Particle Safety Assessment in Additive Manufacturing: From Exposure Risks to Advanced Toxicology Testing

Assessment of the carcinogenic potential of particulate matter generated from 3D printing devices in Balb/c 3T3-1-1 cells

Recently, there have been reports of sarcoma occurring in a Korean science teachers who used a 3D printer with acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) and polylactic acid (PLA) filaments for educational purposes. However, limited toxicological research data on 3D printing make it challenging to confirm a causal relationship between 3D printing and cancer. Therefore, occupational accidents involving teachers who have developed sarcoma have not been officially recognized. To address this gap, we aimed to evaluate the carcinogenic potential of particulate matter produced from ABS and PLA filaments commonly used in 3D printing. We created a generator mimicking 3D printing to generate particulate matter, which was used as an experimental material. The collected particulate matter was exposed to an in vitro system to investigate genetic damage, effects on cell transformation, and changes in carcinogenesis-related genes. Various assays, such as the comet assay, cell transformation assays, microarray analysis, and glucose consumption measurement, were employed. Cytotoxicity tests performed to determine the exposure concentration for the comet assay showed that cell viability was 83.6, 62.6, 42.0, and 10.2% for ABS at exposure concentrations of 50, 100, 200, and 400 µg/mL, respectively. PLA showed 91.7, 80.3, 65.1, and 60.8% viability at exposure concentrations of 50, 100, 200, and 400 µg/mL, respectively. Therefore, 50 µg/mL was set as the highest concentration for both ABS and PLA, and 25 and 12.5 µg/mL were set as the medium and low concentrations, respectively. The comet assay showed no changes in genetic damage caused by the particulate matter. Cytotoxicity results performed to establish exposure concentrations in the transformation assay showed that ABS showed cell viability of 88.0, 77.4, 84.7, and 85.5% at concentrations of 1.25, 2.5, 5, and 10 µg/mL, respectively, but few cells survived at concentrations above 20 µg/mL. PLA showed minimal cytotoxicity up to a concentration of 20 µg/ml. Therefore, in the cell transformation assay, a concentration of 10 µg/mL for ABS and 20 µg/mL for PLA was set as the highest exposure concentration, followed by medium and low exposure concentrations with a common ratio of 2. In cell transformation assays, only one transformed focus each was observed for both ABS and PLA particulate matter-exposed cells. The microarray assay revealed changes in gene expression, with a 41.7% change at 10 µg/mL for ABS and an 18.6% change at 20 µg/mL for PLA compared to the positive control group. Analysis of carcinogenesis-related gene expression changes on days 1, 7, and 25 of the promotion phase revealed that in cells exposed to 5 µg/mL of ABS, RBM3 gene expression increased by 3.66, 3.26, and 3.74 times, respectively, while MPP6 gene expression decreased by 0.33, 0.28, and 0.38 times, respectively, compared to the negative control group. Additionally, the measurement of glucose consumption showed that it increased in cells exposed to ABS and PLA particulate matter. Our findings suggest that the carcinogenic potential of ABS- and PLA-derived particulate matter in 3D printing cannot be completely ruled out. Therefore, further research in other test systems and analysis of additional parameters related to carcinogenesis, are deemed necessary to evaluate the carcinogenic risk of 3D printers using these materials.

Responsible Development of Emerging Technologies: Extensions and Lessons From Nanotechnology for Worker Protection

OBJECTIVES

This paper identifies approaches to the responsible development of emerging technologies to secure worker safety and health.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis was used to describe the history of the responsible development of worker protection from engineered nanomaterials. Lessons from that history were extended and applied to emerging technologies and illustrated in three examples: advanced manufacturing, synthetic biology, and artificial intelligence.

RESULTS

The same principles used to underpin responsible development of nanotechnology can be applied to emerging technologies. Five criterion actions were identified that embody these principles.

CONCLUSION

Responsible development of emerging technologies requires anticipating hazards and risks and ethical issues attendant to them. Occupational and environment health specialists are often called upon to provide guidance on emerging technologies and the approach described here can serve as a basis for that guidance.

Visible particles in parenteral drug products: A review of current safety assessment practice

Parenteral drug products (PDPs) are administered extensively to treat various diseases. Product quality plays a critical role in ensuring patient safety and product efficacy. One important quality challenge is the contamination of particles in PDPs. Particle presence in PDPs represents potential safety risk to patients. Differential guidance and practice have been in place for visible (VPs) and subvisible particles (SVPs) in PDPs. For SVPs, the amount limits have been harmonized in multiple Pharmacopeias. The pharmaceutical industry follows the guided limits for regulatory and quality compliance. However, for VPs, no such acceptable limit has been set. This results in not only quality but also safety challenges for manufacturers and drug developers in managing and evaluating VPs. It is important to understand the potential safety risk of VPs so these can be weighed against the benefit of the PDPs. To evaluate their potential risk(s), it is necessary to understand their nature, origin, frequency of their occurrence, safety risk, the risk mitigation measures, and the method to evaluate their safety. The current paper reviews the critical literature on these aspects and provides insight into considerations when performing safety assessment and managing the risk(s) for VPs in PDPs.

The triple exposure nexus of microplastic particles, plastic-associated chemicals, and environmental pollutants from a human health perspective

The presence of microplastics (MPs) is increasing at a dramatic rate globally, posing risks for exposure and subsequent potential adverse effects on human health. Apart from being physical objects, MP particles contain thousands of plastic-associated chemicals (i.e., monomers, chemical additives, and non-intentionally added substances) captured within the polymer matrix. These chemicals are often migrating from MPs and can be found in various environmental matrices and human food chains; increasing the risks for exposure and health effects. In addition to the physical and chemical attributes of MPs, plastic surfaces effectively bind exogenous chemicals, including environmental pollutants (e.g., heavy metals, persistent organic pollutants). Therefore, MPs can act as vectors of environmental pollution across air, drinking water, and food, further amplifying health risks posed by MP exposure. Critically, fragmentation of plastics in the environment increases the risk for interactions with cells, increases the presence of available surfaces to leach plastic-associated chemicals, and adsorb and transfer environmental pollutants. Hence, this review proposes the so-called triple exposure nexus approach to comprehensively map existing knowledge on interconnected health effects of MP particles, plastic-associated chemicals, and environmental pollutants. Based on the available data, there is a large knowledge gap in regard to the interactions and cumulative health effects of the triple exposure nexus. Each component of the triple nexus is known to induce genotoxicity, inflammation, and endocrine disruption, but knowledge about long-term and inter-individual health effects is lacking. Furthermore, MPs are not readily excreted from organisms after ingestion and they have been found accumulated in human blood, cardiac tissue, placenta, etc. Even though the number of studies on MPs-associated health impacts is increasing rapidly, this review underscores that there is a pressing necessity to achieve an integrated assessment of MPs' effects on human health in order to address existing and future knowledge gaps.

Pulmonary evaluation of whole-body inhalation exposure of polycarbonate (PC) filament 3D printer emissions in rats

During fused filament fabrication (FFF) 3D printing with polycarbonate (PC) filament, a release of ultrafine particles (UFPs) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) occurs. This study aimed to determine PC filament printing emission-induced toxicity in rats via whole-body inhalation exposure. Male Sprague Dawley rats were exposed to a single concentration (0.529 mg/m3, 40 nm mean diameter) of the 3D PC filament emissions in a time-course via whole body inhalation for 1, 4, 8, 15, and 30 days (4 hr/day, 4 days/week), and sacrificed 24 hr after the last exposure. Following exposures, rats were assessed for pulmonary and systemic responses. To determine pulmonary injury, total protein and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) activity, surfactant proteins A and D, total as well as lavage fluid differential cells in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) were examined, as well as histopathological analysis of lung and nasal passages was performed. To determine systemic injury, hematological differentials, and blood biomarkers of muscle, metabolic, renal, and hepatic functions were also measured. Results showed that inhalation exposure induced no marked pulmonary or systemic toxicity in rats. In conclusion, inhalation exposure of rats to a low concentration of PC filament emissions produced no significant pulmonary or systemic toxicity.

Immunotoxic, genotoxic, and endocrine disrupting impacts of polyamide microplastic particles and chemicals

Due to their exceptional properties and cost effectiveness, polyamides or nylons have emerged as widely used materials, revolutionizing diverse industries, including industrial 3D printing or additive manufacturing (AM). Powder-based AM technologies employ tonnes of polyamide microplastics to produce complex components every year. However, the lack of comprehensive toxicity assessment of particulate polyamides and polyamide-associated chemicals, especially in the light of the global microplastics crisis, calls for urgent action. This study investigated the physicochemical properties of polyamide-12 microplastics used in AM, and assessed a number of toxicity endpoints focusing on inflammation, immunometabolism, genotoxicity, aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR) activation, endocrine disruption, and cell morphology. Specifically, microplastics examination by means of field emission scanning electron microscopy revealed that work flow reuse of material created a fraction of smaller particles with an average size of 1-5 µm, a size range readily available for uptake by human cells. Moreover, chemical analysis by means of gas chromatography high-resolution mass spectrometry detected several polyamide-associated chemicals including starting material, plasticizer, thermal stabilizer/antioxidant, and migrating slip additive. Even if polyamide particles and chemicals did not induce an acute inflammatory response, repeated and prolonged exposure of human primary macrophages disclosed a steady increase in the levels of proinflammatory chemokine Interleukin-8 (IL-8/CXCL-8). Moreover, targeted metabolomics disclosed that polyamide particles modulated the kynurenine pathway and some of its key metabolites. The p53-responsive luciferase reporter gene assay showed that particles per se were able to activate p53, being indicative of a genotoxic stress. Polyamide-associated chemicals triggered moderate activation of AhR and elicited anti-androgenic activity. Finally, a high-throughput and non-targeted morphological profiling by Cell Painting assay outlined major sites of bioactivity of polyamide-associated chemicals and indicated putative mechanisms of toxicity in the cells. These findings reveal that the increasing use of polyamide microplastics may pose a potential health risk for the exposed individuals, and it merits more attention.

Health hazards of particles in additive manufacturing: a cross-disciplinary study on reactivity, toxicity and occupational exposure to two nickel-based alloys

The increasing use of additive manufacturing (AM) techniques (e.g., 3D-printing) offers many advantages but at the same time presents some challenges. One concern is the possible exposure and health risk related to metal containing particles of different sizes. Using the nickel-based alloys Hastelloy X (HX) and Inconel 939 (IN939) as a case, the aim of this cross-disciplinary study was to increase the understanding on possible health hazards and exposure. This was done by performing in-depth characterization of virgin, reused and condensate powders, testing in vitro toxicity (cytotoxicity, genotoxicity, oxidative stress), and measuring occupational airborne exposure. The results showed limited metal release from both HX and IN939, and slightly different surface composition of reused compared to virgin powders. No or small effects on the cultured lung cells were observed when tested up to 100 µg/mL. Particle background levels in the printing facilities were generally low, but high transient peaks were observed in relation to sieving. Furthermore, during post processing with grinding, high levels of nanoparticles (> 100,000 particles/cm3) were noted. Urine metal levels in AM operators did not exceed biomonitoring action limits. Future studies should focus on understanding the toxicity of the nanoparticles formed during printing and post-processing.

NLRP3 inflammasome as a sensor of micro- and nanoplastics immunotoxicity

Micro- and nanoplastics (MNPs) are emerging pollutants with scarcely investigated effects on human innate immunity. If they follow a similar course of action as other, more thoroughly investigated particulates, MNPs may penetrate epithelial barriers, potentially triggering a cascade of signaling events leading to cell damage and inflammation. Inflammasomes are intracellular multiprotein complexes and stimulus-induced sensors critical for mounting inflammatory responses upon recognition of pathogen- or damage-associated molecular patterns. Among these, the NLRP3 inflammasome is the most studied in terms of activation via particulates. However, studies delineating the ability of MNPs to affect NLRP3 inflammasome activation are still rare. In this review, we address the issue of MNPs source and fate, highlight the main concepts of inflammasome activation via particulates, and explore recent advances in using inflammasome activation for assessment of MNP immunotoxicity. We also discuss the impact of co-exposure and MNP complex chemistry in potential inflammasome activation. Development of robust biological sensors is crucial in order to maximize global efforts to effectively address and mitigate risks that MNPs pose for human health.

A Novel Nanosafety Approach Using Cell Painting, Metabolomics, and Lipidomics Captures the Cellular and Molecular Phenotypes Induced by the Unintentionally Formed Metal-Based (Nano)Particles

Additive manufacturing (AM) or industrial 3D printing uses cutting-edge technologies and materials to produce a variety of complex products. However, the effects of the unintentionally emitted AM (nano)particles (AMPs) on human cells following inhalation, require further investigations. The physicochemical characterization of the AMPs, extracted from the filter of a Laser Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF) 3D printer of iron-based materials, disclosed their complexity, in terms of size, shape, and chemistry. Cell Painting, a high-content screening (HCS) assay, was used to detect the subtle morphological changes elicited by the AMPs at the single cell resolution. The profiling of the cell morphological phenotypes, disclosed prominent concentration-dependent effects on the cytoskeleton, mitochondria, and the membranous structures of the cell. Furthermore, lipidomics confirmed that the AMPs induced the extensive membrane remodeling in the lung epithelial and macrophage co-culture cell model. To further elucidate the biological mechanisms of action, the targeted metabolomics unveiled several inflammation-related metabolites regulating the cell response to the AMP exposure. Overall, the AMP exposure led to the internalization, oxidative stress, cytoskeleton disruption, mitochondrial activation, membrane remodeling, and metabolic reprogramming of the lung epithelial cells and macrophages. We propose the approach of integrating Cell Painting with metabolomics and lipidomics, as an advanced nanosafety methodology, increasing the ability to capture the cellular and molecular phenotypes and the relevant biological mechanisms to the (nano)particle exposure.

Comprehensive Analysis of Two H13-Type Starting Materials Used for Laser Cladding and Aerosol Particles Formed in This Process

Laser cladding with H13 steel powders was performed and the related material transformations were studied for the particles emitted during this process. Fractions of various sizes of the aerosol particles formed during the laser cladding were collected on a cascade impactor, while the electromobility and the aerodynamic size of the particles were measured using a scanning mobility particle spectrometer and an aerodynamic particle sizer, respectively. The aerosol particles deposited onto the impactor plates were analyzed using scanning electron microscopy−energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy, as well as total-reflection X-ray fluorescence and X-ray absorption near-edge structure spectroscopy. Both the concentration and mean oxidation state of the major components were correlated with the aerosol particle size. The ultrafine aerosol particles (with a diameter less than about 100 nm) were predominantly oxidized and formed as the result of an evaporation−oxidation−condensation process sequence. The larger particles (>200 nm in geometric diameter) were primarily the residues of the original metal powder and exhibited a composition change as compared to the as-received metal powder. Correlations between the changes in the concentration ratio of the components were detected and explained.