The Trigger Factor Chaperone Encapsulates and Stabilizes Partial Folds of Substrate Proteins

Dosage constraint of the ribosome-associated molecular chaperone drives the evolution and fates of its duplicates in bacteria

Gene duplication events happen prevalently during evolution, and the mechanisms governing the loss or retention of duplicated genes are mostly elusive. Our genome scanning analysis revealed that trigger factor (TF), the one and only bacterial ribosome-associated molecular chaperone, is singly copied in virtually every bacterium except for a very few that possess two or more copies. However, even in these exceptions, only one complete TF copy exists, while other homologs lack the N-terminal domain that contains the conserved ribosome binding site (RBS) motif. Consistently, we demonstrated that the overproduction of the N-terminal complete TF proteins is detrimental to the cell, which can be rescued by removing the N-terminal domain. Our findings also indicated that TF overproduction leads to a decrease in protein productivity and profile changes in proteome due to its characteristic ribosome binding and holdase activities. Additionally, these N-terminal deficient TF homologs in bacteria with multiple TF homologs partition the function of TF via subfunctionalization. Our results revealed that TF is subjected to a dosage constraint that originates from its own intrinsic functions, which may drive the evolution and fates of duplicated TFs in bacteria.

IMPORTANCE

Gene duplication events presumably occur in tig, which encodes the ribosome-associated molecular chaperone trigger factor (TF). However, TF is singly copied in virtually every bacterium, and these exceptions with multiple TF homologs always retain only one complete copy while other homologs lack the N-terminal domain. Here, we reveal the manner and mechanism underlying the evolution and fates of TF duplicates in bacteria. We discovered that the mutation-to-loss or retention-to-sub/neofunctionalization of TF duplicates is associated with the dosage constraint of N-terminal complete TF. The dosage constraint of TF is attributed to its characteristic ribosome binding and substrate-holding activities, causing a decrease in protein productivity and profile changes in cellular proteome.

Mechanism of chaperone coordination during cotranslational protein folding in bacteria

Protein folding is assisted by molecular chaperones that bind nascent polypeptides during mRNA translation. Several structurally distinct classes of chaperones promote de novo folding, suggesting that their activities are coordinated at the ribosome. We used biochemical reconstitution and structural proteomics to explore the molecular basis for cotranslational chaperone action in bacteria. We found that chaperone binding is disfavored close to the ribosome, allowing folding to precede chaperone recruitment. Trigger factor recognizes compact folding intermediates that expose an extensive unfolded surface, and dictates DnaJ access to nascent chains. DnaJ uses a large surface to bind structurally diverse intermediates and recruits DnaK to sequence-diverse solvent-accessible sites. Neither Trigger factor, DnaJ, nor DnaK destabilize cotranslational folding intermediates. Instead, the chaperones collaborate to protect incipient structure in the nascent polypeptide well beyond the ribosome exit tunnel. Our findings show how the chaperone network selects and modulates cotranslational folding intermediates.

Cytosolic Interactome Protects Against Protein Unfolding in a Single Molecule Experiment

Single molecule techniques are particularly well suited for investigating the processes of protein folding and chaperone assistance. However, current assays provide only a limited perspective on the various ways in which the cellular environment can influence the folding pathway of a protein. In this study, a single molecule mechanical interrogation assay is developed and used to monitor protein unfolding and refolding within a cytosolic solution. This allows to test the cumulative topological effect of the cytoplasmic interactome on the folding process. The results reveal a stabilization against forced unfolding for partial folds, which are attributed to the protective effect of the cytoplasmic environment against unfolding and aggregation. This research opens the possibility of conducting single molecule molecular folding experiments in quasi-biological environments.

Bacillus subtilis forms twisted cells with cell wall integrity defects upon removal of the molecular chaperones DnaK and trigger factor

The protein homeostasis network ensures a proper balance between synthesis, folding, and degradation of all cellular proteins. DnaK and trigger factor (TF) are ubiquitous bacterial molecular chaperones that assist in protein folding, as well as preventing protein misfolding and aggregation. In Escherichia coli, DnaK and TF possess partially overlapping functions. Their combined depletion results in proteostasis collapse and is synthetically lethal at temperatures above 30°C. To increase our understanding on how proteostasis is maintained in Gram-positive bacteria, we have investigated the physiological effects of deleting dnaK and tig (encoding for DnaK and TF) in Bacillus subtilis. We show that combined deletion of dnaK and tig in B. subtilis is non-lethal, but causes a severe pleiotropic phenotype, including an aberrant twisted and filamentous cell morphology, as well as decreased tolerance to heat and to cell wall active antibiotics and hydrolytic enzymes, indicative of defects in cell wall integrity. In addition, cells lacking DnaK and TF have a much smaller colony size due to defects in motility. Despite these physiological changes, we observed no major compromises in important cellular processes such as cell growth, FtsZ localization and division and only moderate defects in spore formation. Finally, through suppressor analyses, we found that the wild-type cell shape can be partially restored by mutations in genes involved in metabolism or in other diverse cellular processes.

Single-molecule mechanical studies of chaperones and their clients

Single-molecule force spectroscopy provides access to the mechanics of biomolecules. Recently, magnetic and laser optical tweezers were applied in the studies of chaperones and their interaction with protein clients. Various aspects of the chaperone-client interactions can be revealed based on the mechanical probing strategies. First, when a chaperone is probed under load, one can examine the inner workings of the chaperone while it interacts with and works on the client protein. Second, when protein clients are probed under load, the action of chaperones on folding clients can be studied in great detail. Such client folding studies have given direct access to observing actions of chaperones in real-time, like foldase, unfoldase, and holdase activity. In this review, we introduce the various single molecule mechanical techniques and summarize recent single molecule mechanical studies on heat shock proteins, chaperone-mediated folding on the ribosome, SNARE folding, and studies of chaperones involved in the folding of membrane proteins. An outlook on significant future developments is given.

Direct observation of Hsp90-induced compaction in a protein chain

The chaperone heat shock protein 90 (Hsp90) is well known to undergo important conformational changes, which depend on nucleotide and substrate interactions. Conversely, how the conformations of its unstable and disordered substrates are affected by Hsp90 is difficult to address experimentally yet is central to its function. Here, using optical tweezers, we find that Hsp90 promotes local contractions in unfolded chains that drive their global compaction down to dimensions of folded states. This compaction has a gradual nature while showing small steps, is stimulated by ATP, and performs mechanical work against counteracting forces that expand the chain dimensions. The Hsp90 interactions suppress the formation of larger-scale folded, misfolded, and aggregated structures. The observations support a model in which Hsp90 alters client conformations directly by promoting local intra-chain interactions while suppressing distant ones. We conjecture that chain compaction may be central to how Hsp90 protects unstable clients and cooperates with Hsp70.

Update on the Protein Homeostasis Network in Bacillus subtilis

Protein homeostasis is fundamental to cell function and survival. It relies on an interconnected network of processes involving protein synthesis, folding, post-translational modification and degradation as well as regulators of these processes. Here we provide an update on the roles, regulation and subcellular localization of the protein homeostasis machinery in the Gram-positive model organism Bacillus subtilis. We discuss emerging ideas and current research gaps in the field that, if tackled, increase our understanding of how Gram-positive bacteria, including several human pathogens, maintain protein homeostasis and cope with stressful conditions that challenge their survival.

Is Protein Folding a Thermodynamically Unfavorable, Active, Energy-Dependent Process?

The prevailing current view of protein folding is the thermodynamic hypothesis, under which the native folded conformation of a protein corresponds to the global minimum of Gibbs free energy G. We question this concept and show that the empirical evidence behind the thermodynamic hypothesis of folding is far from strong. Furthermore, physical theory-based approaches to the prediction of protein folds and their folding pathways so far have invariably failed except for some very small proteins, despite decades of intensive theory development and the enormous increase of computer power. The recent spectacular successes in protein structure prediction owe to evolutionary modeling of amino acid sequence substitutions enhanced by deep learning methods, but even these breakthroughs provide no information on the protein folding mechanisms and pathways. We discuss an alternative view of protein folding, under which the native state of most proteins does not occupy the global free energy minimum, but rather, a local minimum on a fluctuating free energy landscape. We further argue that ΔG of folding is likely to be positive for the majority of proteins, which therefore fold into their native conformations only through interactions with the energy-dependent molecular machinery of living cells, in particular, the translation system and chaperones. Accordingly, protein folding should be modeled as it occurs in vivo, that is, as a non-equilibrium, active, energy-dependent process.

Chaperonin Abundance Enhances Bacterial Fitness

The ability of chaperonins to buffer mutations that affect protein folding pathways suggests that their abundance should be evolutionarily advantageous. Here, we investigate the effect of chaperonin overproduction on cellular fitness in Escherichia coli. We demonstrate that chaperonin abundance confers 1) an ability to tolerate higher temperatures, 2) improved cellular fitness, and 3) enhanced folding of metabolic enzymes, which is expected to lead to enhanced energy harvesting potential.

Mechanisms of Cotranslational Protein Maturation in Bacteria

Growing cells invest a significant part of their biosynthetic capacity into the production of proteins. To become functional, newly-synthesized proteins must be N-terminally processed, folded and often translocated to other cellular compartments. A general strategy is to integrate these protein maturation processes with translation, by cotranslationally engaging processing enzymes, chaperones and targeting factors with the nascent polypeptide. Precise coordination of all factors involved is critical for the efficiency and accuracy of protein synthesis and cellular homeostasis. This review provides an overview of the current knowledge on cotranslational protein maturation, with a focus on the production of cytosolic proteins in bacteria. We describe the role of the ribosome and the chaperone network in protein folding and how the dynamic interplay of all cotranslationally acting factors guides the sequence of cotranslational events. Finally, we discuss recent data demonstrating the coupling of protein synthesis with the assembly of protein complexes and end with a brief discussion of outstanding questions and emerging concepts in the field of cotranslational protein maturation.

PRAT Proteins Operate in Organellar Protein Import and Export in Arabidopsis thaliana

Chloroplasts need to import preproteins and amino acids from the cytosol during their light-induced differentiation. Similarly, chloroplasts have to export organic matter including proteins and amino acids during leaf senescence. Members of the PRAT (preprotein and amino acid transporter) family are candidate transporters for both processes. Here, we defined the role of two small PRAT gene families, At4g26670 and At5g55510 (HP20 subfamily) versus At3g49560 and At5g24650 (HP30 subfamily) during greening of etiolated plants and during leaf senescence. Using a combination of reverse genetics, protein biochemistry and physiological tools, evidence was obtained for a role of chloroplast HP20, HP30 and HP30-2 in protein, but not amino acid, import into chloroplasts. HP20, HP30 and HP30-2 form larger complexes involved in the uptake of transit sequence-less cytosolic precursors. In addition, we identified a fraction of HP30-2 in mitochondria where it served a similar function as found for chloroplasts and operated in the uptake of transit sequence-less cytosolic precursor proteins. By contrast, HP22 was found to act in the export of proteins from chloroplasts during leaf senescence, and thus its role is entirely different from that of its orthologue, HP20. HP22 is part of a unique protein complex in the envelope of senescing chloroplasts that comprises at least 11 proteins and contains with HP65b (At5g55220) a protein that is related to the bacterial trigger factor chaperone. An ortholog of HP65b exists in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis and has previously been implicated in protein secretion. Whereas plants depleted of either HP22 or HP65b or even both were increasingly delayed in leaf senescence and retained much longer stromal chloroplast constituents than wild-type plants, HP22 overexpressors showed premature leaf senescence that was associated with accelerated losses of stromal chloroplast proteins. Together, our results identify the PRAT protein family as a unique system for importing and exporting proteins from chloroplasts.

Circuit Topology Analysis of Polymer Folding Reactions

Circuit topology is emerging as a versatile measure to classify the internal structures of folded linear polymers such as proteins and nucleic acids. The topology framework can be applied to a wide range of problems, most notably molecular folding reactions that are central to biology and molecular engineering. In this Outlook, we discuss the state-of-the art of the technology and elaborate on the opportunities and challenges that lie ahead.

The Anti-Aggregation Holdase Hsp33 Promotes the Formation of Folded Protein Structures

Holdase chaperones are known to be central to suppressing aggregation, but how they affect substrate conformations remains poorly understood. Here, we use optical tweezers to study how the holdase Hsp33 alters folding transitions within single maltose binding proteins and aggregation transitions between maltose binding protein substrates. Surprisingly, we find that Hsp33 not only suppresses aggregation but also guides the folding process. Two modes of action underlie these effects. First, Hsp33 binds unfolded chains, which suppresses aggregation between substrates and folding transitions within substrates. Second, Hsp33 binding promotes substrate states in which most of the chain is folded and modifies their structure, possibly by intercalating its intrinsically disordered regions. A statistical ensemble model shows how Hsp33 function results from the competition between these two contrasting effects. Our findings reveal an unexpectedly comprehensive functional repertoire for Hsp33 that may be more prevalent among holdases and dispels the notion of a strict chaperone hierarchy.

Chaperone Interactions at the Ribosome

The continuous refreshment of the proteome is critical to maintain protein homeostasis and to adapt cells to changing conditions. Thus, de novo protein biogenesis by ribosomes is vitally important to every cellular system. This process is delicate and error-prone and requires, besides cytosolic chaperones, the guidance by a specialized set of molecular chaperones that bind transiently to the translation machinery and the nascent protein to support early folding events and to regulate cotranslational protein transport. These chaperones include the bacterial trigger factor (TF), the archaeal and eukaryotic nascent polypeptide-associated complex (NAC), and the eukaryotic ribosome-associated complex (RAC). This review focuses on the structures, functions, and substrates of these ribosome-associated chaperones and highlights the most recent findings about their potential mechanisms of action.

Exploring the roles of substrate-binding surface of the chaperone site in the chaperone activity of trigger factor

Trigger factor (TF) is a key component of the prokaryotic chaperone network, which is involved in many basic cellular processes, such as protein folding, protein trafficking, and ribosome assembly. The major chaperone site of TF has a cradle-like structure in which protein substrate may fold without interference from other proteins. Here, we investigated in vivo and in vitro the roles of hydrophobic and charged patches on the edge and interior of cradle during TF-assisted protein folding. Our results showed that most of the surface of the cradle was involved in TF-assisted protein folding, which was larger than found in early studies. Although the inner surface of cradle was mostly hydrophobic, both hydrophobic and electrostatic patches were indispensable for TF to facilitate correct protein folding. However, hydrophobic patches were more important for the antiaggregation activity of TF. Furthermore, it was found that the patches on the surface of cradle were involved in TF-assisted protein folding in a spatial and temporal order. These results suggest that the folding-favorable interface between the cradle and substrate was dynamic during TF-assisted protein folding, which enabled TF to be involved in the folding of substrate in an aggressive manner rather than acting as a classic holdase.-Fan, D., Cao, S., Zhou, Q., Zhang, Y., Yue, L., Han, C., Yang, B., Wang, Y., Ma, Z., Zhu, L., Liu, C. Exploring the roles of substrate-binding surface of chaperone site in the chaperone activity of trigger factor.

Protein Folding Mediated by Trigger Factor and Hsp70: New Insights from Single-Molecule Approaches

Chaperones assist in protein folding, but what this common phrase means in concrete terms has remained surprisingly poorly understood. We can readily measure chaperone binding to unfolded proteins, but how they bind and affect proteins along folding trajectories has remained obscure. Here we review recent efforts by our labs and others that are beginning to pry into this issue, with a focus on the chaperones trigger factor and Hsp70. Single-molecule methods are central, as they allow the stepwise process of folding to be followed directly. First results have already revealed contrasts with long-standing paradigms: rather than acting only "early" by stabilizing unfolded chain segments, these chaperones can bind and stabilize partially folded structures as they grow to their native state. The findings suggest a fundamental redefinition of the protein folding problem and a more extensive functional repertoire of chaperones than previously assumed.

The chaperone toolbox at the single-molecule level: From clamping to confining

Protein folding is well known to be supervised by a dedicated class of proteins called chaperones. However, the core mode of action of these molecular machines has remained elusive due to several reasons including the promiscuous nature of the interactions between chaperones and their many clients, as well as the dynamics and heterogeneity of chaperone conformations and the folding process itself. While troublesome for traditional bulk techniques, these properties make an excellent case for the use of single-molecule approaches. In this review, we will discuss how force spectroscopy, fluorescence microscopy, FCS, and FRET methods are starting to zoom in on this intriguing and diverse molecular toolbox that is of direct importance for protein quality control in cells, as well as numerous degenerative conditions that depend on it.

Topology of internally constrained polymer chains

An interacting partner can provide external control over folding rates and realized topologies.

Global Analysis of the Impact of Deleting Trigger Factor on the Transcriptome Profile of Escherichia coli

Trigger factor (TF) is a key component of prokaryotic chaperone network, which is involved various basic cellular processes such as nascent peptide folding, protein trafficking, ribosome assembly. To better understanding the physiological roles of TF, global transcriptome profiles of a variety of TF deletion mutant strains of Escherichia coli were determined. We found that deletion of the tig gene, encoding TF, led to a dramatic alteration of transcriptome profile, not only affecting the gene expression of members of the chaperone network, but also changing the levels of quite a few RNAs related to metabolism and other cellular processes. Further studies showed that this alteration was only partially recovered by knockin of TF domain-deletion mutants into the endogenous tig locus, indicating that structural integrity is crucial for the biological function of TF. Finally, by combining the transcriptome and phenotype results, a physiological mechanism underlying the impact of TF deletion on the transcriptome profile was proposed. J. Cell. Biochem. 118: 141-153, 2017. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Trigger factor assisted soluble expression of recombinant spike protein of porcine epidemic diarrhea virus in Escherichia coli

BACKGROUND

Porcine epidemic diarrhea virus (PEDV) is a highly contagious enteric pathogen of swine. The spike glycoprotein (S) of PEDV is the major immunogenic determinant that plays a pivotal role in the induction of neutralizing antibodies against PEDV, which therefore is an ideal target for the development of subunit vaccine. In an attempt to develop a subunit vaccine for PEDV, we cloned two different fragments of S protein and expressed as glutathione S-transferase (GST)-tagged fusion proteins, namely rGST-COE and rGST-S1D, in E.coli. However, the expression of these recombinant protein antigens using a variety of expression vectors, strains, and induction conditions invariably resulted in inclusion bodies. To achieve the soluble expression of recombinant proteins, several chaperone co-expression systems were tested in this study.

RESULTS

We firstly tested various chaperone co-expression systems and found that co-expression of trigger factor (TF) with recombinant proteins at 15 °C was most useful in soluble production of rGST-COE and rGST-S1D compared to GroEL-ES and DnaK-DnaJ-GrpE/GroEL-ES systems. The soluble rGST-COE and rGST-S1D were purified using glutathione Sepharose 4B with a yield of 7.5 mg/l and 5 mg/l, respectively. Purified proteins were detected by western blot using mouse anti-GST mAb and pig anti-PEDV immune sera. In an indirect ELISA, purified proteins showed immune reactivity with pig anti-PEDV immune sera. Finally, immunization of mice with 10 μg of purified proteins elicited highly potent serum IgG and serum neutralizing antibody titers.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, soluble production of recombinant spike protein of PEDV, rGST-COE and rGST-S1D, were achieved by using TF chaperone co-expression system. Our results suggest that soluble rGST-COE and rGST-S1D produced by co-expressing chaperones may have the potential to be used as subunit vaccine antigens.