Comprehensive analysis of clinical spectrum and genotype associations in Chinese and literature reported KBG syndrome

Insights into the ANKRD11 variants and short-stature phenotype through literature review and ClinVar database search

Ankyrin repeat domain containing-protein 11 (ANKRD11), a transcriptional factor predominantly localized in the cell nucleus, plays a crucial role in the expression regulation of key genes by recruiting chromatin remodelers and interacting with specific transcriptional repressors or activators during numerous biological processes. Its pathogenic variants are strongly linked to the pathogenesis and progression of multisystem disorder known as KBG syndrome. With the widespread application of high-throughput DNA sequencing technologies in clinical medicine, numerous pathogenic variants in the ANKRD11 gene have been reported. Patients with KBG syndrome usually exhibit a broad phenotypic spectrum with a variable degree of severity, even if having identical variants. In addition to distinctive dental, craniofacial and neurodevelopmental abnormalities, patients often present with skeletal anomalies, particularly postnatal short stature. The relationship between ANKRD11 variants and short stature is not well-understood, with limited knowledge regarding its occurrence rate or underlying biological mechanism involved. This review aims to provide an updated analysis of the molecular spectrum associated with ANKRD11 variants, investigate the prevalence of the short stature among patients harboring these variants, evaluate the efficacy of recombinant human growth hormone in treating children with short stature and ANKRD11 variants, and explore the biological mechanisms underlying short stature from both scientific and clinical perspectives. Our investigation indicated that frameshift and nonsense were the most frequent types in 583 pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants identified in the ANKRD11 gene. Among the 245 KBGS patients with height data, approximately 50% displayed short stature. Most patients showed a positive response to rhGH therapy, although the number of patients receiving treatment was limited. ANKRD11 deficiency potentially disrupts longitudinal bone growth by affecting the orderly differentiation of growth plate chondrocytes. Our review offers crucial insights into the association between ANKRD11 variants and short stature and provides valuable guidance for precise clinical diagnosis and treatment of patients with KBG syndrome.

Functional investigation of a novel ANKRD11 frameshift variant identified in a Chinese family with KBG syndrome

KBG syndrome is a rare autosomal dominant condition characterized by multisystem developmental disorder, primarily caused by loss-of-function variants in ankyrin repeat domain-containing protein 11 (ANKRD11). Approximately 80 % of ANKRD11 variants associated with KBG syndrome, are frameshift and nonsense variants. Current insight into the pathogenesis of KBG syndrome resulting from ANKRD11 truncating variants remains limited. Here, we presented two members from a non-consanguineous Chinese pedigree both exhibiting characteristics fitting the KBG syndrome-associated phenotypic spectrum. Whole-exome sequencing identified a novel heterozygous frameshift variant in ANKRD11 (NM_013275.6, c.2280_2281delGT, p.Y761Qfs*20) in the proband. Sanger sequencing confirmed that the variant was inherited from her mother and co-segregated with KBG syndrome phenotype. In vitro functional assays revealed that the frameshift variant escaped nonsense-mediated mRNA decay, and resulting in a truncated protein with significantly increased expression levels compared to full-length ANKRD11. Immunofluorescence results demonstrated that truncated protein was predominantly expressed in the nucleus of HEK293 cells, while wild-type ANKRD11 was equally distributed in both the nucleus and cytoplasm. Moreover, the truncated protein significantly reduced CDKN1A/P21-promoter luciferase activity in comparison to wild-type ANKRD11 protein, as well as a remarkably decrease in the endogenous CDKN1A/P21 mRNA level in HEK293 cells. These findings suggest a loss of transcriptional activation function and potentially a dominant-negative mechanism. Overall, our study expands the mutational spectrum of ANKRD11 gene and provides new insights into the pathogenic mechanism of KBG syndrome caused by ANKRD11 truncating variants.

Epileptic dyskinetic encephalopathy in KBG syndrome: Expansion of the phenotype

KBG syndrome is characterised by developmental delay, dental (macrodontia of upper central incisors), craniofacial and skeletal anomalies. Since the identification of variants in the gene (ANKRD11) responsible for KBG syndrome, wider phenotypes are emerging. While there is phenotypic variability within many features of KBG syndrome, epilepsy is not usually markedly severe and movement disorders largely undocumented. Here we describe a novel early onset phenotype of dyskinetic epileptic encephalopathy in a male, who presented during infancy with a florid hyperkinetic movement disorder and developmental regression. Initially he had epileptic spasms and tonic seizures, and EEGs revealed a modified hypsarrhythmia. The epilepsy phenotype evolved to Lennox-Gastaut syndrome with seizures resistant to multiple anti-seizure therapies and the movement disorder evolved to choreoathetosis of limbs and head with oro-lingual dyskinesias. Previous extensive neurometabolic and imaging investigations, including panel-based exome sequencing were unremarkable. Later trio exome sequencing identified a de novo pathogenic heterozygous frameshift deletion of ANKRD11 (c.6792delC; p.Ala2265Profs*72). Review of the literature did not identify any individuals with such a hyperkinetic movement disorder presentation in combination with early-onset epileptic encephalopathy. This report expands the phenotype of ANKRD11-related KBG syndrome to include epileptic dyskinetic encephalopathy.

Epilepsy is an important feature of KBG syndrome associated with poorer developmental outcome

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to describe the epilepsy phenotype in a large international cohort of patients with KBG syndrome and to study a possible genotype-phenotype correlation.

METHODS

We collected data on patients with ANKRD11 variants by contacting University Medical Centers in the Netherlands, an international network of collaborating clinicians, and study groups who previously published about KBG syndrome. All patients with a likely pathogenic or pathogenic ANKRD11 variant were included in our patient cohort and categorized into an "epilepsy group" or "non-epilepsy group". Additionally, we included previously reported patients with (likely) pathogenic ANKRD11 variants and epilepsy from the literature.

RESULTS

We included 75 patients with KBG syndrome of whom 26 had epilepsy. Those with epilepsy more often had moderate to severe intellectual disability (42.3% vs 9.1%, RR 4.6 [95% CI 1.7-13.1]). Seizure onset in patients with KBG syndrome occurred at a median age of 4 years (range 12 months - 20 years), and the majority had generalized onset seizures (57.7%) with tonic-clonic seizures being most common (23.1%). The epilepsy type was mostly classified as generalized (42.9%) or combined generalized and focal (42.9%), not fulfilling the criteria of an electroclinical syndrome diagnosis. Half of the epilepsy patients (50.0%) were seizure free on anti-seizure medication (ASM) for at least 1 year at the time of last assessment, but 26.9% of patients had drug-resistant epilepsy (failure of ≥2 ASM). No genotype-phenotype correlation could be identified for the presence of epilepsy or epilepsy characteristics.

SIGNIFICANCE

Epilepsy in KBG syndrome most often presents as a generalized or combined focal and generalized type. No distinctive epilepsy syndrome could be identified. Patients with KBG syndrome and epilepsy had a significantly poorer neurodevelopmental outcome compared with those without epilepsy. Clinicians should consider KBG syndrome as a causal etiology of epilepsy and be aware of the poorer neurodevelopmental outcome in individuals with epilepsy.

Mosaicism of a novel variant in the ANKRD11 gene in a child with a mild KBG phenotype: A case report

BACKGROUND

KBG syndrome is likely underdiagnosed because of mild and non-specific features in some affected patients especially before the upper permanent central incisors eruption at about the age of 7-8 years. Somatic mosaicisms are usually recognized in the parents only after a typically affected son is diagnosed with KBG syndrome. We describe for the first time the mosaicism of a novel variant in a child with a mild KBG phenotype.

CASE SUMMARY

Our patient presented at 24 mo of age with short stature, hand abnormalities, facial dysmorphism and mild developmental delay. Pituitary hypoplasia and central hypothyroidism were also detected. By next generation sequencing (NGS) analysis we found a novel deletion in the ANKRD11 gene (c.4880_4893del.), that can be classified as likely pathogenic for the syndrome, with the percentage of mutated allele of 36%. We considered this finding as causative of the mild and non-specific phenotype for KBG syndrome in our patient, as previously reported in adults. A heterozygous variant in HESX1 gene, classified as variant of uncertain significance, but suspected of causing pituitary hypoplasia and hormonal deficiency, was also found. The patient started levothyroxine and growth hormone treatment.

CONCLUSION

The increased use of NGS analysis may expand the phenotypic spectrum of KBG syndrome because it allows genetic diagnosis of somatic mosaicisms also in children.

Natural history of KBG syndrome in a large European cohort

KBG syndrome (KBGS) is characterized by distinctive facial gestalt, short stature and variable clinical findings. With ageing, some features become more recognizable, allowing a differential diagnosis. We aimed to better characterize natural history of KBGS. In the context of a European collaborative study, we collected the largest cohort of KBGS patients (49). A combined array- based Comparative Genomic Hybridization and next generation sequencing (NGS) approach investigated both genomic Copy Number Variants and SNVs. Intellectual disability (ID) (82%) ranged from mild to moderate with severe ID identified in two patients. Epilepsy was present in 26.5%. Short stature was consistent over time, while occipitofrontal circumference (median value: -0.88 SD at birth) normalized over years. Cerebral anomalies, were identified in 56% of patients and thus represented the second most relevant clinical feature reinforcing clinical suspicion in the paediatric age when short stature and vertebral/dental anomalies are vague. Macrodontia, oligodontia and dental agenesis (53%) were almost as frequent as skeletal anomalies, such as brachydactyly, short fifth finger, fifth finger clinodactyly, pectus excavatum/carinatum, delayed bone age. In 28.5% of individuals, prenatal ultrasound anomalies were reported. Except for three splicing variants, leading to a premature termination, variants were almost all frameshift. Our results, broadening the spectrum of KBGS phenotype progression, provide useful tools to facilitate differential diagnosis and improve clinical management. We suggest to consider a wider range of dental anomalies before excluding diagnosis and to perform a careful odontoiatric/ear-nose-throat (ENT) evaluation in order to look for even submucosal palate cleft given the high percentage of palate abnormalities. NGS approaches, following evidence of antenatal ultrasound anomalies, should include ANKRD11.

Expanding the Molecular Spectrum of ANKRD11 Gene Defects in 33 Patients with a Clinical Presentation of KBG Syndrome

KBG syndrome (KBGS) is a neurodevelopmental disorder caused by the Ankyrin Repeat Domain 11 (ANKRD11) haploinsufficiency. Here, we report the molecular investigations performed on a cohort of 33 individuals with KBGS clinical suspicion. By using a multi-testing genomic approach, including gene sequencing, Chromosome Microarray Analysis (CMA), and RT-qPCR gene expression assay, we searched for pathogenic alterations in ANKRD11. A molecular diagnosis was obtained in 22 out of 33 patients (67%). ANKRD11 sequencing disclosed pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants in 18 out of 33 patients. CMA identified one full and one terminal ANKRD11 pathogenic deletions, and one partial duplication and one intronic microdeletion, with both possibly being pathogenic. The pathogenic effect was established by RT-qPCR, which confirmed ANKRD11 haploinsufficiency only for the three deletions. Moreover, RT-qPCR applied to six molecularly unsolved KBGS patients identified gene downregulation in a clinically typical patient with previous negative tests, and further molecular investigations revealed a cryptic deletion involving the gene promoter. In conclusion, ANKRD11 pathogenic variants could also involve the regulatory regions of the gene. Moreover, the application of a multi-test approach along with the innovative use of RT-qPCR improved the diagnostic yield in KBGS suspected patients.