into focus on the outer segments (transillumination) or was focused directly on the outer segments (incident illumination). For each displacement both the amount of light scattered onto the impaled rod and the response of the rod were measured. 5. The amount of light scattered onto the impaled rod was assessed for each displacement of the stimulus. For incident illumination this assessment was made by measuring the distribution of bleached pigment about the slit stimulus. The bleaching could be described by an exponential that decreased with distance; this exponential had a space constant of 4 micrometer. For transillumination the assessment was made in two ways. The light that passed through the impaled rod was measured and found to decrease exponentially with slit displacement; the mean space constant of this exponentially was 9.3 +/- 3.2 micrometer (S.D.). In few experiments the distribution of bleached pigment about the slit stimulus was measured and was found to decrease exponentially with distance; this latter exponential had a slightly longer space constant than the exponential measured using transmitted light. 6. For each impaled rod a convolution of an exponential interaction function with the measured distribution of stimulus illuminance about the impaled rod could be fitted to the plot of response amplitude versus displacement of the slit stimulus. For stimuli presented by transillumination the mean space constant describing the interaction functions was 20 +/- 6 micrometer (S.D.). For stimuli presented by incident illumination the mean space constant of the interaction functions was 22 +/- 4 micrometer (S.D.). 7. This report presents new evidence that interactions among rods exist in the isolated retina and that the extent of interactions can be described by a space constant of about 20 micrometer.

Absorption of light in photoreceptors: transverse incidence

The time variation of the absorption rate (i.e., the number of photons absorbed per see) in a photoreceptor when light is incident perpendicular to its axis has been studied for various species and different conditions. Due to the cylindrical geometry of the photoreceptor the expressions for the absorption rates become very complicated. Hence, simple approximate expressions for the absorption rates in the case of some of the species have been suggested. The present analysis will be useful in analysing the mechanism of the photoreceptor when light is incident perpendicular to the axis.