Antibody-mediated rejection of human renal allografts: an electron microscopic study of peritubular capillaries

On a Long and Winding Road: Alloantibodies in Organ Transplantation

Today we know that both the humoral and the cellular arm of the immune system are engaged in severe immunological challenges. A close interaction between B and T cells can be observed in most "natural" challenges, including infections, malignancies, and autoimmune diseases. The importance and power of humoral immunity are impressively demonstrated by the current coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. Organ transplant rejection is a normal immune response to a completely "artificial" challenge. It took a long time before the multifaceted action of different immunological forces was recognized and a unified, generally accepted opinion could be formed. Here, we address prominent paradigms and paradigm shifts in the field of transplantation immunology. We identify several instances in which the transplant community missed a timely paradigm shift because essential, available knowledge was ignored. Moreover, we discuss key findings that critically contributed to our understanding of transplant immunology but sometimes developed with delay and in a roundabout way, as was the case with antibody-mediated rejection-a main focus of this article. These include the discovery of the molecular principles of histocompatibility, the recognition of the microcirculation as a key interface of immune damage, the refinement of alloantibody detection, the description of C4d as a footmark of endothelium-bound antibody, and last but not least, the developments in biopsy-based diagnostics beyond conventional morphology, which only now give us a glimpse of the enormous complexity and pathogenetic diversity of rejection.

CYC1, SDHA, UQCRC1, UQCRQ, and SDHB might be important biomarkers in kidney transplant rejection

BACKGROUND

Kidney transplant rejection is considered as a vital factor of kidney transplant failure. Therefore, it's necessary to search for effective biomarkers for kidney transplant surveillance.

METHODS

In this study, we conducted time-series gene expression profiles analysis of samples from kidney transplant patients with different post-transplant days through weighted gene co-expression network analysis (WGCNA). Associations between gene co-expression modules and days post-transplant were determined through spearman rank correlation analysis. Potential kidney transplant rejection-related modules were subjected to gene functional enrichment analysis through clusterProfiler and protein-protein interaction analysis via STRING database.

RESULTS

A total of 11 gene co-expression modules were identified, and the pink module which was mainly involved in "energy derivation by oxidation of organic compounds" and "Huntington disease" showed significant correlation with the phenotypic trait "days post-transplant". CYC1, SDHA, UQCRC1, UQCRQ, and SDHB in the pink module exhibited high scores in the protein-protein interaction network analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

We reported several potential genes may be associated with the kidney transplant rejection, which should provide novel biomarkers for kidney transplant surveillance.

An analysis of transplant glomerulopathy and thrombotic microangiopathy in kidney transplant biopsies

Glomerular diseases of the transplanted kidney are the most important cause of poor long- term outcome. The estimation of the magnitude of this problem and an elucidation of pathogenic mechanism is essential for improvement of graft survival. This study from the Indian subcontinent aims (i) to determine the incidence of transplant glomerulopathy (TG) and thrombotic microangiopathy (TMA) in a large cohort of indicated renal transplant biopsies, (ii) to evaluate the histological and ultrastructural features of TG and TMA, and (iii) to assess the relationship between the two glomerular lesions. Of a total of 1792 indication renal transplant biopsies received over 5 years (2006-2010), 266 biopsies (of 249 patients) had significant glomerular pathology and were further analyzed along with immunofluorescence, electron microscopy (EM), and C4d immunohistochemistry. TG is the most common glomerular lesion followed by TMA seen in 5.97% and 5.08% of allograft biopsies, respectively, which constitutes 40.23% and 34.2% of biopsies with significant glomerular lesions. Pathologic antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) is associated with both TG and TMA in 71% and 46.5%, respectively. A coexistent TG was found in 18.4% of biopsies with TMA. Endothelial swelling with subendothelial widening, a feature of TMA, is also seen in early TG by EM. Our findings support the concept that TG evolves from a smoldering TMA of various causes.

Capillary dilation and rarefaction are correlated with intracapillary inflammation in antibody-mediated rejection

Antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) remains one of the major causes of graft loss after renal transplantation. It is dominated by endothelial damage in microcirculation. Clarifying the mechanism of microcirculating damage is obviously a key step to understand the pathogenesis of ABMR. Here we characterized capillary variation in ABMR and its possible mechanisms. Compared with T cell-mediated rejection and stable grafts, there was a significant dilation and rarefaction in peritubular capillaries (PTCs) of the ABMR group; Image-Pro Plus revealed a significantly larger intra-PTC area. Interestingly, the dilation of PTCs was strongly correlated with the intra-PTC cell counting. Moreover, peritubular capillary inflammation is correlated with in situ T-bet expression, and there was a good correlation between the intra-PTC expression of T-bet and the PTC diameter. HIF-1α up-regulation could be observed in ABMR but it was not necessary for capillary dilation. In general, ABMR is characterized with early capillary dilation and rarefaction; our data confirmed that the dilation is strongly correlated with intracapillary inflammation, which in turn is correlated with in situ T-bet expression. T-bet plays an important role in the development of microcirculating injury, and thus it is a potential target for the treatment of ABMR.

Value of a simple method to assess chronic rejection in renal allograft on electron microscopy

Electron microscopy is a powerful tool for the assessment of complex lesions in nontumor renal pathology, however it is a time-consuming procedure. We evaluated a simple method to assess morphological signs of chronic rejection in renal allograft that seems to have prognostic significance.

Experimental glomerular endothelial injury in vivo

The microvascular endothelium of the kidney glomerulus is injured in Shiga-like toxigenic bacterial infection, genetic or acquired loss of complement regulatory protein function, and allo-immune responses of solid-organ or bone marrow transplantation. Existing models of diseases with glomerular endothelial cell (EC) injury, collectively grouped as thrombotic microangiopathies, are problematic, impeding investigation of the mechanisms of microvascular defense and repair. To develop a model of glomerular endothelial injury in the mouse, we conjugated the M. oreades lectin to the cytotoxin, saporin, (LS) to selectively injure the glomerular endothelium. Injury of the microvasculature was evaluated by light, immunofluorescence, and electron microscopy, and by quantitative RT-PCR of cell-type specific transcripts. Renal function was evaluated by quantitation of serum creatinine. The toxin conjugate induced apoptosis of microvascular ECs in vitro, and subtle histologic features of thrombotic microangiopathy in vivo that were enhanced by co-injection of 50 μg/kg LPS. Among LS/LPS-treated animals, loss of glomerular EC staining correlated with decreased expression of EC-specific transcripts, and impaired kidney function. Selective injury of the glomerular microvasculature with LS toxin conjugate and LPS elicits histologic features of thrombotic microangiopathy and acute kidney failure.

Determinants of long-term graft outcome in transplant glomerulopathy

BACKGROUND

Transplant glomerulopathy (TG) is a renal allograft disease defined by glomerular basement membrane duplication with peritubular capillary basement membrane multilayering (PTCML), and associated with anti-human leukocyte antigen antibodies and C4d. Outcome in TG is poor but variable, and prognostic factors, particularly those affecting long-term outcome, are not well known. We investigated several potentially prognostic clinical and pathologic factors in TG and evaluated estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) slopes to assess graft function and early decline.

METHODS

We examined all cases of TG from 2001 to 2005 with at least 4-year follow-up after biopsy, excluding those with a second confounding diagnosis.

RESULTS

Among 36 cases of pure TG, mean graft age at biopsy was 8.8±6 years. C4d stain was positive in 11 (33%) cases. Clinical characteristics at biopsy were not different based on C4d. C4d was associated with greater PTCML (P=0.03), peritubular capillaritis (P=0.04), and glomerulitis (P=0.03). Death-censored graft survival was significantly associated with interstitial fibrosis (P=0.001), PTCML (P=0.001), and arteriolar hyalinosis (P=0.007), and it showed a trend with proteinuria (P=0.07) and C4d positivity (P=0.08). C4d-positive cases also showed a trend toward rapid graft loss. Analysis of eGFR slopes showed a pattern of preserved, slightly negative slope from transplant until approximately 1 year before biopsy, at which point the slope became significantly more negative (P<0.001).

CONCLUSION

Interstitial fibrosis, PTCML, and arteriolar hyalinosis were significant predictors of graft survival in TG. C4d positivity was associated with a more rapid rate of function decline. eGFR slope data showed significant deterioration in graft function well before the diagnostic biopsy.

Ultrastructure as a Diagnostic Adjunct in the Evaluation of Lung Allograft Biopsies

Humoral immunity contributes significantly to lung graft dysfunction. Recognizing a role of ultrastructural studies in the evaluation and diagnosis of chronic humoral allograft rejection in the kidney, the authors sought to explore its utility as a diagnostic adjunct in lung allograft biopsies. Ultrastructural studies were conducted on 44 biopsies from 26 lung transplant recipients. Endothelial cell activation and necrosis were seen in the setting of acute humoral allograft rejection. Septal chronic vasculopathic changes of thickening and lamellation of the basement membrane zone (BMZ) and BMZ collagen deposition were correlated with greater numbers of humoral allograft rejection episodes and with the development of chronic graft dysfunction/bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome. There was a positive correlation between the extent of septal fibrosis and certain chronic vasculopathic changes, namely collagen deposition in the BMZ and BMZ wrinkling. Patients with chronic graft dysfunction and multiple rejection episodes manifested low diffusion capacities (less than 50% predicted). The results indicate that ultrastructural analysis is useful in identification of septal fibrosis and chronic vasculopathy of the septal microvasculature, correlating with chronic graft dysfunction, encompassing not only fibrotic sequelae of the bronchial wall but also irreversible terminal lung parenchymal changes, the latter associated with repeated episodes of humoral rejection.

Glycocalyx Damage Estimated Using Colloidal Iron Staining

Anionic constituents in the peritubular capillary basement membranes and the glomerular endothelial cells have been demonstrated to function as a size- and charge-selective barrier. Cationic colloidal iron staining of human biopsy specimens revealed a glycocalyx on the surface of the glomerular basement membrane (GBM), peritubular capillary (PTC) endothelial cells, and brush border of the tubular epithelial cells of normal kidney. However, the glycocalyx was abolished in the PTC wall of C4d-positive acute humoral rejected kidney, and in the GBM as well as the PTC wall of a chronic, allograft, nephropathy kidney. In addition, cyclosporine eliminated the glycocalyx in the PTC wall, while treatment with heparin inhibited the elimination of the PTC glycocalyx. In conclusion, the glycocalyx on the surface of the GBM and PTC is an important component in the endothelial cell barrier.

Transplant glomerulopathy: subclinical incidence and association with alloantibody

Transplant glomerulopathy (TG) usually has been described as part of a constellation of late chronic histologic abnormalities associated with proteinuria and declining function. The current study used both protocol and clinically-indicated biopsies to investigate clinical and subclinical TG, their prognosis and possible association with alloantibody. We retrospectively studied 582 renal transplants with a negative pre-transplant T-cell complement dependent cytotoxicity crossmatch. TG was diagnosed in 55 patients, 27 (49%) based on protocol biopsy in well-functioning grafts. The cumulative incidence of TG increased over time to 20% at 5 years. The prognosis of subclinical TG was equally as poor as TG diagnosed with graft dysfunction, with progressive worsening of histopathologic changes and function. Although TG was associated with both acute and chronic histologic abnormalities, 14.5% of TG biopsies showed no interstitial fibrosis or tubular atrophy, while 58% (7/12) of biopsies with severe TG showed only minimal abnormalities. TG was associated with acute rejection, pretransplant hepatitis C antibody positivity and anti-HLA antibodies (especially anti-Class II), with the risk increasing if the antibodies were donor specific. We suggest that subclinical TG is an under-recognized cause of antibody-mediated, chronic renal allograft injury which may be mechanistically distinct from other causes of nephropathy.

The role of anti-endothelial cell antibody-mediated microvascular injury in the evolution of pulmonary fibrosis in the setting of collagen vascular disease

We encountered 16 patients with connective tissue disease in whom pulmonary fibrosis developed. Routine light microscopic, ultrastructural, and direct immunofluorescent analyses were conducted, and circulating antibodies, including those of endothelial cell derivation, were assessed using indirect immuno-fluorescence and Western blot assays. Underlying diseases were dermatomyositis, scleroderma, mixed connective tissue disease, sclerodermatomyositis, Sjögren syndrome, rheumatoid arthritis, and anti-Ro-associated systemic lupus erythematosus. Antibodies to one or more Ro, RNP, Jo 1, OJ, and/or nucleolar antigens were seen in all cases and antiphospholipid antibodies in half. All biopsies revealed microvascular injury in concert with intraparenchymal fibrosis; in some cases, there were corroborative ultrastructural findings of microvascular injury. Patterns of fibroplasia represented nonspecific interstitial pneumonitis and usual interstitial pneumonitis. We noted IgG, IgA, and/or complement in the septal microvasculature. In 6 cases with available serum samples, indirect immunofluorescent endothelial cell antibody studies were positive and Western Blot studies showed reactivity of serum samples to numerous endothelial cell lysate-derived proteins. Pulmonary fibrosis, a recognized complication of systemic connective tissue disease, develops in connective tissue disease syndromes with pathogenetically established immune-based microvascular injury at other sites. A similar mechanism of antibody-mediated endothelial cell injury may be the basis of the tissue injury and fibrosing reparative response.

Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis Related to Endothelial Injury and Antiendothelial Cell Antibodies

Mechanisms underlying idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis are not well understood. This paper presents data supporting the hypothesis that microvascular endothelial cell injury and antiendothelial cell antibodies play roles in human idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis. Serologic and pathologic features of 40 patients diagnosed with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis were evaluated. All patients had open lung biopsies indicating either usual or nonspecific interstitial pneumonitis. All biopsies had morphologic evidence of microvascular injury to the endothelium, and direct immunofluorescence testing revealed variable deposition of IgG, IgM, or IgA within septal microvasculature suggestive of humorally mediated microvascular injury. Ultrastructural studies revealed changes of endothelial cell injury and necrosis and evidence of repetitive episodes of microvascular injury characterized by basement membrane zone collagen deposition and lamellation. Serum samples demonstrated reactivity to multiple endothelial cell antigenic epitopes, and indirect immunofluorescent testing demonstrated a prominent pattern of fluorescence in pulmonary endothelial cell preparations. Serum samples were positive in 37/40 patients for antiphospholipid antibodies with one fourth having positive lupus anticoagulant tests accompanied by thrombotic episodes. In patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis, Factor VIII levels and C-reactive protein levels were also elevated, supporting the presence of endothelial cell injury and inflammation. These data underscore a potential role for immune-based microvascular injury in the evolution of usual or nonspecific interstitial pneumonitis and indicate that those patients have evidence of microvascular injury and endothelial cell necrosis. The high prevalence of antiphospholipid antibodies in these patients may lead to an inherent thrombophilic tendency.

Peritubular capillary damage in acute humoral rejection: an ultrastructural study on human renal allografts

The ultrastructural features of peritubular capillary (PC) damage was studied in 12 kidney allografts with acute humoral rejection (AHR). AHR manifested in diffuse linear PC staining for C4d, and histology consistent with Banff grade III in 7 recipients and Banff grade II in 5. Allografts with acute tubular necrosis served as controls. First biopsies (post-transplantation day 16.2 +/- 2.2): The intra-capillary exudate comprised monocytes (59%), polymorphonuclears (14%), lymphocytes (12%) and not otherwise specified mononuclears (15%). Three patterns of focal PC endothelial injury were observed: lysis, an increased rate of apoptosis and fragmentation. No correlation was found between the respective damage types and the inflammatory cell types or the Banff grades. Controls revealed endothelial swelling, detachment from basement membrane and fragmentation. Follow-up biopsies: Monocytes transformed into macrophages intra-luminally. The reparative changes comprised endothelial cytoplasmic protrusions, binucleated endothelial cells and capillary sprouts. Early transplant capillaropathy and transplant glomerulopathy were noted in 2 recipients. Literature data indicate that lysis is mediated by anti-HLA alloantibodies; apoptosis, demonstrated first in the present study, may be induced by non-HLA-type anti-endothelial antibodies. Fragmentation is caused by ischemia. Ongoing endothelial injury leads to transplant capillaropathy and transplant glomerulopathy, the characteristic lesions of chronic rejection.

The role of microvascular injury on steroid and OKT3 response in renal allograft rejection

BACKGROUND

The authors' aim is to understand the influence of human leukocyte antigen-DR positive microvascular (MV)-DR destruction on steroid and OKT3 response in acute rejection (AR).

METHODS

Twenty of 40 patients had steroid-resistant AR (group 1) and received OKT3 treatment, and the other 20 patients had AR that responded to steroid treatment (group 2). A renal biopsy specimen was obtained from each subject during the AR episode. The degree of MV-DR destruction and the peritubular capillary (PTC) leukocyte infiltration were recorded in each case, using three-tiered scales. The follow-up biopsy specimens of all cases were evaluated for the development of interstitial fibrosis (IF).

RESULTS

Seventy-eight percent of the cases with severe MV destruction and 45% of those with moderate MV destruction did not show response to steroid therapy, whereas 74% of the cases with mild MV destruction responded to steroid therapy. Group 1 patients showed higher frequencies of vascular rejection (80%) and high-grade PTC leukocyte infiltration (85%) than the group 2 cases (P<0.01 for both). Seventy percent of the patients in group 1 responded to OKT3 therapy. The biopsy specimens from the six individuals who were resistant to OKT3 had shown severe MV destruction, vascular rejection, and high-grade PTC leukocyte infiltration. Severity of MV destruction in the initial AR diagnostic biopsy was positively correlated with development of diffuse IF and chronic allograft nephropathy in the follow-up biopsy specimens (P<0.001)

CONCLUSIONS

Analysis of MV destruction may be helpful for diagnosing rejection and predicting graft prognosis. This type of assessment may be useful for determining the immune response and thus identifying the most appropriate treatment.

Rarefaction of peritubular capillaries following ischemic acute renal failure: a potential factor predisposing to progressive nephropathy

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Long-term renal complications of acute renal failure have generally not been expected in patients that recover from acute renal failure. However, as the incidence of acute renal failure is rising, the incidence of long-term complications is likely to increase. As a corollary to ischemic acute renal failure, ischemic injury in the setting of transplant is a leading cause of delayed graft function. Unlike acute renal failure in native kidneys, delayed graft function is highly predictive of chronic nephropathy and organ failure. It is generally well accepted that acute reversible injuries mediated by ischemia render grafts susceptible toward future demise. The nature of the susceptibility that is conveyed to grafts following ischemic injury is not well understood.

RECENT FINDINGS

Evidence from animal models suggests that acute injury results in microvascular damage and vessel loss in the kidney, which, as opposed to tubular damage, is largely persistent. In addition, various studies of biopsies of renal transplants suggest that ischemia imposes an early and sustained loss in peritubular capillaries in the transplanted graft. The loss of peritubular capillaries has been associated with nephropathies of diverse etiologies and may represent a single, common pathway towards progressive damage.

SUMMARY

It is hypothesized that rarefaction of peritubular capillaries represents a critical event, following ischemic injury, that permanently alters renal function and predisposes patients to the development of chronic renal insufficiency. Factors that affect vascular reactivity or the structural dynamics of the kidney vascular system following injury may represent future treatment modalities following renal injury.

Peritubular capillary changes and C4d deposits are associated with transplant glomerulopathy but not IgA nephropathy

We examined our renal transplant population for glomerular diseases demonstrated on biopsy between January 1993 and April 2002, focusing on transplant glomerulopathy (TGP). Of 1156 patients followed in our clinics during this period, glomerular disease was diagnosed in 132 cases (11.4%). Glomerulonephritis was diagnosed in 86 transplants (7.4%), with IgA nephropathy (IgAN) being the commonest diagnosis [32 cases (2.8%)]. Thirty-one cases (2.7%) of biopsy-proven TGP were analyzed for associated factors compared with 27 cases (2.3%) of recurrent IgAN. Transplant glomerulopathy was less frequent with mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) and/or tacrolimus, whereas recurrent IgAN showed no such tendency (P= 0.02). Peritubular capillary (PTC) C4d deposition was observed in six of 24 cases (25%) with TGP but none with recurrent IgAN (P= 0.02). Peritubular capillary basement membrane (BM) multilayering was significantly greater in TGP (4.92 +/- 2.94) than in recurrent IgAN (1.86 +/- 1.04) (P < 0.001). The graft survival of TGP was worse than recurrent IgAN (P= 0.05). The association of TGP with BM multilayering and C4d deposits in PTC suggests a generalized disorder of the graft microcirculation and its BM, owing to antibody-mediated rejection in at least some cases. Transplant glomerulopathy has a serious prognosis but is less frequent in patients on newer immunosuppression, unlike recurrent IgAN.

The role of B cells and alloantibody in the host response to human organ allografts

Some human organ transplants deteriorate slowly over a period of years, often developing characteristic syndromes: transplant glomerulopathy (TG) in kidneys, bronchiolitis obliterans in lungs, and coronary artery disease in hearts. In the past, we attributed late graft deterioration to "chronic rejection", a distinct but mysterious immunologic process different from conventional rejection. However, it is likely that much of chronic rejection is explained by conventional T-cell-mediated rejection (TMR), antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), and other insults. Recently, criteria have emerged to now permit us to diagnose AMR in kidney transplants, particularly C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries and circulating antibody against donor human leukocyte antigens (HLA). Some cases with AMR develop TG, although the relationship of TG to AMR is complex. Thus, a specific diagnosis of AMR in kidney can now be made, based on graft damage, C4d deposition, and donor-specific alloantibodies. Criteria for AMR in other organs must be defined. Not all late rejections are AMR; some deteriorating organs probably have smoldering TMR. The diagnosis of late ongoing AMR raises the possibility of treatment to suppress the alloantibody, but efficacy of the available treatments requires further study.

Platelets and capillary injury in acute humoral rejection of renal allografts

Platelet accumulation in glomerular capillaries (GC) and peritubular capillaries (PC) has pathogenetic importance in antibody-mediated hyperacute renal allograft rejection. CD61 is expressed constitutively by platelets, by platelet microparticles arising from platelet activation, and is readily detectable by immunohistochemistry. This study examined the immunohistochemical localization of CD61 in acute humoral rejection (AHR) of renal allografts to explore the relationship of platelet accumulation to antibody-mediated rejection. Two observers graded the extent of CD61 staining in PC and GC from 0 (none) to 2+ (>50%) in 15 renal allograft biopsy specimens with AHR and compared these with tissues from allografts with acute cellular rejection (ACR) (n = 23); acute calcineurin inhibitor toxicity (ACIT) (n = 21) with thrombotic microangiopathy (TMA) (n = 11) and tubular toxicity only (n = 10); acute tubular necrosis (ATN) (n = 16); acute renal vein thrombosis (RVT) (n = 4); and histologically unremarkable native kidneys (n = 26). Selected tissues were examined by electron microscopy and stained for CD34 by immunohistochemistry. Histologically unremarkable native kidney tissues had CD61 only in scattered small lumenal granules in GC and PC. Mural and occlusive lumenal CD61 deposits (>0.5+) were observed in 13 of 13 (100%) allograft tissues with GC thrombi due to AHR (1) and ACIT TMA (9) and RVT (3). Twenty-seven of 66 allografts (40.9%) without glomerular thrombi had >0.5+ GC CD61 in AHR (60%), ACR (26%), tubular ACIT (60%), and ATN (44%). More than trace (>0.5+) PC mural and lumenal CD61 deposits were seen only in AHR (53.3%) and ACR (30%). PC CD61 correlated with interstitial hemorrhage (r = 0.64), neutrophilic capillaritis (r = 0.47), and interstitial inflammation (r = 0.47) (P <0.001 for each). PC CD61 was observed in 11 of 11 foci of necrosis due to AHR, RVT, and ischemia. In AHR, capillaries with CD61 deposits had few platelets, numerous microvesicles and membrane fragments, severe endothelial injury seen on electron microscopy, and reduced capillary CD34 expression. CD61 detection by immunohistochemistry revealed products of capillary platelet activation in allograft biopsy specimens without light microscopic thrombi. Observations in this study suggest that intracapillary platelet activation occurs in response to graft capillary injury from many causes and may not be specific for antibody-mediated rejection.

Capillary deposition of complement split product C4d in renal allografts is associated with basement membrane injury in peritubular and glomerular capillaries: a contribution of humoral immunity to chronic allograft rejection

Endothelial deposition of the complement split product C4d is an established marker of antibody-mediated acute renal allograft rejection. A contribution of alloantibody-dependent immune reactions to chronic rejection is under discussion. In this study, the association of immunohistochemically detected endothelial C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries (PTC) with morphologic features of chronic renal allograft injury was investigated in a large study cohort. C4d deposits in PTC were detected in 73 (34%) of 213 late allograft biopsies performed in 213 patients more than 12 mo after transplantation (median, 4.9 yr) because of chronic allograft dysfunction. Endothelial C4d deposition was found to be associated with chronic transplant glomerulopathy (CG) (P < 0.0001), with basement membrane multilayering in PTC (P = 0.01), and with an accumulation of mononuclear inflammatory cells in PTC (P < 0,001). Furthermore, C4d deposits in PTC (in biopsies with normal glomerular morphology) were associated with development of CG in follow-up biopsies. Other morphologic features of chronic allograft nephropathy (with exception of tubular atrophy) were not associated with C4d deposits in PTC. Analyses of previous and follow-up biopsies revealed that C4d deposits may occur de novo and may also disappear at any time after transplantation. In conclusion, the data suggest that complement activation in renal microvasculature, indicating humoral alloreactivity, contributes to chronic rejection characterized by chronic transplant glomerulopathy and basement membrane multilayering in PTC.

A complement-dependent model of thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura induced by antibodies reactive with endothelial cells

Thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP) is an immunologically mediated disease characterized by thrombocytopenia, hemolytic anemia, and pathologic changes in various organs, including the kidney, which are secondary to widespread thromboses. Central to TTP is platelet activation, which may occur from a variety of mechanisms, including endothelial cell activation or injury. In this study, injection of K6/1, a monoclonal antibody with widespread reactivity toward endothelia, led to dose-dependent thrombocytopenia in rats. This was magnified if animals were preimmunized with mouse IgG, thereby resulting in an accelerated autologous phase of injury. In this setting, significant anemia also resulted. Rats injected with K6/1 developed renal injury, consisting of tubular damage and glomerular thrombi. Thrombocytopenia and renal morphological abnormalities were eliminated if animals were complement depleted with cobra venom factor prior to K6/1 injection and worsened when the activity of the ubiquitous complement regulator Crry was inhibited with function-neutralizing antibodies. Therefore, we have developed a complement-dependent model of TTP in rats by injecting monoclonal antibodies reactive with endothelial cells. Antibody-directed complement activation leads to stimulation of platelets, through direct interactions with complement fragments and/or indirectly through endothelial cell activation or injury, with the subsequent development of TTP.

The value of electron microscopy in the diagnosis of chronic renal allograft rejection

The main causes of the late dysfunction of renal allografts are chronic rejection and chronic transplant nephropathy. Both are clinicopathologic entities, with a similar clinical presentation, but different histologic appearances. Chronic rejection is characterized by the presence of alloantigen-induced lesions (transplant arteriopathy and transplant glomerulopathy), and chronic transplant nephropathy by nonspecific sclerosing changes. The incidence of transplant arteriopathy and transplant glomerulopathy is relatively low. Electron microscopy (EM) may overcome the limitations in the histologic diagnosis of chronic rejection, because it verifies alloantigen-induced chronic microvasculopathy in the peritubular capillaries (transplant capillaropathy), and identifies transplant glomerulopathy more precisely than does light microscopy. To assess the value of EM in chronic rejection diagnosis, a retrospective search for transplant capillaropathy and transplant glomerulopathy was performed in a consecutive series of 91 biopsies performed > or = 6 months after implantation (median: 26 months, range 6-186) and the diagnoses were reclassified on the basis of the ultrastructural findings. The definitions used were: transplant capillaropathy: a peritubular capillary profile with seven or more circumferential basement membrane layers, or at least three profiles with five or six circumferential layers; ultrastructurally verified transplant glomerulopathy: thickening of the capillary wall in at least three loops in consequence of the widening of the subendothelial space by abnormal basement membrane material, and the formation of a new layer(s) of basal lamina; and chronic rejection: the presence of transplant capillaropathy and/or transplant glomerulopathy and/or transplant arteriopathy. Histologically, chronic transplant nephropathy, chronic rejection, chronic cyclosporine nephrotoxicity, glomerulonephritis, acute rejection, "suspicious" for acute rejection, and "others" were diagnosed in 37%, 34%, 21%, 19%, 57%, 30%, and 5% of the specimens, respectively. The results of EM increased the diagnosis of chronic rejection to 69% of the cases, and decreased chronic transplant nephropathy to 15%. The individual incidence of transplant capillaropathy and transplant glomerulopathy was 79% and 57%, respectively, and their cumulative incidence was 92%. Five biopsies exhibited merely transplant arteriopathy. A late dysfunction typically had more than one cause; the most frequent combination was chronic rejection and acute rejection. In conclusion, the EM search for transplant capillaropathy and transplant glomerulopathy doubled the frequency of the diagnosis of chronic rejection. Currently, the evaluation of renal allograft biopsies from recipients with a late dysfunction relies on standard light microscopy. Because light microscopy per se proved to be insensitive in the diagnosis of chronic rejection, incorporation of EM into the evaluation of late dysfunction biopsies is strongly recommended.

Transplant accommodation in highly sensitized patients: a potential role for Bcl-xL and alloantibody

Transplantation of renal allografts into recipients with circulating anti-HLA antibodies results in hyperacute rejection. In some cases, however, antibodies return without causing harm; this phenomenon has been termed 'accommodation'. We have investigated this process in human allotransplantation. We removed anti-HLA antibodies by immunoadsorption in seven highly sensitized dialysis patients who subsequently underwent renal transplantation. Immunohistochemistry of renal biopsies for IgG and antiapoptotic proteins was performed. We also developed a model of 'accommodation' using anti-HLA antibodies eluted from sensitized patients and incubated with human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs) at different concentrations. Their effect on HUVEC phenotype was then analysed. Anti-donor antibody returned in 4/7 patients, without evidence of hyperacute rejection. Three out of four of these 'accommodated' grafts showed specific endothelial up-regulation of Bcl-xL and 2/2 tested positive for endothelial IgG deposition. HUVECs incubated with subsaturating concentrations of anti-HLA antibody showed increased expression of Bcl-xL, were rendered refractory to endothelial cell activation and became resistant to complement-mediated lysis. In contrast, HUVECs incubated with saturating concentrations underwent activation and expressed low levels of Bcl-xL. In conclusion, endothelial Bcl-xL expression defines the accommodation process in human allografts and this phenotype may be initiated by exposure of endothelium to low concentrations of anti-donor HLA antibodies.

Control of antidonor antibody production with tacrolimus and mycophenolate mofetil in renal allograft recipients with chronic rejection

BACKGROUND

In renal transplantation, chronic rejection is a major cause of late allograft loss. Recent studies indicate that a subset of chronic rejection is associated with anti-HLA donor specific antibodies (DSA) and complement C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries (PTC). Since rescue therapy with tacrolimus and mycophenolate mofetil has been found to limit antidonor B-cell responses in recipients with acute humoral rejection, we sought to determine whether a similar immunosuppressive regimen might be effective in patients with 'chronic humoral rejection'.

METHODS

Four renal allograft recipients with 'chronic humoral rejection' were prospectively identified. The diagnosis was based on: (1) progressive rise in serum creatinine over 12 months; (2) typical pathologic features by light microscopy (transplant arteriopathy and glomerulopathy); (3) widespread C4d deposits in PTC by immunofluorescence; (4) detection of 'de novo' DSA at the time of biopsy. Maintenance immunosuppression was CsA, prednisone and azathioprine (n=3) or prednisone and azathioprine (n=1). Rescue therapy with tacrolimus and mycophenolate mofetil was initiated in all patients, 12 hr after cyclosporine and azathioprine discontinuation.

RESULTS

At diagnosis, the mean serum creatinine was 3.9 mg/dl (range: 3.3 to 5.4 mg/dl). DSA was an IgG directed against HLA class II (n=3) or class I (n=2), that is one patient had both anti-HLA class I and class II antibodies. Pretreatment antibody titers varied between 1:8 and 1:128. Rescue therapy was associated with a rapid and sustained decrease in antibody titers. In two patients, DSA became undetectable after 9 months and a repeat biopsy performed after 12 months revealed a decrease in C4d deposition in PTC.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that a decrease in DSA production can be induced in renal allograft recipients with 'chronic humoral rejection' by using an immunosuppressive regimen that combines tacrolimus and mycophenolate mofetil. Limitation of antidonor antibody synthesis may be important for the treatment or the prevention of chronic rejection in organ transplantation.

Rejection of peritubular capillaries in renal allo- and xeno-graft

The microvasculature plays an important role in the pathogenesis of humoral- and cell-mediated renal allo- and xeno-graft rejection. Peritubular capillary (PTC) endothelium expresses the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I and II antigens in the resting phase, as does the glomerular capillary endothelium, suggesting that these cells may be major immune targets. However, the role of PTCs in renal allo- and xeno-graft rejection is unclear. In this review, we discuss injury and subsequent remodeling of PTCs in both humoral- and cell-mediated rejection in allo- and xeno-grafts. Recent evidence suggests that PTC injury and endothelial cell death occur during both cell- and humoral-mediated rejection. Severe PTC rejection contributes to deterioration of graft function and acute graft loss. The mild but recurrent form of PTC rejection is associated with progressive interstitial fibrosis and chronic rejection. Following endothelial injury, the remaining PTC endothelium activates with up-regulation of allo-antigens and adhesion molecules, and down-regulation of anti-coagulant proteins. Subsequent to this, more severe rejection and graft dysfunction occur. Therefore, a careful analysis of cellular- and antibody-mediated rejection in PTCs is important in the diagnosis of rejection, prediction of graft prognosis, and in further development of new anti-rejection therapies.

Peritubular capillary basement membrane reduplication in allografts and native kidney disease: a clinicopathologic study of 278 consecutive renal specimens

BACKGROUND

An association has been found between transplant glomerulopathy (TG) and reduplication of peritubular capillary basement membranes (PTCR). Although such an association is of practical and theoretical importance, only one prospective study has tried to confirm it.

METHODS

We examined 278 consecutive renal specimens (from 135 transplants and 143 native kidneys) for ultrastructural evidence of PTCR. In addition to renal allografts with TG, we also examined grafts with acute rejection, recurrent glomerulonephritis, chronic allograft nephropathy and stable grafts ("protocol biopsies"). Native kidney specimens included a wide range of glomerulopathies as well as cases of thrombotic microangiopathy, malignant hypertension, acute interstitial nephritis, and acute tubular necrosis.

RESULTS

We found PTCR in 14 of 15 cases of TG, in 7 transplant biopsy specimens without TG, and in 13 of 143 native kidney biopsy specimens. These 13 included cases of malignant hypertension, thrombotic microangiopathy, lupus nephritis, Henoch-Schonlein nephritis, crescentic glomerulonephritis, and cocaine-related acute renal failure. Mild PTCR in allografts without TG did not predict renal failure or significant proteinuria after follow-up periods of between 3 months and 1 year.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that in transplants, there is a strong association between well-developed PTCR and TG, while the significance of mild PTCR and its predictive value in the absence of TG is unclear. PTCR also occurs in certain native kidney diseases, though the association is not as strong as that for TG. We suggest that repeated endothelial injury, including immunologic injury, may be the cause of this lesion both in allografts and native kidneys.

Involvement of antibody-dependent apoptosis in graft rejection

BACKGROUND

Both humoral factors and apoptosis have been recently suggested to play a role in chronic allograft rejection. However, a link between alloantibodies and grafted cell apoptosis has never been proposed. Using the aortic allograft model in the rat, we have previously demonstrated the presence of IgG associated with the disappearance of donor endothelial and medial smooth muscle cells. In the present study, we tested the interaction between recipient allosera, enriched with antibodies by presensitization, and primary culture of cardiovascular cells of donor origin.

METHODS

For this purpose endothelial cells, smooth muscle cells, adventitial fibroblasts, and cardiac myocytes of donor origin were cultured. Binding of alloantisera to these cells was analyzed by flow cytometry. Apoptosis of donor cells was evaluated by Tdt-mediated d' UTP-FITC nick end labeling, 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole and DNA ladder techniques. The alloantisera were compared with anti-MHC class I monoclonal antibodies. Finally the colocalization of antibodies and apoptosis was investigated in vivo.

RESULTS

In vitro, alloantisera bind to cardiovascular cells of donor origin. These cells expressed MHC class I but not MHC class II. There was a partial competition between anti-MHC I mouse monoclonal antibody and alloantisera mainly of the IgG isotype. Alloantisera bound to, but did not induce lysis of, donor RBC. Alloantisera induced apoptosis of donor cardiovascular cells as assessed by the typical morphological aspect of the donor cells after 24 hr of incubation. These data were confirmed by the Tdt-mediated d' UTP-FITC nick end labeling positivity of the cells and the fragmentation of the nucleus visualized by 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole and DNA ladder techniques. Similar apoptosis was induced by specific monoclonal antibodies directed against the MHC class I of donor cells. Primary culture of similar vascular cells of recipient origin was insensitive to alloantisera directed against donor alloantigens. Finally, in vivo, using allopresentization and aortic allografts, an association of alloantibody binding and endothelial cell apoptosis was observed at day 5, and a similar association with smooth muscle cell apoptosis on day 12 after grafting.

CONCLUSION

These data demonstrate the role of humoral injury in chronic allograft rejection and suggest new therapeutical approaches focused on the induction of resistance to antibody-dependent apoptosis.

Role of electron microscopy in transplant renal pathology

The crucial role that electron microscopy plays in diagnostic renal pathology is undisputed. By allowing recognition of findings not identifiable by light microscopic evaluation, electron microscopy has contributed significantly to the understanding of renal diseases and has proven to be of unquestionable value in many diagnostic situations. However, the percentage of cases in which electron microscopic examination adds important information that is either key for establishing or confirming a diagnosis or provides valuable data that influence patient's management remains controversial. This figure depends on the renal biopsy service that is surveyed, but it is reported that on the average ultrastructural evaluation is of value in approximately 30 to 45% of the cases. Correct interpretation of a renal biopsy depends on the ability to correlate light, immunofluorescence, and ultrastructural findings. In contrast, the role of electron microscopy in the examination of renal transplant specimens remains controversial. Many centers do not use routine electron microscopy to examine these specimens and insist that there are only a few specific indications that require ultrastructural evaluation. There is general agreement among renal pathologists that electron microscopy is of importance in the evaluation of renal specimens from patients with proteinuria to distinguish between transplant glomerulopathy, recurrent or de novo glomerulonephritis in order to correctly manage these patients and predict survival of the graft. The other possible indications are much more controversial. This paper summarizes and critically reviews the literature available on this subject and defines recommendations based on the information available at the current time.