Improving the Cross-Subject Performance of the ERP-Based Brain-Computer Interface Using Rapid Serial Visual Presentation and Correlation Analysis Rank

Group-member selection for RSVP-based collaborative brain-computer interfaces

Objective

The brain-computer interface (BCI) systems based on rapid serial visual presentation (RSVP) have been widely utilized for the detection of target and non-target images. Collaborative brain-computer interface (cBCI) effectively fuses electroencephalogram (EEG) data from multiple users to overcome the limitations of low single-user performance in single-trial event-related potential (ERP) detection in RSVP-based BCI systems. In a multi-user cBCI system, a superior group mode may lead to better collaborative performance and lower system cost. However, the key factors that enhance the collaboration capabilities of multiple users and how to further use these factors to optimize group mode remain unclear.

Approach

This study proposed a group-member selection strategy to optimize the group mode and improve the system performance for RSVP-based cBCI. In contrast to the conventional grouping of collaborators at random, the group-member selection strategy enabled pairing each user with a better collaborator and allowed tasks to be done with fewer collaborators. Initially, we introduced the maximum individual capability and maximum collaborative capability (MIMC) to select optimal pairs, improving the system classification performance. The sequential forward floating selection (SFFS) combined with MIMC then selected a sub-group, aiming to reduce the hardware and labor expenses in the cBCI system. Moreover, the hierarchical discriminant component analysis (HDCA) was used as a classifier for within-session conditions, and the Euclidean space data alignment (EA) was used to overcome the problem of inter-trial variability for cross-session analysis.

Main results

In this paper, we verified the effectiveness of the proposed group-member selection strategy on a public RSVP-based cBCI dataset. For the two-user matching task, the proposed MIMC had a significantly higher AUC and TPR and lower FPR than the common random grouping mode and the potential group-member selection method. Moreover, the SFFS with MIMC enabled a trade-off between maintaining performance and reducing the number of system users.

Significance

The results showed that our proposed MIMC effectively optimized the group mode, enhanced the classification performance in the two-user matching task, and could reduce the redundant information by selecting the sub-group in the RSVP-based multi-user cBCI systems.

From lab to life: assessing the impact of real-world interactions on the operation of rapid serial visual presentation-based brain-computer interfaces

Objective.Brain-computer interfaces (BCI) have been extensively researched in controlled lab settings where the P300 event-related potential (ERP), elicited in the rapid serial visual presentation (RSVP) paradigm, has shown promising potential. However, deploying BCIs outside of laboratory settings is challenging due to the presence of contaminating artifacts that often occur as a result of activities such as talking, head movements, and body movements. These artifacts can severely contaminate the measured EEG signals and consequently impede detection of the P300 ERP. Our goal is to assess the impact of these real-world noise factors on the performance of a RSVP-BCI, specifically focusing on single-trial P300 detection.Approach.In this study, we examine the impact of movement activity on the performance of a P300-based RSVP-BCI application designed to allow users to search images at high speed. Using machine learning, we assessed P300 detection performance using both EEG data captured in optimal recording conditions (e.g. where participants were instructed to refrain from moving) and a variety of conditions where the participant intentionally produced movements to contaminate the EEG recording.Main results.The results, presented as area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC-AUC) scores, provide insight into the significant impact of noise on single-trial P300 detection. Notably, there is a reduction in classifier detection accuracy when intentionally contaminated RSVP trials are used for training and testing, when compared to using non-intentionally contaminated RSVP trials.Significance.Our findings underscore the necessity of addressing and mitigating noise in EEG recordings to facilitate the use of BCIs in real-world settings, thus extending the reach of EEG technology beyond the confines of the laboratory.

Semantic image sorting method for RSVP presentation

Objective.The rapid serial visual presentation (RSVP) paradigm, which is based on the electroencephalogram (EEG) technology, is an effective approach for object detection. It aims to detect the event-related potentials (ERP) components evoked by target images for rapid identification. However, the object detection performance within this paradigm is affected by the visual disparity between adjacent images in a sequence. Currently, there is no objective metric to quantify this visual difference. Consequently, a reliable image sorting method is required to ensure the generation of a smooth sequence for effective presentation.Approach. In this paper, we propose a novel semantic image sorting method for sorting RSVP sequences, which aims at generating sequences that are perceptually smoother in terms of the human visual experience.Main results. We conducted a comparative analysis between our method and two existing methods for generating RSVP sequences using both qualitative and quantitative assessments. A qualitative evaluation revealed that the sequences generated by our method were smoother in subjective vision and were more effective in evoking stronger ERP components than those generated by the other two methods. Quantitatively, our method generated semantically smoother sequences than the other two methods. Furthermore, we employed four advanced approaches to classify single-trial EEG signals evoked by each of the three methods. The classification results of the EEG signals evoked by our method were superior to those of the other two methods.Significance. In summary, the results indicate that the proposed method can significantly enhance the object detection performance in RSVP-based sequences.

[Research progress of brain-computer interface application paradigms based on rapid serial visual presentation]

Rapid serial visual presentation (RSVP) is a type of psychological visual stimulation experimental paradigm that requires participants to identify target stimuli presented continuously in a stream of stimuli composed of numbers, letters, words, images, and so on at the same spatial location, allowing them to discern a large amount of information in a short period of time. The RSVP-based brain-computer interface (BCI) can not only be widely used in scenarios such as assistive interaction and information reading, but also has the advantages of stability and high efficiency, which has become one of the common techniques for human-machine intelligence fusion. In recent years, brain-controlled spellers, image recognition and mind games are the most popular fields of RSVP-BCI research. Therefore, aiming to provide reference and new ideas for RSVP-BCI related research, this paper reviewed the paradigm design and system performance optimization of RSVP-BCI in these three fields. It also looks ahead to its potential applications in cutting-edge fields such as entertainment, clinical medicine, and special military operations.

A novel brain-computer interface based on audio-assisted visual evoked EEG and spatial-temporal attention CNN

Objective

Brain-computer interface (BCI) can translate intentions directly into instructions and greatly improve the interaction experience for disabled people or some specific interactive applications. To improve the efficiency of BCI, the objective of this study is to explore the feasibility of an audio-assisted visual BCI speller and a deep learning-based single-trial event related potentials (ERP) decoding strategy.

Approach

In this study, a two-stage BCI speller combining the motion-onset visual evoked potential (mVEP) and semantically congruent audio evoked ERP was designed to output the target characters. In the first stage, the different group of characters were presented in the different locations of visual field simultaneously and the stimuli were coded to the mVEP based on a new space division multiple access scheme. And then, the target character can be output based on the audio-assisted mVEP in the second stage. Meanwhile, a spatial-temporal attention-based convolutional neural network (STA-CNN) was proposed to recognize the single-trial ERP components. The CNN can learn 2-dimentional features including the spatial information of different activated channels and time dependence among ERP components. In addition, the STA mechanism can enhance the discriminative event-related features by adaptively learning probability weights.

Main results

The performance of the proposed two-stage audio-assisted visual BCI paradigm and STA-CNN model was evaluated using the Electroencephalogram (EEG) recorded from 10 subjects. The average classification accuracy of proposed STA-CNN can reach 59.6 and 77.7% for the first and second stages, which were always significantly higher than those of the comparison methods (p < 0.05).

Significance

The proposed two-stage audio-assisted visual paradigm showed a great potential to be used to BCI speller. Moreover, through the analysis of the attention weights from time sequence and spatial topographies, it was proved that STA-CNN could effectively extract interpretable spatiotemporal EEG features.

[A spatial-temporal hybrid feature extraction method for rapid serial visual presentation of electroencephalogram signals]

Rapid serial visual presentation-brain computer interface (RSVP-BCI) is the most popular technology in the early discover task based on human brain. This algorithm can obtain the rapid perception of the environment by human brain. Decoding brain state based on single-trial of multichannel electroencephalogram (EEG) recording remains a challenge due to the low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and nonstationary. To solve the problem of low classification accuracy of single-trial in RSVP-BCI, this paper presents a new feature extraction algorithm which uses principal component analysis (PCA) and common spatial pattern (CSP) algorithm separately in spatial domain and time domain, creating a spatial-temporal hybrid CSP-PCA (STHCP) algorithm. By maximizing the discrimination distance between target and non-target, the feature dimensionality was reduced effectively. The area under the curve (AUC) of STHCP algorithm is higher than that of the three benchmark algorithms (SWFP, CSP and PCA) by 17.9%, 22.2% and 29.2%, respectively. STHCP algorithm provides a new method for target detection.

Combining Statistical Analysis and Machine Learning for EEG Scalp Topograms Classification

Incorporating brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) into daily life requires reducing the reliance of decoding algorithms on the calibration or enabling calibration with the minimal burden on the user. A potential solution could be a pre-trained decoder demonstrating a reasonable accuracy on the naive operators. Addressing this issue, we considered ambiguous stimuli classification tasks and trained an artificial neural network to classify brain responses to the stimuli of low and high ambiguity. We built a pre-trained classifier utilizing time-frequency features corresponding to the fundamental neurophysiological processes shared between subjects. To extract these features, we statistically contrasted electroencephalographic (EEG) spectral power between the classes in the representative group of subjects. As a result, the pre-trained classifier achieved 74% accuracy on the data of newly recruited subjects. Analysis of the literature suggested that a pre-trained classifier could help naive users to start using BCI bypassing training and further increased accuracy during the feedback session. Thus, our results contribute to using BCI during paralysis or limb amputation when there is no explicit user-generated kinematic output to properly train a decoder. In machine learning, our approach may facilitate the development of transfer learning (TL) methods for addressing the cross-subject problem. It allows extracting the interpretable feature subspace from the source data (the representative group of subjects) related to the target data (a naive user), preventing the negative transfer in the cross-subject tasks.

Two brains, one target: Design of a multi-level information fusion model based on dual-subject RSVP

BACKGROUND

Rapid serial visual presentation (RSVP) based brain-computer interface (BCI) is widely used to categorize the target and non-target images. The available information limits the prediction accuracy of single-trial using single-subject electroencephalography (EEG) signals. New Method. Hyperscanning is a new manner to record two or more subjects' signals simultaneously. So we designed a multi-level information fusion model for target image detection based on dual-subject RSVP, namely HyperscanNet. The two modules of this model fuse the data and features of the two subjects at the data and feature layers. A chunked long and short-term memory artificial neural network (LSTM) was used in the time dimension to extract features at different periods separately, completing fine-grained underlying feature extraction. While the feature layer is fused, some plain operations are used to complete the fusion of the data layer to ensure that important information is not missed.

RESULTS

Experimental results show that the F1-score (the harmonic mean of precision and recall) of this method with best group of channels and segment length is 82.76%. Comparison with existing methods. This method improves the F1-score by at least 5% compared to single-subject target detection.

CONCLUSIONS

Target detection can be accomplished by the two subjects' collaboration to achieve a higher and more stable F1-score than a single subject.

Optimization of Task Allocation for Collaborative Brain-Computer Interface Based on Motor Imagery

OBJECTIVE

Collaborative brain-computer interfaces (cBCIs) can make the BCI output more credible by jointly decoding concurrent brain signals from multiple collaborators. Current cBCI systems usually require all collaborators to execute the same mental tasks (common-work strategy). However, it is still unclear whether the system performance will be improved by assigning different tasks to collaborators (division-of-work strategy) while keeping the total tasks unchanged. Therefore, we studied a task allocation scheme of division-of-work and compared the corresponding classification accuracies with common-work strategy's.

APPROACH

This study developed an electroencephalograph (EEG)-based cBCI which had six instructions related to six different motor imagery tasks (MI-cBCI), respectively. For the common-work strategy, all five subjects as a group had the same whole instruction set and they were required to conduct the same instruction at a time. For the division-of-work strategy, every subject's instruction set was a subset of the whole one and different from each other. However, their union set was equal to the whole set. Based on the number of instructions in a subset, we divided the division-of-work strategy into four types, called "2 Tasks" … "5 Tasks." To verify the effectiveness of these strategies, we employed EEG data collected from 19 subjects who independently performed six types of MI tasks to conduct the pseudo-online classification of MI-cBCI.

MAIN RESULTS

Taking the number of tasks performed by one collaborator as the horizontal axis (two to six), the classification accuracy curve of MI-cBCI was mountain-like. The curve reached its peak at "4 Tasks," which means each subset contained four instructions. It outperformed the common-work strategy ("6 Tasks") in classification accuracy (72.29 ± 4.43 vs. 58.53 ± 4.36%).

SIGNIFICANCE

The results demonstrate that our proposed task allocation strategy effectively enhanced the cBCI classification performance and reduced the individual workload.