A Review of Microfluidic Detection Strategies for Heavy Metals in Water

Fill, Fold, Photo: Preconcentration and Multiplex Detection of Trace Level Heavy Metals in Water

Heavy metal contamination is an increasing global threat to human and environmental health, particularly in resource-limited areas. Traditional platforms for heavy metal detection are labor intensive and expensive and require lab facilities. While paper-based colorimetric sensors offer a simpler approach, their sensitivity limitations prevent them from meeting legislative requirements for many metals. Existing preconcentration systems, on the other hand, can achieve lower detection limits but typically focus on analyzing only one metal, making comprehensive monitoring difficult. We address these limitations by introducing a low-cost preconcentration system coupled with colorimetric analysis for the simultaneous detection of seven metal ions at low ppb levels without the need for external equipment outside a smartphone. The system achieved detection limits of 15 ppb (Ni(II)), 7 ppb (Cu(II)), 2 ppb (Fe(III)), 20 ppb (Cr(VI)), 13 ppb (Pb(II)), 26 ppb (Hg(II)), and 15 ppb (Mn(II)) with six out of seven limits of detection values falling well below EPA regulatory guidelines for drinking water. The user-friendly Fill, Fold, Photo approach eliminates complex pretreatment steps. Smartphone-based detection offers portable quantification within seconds. Employing masking strategies ensured higher selectivity for each assay on the card, while our packaging protocols enable system stability for over 4 weeks of study, facilitating mass production and deployment within a realistic time frame. To validate the sensor's performance in real-world scenarios, the sensor was tested with environmental water samples. The sensor demonstrated good recovery, ranging from 77% to 94% compared to the standard ICP-MS method. Furthermore, spike recovery analysis confirmed the sensor's accuracy, with a relative standard deviation (RSD) of less than 15%. This technology holds significant promise for future development as a convenient, portable solution for field-based monitoring of a broad spectrum of water contaminants, including pesticides, PFAS, fertilizers, and beyond.

Indirect detection of lead(II), cadmium(II) and mercury(II) on a microfluidic electrophoresis chip

Water environments contaminated by heavy metal ions present significant challenges because these pollutants do not degrade naturally, leading to their gradual bioaccumulation in animals and plants, which ultimately poses an insurmountable threat to human health. Therefore, rapid and accurate detection of heavy metal ions in water is of great significance for environmental protection and disease prevention. In this work, we developed a novel method based on microfluidic electrophoresis coupled with indirect chemiluminescence for the immediate detection of Cd(II), Pb(II) and Hg(II) heavy metal ions. The displacement of the Co(II) ions within the chemiluminescence mixture by the above migrating sample cations caused a measurable reduction in the background signal. The results showed that the detection limits of Cd(II), Pb(II) and Hg(II) ions under the best detection conditions were 5.83 × 10-8 M, 5.38 × 10-8 M and 2.09 × 10-8 M, respectively, which were 1-2 orders of magnitude lower than those of the indirect UV method and 1 order of magnitude lower than that of the indirect laser induced detection method. This method can provide a possibility for the rapid detection of multiple heavy metal ions in actual water environments.

Carbon and boron nitride quantum dots as optical sensor probes for selective detection of toxic metals in drinking water: a quantum chemical prediction through structure- and morphology-dependent electronic and optical properties

Toxic metals present in drinking water pose a serious threat to the environment and human beings when present in abundance. In this work, we investigated the sensing ability of quantum dots (pristine CQDs, boron/nitrogen/sulphur (B/N/S)-doped CQDs, and BNQDs) of various sizes and morphologies (rectangular, circular, and triangular) towards toxic metals such as arsenic (As), cobalt (Co), nickel (Ni), copper (Cu), and lead (Pb) using quantum chemical density functional theory calculations in both gas and water phases. We probed the structural, electronic, and optical properties of the QDs. All the modelled QDs are energetically stable. Frontier molecular orbital analysis predicted that BNQDs are more chemically stable than all other CQDs. UV-vis absorption and Raman spectra analyses helped to understand the optical properties of all the QDs. Further, adsorption studies revealed that triangular pristine CQDs and sulphur-doped CQDs show higher adsorption affinity towards the toxic metals. The magnitude of adsorption energies follows the trend Ni > Pb > As > Cu > Co in most of the QDs. Several pristine and doped CQDs exhibited chemisorption towards the toxic metals, and hence, they can be used as adsorbents. However, a majority of BNQDs showed physisorption towards the metals, and therefore, they can be used as efficient optical sensors compared to CQDs. Further, the sensing ability of the QDs was explored through optical phenomena such as changes in UV-vis absorption spectra and fluorescence after metal adsorption. When compared to pristine CQDs and B/N/S-doped CQDs, metal complexation caused significant changes in the UV-vis absorbance peak intensities in BNQDs along with peak shifts. Moreover, metal interaction with the QDs increased their fluorescence lifetime with the highest values observed in Co-adsorbed triangular H18C46 (152.30 ns), Pb-adsorbed rectangular H15C30S (21.29 ns), and As-adsorbed circular B27N27H18 (2.99 μs) among pristine CQDs, B/N/S-doped CQDs, and BNQDs, respectively. Overall, we believe that our first-of-its-kind computational prediction of the optical sensing ability of tailor-made zero-dimensional systems such as QDs will be a great aid for experimentalists in designing novel and rapid optical probes to detect toxic metals in drinking water.

Integrated microfluidic platforms for heavy metal sensing: a comprehensive review

Heavy metals are found naturally; however, anthropogenic activities such as mining, inappropriate disposal of industrial waste, and the use of pesticides and fertilizers containing heavy metals can cause their unwanted release into the environment. Conventionally, detection of heavy metals is performed using atomic absorption spectrometry, electrochemical methods and inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry; however, they involve expensive and sophisticated instruments and multistep sample preparation that require expertise for accurate results. In contrast, microfluidic devices involve rapid, cost-efficient, simple, and reliable approaches for in-laboratory and real-time monitoring of heavy metals. The use of inexpensive and environment friendly materials for fabrication of microfluidic devices has increased the manufacturing efficiency of the devices. Different types of techniques used in heavy metal detection include colorimetry, absorbance-based, and electrochemical detection. This review provides insight into the detection of toxic heavy metals such as mercury (Hg), cadmium (Cd), lead (Pb), and arsenic (As). Importance is given to colorimetry, optical, and electrochemical techniques applied for the detection of heavy metals using microfluidics and their modifications to improve the limit of detection (LOD).

Use of a rhodamine-based chelator in a microfluidic paper-based analytical device for the in-situ copper quantification in natural waters

This work describes the development of a microfluidic paper-based analytical device (μPAD) for the determination of copper in fresh and marine waters. A functionalized rhodamine-based chelator was synthesized and used as a chromogenic reagent, forming a highly intense pink complex with the analyte. The aim was to create a paper device that offers optimal performance and provides in-situ, rapid and cost-effective analysis in line with World Health Organization guidelines. The influence on the determination of several physical and chemical parameters was evaluated aiming to achieve the best performance. Under optimised conditions, a linear correlation was established in the range of 0.05-0.50 mg L-1 of copper, with a limit of detection of 10 μg L-1. The accuracy of the proposed method was assessed by comparing the results obtained with the developed μPAD and the results obtained with Inductively Coupled Plasma measurements (RE < 10 %). Recovery studies were also performed using different types of water samples with no need for any prior sample pre-treatment: tap, well, river and seawater. The average recovery percentage of 101 % (RSD = 4.3 %) was obtained, a clear indication of no multiplicative matrix interferences.

Multi-scale fractal Fourier Ptychographic microscopy to assess the dose-dependent impact of copper pollution on living diatoms

Accumulation of bioavailable heavy metals in aquatic environment poses a serious threat to marine communities and human health due to possible trophic transfers through the food chain of toxic, non-degradable, exogenous pollutants. Copper (Cu) is one of the most spread heavy metals in water, and can severely affect primary producers at high doses. Here we show a novel imaging test to assay the dose-dependent effects of Cu on live microalgae identifying stress conditions when they are still capable of sustaining a positive growth. The method relies on Fourier Ptychographic Microscopy (FPM), capable to image large field of view in label-free phase-contrast mode attaining submicron lateral resolution. We uniquely combine FPM with a new multi-scale analysis method based on fractal geometry. The system is able to provide ensemble measurements of thousands of diatoms in the liquid sample simultaneously, while ensuring at same time single-cell imaging and analysis for each diatom. Through new image descriptors, we demonstrate that fractal analysis is suitable for handling the complexity and informative power of such multiscale FPM modality. We successfully tested this new approach by measuring how different concentrations of Cu impact on Skeletonema pseudocostatum diatom populations isolated from the Sarno River mouth.

Absorption-based colorimetric detection of nickel(II) ion by phase separation of thermoresponsive magnetic nanoparticles under microflow

Therma-Max™ LSA Streptavidin is a thermoresponsive magnetic nanoparticle (TMNP). It can be introduced conveniently to molecular recognition groups by avidin-biotin interaction. In this study, we demonstrated the detection of nickel(II) ions by the magnetic separation of TMNP induced by their phase transition under microflow. The NTA-tagged TMNP solution mixed with a Ni2+ sample was introduced into a microchannel with a well structure. Moreover, the sample was heated to induce the thermally induced aggregation of TMNP. The Ni-capturing TMNP were trapped in the well by magnetic fields. The supernatant was removed from the outlet, and a dimethylglyoxime (DMG) solution was introduced into the device for colorimetric detection in the well. Because DMG has a higher stability constant with Ni2+, sensitive colorimetric detection of Ni2+ can be achieved in devices where the sample volume, e.g., optical pathlength, is short. To demonstrate the feasibility of the proposed method, a recovery test was conducted using a commercially available cosmetic sample. Therein, complete collection was achieved.

Microfluidics in environmental analysis: advancements, challenges, and future prospects for rapid and efficient monitoring

Microfluidic devices have emerged as advantageous tools for detecting environmental contaminants due to their portability, ease of use, cost-effectiveness, and rapid response capabilities. These devices have wide-ranging applications in environmental monitoring of air, water, and soil matrices, and have also been applied to agricultural monitoring. Although several previous reviews have explored microfluidic devices' utility, this paper presents an up-to-date account of the latest advancements in this field for environmental monitoring, looking back at the past five years. In this review, we discuss devices for prominent contaminants such as heavy metals, pesticides, nutrients, microorganisms, per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), etc. We cover numerous detection methods (electrochemical, colorimetric, fluorescent, etc.) and critically assess the current state of microfluidic devices for environmental monitoring, highlighting both their successes and limitations. Moreover, we propose potential strategies to mitigate these limitations and offer valuable insights into future research and development directions.

Microfluidic advances in food safety control

Food contamination is a global concern, particularly in developing countries. Two main types of food contaminants-chemical and biological-are common problems that threaten human health. Therefore, rapid and accurate detection methods are required to address the threat of food contamination. Conventional methods employed to detect these two types of food contaminants have several limitations, including high costs and long analysis time. Alternatively, microfluidic technology, which allows for simple, rapid, and on-site testing, can enable us to control food safety in a timely, cost-effective, simple, and accurate manner. This review summarizes advances in microfluidic approaches to detect contaminants in food. Different detection methods have been applied to microfluidic platforms to identify two main types of contaminants: chemical and biological. For chemical contaminant control, the application of microfluidic approaches for detecting heavy metals, pesticides, antibiotic residues, and other contaminants in food samples is reviewed. Different methods including enzymatic, chemical-based, immunoassay-based, molecular-based, and electrochemical methods for chemical contaminant detection are discussed based on their working principle, the integration in microfluidic platforms, advantages, and limitations. Microfluidic approaches for foodborne pathogen detection, from sample preparation to final detection, are reviewed to identify foodborne pathogens. Common methods for foodborne pathogens screening, namely immunoassay, nucleic acid amplification methods, and other methods are listed and discussed; highlighted examples of recent studies are also reviewed. Challenges and future trends that could be employed in microfluidic design and fabrication process to address the existing limitations for food safety control are also covered. Microfluidic technology is a promising tool for food safety control with high efficiency and applicability. Miniaturization, portability, low cost, and samples and reagents saving make microfluidic devices an ideal choice for on-site detection, especially in low-resource areas. Despite many advantages of microfluidic technology, the wide manufacturing of microfluidic devices still demands intensive studies to be conducted for user-friendly and accurate food safety control. Introduction of recent advances of microfluidic devices will build a comprehensive understanding of the technology and offer comparative analysis for future studies and on-site application.

Live synthesis of selective carbon dots as fluorescent probes for cobalt determination in water with an automatic microanalyzer

A new strategy integrating the straight synthesis of carbon dots (CDs) and their direct use for the determination of heavy metals by means of fluorescence quenching is presented. The proposal consists of a modular analyzer, which includes a low temperature co-fired ceramics (LTCC) microreactor for the synthesis of CDs and a cyclic olefin copolymer (COC) microfluidic platform, which automatically performs a reverse flow injection analysis (rFIA) protocol for the determination of heavy metal ions in water by CD fluorescence quenching. As a proof of concept, nitrogen-doped CDs were synthesized from acrylic acid and ethylenediamine (ED) with quantum yields (QYs) of up to 44%, which are selective to cobalt. With the described system, we synthesized homogeneous CDs without the need for further purification and with the minimum consumption of reagents, and optimized fluorescence measurements can be performed with freshly obtained luminescent nanomaterials that have not undergone decomposition processes. They have an average hydrodynamic diameter of 4.2 ± 0.9 nm and maximum excitation and emission wavelengths at 358 nm and 452 nm, respectively. The system allows the automatic dilution and buffering of the synthesized CDs and the sample prior to the determination of cobalt. The concentration of cobalt was determined with good sensitivity and a limit of detection of 7 μg·L-1 with a linear range of 0.02-1 mg·L-1 of Co2+. Spiked tap water and river water samples were analyzed, obtaining recovery from 98 to 104%. This demonstrates the potential of the equipment as an efficient on-site control system for heavy metal monitoring in water.

Integrated Plastic Microfluidic Device for Heavy Metal Ion Detection

The presence of heavy metal ions in soil, air and water constitutes an important global environmental threat, as these ions accumulate throughout the food chain, contributing to the rise of chronic diseases, including, amongst others, cancer and kidney failure. To date, many efforts have been made for their detection, but there is still a need for the development of sensitive, low-cost, and portable devices able to conduct on-site detection of heavy metal ions. In this work, we combine microfluidic technology and electrochemical sensing in a plastic chip for the selective detection of heavy metal ions utilizing DNAzymes immobilized in between platinum nanoparticles (PtNPs), demonstrating a reliable portable solution for water pollution monitoring. For the realization of the microfluidic-based heavy metal ion detection device, a fast and easy-to-implement fabrication method based on the photolithography of dry photosensitive layers is proposed. As a proof of concept, we demonstrate the detection of Pb2+ ions using the prototype microfluidic device.

Microfluidic Devices for Heavy Metal Ions Detection: A Review

The contamination of air, water and soil by heavy metal ions is one of the most serious problems plaguing the environment. These metal ions are characterized by a low biodegradability and high chemical stability and can affect humans and animals, causing severe diseases. In addition to the typical analysis methods, i.e., liquid chromatography (LC) or spectrometric methods (i.e., atomic absorption spectroscopy, AAS), there is a need for the development of inexpensive, easy-to-use, sensitive and portable devices for the detection of heavy metal ions at the point of interest. To this direction, microfluidic and lab-on-chip (LOC) devices fabricated with novel materials and scalable microfabrication methods have been proposed as a promising approach to realize such systems. This review focuses on the recent advances of such devices used for the detection of the most important toxic metal ions, namely, lead (Pb), mercury (Hg), arsenic (As), cadmium (Cd) and chromium (Cr) ions. Particular emphasis is given to the materials, the fabrication methods and the detection methods proposed for the realization of such devices in order to provide a complete overview of the existing technology advances as well as the limitations and the challenges that should be addressed in order to improve the commercial uptake of microfluidic and LOC devices in environmental monitoring applications.

Sustainable Downscaled Catalytic Colorimetric Determination of Manganese in Freshwater Using Smartphone-Based Monitoring Oxidation of 3,3′,5,5′-Tetramethylbenzidine by Periodate

A sustainable downscaled procedure using smartphone-based colorimetric determination of manganese (Mn(II)) was developed. This novel Mn(II) determination procedure is proposed using a simple, available microwell-plate platform and a smartphone as a detector. This approach is based on the oxidation of 3,3′,5,5′-tetramethylbenzidine (TMB) by periodate using Mn(II) as a catalyst. The catalytic kinetics of Mn(II) under different conditions was investigated to determine the optimum condition where the different catalytic activities of various concentrations of Mn(II) evince. Under the optimum condition, the bluish-green product of oxidized TMB, proportioned to the concentration of Mn(II), was monitored using a smartphone camera, and the color signals were processed using ImageJ Software. The developed procedure showed great selectivity and sensitivity as linearity ranged from 1.8 × 10⁻⁶ to 4.6 × 10⁻⁵ M (0.1 to 2.5 μg/mL). The limits of detection and quantitation were 3.6 × 10⁻⁶ and 1.1 × 10⁻⁵ M (0.2 and 0.6 μg/mL), respectively. The determination of Mn(II) in freshwater samples was demonstrated to assess environmental water quality as an initial model to more easily promote water management according to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UN-SDGs). The intensity of the red could be successfully applied to evaluate Mn(II) in canals and river water with no significant differences compared with the reference method of Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectrometry at a confidence level of 95%.

Plot-on-demand integrated paper-based sensors for drop-volume voltammetric monitoring of Pb(II) and Cd(II) using a bismuth nanoparticle-modified electrode

The fabrication of fully ink-drawn fluidic electrochemical paper-based analytical devices (ePADs) is reported for the determination of trace Pb(II) and Cd(II) by differential pulse anodic stripping voltammetry (DPASV). The fluidic pattern was formed on the paper substrate using an inexpensive computer-controlled x-y plotter and a commercial hydrophobic marker pen. Then, electrodes were deposited on the devices using a second x-y plotting step with a commercial technical pen filled with a graphite-based conductive ink prepared in house. The fabrication parameters of the ePADs were studied by cyclic voltammetry using the ferro/ferri couple as a probe and by scanning electron microscopy. The ePADs, featuring a bismuth nanoparticle-modified working electrode, were applied to the determination of Pb(II) and Cd(II) by DPASV. The chemical and instrumental conditions were studied. The limits of detection were 3.1 μg L^-1 for Cd(II) and 4.5 μg L^-1 for Pb(II) whereas the between-device reproducibility (expressed as the % relative standard deviation of the response at 6 different ePADs) was < 14%. Each ePAD requires 120 s to fabricate and costs less than 0.15 € in terms of consumables. The ePADs are suitable for the on-site determination of Pb(II) and Cd(II) in environmental and food samples.

Nanomaterial-assisted microfluidics for multiplex assays

Simultaneous detection of different biomarkers from a single specimen in a single test, allowing more rapid, efficient, and low-cost analysis, is of great significance for accurate diagnosis of disease and efficient monitoring of therapy. Recently, developments in microfabrication and nanotechnology have advanced the integration of nanomaterials in microfluidic devices toward multiplex assays of biomarkers, combining both the advantages of microfluidics and the unique properties of nanomaterials. In this review, we focus on the state of the art in multiplexed detection of biomarkers based on nanomaterial-assisted microfluidics. Following an overview of the typical microfluidic analytical techniques and the most commonly used nanomaterials for biochemistry analysis, we highlight in detail the nanomaterial-assisted microfluidic strategies for different biomarkers. These highly integrated platforms with minimum sample consumption, high sensitivity and specificity, low detection limit, enhanced signals, and reduced detection time have been extensively applied in various domains and show great potential in future point-of-care testing and clinical diagnostics.

On-Chip Optical Anodic Stripping with Closed Bipolar Cells and Cathodic Electrochemiluminescence Reporting

The aim of this work was to develop a simple, accessible, and point-of-use sensor to measure heavy metal ions in water in low-resource areas that cannot accommodate expensive or technical solutions. This report describes a new bipolar electrochemical sensor platform that reimagines conventional anodic stripping voltammetry in a wireless bipolar format with an optical electrochemiluminescent readout that can be quantified with any simple optical sensor like that found on most modern cell phone cameras. We call this technique as optical anodic stripping. Using a new nonlithographic fabrication process, devices could be produced rapidly and simply at <$1/sensor. The sensing scheme was developed, characterized, and optimized using electrochemical and optical methods. Quantitation of Pb²⁺ in both lab and natural water samples was rapid (2-3 min), accurate, precise, and highly linear in the 25-1000 ppb range and was shown to be sufficiently selective in the presence of other common heavy metal ions such as Cu²⁺, Cd²⁺, and Zn²⁺.

A High-Response Electrochemical As(III) Sensor Using Fe3O4–rGO Nanocomposite Materials

Nowadays, heavy metal ion pollution in water is becoming more and more common, especially arsenic, which seriously threatens human health. In this work, we used Fe3O4–rGO nanocomposites to modify a glassy carbon electrode and selected square wave voltametric electrochemical detection methods to detect trace amounts of arsenic in water. Field emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) showed that Fe3O4 nanoparticles were uniformly distributed on the rGO sheet, with a particle size of about 20 nm. Raman spectroscopy and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) showed that rGO provides higher sensitivity and conductive substrates. Under optimized experimental conditions, Fe3O4–rGO-modified glassy carbon electrodes showed a higher sensitivity (2.15 µA/ppb) and lower limit of detection (1.19 ppb) for arsenic. They also showed good selectivity, stability, and repeatability.