Knockout of the HaREase Gene Improves the Stability of dsRNA and Increases the Sensitivity of Helicoverpa armigera to Bacillus thuringiensis Toxin

Identification and functional analysis of gut dsRNases in the beet armyworm Spodoptera exigua

RNA interference (RNAi)-based products have the potential to significantly contribute to insect pest control. However, RNAi efficiency varies widely among different insect orders, particularly in Lepidoptera, where it is often low. One key factor affecting RNAi efficiency is the presence of double-stranded ribonuclease (dsRNase) in the digestive tract, which can degrade dsRNA prior to uptake by gut cells. In this study, four dsRNases were identified in the beet armyworm, Spdoptera exigua, of which two were highly expressed gut dsRNases, SedsRNase1 and SedsRNase2. To assess their effect on dsRNA degradation activity via the oral route, CRISPR/Cas9-based gene editing was employed to knock out these gut dsRNases. The results indicate that all mutant strains, including SeKO1 (knockout SedsRNase1), SeKO2 (knockout SedsRNase2), and SeKO1KO2 (knockout SedsRNase1 and SedsRNase2), showed significantly decreased dsRNA degradation activity, particularly in the SeKO1KO2 mutant strain, where the weakest degradation occurred in both the gut and whole body. Additionally, we noticed that the lack of gut SedsRNases led to a slight extended developmental period and reduced reproductive capacity in S. exigua. Collectively, these findings deepen our understanding of gut SedsRNases and how they can impact the biology of the beet armyworm and can support the exploration dsRNA-based approaches for pest control.

Ex vivo delivery of dsRNA targeting ryanodine receptors for control of Tuta absoluta

BACKGROUND

RNA interference (RNAi) is an endogenous eukaryote viral defence mechanism representing a unique form of post-transcriptional gene silencing. Owing to its high specificity, this technology is being developed for use in dsRNA-based biopesticides for control of pest insects. Whilst many lepidopteran species are recalcitrant to RNAi, Tuta absoluta, a polyphagous insect responsible for extensive crop damage, is sensitive. Ryanodine receptors (RyRs) are intracellular calcium channels regulating calcium ion (Ca2+) release. The chemical pesticide class of diamides functions agonistically against lepidopteran RyR, resulting in uncontrolled Ca2+ release, feeding cessation and death. Resistance to diamides has emerged in T. absoluta, derived from RyR point mutations.

RESULTS

RNAi was used to target RyR transcripts of T. absoluta. Data presented here demonstrate the systemic use of exogenous T. absoluta RyR-specific (TaRy) dsRNA in tomato plants (Solanum lycopersicum) to significantly downregulate expression of the target gene, resulting in significant insect mortality and reduced leaf damage. Using a leaflet delivery system, daily dosing of 3 μg TaRy dsRNA for 72 h resulted in 50% downregulation of the target gene and 50% reduction in tomato leaf damage. Corrected larval mortality and adult emergence were reduced by 38% and 33%, respectively. TaRy dsRNA demonstrated stability in tomato leaves ≤72 h after dosing.

CONCLUSIONS

This work identifies TaRy as a promising target for RNAi control of this widespread crop pest. © 2024 The Author(s). Pest Management Science published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Society of Chemical Industry.

Recent advances in understanding of the mechanisms of RNA interference in insects

We highlight the recent 5 years of research that contributed to our understanding of the mechanisms of RNA interference (RNAi) in insects. Since its first discovery, RNAi has contributed enormously as a reverse genetic tool for functional genomic studies. RNAi is also being used in therapeutics, as well as agricultural crop and livestock production and protection. Yet, for the wider application of RNAi, improvement of its potency and delivery technologies is needed. A mechanistic understanding of every step of RNAi, from cellular uptake of RNAi trigger molecules to targeted mRNA degradation, is key for developing an efficient strategy to improve RNAi technology. Insects provide an excellent model for studying the mechanism of RNAi due to species-specific variations in RNAi efficiency. This allows us to perform comparative studies in insect species with different RNAi sensitivity. Understanding the mechanisms of RNAi in different insects can lead to the development of better strategies to improve RNAi and its application to manage agriculturally and medically important insects.

Functional Characterization and Putative Regulatory Mechanism of an RNAi Efficiency-Related Nuclease (REase) in the Fall Armyworm, Spodoptera frugiperda

The lepidopteran-specific RNAi efficiency-related nuclease (REase) has been shown to contribute to double-strand RNA (dsRNA) degradation in several lepidopteran insects. However, little is known about its regulatory mechanism. In this study, we identified and characterized SfREase in Spodoptera frugiperda. The exposure of the third-instar larvae to dsEGFP and high temperature led to the upregulation of SfREase, whereas starvation treatment resulted in the downregulation of SfREase. Further experiments revealed that dsRNA degraded more slowly in the hemolymph or midgut fluid extracted from dsSfREase-injected or dsSfREase-ingested larvae compared with those from dsEGFP-treated larvae, and the recombinant SfREase degraded dsRNA in a concentration-dependent manner. Additionally, the knockdown of SfREase improved RNAi efficiency. Finally, both RNAi and dual-luciferase reporter assay in Sf9 cells revealed that SfREase is negatively regulated by FOXO. These data provide insights into the function and regulatory mechanism of REase and have applied implications for the development of an RNAi-based control strategy of S. frugiperda.

Hsp70 and Hsp90 Elaborately Regulate RNAi Efficiency in Plutella xylostella

Heat-shock proteins (HSPs) serve as molecular chaperones in the RNA interference (RNAi) pathway of eukaryotic organisms. In model organisms, Hsp70 and Hsp90 facilitate the folding and remodeling of the client protein Argonaute (Ago). However, the specific function of HSPs in the RNAi pathway of Plutella xylostella (L.) (Lepidoptera: Plutellidae) remains unknown. In this study, we identified and analyzed the coding sequences of PxHsc70-4 and PxHsp83 (also known as PxHsp90). Both PxHsc70-4 and PxHsp83 exhibited three conserved domains that covered a massive portion of their respective regions. The knockdown or inhibition of PxHsc70-4 and PxHsp83 in vitro resulted in a significant increase in the gene expression of the dsRNA-silenced reporter gene PxmRPS18, leading to a decrease in its RNAi efficiency. Interestingly, the overexpression of PxHsc70-4 and PxHsp83 in DBM, Sf9, and S2 cells resulted in an increase in the bioluminescent activity of dsRNA-silenced luciferase, indicating a decrease in its RNAi efficiency via the overexpression of Hsp70/Hsp90. Furthermore, the inhibition of PxHsc70-4 and PxHsp83 in vivo resulted in a significant increase in the gene expression of PxmRPS18. These findings demonstrated the essential involvement of a specific quantity of Hsc70-4 and Hsp83 in the siRNA pathway in P. xylostella. Our study offers novel insights into the roles played by HSPs in the siRNA pathway in lepidopteran insects.

dsRNase1 contribution to dsRNA degradation activity in the Sf9 cells conditioned medium

RNA interference (RNAi) is inefficient in lepidopteran insects, including Spodoptera frugiperda. RNase activity in the lumen and hemocoel is known to contribute to low RNAi efficiency in these insects. Conditioned medium from Sf9 cells developed from ovaries of S. frugiperda shows high dsRNA degradation activity. But the enzymes responsible for this activity have not been identified. The nuclease genes that are highly expressed in Sf9 cells, REase, RNaseT2, and dsRNase1, were identified. Knockdown of dsRNase1 in Sf9 cells resulted in a reduction of dsRNA degradation activity in the Sf9 cells conditioned medium. Knockdown of dsRNase1 also increased RNAi efficiency in Sf9 cells. The results from these studies identified a major player in dsRNA degradation activity in the Sf9 cells conditioned medium. We also describe an efficient system that can be used to identify other genes responsible for dsRNA degradation and RNAi efficiency in Sf9 cells.

A fructose receptor gene influences development and feed intake in Helicoverpa armigera

Gustatory receptors (GRs) are critical for multiple life activities of insects. Owing to the rapid development of genome and transcriptome sequencing, numerous insect GRs have been identified. However, the expression patterns and functions of these receptors are poorly understood. In this study, we analyzed the expression pattern of GRs in Helicoverpa armigera and found that the fructose receptor HarmGR9 was highly expressed in the foregut and abdomen. The function of HarmGR9 was identified using the clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)/CRISPR-associated protein 9 (Cas9) system. Knockout of the HarmGR9 gene shortened the developmental period of the larval stages and increased food consumption in both larvae and adults. This study revealed the tissue distribution of sugar-sense-related receptors in H. armigera and thereby expanded the understanding of insect feeding regulation.

Why is oral-induced RNAi inefficient in Diatraea saccharalis? A possible role for DsREase and other nucleases

The efficiency of RNAi technology in insects varies considerably, particularly in lepidopterans. An important limiting factor of RNAi-mediated gene silencing is the degradation of dsRNA by insect nucleases before cellular uptake. To date, few studies have reported effective gene knockdown in the sugarcane borer Diatraea saccharalis. However, yielding contradictory results when using oral delivery. Further, the RNAi efficiency in D. saccharalis and presumed activity of gut nucleases remain poorly understood. Therefore, we investigated whether gene silencing was feasible via dsRNA feeding in D. saccharalis. Two different genes were tested, juvenile hormone esterase (DsJHE) and chitin synthase 1 (DsCHS1). Discrete knockdown was verified only for DsCHS1 with high dsRNA dosages and long exposure times. Neither mortality nor abnormal phenotypes were observed after treatment with any tested dsRNA. It was also verified that dsRNAs were quickly degraded when incubated with gut juice. Furthermore, we identified four possible nucleases that could reduce the knockdown efficiency in D. saccharalis. Three of them had the endonuclease_NS domain (DsNucleases), and one had the PIN domain (DsREase), with REase-like genes being scarcely represented in databanks. We further remark that DsNuclease1 and DsREase are highly expressed in the larval gut, and DsREase was upregulated as insects were fed with artificial diet (without dsRNA), and also when injected with dsRNA. Conversely, no nuclease was triggered when insects were fed with a sucrose droplet containing dsRNA. Thus, our findings suggest that nuclease activity within the gut is one of the possible reasons for the inefficiency of RNAi in D. saccharalis. Our data may shed light on the challenges to overcome when introducing RNAi as a strategy for controlling lepidopteran pests.

Multiple dsRNases Involved in Exogenous dsRNA Degradation of Fall Armyworm Spodoptera frugiperda

RNAi is regarded as a promising technology for pest control. However, not all insects are sensitive to RNAi. Studies have confirmed that insect dsRNases are one of key factors affecting RNAi efficiency. In the current study, we identified four genes coding for dsRNases from the Spodoptera frugiperda genome. Spatial and temporal expression analysis showed that those dsRNases were highly expressed in the midgut and old larvae. Then a delivery method was applied for inducing efficient RNAi based on dsRNA encapsulated by liposome. Furthermore, we assessed degradation efficiency by incubation with dsRNA with gut juice or hemocoel to characterize potential roles of different SfdsRNases after suppression of SfdsRNase. The result showed that interferenced with any sfdsRNase reduced the degradation of exogenous dsRNA in midgut, interfered with sfdsRNase1 and sfdsRNase3 slowed down the degradation of exogenous dsRNA in hemolymph. Our data suggest the evolutionary expansion and multiple high activity dsRNase genes would take part in the RNAi obstinate in S. frugiperda, besides we also provide an efficient RNAi method for better use of RNAi in S. frugiperda.

The stability and sequence cleavage preference of dsRNA are key factors differentiating RNAi efficiency between migratory locust and Asian corn borer

We compared the stability of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) in each of two body fluids (hemolymph, midgut fluid) and in each of two tissues (integument, midgut), and the uptake of dsRNA in each of two cultured tissues (integument, midgut) between the migratory locust (Locusta migratoria) and the Asian corn borer (Ostrinia furnacalis). We further compared the abundance of putative small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) generated from each of two dsRNAs (dsβ-actin, dsEf1α) and the preference of dsRNA cleavages between the two insect species. Our studies showed a rapid degradation of dsRNA in the midgut fluids of both insect species and in O. furnacalis hemolymph. However, dsRNA remained reasonably stable in L. migratoria hemolymph. When nuclease degradation of dsRNA in cultured tissues was inhibited, dsRNA uptake was not significantly different between the two species. We further showed that the silencing efficiency against target genes was consistent with the abundance of putative siRNAs processed from the dsRNA. In addition, O. furnacalis showed a strong preference in cleaving dsRNA when the nucleotide G was in the position of "1" at 5'-end whereas L. migratoria showed broad spectrum in cleavage sites to generate siRNA. Taken together, our study revealed that silencing efficiency of a target gene by RNAi was directly related to the dsRNA degradation by nucleases and the abundance of siRNAs generated from the dsRNA.

Visualization of the process of a nanocarrier-mediated gene delivery: stabilization, endocytosis and endosomal escape of genes for intracellular spreading

Nanoparticles have been widely applied as gene carrier for improving RNA interference (RNAi) efficiency in medical and agricultural fields. However, the mechanism and delivery process of nanoparticle-mediated RNAi is not directly visualized and elucidated. Here we synthesized a star polymer (SPc) consisted of a hydrophilic shell with positively-charged tertiary amine in the side chain, which was taken as an example to investigate the mechanism in gene delivery. The SPc could assemble with dsRNA spontaneously through electrostatic force, hydrogen bond and van der Waals force. Interestingly, the SPc could protect dsRNA from degradation by RNase A and insect hemolymph, thus remarkably increasing the stability of dsRNA. Meanwhile, the SPc could efficiently promote the cellular uptake and endosomal escape for intracellular spreading of dsRNA. Transcriptome analysis revealed that the SPc could up-regulate some key genes such as Chc, AP2S1 and Arf1 for activating clathrin-mediated endocytosis. Furthermore, the suppression of endocytosis hindered the cellular uptake of SPc-delivered dsRNA in vitro, and the subsequent RNAi effect was also disappeared in vivo. To our knowledge, our study is the first direct visualization of the detailed cellular delivery process and mechanism of nanocarrier-mediated gene delivery. Above mechanism supports the application of nanocarrier-based RNAi in gene therapy and pest management.

CRISPR/Cas9-Mediated Genome Editing System in Insect Genomics and Pest Management

The CRISPR/Cas9 is being developed as an invaluable system that allows rapid and site-specific genome editing in a wide variety of organisms, including diverse insects. It has been successfully used for gene function annotations of RNAi pathway in insect genomics and will facilitate research on RNAi mechanism. Here, we describe a streamlined method to generate and detect somatic and germline knockout mutations of desired target genes in tephritid pests by injecting mRNA encoding the Cas9 endonuclease and in vitro transcribed single guide RNA (sgRNA) into embryos. Target site selection, sgRNA synthesis, Cas9 synthesis, microinjection, and mutation identification are presented in detail.

A dsRNA-degrading nuclease (dsRNase2) limits RNAi efficiency in the Asian corn borer (Ostrinia furnacalis)

The efficiency of RNA interference (RNAi) varies substantially among different insect species. Rapid degradation of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) by dsRNA-degrading nucleases (dsRNases) has been implicated to cause low RNAi efficiency in several insect species. In this study, we identified four dsRNase genes (OfdsRNase1, OfdsRNase2, OfdsRNase3 and OfdsRNase4) from the Asian corn borer (Ostrinia furnacalis) transcriptome database. Bioinformatic analyses showed that each deduced protein sequence contained endonuclease NS domains and signal peptides. Gene expression analysis revealed that OfdsRNase2 was exclusively expressed in the midgut of larvae. RNAi efficiency was investigated in 2-d-old fifth-instar larvae (high expression of dsRNase2) and 2-d-old pupae (low expression of dsRNase2) by feeding or injecting dsRNA targeting a marker gene that encodes the lethal giant larvae protein (OfLgl). Our results showed that OfLgl only partially silenced the expression of OfLgl in pupae, but not in larvae, suggesting that OfdsRNase2 could contribute to lower RNAi efficiency in larval stages. This hypothesis was supported by our RNAi-of-RNAi experiment using a tissue culture technique where the silencing efficiency against the reporter gene, OfHex1, was significantly improved after knockdown of OfdsRNase2. When double luciferase assays were performed to evaluate the role of the four dsRNases in vitro, only OfdsRNase2 expressed in S2 cells significantly affected RNAi efficiency by degrading dsRNA. Taken together, our results suggested that the degradation of dsRNA by OfdsRNase2 in the midgut contributed to low RNAi efficiency in O. furnacalis larvae.

CRISPR/Cas9 in lepidopteran insects: Progress, application and prospects

Clustered regularly spaced short palindrome repeats (CRISPR) structure family forms the acquired immune system in bacteria and archaea. Recent advances in CRISPR/Cas genome editing as derived from prokaryotes, confirmed the characteristics of robustness, high target specificity and programmability, and also revolutionized the insect sciences field. The successful application of CRISPR in a wide variety of lepidopteran insects, with a high genetic diversity, provided opportunities to explore gene functions, insect modification and pest control. In this review, we present a detailed overview on the recent progress of CRISPR in lepidopteran insects, and described the basic principles of the system and its application. Major interest is on wing development, pigmentation, mating, reproduction, sex determination, metamorphosis, resistance and silkworm breeding innovation. Finally, we outlined the limitations of CRISPR/Cas system and discussed its application prospects in lepidopteran insects.

Characterization, expression patterns, and transcriptional responses of three core RNA interference pathway genes from Ostrinia nubilalis

RNA interference (RNAi) is commonly used in the laboratory to analyze gene function, and RNAi-based pest management strategies are now being employed. Unfortunately, RNAi is hindered by inefficient and highly-variable results when different insects are targeted, especially lepidopterans, such as the European corn borer (ECB), Ostrinia nubilalis (Lepidoptera: Crambidae). Previous efforts to achieve RNAi-mediated gene suppression in ECB revealed low RNAi efficiency with both double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) injection and ingestion. One mechanism that can affect RNAi efficiency in insects is the expression and function of core RNAi pathway genes, such as those encoding Argonaut 2 (Ago2), Dicer 2 (Dcr2), and a dsRNA binding protein (R2D2). To determine if deficiencies in these core RNAi pathway genes contribute to low RNAi efficiency in ECB, full-length complementary DNAs encoding OnAgo2, OnDcr2, and OnR2D2 were cloned, sequenced, and characterized. A comparison of domain architecture suggested that all three predicted proteins contained the necessary domains to function. However, a comparison of evolutionary distances revealed potentially important variations in the first RNase III domain of OnDcr2, the double-stranded RNA binding domains of OnR2D2, and both the PAZ and PIWI domains of OnAgo2, which may indicate functional differences in enzymatic activity between species. Expression analysis indicated that transcripts for all three genes were expressed in all developmental stages and tissues investigated. Interestingly, the introduction of non-target dsRNA into ECB second-instar larvae via microinjection did not affect OnAgo2, OnDcr2, or OnR2D2 expression. In contrast, ingestion of the same dsRNAs resulted in upregulation of OnDcr2 but downregulation of OnR2D2. The unexpected transcriptional responses of the core machinery and the divergence in amino-acid sequence between specific domains in each core RNAi protein may possibly contribute to low RNAi efficiency in ECB. Understanding the contributions of different RNAi pathway components is critical to adapting this technology for use in controlling lepidopteran pests that exhibit low RNAi efficiency.

Molecular Characterizations of Double-Stranded RNA Degrading Nuclease Genes from Ostrinia nubilalis

Simple Summary

RNA interference is a gene suppression tool that uses double-stranded RNA to prevent specific genes from producing proteins. By targeting essential genes RNA interference can be developed for control of insect pests. Unfortunately, RNA interference is not equally effective for all insects. Previous investigation suggested that RNA is rapidly digested by unidentified components of body fluids in the European corn borer caterpillar. We characterized genes encoding proteins from European corn borer that are associated with RNA digestion in other insects. Our results suggest that two proteins (RNA interference efficiency-related nuclease and double-stranded RNA-degrading endonuclease 2) may be responsible for digesting RNAs in the European corn borer gut, whereas two other proteins (double-stranded RNA-degrading endonuclease 1 and double-stranded RNA-degrading endonuclease 4) may be responsible for digesting RNA in European corn borer body fluid. These findings suggest digestion of RNA in the European corn borer is likely due to the activity of these proteins. These findings provide information about the mechanism(s) influencing RNA stability in insects. The knowledge generated by this study will facilitate the development of strategies for enhancing RNA interference in insects.

Abstract

Variable RNA interference (RNAi) efficiencies limit RNAi-based pest management strategies for many pests. Previous efforts to understand mechanisms contributing to low RNAi efficiency indicate that double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) is degraded in the European corn borer (ECB), Ostrinia nubilalis, due to nuclease activity. To investigate the contribution of dsRNA-degrading endonucleases (dsRNases) and lepidopteran-specific RNAi efficiency-related nucleases (REases) to dsRNA instability and low RNAi efficiency in ECB, five complementary DNAs putatively encoding four dsRNases (OndsRNase1, 2, 3, and 4) and one REase (OnREase) were sequenced. Characterization of these transcripts revealed that substrate specificity might vary among the four dsRNases due to different amino acid combinations in the substrate-binding sites. Gene expression analysis indicated that OndsRNase2 and OnREase were highly expressed in the larval gut, and OndsRNase1 showed the highest expression in hemolymph, especially in older developmental stages. Transcript level analysis after dsRNA exposure revealed that expression of OnREase rapidly increased upon dsRNA ingestion or injection, whereas OndsRNase4 expression only increased after long-term ingestion of dsRNA. While the biological function of these nucleases remains to be verified, our results suggest that OnREase and OndsRNase2, and OndsRNase1 and OndsRNase4 may be responsible for degradation of dsRNAs in the ECB gut and hemolymph, respectively, thereby contributing to low RNAi efficiency.