Large Residual Volume, Not Low Packing Density, Is the Most Influential Risk Factor for Recanalization after Coil Embolization of Cerebral Aneurysms

Coil embolization of the middle cerebral artery bifurcation aneurysms: Feasibility and durability

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the feasibility and durability of coil embolization for MCAB aneurysms by analyzing clinical and radiological results.

METHODS

From January of 2008 to June of 2018, we treated a total of 1785 aneurysms using coil embolization. The aneurysms were treated by both coiling and stent-assisted coiling. Among these cases, 223 MCAB aneurysms were analyzed retrospectively. Clinical and radiological assessments were conducted at admission, after treatment, at discharge, and at last clinical follow-up.

RESULTS

Coil embolization was performed on 223 MCAB aneurysms in 217 patients. Peri-procedural ischemic, hemorrhagic, and other complications within 30 days after coil embolization occurred at rates of 8.0 %, 8.0 %, and 2.0 %, respectively, in the ruptured group and at 2.9 %, 1.2 %, and 0 %, respectively, in the unruptured group. The overall morbidity and mortality rates associated with complications were 2.3 % and 2.0 %. The cumulative major recurrence rates were 5.1 % at 12 months, 7.1 % at 18 months, and 11.9 % at three years after coil embolization. The mean follow-up period was 33.27 ± 25.48 months. Independent risk factors for major recurrence after coil embolization for MCAB aneurysms were a ruptured aneurysm, initial incomplete occlusion, the aneurysm size, and the neck size.

CONCLUSION

Coil embolization is a good alternative treatment option for MCAB aneurysms compared to surgical clipping. Considering the risk factors for major recurrence, the follow-up angiography should continue up to three years after coil embolization.

Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Endovascular Therapy Effectiveness for Unruptured Saccular Intracranial Aneurysms

Background

Currently, endovascular treatment of intracranial aneurysms (ICAs) is limited by low complete occlusion rates. The advent of novel endovascular technology has expanded the applicability of endovascular therapy; however, the superiority of novel embolic devices over the traditional Guglielmi detachable coils (GDCs) is still debated. We performed a systematic review of literature that reported Raymond-Roy occlusion classification (RROC) rates of modern endovascular devices to determine their immediate and follow-up occlusion effectiveness for the treatment of unruptured saccular ICAs.

Methods

A search was conducted using electronic databases (PUBMED, Cochrane, ClinicalTrials.gov, Web of Science). We retrieved studies published between 2000-2022 reporting immediate and follow-up RROC rates of subjects treated with different endovascular ICA therapies. We extracted demographic information of the treated patients and their reported angiographic RROC rates.

Results

A total of 80 studies from 15 countries were included for data extraction. RROC rates determined from angiogram were obtained for 21,331 patients (72.5% females, pooled mean age: 58.2 (95% CI: 56.8-59.6), harboring 22,791 aneurysms. The most frequent aneurysm locations were the internal carotid artery (46.4%, 95% CI: 41.9%-50.9%), the anterior communicating artery (26.4%, 95% CI: 22.5%-30.8%), the middle cerebral artery (24.5%, 95% CI:19.2%-30.8%) and the basilar tip (14.4%, 95% CI:11.3%-18.3%). The complete occlusion probability (RROC-I) was analyzed for GDCs, the Woven EndoBridge (WEB), and flow diverters. The RROC-I rate was the highest in balloon-assisted coiling (73.9%, 95% CI: 65.0%-81.2%) and the lowest in the WEB (27.8%, 95% CI:13.2%-49.2%). The follow-up RROC-I probability was homogenous in all analyzed devices.

Conclusions

We observed that the coil-based endovascular therapy provides acceptable rates of complete occlusion, and these rates are improved in balloon-assisted coils. Out of the analyzed devices, the WEB exhibited the shortest time to achieve >90% probability of follow-up complete occlusion (~18 months). Overall, the GDCs remain the gold standard for endovascular treatment of unruptured saccular aneurysms.

Preshaped 4D Photocurable Ultratough Organogel Microcoils for Personalized Endovascular Embolization

Endovascular embolization using microcoils can be an effective technique to treat artery aneurysms. However, microcoils with fixed designs are difficult to adapt to all aneurysm types. In this paper, a photocurable ultratough shape memory organogel with a curing time of only 2 s and megapascal-level mechanical properties is proposed. Then, it is used to manufacture the personalized 4D microcoil with a wire diameter of only 0.3 mm. The improved mechanical modulus (511.63 MPa) can reduce the possibility of microcoils' fracture during embolization. Besides, the fast body-temperature-triggering shape memory ability makes the 4D microcoil applicable in vivo. These 4D microcoils are finally delivered into the rabbit, and successfully blocked the blood flow inside different aneurysms, with neoendothelial cells and collagen fibers growing on the microcoil surface snugly, indicating full aneurysm recovery. This 4D organogel microcoil can potentially be used in personalized clinical translation on human beings.

Packing density and the angiographic results of coil embolization of intracranial aneurysms: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Endovascular coil embolization (ECE) for intracranial aneurysms has been proven as an effective minimally invasive treatment. However, the aneurysm recanalization after coiling is a serious complication of this technique. Among all the proposed factors associated with recanalization, the impact of packing density (PD) is still controversial.

OBJECTIVE

To clarify the role of PD in the aneurysm recanalization following ECE, via conducting a systematic review and meta-analysis.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was conducted using PubMed, Scopus, Embase, and Web of Science databases, until November 28, 2022, by adhering to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analyses statement guidelines. Considering the eligibility criteria, all the studies reporting the outcomes of interest were included. Data elements of interest were extracted and analyzed using R software version 4.2.1.

RESULTS

The pooled analysis of the 17 eligible papers revealed a 29% higher PD of the nonrecanalized aneurysms (ROM = 1.29, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.18-1.40, p < 0.001), even after removing outlier studies to reduce heterogeneity. However, the pooled estimates from multivariable regression models within nine included studies showed no significant effect of PD on recanalization odds when incorporated into a multivariable model with other predictors (odds ratio [OR] = 0.93, 95% CI = 0.84-1.02, p = 0.126), even after removing outlier studies.

CONCLUSION

The current literature does not support PD as a significant predictor of aneurysm treatment outcomes, especially with adjusting for other variables. This finding necessitates further prospective multicenter studies with a larger sample size to overcome the current methodological shortcomings.

Radiological follow-up of endovascularly treated intracranial aneurysms: a survey of current practice in the UK and Ireland

PURPOSE

Due to the risk of intracranial aneurysm (IA) recurrence and the potential requirement for re-treatment following endovascular treatment (EVT), radiological follow-up of these aneurysms is necessary. There is little evidence to guide the duration and frequency of this follow-up. The aim of this study was to establish the current practice in neurosurgical units in the UK and Ireland.

METHODS

A survey was designed with input from interventional neuroradiologists and neurosurgeons. Neurovascular consultants in each of the 30 neurosurgical units providing a neurovascular service in the UK and Ireland were contacted and asked to respond to questions regarding the follow-up practice for IA treated with EVT in their department.

RESULTS

Responses were obtained from 28/30 (94%) of departments. There was evidence of wide variations in the duration and frequency of follow-up, with a minimum follow-up duration for ruptured IA that varied from 18 months in 5/28 (18%) units to 5 years in 11/28 (39%) of units. Young patient age, previous subarachnoid haemorrhage and incomplete IA occlusion were cited as factors that would prompt more intensive surveillance, although larger and broad-necked IA were not followed-up more closely in the majority of departments.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a wide variation in the radiological follow-up of IA treated with EVT in the UK and Ireland. Further standardisation of this aspect of patient care is likely to be beneficial, but further evidence on the behaviour of IA following EVT is required in order to inform this process.

Shape Memory Polymer-Based Endovascular Devices: Design Criteria and Future Perspective

Devices for the endovascular embolization of intracranial aneurysms (ICAs) face limitations related to suboptimal rates of lasting complete occlusion. Incomplete occlusion frequently leads to residual flow within the aneurysm sac, which subsequently causes aneurysm recurrence needing surgical re-operation. An emerging method for improving the rates of complete occlusion both immediately after implant and in the longer run can be the fabrication of patient-specific materials for ICA embolization. Shape memory polymers (SMPs) are materials with great potential for this application, owing to their versatile and tunable shape memory properties that can be tailored to a patient’s aneurysm geometry and flow condition. In this review, we first present the state-of-the-art endovascular devices and their limitations in providing long-term complete occlusion. Then, we present methods for the fabrication of SMPs, the most prominent actuation methods for their shape recovery, and the potential of SMPs as endovascular devices for ICA embolization. Although SMPs are a promising alternative for the patient-specific treatment of ICAs, there are still limitations that need to be addressed for their application as an effective coil-free endovascular therapy.

EFFECTS OF THE ANEURYSM TREATMENT METHOD ON COIL PACKING DENSITY AND ITS RELATIONSHIP WITH THE OSTIUM AREA

PURPOSE

To test the following hypotheses: (1) balloon or stent assistance increases coil packing density (CPD) in the endovascular treatment of intracranial aneurysms and (2) CPD is related to the ostium area and volume of the aneurysm.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This retrospective study included 60 ruptured and unruptured (54 and 6, respectively) aneurysms treated between August 2017 and December 2019 in the authors' institution with simple coiling (n=18), balloon-assisted coiling (n=7), or stent-assisted coiling (n=35). Aneurysm volume and ostium area measurements were obtained using commercial software from three-dimensional digital subtraction angiography images. Coil sizes were retrieved from patient files, and coil volume measurements were obtained using https://www.angiocalc.com/. Analysis of covariance, multivariable covariance analysis, and Pearson's correlation analyses were performed.

RESULTS

The median values for the aneurysm volume, coil volume, CPD, and ostium area were 63.4 (range 5.5-1771.4) mm³, 23.13 (2.03-296.95) mm³, 33.29% (13.41%-81.02%), and 10.7 (2.7-49.9) mm², respectively. Multivariate analysis showed that the CPD values were not significantly different among the treatment groups, although the ostium area differed significantly between the simple and stent-assisted coiling groups (P<.05). Pearson's correlations showed that similar to aneurysm volume, the ostium area was negatively correlated with CPD (r=-0.321, P<.05).

CONCLUSION

In cerebral aneurysms treated with balloon- or stent-assisted coiling, the CPD value does not differ from that in aneurysms treated with simple coiling.

Risk factors for recanalization of dense coil packing for unruptured cerebral aneurysms in endovascular coil embolization: Analysis of a single center's experience

In coil embolization of cerebral aneurysms, inadequate packing is known to increase the probability of recanalization. Even tightly embolized aneurysms may be recanalized, but predictive factors for recanalization have not been fully investigated. This retrospective study aimed to identify risk factors for recanalization of treated aneurysms with a volume embolization ratio (VER) ≥ 25%. A total of 301 unruptured aneurysms in 248 patients who underwent coil embolization between March 2012 and January 2021 were analyzed. Cases involving dissecting aneurysm, intraluminal thrombosis, parent artery occlusion, intraoperative rupture, re-treatment, rupture the day after surgery, postoperative coil migration, and postoperative parent artery occlusion were excluded due to the inaccuracy of VER. A total of 105 aneurysms (34.9%) treated with VER ≥ 25% were extracted. Clinical features (age, sex, medical history, family history), anatomical features (shape, location, aneurysm size, inflow angle, and volume), procedural features (stent-assisted, Raymond-Roy occlusion classification [RROC] immediately after treatment, re-treatment rate), and follow-up period were compared between Recanalization and Non-recanalization groups. Predictors of recanalization were determined using logistic regression and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analyses. Eleven aneurysms were recanalized. In multivariate analysis, RROC class 3 (odds ratio [OR] 11.0; 95% confidence interval [CI] 2.03-59.4) and aneurysm volume (OR 1.005; 95%CI 1.001-1.008) were independent predictors of recanalization. ROC curve analysis showed optimal cutoff values for aneurysm volume of 69.5 mm³ (sensitivity, 81.8%; specificity, 72.3%). In coil embolization of unruptured aneurysms that VER ≥ 25%, cases with RROC class 3 or high aneurysm volume may be associated with a higher risk of recanalization, and should be carefully followed-up.

Propensity score-adjusted analysis on stent-assisted coiling versus coiling alone for ruptured intracranial aneurysms

Stent-assisted coiling (SAC) for ruptured intracranial aneurysms (RIAs) remains controversial due to an inherent risk of potential thromboembolic and hemorrhagic complications. We compared SAC and coiling alone for the management of RIAs using propensity score-adjustment. Sixty-four patients treated by SAC and 220 by stand-alone coiling were retrospectively reviewed and compared using inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPTW) with propensity scores. Functional outcome, procedure-related and overall complications and angiographic results were analyzed. Aneurysms treated by SAC had a larger diameter, a wider neck and were more frequently located at the posterior circulation. SAC had a higher risk for thromboembolic complications (17.2% vs. 7.7%, p = 0.025), however, this difference did not persist in the IPTW analysis (OR 1.2, 95% CI 0.7-2.3, adjusted p = 0.458). In the adjusted analysis, rates of procedural cerebral infarction (p = 0.188), ventriculostomy-related hemorrhage (p = 0.584), in-hospital mortality (p = 0.786) and 6-month favorable functional outcome (p = 0.471) were not significantly different between the two groups. SAC yielded a higher complete occlusion (80.0% vs. 67.2%, OR 3.2, 95% CI 1.9-5.4, p < 0.001) and a lower recanalization rate (17.5% vs. 26.1%, OR 0.3, 95% CI 0.2-0.6, p < 0.001) than stand-alone coiling at 6-month follow-up. In conclusion, SAC of large and wide-necked RIAs provided higher aneurysm occlusion and similar clinical outcome, when compared to stand-alone coiling.

Hemodynamic and Morphological Factors Related to Coil Compaction in Basilar Artery Tip Aneurysms

PURPOSE

Coil compaction is directly related to the degree of cerebral aneurysmal recanalization. The Degree of Recanalization (DoR) was quantified by measuring the volume vacated by coil deformation. The purpose of this study was to clarify the hemodynamic and morphological factors associated with coil compaction.

METHODS

Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations were performed on 28 middle size (5-10 mm), unruptured basilar artery tip aneurysms. The DoR was measured by comparing the coil mass shape obtained from three-dimensional digital subtraction angiography data immediately after coil embolization and again within 1 to 2 years of follow-up. Deployed coils were modeled using a virtual coiling technique for CFD simulations. Hemodynamic and morphological factors to predict the DoR were derived using multiple linear regression.

RESULTS

Aneurysmal neck area, the maximum pressure generated on the neck surface after coil embolization, and the high-pressure position on the neck surface predicted DoR with statistical significance (p<0.001, p<0.001, p=0.004, respectively). DoR tended to increase when the neck area was large, the pressure generated on the coils was high, and the high-pressure position was close to the center of the neck surface. The volume embolization ratio was not statistically relevant for the DoR in the cases of this study.

CONCLUSIONS

Coil compaction occurs in cerebral aneurysms with a wide neck, high pressure generated on the coils, and high pressure in the center of the neck surface. Establishing the DoR can contribute to the prediction of recanalization after coil embolization.

An Efficient Method for Aneurysm Volume Quantification Applicable in Any Shape and Modalities

Objective

Aneurysm volume quantification (AVQ) using the equation of ellipsoid volume is widely used although it is inaccurate. Furthermore, AVQ with 3-dimensional (3D) rendered data has limitations in general use. A novel universal method for AVQ is introduced for any diagnostic modality and application to any shape of aneurysms.

Methods

Relevant AVQ studies published from January 1997 to June 2019 were identified to determine common methods of AVQ. The basic idea is to eliminate the normal artery volume from 3D model with the aneurysm. After Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) data is converted and exported to stereolithography (STL) file format, the 3D STL model is modified to remove the aneurysm and the volume difference between the 3D model with/without the aneurysm is defined as the aneurysm volume. Fifty randomly selected aneurysms from DICOM database were used to validate the different AVQ methods.

Results

We reviewed and categorized AVQ methods in 121 studies. Approximately 60% used the ellipsoid method, while 24% used the 3D model. For 50 randomly selected aneurysms, volumes were measured using 3D Slicer, RadiAnt, and ellipsoid method. Using 3D Slicer as the reference, the ratios of mean difference to mean volume obtained by RadiAnt and ellipsoid method were -1.21±7.46% and 4.04±30.54%, respectively. The deviations between RadiAnt and 3D Slicer were small despite of aneurysm shapes, but those of ellipsoid method and 3D Slicer were large.

Conclusion

In spite of inaccuracy, ellipsoid method is still mostly used. We propose a novel universal method for AVQ that is valid, low cost, and easy to use.

Experimental Study of Coil Compaction: Impact of Pulsatile Stress

Objective

Coil compaction after aneurysm embolization is one of the major issues associated with aneurysm recurrence. On the presumption that pulsatile stress to the aneurysm is responsible for coil compaction, we developed an experimental model in vitro to visualize the mechanical stresses exerted by blood pressure and pulse and their relation to coil compaction.

Methods

A closed-type non-circulation system was developed by installing a syringe that generated pressure at one end of a tube, along with a spherical aneurysm made of silicone and a pressure sensor in the bifurcated end. We installed a fixed-pressure model under a steady pressure of 300 mmHg while the pressure-fluctuation model simulated the pressure variations using a plunger (in a syringe) by using a motor that applied pulsatile stress in the range of 50 mmHg for a 10-ms cycle. We devised four types of aneurysms with different depths and the same coil length. After coil packing, the aneurysms were observed for 3 days (the observation period in the pressure-fluctuation model corresponded to approximately 300 days in real time). The distance from the datum point to the observable coil loops was determined as the initial position, and the temporal change in the distance from that position was measured.

Results

In the fixed-pressure model, the average distance of coil movement was very small (less than ±0.1 mm). In the pressure-fluctuation model, the movement of coils was observed to be significant for the two longest depths (0.11 and 0.14 mm). The maximal dynamic change in coil movement was observed on the second day. The range of movement was observed to decrease thereafter.

Conclusion

Our experimental study enabled the observation of coil movement within a short duration. It examined coil compaction by applying pulsed pressure to the coils at high speeds. Consequently, a shift of the coil loops inside the incompletely occluded aneurysms was detected on applying a pulsed pressure.

Three-dimensional aneurysm volume measurements show no correlation between coil packing density and recurrence

Objective

Endovascular treatment is the mainstay therapy for brain aneurysms. About 15% of patients need re-treatment within six months due to early recanalization. In this study, we investigate risk factors associated with treatment failure.

Methods

This retrospective cohort study includes endovascularly treated aneurysm cases between July 2012 and December 2015 at the University of California Davis Medical Center with pre-treatment and early post-treatment imaging. Thin cut 3D aneurysm volume rendering was used for morphologic analyses. Univariate and bivariate analyses were conducted to evaluate differences between patients and clinical factors by treatment failure.

Results

Of the 50 patients who met the inclusion criteria, 41 (82.0%) were female, with an average age of 61 years. Most aneurysms were on the anterior communicating artery (40%) or posterior communicating artery (22.0%), and 34 (68%) aneurysms were ruptured. Early treatment failure was observed in 14 (28.0%) of endovascularly treated patients. Raymond-Roy class (RRC) was significantly associated with treatment failure (p = 0.0052), with 10 out of the 14 cases (71.4%) with early recanalization having an RRC of 3. Coil packing density did not associate with aneurysm recanalization (p = 0.61).

Conclusion

In our single institution series, patient characteristics, aneurysm characteristics, or coil packing density did not affect early aneurysm recanalization. RRC was the best predictor of early recanalization; however, further confirmation with additional studies are required. Although this study focused on early treatment failure, late recanalization has been shown with longer follow up. Further investigation into factors associated with late treatment failure will need further investigation. New intrasaccular devices and flow diverters will also likely play a role in reducing recurrence in the future as these treatments gain usage.

Aneurysm characteristics, coil packing, and post-coiling hemodynamics affect long-term treatment outcome

BACKGROUND

Recurrence of intracranial aneurysms after endovascular coiling is a serious clinical concern.

OBJECTIVE

We hypothesized that recurrence is associated with aneurysm morphology and flow, as well as the coil intervention and the induced flow modifications.

METHODS

We collected 52 primary-coiling aneurysm cases that were either occluded (n=34) or recurrent (n=18) at >1 year follow-up. We created aneurysm models from pre-coiling digital subtraction angiographic images, calculated aneurysm morphology, simulated pre-coiling hemodynamics, modeled coil deployment, and obtained post-coiling hemodynamics for each case. We performed univariable analysis on 26 morphologic, treatment-specific, and hemodynamic parameters to distinguish between recurrent and occluded groups, and multivariable analysis to identify independently significant parameters associated with recurrence. Univariable analysis was also performed on ruptured and unruptured aneurysm subcohorts separately to investigate if they shared specific significant parameters.

RESULTS

Recurrence was associated with pre-coiling aneurysm morphologic and flow parameters including larger size (maximum dimension and volume), larger neck (diameter, area, and neck-to-parent-artery ratio), and higher flow momentum and kinetic energy. Recurrence was also associated with lower coil packing (packing density and uncoiled volume), higher post-treatment flow (velocity, momentum, and kinetic energy), lower post-treatment washout time, and higher post-treatment impingement force at the neck. Multivariable analysis identified two aneurysmal characteristics (neck diameter and pre-coiling flow kinetic energy), one coil packing parameter (uncoiled volume), and one post-treatment hemodynamic parameter (flow momentum) that were independently associated with recurrence. In ruptured aneurysms, recurrence was associated with larger neck (diameter and area), whereas in unruptured aneurysms, recurrence was associated with larger size (maximum dimension and volume). In both subcohorts, recurrence was associated with higher post-coiling flow momentum and kinetic energy.

CONCLUSION

Recurrence at >1 year after coil treatment is associated with intrinsic aneurysm characteristics, coiling itself, and flow changes induced by coiling. Larger aneurysm size and neck, less coil packing, and higher intra-aneurysmal flow before and after coiling predict recurrence.

Microvascular Revascularization for Recurrent A1 Anterior Cerebral Artery Aneurysm Postendovascular Treatment: A Case Report and Review of the Literature

The recurrence of aneurysms postcoil embolization is a common occurrence. Endovascular coiling has been noted to be more effective for small lesions rather than the giant aneurysms. A postembolization recurrent aneurysm is a difficult condition to manage. We present a case of a recurrent giant aneurysm of the anterior cerebral arteries (ACAs) first segment (A1). It was managed by superficial temporal artery to A3 segment of anterior cerebral artery bypass anastomotic revascularization plus distal A1- segment clipping. A literature review is presented for the management of giant A1 artery aneurysms.

LVIS Blue as a low porosity stent and coil adjuvant

Introduction

The LVIS Blue is an FDA-approved stent with 28% metallic coverage that is indicated for use in conjunction with coil embolization for the treatment of intracranial aneurysms. Given a porosity similar to approved flow diverters and higher than currently available intracranial stents, we sought to evaluate the effectiveness of this device for the treatment of intracranial aneurysms.

Methods

We performed an observational single-center study to evaluate initial occlusion and occlusion at 6-month follow-up for patients treated with the LVIS Blue in conjunction with coil embolization at our institution using the modified Raymond–Roy classification (mRRC), where mRRC 1 indicates complete embolization, mRRC 2 persistent opacification of the aneurysm neck, mRRC 3a filling of the aneurysm dome within coil interstices, and mRRC 3b filling of the aneurysm dome.

Results

Sixteen aneurysms were treated with the LVIS Blue device in conjunction with coil embolization with 6-month angiographic follow-up. Aneurysms were treated throughout the intracranial circulation: five proximal internal carotid artery (ICA) (ophthalmic or communicating segments), two superior cerebellar artery, two ICA terminus, two anterior communicating artery, two distal middle cerebral artery, one posterior inferior cerebellar artery, and two basilar tip aneurysms. Post-procedurally, there was one mRRC 1 closure, five mRRC 2 closures, and 10 mRRC 3a or 3b occlusion. At follow-up, all the mRRC 1 and mRRC 3a closures, 85% of the mRRC 3b closures and 75% of the mRRC 2 closures were stable or improved to an mRRC 1 or 2 at follow-up.

Conclusions

The LVIS Blue represents a safe option as a coil adjunct for endovascular embolization within both the proximal and distal anterior and posterior circulation.

Risk factors for angiographic recurrence after treatment of unruptured intracranial aneurysms: Outcomes from a series of 178 unruptured aneurysms treated by regular coiling or surgery

BACKGROUND

Long-term stability after intracranial aneurysm exclusion by coiling is still a matter of debate; after surgical clipping little is known.

OBJECTIVE

To study outcome after endovascular and surgical treatments for unruptured intracranial aneurysms in terms of short- and long-term angiographic exclusion and risk factors for recanalization.

METHODS

From 2004 and 2009, patients treated for unruptured berry intracranial aneurysms by coiling or clipping were reviewed. Aneurysmal exclusion was evaluated using the Roy-Raymond grading scale; immediate clinical outcome was also assessed. Clinical outcome, recanalization, risk factors for recurrence and bleeding during the follow-up period were analyzed by groups; "surgery" and "embolization".

RESULTS

From 2004 to 2009, 178 consecutive unruptured aneurysms were treated. The post-procedure angiographic results for "surgery" were: total exclusion 75.6%; residual neck 13.5%; residual aneurysm 10.8%. For "embolization", the results were, respectively: 72%; 20.7%; and 7.2%. Morbidity was 3% for "surgery" and 1.6% for "embolization" (P=0.74); mortality was nil. Mean clinical and angiographic follow-up was 5years. Recurrence rate was of 11.5% for "surgery" vs. 44% for "embolization" with a mean follow-up of 4 and 5.75years, respectively (P=1.10-5). The retreatment rate was 8.4%. Two significant risk factors for recanalization were identified: maximum diameter of the aneurysm sac (P=0.0038) and pericallosal location (P=0.0388). No bleeding event occurred.

CONCLUSION

Both techniques are safe. The rate of aneurismal recurrence was significantly higher for embolization, especially for large diameter aneurysms and pericallosal locations. No bleeding event occurred after recanalization.