Metabolic Consequences of Efferocytosis and its Impact on Atherosclerosis

Huanglian Jiedu Decoction enhances the stability of atherosclerotic plaques through SLC2A1-mediated efferocytosis

BACKGROUND

Atherosclerotic (AS) plaques require a dense necrotic core and a robust fibrous cap to maintain stability. While previous studies have indicated that the traditional Chinese medicine Huang Lian Jie Du Decoction (HLJDD) possesses the capability to stabilize AS plaques, the underlying mechanisms remain obscure. This study aims to delve deeper into the potential mechanisms by which HLJDD improves AS through an integrated research strategy.

METHODS

Leveraging an AS model in ApoE-/- mice exposed to a high-fat diet (HFD), we scrutinized the therapeutic effects of HLJDD using microscopic observations, oil red O staining, HE staining and Masson staining. Employing comprehensive techniques of network pharmacology, bioinformatics, and molecular docking, we elucidated the mechanism by which HLJDD stabilizes AS plaques. In vitro experiments, utilizing ox-LDL-induced macrophages and apoptotic vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs), assessed the impact of HLJDD on efferocytosis and the role of SLC2A1.

RESULTS

In vivo experiments showcased the efficacy of HLJDD in reducing the quantity of aortic plaques, diminishing lipid deposition, and enhancing plaque stability in AS mice. Employing network pharmacology and machine learning, we pinpointed SLC2A1 as a crucial regulatory target. Molecular docking further validated the binding of HLJDD components with SLC2A1. The experiments demonstrated a dose-dependent upregulation in SLC2A1 expression by HLJDD, amplifying efferocytosis. Importantly, this effect was reversed by the SLC2A1 inhibitor STF-31, highlighting the pivotal role of SLC2A1 as a target.

CONCLUSION

The HLJDD can modulate macrophage efferocytosis by enhancing the expression levels of SLC2A1, thereby improving the stability of atherosclerotic plaques.

Targeting mitochondrial damage: shining a new light on immunotherapy

Mitochondrial damage has a particular impact on the immune system and tumor microenvironment, which can trigger cell stress, an inflammatory response, and disrupt immune cell function, thus all of which can accelerate the progression of the tumor. Therefore, it is of essence to comprehend how the immune system function and the tumor microenvironment interact with mitochondrial dysfunction for cancer treatment. Preserving the integrity of mitochondria or regulating the function of immune cells, such as macrophages, may enhance the efficacy of cancer therapy. Future research should concentrate on the interactions among mitochondria, the immune system, and the tumor microenvironment to identify new therapeutic strategies.

Mechanism of efferocytosis in atherosclerosis

Atherosclerosis (AS) is a chronic inflammatory vascular disease that occurs in the intima of large and medium-sized arteries with the immune system's involvement. It is a common pathological basis for high morbidity and mortality of cardiovascular diseases. Abnormal proliferation of apoptotic cells and necrotic cells leads to AS plaque expansion, necrotic core formation, and rupture. In the early stage of AS, macrophages exert an efferocytosis effect to engulf and degrade apoptotic, dead, damaged, or senescent cells by efferocytosis, thus enabling the regulation of the organism. In the early stage of AS, macrophages rely on this effect to slow down the process of AS. However, in the advanced stage of AS, the efferocytosis of macrophages within the plaque is impaired, which leads to the inability of macrophages to promptly remove the apoptotic cells (ACs) from the organism promptly, causing exacerbation of AS. Moreover, upregulation of CD47 expression in AS plaques also protects ACs from phagocytosis by macrophages, resulting in a large amount of residual ACs in the plaque, further expanding the necrotic core. In this review, we discussed the molecular mechanisms involved in the process of efferocytosis and how efferocytosis is impaired and regulated during AS, hoping to provide new insights for treating AS.

Macrophages in cardiovascular diseases: molecular mechanisms and therapeutic targets

The immune response holds a pivotal role in cardiovascular disease development. As multifunctional cells of the innate immune system, macrophages play an essential role in initial inflammatory response that occurs following cardiovascular injury, thereby inducing subsequent damage while also facilitating recovery. Meanwhile, the diverse phenotypes and phenotypic alterations of macrophages strongly associate with distinct types and severity of cardiovascular diseases, including coronary heart disease, valvular disease, myocarditis, cardiomyopathy, heart failure, atherosclerosis and aneurysm, which underscores the importance of investigating macrophage regulatory mechanisms within the context of specific diseases. Besides, recent strides in single-cell sequencing technologies have revealed macrophage heterogeneity, cell-cell interactions, and downstream mechanisms of therapeutic targets at a higher resolution, which brings new perspectives into macrophage-mediated mechanisms and potential therapeutic targets in cardiovascular diseases. Remarkably, myocardial fibrosis, a prevalent characteristic in most cardiac diseases, remains a formidable clinical challenge, necessitating a profound investigation into the impact of macrophages on myocardial fibrosis within the context of cardiac diseases. In this review, we systematically summarize the diverse phenotypic and functional plasticity of macrophages in regulatory mechanisms of cardiovascular diseases and unprecedented insights introduced by single-cell sequencing technologies, with a focus on different causes and characteristics of diseases, especially the relationship between inflammation and fibrosis in cardiac diseases (myocardial infarction, pressure overload, myocarditis, dilated cardiomyopathy, diabetic cardiomyopathy and cardiac aging) and the relationship between inflammation and vascular injury in vascular diseases (atherosclerosis and aneurysm). Finally, we also highlight the preclinical/clinical macrophage targeting strategies and translational implications.

Efferocytosis in dendritic cells: an overlooked immunoregulatory process

Efferocytosis, the process of engulfing and removing apoptotic cells, plays an essential role in preserving tissue health and averting undue inflammation. While macrophages are primarily known for this task, dendritic cells (DCs) also play a significant role. This review delves into the unique contributions of various DC subsets to efferocytosis, highlighting the distinctions in how DCs and macrophages recognize and handle apoptotic cells. It further explores how efferocytosis influences DC maturation, thereby affecting immune tolerance. This underscores the pivotal role of DCs in orchestrating immune responses and sustaining immune equilibrium, providing new insights into their function in immune regulation.

Dysregulated cellular metabolism in atherosclerosis: mediators and therapeutic opportunities

Accumulating evidence over the past decades has revealed an intricate relationship between dysregulation of cellular metabolism and the progression of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. However, an integrated understanding of dysregulated cellular metabolism in atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease and its potential value as a therapeutic target is missing. In this Review, we (1) summarize recent advances concerning the role of metabolic dysregulation during atherosclerosis progression in lesional cells, including endothelial cells, vascular smooth muscle cells, macrophages and T cells; (2) explore the complexity of metabolic cross-talk between these lesional cells; (3) highlight emerging technologies that promise to illuminate unknown aspects of metabolism in atherosclerosis; and (4) suggest strategies for targeting these underexplored metabolic alterations to mitigate atherosclerosis progression and stabilize rupture-prone atheromas with a potential new generation of cardiovascular therapeutics.

The Role of Macrophages in Atherosclerosis: Participants and Therapists

Currently, atherosclerosis, characterized by the dysfunction of lipid metabolism and chronic inflammation in the intimal space of the vessel, is considered to be a metabolic disease. As the most abundant innate immune cells in the body, macrophages play a key role in the onset, progression, or regression of atherosclerosis. For example, macrophages exhibit several polarization states in response to microenvironmental stimuli; an increasing proportion of macrophages, polarized toward M2, can suppress inflammation, scavenge cell debris and apoptotic cells, and contribute to tissue repair and fibrosis. Additionally, specific exosomes, generated by macrophages containing certain miRNAs and effective efferocytosis of macrophages, are crucial for atherosclerosis. Therefore, macrophages have emerged as a novel potential target for anti-atherosclerosis therapy. This article reviews the role of macrophages in atherosclerosis from different aspects: origin, phenotype, exosomes, and efferocytosis, and discusses new approaches for the treatment of atherosclerosis.

Spatially Resolved Metabolites in Stable and Unstable Human Atherosclerotic Plaques Identified by Mass Spectrometry Imaging

BACKGROUND

Impairments in carbohydrate, lipid, and amino acid metabolism drive features of plaque instability. However, where these impairments occur within the atheroma remains largely unknown. Therefore, we sought to characterize the spatial distribution of metabolites within stable and unstable atherosclerosis in both the fibrous cap and necrotic core.

METHODS

Atherosclerotic tissue specimens from 9 unmatched individuals were scored based on the Stary classification scale and subdivided into stable and unstable atheromas. After performing mass spectrometry imaging on these samples, we identified over 850 metabolite-related peaks. Using MetaboScape, METASPACE, and Human Metabolome Database, we confidently annotated 170 of these metabolites and found over 60 of these were different between stable and unstable atheromas. We then integrated these results with an RNA-sequencing data set comparing stable and unstable human atherosclerosis.

RESULTS

Upon integrating our mass spectrometry imaging results with the RNA-sequencing data set, we discovered that pathways related to lipid metabolism and long-chain fatty acids were enriched in stable plaques, whereas reactive oxygen species, aromatic amino acid, and tryptophan metabolism were increased in unstable plaques. In addition, acylcarnitines and acylglycines were increased in stable plaques whereas tryptophan metabolites were enriched in unstable plaques. Evaluating spatial differences in stable plaques revealed lactic acid in the necrotic core, whereas pyruvic acid was elevated in the fibrous cap. In unstable plaques, 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid was enriched in the fibrous cap.

CONCLUSIONS

Our work here represents the first step to defining an atlas of metabolic pathways involved in plaque destabilization in human atherosclerosis. We anticipate this will be a valuable resource and open new avenues of research in cardiovascular disease.

Phagocytosis increases an oxidative metabolic and immune suppressive signature in tumor macrophages

Phagocytosis is a key macrophage function, but how phagocytosis shapes tumor-associated macrophage (TAM) phenotypes and heterogeneity in solid tumors remains unclear. Here, we utilized both syngeneic and novel autochthonous lung tumor models in which neoplastic cells express the fluorophore tdTomato (tdTom) to identify TAMs that have phagocytosed neoplastic cells in vivo. Phagocytic tdTompos TAMs upregulated antigen presentation and anti-inflammatory proteins, but downregulated classic proinflammatory effectors compared to tdTomneg TAMs. Single-cell transcriptomic profiling identified TAM subset-specific and common gene expression changes associated with phagocytosis. We uncover a phagocytic signature that is predominated by oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS), ribosomal, and metabolic genes, and this signature correlates with worse clinical outcome in human lung cancer. Expression of OXPHOS proteins, mitochondrial content, and functional utilization of OXPHOS were increased in tdTompos TAMs. tdTompos tumor dendritic cells also display similar metabolic changes. Our identification of phagocytic TAMs as a distinct myeloid cell state links phagocytosis of neoplastic cells in vivo with OXPHOS and tumor-promoting phenotypes.

Atherosclerosis and Inflammation: Insights from the Theory of General Pathological Processes

Recent advances have greatly improved our understanding of the molecular mechanisms behind atherosclerosis pathogenesis. However, there is still a need to systematize this data from a general pathology perspective, particularly with regard to atherogenesis patterns in the context of both canonical and non-classical inflammation types. In this review, we analyze various typical phenomena and outcomes of cellular pro-inflammatory stress in atherosclerosis, as well as the role of endothelial dysfunction in local and systemic manifestations of low-grade inflammation. We also present the features of immune mechanisms in the development of productive inflammation in stable and unstable plaques, along with their similarities and differences compared to canonical inflammation. There are numerous factors that act as inducers of the inflammatory process in atherosclerosis, including vascular endothelium aging, metabolic dysfunctions, autoimmune, and in some cases, infectious damage factors. Life-critical complications of atherosclerosis, such as cardiogenic shock and severe strokes, are associated with the development of acute systemic hyperinflammation. Additionally, critical atherosclerotic ischemia of the lower extremities induces paracoagulation and the development of chronic systemic inflammation. Conversely, sepsis, other critical conditions, and severe systemic chronic diseases contribute to atherogenesis. In summary, atherosclerosis can be characterized as an independent form of inflammation, sharing similarities but also having fundamental differences from low-grade inflammation and various variants of canonical inflammation (classic vasculitis).

Posing the rationale for synthetic lipoxin mimetics as an adjuvant treatment to gold standard atherosclerosis therapies

Atherosclerosis is a progressive, multifactorial inflammatory, and dyslipidaemic disease, responsible for the majority of cardiovascular diseases globally. The chronic inflammation is the main driver of the initiation and progression of such disease, as a result of an imbalanced lipid metabolism and an ineffective immune response to attenuate the inflammatory component. The importance of inflammation resolution is being increasingly recognised in atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease. It has a complex mechanism consisting of multiple stages, including restoring an effective removal of apoptotic bodies (efferocytosis) and their degradation (effero-metabolism), a macrophage phenotype switching towards resolving phenotypes, and the promotion of tissue healing and regeneration. The low-grade inflammation associated with atherosclerosis development is a driving force in disease exacerbation, and hence inflammation resolution is a key area of research. In this review, we explore the complex disease pathogenesis and its many contributing factors to gain a greater understanding of the disease and identify the current and potential therapeutic targets. First-line treatments and their efficacy will also be discussed in detail, to highlight the emerging field of resolution pharmacology. Despite the great efforts made by current gold-standard treatments, such as lipid-lowering and glucose-lowering drugs, they remain ineffective at tackling residual inflammatory risk and residual cholesterol risk. Resolution pharmacology represents a new era of atherosclerosis therapy, as endogenous ligands associated with inflammation resolution are exploited for their pharmacological benefits in a more potent and longer-acting manner. Novel FPR2-agonists, such as synthetic lipoxin analogues, provide an exciting new approach to enhance the pro-resolving response of the immune system and subsequently end the pro-inflammatory response to allow for an anti-inflammatory and pro-resolving environment for tissue healing, regeneration, and return to homeostasis.

Development of synthetic lipoxin-A4 mimetics (sLXms): New avenues in the treatment of cardio-metabolic diseases

Resolution of inflammation is a complex, dynamic process consisting of several distinct processes, including inhibition of endothelial activation and leukocyte trafficking; promotion of inflammatory cell apoptosis and subsequent non-phlogistic scavenging and degradation; augmentation of pathogen phagocytosis; modulation of stromal cell phenotype coupled to the promotion of tissue regeneration and repair. Among these tightly regulated processes, the clearance and degradation of apoptotic cells without eliciting an inflammatory response is a crucial allostatic mechanism vital to developmental processes, host defence, and the effective resolution of inflammation. These efferocytic and subsequent effero-metabolism processes can be carried out by professional and non-professional phagocytes. Defective removal or inadequate processing of apoptotic cells leads to persistent unresolved inflammation, which may promote insidious pathologies including scarring, fibrosis, and eventual organ failure. In this manuscript, the well-established role of endothelial activation and leukocyte extravasation, as classical vascular targets of the 'inflammation pharmacology', will be briefly reviewed. The main focus of this work is to bring attention to a less explored aspect of the 'resolution pharmacology', aimed at tackling defective efferocytosis and inefficient effero-metabolism, as key targeted mechanisms to prevent or pre-empt vascular complications in cardio-metabolic diseases. Despite the use of gold standard lipid-lowering drugs or glucose-lowering drugs, none of them are able to tackle the so called residual inflammatory risk and/or the metabolic memory. In this review, the development of synthetic mimetics of endogenous mediators of inflammation is highlighted. Such molecules finely tune key components across the whole inflammatory process, amongst various other novel therapeutic paradigms that have emerged over the past decade, including anti-inflammatory therapy. More specifically, FPR2-agonists in general, and Lipoxin analogues in particular, greatly enhance the reprogramming and cross-talk between classical and non-classical innate immune cells, thus inducing both termination of the pro-inflammatory state as well as promoting the subsequent resolving phase, which represent pivotal mechanisms in inflammatory cardio-metabolic diseases.

Mechanisms of continual efferocytosis by macrophages and its role in mitigating atherosclerosis

Atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease is the leading cause of death worldwide. Rupture-prone atheromas that give rise to myocardial infarction and stroke are characterized by the presence of a necrotic core and a thin fibrous cap. During homeostasis, cellular debris and apoptotic cells are cleared quickly through a process termed "efferocytosis". However, clearance of apoptotic cells is significantly compromised in many chronic inflammatory diseases, including atherosclerosis. Emerging evidence suggests that impairments in efferocytosis drive necrotic core formation and contribute significantly to plaque vulnerability. Recently, it has been appreciated that successive rounds of efferocytosis, termed "continual efferocytosis", is mechanistically distinct from single efferocytosis and relies heavily on the metabolism and handling of apoptotic cell-derived cargo. In vivo, selective defects in continual efferocytosis drive secondary necrosis, impair inflammation resolution, and worsen atherosclerosis. This Mini Review focuses on our current understanding of the cellular and molecular mechanisms of continual efferocytosis and how dysregulations in this process mediate nonresolving inflammation. We will also discuss possible strategies to enhance efferocytosis when it fails.

The regulation of efferocytosis signaling pathways and adipose tissue homeostasis in physiological conditions and obesity: Current understanding and treatment options

Obesity is associated with changes in the resolution of acute inflammation that contribute to the clinical complications. The exact mechanisms underlying unresolved inflammation in obesity are not fully understood. Adipocyte death leads to pro-inflammatory adipose tissue macrophages, stimulating additional adipocyte apoptosis. Thus, a complex and tightly regulated process to inhibit inflammation and maintain homeostasis after adipocyte apoptosis is needed to maintain health. In normal condition, a specialized phagocytic process (efferocytosis) performs this function, clearing necrotic and apoptotic cells (ACs) and controlling inflammation. For efficient and continued efferocytosis, phagocytes must internalize multiple ACs in physiological conditions and handle the excess metabolic burden in adipose tissue. In obesity, this control is lost and can be an important hallmark of the disease. In this regard, the deficiency of efferocytosis leads to delayed resolution of acute inflammation and can result in ongoing inflammation, immune system dysfunction, and insulin resistance in obesity. Hence, efficient clearance of ACs by M2 macrophages could limit long-term inflammation and ensue clinical complications, such as cardiovascular disease and diabetes. This review elaborates upon the molecular mechanisms to identify efferocytosis regulators in obesity, and the mechanisms that can improve efferocytosis and reduce obesity-related complications, such as the use of pharmacological agents and regular exercise.

Crosstalk Between Macrophages and Vascular Smooth Muscle Cells in Atherosclerotic Plaque Stability

Most acute cardiovascular events are due to plaque rupture, with atheromas containing large necrotic cores and thin fibrous caps being more susceptible to rupture and lesions with small necrotic cores and thick fibrous caps being more protected from rupture. Atherosclerotic plaques are comprised various extracellular matrix proteins, modified lipoprotein particles, and cells of different origins, that is, vascular cells and leukocytes. Although much has been revealed about the mechanisms that lead to plaque instability, several key areas remain incompletely understood. This In-Focus Review highlights processes related to cellular crosstalk and the role of the tissue microenvironment in determining cell function and plaque stability. Recent advances highlight critical underpinnings of atherosclerotic plaque vulnerability, particularly impairments in the ability of macrophages to clear dead cells and phenotypic switching of vascular smooth muscle cells. However, these processes do not occur in isolation, as crosstalk between macrophages and vascular smooth muscle cells and interactions with their surrounding microenvironment play a significant role in determining plaque stability. Understanding these aspects of cellular crosstalk within an atherosclerotic plaque may shed light on how to modify cell behavior and identify novel approaches to transform rupture-prone atheromas into stable lesions.

Adipose Tissue Immunometabolism and Apoptotic Cell Clearance

The safe removal of apoptotic debris by macrophages—often referred to as efferocytosis—is crucial for maintaining tissue integrity and preventing self-immunity or tissue damaging inflammation. Macrophages clear tissues of hazardous materials from dying cells and ultimately adopt a pro-resolving activation state. However, adipocyte apoptosis is an inflammation-generating process, and the removal of apoptotic adipocytes by so-called adipose tissue macrophages triggers a sequence of events that lead to meta-inflammation and obesity-associated metabolic diseases. Signals that allow apoptotic cells to control macrophage immune functions are complex and involve metabolites released by the apoptotic cells and also metabolites produced by the macrophages during the digestion of apoptotic cell contents. This review provides a concise summary of the adipocyte-derived metabolites that potentially control adipose tissue macrophage immune functions and, hence, may induce or alleviate adipose tissue inflammation.