Fulminant meningococcal infections in a family with inherited deficiency of properdin

Complement factor D haplodeficiency is associated with a reduced complement activation speed and diminished bacterial killing

Objectives

Complete deficiency of alternative pathway (AP) complement factors, explained by homozygous mutations, is a well‐known risk factor for invasive bacterial infections; however, this is less obvious for heterozygous mutations. We describe two siblings with a heterozygous NM_001928.3(CFD):c.125C>A p.(Ser42*) mutation in the complement factor D (fD) gene having a history of recurrent bacterial infections. We determined the effect of heterozygous fD deficiency on AP complement activity.

Methods

We determined the effect of fD levels on complement activation as measured by AP activity, complement C3 binding to the bacterial surface of Neisseria meningitidis (Nm), Streptococcus pneumoniae (Sp) and non‐typeable Haemophilus influenzae (NTHi), and complement‐mediated killing of Nm and NTHi. In addition, we measured the effect of vaccination of complement C3 binding to the bacterial surface and killing of Nm.

Results

Reconstitution of fD‐deficient serum with fD increased AP activity in a dose‐ and time‐dependent way. Reconstitution of patient serum with fD to normal levels increased complement C3 binding to Sp, Nm and NTHi, as well as complement‐mediated killing of Nm and NTHi. Vaccination increased complement C3 binding and resulted in complete killing of Nm without fD reconstitution.

Conclusion

We conclude that low fD serum levels (< 0.5 μg mL⁻¹) lead to a reduced speed of complement activation, which results in diminished bacterial killing, consistent with recurrent bacterial infections observed in our index patients. Specific antibodies induced by vaccination are able to overcome the diminished bacterial killing capacity in patients with low fD levels.

Invasive Bacterial Infections in Subjects with Genetic and Acquired Susceptibility and Impacts on Recommendations for Vaccination: A Narrative Review

The WHO recently endorsed an ambitious plan, “Defeating Meningitis by 2030”, that aims to control/eradicate invasive bacterial infection epidemics by 2030. Vaccination is one of the pillars of this road map, with the goal to reduce the number of cases and deaths due to Neisseria meningitidis, Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus influenzae and Streptococcus agalactiae. The risk of developing invasive bacterial infections (IBI) due to these bacterial species includes genetic and acquired factors that favor repeated and/or severe invasive infections. We searched the PubMed database to identify host risk factors that increase the susceptibility to these bacterial species. Here, we describe a number of inherited and acquired risk factors associated with increased susceptibility to invasive bacterial infections. The burden of these factors is expected to increase due to the anticipated decrease in cases in the general population upon the implementation of vaccination strategies. Therefore, detection and exploration of these patients are important as vaccination may differ among subjects with these risk factors and specific strategies for vaccination are required. The aim of this narrative review is to provide information about these factors as well as their impact on vaccination against the four bacterial species. Awareness of risk factors for IBI may facilitate early recognition and treatment of the disease. Preventive measures including vaccination, when available, in individuals with increased risk for IBI may prevent and reduce the number of cases.

Human genetics of meningococcal infections

Neisseria meningitidis is a leading cause of bacterial septicaemia and meningitis worldwide. Meningococcal disease is rare but can be life threatening with a tendency to affect children. Many studies have investigated the role of human genetics in predisposition to N. meningitidis infection. These have identified both rare single-gene mutations as well as more common polymorphisms associated with meningococcal disease susceptibility and severity. These findings provide clues to the pathogenesis of N. meningitidis, the basis of host susceptibility to infection and to the aetiology of severe disease. From the multiple discoveries of monogenic complement deficiencies to the associations of complement factor H and complement factor H-related three polymorphisms to meningococcal disease, the complement pathway is highlighted as being central to the genetic control of meningococcal disease. This review aims to summarise the current understanding of the host genetic basis of meningococcal disease with respect to the different stages of meningococcal infection.

Meningococcal disease and the complement system

Despite considerable advances in the understanding of the pathogenesis of meningococcal disease, this infection remains a major cause of morbidity and mortality globally. The role of the complement system in innate immune defenses against invasive meningococcal disease is well established. Individuals deficient in components of the alternative and terminal complement pathways are highly predisposed to invasive, often recurrent meningococcal infections. Genome-wide analysis studies also point to a central role for complement in disease pathogenesis. Here we review the pathophysiologic events pertinent to the complement system that accompany meningococcal sepsis in humans. Meningococci use several often redundant mechanisms to evade killing by human complement. Capsular polysaccharide and lipooligosaccharide glycan composition play critical roles in complement evasion. Some of the newly described protein vaccine antigens interact with complement components and have sparked considerable research interest.

Antibody directs properdin-dependent activation of the complement alternative pathway in a mouse model of abdominal aortic aneurysm

Abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) is a complex inflammatory vascular disease. There are currently limited treatment options for AAA when surgery is inapplicable. Therefore, insights into molecular mechanisms underlying AAA pathogenesis may reveal therapeutic targets that could be manipulated pharmacologically or biologically to halt disease progression. Using an elastase-induced AAA mouse model, we previously established that the complement alternative pathway (AP) plays a critical role in the development of AAA. However, the mechanism by which complement AP is initiated remains undefined. The complement protein properdin, traditionally viewed as a positive regulator of the AP, may also initiate complement activation by binding directly to target surfaces. In this study, we sought to determine whether properdin serves as a focal point for the initiation of the AP complement activation in AAA. Using a properdin loss of function mutation in mice and a mutant form of the complement factor B protein that produces a stable, properdin-free AP C3 convertase, we show that properdin is required for the development of elastase-induced AAA in its primary role as a convertase stabilizer. Unexpectedly, we find that, in AAA, natural IgG antibodies direct AP-mediated complement activation. The absence of IgG abrogates C3 deposition in elastase-perfused aortic wall and protects animals from AAA development. We also determine that blockade of properdin activity prevents aneurysm formation. These results indicate that an innate immune response to self-antigens activates the complement system and initiates the inflammatory cascade in AAA. Moreover, the study suggests that properdin-targeting strategies may halt aneurysmal growth.

Native polymeric forms of properdin selectively bind to targets and promote activation of the alternative pathway of complement

Properdin, a positive regulator of the complement system, has recently been reported to bind to certain pathogenic microorganisms, to early or late apoptotic and necrotic cells, and to particular live human cell lines, thus providing a platform for de novo convertase assembly and complement activation. These studies, with some contradictory results, have been carried out with purified properdin, which forms a series of oligomers of a ∼53,000 Mr subunit, assembling into dimers (P₂), trimers (P₃), tetramers (P₄) and higher forms (P(n)). The P(n) forms have been shown to likely be an artefact of purification that results from procedures including freeze-thawing of properdin. In this study we isolated the individual natural forms of properdin (P₂, P₃, and P₄) and separated them from the P(n) forms present in purified frozen properdin using ion exchange and/or size exclusion chromatography. We analyzed the ability of each form to bind to live or necrotic Jurkat and Raji cells, rabbit erythrocytes (E(R)), and zymosan by FACS analysis. While the unseparated properdin and the purified P(n) forms bound to all the surfaces except E(R), the physiological P₂-P₄ forms specifically bound only to zymosan and to necrotic nucleated cells. Our results indicate that aggregated P(n) present in unseparated properdin may bind non-specifically to some surfaces and should be separated before analysis in order to obtain meaningful results. Finally, we have determined for the first time that the physiological forms of human properdin can selectively recognize surfaces and enhance or promote complement activation, which is in agreement with the reported role for properdin as a complement initiator.

An evaluation of the role of properdin in alternative pathway activation on Neisseria meningitidis and Neisseria gonorrhoeae

Properdin, a positive regulator of the alternative pathway (AP) of complement is important in innate immune defenses against invasive neisserial infections. Recently, commercially available unfractionated properdin was shown to bind to certain biological surfaces, including Neisseria gonorrhoeae, which facilitated C3 deposition. Unfractionated properdin contains aggregates or high-order oligomers, in addition to its physiological "native" (dimeric, trimeric, and tetrameric) forms. We examined the role of properdin in AP activation on diverse strains of Neisseria meningitidis and N. gonorrhoeae specifically using native versus unfractionated properdin. C3 deposition on Neisseria decreased markedly when properdin function was blocked using an anti-properdin mAb or when properdin was depleted from serum. Maximal AP-mediated C3 deposition on Neisseriae even at high (80%) serum concentrations required properdin. Consistent with prior observations, preincubation of bacteria with unfractionated properdin, followed by the addition of properdin-depleted serum resulted in higher C3 deposition than when bacteria were incubated with properdin-depleted serum alone. Unexpectedly, none of 10 Neisserial strains tested bound native properdin. Consistent with its inability to bind to Neisseriae, preincubating bacteria with native properdin followed by the addition of properdin-depleted serum did not cause detectable increases in C3 deposition. However, reconstituting properdin-depleted serum with native properdin a priori enhanced C3 deposition on all strains of Neisseria tested. In conclusion, the physiological forms of properdin do not bind directly to either N. meningitidis or N. gonorrhoeae but play a crucial role in augmenting AP-dependent C3 deposition on the bacteria through the "conventional" mechanism of stabilizing AP C3 convertases.

Factor H and neisserial pathogenesis

Both Neisseria gonorrhoeae and N. meningitidis bind to factor H which enhances their ability to evade complement-dependent killing. While porin is the ligand for human fH on gonococci, meningococci use a lipoprotein called factor H binding protein (fHbp) to bind to factor H and enhance their ability to evade complement-dependent killing. This protein is currently being intensively investigated as a meningococcal vaccine candidate antigen. Consistent with the observation that meningococci cause natural infection only in humans, the organism resists human complement, and are more readily killed by complement from lower animals. This human species-specific complement evasion has important implications for evaluation of vaccine-elicited antibodies using non-human complement sources and development of animal models of disease.

Discrimination between host and pathogens by the complement system

Pathogen-specific complement activation requires direct recognition of pathogens and/or the absence of complement control mechanisms on their surfaces. Antibodies direct complement activation to potential pathogens recognized by the cellular innate and adaptive immune systems. Similarly, the plasma proteins MBL and ficolins direct activation to microorganisms expressing common carbohydrate structures. The absence of complement control proteins permits amplification of complement by the alternative pathway on any unprotected surface. The importance of complement recognition molecules (MBL, ficolins, factor H, C3, C1q, properdin, and others) to human disease are becoming clear as analysis of genetic data and knock out animals reveals links between complement proteins and specific diseases.

Properdin: New roles in pattern recognition and target clearance

Properdin was first described over 50 years ago by Louis Pillemer and his collaborators as a vital component of an antibody-independent complement activation pathway. In the 1970s properdin was shown to be a stabilizing component of the alternative pathway convertases, the central enzymes of the complement cascade. Recently we have reported that properdin can also bind to target cells and microbes, provide a platform for convertase assembly and function, and promote target phagocytosis. Evidence is emerging that suggests that properdin interacts with a network of target ligands, phagocyte receptors, and serum regulators. Here we review the new findings and their possible implications.

Properdin can initiate complement activation by binding specific target surfaces and providing a platform for de novo convertase assembly

Complement promotes the rapid recognition and elimination of pathogens, infected cells, and immune complexes. The biochemical basis for its target specificity is incompletely understood. In this report, we demonstrate that properdin can directly bind to microbial targets and provide a platform for the in situ assembly and function of the alternative pathway C3 convertases. This mechanism differs from the standard model wherein nascent C3b generated in the fluid phase attaches nonspecifically to its targets. Properdin-directed complement activation occurred on yeast cell walls (zymosan) and Neisseria gonorrhoeae. Properdin did not bind wild-type Escherichia coli, but it readily bound E. coli LPS mutants, and the properdin-binding capacity of each strain correlated with its respective serum-dependent AP activation rate. Moreover, properdin:single-chain Ab constructs were used to direct serum-dependent complement activation to novel targets. We conclude properdin participates in two distinct complement activation pathways: one that occurs by the standard model and one that proceeds by the properdin-directed model. The properdin-directed model is consistent with a proposal made by Pillemer and his colleagues >50 years ago.

The role of properdin in the assembly of the alternative pathway C3 convertases of complement

Complement is a powerful host defense system that contributes to both innate and acquired immunity. There are three pathways of complement activation, the classical pathway, lectin pathway, and alternative pathway. Each generates a C3 convertase, a serine protease that cleaves the central complement protein, C3. Nearly all the biological consequences of complement are dependent on the resulting cleavage products. Properdin is a positive regulator of complement activation that stabilizes the alternative pathway convertases (C3bBb). Properdin is composed of multiple identical protein subunits, with each subunit carrying a separate ligand-binding site. Previous reports suggest that properdin function depends on multiple interactions between its subunits with its ligands. In this study I used surface plasmon resonance assays to examine properdin interactions with C3b and factor B. I demonstrated that properdin promotes the association of C3b with factor B and provides a focal point for the assembly of C3bBb on a surface. I also found that properdin binds to preformed alternative pathway C3 convertases. These findings support a model in which properdin, bound to a target surface via C3b, iC3b, or other ligands, can use its unoccupied C3b-binding sites as receptors for nascent C3b, bystander C3b, or pre-formed C3bB and C3bBb complexes. New C3bP and C3bBP intermediates can lead to in situ assembly of C3bBbP. The full stabilizing effect of properdin on C3bBb would be attained as properdin binds more than one ligand at a time, forming a lattice of properdin: ligand interactions bound to a surface scaffold.

Meningococcal vaccines: a progress report

Neisseria meningitidis causes a wide range of human disease and remains a common cause of septicaemia and meningitis. Meningococcal serogroups A, B, C and Y cause the majority of cases of invasive disease in the US and throughout the world, with epidemics usually caused by serogroups A and C. Most patients with meningococcaemia, with or without meningitis, respond to standard antimicrobial therapy with either penicillin or ampicillin, but the recent emergence of meningococcal strains that are intermediately resistant to penicillin may alter these recommendations in the future. Given the devastating nature of meningococcal disease and emergence of these resistant strains, prevention (specifically through vaccination) remains the best approach to control this serious infection. A polysaccharide meningococcal vaccine is efficacious against disease caused by serogroups A, C, Y and W135, but is not effective in infants and children aged <2 years, and the duration of efficacy decreases markedly during the first 3 years after a single dose of the vaccine. Conjugate meningococcal vaccines have been developed to address these concerns. Initial studies with the meningococcal C conjugate vaccine have shown that the vaccine is safe and immunogenic and provides a T cell-dependent antigen that can be boosted by further doses of vaccine, or following exposure to the homologous organism or cross-reacting antigens. The UK recently implemented routine vaccination with the meningococcal C conjugate vaccine to all infants, and to all persons aged >1 year in a catch-up programme to immunise all school-aged children and young adults up to 20 years of age. Early postlicensure data indicate that this vaccine has shown significant efficacy in reduction of invasive meningococcal disease in these age groups. The full impact of vaccination will be determined once all age groups are immunised.

Protection against meningococcal serogroup ACYW disease in complement-deficient individuals vaccinated with the tetravalent meningococcal capsular polysaccharide vaccine

Individuals with properdin, C3 or late complement component deficiency (LCCD) frequently develop meningococcal disease. Vaccination of these persons has been recommended, although reports on efficacy are scarce and not conclusive. We immunized 53 complement-deficient persons, of whom 19 had properdin deficiency, seven a C3 deficiency syndrome and 27 had LCCD with the tetravalent (ACYW) meningococcal capsular polysaccharide vaccine. Serological studies were performed in 43 of them. As controls 25 non-complement-deficient relatives of the complement-deficient vaccinees and 21 healthy non-related controls were vaccinated. Post-vaccination, complement-deficient individuals and controls developed a significant immunoglobulin-specific antibody response to capsular polysaccharides group A, C, Y, W135, but a great individual variation was noticed. Also, the proportion of vaccinees of the various vaccinated groups with a significant increase in bactericidal titre (assayed with heterologous complement) was similar. Opsonization of meningococci A and W135 with sera of the 20 LCCD individuals yielded in 11 (55%) and eight (40%) sera a significant increase of phagocytic activity after vaccination, respectively. Despite vaccination, four complement-deficient patients experienced six episodes of meningococcal disease in the 6 years post-vaccination. Four episodes were due to serogroup B, not included in the vaccine. Despite good response to serogroup Y upon vaccination, disease due to serogroup Y occurred in two C8beta-deficient patients, 3.5 and 5 years post-vaccination. These results support the recommendation to vaccinate complement-deficient individuals and to revaccinate them every 3 years.

Properdin: approaching four decades of research

Properdin plays a key role in the alternative pathway by stabilizing the C3 convertase. This review chronicles the evolution of our knowledge of the structure and function of properdin over the 40 years since its discovery. The story begins with the first description of properdin and the controversy that ensued over its existence. Then, this review describes: the rediscovery and acceptance of properdin and the alternative pathway as important components of natural immunity; properdin structure and molecular sequence; speculations on the significance of sequence similarities to thrombospondin and other proteins, and properdin biosynthesis. Finally, this review characterizes properdin deficiency. Properdin does indeed appear to play an important role in homeostasis.

Infectious diseases associated with complement deficiencies

The complement system consists of both plasma and membrane proteins. The former influence the inflammatory response, immune modulation, and host defense. The latter are complement receptors, which mediate the cellular effects of complement activation, and regulatory proteins, which protect host cells from complement-mediated injury. Complement activation occurs via either the classical or the alternative pathway, which converge at the level of C3 and share a sequence of terminal components. Four aspects of the complement cascade are critical to its function and regulation: (i) activation of the classical pathway, (ii) activation of the alternative pathway, (iii) C3 convertase formation and C3 deposition, and (iv) membrane attack complex assembly and insertion. In general, mechanisms evolved by pathogenic microbes to resist the effects of complement are targeted to these four steps. Because individual complement proteins subserve unique functional activities and are activated in a sequential manner, complement deficiency states are associated with predictable defects in complement-dependent functions. These deficiency states can be grouped by which of the above four mechanisms they disrupt. They are distinguished by unique epidemiologic, clinical, and microbiologic features and are most prevalent in patients with certain rheumatologic and infectious diseases. Ethnic background and the incidence of infection are important cofactors determining this prevalence. Although complement undoubtedly plays a role in host defense against many microbial pathogens, it appears most important in protection against encapsulated bacteria, especially Neisseria meningitidis but also Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus influenzae, and, to a lesser extent, Neisseria gonorrhoeae. The availability of effective polysaccharide vaccines and antibiotics provides an immunologic and chemotherapeutic rationale for preventing and treating infection in patients with these deficiencies.

Childhood acute bacterial meningitis in the Sudan: an epidemiological, clinical and laboratory study

The aims of the present study were to document the epidemiology, clinical features and complications of childhood acute bacterial meningitis (ABM) in The Sudan during both an inter-epidemic (endemic) period (1985-1986), and the 1988 serogroup A epidemic; and to examine the phenotypic and genetic similarities and differences of Neisseria meningitidis strains isolated in The Sudan and Sweden. A new enzyme immunoassay test (Pharmacia Meningitis EIA-Test) was evaluated as a potential rapid diagnostic method for the detection of Haemophilus influenzae (HI) type b, Neisseria meningitidis (MC) and Streptococcus pneumoniae (PNC). The test was found to have good sensitivity (0.86) and specificity (0.95) in the inter-epidemic period; and to be adaptable to the field work in The Sudan during the 1988 MC epidemic. During inter-epidemic (endemic) situations in The Sudan, greater than 90% of childhood ABM was caused by one of the three organisms, HI type b, MC and PNC. HI accounted for 57% of the cases. The peak incidence (76%) of HI cases was in infants (less than 12 months) similar to the situation in other African countries. The overall case fatality ratio was 18.6%. Prospective follow-up of survivors for 3-4 years revealed that an additional 43% either died or had permanent neurological complications, the most prevalent and persistent of which was sensorineural hearing loss recorded in 22% of long term survivors. Post-meningitic children were found to have significantly lower intelligence quotients (92.3 +/- 13.9) than their sibling controls (100.7 +/- 10.2, P = 0.029). Features of the large serogroup A sulphonamide resistant MC epidemic (February-August 1988) in Khartoum are described. An estimated annual incidence of 1,679/100,000 was recorded at the peak of the epidemic. The highest attack rate was in young children less than 5 years, as in many other African countries; nevertheless, a high morbidity was observed in adults (31% of the cases greater than or equal to 20 years). The clinical features, mortality (6.3%) and short term sequelae in Sudanese children were generally within the framework described for MC disease elsewhere. Detailed analysis of MC isolates from Sudan and Sweden by characterizing their electrophoretic enzyme types, DNA restriction endonuclease pattern and outer membrane proteins, revealed that serogroup A MC clone III-1 was responsible of The Sudan epidemic in 1988 and has been the dominant serogroup A organism in Sweden since 1973. The Sudanese strains isolated prior to the epidemic (1985) were clone IV-1.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Immune response to tetravalent meningococcal vaccine: opsonic and bactericidal functions of normal and properdin deficient sera

Neisseria meningitidis serogroup W-135 appears to be a fairly common cause of infection associated with properdin deficiency or dysfunction, and anticapsular antibodies might be protective in these patients. For this reason, bactericidal and opsonophagocytic activities for serogroup W-135 were investigated before and four weeks after vaccination of two properdin-deficient adults with tetravalent meningococcal vaccine. In addition, the response of IgM, IgG and IgA class antibodies to the serogroups A, C, Y and W-135 was determined by ELISA. There was no evidence of poor antibody responses in the properdin-deficient persons. Vaccination promoted classical pathway-mediated killing in serum and opsonization of serogroup W-135 to the same extent as that seen in vaccinated controls. The increase of alternative pathway-mediated killing in the properdin-deficient sera was moderate, but vaccination clearly enhanced alternative pathway-mediated opsonophagocytosis in the sera. It was also shown that vaccination markedly reduced the requirement for properdin in alternative pathway-mediated killing of the meningococci.

Congenital properdin deficiency and meningococcal infection

We report a family in which three males in two generations had meningococcal infections; one of them died. Hemolytic activity of the alternative complement pathway in the two survivors and in one healthy boy belonging to the family was reduced, as measured in a kinetic system. These three individuals had 10-11% of normal properdin concentration in plasma, as measured by a catching ELISA method, while the other complement components were normal. Hemolytic complement activity was normalized when purified properdin was added. The data are compatible with an X-linked mode of inheritance of properdin deficiency.

Factors influencing susceptibility to meningococcal disease during an epidemic in The Gambia, West Africa

A study was made of factors that influenced susceptibility to group A meningococcal disease during an epidemic that affected The Gambia, West Africa during the dry season of 1982-83. No explanations were found for the distribution of cases between villages or within affected villages. Socio-economic status, crowding, nutrition and previous exposure to meningococcal disease all appeared to be unimportant. Examination of serum samples obtained before the outbreak from a few children who subsequently became patients and from an equal number of age-matched controls from the same village showed a higher mean serum IgA value in children who became patients than in controls. There were not, however, any significant differences found in the concentrations of IgG, IgM, complement or meningococcal antibody between the two groups. Four children who developed culture-proven group A meningococcal disease had raised titres of bactericidal antibody to the epidemic strain 2-3 months before their illnesses. Our findings suggest that some important risk factors for group A meningococcal disease remain to be identified.