In vivo crevicular leucocyte response in humans to a chemotactic challenge. Effects of periodontal diseases

Potential effect of neutrophil functional disorders on pathogenesis of aggressive periodontitis

INTRODUCTION

Leukocytes play a key role in maintaining the balance between an effective host defence response to microorganisms and periodontal tissue destruction. Neutrophil dysfunction has been associated with increased susceptibility to periodontal diseases. We undertook this study to determine to what extent neutrophil dysfunction constitutes to the pathogenesis of aggressive periodontitis (AgP) in tropical country like ours.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Age- and sex-matched groups consisting of 20 subjects each of generalized aggressive periodontitis (GAP)-cases and nonperiodontitis (NP)-controls. diabetes mellitus, HIV infection, prolonged antibiotic use and smoking were excluded. Each neutrophil function was assessed using the chemotactic assay using case in, phagocytosis assay, candidacidal assay (for intracellular killing) and NBT assay (for respiratory burst failure).

STATISTICAL ANALYSIS USED

Student's t-test, Fisher's exact test and Chi-square test.

RESULTS

In the study 17 out of 20 subjects (85%) had at least one abnormal neutrophil assay either hypofunctional or hyperfunctional of which 16 (80%) had hypofunctional assays and 8 (40%) had hyperfunctional assays. Defective phagocytosis was the commonest (50%) followed by chemotactic defect (45%), defective respiratory burst (40%) and defective intracellular killing (30%). Mean of chemotaxis assay was significantly less in AgP when compared to controls (103 vs 129 µm, p=0.002), similarly for phagocytic defect (3.45 vs 4.65, p≤0.001) and with candidacidal assay (26.80 vs 37.35, p<0.001).

CONCLUSION

The prevalence of neutrophil dysfunction, predominantly hypofunctional, was significantly very high in GAP patients with few even having hyperactive respiratory burst function. Multiple level neutrophil defects could account for the aggressive nature of AgP even in apparently healthy subjects.

A potential role of an intracellular signaling defect in neutrophil functional abnormalities and promotion of tissue damage in patients with localized juvenile periodontitis

Localized juvenile periodontitis is a destructive form of periodontal inflammatory disease which has its onset at puberty. The etiopathology of the disease is still unclear but neutrophils have been suggested to play a major role both in the production and development of the disorder. About 70% of the patients with localized juvenile periodontitis exhibit neutrophil functional abnormalities, such as decreased chemotaxis and phagocytosis. Interestingly, it has been frequently reported that the same hypoactive cells show an enhanced respiratory burst response and increased adhesion. Several possible mechanisms explaining neutrophil anomalies in localized juvenile periodontitis have been proposed. These include the presence of soluble serum factors capable of modulating neutrophil function, altered cell-surface receptor expression and/or function, and a change in the post-receptor signaling events. Recently, a growing evidence has accumulated showing that the diacylglycerol metabolism could be altered in neutrophils from patients with localized juvenile periodontitis. This change, which may be due to a defect in a major diacylglycerol metabolizing enzyme, diacylglycerol kinase, results in enhanced accumulation of diacylglycerol in activated cells. Because diacylglycerol is an endogenous activator of protein kinase C, the increased and prolonged generation of diacylglycerol could lead to abnormal pattern of protein kinase C-regulated neutrophil functions, explaining the parallel hypo- and hyperactivities.

Elastase and alpha-1-proteinase inhibitor in gingival crevicular fluid and gingival tissue in adult and juvenile periodontitis

The presence and localization of PMN/neutrophil elastase and its endogenous inhibitor alpha 1-proteinase inhibitor (alpha 1 PI) were studied immunohistochemically in gingival tissue specimens collected from 9 adult periodontitis (AP) patients during flap surgery after the initial phase of periodontal therapy, and from 6 healthy controls with clinically-healthy periodontium upon surgical extraction of impacted third molars. In order to evaluate how periodontal tissue destructive events are reflected in gingival crevicular fluid (GCF), GCF samples were collected from the AP patients before any periodontal treatment and prior to flap surgery, from 5 localized juvenile periodontitis (LJP) patients, and from the controls. Elastase activity in the GCF was measured with the SAAVNA-assay and the molecular forms and amount of alpha 1PI by Western- and dot-blotting. Immunohistochemical staining for PMN elastase was strongly positive in the connective tissue, but not in the epithelium, of the AP patients' gingival tissue specimens. In the healthy gingival tissue specimens only a few elastase-positive cells were present. Both in AP and in control gingival specimens, alpha 1PI was detected in the connective tissue and in the keratinized layer of the epithelium, however, its amount was markedly lower in the control specimens. Elevated levels of alpha 1PI and PMN elastase were detected in the GCF of all periodontitis patients when compared to controls.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

A skin window study of neutrophil migration in subjects with localized juvenile periodontitis

This study investigated the effect of a chemoattractant, N-formyl-methionyl-leucyl-phenylalanine (FMLP), upon skin window migration of neutrophils into filters in 5 patients with a history of localized juvenile periodontitis (LJP) and 8 controls. On 2 occasions, each subject had 2 superficial skin abrasions made on the inner aspect of the forearm. Initial periodontal treatment was carried out on the disease group between the visits. On one skin window filters were placed that were soaked in physiological saline, and on the other filters soaked with FMLP. Leading fronts and cell densities were measured in each filter. At visit 1, LJP subjects had significantly lower leading fronts and cell densities. At visit 2, the differences were insignificant. The leading fronts for the LJP group were significantly improved on the second visit. No difference was observed between saline and FMLP. The findings of this study indicate that neutrophil migration is reduced in LJP patients where treatment is not involved, and that FMLP has no effect on neutrophil migration from the skin windows under the conditions of this study.

Host responses in periodontal diseases: current concepts

In periodontal diseases, bacteria trigger inflammatory host responses which, along with the direct destructive effects of the bacteria, cause most of the tissue destruction. Periodontal inflammatory responses are, by and large, immunologic, and our understanding of these reactions has been advanced by the explosion of knowledge in immunobiology, some of which is discussed in this review. Understanding the role of immune cells and their regulatory cell surface molecules such as the MHC, CD antigens, and receptors, as well as knowledge of effector systems set into motion such as phagocytes and cytotoxic T-cells, and the effector molecules such as antibodies, complement, and cytokines, have led to better understanding of the complex pathogenesis of periodontal disease. The role of mediators including the matrix metalloproteinases, proteoglycans, the kinins and anaphylatoxins, and low molecular weight mediators including products of arachidonic metabolism is beginning to be elucidated in periodontal disease. Important avenues of research for development of diagnostic tests based upon host response are apparent. For example, tissue products released during periodontal inflammation including the metalloproteinases, elastase, cytokines, prostaglandins, antibodies, and complement components may provide the basis for future diagnostic indicator tests. The recognition that the neutrophil/antibody/complement axis is critical for protection against periodontal bacteria and that abnormalities in this system often lead to increased periodontal susceptibility provide approaches for the development of diagnostic tests assessing risk. A group of factors which are negative regulators of inflammation including TGF-beta, gamma-interferon, and IL-1 receptor antagonist provide potential for assessment of periodontal disease in remission or in the healing phase. Finally, factors such as HLA associations and the molecular basis for neutrophil abnormalities may provide genetic markers for periodontal disease susceptibility. Diagnostic factors based upon host response measures offer great potential for predicting host susceptibility and will likely be used in combination with microbial diagnostics which identify specific infecting organisms.

Neutrophil function and oral disease

The pathological sequela of reduced neutrophil function in the oral cavity and the mechanisms behind dysfunction have added to our understanding of infectious diseases. Numerous examples have been given, and the overriding conclusion must be that any impairment of neutrophil function will lead to some degree of increased susceptibility to infection. Perhaps the tissue most sensitive to pathological changes in the oral cavity is the periodontium. In cases of severe neutrophil dysfunction, there is severe periodontal breakdown, but also in cases of "mild" neutrophil dysfunction, where there is no other infection, such as in individuals with LJP, there is severe periodontal breakdown. The molecular basis of neutrophil dysfunction is beginning to be understood in individuals with LJP, LAD, CGD, and AIDS. It is our hope that further research in this area will help to delineate the pathogenesis of these and other oral diseases.

An in vivo study of neutrophil locomotion in relation to periodontal disease status and local chlorhexidine

Neutrophil migration from skin window abrasions was studied in 10 patients with no history of periodontitis, 10 with localised juvenile or post-juvenile periodontitis, and 10 with chronic adult periodontitis. Filters contained either saline or chlorhexidine (0.002% or 0.02%). The leading front was measured in filters placed for 30 min after cell migration had been established for 2 h. Subjects in the juvenile/post juvenile group showed a reduced range of migration distances, but were still within the normal range when compared with the other 2 groups. Chlorhexidine at 0.002% tended to increase leading front distances, and 0.02% to decrease them. We conclude that: 1) migrating neutrophils in vivo may move less far in patients with a history of juvenile periodontitis; 2) chlorhexidine may inhibit cell migration, possibly decreasing the host response in vivo if applied at current therapeutic concentrations.

Reconstruction of parodontal tissue with chitosan

Chitosan ascorbate, obtained by mixing chitosan with ascorbic acid and sodium ascorbate, was produced in a gel form suitable for the treatment of periodontitis according to current dental surgery. While chitosan ascorbate underwent degradation in vitro, especially in the presence of atmospheric oxygen and at pH 6.0, the protection from oxygen offered by the surgical cements and the physiological pH value permitted chitosan ascorbate to play an important biological role in vivo, where it kept a honeycomb structure, as indicated by SEM on biopsies taken on 10 patients. The proliferation and organization of the cells were thus favoured with a subsequent enhanced capability of reconstructing a histoarchitectural tissue. Chitosan was progressively reabsorbed by the host, with very satisfactory clinical recoveries of the 52 defects treated, for which tooth mobility and pocket depths were significantly reduced.

The effect of sequential sampling on crevicular fluid volume and enzyme activity

Gingival crevicular fluid (GCF) volume and constituents in static samples were compared to volume and constituents in subsequent GCF samples collected during a 60-min interval. Using deep intracrevicular placement of precut filter paper strips, GCF was collected from interproximal and facial sites from patients with gingivitis (N = 14; 28 interproximal sites, 28 facial sites) and chronic adult periodontitis (N = 11; 26 interproximal sites, 18 facial sites). The strips were inserted for 30 s at 0, 4, 8, 30 and 60 min. The amount of fluid on each strip was determined and microspectrophotometric techniques were used to assess cytoplasmic and lysosomal enzyme activity. Within each group of sites, mean GCF volume showed minimal fluctuation with repeated sampling. In contrast, the static GCF sample contained the greatest amount of total enzyme activity, and differences were detected between groups. The interproximal sites and the gingivitis-facial sites displayed a similar pattern of change in total enzyme activity during the test period. The highest total enzyme activity was observed in the first sample and decreased at 4 and 8 minutes. At 30 and 60 min, the amount of enzyme either remained at the level detected at 8 min, or displayed a mild tendency to recover towards baseline. A different pattern of total enzyme activity was observed for the periodontitis-facial sites, where a significant decrease was first observed at 30 min. Enzyme concentration was higher in the facial sites than the interproximal sites, and enzyme concentration was generally highest in the static samples. The concentration data, however, is difficult to interpret since a number of sites demonstrated a converted GCF volume of 0 microliter. Our data suggests that total enzyme activity and enzyme concentration are generally greater in the static GCF samples compared to subsequent samples.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Neutrophil chemotaxis in refractory cases of periodontitis

Refractory cases of periodontitis were assayed for chemotaxis of polymorphonuclear neutrophilic leukocytes using an in vivo assay. 9 refractory patients and 9 normal patients were studied. When cell counts were plotted against time, normal patients showed a single peak at 25-30 min after casein (chemo-attractant) challenge, whereas refractory patients showed 2 and 3 peaks of PMN's at varying time intervals. 5 of the refractory patients showed this pattern in tests of normal sulci as well as deep periodontal pockets. 4 of the refractory cases showed a double peak in tests of deep periodontal pockets. This suggests that some refractory cases have an intrinsic chemotactic defect of polymorphonuclear neutrophils while in others the defect may be a secondary phenomenon. It appears that patients with refractory periodontitis have the characteristic cell response that was reported for LJP.

1985 Kreshover lecture. Molecular factors influencing neutrophil defects in periodontal disease

Major advances in our understanding of the role of the neutrophil in host defense against periodontal organisms have been made through studies of localized juvenile periodontitis (LJP). Several lines of evidence suggest that LJP is an infectious process closely associated with Actinobacillus (Haemophilus) actinomycetemomitans as a causative agent, although other organisms may also participate. The immunologic profile of LJP patients suggests that a cell-associated neutrophil locomotory dysfunction is a key underlying immunodeficiency resulting in increased susceptibility to periodontal infection. In addition, LJP patients often exhibit cervical lymphadenopathy and IgG-hypergammaglobulinemia, and a markedly elevated antibody response to the infecting organism, A. actinomycetemcomitans, is found in the serum and crevicular fluid of most patients. Evaluation of the locomotory properties of LJP neutrophils shows that random migration and chemokinesis are normal; however, about 70% of the LJP patients suffer from a defect in chemotaxis, with their neutrophils responding poorly to bacterial chemotactic factors, synthetic chemotactic peptides, and complement fragments (C5a). Depressed chemotaxis of LJP neutrophils is paralleled by their reduced capacity to bind the synthetic chemotactic peptide N-formylmethionylleucylphenylalanine (FMLP), as well as C5a. Furthermore, there is a reduction in the amount of glycoprotein 110, a neutrophil membrane matrix component and differentiation antigen which is associated with FMLP- and possibly also C5a-mediated chemotaxis. Reduction of C5a and of FMLP ligand binding, decreased expression of GP-110, and reduced neutrophil chemotaxis are consistent with a stem cell maturation error in LJP patients. This is further supported by studies demonstrating increased expression of CR2, the C3d/EBV receptor, on peripheral blood neutrophils of LJP patients. CR2 receptors are normally present on immature human neutrophils but are lost during the maturation process. These alterations in neutrophil surface components and their reduced chemotaxis may result from a genetically determined abnormality. Studies demonstrating the familial nature of both the neutrophil chemotactic disorder and the clinical entity represented by localized juvenile periodontitis point to a strong role for genetic determinants in the disease which affect neutrophil surface receptors.

Indicators of periodontal disease activity: an evaluation

It is becoming increasingly apparent that the traditional clinical criteria are inadequate for: determining active disease sites in periodontitis, monitoring quantitatively the response to therapy or measuring the degree of susceptibility to future breakdown. In an attempt to develop objective measures, a wide variety of studies have been undertaken using saliva, blood, plaque and gingival crevicular fluid (GCF) as the specimen source. Examination has included: specific bacteria and their products; host cells and their products (enzymatic and antibacterial, both immunologic and non-immunologic); products of tissue injury derived from local epithelial and connective tissues and bone. Although most of the work to date has failed to provide reliable aids to the clinician, refinements in techniques for sampling and the availability of more sophisticated analytic techniques give cause for optimism. Methods proposed for detection of disease-associated bacteria in subgingival plaque vary in their sensitivity and specificity. Dark field microscopy shows some correlation with existing disease; however, the limited specificity of this method imposes severe restrictions on its usefulness. Highly specific polyclonal and monoclonal antisera to suspected pathogens Bacteroides gingivalis and Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans have been developed and improved methods of identification of these microbes in plaque by ELISA immunofluorescence and flow cytometry are under development. With respect to the host response, a strong correlation between antibody patterns to specific bacteria and periodontal disease categories appears to be emerging. Although most studies have focused on serum antibody derived from peripheral blood, a shift to detection of local antibody response appears to be likely. Techniques of measurement that are exquisitely sensitive have been developed for detection of major immune recognition proteins such as antibody and complement in crevicular fluid. Research efforts attempting to correlate local antibody response to local disease activity are underway. Measurement of GCF flow rate, endotoxin, H2S, butyrate and a variety of enzymes (e.g., collagenase, arylsulfatase, B-glucuronidase) show good correlation with levels of gingivitis. In periodontitis, the most promising markers of tissue breakdown are prostaglandins of the E series, the enzymes collagenase and aspartate aminotransferase, sulfated glycosaminoglycans, osteoclastic activating factor and bone resorptive capacity of crevicular cells. Assay of the migration of crevicular leucocytes in vivo can serve as an indicator of a defect in host resistance.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Phagocytic cells in periodontal defense. Periodontal status of patients with chronic granulomatous disease of childhood

Both qualitative and quantitative neutrophil abnormalities have been associated with severe forms of periodontitis. Defects in chemotaxis, phagocytosis and bacterial killing have been reported among both peripheral blood and gingival neutrophils harvested from patients with juvenile and rapidly progressive periodontitis. Chronic granulomatous disease of childhood (CGD) is a rare, inherited disorder associated with the occurrence of severe, life-threatening, suppurative infections of skin, liver, lymph nodes and other organs. Neutrophils and monocytes from individuals with CGD lack enzymes necessary for the production of oxygen reduction/products such as H2O2 and superoxide anion, and therefore are unable to kill many species of bacteria and fungi. However, no detailed study of the periodontium of these patients has been undertaken. Accordingly, five patients whose ages ranged from 17 to 32 years were included in this study. An additional (sixth) patient was included based on complete dental records. Neutrophils from all patients demonstrated defective O2 metabolism, and all patients had histories of chronic recurrent abscesses consistent with CGD. All patients were receiving antibiotic prophylaxis. Several patients had ulcerative lesions of the oral cavity of unknown etiology. Examination of the periodontium revealed that three patients had gingivitis, one had localized early periodontitis, and one had generalized early-to-moderate periodontitis. The severity of periodontal disease was consistent with patient age and local etiologic factors. No patients had evidence of juvenile, severe or rapidly-progressing disease in spite of their leukocyte defects. These findings suggest the following possibilities.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)