Influence of smoking on long-term clinical results of intrabony defects treated with regenerative therapy

Guided flapless surgery with immediate loading for the high narrow ridge without grafting

Computer guided implant treatment allows implants and associated restorations to be precisely placed during the same procedure directly through the gingiva with reduced postoperative complications and surgical time. When bone height is adequate but very narrow, the virtual guided sleeve is often placed too deeply into the ridge crest interfering with the seating of the surgical template. This case report of a patient exhibiting very narrow residual ridges due to severe resorption describes a new computer guided procedure using a single surgical template maintaining bone height and immediate restoration without a mucoperiosteal flap. The success of this technique is the result of innovative modifications in the software as well as instrumentation. Modifications include planning a different implant length virtually to raise the position of guide sleeves, alteration of drilling sequences, modifications of the start drill, incorporation of osteotomes, and use of an alternative implant seating mount. The combination of these methods allows for deeper site preparation and implant seating beyond the default settings, without any crestal bone reduction. These modifications not only make the guided concept possible for the entire preparation and seating procedures, but also allow for the slight removal of bone that would interfere with the implant seating through the surgical template without a mucoperiosteal flap. This new approach to computer guided surgery maintains prosthetic precision in the fabrication of a provisional restoration prior to implantation with minimal delivery adjustments using prefabricated conical abutments when placing implants at differing levels into the high narrow ridge.

[Effects of smoking on periodontal disease]

INTRODUCTION

Smoking is an independent risk factor for periodontal disease and tooth loss.

STATE OF THE ART

Smoking impairs inflammatory and immune responses to periodontal pathogens, and exerts both systemic and local effects. Periodontal disease is increased both in prevalence and severity in smokers. Smoking is a predisposing factor to acute necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis and is associated with an increased rate of periodontal disease in terms of pocket formation and attachment loss, as well as alveolar bone loss. Cigar, pipe, water-pipe and cannabis smoking have similar adverse effects on periodontal health as cigarette smoking. Passive smoking is also an independent periodontal disease risk factor. Smokeless tobacco is associated with localized periodontal disease. Smokers respond less favourably to both non-surgical and surgical treatments and have higher failure rates and complications following dental implantation. Smoking cessation may halt the disease progression and improve the outcome of periodontal treatment.

CONCLUSION

Smoking cessation counselling should be an integral part of periodontal therapy and prevention.

Regeneration of periodontal tissue: bone replacement grafts

Bone replacement grafts are widely used to promote bone formation and periodontal regeneration. Conventional surgical approaches, such as open flap debridement, provide critical access to evaluate and detoxify root surfaces as well as establish improved periodontal form and architecture; however, these surgical techniques offer only limited potential in restoring or reconstituting component periodontal tissues. A wide range of bone grafting materials, including bone grafts and bone graft substitutes, have been applied and evaluated clinically, including autografts, allografts, xenografts, and alloplasts (synthetic/semisynthetic materials). This review provides an overview of the biologic function and clinical application of bone replacement grafts for periodontal regeneration. Emphasis is placed on the clinical and biologic goals of periodontal regeneration as well as evidence-based treatment outcomes.

Commentary: prognosis revisited: a system for assigning periodontal prognosis

Prognosis is an integral part of the periodontal practice because it directly influences treatment planning. However, there is limited direct evidence in the literature regarding the assignment of periodontal prognosis. There are several important concepts to consider in developing a system of periodontal prognosis. Traditional systems are based on tooth loss and may have limited use for patient management. On the other hand, prognosis can be based on stability of the periodontal supporting apparatus, which is influenced by more evidence-based factors and may be more useful for patient management. Other important concepts include the timing of the projection (short and long term) and the consideration of individual teeth versus the overall dentition. Historically, several authors have formulated and investigated their own prognostication systems. Results were variable, but they generally showed that systems based on tooth loss were unpredictable over the long term. Therefore, the purpose of this report is to review relevant literature and propose a new periodontal prognostication system.

Surgical guided tissue regeneration treatment of advanced periodontal defects: a 5-year follow-up study

OBJECTIVES

To study the 5-year outcome of combined use of guided tissue regeneration (GTR) barriers and bovine bone in advanced periodontal defects.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In each of 24 patients, one defect was surgically exposed, debrided, filled with bovine bone, and covered with a bioresorbable barrier. Re-examinations were made after 1, 3, and 5 years.

RESULTS

Average full-mouth plaque scores (FMPS) were 14.5% at baseline and 10.7%, 9.8%, and 18.9% after 1, 3, and 5 years, respectively. Mean probing pocket depth (PPD) was 10.0 mm at baseline. Mean PPD reduction was 5.2 mm after 1 year, 5.6 mm after 3 years, and 5.3 mm after 5 years. Mean gingival recession was 1.0 mm after 1 year, 1.6 mm after 3 years, and 1.3 mm after 5 years. Mean gain in clinical attachment level (CAL) was 4.2 mm at the 1-year, 4.1 mm at the 3-year, and 4.3 mm at the 5-year examination. Smoking significantly influenced CAL change at all re-examinations. FMPS were significantly correlated with radiographic defect depth at the 5-year examination and CAL with smoking and FMPS at the 3-year examination.

CONCLUSION

Advanced periodontal defects can be successfully treated with the combined use of GTR barriers and bovine bone to substantially reduce PPD and achieve a stable, long-term gain of CAL.

Surgical treatment of peri-implantitis using a bone substitute with or without a resorbable membrane: a prospective cohort study

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this prospective cohort study was to compare two regenerative surgical treatment modalities for peri-implantitis.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Thirty-six patients having a minimum of one osseointegrated implant, with a progressive loss of bone amounting to > or =3 threads (1.8 mm) following the first year of healing, combined with bleeding and/or pus on probing, were involved in this study. The patients were assigned to two different treatment strategies. After surgical exposure of the defect, granulomatous tissue was removed and the infected implant surface was treated using 3% hydrogen peroxide. The bone defects were filled with a bone substitute (Algipore). In 17 patients (Group 1), a resorbable membrane (Osseoquest) was placed over the grafted defect before suturing. In 19 patients (Group 2), the graft was used alone.

RESULTS

One-year follow-up demonstrated clinical and radiographic improvements. Probing depths were reduced by 2.9 mm in Group 1 and by 3.4 mm in Group 2. Defect fill amounted to 1.5 and 1.4 mm, respectively. There was no significant difference between the groups.

CONCLUSION

It is possible to treat peri-implant defects with a bone substitute, with or without a resorbable membrane.

Gingival Recession Treatment With Connective Tissue Grafts in Smokers and Non-Smokers

BACKGROUND

Cigarette smoking can adversely affect the results of many periodontal procedures. The purpose of this study was to determine whether cigarette smoking affects wound healing of subepithelial connective tissue grafts.

METHODS

Seventeen systemically healthy patients with 22 Miller Class I or II mucogingival defects were divided into a non-smoker group or smoker group. Patients were regarded as smokers if they reported smoking 10 to 20 cigarettes per day. The following parameters were documented at the surgery date and 3 and 6 months postoperatively: recession depth (RD), recession width (RW), keratinized gingiva height measured apico-coronally (KG), relative attachment level (RAL), probing depths (PD), bleeding on probing (BOP), and the full-mouth plaque score (FMP). Salivary cotinine samples were taken at the surgery to confirm the smoking history and to quantify cigarette use.

RESULTS

Non-smokers (0- to 10-ng/ml cotinine level) healed with statistically more recession coverage than the smokers (>10-ng/ml cotinine level) (98.3% versus 82.3%, respectively; P=0.001). Six months postoperatively, the non-smokers healed with a 0.2-mm mean recession depth compared to a 1.0-mm mean recession depth for the smokers. This difference in recession depth was statistically significant (P=0.014).

CONCLUSIONS

Root coverage with connective tissue grafts appears to be negatively associated with cigarette smoking. Smokers should consider smoking cessation or reducing the use of cigarettes for optimal results with connective tissue grafts.

The effect of smoking on periodontal treatment response: a review of clinical evidence

BACKGROUND

Smoking has been identified as a significant risk factor for periodontal diseases and is regarded as being responsible for incomplete or delayed healing in patients following treatment.

AIM AND METHOD

The aim of this conventional review was to review, collate and tabulate the relative effectiveness of treatments of chronic periodontitis in smokers, non-smokers and ex-smokers.

OBSERVATIONS

The majority of clinical trials show significantly greater reductions in probing depths and bleeding on probing, and significantly greater gain of clinical attachment following non-surgical and surgical treatments in non-smokers compared with smokers. This benefit is also seen at class I and II furcation sites and in patients prescribed systemic or local antimicrobial treatments.

CONCLUSIONS

Data from epidemiological, cross-sectional and case-control studies strongly suggest that quitting smoking is beneficial to patients following periodontal treatments. The periodontal status of ex-smokers following treatment suggests that quitting the habit is beneficial although there are only limited data from long-term longitudinal clinical trials to demonstrate unequivocally the periodontal benefit of quitting smoking.

Smoking, periodontal disease and the role of the dental profession

Epidemiological investigations support a firm relationship between smoking and periodontal disease. The likely benefits of smoking cessation programmes are considerable for periodontal disease, cancers and nearly all chronic systemic diseases. The mechanisms by which smoking may influence the development and progression of periodontal disease are as yet unclear, but may include changes in the vasculature, the immune and inflammatory systems, tissue oxygenation and the healing processes. Unfortunately, although dental professionals have more opportunities to encourage smokers to quit (most people visit their dentist more frequently than their doctor), dentists claim that they are not well informed on this subject. The purpose of this review is to describe the evidence for a link between smoking and periodontal disease, the possible pathology induced by smoking on the periodontal tissues and its impact on therapy, and to outline the smoking cessation techniques that are currently available.

The effect of quitting smoking on chronic periodontitis

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate longitudinally the effect of smoking cessation on clinical and radiographic outcomes following non-surgical treatment in smokers with chronic periodontitis.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Forty-nine smokers with chronic periodontitis who wished to quit smoking were recruited. Full-mouth probing depths, bleeding and plaque data were recorded at baseline, 3, 6 and 12 months. Clinical attachment levels were recorded at target sites and subtraction radiography was used to assess bone density changes. Patients received non-surgical periodontal therapy during the first 3 months and supportive periodontal care over the remainder of the study. Smoking cessation counselling was provided according to individual need.

RESULTS

After 12 months, of patients with complete data, 10 had continuously quit smoking (20% of the original population), 10 continued smoking and six were oscillators (those patients who quit and then relapsed). There were no differences between the groups following treatment with respect to mean clinical or radiographic parameters. Analysis of probing depth reductions between baseline and month 12, however, and comparing quitters with the other two groups combined, demonstrated a significant difference in favour of quitters (p<0.05). Furthermore, quitters were significantly more likely to demonstrate probing depth reductions > or =2 and > or =3 mm than non-quitters and oscillators (p<0.05).

CONCLUSION

Quitting smoking has an additional beneficial effect in reducing probing depths following non-surgical treatment over a 12-month period.

Evaluation of Demineralized Bone Matrix Paste and Putty in Periodontal Intraosseous Defects

BACKGROUND

Demineralized bone matrix (DBX) paste and putty are particulate demineralized bone matrices in a 2% or 4% hyaluronate carrier, respectively. The purpose of this study was to determine the effectiveness of DBX paste and putty compared to demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft (DFDBA) in the treatment of human intraosseous periodontal defects.

METHODS

Sixty systemically healthy individuals between the ages of 31 and 71 years with at least one intraosseous periodontal defect of > or = 3 mm in depth and radiographic evidence of at least 40% to 50% vertical bone loss were accrued. Following initial non-surgical periodontal therapy, sites were randomly selected to receive either DBX paste, DBX putty, or DFDBA (control). Baseline and 6-month reentry soft and hard tissue parameter measurements were made by calibrated examiners. Data were analyzed within and between groups utilizing analysis of variance (ANOVA) and paired and unpaired Student t tests.

RESULTS

Probing depth reductions were significantly improved in all treatment groups with DFDBA, DBX paste, and putty patients demonstrating 2.8 mm, 3.6 mm, and 2.3 mm, respectively. Attachment level gains were significantly improved from baseline for all treatment groups with DFDBA, DBX paste, and putty, respectively, demonstrating 2.4 mm, 2.9 mm, and 1.6 mm. Bone fill was similar between all groups with DBX paste, putty, and DFDBA control groups demonstrating 2.0 mm, 2.4 mm, and 2.2 mm, respectively. All groups yielded significant improvements in percent bone fill with DFDBA, DBX paste and putty, respectively, achieving 37%, 42.1%, and 50% with no significant differences between the groups.

CONCLUSION

In summary, demineralized bone matrix paste, demineralized bone matrix putty, and demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft all demonstrated similar favorable improvements in soft and hard tissue parameters in the treatment of human intraosseous defects.

Clinical evaluation of a composite bone graft with a calcium sulfate barrier

BACKGROUND

The goal of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of a composite bone graft (demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft, calcium sulfate, tetracycline, and porous hydroxyapatite) and calcium sulfate barrier to treat non-furcation osseous defects.

METHODS

One hundred patients were treated with the technique. The preoperative measurements were compared to the postoperative measurements (mean 5.2 months) to determine whether the technique had a statistically significant effect. Various factors were evaluated to determine whether they could be related to improved or diminished results.

RESULTS

The surgical procedure produced a statistically significant change in the clinical measurements. The mean recession increased from 0.8 to 1.8 mm; the mean probing depth decreased from 8.5 to 3.8 mm; and the attachment level improved from 9.3 to 5.5 mm. Non-smokers, defects in the mandibular arch, defects with deeper probing depths, or defects with greater attachment loss had statistically significant changes in one or more of the clinical parameters evaluated.

CONCLUSION

The technique examined in this study (composite bone graft + calcium sulfate barrier) was an effective method to improve the clinical measurements.

The efficacy of bone replacement grafts in the treatment of periodontal osseous defects. A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Bone replacement grafts (BRG) are widely used in the treatment of periodontal osseous defects; however, the clinical benefits of this therapeutic practice require further clarification through a systematic review of randomized controlled studies.

RATIONALE

The purpose of this systematic review is to access the efficacy of bone replacement grafts in proving demonstrable clinical improvements in periodontal osseous defects compared to surgical debridement alone.

FOCUSED QUESTION

What is the effect of bone replacement grafts compared to other interventions on clinical, radiographic, adverse, and patient-centered outcomes in patients with periodontal osseous defects?

SEARCH PROTOCOL

The computerized bibliographical databases MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched from 1966 and 1974, respectively, to October 2002 for randomized controlled studies in which bone replacement grafts were compared to other surgical interventions in the treatment of periodontal osseous defects. The search strategy included screening of review articles and reference lists of retrieved articles as well as hand searches of selected journals.

INCLUSION CRITERIA

All searches were limited to human studies in English language publications.

EXCLUSION CRITERIA

Non-randomized observational studies (e.g., case reports, case series), publications providing summary statistics without variance estimates or data to permit computation, and studies without BRG intervention alone were excluded.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

The therapeutic endpoints examined included changes in bone level, clinical attachment level, probing depth, gingival recession, and crestal resorption. For purposes of meta-analysis, change in bone level (bone fill) was used as the primary outcome measure, measured upon surgical re-entry or transgingival probing (sounding).

MAIN RESULTS

1. Forty-nine controlled studies met eligibility criteria and provided clinical outcome data on intrabony defects following grafting procedures. 2. Seventeen studies provided clinical outcome data on BRG materials for the treatment of furcation defects.

REVIEWERS' CONCLUSIONS

1. With respect to the treatment of intrabony defects, the results of meta-analysis supported the following conclusions: 1) bone grafts increase bone level, reduce crestal bone loss, increase clinical attachment level, and reduce probing depth compared to open flap debridement (OFD) procedures; 2) No differences in clinical outcome measures emerge between particulate bone allograft and calcium phosphate (hydroxyapatite) ceramic grafts; and 3) bone grafts in combination with barrier membranes increase clinical attachment level and reduce probing depth compared to graft alone. 2. With respect to the treatment of furcation defects, 15 controlled studies provided data on clinical outcomes. Insufficient studies of comparable design were available to submit data to meta-analysis. Nonetheless, outcome data from these studies generally indicated positive clinical benefits with the use of grafts in the treatment of Class II furcations. 3. With respect to histological outcome parameters, 2 randomized controlled studies provide evidence that demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft (DFDBA) supports the formation of a new attachment apparatus in intrabony defects, whereas OFD results in periodontal repair characterized primarily by the formation of a long junctional epithelial attachment. Multiple observational studies provide consistent histological evidence that autogenous and demineralized allogeneic bone grafts support the formation of new attachment. Limited data also suggest that xenogenic bone grafts can support the formation of a new attachment apparatus. In contrast, essentially all available data indicate that alloplastic grafts support periodontal repair rather than regeneration. 4. The results of this systematic review indicate that bone replacement grafts provide demonstrable clinical improvements in periodontal osseous defects compared to surgical debridement alone.

Cigarette Smoking and the Periodontal Patient

Evidence from cross-sectional and case-control studies in various populations demonstrates that adult smokers are approximately three times as likely as non-smokers to have periodontitis. The association between smoking and attachment loss is even stronger when the definition of periodontitis is restricted to the most severely affected subjects. Smokers have a diminished response to periodontal therapy and show approximately half as much improvement in probing depths and clinical attachment levels following non-surgical and various surgical modalities of therapy. Implant failures in smokers are twice those of non-smokers, with a higher failure rate in the maxillary arch accounting for the majority of the difference. Tobacco-induced alterations in microbial and host factors contribute to these deleterious effects of smoking on the periodontium. In longitudinal studies, the rate of periodontal disease progression is increased in smokers, but decreases to that of a non-smoker following tobacco cessation. Likewise, recent non-smokers respond to periodontal therapy in a manner similar to patients who have never smoked. Data regarding the impact of smoking on periodontal status included in this review will be helpful to dental health professionals as they counsel their patients regarding tobacco use. The role of dental health professionals in tobacco cessation is discussed, including the use of the five A's: ask--identify tobacco users; advise--advise them to quit; assess--evaluate the patient's readiness to quit; assist--offer assistance in cessation; and arrange--follow up on the patient's cessation efforts. The addition of pharmacotherapy to behavioral therapy, including nicotine replacement therapy and bupropion, can increase cessation rates. The most popular form of nicotine replacement therapy is the patch, and its use has been shown to double cessation rates compared to behavioral therapy alone. Use of bupropion in combination with nicotine replacement therapy may be particularly helpful for heavy smokers or smokers who have experienced multiple failed attempts at cessation. The American Academy of Periodontology Parameters of Care include tobacco cessation as a part of periodontal therapy, and the 2000 Surgeon General's Report on Oral Health in America encourages dental professionals to become more active in tobacco cessation counseling. Doing so will have far-reaching positive effects on our patients' oral and general health.

Effect of Tobacco Smoking on Neutrophil Activity Following Periodontal Surgery

BACKGROUND

Tobacco smoking has considerable negative effects on the outcome of periodontal treatment. The reason for the inferior therapeutical effect might be related to an altered neutrophil activity in terms of elastase and/or matrix metalloproteinase-8 (MMP-8), as well as in the protease inhibitor alpha-1-antitrypsin (alpha-AT) and alpha-2-macroglobulin (alpha-2-MG) activities. The aim of the present study, therefore, was to elucidate the effect of tobacco smoking on gingival crevicular fluid (GCF) levels of these substances following surgical treatment.

METHODS

The study population included 15 smoking and 15 non-smoking patients with moderate to severe periodontitis receiving surgical treatment. Clinical examinations and collection of GCF were done prior to surgery and 1 and 5 weeks following treatment. The elastase activity was measured with a chromogenic low-molecular substrate and the levels of alpha-1-AT, alpha-2-MG, and MMP-8 with enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.

RESULTS

The results showed unaltered levels of alpha-1-AT, alpha-2-MG, and MMP-8 in smokers following surgery. In non-smokers, the levels of alpha-1-AT and alpha-2-MG increased, whereas MMP-8 levels decreased. The levels of elastase remained unaltered in both smokers and non-smokers.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that in the presence of smoking, the levels of alpha-1-AT, alpha-2-MG, and MMP-8 remained unaltered during the recovery period following surgical treatment. This is interpreted as a possible interference of smoking with the treatment response and may, in part, explain the clinical evidence of an inferior treatment outcome in smokers.

Factors Influencing the Outcome of Regenerative Therapy in Mandibular Class II Furcations: Part I

BACKGROUND

Factors influencing the outcome of regenerative therapy of Class II furcations are incompletely and poorly understood. The purpose of this 24-month prospective study was to examine the relationship of patient-, site-, and treatment-related factors to the clinical closure of randomly selected mandibular Class II furcations. Results of therapy were evaluated at 1 and 2 years postoperatively. One-year outcome data are presented in this report.

METHODS

A total of 43 otherwise healthy individuals with chronic periodontitis (26 male, 17 female), 36 to 70 years of age, completed the 12-month evaluation of the study. Entry criteria included clinical and radiographic evidence of two or more mandibular facial Class II furcation defects (> or = 3 mm horizontal probing depth). Surgical therapy was completed by four periodontists (two each) in either a university clinic or private practice. Each patient contributed two furcation defects that were treated by combination therapy using an expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) membrane and demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft (DFDBA). Clinical measurements included a gingival index, plaque index, mobility, and, referencing an occlusal stent, probing depth (PD), probing attachment level-vertical (PAL-V), and probing attachment level-horizontal (PAL-H). Multiple linear measurements were recorded for each site clinically and after surgical debridement to characterize defect morphology, root configuration, and barrier placement. Defect volume was computed mathematically. Postsurgical maintenance care was provided at 1 to 2, 4, 6, and 8 weeks, and then biweekly until 3 months, with subsequent supportive periodontal maintenance visits at 3-month intervals. The clinical status of the furcation (open or closed), measured by a non-treating periodontist at 1 and 2 years, was the primary outcome measure. The association of patient-related factors (e.g., smoking), site-related factors (e.g., root configuration and defect morphology), and treatment-related factors (e.g., membrane exposure) to clinical status of furcations was assessed using random effects hierarchical logistic regression analysis, controlling for design and demographic variables. Non-parametric analysis was used for specific group comparisons.

RESULTS

Complete clinical closure was achieved in 74% of all sites. Of the residual furcation defects, 68% were reduced to Class I. No defects progressed to Class III. Significant improvements in mean PD and PAL-V were obtained following surgical therapy. Although the proportion of sites demonstrating complete furcation closure was comparable for smokers and non-smokers, the proportion of Class II residual defects was significantly higher among smokers than non-smokers (62.5% versus 14.3%, respectively). Increases in presurgical PAL-H were associated with monotonic decreases in the percentage of sites demonstrating complete clinical closure, with only 53% of lesions > or = 5 mm responding with complete closure. Similarly, significant reductions in the frequency of clinical closure were associated with increases in the distance between the roof of furcation and crest of bone, roof of furcation and base of defect, depth of horizontal defect, and divergence of roots at the crest of bone.

CONCLUSIONS

The successful clinical closure of Class II furcations was achievable at 1 year following combination therapy with an ePTFE membrane and DFDBA. The highest frequency of clinical furcation closure was observed in early Class II defects. Furcations with vertical or horizontal bone loss of 5 mm or greater responded with the lowest frequency of complete clinical closure. Nevertheless, complete furcation closure was achievable in 50% of molars with extensive bone loss. Also, 15 out of 22 (68%) of all residual defects were reduced to Class I and only seven (8%) failed to improve, demonstrating that successful clinical resolution of advanced defects remains an attainable goal.

Guided tissue regeneration in human Class II furcation defects using a diphenylphosphorylazide-cross-linked collagen membrane: a consecutive case series

BACKGROUND

Several bioabsorbable collagen membranes are either currently available or under investigation for use in guided tissue regeneration (GTR) procedures. The aim of this 12-month reentry study was to evaluate a diphenylphosphorylazide (DPPA)-cross-linked bovine type I collagen membrane in the healing of mandibular Class II furcation defects. The DPPA technique prevents the inclusion of foreign cytotoxic cross-linking substances in the reticulated molecules, thus providing a more biocompatible product.

METHODS

Forty non-smoking periodontally compromised adult subjects volunteered for this study, and one defect was randomly selected in each patient. At baseline, plaque index (PI), gingival index (GI), probing depth (PD), gingival margin location (GML), clinical attachment level (CAL), and width of the attached gingiva (AG) were measured. Intrasurgical hard tissue measurements consisted of the vertical open probing attachment level (V-OPAL) and horizontal open probing attachment level (H-OPAL), as well as furcation entrance width (FW) and height (FH) and subclassification of defects according to vertical bone loss. All soft tissue measurements were repeated 12 months after membrane placement using conservative flap reentry surgeries; hard tissue parameters were also assessed at this time.

RESULTS

DPPA-cross-linked collagen membranes demonstrated good handling characteristics, and no postoperative adverse tissue reactions or clinically detectable localized allergic responses were observed. GI and PI remained low during the entire study period. When the one year reentry values were compared to the baseline measurements, a significant reduction in PD (1.9 +/- 1.4), FW (2.1 +/- 1.7), FH (2.9 +/- 1.6), and gain in CAL (1.7 +/- 1.5), V-OPAL (2.1 +/- 1.9), and H-OPAL (4.7 +/- 1.4) were observed (P < or = 0.05). However, there were no significant differences in GML or AG. Hard tissue improvements resulted in the complete closure of 30% (12) of the defects, and transformation of 67.5% (27) of the defects to Class I, while one defect remained a Class II (2.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

Based on this 12-month clinical reentry study, a DPPA-cross-linked collagen membrane could be beneficial in GTR treatment of Class II mandibular furcation involvements, both in terms of soft and hard tissue improvements.

Guided tissue regeneration using a polylactic acid barrier

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to determine the relative impact of various predictors responsible for the variability in treatment outcome after guided tissue regeneration (GTR) in intraosseous periodontal defects.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

30 patients with chronic periodontitis and at least one intraosseous periodontal lesion (> or =4 mm) were enrolled. Following full-mouth scaling, GTR using polylactic acid membranes was performed at one site in each patient. Main periodontal pathogens, defect morphology, membrane exposure and smoking habit were assessed as predictor variables. Alveolar bone level change served as the primary outcome variable in a multiple regression analysis.

RESULTS

After 12 months, the 29 patients completing the study showed alveolar bone changes ranging from 4 mm bone gain to 1 mm bone loss (mean: 1.6+/-0.4 mm gain). Active smoking (beta-weight:-0.49, P=0.003) and persistence of subgingival infection with P. gingivalis (P.g.) (beta-weight:-0.25, P=0.11) were associated with poor treatment outcome. Deep initial intraosseous defects (beta-weight: 0.32, P=0.045) were associated with favorable treatment outcome, and membrane exposure had no impact on bone gain.

CONCLUSION

Active smoking was the strongest predictor variable negatively affecting alveolar bone gain following GTR in the treatment of periodontal defects. It was followed by a positive influence of a deeper intraosseous defect and by a negative effect by persistent subgingival infection of P. gingivalis. The relative impact of these factors may be useful in assessing the prognosis of GTR in intraosseous periodontal defects.

Impaired healing response of periodontal furcation defects following flap debridement surgery in smokers. A controlled clinical trial

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of the present parallel-design, controlled clinical trial was to evaluate the treatment outcome of periodontal furcation defects following flap debridement surgery (FDS) procedure in cigarette smokers compared to non-smokers.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

After initial therapy, 31 systemically healthy subjects with moderate to advanced periodontitis, who presented at least one Class I or II molar furcation defect, were selected. Nineteen patients (mean age: 40.3 years, 15 males) were smokers (>or=10 cigarettes/day) and 12 patients (mean age: 44.8 years, 3 males) were non-smokers. Full-mouth plaque score (FMPS) and full-mouth bleeding score (FMBS), probing pocket depth (PPD), vertical clinical attachment level (v-CAL), and horizontal clinical attachment level (h-CAL) were assessed immediately before and 6 months following surgery.

RESULTS

Overall, statistically significant v-CAL gain was observed in smokers (1.0 +/- 1.3 mm) and non-smokers (1.3+/-1.1 mm), the difference between groups being statistically significant (p=0.0003). In proximal furcation defects, v-CAL gain amounted to 2.3+/-0.7 mm in non-smokers as compared to 1.0+/-1.1 mm in smokers (p=0.0013). At 6 months postsurgery, non-smokers presented a greater h-CAL gain (1.3+/-1.1 mm) than smokers (0.6+/-1.0 mm), with a statistically significant difference between groups (p=0.0089). This trend was confirmed in both facial/lingual (1.4+/-1.0 versus 0.8+/-0.8 mm) and proximal furcation defects (1.2+/-1.3 versus 0.5+/-1.2 mm). The proportion of Class II furcations showing improvement to postsurgery Class I was 27.6% in smokers and 38.5% in non-smokers. After 6 months, 3.4% of presurgery Class I furcation defects in smokers showed complete closure, as compared to 27.8% in non-smokers.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the present study indicated that (1) FDS produced clinically and statistically significant PPD reduction, v-CAL gain, and h-CAL gain in Class I/II molar furcation defects, and (2) cigarette smokers exhibited a less favorable healing outcome following surgery in terms of both v-CAL and h-CAL gain.

A retrospective case series comparing the use of demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft and freeze-dried bone allograft combined with enamel matrix derivative for the treatment of advanced osseous lesions

BACKGROUND

Combined regenerative approaches have been used for treating advanced osseous lesions around teeth. The aim of combining treatments is to enhance both clinical predictability and regenerative outcome compared to a monotherapeutic approach. This case series from a private practice reports on the clinical efficacy of an enamel matrix derivative (EMD) combined with either demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft (DFDBA) or freeze-dried bone allograft (FDBA) in the treatment of advanced infrabony lesions. The advanced lesions were veneered by a rapidly formed absorbable polymer barrier of poly(DL-lactide) to enhance graft containment.

METHODS

A total of 22 consecutive patients, each contributing one infrabony lesion, are reported. After patients completed presurgical preparation, the infrabony lesions were surgically treated with a combined approach that included root surface treatment with citric acid. The two groups differed in their composite graft; one received DFDBA-EMD (n = 10) and the other received FDBA-EMD (n = 12). Patients followed a stringent postoperative protocol and were evaluated 6 months postsurgery. Clinical outcomes were assessed by changes in clinical attachment level (CAL) and probing depth (PD) from pretreatment. Surgical re-entry of several sites was possible in each group.

RESULTS

CAL at pretreatment measured 9.2 +/- 1.3 mm and 9.1 +/- 1.9 mm for DFDBA-EMD and FDBA-EMD groups, respectively, with corresponding PD of 8.4 +/- 1.6 mm and 8.9 +/- 2.0 mm for each group. At 6 months post-treatment, CALs were reduced to 4.7 +/- 1.3 mm and 3.8 +/- 1.0 mm for DFDBA-EMD and FDBA-EMD groups, respectively; with corresponding PD decreased to 3.0 +/- 0.8 mm and 3.2 +/- 1.0 mm. Relative improvements in CAL for the DFDBA-EMD and DFDBA-EMD groups were 49.1% +/- 11.0% and 57.3% +/- 9.4%, respectively (P <0.07).

CONCLUSIONS

This case series demonstrates the clinical benefits of using a combined therapeutic approach in which a biologic mediator (EMD) was combined with either DFDBA or FDBA. In this limited case series, a trend was observed towards greater improvement in clinical attachment level gain in advanced infrabony defects when EMD was combined with FDBA as compared to DFDBA. Larger prospective controlled clinical trials are needed to determine if differences exist in the relative efficacy of DFDBA versus FDBA in combination with EMD.

Effect of cigarette smoking on human PDL fibroblasts attachment to periodontally involved root surfaces in vitro

BACKGROUND/AIM

Cigarette smoking is one of the most significant risk factors in the development and further advancement of inflammatory periodontal disease. However, no study has been performed to investigate the effect of smoking on the attachment of human periodontal ligament fibroblasts to either periodontally diseased or healthy roots. The present study was conducted to evaluate the attachment of fibroblasts derived from healthy human periodontal ligament (PDL) to periodontally diseased root surfaces of smokers.

METHOD

The subjects included 14 smokers and seven nonsmokers with at least a single periodontally involved anterior tooth planned for extraction. In addition, seven impacted third molars, which had been removed from nonsmoking adolescents, were used as a healthy control. The smoking status of each patient was determined by classifying the volunteers into four groups according to their level of cigarette consumption at the initial examination (seven patients each). Nonsmoking subjects who had never smoked cigarettes and had healthy periodontium were called healthy control (G1). In subjects with periodontal diseases, nonsmoking subjects who had never regularly smoked cigarettes (< 2 cigarettes/week) were called positive control (G2), smokers consuming <or=19 cigarettes/day were placed in group G3, and smokers consuming >or=20 cigarettes/day were located in group G4. To exclude the effects of all local irritants except for the adsorbed tobacco products, all teeth were subjected to thorough scaling and root planing 1 week before extraction. After 1 week of meticulous home care and continued smoking experience, teeth were extracted and the periodontally involved test areas were prepared for PDL culturing. PDL cells were cultured on root segments for 24 h. Samples were prepared for SEM viewing, photographing and counting at x750 in a standard area.

RESULTS

The results of this study indicated that smokers' data (G3, G4) revealed a significant reduction of attached PDL cells when compared to that of nonsmokers' healthy and positive controls (G1, G2). No significant difference in the mean number of attached cells was found between data derived from smokers' groups (G3 vs. G4). The attached cells in all groups varied in shape; they were flatter in the control groups, while they were round in smokers' groups, with no dose-dependent effect.

CONCLUSION

The present results suggest that cigarette smoking compromises PDL cell adhesion to root planed surfaces, which might affect periodontal regeneration following therapy.

Supracrestal soft tissue preservation with enamel matrix proteins in treatment of deep intrabony defects

BACKGROUND/AIMS

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the effectiveness of a regenerative procedure based on supracrestal soft tissue preservation in association with enamel matrix proteins (EMP) in the treatment of deep intrabony defects.

METHODS

The subjects included 35 consecutively treated patients, 23 females and 12 males, aged 28-61 years, 11 of whom were smokers. Patients presented with at least one intrabony defect with probing pocket depth > or = 6 mm and a radiographic depth of the defect > or = 4 mm at the initial visit. Immediately before surgery and 9-12 months after surgery, Local Plaque Score (LPS), Local Bleeding Score (LBS), probing pocket depth (PPD), clinical attachment level (CAL), gingival recession (REC), and radiographic depth of the defect (DEPTH) were recorded.

RESULTS

Thirty-one (88.6%) defects were LPS-negative presurgery, while 29 (82.9%) defects presented with no plaque postsurgery. The prevalence of LBS-positive defects shifted from 94.3% presurgery to 8.4% postsurgery (p < 0.0000). PPD was 8.9 mm before surgery, and decreased to 3.5 mm postsurgery (p < 0.0000). CAL varied from 10.1 mm presurgery to 5.4 mm postsurgery (p < 0.0000), with an average improvement (gain) of 4.7 +/- 1.7 mm. Twenty-six (74.3%) defects presented a gain of least 4 mm. Regression analysis showed a positive correlation between CAL gain as a dependent variable, and presurgery PPD and amount of supracrestal soft tissues as predictors. DEPTH improvement (gain) was 3.9 +/- 1.8 mm, which represented 65% of defect fill. Twenty (57.1%) defects presented a DEPTH gain of at least 4 mm. DEPTH gain was significantly correlated to presurgery PPD (p < 0.000). No significant differences were found between smokers and non-smokers in terms of CAL and DEPTH gain.

CONCLUSIONS

Results from the present study indicated that the regenerative procedure based on supracrestal soft tissue preservation and EMP application leads to clinically and statistically significant improvement of hard and soft tissue conditions of deep intrabony defects.

Treatment of plaque-induced gingivitis, chronic periodontitis, and other clinical conditions

The inflammatory components of plaque induced gingivitis and chronic periodontitis can be managed effectively for the majority of patients with a plaque control program and non-surgical and/or surgical root debridement coupled with continued periodontal maintenance procedures. Some patients may need additional therapeutic procedures. All of the therapeutic modalities reviewed in this position paper may be utilized by the clinician at various times over the long-term management of the patient's periodontal condition.

Effect of nicotine on fibroblast beta 1 integrin expression and distribution in vitro

BACKGROUND

Integrins are a family of transmembrane cell surface glycoproteins, and those with the beta 1-subunit function in both cell-to-cell and cell-to-substrate adhesion. The purpose of this study was to determine nicotine's effect on the expression and distribution of the beta 1 integrin subunit on the human gingival fibroblast cell surface.

METHODS

Pure nicotine was diluted in medium to the following concentrations: 0 (control), 0.025, 0.05, 0.1, 0.2, and 0.4 microM. Human gingival fibroblasts (HFG) were grown for 24 hours in each concentration and fluorescein-labeled with a mouse monoclonal anti-human beta 1 antibody and secondarily incubated with a urease-labeled anti-mouse IgG antibody. After a final wash, the cells were incubated with urea/bromcresol blue substrate for 15 minutes at 37 degrees C and measured in a microplate reader at 570 nm.

RESULTS

The integrin beta 1-subunit was detected on the HGF surface membrane by fluorescence labeling, and cell-enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay testing demonstrated its decreased expression with increasing nicotine concentrations that were statistically different at the concentrations of 0.2 and 0.4 microM versus controls (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Nicotine concentrations of 0.2 and 0.4 microM significantly decrease beta 1 integrin expression in human gingival fibroblasts that may affect cell-cell and cell-substratum adhesion during wound healing.

Smoking and periodontal disease

Numerous investigations of the relationship between smoking and periodontal disease have been performed over the last 15 years, and there now exists a substantial body of literature upon which this current review is based. From both cross-sectional and longitudinal studies, there appears to be strong epidemiological evidence that smoking confers a considerably increased risk of periodontal disease. This evidence is further supported by the data emanating from patients who stop smoking. These patients have levels of risk similar to those of non-smokers. Numerous studies of the potential mechanisms whereby smoking tobacco may predispose to periodontal disease have been conducted, and it appears that smoking may affect the vasculature, the humoral immune system, and the cellular immune and inflammatory systems, and have effects throughout the cytokine and adhesion molecule network. The aim of this review is to consider the evidence for the association between smoking and periodontal diseases and to highlight the biological mechanisms whereby smoking may affect the periodontium.

Cigarette smoking negatively affects healing response following flap debridement surgery

BACKGROUND

The purpose of the present parallel design, controlled clinical trial was to evaluate the treatment outcome following flap debridement surgery (FDS) in cigarette smokers compared to non-smokers.

METHODS

After initial therapy, 57 systemically healthy subjects with moderate to advanced periodontitis who presented with one area (at least 3 teeth) where surgery was required were selected. Twenty-eight patients (mean age: 39.6 years, 20 males) were smokers (> or = 10 cigarettes/day); 29 patients (mean age: 43.9 years, 7 males) were non-smokers. Full-mouth plaque (FMP) and bleeding on probing (BOP) scores, probing depth (PD), clinical attachment level (CAL), and recession depth (RD) were assessed immediately before and 6 months following surgery. Only sites with presurgery PD > or = 4 mm were used for statistical analysis.

RESULTS

Presurgery FMP and BOP were similar in smokers and non-smokers and significantly decreased postsurgery in both groups. Overall, PD reduction and CAL gain were greater, although not significantly, in non-smokers (2.4 +/- 0.9 mm and 1.6 +/- 0.7 mm, respectively) than in smokers (1.9 +/- 0.7 mm and 1.2 +/- 0.7 mm, respectively). For moderate sites (PD 4 to 6 mm), no significant differences in PD and CAL changes were found between groups. For deep sites (PD > or = 7 mm), PD reduction was 3.0 +/- 1.0 mm in smokers and 4.0 +/- 0.8 mm in non-smokers, and CAL gain amounted to 1.8 +/- 1.1 mm in smokers and 2.8 +/- 1.0 mm in non-smokers (P = 0.0477). In smokers, 16% of deep sites healed to postsurgery PD values < or = 3 mm as compared to 47% in non-smokers (P = 0.0000); 58% of deep sites in smokers showed a CAL gain > or = 2 mm, as compared to 82% in non-smokers (P = 0.0000).

CONCLUSIONS

Results of the study indicated that: 1) FDS determined a statistically significant PD reduction and CAL gain in patients with moderate to advanced periodontitis; 2) smokers exhibited a trend towards less favorable healing response following FDS compared to non-smokers, both in terms of PD reduction and CAL gain; and 3) this trend reached clinical and statistical significance at sites with initial deep PD.

Oxygen sufficiency in the gingiva of smokers and non-smokers with periodontal disease

BACKGROUND

Epidemiological studies have demonstrated deteriorating effects of smoking on periodontal tissue. The aims of this study were to compare oxygen saturation of hemoglobin in the gingiva (GSo2) of smokers and non-smokers and to evaluate the chronic effect of smoking on gingival oxygen sufficiency.

METHODS

GSo2 was determined using tissue reflectance spectrophotometry in 110 papillary gingival sites of 62 smokers and 100 sites of 60 non-smokers.

RESULTS

No significant difference was found in GSo2 between smokers and non-smokers. In the model of ANOVA with covariates, age (P= 0.0048) and probing depth (P= 0.0012) had significant effects on GSo2. No significant effect was found in either smoking status (P= 0.3557) or the modified gingival index (MGI) (P= 0.3824). The interaction effect between smoking status and the MGI was highly significant (P = 0.0003) indicating that the effect of smoking status on the GSo2 should be compared at each level of the MGI score. GSo2 in healthy gingiva was significantly lower in smokers than non-smokers (P = 0.0014), while smokers showed higher GSo2 than non-smokers in moderately inflamed gingiva (P = 0.0356). The GSo2 in inflamed gingiva was significantly decreased compared with healthy gingiva in non-smokers (P = 0.0044), while smokers showed no significant difference between healthy and inflamed gingiva (P= 0.2772 to 0.8665). GSo2 in smokers was consistently and significantly lower than that of healthy gingiva of non-smokers (P = 0.0391 to 0.0004).

CONCLUSIONS

Smokers exhibit possibly lower function of oxygen sufficiency in healthy gingiva and reduced ability to adapt the function in inflamed gingiva than non-smokers. This suggests that smokers have functional impairments in the gingival microcirculation.

Effects of smoking on periodontal health: a review

Cigarette smoking is a risk factor for several diseases, and recent evidence strongly suggests an adverse effect on periodontal health. Nevertheless, the nature of the relationship between smoking and periodontal disease is not clear. Smoking causes defects in neutrophil function, impairs inflammatory and immune responses to periodontal pathogens, and exerts both systemic and local effects. Smoking is associated with an increased rate of periodontal disease in terms of alveolar bone loss and attachment loss, as well as pocket formation. Nicotine, the major component of cigarette smoke, may weaken host defenses to the bacterial invasion induced by plaque.

Position paper: tobacco use and the periodontal patient. Research, Science and Therapy Committee of the American Academy of Periodontology

This paper was prepared by the Research, Science and Therapy Committee of The American Academy of Periodontology and is intended for the information of the dental profession. The purpose of the paper is to provide the reader with a general overview of the relationship of tobacco use and periodontal diseases. This paper will review the epidemiological and clinical findings that have led to our understanding of the role of tobacco use in relation to periodontal diseases and their treatment. In addition, this paper will review the possible underlying mechanisms for these effects from tobacco use. The practitioner can use this information in treatment decisions and in giving advice to the patients who use tobacco products.

Long-term stability of the mucogingival complex following guided tissue regeneration in gingival recession defects

The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the stability of soft tissue conditions in gingival recession defects treated with guided tissue regeneration (GTR). The study population was selected among those patients who had been treated with GTR procedures for Miller's class I or II, deep (> or =3 mm), buccal gingival recession defects. Defects were included only when they had revealed recession depth reduction > or =2 mm and root coverage > or =60% at 6 months following GTR treatment. These defects were regarded as successfully treated and scheduled for further monitoring. 20 patients, 11 male and 9 female, aged 23 to 57 years (mean age: 33.2 years), each contributing 1 defect, were selected. 9 patients were smokers (> or =10 cigarette per day). Recession depth (RD), probing depth (PD), clinical attachment level (CAL), and width of keratinized gingiva (KG) were assessed immediately before surgery, at 6 months post-surgery (baseline examination), and at 4 years post-surgery (4-year examination). At baseline examination, RD reduction was 3.6+/-0.9 mm (mean root coverage: 80%). CAL gain amounted to 4.2+/-1.3 mm, 60% of the defects showing CAL gain > or =4 mm. KG increased from 1.9+/-1.2 mm at presurgery examination to 3.1+/-0.9 mm at baseline examination. At 4-year examination, no significant changes from baseline RD, CAL and KG recordings were observed. Differences in baseline-4 year changes between smokers and non-smokers were not statistically significant. The results of the present study demonstrate that clinical outcome achieved following GTR procedure in gingival recession defects can be maintained over periods up to 4 years.

Clinical evaluation of bioactive glass in the treatment of periodontal osseous defects in humans

The purpose of this study was to compare the use of bioactive glass to demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft (DFDBA) in the treatment of human periodontal osseous defects. Fifteen systemically healthy patients (6 males and 9 females, aged 30 to 63) with moderate to advanced adult periodontitis were selected for the study. All patients underwent initial therapy, which included scaling and root planing, oral hygiene instruction, and an occlusal adjustment when indicated, followed by re-evaluation 4 to 6 weeks later. Paired osseous defects in each subject were randomly selected to receive grafts of bioactive glass or DFDBA. Both soft and hard tissue measurements were taken the day of surgery (baseline) and at the 6-month re-entry surgery. The clinical examiner was calibrated and blinded to the surgical procedures, while the surgeon was masked to the clinical measurements. Statistical analysis was performed by using the paired Student's t test. The results indicated that probing depths were reduced by 3.07 +/- 0.80 mm with the bioactive glass and 2.60 +/- 1.40 mm with DFDBA. Sites grafted with bioactive glass resulted in 2.27 +/- 0.88 mm attachment level gain, while sites grafted with DFDBA had a 1.93 +/- 1.33 mm gain in attachment. Bioactive glass sites displayed 0.53 +/- 0.64 mm of crestal resorption and 2.73 mm bone fill. DFDBA-grafted sites experienced 0.80 +/- 0.56 mm of crestal resorption and 2.80 mm defect fill. The use of bioactive glass resulted in 61.8% bone fill and 73.33% defect resolution. DFDBA-grafted defects showed similar results, with 62.5% bone fill and 80.87% defect resolution. Both treatments provided soft and hard tissue improvements when compared to baseline (P < or = 0.0001). No statistical difference was found when comparing bioactive glass to DFDBA; however, studies with larger sample sizes may reveal true differences between the materials. This study suggests that bioactive glass is capable of producing results in the short term (6 months) similar to that of DFDBA when used in moderate to deep intrabony periodontal defects.

Cigarette smoking and periodontal diseases: etiology and management of disease

Cigarette smoking has long been suspected to be associated with a variety of oral conditions including periodontal diseases. Experimental evidence accumulated over the last 2 decades has indicated that cigarette smoking is probably a true risk factor for periodontitis. This environmental exposure has been associated with 2- to 3-fold increases in the odds of developing clinically detectable periodontitis. Smokers have both increased prevalence and more severe extent of periodontal disease, as well as higher prevalence of tooth loss and edentulism, compared to non-smokers. The greater severity of periodontal destruction may be partly accounted for by the reported increases in the rate of periodontal disease progression. The noxious effect of smoking has been shown to be dose dependent and to be particularly marked in younger individuals; in these subjects, up to 51% of the observed risk of periodontitis was associated with smoking. Much of the literature has also indicated that smokers affected with periodontitis respond less favorably to both non-surgical, surgical, and regenerative periodontal treatments. The success rate of dental implants has also been shown to be compromised in smokers. Furthermore, longterm studies have pointed out that smoking was associated with recurrence of periodontitis during periodontal maintenance; the effect appeared to be dose dependent, with heavy smokers (> 10 cigarettes/day) presenting with higher levels of disease progression. The indication that previous smokers have lower levels of risk for periodontitis compared to current smokers is considered to be the strongest available evidence that smoking cessation will result in improved periodontal health and that smoking cessation counseling should be an integral part of periodontal therapy and prevention. So far, however, no randomized controlled clinical trial establishing the effect of smoking cessation and/or reduction on the periodontal outcomes has been reported. Given the present state of uncertainty about the periodontal benefits, but in light of the established general health gains for the patient that could be derived from a smoking cessation program, practitioners are incorporating smoking cessation counseling as an integral part of periodontal therapy. Furthermore, smoking status represents a key parameter to assess the periodontal risk of an individual subject and therefore to make evidence-based clinical decisions.

Clinical and microbiological evaluation of a bioabsorbable and a nonresorbable barrier membrane in the treatment of periodontal intraosseous lesions

Clinical and microbiological features of periodontal healing in barrier membrane-treated sites were determined in a randomized clinical trial. The study included 10 patients with advanced adult periodontitis and a minimum of one set of similar 2 to 3 wall intraosseous periodontal lesions with no furcation involvement. In each patient, one periodontal lesion was treated with a biodegradable membrane and a contralateral lesion with a nonresorbable barrier membrane. Within the preceding 3 months of regenerative therapy, all patients received full mouth osseous surgery except for the sites for regeneration, were instructed in oral hygiene, and were prescribed systemic ciprofloxacin and metronidazole (250 mg of each, TID, 8 days), starting 7 days before membrane placement. At baseline and at 6 months postsurgery, probing depth and clinical attachment level were assessed in each study site. The subgingival presence of suspected periodontal pathogens was determined by non-selective and selective culture and by DNA probe analyses, and of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) and Epstein-Barr virus type 1 (EBV-1) by a nested-polymerase chain reaction detection method. At baseline, the barrier-treated sites did not differ significantly in clinical and microbial parameters. Mean baseline probing depth was 7.8+/-1.1 mm for bioabsorbable and 7.9+/-1.3 mm for nonresorbable barrier-treated sites. At 6 months, sites treated with bioabsorbable barrier revealed 4.6+/-1.7 mm gain of clinical attachment (range: 1 to 7 mm) and sites treated with nonresorbable barrier 4.2+/-2.0 mm (range: 1 to 8 mm). The 11 barrier-treated sites that harbored 10% or less bacterial pathogens and were free of HCMV and EBV-1 averaged significantly more clinical attachment gain than the 9 sites that yielded more than 10% bacterial pathogens and/or test viruses (5.6 mm versus 3.0 mm; P=0.005). The present data suggest bioabsorbable and nonresorbable barriers provide similar clinical healing of 2 to 3 wall intraosseous periodontal lesions, emphasize the importance of controlling bacterial pathogens prior to and during periodontal healing, and point to the possible detrimental role of HCMV and EBV-1 in periodontal repair.