Molecular Basis and Therapeutic Strategies to Rescue Factor IX Variants That Affect Splicing and Protein Function

Age-dependent regulation of ELP1 exon 20 splicing in Familial Dysautonomia by RNA Polymerase II kinetics and chromatin structure

Familial Dysautonomia (FD) is a rare disease caused by ELP1 exon 20 skipping. Here we clarify the role of RNA Polymerase II (RNAPII) and chromatin on this splicing event. A slow RNAPII mutant and chromatin-modifying chemicals that reduce the rate of RNAPII elongation induce exon skipping whereas chemicals that create a more relaxed chromatin exon inclusion. In the brain of a mouse transgenic for the human FD-ELP1 we observed on this gene an age-dependent decrease in the RNAPII density profile that was most pronounced on the alternative exon, a robust increase in the repressive marks H3K27me3 and H3K9me3 and a decrease of H3K27Ac, together with a progressive reduction in ELP1 exon 20 inclusion level. In HEK 293T cells, selective drug-induced demethylation of H3K27 increased RNAPII elongation on ELP1 and SMN2, promoted the inclusion of the corresponding alternative exons, and, by RNA-sequencing analysis, induced changes in several alternative splicing events. These data suggest a co-transcriptional model of splicing regulation in which age-dependent changes in H3K27me3/Ac modify the rate of RNAPII elongation and affect processing of ELP1 alternative exon 20.

All exons are not created equal-exon vulnerability determines the effect of exonic mutations on splicing

It is now widely accepted that aberrant splicing of constitutive exons is often caused by mutations affecting cis-acting splicing regulatory elements (SREs), but there is a misconception that all exons have an equal dependency on SREs and thus a similar vulnerability to aberrant splicing. We demonstrate that some exons are more likely to be affected by exonic splicing mutations (ESMs) due to an inherent vulnerability, which is context dependent and influenced by the strength of exon definition. We have developed VulExMap, a tool which is based on empirical data that can designate whether a constitutive exon is vulnerable. Using VulExMap, we find that only 25% of all exons can be categorized as vulnerable, whereas two-thirds of 359 previously reported ESMs in 75 disease genes are located in vulnerable exons. Because VulExMap analysis is based on empirical data on splicing of exons in their endogenous context, it includes all features important in determining the vulnerability. We believe that VulExMap will be an important tool when assessing the effect of exonic mutations by pinpointing whether they are located in exons vulnerable to ESMs.

Pleiotropic effects of different exonic nucleotide changes at the same position contribute to hemophilia B phenotypic variation

BACKGROUND

The disease-causing effects of genetic variations often depend on their location within a gene. Exonic changes generally lead to alterations in protein production, secretion, activity, or clearance. However, owing to the overlap between proteins and splicing codes, missense variants can also affect messenger RNA splicing, thus adding a layer of complexity and influencing disease phenotypes.

OBJECTIVES

To extensively characterize a panel of 13 exonic variants in the F9 gene occurring at 6 different factor IX positions and associated with varying severities of hemophilia B (HB).

METHODS

Computational predictions, splicing analysis, and recombinant factor IX assays were exploited to characterize F9 variants.

RESULTS

We demonstrated that 5 (38%) of 13 selected F9 exonic variants have pleiotropic effects. Although bioinformatic approaches accurately classified effects, extensive experimental assays were required to elucidate and deepen the molecular mechanisms underlying the pleiotropic effects. Importantly, their characterization was instrumental in developing tailored RNA therapeutics based on engineered U7 small nuclear RNA to mask cryptic splice sites and compensatory U1 small nuclear RNA to enhance exon definition.

CONCLUSION

Overall, albeit a multitool bioinformatic approach suggested the molecular effects of multiple HB variants, the deep investigation of molecular mechanisms revealed insights into the HB phenotype-genotype relationship, enabling accurate classification of HB variants. Importantly, knowledge of molecular mechanisms allowed the development of tailored RNA therapeutics, which can also be translated to other genetic diseases.

Development of Engineered-U1 snRNA Therapies: Current Status

Splicing of pre-mRNA is a crucial regulatory stage in the pathway of gene expression. The majority of human genes that encode proteins undergo alternative pre-mRNA splicing and mutations that affect splicing are more prevalent than previously thought. Targeting aberrant RNA(s) may thus provide an opportunity to correct faulty splicing and potentially treat numerous genetic disorders. To that purpose, the use of engineered U1 snRNA (either modified U1 snRNAs or exon-specific U1s-ExSpeU1s) has been applied as a potentially therapeutic strategy to correct splicing mutations, particularly those affecting the 5' splice-site (5'ss). Here we review and summarize a vast panoply of studies that used either modified U1 snRNAs or ExSpeU1s to mediate gene therapeutic correction of splicing defects underlying a considerable number of genetic diseases. We also focus on the pre-clinical validation of these therapeutic approaches both in vitro and in vivo, and summarize the main obstacles that need to be overcome to allow for their successful translation to clinic practice in the future.

Rescue of a familial dysautonomia mouse model by AAV9-Exon-specific U1 snRNA

Familial dysautonomia (FD) is a currently untreatable, neurodegenerative disease caused by a splicing mutation (c.2204+6T>C) that causes skipping of exon 20 of the elongator complex protein 1 (ELP1) pre-mRNA. Here, we used adeno-associated virus serotype 9 (AAV9-U1-FD) to deliver an exon-specific U1 (ExSpeU1) small nuclear RNA, designed to cause inclusion of ELP1 exon 20 only in those cells expressing the target pre-mRNA, in a phenotypic mouse model of FD. Postnatal systemic and intracerebral ventricular treatment in these mice increased the inclusion of ELP1 exon 20. This also augmented the production of functional protein in several tissues including brain, dorsal root, and trigeminal ganglia. Crucially, the treatment rescued most of the FD mouse mortality before one month of age (89% vs 52%). There were notable improvements in ataxic gait as well as renal (serum creatinine) and cardiac (ejection fraction) functions. RNA-seq analyses of dorsal root ganglia from treated mice and human cells overexpressing FD-ExSpeU1 revealed only minimal global changes in gene expression and splicing. Overall then, our data prove that AAV9-U1-FD is highly specific and will likely be a safe and effective therapeutic strategy for this debilitating disease.

Effects of 14 F9 synonymous codon variants on hemophilia B expression: Alteration of splicing along with protein expression

There is growing evidence that synonymous codon variants (SCVs) can cause disease through the disruption of different processes of protein production. The aim of the study is to investigate whether the 14 SCVs reported in the F9 variant database were the pathogenic causes of hemophilia B. The impacts of SCVs on splicing and protein expression were detected using a combination of in silico prediction, in vitro minigene splicing assay and cell expression detection. The splicing transcripts were identified and quantified by co-amplification fluorescent PCR. The mechanism of splicing was verified by a modified pU1snRNA and pU7snRNA approach. Aberrant splicing patterns were found in eight SCVs. Five of the 8 SCVs produced almost all aberrant splicing isoforms, which were expected to truncate protein, three of them presented a partial defect on both splicing and protein secretion, the overall effects were consistent with the residual Factor IX activity of the affected cases. Neither the pre-messenger RNA (mRNA) splicing process nor the protein function was impaired in the rest six SCVs. In conclusion, our study firstly revealed the pathogenic mechanism of the 14 F9 SCVs and highlighted the importance of performing mRNA splicing analysis and protein expression studies of SCVs in inherited disorders.

Dissection of pleiotropic effects of variants in and adjacent to F8 exon 19 and rescue of mRNA splicing and protein function

The pathogenic significance of nucleotide variants commonly relies on nucleotide position within the gene, with exonic changes generally attributed to quantitative or qualitative alteration of protein biosynthesis, secretion, activity, or clearance. However, these changes may exert pleiotropic effects on both protein biology and mRNA splicing due to the overlapping of the amino acid and splicing codes, thus shaping the disease phenotypes. Here, we focused on hemophilia A, in which the definition of F8 variants' causative role and association to bleeding phenotypes is crucial for proper classification, genetic counseling, and management of affected individuals. We extensively characterized a large panel of hemophilia A-causing variants (n = 30) within F8 exon 19 by combining and comparing in silico and recombinant expression analyses. We identified exonic variants with pleiotropic effects and dissected the altered protein features of all missense changes. Importantly, results from multiple prediction algorithms provided qualitative results, while recombinant assays allowed us to correctly infer the likely phenotype severity for 90% of variants. Molecular characterization of pathogenic variants was also instrumental for the development of tailored correction approaches to rescue splicing affecting variants or missense changes impairing protein folding. A single engineered U1snRNA rescued mRNA splicing of nine different variants and the use of a chaperone-like drug resulted in improved factor VIII protein secretion for four missense variants. Overall, dissection of the molecular mechanisms of a large panel of HA variants allowed precise classification of HA-affected individuals and favored the development of personalized therapeutic approaches.

Alternative RNA Splicing in Fatty Liver Disease

Alternative RNA splicing is a process by which introns are removed and exons are assembled to construct different RNA transcript isoforms from a single pre-mRNA. Previous studies have demonstrated an association between dysregulation of RNA splicing and a number of clinical syndromes, but the generality to common disease has not been established. Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is the most common liver disease affecting one-third of adults worldwide, increasing the risk of cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). In this review we focus on the change in alternative RNA splicing in fatty liver disease and the role for splicing regulation in disease progression.

Rescue of common exon-skipping mutations in cystic fibrosis with modified U1 snRNAs

In cystic fibrosis (CF), the correction of splicing defects represents an interesting therapeutic approach to restore normal CFTR function. In this study, we focused on 10 common mutations/variants 711+3A>G/C, 711+5G>A, TG13T3, TG13T5, TG12T5, 1863C>T, 1898+3A>G, 2789+5G>A, and 3120G>A that induce skipping of the corresponding CFTR exons 5, 10, 13, 16, and 18. To rescue the splicing defects we tested, in a minigene assay, a panel of modified U1 small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs), named Exon Specific U1s (ExSpeU1s), that was engineered to bind to intronic sequences downstream of each defective exon. Using this approach, we show that all 10 splicing mutations analyzed are efficiently corrected by specific ExSpeU1s. Using complementary DNA-splicing competent minigenes, we also show that the ExspeU1-mediated splicing correction at the RNA level recovered the full-length CFTR protein for 1863C>T, 1898+3A>G, 2789+5G>A variants. In addition, detailed mutagenesis experiments performed on exon 13 led us to identify a novel intronic regulatory element involved in the ExSpeU1-mediated splicing rescue. These results provide a common strategy based on modified U1 snRNAs to correct exon skipping in a group of disease-causing CFTR mutations.

Profiling of cis- and trans-acting factors supporting noncanonical splice site activation

Recently, by combining transcriptomics with functional splicing reporter assays we were able to identify GT > GC > TT as the three highest ranked dinucleotides of human 5' splice sites (5'ss). Here, we have extended our investigations to the proteomic characterization of nuclear proteins that bind to canonical and noncanonical 5'ss. Surprisingly, we found that U1 snRNP binding to functional 5'ss sequences prevented components of the DNA damage response (DDR) from binding to the RNA, suggesting a close link between spliceosome arrangement and genome stability. We demonstrate that all tested noncanonical 5'ss sequences are bona-fide targets of the U2-type spliceosome and are bound by U1 snRNP, including U1-C, in the presence of splicing enhancers. The quantity of precipitated U1-C protein was similar for all noncanonical 5'ss dinucleotides, so that the highly different 5'ss usage was likely due to a later step after early U1 snRNP binding. In addition, we show that an internal GT at positions +5/+6 can be advantageous for splicing at position +1 of noncanonical splice sites. Likewise, and in agreement with previous observations, splicing inactive U1 snRNP binding sites could serve as splicing enhancers, which may also explain the higher abundance of U1 snRNPs compared to other U snRNPs. Finally, we observe that an arginine-serine (RS)-rich domain recruitment to stem loop I of the U1 snRNA is functionally sufficient to promote exon-definition and upstream 3'ss activation.

Innovative Therapeutic and Delivery Approaches Using Nanotechnology to Correct Splicing Defects Underlying Disease

Alternative splicing of pre-mRNA contributes strongly to the diversity of cell- and tissue-specific protein expression patterns. Global transcriptome analyses have suggested that >90% of human multiexon genes are alternatively spliced. Alterations in the splicing process cause missplicing events that lead to genetic diseases and pathologies, including various neurological disorders, cancers, and muscular dystrophies. In recent decades, research has helped to elucidate the mechanisms regulating alternative splicing and, in some cases, to reveal how dysregulation of these mechanisms leads to disease. The resulting knowledge has enabled the design of novel therapeutic strategies for correction of splicing-derived pathologies. In this review, we focus primarily on therapeutic approaches targeting splicing, and we highlight nanotechnology-based gene delivery applications that address the challenges and barriers facing nucleic acid-based therapeutics.

Mechanism underlying the regulation of sortilin expression and its trafficking function

This review summarizes and analyzes the updated information on the regulation of sortilin expression and its trafficking function. Evidence indicates that the expression and function of sortilin are closely regulated at four levels: DNA, messenger RNA (mRNA), protein, and trafficking function. DNA methylation, several mutations, and minor single-nucleotide polymorphisms within DNA fragments affect the expression of SORT1 gene. A few transcription factors and microRNAs modulate its transcription as well as the splicing or stability of the mRNA. Moreover, several translation factors control the synthesis of sortilin protein, and posttranslational modifications affect its degradation processes. Multiple adaptor molecules modulate the sortilin trafficking function in the anterograde or retrograde pathway. Recent advances in the regulation of sortilin expression and function, and its related mechanisms will help the ongoing research related to sortilin and promote future clinical application via sortilin intervention.

Rescue of spinal muscular atrophy mouse models with AAV9-Exon-specific U1 snRNA

Spinal Muscular Atrophy results from loss-of-function mutations in SMN1 but correcting aberrant splicing of SMN2 offers hope of a cure. However, current splice therapy requires repeated infusions and is expensive. We previously rescued SMA mice by promoting the inclusion of a defective exon in SMN2 with germline expression of Exon-Specific U1 snRNAs (ExspeU1). Here we tested viral delivery of SMN2 ExspeU1s encoded by adeno-associated virus AAV9. Strikingly the virus increased SMN2 exon 7 inclusion and SMN protein levels and rescued the phenotype of mild and severe SMA mice. In the severe mouse, the treatment improved the neuromuscular function and increased the life span from 10 to 219 days. ExspeU1 expression persisted for 1 month and was effective at around one five-hundredth of the concentration of the endogenous U1snRNA. RNA-seq analysis revealed our potential drug rescues aberrant SMA expression and splicing profiles, which are mostly related to DNA damage, cell-cycle control and acute phase response. Vastly overexpressing ExspeU1 more than 100-fold above the therapeutic level in human cells did not significantly alter global gene expression or splicing. These results indicate that AAV-mediated delivery of a modified U1snRNP particle may be a novel therapeutic option against SMA.

An Altered Splicing Registry Explains the Differential ExSpeU1-Mediated Rescue of Splicing Mutations Causing Haemophilia A

The exon recognition and removal of introns (splicing) from pre-mRNA is a crucial step in the gene expression flow. The process is very complex and therefore susceptible to derangements. Not surprisingly, a significant and still underestimated proportion of disease-causing mutations affects splicing, with those occurring at the 5’ splice site (5’ss) being the most severe ones. This led to the development of a correction approach based on variants of the spliceosomal U1snRNA, which has been proven on splicing mutations in several cellular and mouse models of human disease. Since the alternative splicing mechanisms are strictly related to the sequence context of the exon, we challenged the U1snRNA-mediated strategy in the singular model of the exon 5 of coagulation factor (F)VIII gene (F8) in which the authentic 5’ss is surrounded by various cryptic 5’ss. This scenario is further complicated in the presence of nucleotide changes associated with FVIII deficiency (Haemophilia A), which weaken the authentic 5’ss and create/strengthen cryptic 5’ss. We focused on the splicing mutations (c.602-32A > G, c.602-10T > G, c.602G > A, c.655G > A, c.667G > A, c.669A > G, c.669A > T, c.670G > T, c.670+1G > T, c.670+1G > A, c.670+2T > G, c.670+5G > A, and c.670+6T > C) found in patients with severe to mild Haemophilia A. Minigenes expression studies demonstrated that all mutations occurring within the 5’ss, both intronic or exonic, lead to aberrant transcripts arising from the usage of two cryptic intronic 5’ss at positions c.670+64 and c.670+176. For most of them, the observed proportion of correct transcripts is in accordance with the coagulation phenotype of patients. In co-transfection experiments, we identified a U1snRNA variant targeting an intronic region downstream of the defective exon (Exon Specific U1snRNA, U1sh7) capable to re-direct usage of the proper 5’ss (∼80%) for several mutations. However, deep investigation of rescued transcripts from +1 and +2 variants revealed only the usage of adjacent cryptic 5’ss, leading to frameshifted transcript forms. These data demonstrate that a single ExSpeU1 can efficiently rescue different mutations in the F8 exon 5, and provide the first evidence of the applicability of the U1snRNA-based approach to Haemophilia A.

RNA Therapeutics: How Far Have We Gone?

In recent years, the RNA molecule became one of the most promising targets for therapeutic intervention. Currently, a large number of RNA-based therapeutics are being investigated both at the basic research level and in late-stage clinical trials. Some of them are even already approved for treatment. RNA-based approaches can act at pre-mRNA level (by splicing modulation/correction using antisense oligonucleotides or U1snRNA vectors), at mRNA level (inhibiting gene expression by siRNAs and antisense oligonucleotides) or at DNA level (by editing mutated sequences through the use of CRISPR/Cas). Other RNA approaches include the delivery of in vitro transcribed (IVT) mRNA or the use of oligonucleotides aptamers. Here we review these approaches and their translation into clinics trying to give a brief overview also on the difficulties to its application as well as the research that is being done to overcome them.

Splicing Mutations Impairing CDKL5 Expression and Activity Can be Efficiently Rescued by U1snRNA-Based Therapy

Mutations in the CDKL5 gene lead to an incurable rare neurological condition characterized by the onset of seizures in the first weeks of life and severe intellectual disability. Replacement gene or protein therapies could represent intriguing options, however, their application may be inhibited by the recent demonstration that CDKL5 is dosage sensitive. Conversely, correction approaches acting on pre-mRNA splicing would preserve CDKL5 physiological regulation. Since ~15% of CDKL5 pathogenic mutations are candidates to affect splicing, we evaluated the capability of variants of the spliceosomal U1 small nuclear RNA (U1snRNA) to correct mutations affecting +1 and +5 nucleotides at the 5′ donor splice site and predicted to cause exon skipping. Our results show that CDKL5 minigene variants expressed in mammalian cells are a valid approach to assess CDKL5 splicing pattern. The expression of engineered U1snRNA effectively rescued mutations at +5 but not at the +1 nucleotides. Importantly, we proved that U1snRNA-mediated splicing correction fully restores CDKL5 protein synthesis, subcellular distribution and kinase activity. Eventually, by correcting aberrant splicing of an exogenously expressed splicing-competent CDKL5 transgene, we provided insights on the morphological rescue of CDKL5 null neurons, reporting the first proof-of-concept of the therapeutic value of U1snRNA-mediated CDKL5 splicing correction.

Splicing dysregulation contributes to the pathogenicity of several F9 exonic point variants

BACKGROUND

Pre-mRNA splicing is a complex process requiring the identification of donor site, acceptor site, and branch point site with an adjacent polypyrimidine tract sequence. Splicing is regulated by splicing regulatory elements (SREs) with both enhancer and suppressor functions. Variants located in exonic regions can impact splicing through dysregulation of native splice sites, SREs, and cryptic splice site activation. While splicing dysregulation is considered primary disease-inducing mechanism of synonymous variants, its contribution toward disease phenotype of non-synonymous variants is underappreciated.

METHODS

In this study, we analyzed 415 disease-causing and 120 neutral F9 exonic point variants including both synonymous and non-synonymous for their effect on splicing using a series of in silico splice site prediction tools, SRE prediction tools, and in vitro minigene assays.

RESULTS

The use of splice site and SRE prediction tools in tandem provided better prediction but were not always in agreement with the minigene assays. The net effect of splicing dysregulation caused by variants was context dependent. Minigene assays revealed that perturbed splicing can be found.

CONCLUSION

Synonymous variants primarily cause disease phenotype via splicing dysregulation while additional mechanisms such as translation rate also play an important role. Splicing dysregulation is likely to contribute to the disease phenotype of several non-synonymous variants.

Molecular Mechanisms and Determinants of Innovative Correction Approaches in Coagulation Factor Deficiencies

Molecular strategies tailored to promote/correct the expression and/or processing of defective coagulation factors would represent innovative therapeutic approaches beyond standard substitutive therapy. Here, we focus on the molecular mechanisms and determinants underlying innovative approaches acting at DNA, mRNA and protein levels in inherited coagulation factor deficiencies, and in particular on: (i) gene editing approaches, which have permitted intervention at the DNA level through the specific recognition, cleavage, repair/correction or activation of target sequences, even in mutated gene contexts; (ii) the rescue of altered pre-mRNA processing through the engineering of key spliceosome components able to promote correct exon recognition and, in turn, the synthesis and secretion of functional factors, as well as the effects on the splicing of missense changes affecting exonic splicing elements; this section includes antisense oligonucleotide- or siRNA-mediated approaches to down-regulate target genes; (iii) the rescue of protein synthesis/function through the induction of ribosome readthrough targeting nonsense variants or the correction of folding defects caused by amino acid substitutions. Overall, these approaches have shown the ability to rescue the expression and/or function of potentially therapeutic levels of coagulation factors in different disease models, thus supporting further studies in the future aimed at evaluating the clinical translatability of these new strategies.

A series of 10 Polish patients with thromboembolic events and antithrombin deficiency: two new c.1154-1 G>C and c.1219-534 A>G SERPINC1 gene splicing mutations

: Inherited antithrombin (AT) deficiency, with prevalence in the general population ranging 0.02-0.17%, is an autosomal dominant disorder associated with a high risk of venous thromboembolism. In most cases, deficiency is caused by mutations in the AT-coding gene (SERPINC1). Only 24 splicing defects have been described causing AT deficiency, all affecting exon flanking regions. The aim of the current study was to characterize the mutations underlying AT deficiency in 10 venous thromboembolism Polish patients aged 42.9 (14-63) years. Whole SERPINC1 gene sequencing was done by next generation sequencing methods. Eight cases had mutations previously described. However, we identified two new intronic mutations that might affect the correct splicing of exon 6 according to in-silico predictions: c.1154-1 G>C, which strongly disturbs the acceptor sequence and c.1219-534 A>G, a deep intronic mutation that might generate a cryptic donor sequence; both might compete with the wild-type donor sequence and explain the associated moderate AT deficiency of carriers. In conclusion, we show the molecular base of AT deficiency in 10 new Polish patients, including two novel SERPINC1 gene mutations potentially affecting splicing.

Therapeutic approaches to treat human spliceosomal diseases

Mutated RNA splicing machinery drives many human diseases and is a promising therapeutic target for engineering and small molecule therapy. In the case of mutations in individual genes that cause them to be incorrectly spliced, engineered splicing factors can be introduced to correct splicing of these aberrant transcripts and reduce the effects of the disease phenotype. Mutations that occur in certain splicing factor genes themselves have been implicated in many cancers, particularly myelodysplastic syndromes. Small molecules that target splicing factors have been developed as therapies to preferentially induce apoptosis in these cancer cells. Specifically, drugs targeting the splicing factor SF3B1 have led to recent clinical trials. Here, we review the role of alternative splicing in disease, approaches to rescue incorrect splicing using engineered splicing factors, and small molecule splicing inhibitors developed to treat hematological cancers.

Disease-causing variants of the conserved +2T of 5' splice sites can be rescued by engineered U1snRNAs

The ability of variants of the spliceosomal U1snRNA to rescue splicing has been proven in several human disease models, but not for nucleotide changes at the conserved GT nucleotide of 5' splice sites (5'ss), frequent and associated with severe phenotypes. Here, we focused on variants at the 5'ss of F9 intron 3, leading to factor IX (FIX) deficiency (hemophilia B). Through minigene expression, we demonstrated that all changes induce complete exon 3 skipping, which explains the associated hemophilia B phenotype. Interestingly, engineered U1snRNAs remarkably increased the proportion of correct transcripts in the presence of the c.277+4A>G (∼60%) and also c.277+2T>C mutation (∼20%). Expression of splicing-competent cDNA constructs indicated that the splicing rescue produces an appreciable increase of secreted FIX protein levels. These data provide the first experimental evidence that even part of variants at the conserved 5'ss +2T nucleotide can be rescued, thus expanding the applicability of this U1snRNA-based approach.

Program and Book of the 15th Interuniversity Institute of Myology Meeting - Assisi (Italy), 2018

Not available.

Exon-specific U1 snRNAs improve ELP1 exon 20 definition and rescue ELP1 protein expression in a familial dysautonomia mouse model

Familial dysautonomia (FD) is a rare genetic disease with no treatment, caused by an intronic point mutation (c.2204+6T>C) that negatively affects the definition of exon 20 in the elongator complex protein 1 gene (ELP1 also known as IKBKAP). This substitution modifies the 5' splice site and, in combination with regulatory splicing factors, induces different levels of exon 20 skipping, in various tissues. Here, we evaluated the therapeutic potential of a novel class of U1 snRNA molecules, exon-specific U1s (ExSpeU1s), in correcting ELP1 exon 20 recognition. Lentivirus-mediated expression of ELP1-ExSpeU1 in FD fibroblasts improved ELP1 splicing and protein levels. We next focused on a transgenic mouse model that recapitulates the same tissue-specific mis-splicing seen in FD patients. Intraperitoneal delivery of ELP1-ExSpeU1s-adeno-associated virus particles successfully increased the production of full-length human ELP1 transcript and protein. This splice-switching class of molecules is the first to specifically correct the ELP1 exon 20 splicing defect. Our data provide proof of principle of ExSpeU1s-adeno-associated virus particles as a novel therapeutic strategy for FD.

Intronic PAH gene mutations cause a splicing defect by a novel mechanism involving U1snRNP binding downstream of the 5' splice site

Phenylketonuria (PKU), one of the most common inherited diseases of amino acid metabolism, is caused by mutations in the phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH) gene. Recently, PAH exon 11 was identified as a vulnerable exon due to a weak 3’ splice site, with different exonic mutations affecting exon 11 splicing through disruption of exonic splicing regulatory elements. In this study, we report a novel intron 11 regulatory element, which is involved in exon 11 splicing, as revealed by the investigated pathogenic effect of variants c.1199+17G>A and c.1199+20G>C, identified in PKU patients. Both mutations cause exon 11 skipping in a minigene system. RNA binding assays indicate that binding of U1snRNP70 to this intronic region is disrupted, concomitant with a slightly increased binding of inhibitors hnRNPA1/2. We have investigated the effect of deletions and point mutations, as well as overexpression of adapted U1snRNA to show that this splicing regulatory motif is important for regulation of correct splicing at the natural 5’ splice site. The results indicate that U1snRNP binding downstream of the natural 5’ splice site determines efficient exon 11 splicing, thus providing a basis for development of therapeutic strategies to correct PAH exon 11 splicing mutations. In this work, we expand the functional effects of non-canonical intronic U1 snRNP binding by showing that it may enhance exon definition and that, consequently, intronic mutations may cause exon skipping by a novel mechanism, where they disrupt stimulatory U1 snRNP binding close to the 5’ splice site. Notably, our results provide further understanding of the reported therapeutic effect of exon specific U1 snRNA for splicing mutations in disease.

Splicing defects constitute a major cause of human disease. Mutations affecting conserved splicing sequences at exon-intron junctions are easily recognized as possibly pathogenic, whereas variants in exonic or intronic regions are difficult to classify without functional evidence provided by transcript analysis or in vitro analysis using minigenes. In this work, we sought out to study the pathogenicity of two novel intronic PAH variants identified in phenylketonuria patients. Both mutations resulted in exon skipping in minigenes. We demonstrate that U1snRNP70 binds to the intronic region and that this binding is abolished in the mutant sequences. Correction of the splicing defect was achieved using modified U1 snRNA perfectly complementary to each of the mutant sequences. The results extend the repertoire of natural U1 snRNP cellular functions by including its role as splicing enhancer via binding downstream of the natural 5’ splice site. In addition, our results correlate with the described therapeutic effect of modified U1snRNP for splicing mutations in different genes, thus having a significant impact in the development of specific therapies for splicing defects.

The somatic FAH C.1061C>A change counteracts the frequent FAH c.1062+5G>A mutation and permits U1snRNA-based splicing correction

In tyrosinaemia type 1(HT1), a mosaic pattern of fumarylacetoacetase (FAH) immunopositive or immunonegative nodules in liver tissue has been reported in many patients. This aspect is generally explained by a spontaneous reversion of the mutation into a normal genotype. In one HT1 patient carrying the frequent FAH c.1062+5G>A mutation, a second somatic change (c.1061C>A) has been reported in the same allele, and found in immunopositive nodules. Here, we demonstrated that the c.1062+5G>A prevents usage of the exon 12 5’ splice site (ss), even when forced by an engineered U1snRNA specifically designed on the FAH 5’ss to strengthen its recognition. Noticeably the new somatic c.1061C>A change, in linkage with the c.1062+5G>A mutation, partially rescues the defective 5’ss and is associated to trace level (~5%) of correct transcripts. Interestingly, this combined genetic condition strongly favored the rescue by the engineered U1snRNA, with correct transcripts reaching up to 60%.

Altogether these findings elucidate the molecular basis of HT1 caused by the frequent FAH c.1062+5G>A mutation, and demonstrate the compensatory effect of the c.1061C>A change in promoting exon definition, thus unraveling a rare mechanism leading to FAH immune-reactive mosaicism.

Clustered F8 missense mutations cause hemophilia A by combined alteration of splicing and protein biosynthesis and activity

Dissection of pleiotropic effects of missense mutations, rarely investigated in inherited diseases, is fundamental to understanding genotype-phenotype relationships. Missense mutations might impair mRNA processing in addition to protein properties. As a model for hemophilia A, we investigated the highly prevalent F8 c.6046c>t/p.R2016W (exon 19) mutation. In expression studies exploiting lentiviral vectors, we demonstrated that the amino acid change impairs both Factor VIII (FVIII) secretion (antigen 11.0±0.4% of wild-type) and activity (6.0±2.9%). Investigations in patients' ectopic F8 mRNA and with minigenes showed that the corresponding nucleotide change also decreases correct splicing to 70±5%, which is predicted to lower further FVIII activity (4.2±2%), consistently with patients' levels (<1-5%). Masking the mutated exon 19 region by antisense U7snRNA supported the presence of a splicing regulatory element, potentially affected by several missense mutations causing hemophilia A. Among these, the c.6037g>a (p.G2013R) reduced exon inclusion to 41±3% and the c.6053a>g (p.E2018G) to 28±2%, similarly to a variant affecting the 5' splice site (c.6113a>g, p.N2038S, 26±2%), which displayed normal protein features upon recombinant expression. The p.G2013R reduced both antigen (7.0±0.9%) and activity (8.4±0.8%), while the p.E2018G produced a dysfunctional molecule (antigen: 69.0±18.1%; activity: 19.4±2.3%). In conclusion, differentially altered mRNA and protein patterns produce a gradient of residual activity, and clarify genotype-phenotype relationships. Data detail pathogenic mechanisms that, only in combination, account for moderate/severe disease forms, which in turn determine the mutation profile. Taken together we provide a clear example of interplay between mRNA and protein mechanisms of disease that operate in shaping many other inherited disorders.

Defects of splicing in antithrombin deficiency

BACKGROUND

There is increasing evidence supporting the relevance of aberrant splicing in multiple disorders. In antithrombin deficiency only 22 intronic mutations affecting splicing sites (7% of SERPINC1 mutations) are considered as splicing mutations.

METHODS

SERPINC1 was analyzed by Sanger sequencing and MLPA in 141 unrelated cases with antithrombin deficiency. Plasma antithrombin was studied by functional and western blot assays, purified by FPLC and characterized by proteomic analysis. In silico predictions on splicing was done with the Human Splicing Finder software.

RESULTS

We detected 89 different SERPINC1 defects, 13 with potential effect on splicing. Ten cases presented 9 mutations disturbing splicing sites, 5 new. Three gross or small gene defects also disturbed a correct splicing. Interestingly, the first duplication of a single exon ever described (c.1154-13_1218+115dup), caused mild deficiency (75%). A deeper intronic mutation (c.1154-14G>A), identified in three unrelated patients with traces of disulphide dimers of antithrombin in plasma, created a cryptic splicing site that might generate a variant with 4 additional in frame residues according to in silico predictions. This aberrant splicing was confirmed by proteomic analysis of the dimer purified from plasma.

CONCLUSIONS

A high proportion of cases with antithrombin deficiency (up to 13%) may be explained by an aberrant splicing. Up to 15% of mutations in SERPINC1: splicing site variations, gross gene defects and deep intronic mutations, may affect a correct splicing with three potential consequences type I, type II, and even moderate antithrombin deficiency.

Both Maintenance and Avoidance of RNA-Binding Protein Interactions Constrain Coding Sequence Evolution

While the principal force directing coding sequence (CDS) evolution is selection on protein function, to ensure correct gene expression CDSs must also maintain interactions with RNA-binding proteins (RBPs). Understanding how our genes are shaped by these RNA-level pressures is necessary for diagnostics and for improving transgenes. However, the evolutionary impact of the need to maintain RBP interactions remains unresolved. Are coding sequences constrained by the need to specify RBP binding motifs? If so, what proportion of mutations are affected? Might sequence evolution also be constrained by the need not to specify motifs that might attract unwanted binding, for instance because it would interfere with exon definition? Here, we have scanned human CDSs for motifs that have been experimentally determined to be recognized by RBPs. We observe two sets of motifs-those that are enriched over nucleotide-controlled null and those that are depleted. Importantly, the depleted set is enriched for motifs recognized by non-CDS binding RBPs. Supporting the functional relevance of our observations, we find that motifs that are more enriched are also slower-evolving. The net effect of this selection to preserve is a reduction in the over-all rate of synonymous evolution of 2-3% in both primates and rodents. Stronger motif depletion, on the other hand, is associated with stronger selection against motif gain in evolution. The challenge faced by our CDSs is therefore not only one of attracting the right RBPs but also of avoiding the wrong ones, all while also evolving under selection pressures related to protein structure.

Gene therapy with modified U1 small nuclear RNA

More than 15% of all disease-causing mutations result in mRNA splicing defects. U1 snRNA binds to the 5' splice site (5'ss) through base pairing. Mutation-adapted U1 snRNA (with compensatory U1 snRNA changes) and exon-specific U1 snRNA (complementary to intronic sequences) have been shown to suppress 5'ss mutations in cellular and animal models. Areas covered: The history, mechanism of action, and efficacy of U1 snRNA-mediated gene therapy are covered. The clinical utility of this technology and its limitations will be discussed. Expert commentary: Recently, gene therapies with mutation-adapted U1 snRNAs have been conducted on animal models, including aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase deficiency and spinal muscular atrophy. However, although U1-mediated therapy has the advantage of maintaining the regulated expression of defective genes, its accuracy and efficacy needs to be improved before clinical application of this technique is possible.

Estimating the prevalence of functional exonic splice regulatory information

In addition to coding information, human exons contain sequences necessary for correct splicing. These elements are known to be under purifying selection and their disruption can cause disease. However, the density of functional exonic splicing information remains profoundly uncertain. Several groups have experimentally investigated how mutations at different exonic positions affect splicing. They have found splice information to be distributed widely in exons, with one estimate putting the proportion of splicing-relevant nucleotides at >90%. These results suggest that splicing could place a major pressure on exon evolution. However, analyses of sequence conservation have concluded that the need to preserve splice regulatory signals only slightly constrains exon evolution, with a resulting decrease in the average human rate of synonymous evolution of only 1–4%. Why do these two lines of research come to such different conclusions? Among other reasons, we suggest that the methods are measuring different things: one assays the density of sites that affect splicing, the other the density of sites whose effects on splicing are visible to selection. In addition, the experimental methods typically consider short exons, thereby enriching for nucleotides close to the splice junction, such sites being enriched for splice-control elements. By contrast, in part owing to correction for nucleotide composition biases and to the assumption that constraint only operates on exon ends, the conservation-based methods can be overly conservative.

Transposon-mediated Generation of Cellular and Mouse Models of Splicing Mutations to Assess the Efficacy of snRNA-based Therapeutics

Disease-causing splicing mutations can be rescued by variants of the U1 small nuclear RNA (U1snRNAs). However, the evaluation of the efficacy and safety of modified U1snRNAs as therapeutic tools is limited by the availability of cellular and animal models specific for a given mutation. Hence, we exploited the hyperactive Sleeping Beauty transposon system (SB100X) to integrate human factor IX (hFIX) minigenes into genomic DNA in vitro and in vivo. We generated stable HEK293 cell lines and C57BL/6 mice harboring splicing-competent hFIX minigenes either wild type (SChFIX-wt) or mutated (SChFIXex5-2C). In both models the SChFIXex5-2C variant, found in patients affected by Hemophilia B, displayed an aberrant splicing pattern characterized by exon 5 skipping. This allowed us to test, for the first time in a genomic DNA context, the efficacy of the snRNA U1-fix9, delivered with an adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector. With this approach, we showed rescue of the correct splicing pattern of hFIX mRNA, leading to hFIX protein expression. These data validate the SB100X as a versatile tool to quickly generate models of human genetic mutations, to study their effect in a stable DNA context and to assess mutation-targeted therapeutic strategies.

An Exon-Specific U1snRNA Induces a Robust Factor IX Activity in Mice Expressing Multiple Human FIX Splicing Mutants

In cellular models we have demonstrated that a unique U1snRNA targeting an intronic region downstream of a defective exon (Exon-specific U1snRNA, ExSpeU1) can rescue multiple exon-skipping mutations, a relevant cause of genetic disease. Here, we explored in mice the ExSpeU1 U1fix9 toward two model Hemophilia B-causing mutations at the 5′ (c.519A > G) or 3′ (c.392-8T > G) splice sites of F9 exon 5. Hydrodynamic injection of wt-BALB/C mice with plasmids expressing the wt and mutant (hFIX-2G^5′ss and hFIX-8G^3′ss) splicing-competent human factor IX (hFIX) cassettes resulted in the expression of hFIX transcripts lacking exon 5 in liver, and in low plasma levels of inactive hFIX. Coinjection of U1fix9, but not of U1wt, restored exon inclusion of variants and in the intrinsically weak FIXwt context. This resulted in appreciable circulating hFIX levels (mean ± SD; hFIX-2G5′ss, 1.0 ± 0.5 µg/ml; hFIX-8G3′ss, 1.2 ± 0.3 µg/ml; and hFIXwt, 1.9 ± 0.6 µg/ml), leading to a striking shortening (from ~100 seconds of untreated mice to ~80 seconds) of FIX-dependent coagulation times, indicating a hFIX with normal specific activity. This is the first proof-of-concept in vivo that a unique ExSpeU1 can efficiently rescue gene expression impaired by distinct exon-skipping variants, which extends the applicability of ExSpeU1s to panels of mutations and thus cohort of patients.