Genome Editing and Protoplast Regeneration to Study Plant-Pathogen Interactions in the Model Plant Nicotiana benthamiana

Optimized protoplast isolation and transfection with a breakpoint: accelerating Cas9/sgRNA cleavage efficiency validation in monocot and dicot

The CRISPR-Cas genome editing tools are revolutionizing agriculture and basic biology with their simplicity and precision ability to modify target genomic loci. Software-predicted guide RNAs (gRNAs) often fail to induce efficient cleavage at target loci. Many target loci are inaccessible due to complex chromatin structure. Currently, there is no suitable tool available to predict the architecture of genomic target sites and their accessibility. Hence, significant time and resources are spent on performing editing experiments with inefficient guides. Although in vitro-cleavage assay could provide a rough assessment of gRNA efficiency, it largely excludes the interference of native genomic context. Transient in-vivo testing gives a proper assessment of the cleavage ability of editing reagents in a native genomic context. Here, we developed a modified protocol that offers highly efficient protoplast isolation from rice, Arabidopsis, and chickpea, using a sucrose gradient, transfection using PEG (polyethylene glycol), and validation of single guide RNAs (sgRNAs) cleavage efficiency of CRISPR-Cas9. We have optimized various parameters for PEG-mediated protoplast transfection and achieved high transfection efficiency using our protocol in both monocots and dicots. We introduced plasmid vectors containing Cas9 and sgRNAs targeting genes in rice, Arabidopsis, and chickpea protoplasts. Using dual sgRNAs, our CRISPR-deletion strategy offers straightforward detection of genome editing success by simple agarose gel electrophoresis. Sanger sequencing of PCR products confirmed the editing efficiency of specific sgRNAs. Notably, we demonstrated that isolated protoplasts can be stored for up to 24/48 h with little loss of viability, allowing a pause between isolation and transfection. This high-efficiency protocol for protoplast isolation and transfection enables rapid (less than 7 days) validation of sgRNA cleavage efficiency before proceeding with stable transformation. The isolation and transfection method can also be utilized for rapid validation of editing strategies, evaluating diverse editing reagents, regenerating plants from transfected protoplasts, gene expression studies, protein localization and functional analysis, and other applications.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s42994-024-00139-7.

Generation of CRISPR-edited birch plants without DNA integration using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation technology

CRISPR/Cas9 system has emerged as a powerful tool in genome editing; however, generation of CRISPR-edited DNA-free plants is still challenging. In this study, Betula platyphylla (birch) was used to build a method to generate CRISPR-edited plant without foreign DNA integration using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation (CPDAT method). This technique utilizes transient genetic transformation to introduce T-DNA coding gRNA and Cas9 into birch cells, and T-DNA will express to synthesize gRNA and Cas9 protein, which will form a complex to cleave the target DNA site. The genome may be mutated due to DNA repair, and these mutations will be preserved and accumulated not dependent on whether T-DNA is integrated into the genome or not. After transient transformation, birch plants were cut into explants to induce adventitious buds without antibiotic selection pressure. Each adventitious bud can be considered as an independent potentially CRISPR-edited line for mutation detection. CRISPR-edited birch plants without foreign DNA integration are further selected by screening CRISPR-edited lines without T-DNA integration. Among 65 randomly chosen independent lines, the mutation rate was 80.00% including 40.00% of lines with both alleles mutated. In addition, 5 lines out of 65 studied lines (7.69%) were CRISPR-edited birch plants without DNA integration. In conclusion, this innovative method presents a novel strategy for generating CRISPR-edited birch plants, thereby significantly enhancing the efficiency of generating common CRISPR-edited plants. These findings offer considerable potential to develop plant genome editing techniques further.

Isolation, Purification, and Application of Protoplasts and Transient Expression Systems in Plants

Protoplasts, derived from plant cells, exhibit remarkable totipotency and hold significant value across a wide spectrum of biological and biotechnological applications. These versatile applications encompass protein subcellular localization and interaction analysis, gene expression regulation, functional characterization, gene editing techniques, and single-cell sequencing. Protoplasts' usability stems from their inherent accessibility and their ability to efficiently incorporate exogenous genes. In this review, we provide a comprehensive overview, including details on isolation procedures and influencing factors, purification and viability assessment methodologies, and the utilization of the protoplast transient expression system. The aim is to provide a comprehensive overview of current applications and offer valuable insights into protoplast isolation and the establishment of transient expression systems in a diverse range of plant species, thereby serving as a valuable resource for the plant science community.

De novo transcriptome assembly and functional analysis reveal a dihydrochalcone 3-hydroxylase(DHC3H) of wild Malus species that produces sieboldin in vivo

Sieboldin is a specialised secondary metabolite of the group of dihydrochalcones (DHC), found in high concentrations only in some wild Malus species, closely related to the domesticated apple (Malus × domestica L.). To date, the first committed step towards the biosynthesis of sieboldin remains unknown. In this study, we combined transcriptomic analysis and a de novo transcriptome assembly to identify two putative 3-hydroxylases in two wild Malus species (Malus toringo (K. Koch) Carriere syn. sieboldii Rehder, Malus micromalus Makino) whose DHC profile is dominated by sieboldin. We assessed the in vivo activity of putative candidates to produce 3-hydroxyphloretin and sieboldin by de novo production in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We found that CYP98A proteins of wild Malus accessions (CYP98A195, M. toringo and CYP98A196, M. micromalus) were able to produce 3-hydroxyphloretin, ultimately leading to sieboldin accumulation by co-expression with PGT2. CYP98A197-198 genes of M. × domestica, however, were unable to hydroxylate phloretin in vivo. CYP98A195-196 proteins exerting 3-hydroxylase activity co-localised with an endoplasmic reticulum marker. CYP98A protein model from wild accessions showed mutations in key residues close to the ligand pocket predicted using phloretin for protein docking modelling. These mutations are located within known substrate recognition sites of cytochrome P450s, which could explain the acceptance of phloretin in CYP98A protein of wild accessions. Screening a Malus germplasm collection by HRM marker analysis for CYP98A genes identified three clusters that correspond to the alleles of domesticated and wild species. Moreover, CYP98A isoforms identified in M. toringo and M. micromalus correlate with the accumulation of sieboldin in other wild and hybrid Malus genotypes. Taken together, we provide the first evidence of an enzyme producing sieboldin in vivo that could be involved in the key hydroxylation step towards the synthesis of sieboldin in Malus species.

Cell-penetrating peptide: A powerful delivery tool for DNA-free crop genome editing

Genome editing system based on the CRISPR/Cas (clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats) technology is a milestone for biology. However, public concerns regarding genetically modified organisms (GMOs) and recalcitrance in the crop of choice for regeneration have limited its application. Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) are derived from protein transduction domains (PTDs) that can take on various cargoes across the plant wall, and membrane of target cells. Selected CPPs show mild cytotoxicity and are a suitable delivery tool for DNA-free genome editing. Moreover, CPPs may also be applied for the transient delivery of morphogenic transcription factors, also known as developmental regulators (DRs), to overcome the bottleneck of the crop of choice regeneration. In this review, we introduce a brief history of cell-penetrating peptides and discuss the practice of CPP-mediated DNA-free transfection and the prospects of this potential delivery tool for improving crop genome editing.

Increased rates of gene-editing events using a simplified RNAi configuration designed to reduce gene silencing

An optimal RNAi configuration that could restrict gene expression most efficiently was determined. This approach was also used to target PTGS and yielded higher rates of gene-editing events. Although it was characterized long ago, transgene silencing still strongly impairs transgene overexpression, and thus is a major barrier to plant crop gene-editing. The development of strategies that could prevent transgene silencing is therefore essential to the success of gene editing assays. Transgene silencing occurs via the RNA silencing process, which regulates the expression of essential genes and protects the plant from viral infections. The RNA silencing machinery thereby controls central biological processes such as growth, development, genome integrity, and stress resistance. RNA silencing is typically induced by aberrant RNA, that may lack 5' or 3' processing, or may consist in double-stranded or hairpin RNA, and involves DICER and ARGONAUTE family proteins. In this study, RNAi inducing constructs were designed in eleven different configurations and were evaluated for their capacity to induce silencing in Nicotiana spp. using transient and stable transformation assays. Using reporter genes, it was found that the overexpression of a hairpin consisting of a forward tandem inverted repeat that started with an ATG and that was not followed downstream by a transcription terminator, could downregulate gene expression most potently. Furthermore, using this method, the downregulation of the NtSGS3 gene caused a significant increase in transgene expression both in transient and stable transformation assays. This SGS3 silencing approach was also employed in gene-editing assays and caused higher rates of gene-editing events. Taken together, these findings suggested the optimal genetic configuration to cause RNA silencing and showed that this strategy may be used to restrict PTGS during gene-editing experiments.

Efficient production of transgene-free, gene-edited carrot plants via protoplast transformation

We have developed and validated an efficient protocol for producing gene-edited carrot plants that do not result in the stable incorporation of foreign DNA in the edited plant's genome. We report here a method for producing transgene-free, gene-edited carrot (Daucus carota subs. sativus) plants. With this approach, PEG-mediated transformation is used to transiently express a cytosine base editor and a guide RNA in protoplasts to induce targeted mutations in the carrot genome. These protoplasts are then cultured under conditions that lead to the production of somatic embryos which subsequently develop into carrot plants. For this study, we used the Centromere-Specific Histone H3 (CENH3) gene as a target for evaluating the efficiency with which regenerated, edited plants could be produced. After validating sgRNA performance and protoplast transformation efficiency using transient assays, we performed two independent editing experiments using sgRNAs targeting different locations within CENH3. In the first experiment, we analyzed 184 regenerated plants and found that 22 of them (11.9%) carried targeted mutations within CENH3, while in the second experiment, 28 out of 190 (14.7%) plants had mutations in CENH3. Of the 50 edited carrot lines that we analyzed, 43 were homozygous or bi-allelic for mutations in CENH3. No evidence of the base editor expression plasmid was found in the edited lines tested, indicating that this approach is able to produce transgene-free, gene-edited lines. The protocol that we describe provides an efficient method for easily generating large numbers of transgene-free, gene-edited carrot plants.

DNA-free CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing of wild tetraploid tomato Solanum peruvianum using protoplast regeneration

Wild tomatoes (Solanum peruvianum) are important genomic resources for tomato research and breeding. Development of a foreign DNA-free clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat (CRISPR)-Cas delivery system has potential to mitigate public concern about genetically modified organisms. Here, we established a DNA-free CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing system based on an optimized protoplast regeneration protocol of S. peruvianum, an important resource for tomato introgression breeding. We generated mutants for genes involved in small interfering RNAs biogenesis, RNA-DEPENDENT RNA POLYMERASE 6 (SpRDR6), and SUPPRESSOR OF GENE SILENCING 3 (SpSGS3); pathogen-related peptide precursors, PATHOGENESIS-RELATED PROTEIN-1 (SpPR-1) and PROSYSTEMIN (SpProSys); and fungal resistance (MILDEW RESISTANT LOCUS O, SpMlo1) using diploid or tetraploid protoplasts derived from in vitro-grown shoots. The ploidy level of these regenerants was not affected by PEG-Ca2+-mediated transfection, CRISPR reagents, or the target genes. By karyotyping and whole genome sequencing analysis, we confirmed that CRISPR-Cas9 editing did not introduce chromosomal changes or unintended genome editing sites. All mutated genes in both diploid and tetraploid regenerants were heritable in the next generation. spsgs3 null T0 regenerants and sprdr6 null T1 progeny had wiry, sterile phenotypes in both diploid and tetraploid lines. The sterility of the spsgs3 null mutant was partially rescued, and fruits were obtained by grafting to wild-type (WT) stock and pollination with WT pollen. The resulting seeds contained the mutated alleles. Tomato yellow leaf curl virus proliferated at higher levels in spsgs3 and sprdr6 mutants than in the WT. Therefore, this protoplast regeneration technique should greatly facilitate tomato polyploidization and enable the use of CRISPR-Cas for S. peruvianum domestication and tomato breeding.

Targeted Gene Knockouts by Protoplast Transformation in the Moss Physcomitrella patens

Targeted gene knockout is particularly useful for analyzing gene functions in plant growth, signaling, and development. By transforming knockout cassettes consisting of homologous sequences of the target gene into protoplasts, the classical gene targeting method aims to obtain targeted gene replacement, allowing for the characterization of gene functions in vivo. The moss Physcomitrella patens is a known model organism for a high frequency of homologous recombination and thus harbors a remarkable rate of gene targeting. Other moss features, including easy to culture, dominant haploidy phase, and sequenced genome, make gene targeting prevalent in Physcomitrella patens. However, even gene targeting was powerful to generate knockouts, researchers using this method still experienced technical challenges. For example, obtaining a good number of targeted knockouts after protoplast transformation and regeneration disturbed the users. Off-target mutations such as illegitimate random integration mediated by nonhomologous end joining and targeted insertion wherein one junction on-target but the other end off-target is commonly present in the knockouts. Protoplast fusion during transformation and regeneration was also a problem. This review will discuss the advantages and technical challenges of gene targeting. Recently, CRISPR-Cas9 is a revolutionary technology and becoming a hot topic in plant gene editing. In the second part of this review, CRISPR-Cas9 technology will be focused on and compared to gene targeting regarding the practical use in Physcomitrella patens. This review presents an updated perspective of the gene targeting and CRISPR-Cas9 techniques to plant biologists who may consider studying gene functions in the model organism Physcomitrella patens.

Efficient and Economical Targeted Insertion in Plant Genomes via Protoplast Regeneration

Versatile genome editing can be facilitated by the insertion of DNA sequences into specific locations. Current protocols involving CRISPR and Cas proteins rely on low efficiency homology-directed repair or non-homologous end joining with modified double-stranded DNA oligonucleotides as donors. Our simple protocol eliminates the need for expensive equipment, chemical and enzymatic donor DNA modification, or plasmid construction by using polyethylene glycol-calcium to deliver non-modified single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides and CRISPR-Cas9 ribonucleoprotein into protoplasts. Plants regenerated via edited protoplasts achieved targeted insertion frequencies of up to 50% in Nicotiana benthamiana and 13.6% in rapid cycling Brassica oleracea without antibiotic selection. Using a 60 nt donor containing 27 nt in each homologous arm, 6/22 regenerated N. benthamiana plants showed targeted insertions, and one contained a precise insertion of a 6 bp HindIII site. The inserted sequences were transmitted to the next generation and invite the possibility of future exploration of versatile genome editing by targeted DNA insertion in plants.

Protoplasts: From Isolation to CRISPR/Cas Genome Editing Application

In the clustered regulatory interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)/CRISPR associated protein (Cas) system, protoplasts are not only useful for rapidly validating the mutagenesis efficiency of various RNA-guided endonucleases, promoters, sgRNA designs, or Cas proteins, but can also be a platform for DNA-free gene editing. To date, the latter approach has been applied to numerous crops, particularly those with complex genomes, a long juvenile period, a tendency for heterosis, and/or self-incompatibility. Protoplast regeneration is thus a key step in DNA-free gene editing. In this report, we review the history and some future prospects for protoplast technology, including protoplast transfection, transformation, fusion, regeneration, and current protoplast applications in CRISPR/Cas-based breeding.