Modelling the HPRT-gene mutation induction of particle beams: systematic in vitro data collection, analysis and microdosimetric kinetic model implementation

Objective. Since the early years, particle therapy treatments have been associated with concerns for late toxicities, especially secondary cancer risk (SCR). Nowadays, this concern is related to patients for whom long-term survival is expected (e.g. breast cancer, lymphoma, paediatrics). In the aim to contribute to this research, we present a dedicated statistical and modelling analysis aiming at improving our understanding of the RBE for mutation induction ( RBE M ˜ ) for different particle species. Approach. We built a new database based on a systematic collection of RBE data for mutation assays of the gene encoding for the purine salvage enzyme hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase from literature (105 entries, distributed among 3 cell lines and 16 particle species). The data were employed to perform statistical and modelling analysis. For the latter, we adapted the microdosimetric kinetic model (MKM) to describe the mutagenesis in analogy to lethal lesion induction. Main results. Correlation analysis between RBE for survival (RBES) and RBE M ˜ reveals significant correlation between these two quantities (ρ = 0.86, p < 0.05). The correlation gets stronger when looking at subsets of data based on cell line and particle species. We also show that the MKM can be successfully employed to describe RBE M ˜ , obtaining comparably good agreement with the experimental data. Remarkably, to improve the agreement with experimental data the MKM requires, consistently in all the analysed cases, a reduced domain size for the description of mutation induction compared to that adopted for survival. Significance. We were able to show that RBES and RBE M ˜ are strongly related quantities. We also showed for the first time that the MKM could be successfully applied to the description of mutation induction, representing an endpoint different from the more traditional cell killing. In analogy to the RBES, RBE M ˜ can be implemented into treatment planning system evaluations.

Radiobiological damage by space radiation: extension of the BIANCA model to heavy ions up to iron, and pilot application to cosmic ray exposure

Space research seems to be object of a renewed interest, also considering that human missions to the Moon, and possibly Mars, are being planned. Among the risks affecting such missions, astronauts' exposure to space radiation is a major concern. In this work, the question of the evaluation of biological damage by Galactic Cosmic Rays (GCR) was addressed by a biophysical model called BIophysical ANalysis of Cell death and chromosome Aberrations (BIANCA), which simulates the induction of cell death and chromosome aberrations by different ions. While previously BIANCA has been validated for calculating cell death along hadrontherapy beams up to oxygen, herein the approach was extended up to Fe ions. Specifically, experimental survival curves available in literature for V79 cells irradiated by Si-, Ne-, Ar- and Fe-ions were reproduced, and a reference radiobiological database describing V79 cell survival as a function of ion type (1 ⩽Z⩽ 26), energy and dose was constructed. Analogous databases were generated for Chinese hamster ovary hamster cells and human skin fibroblasts, finding good agreement between simulations and data. Concerning chromosome aberrations, which are regarded as radiation risk biomarkers, dicentric data in human lymphocytes irradiated by heavy ions up to iron were reproduced, and a radiobiological database allowing calculation of lymphocyte dicentric yields as a function of dose, ion type (1 ⩽Z⩽ 26) and energy was constructed. Following interface between BIANCA and the FLUKA Monte Carlo transport code, a feasibility study was performed to calculate the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of different GCR spectrum components, for both dicentrics and cell death. Fe-ions, although representing only 10% of the total absorbed dose, were found to be responsible for about 35%-40% of the RBE-weighted dose. Interestingly, the RBE for dicentrics was higher than that for cell survival. More generally, this work shows that BIANCA can calculate RBE values for cell death and lymphocyte dicentrics not only for ion therapy, but also for space radiation.

First benchmarking of the BIANCA model for cell survival prediction in a clinical hadron therapy scenario

In the framework of RBE modelling for hadron therapy, the BIANCA biophysical model was extended to O-ions and was used to construct a radiobiological database describing the survival of V79 cells as a function of ion type (1  ⩽  Z  ⩽  8) and energy. This database allowed performing RBE predictions in very good agreement with experimental data. A method was then developed to construct analogous databases for different cell lines, starting from the V79 database as a reference. Following interface to the FLUKA Monte Carlo radiation transport code, BIANCA was then applied for the first time to predict cell survival in a typical patient treatment scenario, consisting of two opposing fields of range-equivalent protons or C-ions. The model predictions were found to be in good agreement with CHO cell survival data obtained at the Heidelberg ion-beam therapy (HIT) centre, as well as predictions performed by the local effect model (version LEM IV). This work shows that BIANCA can be used to predict cell survival and RBE not only for V79 and AG01522 cells, as shown previously, but also, in principle, for any cell line of interest. Furthermore, following interface to a transport code like FLUKA, BIANCA can provide predictions of 3D biological dose distributions for hadron therapy treatments, thus laying the foundations for future applications in clinics.

Delayed effects of accelerated heavy ions on the induction of HPRT mutations in V79 hamster cells

Fundamental research on the harmful effects of ionizing radiation on living cells continues to be of great interest. Recently, priority has been given to the study of high-charge and high-energy (HZE) ions that comprise a substantial part of the galactic cosmic ray (GCR) spectra that would be encountered during long-term space flights. Moreover, predictions of the delayed genetic effects of high linear energy transfer (LET) exposure is becoming more important as heavy ion therapy use is increasing. This work focuses mainly on the basic research on the delayed effects of HZE ions on V79 Chinese hamster cells, with emphasis on the induction of HPRT mutations after prolonged expression times (ET). The research was conducted under various irradiation conditions with accelerated ions ¹⁸O (E=35.2MeV/n), ²⁰Ne (E=47.7MeV/n and 51.8MeV/n), and ¹¹B (E=32.4MeV/n), with LET in the range from 49 to 149 keV/μm and with ⁶⁰Co γ-rays. The HPRT mutant fractions (MF) were detected in irradiated cells in regular intervals during every cell culture recultivation (every 3days) up to approximately 40days (70-80 generations) after irradiation. The MF maximum was reached at different ET depending on ionizing radiation characteristics. The position of the maximum was shifting towards longer ET with increasing LET. We speculate that the delayed mutations are created de novo and that they are the manifestation of genomic instability. Although the exact mechanisms involved in genomic instability initiation are yet to be identified, we hypothesize that differences in induction of delayed mutations by radiations with various LET values are related to variations in energy deposition along the particle track. A dose dependence of mutation yield is discussed as well.

Modelling of organ-specific radiation-induced secondary cancer risks following particle therapy

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Radiation-induced cancer is a serious late effect that may follow radiotherapy. A considerable uncertainty is associated with carcinogenesis from photon-based treatment, and even less established when including relative biological effectiveness (RBE) for particle therapy. The aim of this work was therefore to estimate and in particular explore relative risks (RR) of secondary cancer (SC) following particle therapy as applied in treatment of prostate cancer.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

RRs of radiation-induced SC in the bladder and rectum were estimated using a bell-shaped dose-response model incorporating RBE and fractionation effects. The risks from volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) were compared to intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT) and scanning carbon ions for ten patients.

RESULTS

The mean estimated RR (95% CI) of SC for VMAT/C-ion was 1.31 (0.65-2.18) for the bladder and 0.58 (0.41-0.80) for the rectum. Corresponding values for VMAT/IMPT were 1.72 (1.06-2.37) and 1.10 (0.78-1.43). The radio-sensitivity parameter α had the strongest influence on the results with decreasing RR for increasing values of α.

CONCLUSION

Based on the wide spread in RR between patients and variations across the included parameter values, the risk profiles of the rectum and bladder were not dramatically different for the investigated radiotherapy techniques.

Low-radiation environment affects the development of protection mechanisms in V79 cells

Very little is known about the influence of environmental radiation on living matter. In principle, important information can be acquired by analysing possible differences between parallel biological systems, one in a reference-radiation environment (RRE) and the other in a low-radiation environment (LRE). We took advantage of the unique opportunity represented by the cell culture facilities at the Gran Sasso National Laboratories of the Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, where environment dose rate reduction factors in the underground (LRE), with respect to the external laboratory (RRE), are as follows: 10(3) for neutrons, 10(7) for directly ionizing cosmic rays and 10 for total γ-rays. Chinese hamster V79 cells were cultured for 10 months in both RRE and LRE. At the end of this period, all the cultures were kept in RRE for another 6 months. Changes in the activities of antioxidant enzymes (superoxide dismutase, SOD; catalase, CAT; glutathione peroxidase, GPX) and spontaneous mutation frequency at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (hprt) locus were investigated. The results obtained suggest that environmental radiation might act as a trigger of defence mechanisms in V79 cells, specifically those in reference conditions, showing a higher degree of defence against endogenous damage as compared to cells grown in a very low-radiation environment. Our findings corroborate the hypothesis that environmental radiation contributes to the development of defence mechanisms in today living organisms/systems.

Constitutive expression of tdTomato protein as a cytotoxicity and proliferation marker for space radiation biology

The radiation risk assessment for long-term space missions requires knowledge on the biological effectiveness of different space radiation components, e.g. heavy ions, on the interaction of radiation and other space environmental factors such as microgravity, and on the physical and biological dose distribution in the human body. Space experiments and ground-based experiments at heavy ion accelerators require fast and reliable test systems with an easy readout for different endpoints. In order to determine the effect of different radiation qualities on cellular proliferation and the biological depth dose distribution after heavy ion exposure, a stable human cell line expressing a novel fluorescent protein was established and characterized. tdTomato, a red fluorescent protein of the new generation with fast maturation and high fluorescence intensity, was selected as reporter of cell proliferation. Human embryonic kidney (HEK/293) cells were stably transfected with a plasmid encoding tdTomato under the control of the constitutively active cytomegalovirus (CMV) promoter (ptdTomato-N1). The stably transfected cell line was named HEK-ptdTomato-N1 8. This cytotoxicity biosensor was tested by ionizing radiation (X-rays and accelerated heavy ions) exposure. As biological endpoints, the proliferation kinetics and the cell density reached 100 h after irradiation reflected by constitutive expression of the tdTomato were investigated. Both were reduced dose-dependently after radiation exposure. Finally, the cell line was used for biological weighting of heavy ions of different linear energy transfer (LET) as space-relevant radiation quality. The relative biological effectiveness of accelerated heavy ions in reducing cellular proliferation peaked at an LET of 91 keV/μm. The results of this study demonstrate that the HEK-ptdTomato-N1 reporter cell line can be used as a fast and reliable biosensor system for detection of cytotoxic damage caused by ionizing radiation.

In vitro RBE-LET dependence for multiple particle types

BACKGROUND

In vitro RBE values for various high LET radiation types have been determined for many different cell types. Occasionally it is criticized that RBE for a given endpoint cannot be single-value dependent on LET alone, but also on particle species, due to the different dose deposition profiles on microscopic scale. Hence LET is not sufficient as a predictor of RBE, and this is one of the motivations for development of radiobiological models which explicitly depend on the detailed particle energy spectrum of the applied radiation field. The aim of the present study is to summarize the available data in the literature regarding the dependency of RBE on LET for different particles.

METHOD

As RBE is highly dependent on cell type and endpoint, we discriminated the RBE-LET relationship for the three investigated cell lines and at the same endpoint (10% survival in colony formation). Data points were collected from 20, four and four publications for V79, CHO and T1, respectively, in total covering 228 RBE values from a broad range of particle species.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

All RBE-LET data points demonstrate surprising agreement within the general error band formed by the numerous data points, and display the expected RBE peak at around 100-200 keV/μm. For all three cell lines, the influence of varying the particle type on the RBE was far from obvious, compared to the general experimental noise. Therefore, a dependence of particle type cannot be concluded, and LET alone in fact does seem to be an adequate parameter for describing RBE at 10% survival.

Carbon-ion-induced activation of the NF-κB pathway

Carbon-ion cancer therapy offers several physical and radiobiological advantages over conventional photon cancer therapy. The molecular mechanisms that determine cellular outcome, including the activation of transcription factors and the alteration of gene expression profiles, after carbon-ion exposure are still under investigation. We have previously shown that argon ions (LET 272 keV/µm) had a much higher potential to activate the transcription factor nuclear factor κB (NF-κB) than X rays. NF-κB is involved in the regulation of cellular survival, mostly by antiapoptosis and cell cycle-regulating target genes, which are important in the resistance of cancer cells to radiotherapy. Therefore, activation of the NF-κB pathway by accelerated carbon ions (LET 33 and 73 keV/µm) was examined. For comparison, cells were exposed to 150 kV X rays and to accelerated carbon ions. NF-κB-dependent gene induction after exposure was detected in stably transfected human 293 reporter cells. Carbon ions and X rays had a comparable potential to activate NF-κB in human cells, indicating a comparable usefulness of pharmacological NF-κB inhibition during photon and carbon-ion radiotherapy.

Detailed probabilistic modelling of cell inactivation by ionizing radiations of different qualities: the model and its applications

The probabilistic two-stage model of cell killing by ionizing radiation enables to represent both damage induction by radiation and its repair by the cell. The model properties and applications as well as possible interpretation of the underlying damage classification are discussed. Analyses of published survival data for V79 hamster cells irradiated by protons and He, C, O, and Ne ions are reported, quantifying the variations in radiation quality with increasing charge and linear energy transfer of the ions.

Cell killing, nuclear damage and apoptosis in Chinese hamster V79 cells after irradiation with heavy-ion beams of (16)O, (12)C and (7)Li

Chinese hamster V79 cells were exposed to high LET (linear energy transfer) (16)O-beam (625keV/mum) radiation in the dose range of 0-9.83Gy. Cell survival, micronuclei (MN), chromosomal aberrations (CA) and induction of apoptosis were studied as a follow up of our earlier study on high LET radiations ((7)Li-beam of 60keV/mum and (12)C-beam of 295keV/mum) as well as (60)Co gamma-rays. Dose dependent decline in surviving fraction was noticed along with the increase of MN frequency, CA frequency as well as percentage of apoptosis as detected by nuclear fragmentation assay. The relative intensity of DNA ladder, which is a useful marker for the determination of the extent of apoptosis induction, was also increased in a dose dependent manner. Additionally, expression of tyrosine kinase lck-1 gene, which plays an important role in response to ionizing radiation induced apoptosis, was increased with the increase of radiation doses and also with incubation time. The present study showed that all the high LET radiations were generally more effective in cell killing and inflicting other cytogenetic damages than that of low LET gamma-rays. The dose response curves revealed that (7)Li-beam was most effective in cell killing as well as inducing other nuclear damages followed by (12)C, (16)O and (60)Co gamma-rays, in that order. The result of this study may have some application in biological dosimetry for assessment of genotoxicity in heavy ion exposed subjects and in determining suitable doses for radiotherapy in cancer patients where various species of heavy ions are now being generally used.

Response to high LET radiation 12C (LET, 295 keV/microm) in M5 cells, a radio resistant cell strain derived from Chinese hamster V79 cells

PURPOSE

To study the effects of 12C-beam of 295 keV/microm (57.24 MeV) on M5 and Chinese hamster V79 cells by using cytogenetic assays like micronuclei (MN) induction, chromosomal aberrations (CA) and apoptosis. Additionally, the relative survival of these two cell lines was tested by the colony forming ability of the cells, with a view to understanding the mechanism of cellular damages that lead to difference in cell survival.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Confluent cells were irradiated with 12C-beam at various doses using 15UD Pelletron accelerator. Cell survival was studied by the colony forming ability of cells. MN assay was done by fluorescent staining. Different types of chromosomal aberrations in metaphase cells were scored at 12 h after irradiation. Apoptosis was measured at different post irradiation times as detected by nuclear fragmentation and DNA ladder was prepared after 48 h of incubation.

RESULTS

Dose-dependent decrease in surviving fractions was found in both the cell lines. However, the surviving fractions were higher in M5 cells in comparison to V79 cells when exposed to the same radiation doses. On the other hand, induced MN frequencies, CA frequencies and apoptosis percentages were less in M5 cells than V79 cells. Very good correlations between surviving fractions and induced MN frequencies or induced total CA or induced apoptosis percentages were obtained in this study.

CONCLUSIONS

The cell strain M5 showed relatively more radio-resistance to 12C-beam compared to Chinese hamster V79 cells in this study. As the MN formation, CA and apoptosis induction were less in M5 cells as compared to parental V79 cells, the higher cell survival in the former could possibly be attributed to their better repairing ability leading to higher cell survival.

Genotoxic effects in M5 cells and Chinese hamster V79 cells after exposure to 7Li-beam (LET=60 keV/microm) and correlation of their survival dynamics to nuclear damages and cell death

Chinese hamster V79 cell and a cell strain M5, derived from V79 cells and reported to be relatively resistant to gamma-ray, hydrogen peroxide, and N-methyl-N-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG; a potent human carcinogen), were exposed to high LET (7)Li-beam (LET=60 keV/microm) at approximately 90% confluent state in the dose range of 0-1 Gy. Effects of (7)Li-beam exposure on cell survival, micronuclei induction (MN), chromosomal aberrations (CA) and apoptosis were compared in both the cell lines. A dose-dependent decline in survival for both the cell lines was noted, relatively less in M5 cells (mostly p<0.01) indicating greater radio-resistance in this strain. The MN, CA and apoptosis increased in a dose-dependent manner in both V79 and M5 cells. Significant differences in various other parameters between these two cell lines were also noted. The relative intensity of DNA ladder, which is a useful marker for the determination of the extent of apoptosis induction, was much higher in V79 cells. A good correlation between the reduction of the surviving fractions and the increase in frequencies of MN or CA or apoptosis was noted for both the cell lines.

Cellular and molecular effects for mutation induction in normal human cells irradiated with accelerated neon ions

We investigated the linear energy transfer (LET) dependence of mutation induction on the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT) locus in normal human fibroblast-like cells irradiated with accelerated neon-ion beams. The cells were irradiated with neon-ion beams at various LETs ranging from 63 to 335 keV/microm. Neon-ion beams were accelerated by the Riken Ring Cyclotron at the Institute of Physical and Chemical Research in Japan. Mutation induction at the HPRT locus was detected to measure 6-thioguanine-resistant clones. The mutation spectrum of the deletion pattern of exons of mutants was analyzed using the multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR). The dose-response curves increased steeply up to 0.5 Gy and leveled off or decreased between 0.5 and 1.0 Gy, compared to the response to (137)Cs gamma-rays. The mutation frequency increased up to 105 keV/microm and then there was a downward trend with increasing LET values. The deletion pattern of exons was non-specific. About 75-100% of the mutants produced using LETs ranging from 63 to 335 keV/mum showed all or partial deletions of exons, while among gamma-ray-induced mutants 30% showed no deletions, 30% partial deletions and 40% complete deletions. These results suggested that the dose-response curves of neon-ion-induced mutations were dependent upon LET values, but the deletion pattern of DNA was not.

Detailed analysis of the cell-inactivation mechanism by accelerated protons and light ions

A detailed study of the biological effects of diverse quality radiations, addressing their biophysical interpretation, is presented. Published survival data for V79 cells irradiated by monoenergetic protons, helium-3, carbon and oxygen ions and for CHO cells irradiated by carbon ions have been analysed using the probabilistic two-stage model of cell inactivation. Three different classes of DNA damage formed by traversing particles have been distinguished, namely severe single-track lesions which might lead to cell inactivation directly, less severe lesions where cell inactivation is caused by their combinations and lesions of negligible severity that can be repaired easily. Probabilities of single ions forming these lesions have been assessed in dependence on their linear energy transfer (LET) values. Damage induction probabilities increase with atomic number and LET. While combined lesions play a crucial role at lower LET values, single-track damage dominates in high-LET regions. The yields of single-track lethal lesions for protons have been compared with Monte Carlo estimates of complex DNA lesions, indicating that lethal events correlate well with complex DNA double-strand breaks. The decrease in the single-track damage probability for protons of LET above approximately 30 keV microm(-1), suggested by limited experimental evidence, is discussed, together with the consequent differences in the mechanisms of biological effects between protons and heavier ions. Applications of the results in hadrontherapy treatment planning are outlined.

LET and ion species dependence for cell killing in normal human skin fibroblasts

We studied the LET and ion species dependence of the RBE for cell killing to clarify the differences in the biological effects caused by the differences in the track structure that result from the different energy depositions for different ions. Normal human skin fibroblasts were irradiated with heavy-ion beams such as carbon, neon, silicon and iron ions that were generated by the Heavy Ion Medical Accelerator in Chiba (HIMAC) at the National Institute of Radiological Science (NIRS) in Japan. Cell killing was measured as reproductive cell death using a colony formation assay. The RBE-LET curves were different for carbon ions and for the other ions. The curve for carbon ions increased steeply up to around 98 keV/microm. The RBE of carbon ions at 98 keV/microm was 4.07. In contrast, the curves for neon, silicon and iron ions had maximum peaks around 180 keV/microm, and the RBEs at the peak position ranged from 3.03 to 3.39. When the RBEs were plotted as a function of Z*2/beta2 (where Z* is the effective charge and beta is the relative velocity of the ion) instead of LET, the discrepancies between the RBE-LET curves for the different ion beams were reduced, but branching of the RBE-Z*2/beta2 curves still remained. When the inactivation cross section was plotted as a function of either LET or Z*2/beta2, it increased with increasing LET. However, the inactivation cross section was always smaller than the geometrical cross section. These results suggest that the differences in the energy deposition track structures of the different ion sources have an effect on cell killing.

Mutations Induced by Heavy Charged Particles

The relative biological-effectiveness of radiation is increased when cells or tissue are exposed to densely ionizing (high-LET) radiation. A large number of studies focus on the following aspects of the biological effects of high-LET radiation: (i) basic understanding of radiation damage and repair; (ii) developing radiotherapy protocols for accelerated charged particles; and (iii) estimation of human risks from exposure to high-LET heavy charged particles. The increased lethal effectiveness (cell inactivation) of high-LET radiation contributes to new methods for using radiation therapy, but it is also necessary to study the enhanced mutagenic effect of high LET radiation, because higher frequencies of mutation can be expected to provide higher rates of carcinogenicity with human exposure. It is important to note that both measures of biological effectiveness (lethality and mutagenicity) depend on the quality of radiation, the dose, dose-rate effects, and the biological endpoints studied. This paper is intended to provide a review of current research on the mutagenic effects of high-LET radiation, and is organized into three sections. First, are descriptions of the induced mutations studied with various detection systems (section 1) because the detectable mutations induced by ionizing radiation, including heavy-ions, depend largely on the detection system used. Second is a discussion of the biological significance of the dependence of induced mutations on LET (section 2). This is related to the molecular nature of radiation lesions and to the repair mechanisms used to help cells recover from such damage. Finally, applications of mutation detection systems for studies in space (section 3) are described, in which the carcinogenic effects of space environmental radiation are considered.

A microdosimetric-kinetic model for the effect of non-Poisson distribution of lethal lesions on the variation of RBE with LET

The microdosimetric-kinetic (MK) model for cell killing by ionizing radiation is summarized. An equation based on the MK model is presented which gives the dependence of the relative biological effectiveness in the limit of zero dose (RBE1) on the linear energy transfer (LET). The relationship coincides with the linear relationship of RBE1 and LET observed for low LET, which is characteristic of a Poisson distribution of lethal lesions among the irradiated cells. It incorporates the effect of deviation from the Poisson distribution at higher LET. This causes RBE1 to be less than indicated by extrapolation of the linear relationship to higher LET, and to pass through a maximum in the range of LET of 50 to 200 keV per micrometer. The relationship is compared with several experimental studies from the literature. It is shown to approximately fit their results with a reasonable choice for the value of a cross-sectional area related to the morphology and ultrastructure of the cell nucleus. The model and the experiments examined indicate that the more sensitive cells are to radiation at low LET, the lower will be the maximum in RBE they attain as LET increases. An equation that portrays the ratio of the sensitivity of a pair of cell types as a function of LET is presented. Implications for radiotherapy with high-LET radiation are discussed.

Mutagenic effects of heavy charged particles

Heavy charged particles constitute the most important radiation risk in space. Since mutations can give rise to cancer the investigation of their induction may be helpful for risk quantification. This paper describes experiments in a number of mammalian cells performed with a large range of linear energy transfer (LET). RBE values are always found to increase with LET up to about 100 keV/microm and are similar to those suggested by ICRP. Molecular analyses demonstrate that heavy charged particles not only lead to sometimes very large deletions but also to smaller changes which might represent point mutations. Recent evidence shows that repair phenomena play an important role in the processing of initial DNA lesions to mutagenic alterations.

Cell inactivation and double-strand breaks: the role of core ionizations, as probed by ultrasoft X rays

The large RBE (approximately 7) measured for the killing of Chinese hamster V79 cells by 340 eV ultrasoft X rays, which preferentially ionize the K shell of carbon atoms (Hervé du Penhoat et al., Radiat. Res. 151, 649-658, 1999), was used to investigate the location of sensitive sites for cell inactivation and the physical modes of action of radiation. The enhancement of the RBE above the carbon K-shell edge either may indicate a high intrinsic efficiency of carbon K-shell ionizations (due, for example, to a specific physical or chemical effect) or may be related to the preferential localization of these ionizations on the DNA. The second interpretation would indicate a strong local (within 3 nm) action of K-shell ionizations and consequently the importance of a direct mechanism for radiation lethality (without excluding an action in conjunction with an indirect component). To distinguish between these two hypotheses, the efficiencies of core ionizations in DNA atoms (phosphorus L-shell, carbon K-shell, and oxygen K-shell ionizations) to induce damages were investigated by measuring their capacities to produce DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). The effect of photoionizations in isolated DNA was studied using pBS plasmids in a partially hydrated state. No enhancement of the efficiency of DSB induction by carbon K-shell ionizations compared to oxygen K-shell ionizations was found, supporting the hypothesis that it is the localization of these carbon K-shell events on DNA which gives to the 340 eV photons their high killing efficiency. In agreement with this interpretation, cell inactivation and DSB induction, which do not appear to be correlated when expressed in terms of yields per unit dose in the sample, exhibit a rather good correlation when expressed in terms of efficiencies per core event in the DNA. These results suggest that core ionizations in DNA, through core-hole relaxation in conjunction with localized effects of spatially correlated secondary and Auger electrons, may be the major critical events for cell inactivation, and that the resulting DSBs (or a constant fraction of these DSBs) may be a major class of unrepairable lesions.

Mutations in mammalian cells induced by heavy charged particles: an indicator for risk assessment in space

Induction of mutations at the HPRT locus in V79 Chinese hamster cells by heavy charged particles is reviewed. A unique dependence of mutation induction cross sections on LET or any other physical parameter of the particles cannot be found. There is, however, a general trend showing an increase up to about 100 keV/microm and an indication of a saturation with higher LET. An empirical expression is given approximating the data which may be useful for practical purposes. On the basis of this expression, it is suggested that the formula used by the ICRP for the quality factor overestimates the risk for very heavy particles. This may have implications for the assessment of the risk of exposure to iron ions in space.

A microdosimetric-kinetic theory of the dependence of the RBE for cell death on LET

Experiments with cultured mammalian cells exposed to ionizing radiation of varying LET are examined in the context of a microdosimetric-kinetic (MK) model of radiation induced mammalian. cell killing similar to the site model of the theory of dual radiation action. The experimentally measured RBE, in the limit of zero dose, increases linearly with LET for LET less than a value that lies in the range of about 40-90 keV per micron. It is shown that the tendency of the RBE to increase linearly with LET can be explained as a result of the random variation of specific energy among microscopic sized domains (sites), into which the nucleus may be partitioned, and the effect of this variation on the formation of lethal lesions by pairwise combination of repairable primary lesions in DNA. the microscopic subunits corresponding to a site have diameter in the range of 0.56-0.75 microns. The linearity of RBE with increasing LET implies that value of the quadratic parameter of the linear-quadratic survival relation (beta) is constant, at least for LET low enough to be in the linear range, and this in turn implies the production of primary DNA lesion, likely double strand breaks, does not increase with LET. the experiments, interpreted with MK model, also imply that the repairability and potential for lethality of the primary DNA lesion does not change with variation of LET within the linear range. The failure of RBE to maintain its linear increase for higher values of LET, and the resulting RBE maximum at about 100 keV per micron, are likely primarily due to the departure of the distribution of lethal lesions among cells from the Poisson distribution. Some implications concerning the use of radiation to treat cancer are noted.