Genetic resistance to avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC): current status and opportunities

Infections with avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC) can be extremely detrimental to poultry health and production. Investigating host genetic variation could identify the biological mechanisms that control resistance to this pathogen and allow selection for improved resistance in experimental and commercial poultry populations. In this review, the current knowledge of how host genetics contributes to APEC resistance and future opportunities that would benefit the understanding or application of genetic resistance are discussed. Phenotypes, such as antibody responses, lesion scores, and mortality, revealed that genetic background impacts APEC resistance and interacts with other factors including the environment and challenge conditions. Experiments have used divergent selection for APEC-specific antibody levels to facilitate genetic studies, estimated heritabilities in relevant traits, detected quantitative trait loci using microsatellites, and made associations with sequence variation in the major histocompatibility complex, which collectively suggest that improving APEC resistance through selection is feasible, although genetic control is partial, complex, and highly polygenic. Additionally, functional genomics techniques have identified antimicrobial responses, toll-like receptor and cytokine signalling, and the cell cycle as central pathways in the host response to APEC challenge. Opportunities for future research are discussed, including the expansion of existing lines of research and the application of new technologies that are relevant to the study of host genetics and APEC. This review closes with prospective strategies for improvement of host genetic resistance to APEC.

Selective breeding for high natural antibody level increases resistance to avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC) in chickens

Keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH)-binding natural antibody (NAb) titers in chickens are heritable, and higher levels have previously been associated with a higher survival. This suggests that selective breeding for higher NAb levels might increase survival by means of improved general disease resistance. Chickens were divergently selected and bred for total NAb levels binding KLH at 16 weeks of age for six generations, resulting in a High NAb selection line and a Low NAb selection line. To for test differences in disease resistance, chickens were challenged with avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC) in two separate experiments. Chickens at 8 days of age received one of four intratracheal inoculations of 0.2 mL phosphate buffered saline (PBS): 1) mock inoculate, 2) with 0.2 mL PBS containing 10^8.20 colony-forming units (CFU)/mL APEC, 3) with 0.2 mL PBS containing 10^6.64 CFU/mL APEC, and 4) with 0.2 mL PBS containing 10^7.55 CFU/mL APEC. Mortality was recorded during 7 days post inoculation. Overall, 50-60% reduced mortality was observed in the High line compared to the Low line for all APEC doses. In addition, morbidity was determined of the surviving chickens at 15 days of age. The High line had lower morbidity scores compared to the Low line. We conclude that selective breeding for high KLH-binding NAb levels at 16 weeks of age increase APEC resistance in early life. This study and previous studies support the hypothesis that KLH-binding NAb might be used as an indicator trait for to selective breed for general disease resistance in an antigen non-specific fashion.

Response of restraint stress-selected lines of Japanese quail to heat stress and Escherichia coli challenge

Japanese quail selected for divergent corticosterone response to restraint stress were evaluated for their susceptibility to heat stress and challenge with Escherichia coli. These quail lines are designated as high stress (HS), low stress (LS), and the random-bred control (CS) lines. Heat stress (35°C, 8 h/d) began at 24 d until the end of the study at 39 d. Birds were challenged with an aerosol spray containing 2 × 10(9) cfu of E. coli at 25 and 32 d. At 38 d, the surviving birds were necropsied and the intestinal tract was screened for both Salmonella and Campylobacter. Body weights of the CS birds were higher than both HS and LS at 17, 25, and 32 d. At 32 d, there was no difference in mortality between males and females and the CS line had higher mortality compared with the LS line with the HS line being intermediate. At 38 d, females of the CS line that were both heat stressed and challenged had a mortality incidence of 25%, which was significantly higher than male birds of the same line and treatment (5.3%). There was an increased incidence in Salmonella enterica serotype Agona isolation after heat stress, with the LS birds having less isolation than the HS birds. Mean corticosterone levels of male birds were not significantly affected by line, heat stress, or E. coli challenge; however, the LS line subjected to heat stress had one-third the level of the HS line, a difference identical to that seen in the original selection for response to restraint stress.

Efficacy of a bacteriophage isolated from chickens as a therapeutic agent for colibacillosis in broiler chickens

The efficacy of bacteriophage EC1, a lytic bacteriophage, against Escherichia coli O78:K80, which causes colibacillosis in poultry, was determined in the present study. A total of 480 one-day-old birds were randomly assigned to 4 treatments groups, each with 4 pens of 30 birds. Birds from the control groups (groups I and II) received PBS (pH 7.4) or 10(10) pfu of bacteriophage EC1, respectively. Group III consisted of birds challenged with 10(8) cfu of E. coli O78:K80 and treated with 10(10) pfu of bacteriophage EC1 at 2 h postinfection, whereas birds from group IV were challenged with 10(8) cfu of E. coli O78:K80 only. All the materials were introduced into the birds by intratracheal inoculation. Based on the results of the present study, the infection was found to be less severe in the treated E. coli-challenged group. Mean total viable cell counts of E. coli identified on eosin methylene blue agar (designated EMB + E. coli) in the lungs were significantly lower in treated, E. coli-challenged birds than in untreated, E. coli-challenged birds on d 1 and 2 postinfection. The EMB + E. coli isolation frequency was also lower in treated birds; no E. coli was detectable in blood samples on any sampling day, and E. coli were isolated only in the liver, heart, and spleen of treated chickens at a ratio of 2/6, 1/6, and 3/6, respectively, at d 1 postinfection. The BW of birds from the E. coli-challenged group treated with bacteriophage EC1 were not significantly different from those of birds from both control groups but were 15.4% higher than those of the untreated, E. coli-challenged group on d 21 postinfection. The total mortality rate of birds during the 3-wk experimental period decreased from 83.3% in the untreated, E. coli-challenged birds (group IV) to 13.3% in birds treated with bacteriophage EC1 (group III). These results suggest that bacteriophage EC1 is effective in vivo and could be used to treat colibacillosis in chickens.

Effect of selection for resistance and susceptibility to viral diseases on concentrations of dopamine and immunological parameters in six-week-old chickens

White Leghorn chickens were inbred respectively from their parent lines, which were diversely selected for resistance (line 6(3)) or susceptibility (lines 7(2) and 15I(5)) to Marek's disease and lymphoid leukosis. The differences in disease resistance may have been due to differential regulation of immune and neuroendocrine homeostasis. At 5 wk of age, chickens from the same line were randomly assigned to cages at 4 birds per cage. Blood samples were collected from the chickens at 6 wk of age (n = 10/line). Subsets of T lymphocytes (CD4+ and CD8+) and B cells were measured using flow cytometry. Concentrations of plasma IgG and dopamine were quantified with ELISA and HPLC assay, respectively. Line 6(3) chickens had a higher percentage of CD8+ cells but not CD4+ cells than the chickens of the lines 7(2) and 15I(5) (P < 0.01). In contrast, both lines 7(2) and 15I(5) had a greater percentage of B cells (P < 0.01). The concentrations of plasma IgG and dopamine were also regulated differently among the lines; both were in an order of 7(2) > 15I(5) > 6(3) (P < 0.05 and P < 0.01, respectively). These results suggested that genetic selection for disease resistance also directly or indirectly modified the corresponding genetic components that govern the immune and neuroendocrine systems. The genetic lines of chickens may be used as animal models for investigation of the cellular mechanisms of genetic-environmental interactions on disease resistance.

Defining susceptibility of broiler chicks to colibacillosis

This study aimed to define the susceptibility of broilers to colibacillosis through quantification of clinical responses and to examine the relationship between susceptibility and growth retardation. A challenge experiment was carried out twice. In each trial, 192 chicks were challenged intratracheally with Escherichia coli (E. coli) at 7 days of age and 160 chicks served as controls. Surviving chicks were euthanized at 14 or 15 days. Parameters measured were: daily mortality, lesion scores, body weight at 1, 4, 7, 10, 12 and 14 or 15 days and feeding behaviour at 6, 11 and 13 days. The results were reproducible, and increasing susceptibility to colibacillosis was defined by four categories: chicks without lesions, chicks with airsacculitis but no systemic lesions, chicks with systemic lesions, and chicks that die. Increasing susceptibility was associated with increasing growth retardation, but growth retardation was not inevitably linked to challenge with E. coli.

Pulse and continuous oral norfloxacin treatment of experimentally induced Escherichia coli infection in broiler chicks and turkey poults

Experimental colibacillosis was produced in 40 healthy, 7-day-old broiler chickens and turkeys by intratracheal injection of 1 x 10(8) CFU/chick and 1.23 x 10(9) CFU/poult bacteria of an O1:F11 strain of Escherichia coli, respectively. Two days before E. coli challenge all chicks were vaccinated with a live attenuated strain of infectious bronchitis virus (H-52). This model of infection--at least in chicken--proved to be useful for evaluating the efficacy of antimicrobial medication, by recording mortality, body weight gain, pathological alterations and frequency of reisolation of E. coli. Using this model, the efficacy of two different dosing methods of norfloxacin (continuous and pulse dosing) was evaluated. The once-per-day pulse dosing of norfloxacin administered via the drinking water at 15 mg/kg body weight proved to be more efficacious than the continuous dosing method of 100 mg/L for 5 days in chickens, while there were no convincing differences between the two treatment regimens in turkeys. The results confirmed earlier observations on the pharmacokinetic properties of norfloxacin in chicks and turkeys (Laczay et al., 1998).

Effect of genetic selection for group productivity and longevity on immunological and hematological parameters of chickens

A line of White Leghorn chickens was selected for high group productivity and longevity resulting in improved survival and feather score as well as reduced cannibalism and flightiness. Improvements in survival might have also been due to improved immunity. The present study was designed to test the hypothesis that selection for high (HGPS) and low (LGPS) group productivity and survivability also altered immune and hematological parameters. The LGPS line was an intense reverse selected line of the HGPS line at the eighth generation of development. Hens were randomly assigned to individual cages at 17 wk of age. Blood samples were collected from the hens at 21 wk of age. Subsets of T lymphocytes (CD4+, CD8+, and gammadelta cells) were measured using flow cytometry. Concentrations of plasma IgG were quantified with western blot analysis and immunoprecipitation assay. Hematological parameters were collected from blood smears. The HGPS hens had significantly higher percentages of blood lymphocytes and CD4+:CD8+ ratios of circulating T cells (P < 0.01) and tended to have more, but not significantly, gammadelta T cells (P = 0.07) than the LGPS hens. In contrast, the LGPS hens exhibited eosinophilia and heterophilia and greater heterophil:lymphocyte ratios (P < 0.01). The concentrations of plasma IgG were also significantly higher in the LGPS hens (P < 0.01). These results suggest that genetic selection for group productivity and longevity also alters the immunological and hematological systems of hens. The line difference in regulation of T cells, leukocytes, and production of IgG may suggest that different genes or modes of gene action are involved.

Comparison of the efficacies of three fluoroquinolone antimicrobial agents, given as continuous or pulsed-water medication, against Escherichia coli infection in chickens

This study compared the efficacy of continuous or pulsed-water medication with enrofloxacin, danofloxacin, and sarafloxacin in eight groups of 90 chicks each by using an infectious bronchitis virus-Escherichia coli model of colisepticemia. The model produced lesions of typical those occurring in birds with severe colisepticemia; for the infected, nonmedicated birds the mortality was 43.5% and the morbidity was 89%, 17.8% of birds had severe lesions, and the birds had a mean air sac lesion score of 2.58. This experiment showed that continuous dosing and pulsed dosing are clinically equivalent. However, for all fluoroquinolones studied, there was a trend for the continuously mediated birds to have lower mortality and less severe disease than birds receiving pulsed doses. Compared with infected, nonmedicated controls, only birds continuously medicated with enrofloxacin had a significantly lower morbidity (32%), and only birds medicated with enrofloxacin and danofloxacin (continuous and pulsed treatments) had significantly lower mortality (6.7 and 11.0% and 16.8 and 19.2% for continuous and pulsed treatments with enrofloxacin and danofloxacin, respectively). A significantly lower proportion of birds only in the groups medicated with enrofloxacin had severe lesions (for birds receiving continuous and pulsed treatments, 2.2 and 6.7%, respectively). Birds medicated with any of the three fluoroquinolones (continuous and pulsed treatments) except pulsed-water treatment with sarafloxacin had significantly reduced mean air sac lesion scores compared with the scores for nonmedicated birds (air sac lesion scores, 0.60 and 0.83, 1.38 and 1.63, and 1.80 and 2.05 for birds receiving continuous and pulsed treatments with enrofloxacin, danofloxacin, and sarafloxacin, respectively). The performance of the birds that survived the challenge or that recovered after receiving medication was not compromised compared to the performance of noninfected birds. Enrofloxacin was more efficacious than either danofloxacin or sarafloxacin for the treatment of colisepticemia in chickens by medication in drinking water. Similarly, danofloxacin appeared to be more effective than sarafloxacin in treating colisepticemia.

Variation in toe-web response of turkey poults to phytohemagglutinin-P and their resistance to Escherichia coli challenge

One thousand 5-wk-old male turkeys from each of two commercial strains (A and B) were grouped into low, medium, and high responders based on the cutaneous basophil hypersensitivity (CBH) response obtained 24 h after toe-web inoculation with 100 micrograms of phytohemagglutinin-P (PHA-P). The CBH response for Strain A was higher than strain B (P = 0.00001) and ranged from 0 to 1.95 mm, with a mean of 0.66, whereas the CBH response for Strain B ranged from 0 to 1.67 mm with a mean of 0.38. At 6 wk of age, 36 birds from each of the six response groups were inoculated into the left thoracic air sac with 1.5 x 10(7) cfu of an early log phase broth culture of Escherichia coli. Samples of 5 or 10 birds were necropsied from each of the six groups at 7, 14, 28, and 42 d postinfection (PI). Birds were scored for air-sacculitis/pericarditis (AS) and turkey osteomyelitis complex (TOC). Overall mortality of birds inoculated with E. coli was 31%. There were no mortalities in unchallenged controls. Strain A had significantly higher Week 1 mortality, marginally higher overall mortality (P = 0.1), and higher AS scores than Strain B. There were no TOC lesions detected until 7 d PI, after which all mortalities had TOC lesions in multiple sites. The differences in CBH response within each strain were not clearly correlated to E. coli susceptibility. However, these data suggest that air sac inoculation of E. coli can provide a useful model for the study of TOC. The greater incidence of disease in Strain A indicates that an enhanced inflammatory response may increase susceptibility to E. coli septicemia.

Effect of tumor necrosis factor-alpha on progesterone production by granulosa cells in laying hens of different genetic lines

In vitro progesterone production by granulosa cells in the presence or absence of human recombinant tumor necrosis factor-alpha (hrTNF-alpha) was measured at 10, 20, and 30 wk of egg production in White Leghorn hens selected for high (HA)- or low-antibody (LA) response to sheep red blood cell challenge. Isolated granulosa cells from the three largest preovulatory follicles (F1-F3) were incubated with 5 or 250 ng/ml hrTNF-alpha, and progesterone production was determined by the use of a validated radioimmunoassay. F1, F2 and F3 granulosa cells from HA hens produced more (P < or = 0.05) progesterone (140.8, 107.2, and 49.7 ng/ml) than LA hens (109.4, 78.9, and 26.9 ng/ml). The treatment of granulosa cells with hrTNF-alpha consistently inhibited (P < or = 0.05) progesterone secretion by all follicles among HA and LA hens, but not always at both doses. Generally, 5 ng/ml hrTNF-alpha was the maximum inhibitory dose. In the laying hen, a decrease in steroid production in response to cytokines may upset the steroid balance created by follicular hierarchy and inhibit or delay ovulation.

Immunoresponsiveness in chickens: association of antibody production and the B system of the major histocompatibility complex

Lines of White Leghorn chickens were selected for high or low antibody response to sheep erythrocytes for five generations. The base population from which the experiment started was composed of individuals all of which were heterozygous at the MHC haplotypes B13 and B21. Body weights, egg production traits, and genotypes at the B system were monitored for all individuals in each generation. By Generations 4 and 5 there was separation of the two replicate lines selected for high titer from the two replicate lines selected for low titer. Over the course of the experiment, higher antibody titers and lower BW were associated with B21 and lower antibody titers and higher BW were associated with B13, although these relationships did not occur in every instance. Conclusions were that the B system was associated with antibody response, but that the chickens did not depend entirely upon that association for protection against foreign proteins. Also, the importance of having replicate lines in a selection experiment was shown.

Comparison of performance and mortality in the hybro normal and hybro giant meat poultry breeders and their offspring

The performance and mortality of similarly managed parent flocks of Hybro Normal and Hybro Giant meat poultry was compared. The overall daily egg production at 6-9 months of age was insignificantly greater in the Hybro Normal compared to the Hybro Giant parents (p > 0.05). The Hybro Normal parents had a significantly higher average daily egg production (56.08%) compared to that of the Hybro Giant parents (52.03%) during their sixth month of age, one month before the production peak (p < 0.05). The Hydro Giant parent-males had a significantly higher average daily mortality during the sixth and seventh months of age compared to the parent males of the Hybro Normal breed (p < 0.05); however, the females of the Hybro Normal parents had a significantly higher daily mortality during the sixth month of age compared to the Hybro Giant parent females (p < 0.05). The percentage hatchability was significantly lower in eggs collected from Hybro Giant birds compared to those collected from the Hybro Normal birds during the sixth and ninth months of age. The mean live weights at 45-days old of five flocks of Hybro Normal offspring was 1535 g compared to a mean live weight of 1870 g of five similarly managed flocks of the offspring of the Hybro Giant birds (p < 0.05). The feed conversion by the offspring of both breeds was not significantly different (p > 0.05). The mean percentage lameness in the five flocks of the offspring was 2.34% for Hybro Normal and 9.26% for Hybro Giant (p < 0.05). In summary, the overall performance of the Hybro Normal parent stock was superior to the Hybro Giant breeders regarding egg production and hatchability of their eggs; however, the weight gain of the Hybro Giant broiler flocks was superior to that of the Hybro Normal, but this was associated with a higher incidence of lameness.

Evaluation of resistance of four strains of commercial laying hens to experimental infection with Salmonella enteritidis phage type eight

Four different strains of White Leghorn hens were orally infected with 1 x 10(8) cfu of Salmonella enteritidis phage Type 8 per bird. The birds were monitored for 10 wk postinfection for colonization of internal organs, fecal shedding of S. enteritidis, and the production of S. enteritidis-contaminated eggs. There was no difference among the four hen strains in regards to the probability of S. enteritidis isolation from liver and spleen, ovary, and cecal tissue within the first 30 d postinfection. However, during the first 14 d postinfection, S. enteritidis organisms were isolated in significantly higher rates from eggs and fecal samples of Strain A than from samples obtained from the other three hen strains. Results suggest that there may be inherent differences between strains of laying hens with regard to their response to infection with S. enteritidis.

Antibody responses to combinations of antigens in white Leghorn chickens of different background genomes and major histocompatibility complex genotypes

Antibody responses in chickens to SRBC, Newcastle disease (NDV), and Brucella abortus (BA) were compared when given singly or in combination. Chickens used in the present experiment originated from a cross and then backcrossing of White Leghorn populations that had been selected for high (HA) or low (LA) antibody response to SRBC antigens. The populations used in the current study were segregating for MHC haplotypes B13 and B21. The experiment had a 2 x 3 x 6 factorial arrangement of treatments (two background genomes: HA and LA; three MHC haplotypes: B13B13, B13B21, and B21B21; and six antigen treatments: SRBC, NDV, or BA only, SRBC plus NDV, SRBC plus BA, and NDV plus BA). Antigens were administered either i.v. (SRBC) or i.m. (NDV and BA) when chicks were 42 days of age. Blood was obtained 27 days later (69 days of age) for antibody determinations. A significant background genome by MHC haplotype interaction for BA antibodies was due to relatively high titers in Line HA chickens of MHC genotypes B13B13 and B13B21. Background genome by MHC genotype interactions were not significant for SRBC or NDV antibodies. Antibody titers to SRBC were higher in background genome HA than LA, and similar among MHC genotypes. Antibodies to NDV were lower in chickens of MHC genotype B21B21, but there were no differences due to background genome. For each of the three antigens, antibody responses were highest when administered singly rather than in combination. Antibody titers were lower for SRBC when given with BA, and for BA titers when given with NDV.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)