Release Mechanism, Secondary Pollutants and Denitrification Performance Comparison of Six Kinds of Agricultural Wastes as Solid Carbon Sources for Nitrate Removal

Insight into the microbial community of denitrification process using different solid carbon sources: Not only bacteria

There is a lack of understanding about the bacterial, fungal and archaeal communities' composition of solid-phase denitrification (SPD) systems. We investigated four SPD systems with different carbon sources by analyzing microbial gene sequences based on operational taxonomic unit (OTU) and amplicon sequence variant (ASV). The results showed that the corncob-polyvinyl alcohol sodium alginate-polycaprolactone (CPSP, 0.86±0.04 mg NO3--N/(g·day)) and corncob (0.85±0.06 mg NO3--N/(g·day)) had better denitrification efficiency than polycaprolactone (PCL, 0.29±0.11 mg NO3--N/(g·day)) and polyvinyl alcohol-sodium alginate (PVA-SA, 0.24±0.07 mg NO3--N/(g·day)). The bacterial, fungal and archaeal microbial composition was significantly different among carbon source types such as Proteobacteria in PCL (OTU: 83.72%, ASV: 82.49%) and Rozellomycota in PVA-SA (OTU: 71.99%, ASV: 81.30%). ASV methods can read more microbial units than that of OTU and exhibit higher alpha diversity and classify some species that had not been identified by OTU such as Nanoarchaeota phylum, unclassified_ f_ Xanthobacteraceae genus, etc., indicating ASV may be more conducive to understand SPD microbial communities. The co-occurring network showed some correlation between the bacteria fungi and archaea species, indicating different species may collaborate in SPD systems. Similar KEGG function prediction results were obtained in two bioinformatic methods generally and some fungi and archaea functions should not be ignored in SPD systems. These results may be beneficial for understanding microbial communities in SPD systems.

Effect of hydraulic retention time on denitrification performance and microbial communities of solid-phase denitrifying reactors using polycaprolactone/corncob composite

This study investigated the effect of hydraulic retention time (HRT) on the denitrification performance and microbial composition of reactors, packed with composite polycaprolactone and corncob carbon sources, during the treatment mariculture wastewater. The optimal HRT was 3 h, and average nitrogen removal efficiency was 99.00 %, 99.07 %, and 98.98 % in the HRT =3, 5, and 7 h groups, respectively. However, the 3 h group (DOC 2.91 mg/L) was the only group with a lower DOC concentration than that of the influent group (3.31 mg/L). Moreover, species richness was lower at HRT =3 h, with a greater proportion of denitrification-dominant phyla, such as Proteobacteria. The abundance of the NarG, NirK, and NirS functional genes suggested that the HRT =3 h group had a significant advantage in the nitrate and nitrite reduction phases. Under a short HRT, the composite carbon source achieved a good denitrification effect.

Novel slow-release carbon source improves anodic denitrification and electricity generation efficiency in microbial fuel cells

MFC anodic denitrification is more suitable for the coexistence of organic matter and nitrate in actual sewage, but the traditional carbon source has some problems such as high cost and difficulty of dosage control in MFC. Herein, corncob and polycaprolactone (PCL) were mechanically pulverized and mixed in the system of polyvinyl alcohol and sodium alginate, and cross-linked to prepare slow-release carbon source fillers (CPSP), which were added to the MFC anolyte to realize the coupling of solid-phase denitrification and anodic denitrification. Results showed the start-up period of MFC experimental group (MFC-C) with CPSP was slightly longer than the control group (MFC-0), but MFC-C's maximum output voltage (648.4 mV) and power density (2738 mW/m3) could be increased by 5% and 15% higher than that of MFC-0 (P < 0.05). The degradation process of MFC substrate in unit cycle was mainly divided into nitrogen removal stage (0-8 h) and electricity generation stage (8-48 h). The NO3--N and COD degradation and power generation kinetic processes of MFC conformed to the Han-Levenspiel model. Kinetics experiments showed CPSP can improve the affinity and tolerance of MFC to NO3--N, also it can alleviate the pressure of electron competition in anolyte and improve coulombic efficiency. In addition, microbial communities were significantly changed under the effect of CPSP (P < 0.001). Meanwhile, CPSP can promote the synthesis of denitrification functional genes. This study provides a new strategy to improve the performance of MFC by the addition of novel denitrification carbon source.

Effects of antibiotics on corncob supported solid-phase denitrification: Denitrification and antibiotics removal performance, mechanism, and antibiotic resistance genes

Solid-phase denitrification (SPD) has been used in wastewater treatment plant effluent to enhance nitrate removal, and antibiotics co-existing in the effluent is a common environmental problem. In this study, it was systematically investigated the effect of single trace sulfamethoxazole (SMX)/trimethoprim (TMP) and their mixture on microbial denitrification performance, the antibiotics removal, and antibiotics resistance genes (ARGs) in corncob supported SPD system. The average denitrification rate was improved by 46.90% or 61.09% with single 50 µg/L SMX or TMP, while there was no significant inhibition with mixed SMX and TMP. The abundance of dominant denitrifiers (Comamonadaceae family and Azospia) and fermentation bacteria (Ancalomicrobium) were consistent with the denitrification performance of different antibiotics groups. Single SMX and TMP achieved relatively higher denitrification gene and enzyme abundance. Mixed SMX and TMP improved the denitrification gene copies, but they reduced the key denitrification enzymes except for EC 1.7.7.2. Additionally, the removal efficiency of TMP (56.70% ± 3.18%) was higher than that of SMX (25.44% ± 2.62%) in single antibiotic group, and the existence of other antibiotics (i.e. SMX or TMP) had no significant impact on the TMP or SMX removal performance. Biodegradation was the main removal mechanism of SMX and TMP, while sludge and corncob adsorption contributed a little to their removal. SMX had the risk of sulfanilamide resistance genes (SRGs) dissemination. Furthermore, network analysis indicated that Niveibacterium and Bradyrhizobium were the potential hosts of SRGs, which promoted the horizontal transmission of ARGs.

Initial carbon release characteristics, mechanisms and denitrification performance of a novel slow release carbon source

External carbon source addition is one of the effective methods for the treatment of wastewater with low carbon to nitrogen ratio (C/N). Compared with fast-release liquid carbon sources, slow-release solid carbon sources are more suitable for the denitrification process. A novel slow-release solid carbon source (corncob-polyvinyl alcohol sodium alginate- poly-caprolactone, i.e. CPSP) was prepared using corn cob (CC) and poly-caprolactone with polyvinyl alcohol sodium alginate as hybrid scaffold. The physical properties and carbon release characteristics of CPSP and three other carbon sources were compared. CPSP had stable framework and good carbon release performance, which followed the second order release equation. The formic acid, acetic acid, propionic acid and butyric acid released from CPSP accounted for 8.27% ± 1.66 %, 56.48% ± 3.71 %, 18.46% ± 2.69% and 16.79% ± 3.02% of the total released acids respectively. The start-up period of CPSP was shorter than that of the other carbon sources in denitrification experiment, and no COD pollution was observed in the start-up phase (25-72 h) and stable phase (73-240 hr). The composition and structure of the dissolved organic compounds released by CPSP and other carbon sources were analyzed by UV-Vis absorption spectroscopy and three-dimensional fluorescence spectroscopy, which indicated that CPSP was more suitable for denitrification than the other studied carbon sources.

Pseudomonas oligotrophica sp. nov., a Novel Denitrifying Bacterium Possessing Nitrogen Removal Capability Under Low Carbon–Nitrogen Ratio Condition

Pseudomonas is a large and diverse genus within the Gammaproteobacteria known for its important ecological role in the environment. These bacteria exhibit versatile features of which the ability of heterotrophic nitrification and aerobic denitrification can be applied for nitrogen removal from the wastewater. A novel denitrifying bacterium, designated JM10B5a^T, was isolated from the pond water for juvenile Litopenaeus vannamei. The phylogenetic, genomic, physiological, and biochemical analyses illustrated that strain JM10B5a^T represented a novel species of the genus Pseudomonas, for which the name Pseudomonas oligotrophica sp. nov. was proposed. The effects of carbon sources and C/N ratios on denitrification performance of strain JM10B5a^T were investigated. In addition, the results revealed that sodium acetate was selected as the optimum carbon source for denitrification of this strain. Besides, strain JM10B5a^T could exhibit complete nitrate removal at the low C/N ratio of 3. Genomic analyses revealed that JM10B5a^T possessed the functional genes including napA, narG, nirS, norB, and nosZ, which might participate in the complete denitrification process. Comparative genomic analyses indicated that many genes related to aggregation, utilization of alkylphosphonate and tricarballylate, biosynthesis of cofactors, and vitamins were contained in the genome of strain JM10B5a^T. These genomic features were indicative of its adaption to various niches. Moreover, strain JM10B5a^T harbored the complete operons required for the biosynthesis of vibrioferrin, a siderophore, which might be conducive to the high denitrification efficiency of denitrifying bacterium at low C/N ratio. Our findings demonstrated that the strain JM10B5a^T could be a promising candidate for treating wastewater with a low C/N ratio.

Effectiveness of agricultural waste in the enhancement of biological denitrification of aquaculture wastewater

Nitrogen pollution in aquaculture wastewater can pose a significant health and environmental risk if not removed before wastewater is discharged. Biological denitrification uses external carbon sources to remove nitrogen from wastewater; however, these carbon sources are often expensive and require significant energy. In this study, we investigated how six types of agricultural waste can be used as solid carbon sources in biological denitrification. Banana stalk (BS), loofah sponge (LS), sorghum stalk (SS), sweet potato stalk (SPS), watermelon skins (WS) and wheat husk (WH) were studied to determine their capacity to release carbon and improve denitrification efficiency. The results of batch experiments showed that all six agricultural wastes had excellent carbon release capacities, with cumulative chemical oxygen demands of 37.74-535.68 mg/g. During the 168-h reaction, the carbon release process followed the second-order kinetic equation and Ritger-Peppas equation, while carbon release occurred via diffusion. The kinetic equation fitting, scanning electron microscopy, and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy results showed that LS had the lowest c_m and the maximum t_1/2 values and only suffered a moderate degree of hydrolysis. It also had the lowest pollutant release rate and cumulative chemical oxygen demand, as well as the most efficient removal of total phosphorous (TP) and total nitrogen (TN). Therefore, we concluded that LS has the lowest potential risk of excess carbon release and capacity for long-lasting and stable carbon release. The WS leachate had the highest TN contents, while the SPS leachate had the highest TP content. In the 181-h denitrification reaction, all six agricultural wastes completely removed nitrate and nitrite; however, SS had the highest denitrification rate, followed by LS, WH, BS, SPS, and WS (2.16, 1.35, 1.35, 1.34, 1.34, and 1.01 mg/(L·h), respectively). The denitrification process followed a zero-order and first-order kinetic equation. These results provide theoretical guidance for effectively selecting agricultural waste as a solid carbon source and improving the denitrification efficiency of aquaculture wastewater treatment.

Nutrient removal effect and characteristics of integrated floating beds at low temperature

To investigate the effect of combined floating beds on nutrient removal under low temperature, an integrated floating bed with corn flakes (IFB-CF) and an integrated floating bed with light ceramsite (IFB-LC) were constructed in parallel. IFB-LC was used as control group under water temperatures of 9.3-14 °C and a water exchange time of 168 h. Nitrogen and phosphorus removal efficiency, the nutrient level of a hydrophyte (Oenanthe javanica), and the microbial population characteristics of the combined floating bed were investigated. For IFB-CF removal efficiencies, the degradation quantities of total nitrogen (TN), NO₃^--N, and NH₄⁺-N for IFB-CF were 13.58 ± 0.67 mg/L, 4.40 ± 0.61 mg/L, and 9.21 ± 0.38 mg/L, respectively; in contrast, degradation quantities for IFB-LC were lower (6.41 ± 1.47 mg/L, 2.15 ± 0.40 mg/L, and 5.95 ± 0.46 mg/L, respectively). The reductions in COD (Chemical Oxygen Demand, using K₂Cr₂O₇ as oxidizer) for IFB-LC and IFB-CF were 86.89% and 66.06%, respectively. Using the MiSeq high throughput sequencing method, we analysed microbial community structure and diversity on the base material surface of the IFB-CF and IFB-LC. The results showed 15 phyla, 165 genera, and 78 families on the surface of the IFB-CF. The phylum, genus, and family with the highest abundances were Proteobacteria (48.29%), Trichococcus (10.39%), and Comamonadaceae (12.45%), respectively. We identified 15 phyla, 144 genera, and 93 families on the surface of the IFB-LC. The phylum, genus, and family with the highest abundances were Proteobacteria (46.10%), Dyadobacter (22.67%), and Cytophagaceae (28.75%), respectively. The Chao, ACE, and Shannon & Simpson indices for the IFB-LC were 4081, 6295, and 5.10, and 0.05, respectively; for the IFB-CF they were 4938, 7461, 5.77, and 0.02, respectively. Catalase (CAT) and Peroxidase (POD) concentrations in Oenanthe javanica for IFB-LC were 35.48 u/gFW/min and 1.03 u/gFW/min, respectively; for IFB-CF they were 32.33 u/gFW/min and 1.25 u/gFW/min, respectively. The nutritional energies of IFB-CF and IFB-LC were 107 kJ/100g and 84 kJ/100g. Using the Mondal model of TN removal, k (half-saturation constant) values for IFB-LC and IFB-CF were 35.67 mg/L and 39.23 mg/L, respectively, with a correlation coefficient (R²) of 0.97.

Selection and synthesization of multi-carbon source composites to enhance simultaneous nitrification-denitrification in treating low C/N wastewater

Low carbon/nitrogen ratio (C/N) wastewater is widespread and difficult to treat. To find a resolution to this issue, this study systematically evaluated the constituents of composite solid carbon (i.e., skeletons, carbon sources and crosslinking agents), and proposed a new multi-carbon source composite S1 (MCSC.S1). The effects on nitrogen removal were further determined through a sequencing batch moving bed biofilm reactor (SBMBBR). The results showed that MCSC.S1, which was composed of polyvinyl alcohol-sodium alginate (PVA-SA), corncob + poly (R-β-hydroxybutyrate) (CC + PHB), and H₃BO₃-4% CaCl₂+Na₂SO₄ had high stability and absorption. With MCSC.S1, total nitrification removal was enhanced by more than 48.56% through releasing carbon and absorbing the attached denitrifying bacteria. In addition, it was found that MCSC.S1 can simulate the simultaneous nitrification and denitrification (SND) process and contribute to 29.85% of the total nitrogen removal. 16S gene-based analysis attributed this supplementary nitrogen removal to the enrichment of nitrification (i.e., Proteobacteria, Actinobacteria and Chloroflexi), denitrification of associated bacteria (i.e., Nitrospirota) in MCSC.S1 added reactor, and the increase in nitrogen recycling associated genes. These findings collectively demonstrate that the new MCSC.S1 could effectively enhance nitrogen removal efficiency in low C/N ratio wastewater.

Enhanced Denitrification of Integrated Sewage Treatment System by Supplementing Denitrifying Carbon Source

Integrated sewage treatment system (ISTY) is a new technology for rural domestic sewage treatment. In the ISTY, the carbon source in the denitrification stage is often insufficient, affecting the denitrification efficiency. In order to improve the denitrification efficiency, several commonly available agricultural wastes, peanut shell (PS), sawdust (SD), peat (PT), and their mixtures (MT), were selected as supplementary carbon sources in the denitrification stage of ISTY to study the denitrification efficiency. Results show that PS exhibited a high carbon release capacity. PS released an enormous amount of carbon in 144 h, and the cumulative total organic carbon was 41.99 ± 0.7 mg/(g·L). The optimum carbon source dosage was 3 g/L, the nitrate removal rates of PS exceeded 95% after 48 h, and the denitrification rates were 9.35 mg/(g·L), which were 63.92% higher than that of the control group. After running the ISTY for 120 h, and with PS as supplementary carbon sources, the removal rate of TN increased from 29.76% to 83.86%. At the genus level, the dominant denitrifying bacteria in ISTY, after adding PS, were Pseudomonas and Cupriavidus, accounting for 78.68%, an increase of 72.90% compared with the control group. This evidence suggested that PS can obviously enhance the denitrification efficiency of the ISTY as a supplementary carbon source.