Dynamic CT evaluation of the central airways in patients undergoing tracheoplasty for tracheobronchomalacia

Tracheobronchomalacia and Excessive Dynamic Airway Collapse: Current Concepts and Future Directions

Tracheobronchomalacia (TBM) and excessive dynamic airway collapse (EDAC) are airway abnormalities that share a common feature of expiratory narrowing but are distinct pathophysiologic entities. Both entities are collectively referred to as expiratory central airway collapse (ECAC). The malacia or weakness of cartilage that supports the tracheobronchial tree may occur only in the trachea (ie, tracheomalacia), in both the trachea and bronchi (TBM), or only in the bronchi (bronchomalacia). On the other hand, EDAC refers to excessive anterior bowing of the posterior membrane into the airway lumen with intact cartilage. Clinical diagnosis is often confounded by comorbidities including asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, obesity, hypoventilation syndrome, and gastroesophageal reflux disease. Additional challenges include the underrecognition of ECAC at imaging; the interchangeable use of the terms TBM and EDAC in the literature, which leads to confusion; and the lack of clear guidelines for diagnosis and treatment. The use of CT is growing for evaluation of the morphology of the airway, tracheobronchial collapsibility, and extrinsic disease processes that can narrow the trachea. MRI is an alternative tool, although it is not as widely available and is not used as frequently for this indication as is CT. Together, these tools not only enable diagnosis, but also provide a road map to clinicians and surgeons for planning treatment. In addition, CT datasets can be used for 3D printing of personalized medical devices such as stents and splints. An invited commentary by Brixey is available online. Online supplemental material is available for this article. ^©RSNA, 2022.

Detection and diagnosis of large airway collapse: a systematic review

Large airway collapse (LAC) is a frequently encountered clinical problem, caused by tracheobronchomalacia +/− excessive dynamic airway collapse, yet there are currently no universally accepted diagnostic criteria. We systematically reviewed studies reporting a diagnostic approach to LAC in healthy adults and patients, to compare diagnostic modalities and criteria used. Electronic databases were searched for relevant studies between 1989 and 2019. Studies that reported a diagnostic approach using computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging or flexible fibreoptic bronchoscopy were included. Random effects meta-analyses were performed to estimate the prevalence of LAC in healthy subjects and in patients with chronic obstructive airway diseases. We included 41 studies, describing 10 071 subjects (47% female) with a mean±sd age of 59±9 years. Most studies (n=35) reported CT findings, and only three studies reported bronchoscopic findings. The most reported diagnostic criterion was a ≥50% reduction in tracheal or main bronchi calibre at end-expiration on dynamic expiratory CT. Meta-analyses of relevant studies found that 17% (95% CI: 0–61%) of healthy subjects and 27% (95% CI: 11–46%) of patients with chronic airways disease were classified as having LAC, using this threshold. The most reported approach to diagnose LAC utilises CT diagnostics, and at a threshold used by most clinicians (i.e., ≥50%) may classify a considerable proportion of healthy individuals as being abnormal and having LAC in a quarter of patients with chronic airways disease. Future work should focus on establishing more precise diagnostic criteria for LAC, relating this to relevant physiological and disease sequelae.

CT is mostly used to diagnose LAC, and at a threshold used by most clinicians (i.e. ≥50%) that would classify a large proportion of healthy individuals as being abnormal and LAC in a quarter of patients with chronic airway diseaseshttps://bit.ly/3izAuSk

Longitudinal Follow-up of Patients With Tracheobronchomalacia After Undergoing Tracheobronchoplasty: Computed Tomography Findings and Clinical Correlation

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate intermediate and long-term changes in expiratory tracheal collapsibility by computed tomography (CT) in patients with tracheobronchomalacia following surgical treatment with tracheobronchoplasty and to correlate CT findings with clinical findings.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between 2003 and 2016, 18 patients with tracheobronchomalacia underwent tracheobronchoplasty and were imaged preoperatively and postoperatively at both intermediate and long-term intervals. Imaging included end-inspiratory and dynamic expiratory phase scans. The cross-sectional area of the airway lumen was measured at 2 standard levels (1 cm above the aortic arch and carina). These measurements were used to calculate % collapsibility. Clinical findings recorded included a questionnaire on symptomatology and a 6-minute walk test.

RESULTS

Before surgery, expiratory collapsibility of the upper trachea was 72%±25% (mean±SD) and that of the lower trachea was 68%±22%. On intermediate follow-up (mean, 1.5 y), collapsibility significantly decreased to 37%±21% at the upper trachea and 35%±19% at the lower trachea (P<0.001). On long-term follow-up (mean, 6 y), collapsibility increased to 51%±20% at the upper trachea and 47%±17% at the lower trachea and was significantly worse than on intermediate follow-up (P=0.002). However, collapsibility on long-term follow-up remained significantly lower than preoperative collapsibility (P=0.015). Clinical findings showed a similar trend as quantitative CT measurements.

CONCLUSION

Expiratory tracheal collapsibility substantially decreases after tracheobronchoplasty on intermediate follow-up. At long-term follow-up, tracheal collapsibility shows a modest increase, but remains significantly lower than the preoperative baseline. Quantitative measurements from dynamic CT have the potential to play an important role as imaging biomarkers for assessing response to tracheobronchoplasty.

The prefabricated supraclavicular artery flap in high-risk tracheal stenosis patients

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

Primary tracheal resection in appropriately selected patients with tracheal stenosis achieves >90% success rate. Risk factors for complications have been identified, making some patients high risk for this procedure. Herein is a review and discussion of a novel treatment method for tracheal stenosis utilizing a prefabricated composite auricular cartilage graft embedded in a supraclavicular artery island flap (pSCAIF) for tracheal reconstruction in high-risk patients.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case series.

METHODS

After institutional review board approval, cases were analyzed after data collection. Between 2014 and 2016, eight patients underwent airway reconstruction using an auricular cartilage graft prefabricated within a supraclavicular artery island flap reconstruction; all of these were included in the study. Each case was reviewed, and relevant details of patient and disease characteristics, operative course, postoperative course, decannulation, and status at last follow-up were isolated and reported.

RESULTS

Seven of eight patients were female. The most common cause of stenosis was iatrogenically induced multilevel stenosis (7/8 patients). All patients had undergone prior airway procedures, were high risk based on comorbid conditions, and underwent grafting and reconstruction with a composite supraclavicular island flap. All patients continue to follow up in a multidisciplinary clinic, and at last follow-up, eight of eight patients were successfully decannulated.

CONCLUSIONS

The pSCAIF is a novel method for tracheal reconstruction. The analysis of the prefabricated locoregional approach cohort supports its utility for tracheal reconstruction in patients with complicated multilevel stenosis and adverse comorbidities and characteristics.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 130:641-648, 2020.

Helical multi-detector CT scan as a tool for diagnosing tracheomalacia in children

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Tracheomalacia (TM) is not an unusual diagnosis in pediatric respiratory clinics. The aim of this study was to assess the accuracy of paired static end-inspiratory/end-expiratory helical multi-detector CT scan (MDCT) in detecting TM.

METHODS

FB was performed in 28 children suspected of TM on the grounds of presence of recurrent episodes of vibrating cough and a need for more specific diagnostic information. Children diagnosed with flexible bronchoscopy (FB) as having TM were further investigated with MDCT. The cross-sectional area ratio of the trachea during end-expiration and end-inspiration, at the level of maximum end-expiration collapse (CSR), determined the basis for the MDCT diagnosis of TM. FB and MDCT were also performed in five children who suffered from mainly dry-but not honking, barking, or vibrating-cough for more than 3 months, and served as controls.

RESULTS

The diagnosis of TM was established bronchoscopically in 26 out of 28 children. CRS was significantly smaller in patients (0.59 ± 0.14) compared with controls (0.85 ± 0.11) (P = 0.001). The optimal CSR cut-off point for TM diagnosis, as it was estimated by the ROC curve, was ≤0.705 (95%CI: ≤0.635-≤0.850) with a sensitivity 84.6% (95%CI: 65.1-95.6), and specificity 100.0% (95%CI: 47.8-100.0).

CONCLUSIONS

MDCT can effectively diagnose TM in the majority of children and can be used as an alternative to FB. In children, the established criterion of CSR ≤0.5 should be replaced by CSR ≤0.7 that seems to be a more appropriate threshold.

Improving Quality of Dynamic Airway Computed Tomography Using an Expiratory Airflow Indicator Device

PURPOSE

Dynamic computed tomography (CT) of the airways is increasingly used to evaluate patients with suspected expiratory central airway collapse, but current protocols are susceptible to inadequate exhalation caused by variable patient compliance with breathing instructions during the expiratory phase. We developed and tested a low-cost single-use expiratory airflow indicator device that was designed to improve study quality by providing a visual indicator to both patient and operator when adequate expiratory flow was attained.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 56 patients undergoing dynamic airway CT were evaluated, 35 of whom were scanned before introduction of the indicator device (control group), with the rest comprising the intervention group. Lung volumes and tracheal cross-sectional areas on inspiratory/expiratory phases were computed using automated lung segmentation and quantitative software analysis. Inadequate exhalation was defined as absolute volume change of <500 mL during the expiratory phase.

RESULTS

Fewer patients in the intervention group demonstrated inadequate exhalation. The average change in volume was higher in the intervention group (P=0.004), whereas the average minimum tracheal cross-sectional area was lower (P=0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

The described expiratory airflow indicator device can be used to ensure adequate exhalation during the expiratory phase of dynamic airway CT. A higher frequency of adequate exhalation may improve reliability and sensitivity of dynamic airway CT for diagnosis of expiratory central airway collapse.

Imaging in lung transplants: Checklist for the radiologist

Post lung transplant complications can have overlapping clinical and imaging features, and hence, the time point at which they occur is a key distinguisher. Complications of lung transplantation may occur along a continuum in the immediate or longer postoperative period, including surgical and mechanical problems due to size mismatch and vascular as well as airway anastomotic complication, injuries from ischemia and reperfusion, acute and chronic rejection, pulmonary infections, and post-transplantation lymphoproliferative disorder. Life expectancy after lung transplantation has been limited primarily by chronic rejection and infection. Multiple detector computed tomography (MDCT) is critical for evaluation and early diagnosis of complications to enable selection of effective therapy and decrease morbidity and mortality among lung transplant recipients.

Unmasking of tracheomalacia following short-term mechanical ventilation in a patient of adult respiratory distress syndrome

Patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are susceptible to airway malacia, which may be unmasked following mechanical ventilation or tracheostomy decannulation. Dynamic imaging of central airways, a non-invasive test as effective as bronchoscopy to diagnose airway malacia, has increased the recognition of this disorder. We describe a 70-year-old woman admitted with adult respiratory distress syndrome. She had cardiorespiratory arrest on admission, from which she was successfully resuscitated. She had obesity, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, recurrent ventricular tachycardia, sarcoidosis with interstitial lung disease and COPD. She received short-term (18 days) mechanical ventilation with tracheostomy and developed respiratory distress following tracheostomy decannulation.

Multidetector-row Computed Tomography of Diffuse Tracheal Disease: Pictorial Review

Diffuse tracheal diseases are uncommon and may mimic asthma or other forms of chronic obstructive lung disease. Bronchoscopy is usually definitive in establishing a diagnosis and assessing the severity of diffuse tracheal disease. However, advances in multidetector-row computed tomography (MDCT) technology allow for rapid acquisition time and generation of high-quality multiplanar reconstructions and virtual bronchoscopic images, making MDCT evaluation of suspected or known tracheal disease the noninvasive examination of choice. The MDCT findings of the various diseases that diffusely affect the trachea may be highly suggestive of 1 particular disease or narrow the differential diagnosis to a few possibilities. Moreover, MDCT imaging of the chest can help identify associated lung disease or complications of diffuse tracheal disease such as pneumonia or atelectasis. This pictorial review illustrates the MDCT appearances of the more common diffuse tracheal diseases.

Reproducibility of forced expiratory tracheal collapse: assessment with MDCT in healthy volunteers

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

To assess the reproducibility of multidetector-row computed tomography (MDCT)-measured forced expiratory tracheal collapse in healthy volunteers.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Fourteen healthy, nonsmoking volunteers (6 males, 8 females, mean age 48.7 +/- 13.8 years) underwent repeat imaging 1 year after baseline imaging of tracheal dynamics employing the same scanner and technique (64-MDCT, 40 mAs, 120 kVp, and 0.625 mm detector collimation) with spirometric monitoring of total lung capacity and forced exhalation. Cross-sectional area (CSA) of the trachea was measured 1 cm above the aortic arch at end-inspiration and dynamic expiration, and percentage (%) expiratory reduction in tracheal lumen was calculated. Measurements were compared between baseline (Yr1) and repeat imaging (Yr2) using correlation coefficients and Bland-Altman plots.

RESULTS

Mean end-inspiratory CSA was 255.3 +/- 56 mm(2) at Yr1 and 255.1 +/- 52 mm(2) at Yr2; mean dynamic expiratory CSA was 125.6 +/- 60 mm(2) at Yr1 and 132.1 +/- 58 mm(2) at Yr2; and mean % expiratory reduction was 51.7 +/- 18% at Yr1 and 48.7 +/- 19% at Yr2. Mean differences between Yr1 and Yr2 values were 0.2 mm(2) for end-inspiratory CSA, 6.5 mm(2) for dynamic expiratory CSA, and 3.0% for percentage expiratory reduction. There was excellent correlation between the Yr1 and Yr2 measures of end-inspiratory CSA (r(2) = 0.97, P < .001), dynamic expiratory CSA (r(2) = 0.89, P < .001), and % expiratory reduction (r(2) = 0.86, P < .001).

CONCLUSION

MDCT measurements of forced expiratory tracheal collapse in healthy volunteers are highly reproducible over time.

Comparison of standard-dose and reduced-dose expiratory MDCT techniques for assessment of tracheomalacia in children

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to assess the effects of radiation dose reduction on the assessment of the tracheal lumen on expiratory multidetector computed tomographic (MDCT) images of pediatric patients referred for evaluation for tracheomalacia (TM).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The hospital information system was used to retrospectively identify 20 standard-dose and 20 reduced-dose paired inspiratory and expiratory MDCT studies performed for the evaluation of suspected TM in pediatric patients (aged <or= 18 years). The reduced-dose technique used a 50% reduction of the tube current for the expiratory portion of the study compared to the standard-dose technique. Two experienced pediatric radiologists, who were blinded to the tube current of the study, reported their levels of confidence for measuring the tracheal lumen using a four-point scale ranging from zero (no confidence) to three (highest level of confidence). The difference in confidence level between the two groups of studies was analyzed using the Mann-Whitney U test. The percentage of radiation dose reduction using the reduced-dose technique in comparison to the standard-dose technique was estimated using anthropomorphic thorax phantoms. The presence or absence of TM (>or=50% expiratory reduction in tracheal cross-sectional luminal area) on MDCT imaging was compared to bronchoscopic results for the subset of 32 patients who underwent both procedures.

RESULTS

A high level of confidence was reported for measuring the tracheal lumen on MDCT imaging for both standard-dose (median, 3.0) and reduced-dose (median, 3.0) expiratory sequences (P = .80). The total radiation dose of the paired inspiratory-expiratory computed tomographic (CT) exam was decreased by 23% with the reduced-dose technique. TM was diagnosed by CT imaging in seven patients who underwent standard-dose and six patients who underwent reduced-dose paired inspiratory and expiratory MDCT studies. CT results for the presence or absence of TM were concordant with the results of bronchoscopy in all 32 patients who underwent both procedures.

CONCLUSION

The radiation dose of paired inspiratory-expiratory CT imaging can be reduced by 23% while maintaining similar diagnostic confidence for assessment of the tracheal lumen compared to a standard-dose technique in pediatric patients. Thus, a reduced-dose technique is recommended for evaluating TM in children.

Airway malacia in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: prevalence, morphology and relationship with emphysema, bronchiectasis and bronchial wall thickening

The aim of this study was to determine the prevalence of airway malacia and its relationship with ancillary morphologic features in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). A retrospective review was performed of a consecutive series of patients with COPD who were imaged with inspiratory and dynamic expiratory multidetector computed tomography (MDCT). Airway malacia was defined as > or =50% expiratory reduction of the airway lumen. Both distribution and morphology of airway malacia were assessed. The extent of emphysema, extent of bronchiectasis and severity of bronchial wall thickness were quantified. The final study cohort was comprised of 71 patients. Airway malacia was seen in 38 of 71 patients (53%), and such proportion was roughly maintained in each stage of COPD severity. Almost all tracheomalacia cases (23/25, 92%) were characterised by an expiratory anterior bowing of the posterior membranous wall. Both emphysema and bronchiectasis extent did not differ between patients with and without airway malacia (p > 0.05). Bronchial wall thickness severity was significantly higher in patients with airway malacia and correlated with the degree of maximal bronchial collapse (p < 0.05). In conclusion, we demonstrated a strong association between airway malacia and COPD, disclosing a significant relationship with bronchial wall thickening.

Multi-detector CT evaluation in patients suspected of tracheobronchomalacia: Comparison of end-expiratory with dynamic expiratory volumetric acquisitions

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to compare dynamic expiratory imaging and end-expiratory imaging using multi-detector CT (MDCT) of the central airways in patients suspected of tracheobronchomalacia (TBM).

METHODS

This study had local ethical committee approval. Seventy patients suspected of TBM were prospectively included. All patients underwent evaluation of central airways by three different low-dose MDCT acquisitions: end inspiration, end expiration, and dynamic expiration. Degree of airway collapse was measured by calculating the percentage change in the area and diameter of the airways between inspiratory and the two expiratory techniques at three levels of the trachea and in the sagittal diameter of the right and left main bronchi. Three threshold levels of percentage reduction in diameter or area (30%, 50%, and 70%) for defining TBM were evaluated.

RESULTS

In the entire population, the mean percentage of airway collapse was significantly greater with dynamic expiratory imaging than with the end-expiratory imaging at three different levels: lower thoracic trachea (26% vs. 16.6%, p<0.009), right (25.2% vs. 14%, p<0.01) and left main (24.7% vs. 13.3%, p<0.01) bronchus. Whatever the threshold value for defining TBM, dynamic expiratory imaging always resulted in diagnosing TBM in more patients than end-expiratory imaging.

CONCLUSIONS

Dynamic expiratory imaging shows a significantly greater degree and a significantly greater extent of airway collapse than standard end-expiratory imaging in patients suspected of TBM. Further evaluation of the clinical relevance of such findings is warranted.

Anesthetic considerations for airway stenting in adult patients

The attributable morbidity from central airway obstruction is significant. Airway stenting provides a therapeutic option to manage these complex lesions. This article focuses on the relevant anesthetic considerations of airway stenting in adult patients.

A RETROSPECTIVE STUDY OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN TRACHEAL COLLAPSE AND BRONCHIECTASIS IN DOGS

Tracheal collapse is common in middle age toy and miniature breed dogs. Cartilaginous defects have been identified histologically and are considered a form of chondromalacia. In addition to tracheal cartilaginous changes, concurrent lower airway histologic changes indicative of inflammation have been noted in dogs with tracheal collapse and these changes may lead t o concurrent bronchiectasis. The purpose of this study was to investigate the prevalence of bronchiectasis in dogs with a previous radiographic diagnosis of tracheal collapse. The thoracic radiographs of 60 dogs with tracheal collapse were evaluated for evidence of concurrent bronchiectasis. Eighteen of 60 (30%) dogs had evidence of bronchiectasis, and all were cylindrical in morphology. The signalment of affected dogs was similar to that previously reported. The occurrence of bronchiectasis in this group of dogs with tracheal collapse (18 dogs) was six times higher (P < 0.05) than the expected prevalence within a random sample population (three dogs). The results of this study provide evidence of a link between tracheal collapse and bronchiectasis. A finding of bronchiectasis with tracheal collapse should encourage further evaluation for chronic lower airway disease in these patients.

Central Airway Mechanics and Flow Limitation in Acquired Tracheobronchomalacia

BACKGROUND

Acquired tracheobronchomalacia (TBM) can cause central airway collapse in patients with COPD and may worsen airflow obstruction and symptoms. It is usually not known whether central airway malacia contributes to airflow obstruction. This study was undertaken to quantify central airway collapsibility and relate it to expiratory flow limitation in patients with TBM.

METHODS

Eighty patients evaluated for acquired TBM and 4 healthy control subjects were studied with measurements of central airway narrowing derived from bronchoscopic videotapes and simultaneous pressure measurements in the trachea and esophagus. Tracheal narrowing was assessed by a shape index and plotted against the transtracheal pressure to measure collapsibility. Subsequently, airflow and transpulmonary pressure (PL) were measured to identify expiratory flow limitation during quiet breathing and to determine the critical PL required for maximum expiratory flow.

RESULTS

Tracheal collapsibility varied widely among patients. Some had profound tracheal narrowing during quiet breathing, and others showed substantial collapse only during forced exhalation. Of the patients, 15% were not flow limited during quiet breathing, 53% were flow limited throughout exhalation, and 30% were flow limited only during the latter part of the exhalation. Patients with flow limitation at rest showed greater tracheal narrowing than those without (p = 0.009), but the severity of expiratory flow limitation was not closely related to tracheal collapsibility. Twenty-three patients were flow limited during quiet exhalation at PLs that did not cause central airway collapse.

CONCLUSIONS

In TBM, central airway collapse is not closely related to airflow obstruction, and expiratory flow limitation at rest often occurs in peripheral airways without central airway collapse.

Tracheal Morphology in Patients With Tracheomalacia

OBJECTIVE

To identify the spectrum of tracheal morphologies in patients with tracheomalacia, and to determine the prevalence of specific inspiratory (lunate) and expiratory (frown) shapes that have been associated with this condition.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective review was performed of a consecutive series of patients with bronchoscopically-proven tracheomalacia who were imaged with inspiratory and dynamic-expiratory computed tomography (CT). The CT images of each patient were reviewed in a blinded, randomized fashion by an experienced thoracic radiologist. For each case, the shape of the trachea at end-inspiration and dynamic expiration was classified using specific tracheal morphologies described in the literature.

RESULTS

The study population included 17 patients, with a mean age of 54 years. At inspiration, 16 (94%) of 17 subjects demonstrated a normal tracheal configuration (round, oval, horseshoe, or inverted-pear shape), and 1 (6%) of 17 subjects demonstrated an abnormal "lunate" tracheal configuration (coronal: sagittal ratio >1). At expiration, 9 (53%) of 17 subjects demonstrated a crescenteric, "frown" shape; 1 (6%) subject demonstrated complete collapse; and 7 (41%) subjects demonstrated other morphologies.

CONCLUSIONS

Inspiratory tracheal morphology is almost always normal in patients with tracheomalacia, with a lunate configuration only rarely observed. In contrast, an expiratory "frown sign" is observed in approximately half of patients with this condition. This sign has the potential to aid the detection of tracheomalacia when patients inadvertently breathe during routine CT scans.