Dissecting the Role of PCDH19 in Clustering Epilepsy by Exploiting Patient-Specific Models of Neurogenesis

Phenotypic and genotypic characteristics of children with PCDH19 clustering epilepsy in China

PURPOSE

PCDH19 gene variants, termed PCDH19 clustering epilepsy, represent a distinct etiology of epilepsy. This study aimed to elucidate the clinical manifestations and explore the genotypes and phenotypes of children affected by PCDH19 clustering epilepsy.

METHODS

This retrospective study included medical history, magnetic resonance imaging, video-electroencephalography, and genetic analysis of patients diagnosed with PCDH19 Clustering Epilepsy at the Neurology Department of Beijing Children's Hospital from 2015 to 2023. Chi-square tests and logistic regression analyses were conducted to study the factors associated with developmental delay in patients.

RESULTS

The age at seizure onset ranged from 5 to 61 months among all 30 patients (median 14 months; IQR 9.25-22.5 months). Among the 30 patients, 29 were female and 1 was male. Clusters of seizures and fever-triggered seizures were observed, with the most prevalent seizure types being focal to bilateral tonic-clonic seizures (FBTCS). Seizures were successfully controlled in 15 patients. Unfortunately, one patient experienced a sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP). Additionally, 14 patients had hereditary mutations, 14 had de novo mutations, 1 had both hereditary and de novo mutations, and 1 male patient had a mosaic component mutation of 0.64 due to a somatic mutation. Developmental delays were identified in 17 patients (56.7 %), and 6 patients (20 %) were diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Among the 17 patients, 9 experienced developmental delays before the onset of epilepsy, while 8 were initially normal but later developed developmental delays during disease progression. Statistical analysis revealed that the presence of drug-resistant epilepsy was an independent risk factor for the occurrence of developmental delays (P = 0.020, OR = 9.758, 95 % CI (1.440-66.111)).

CONCLUSION

In this study, 13 new potential rare pathogenic variations in PCDH19 clustering epilepsy were identified. The clinical features observed in patients are consistent with known phenotypic features, and we found that patients with drug-resistant epilepsy are more likely to have developmental delays. The severity of the phenotype in patients with PCDH19 variants ranged from drug-responsive seizures to refractory epilepsy.

Morphogenetic Designs, and Disease Models in Central Nervous System Organoids

Since the emergence of the first cerebral organoid (CO) in 2013, advancements have transformed central nervous system (CNS) research. Initial efforts focused on studying the morphogenesis of COs and creating reproducible models. Numerous methodologies have been proposed, enabling the design of the brain organoid to represent specific regions and spinal cord structures. CNS organoids now facilitate the study of a wide range of CNS diseases, from infections to tumors, which were previously difficult to investigate. We summarize the major advancements in CNS organoids, concerning morphogenetic designs and disease models. We examine the development of fabrication procedures and how these advancements have enabled the generation of region-specific brain organoids and spinal cord models. We highlight the application of these organoids in studying various CNS diseases, demonstrating the versatility and potential of organoid models in advancing our understanding of complex conditions. We discuss the current challenges in the field, including issues related to reproducibility, scalability, and the accurate recapitulation of the in vivo environment. We provide an outlook on prospective studies and future directions. This review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the state-of-the-art CNS organoid research, highlighting key developments, current challenges, and prospects in the field.

PCDH19-clustering epilepsy, pathophysiology and clinical significance

PCDH19 clustering epilepsy (PCDH19-CE) is an X-linked epilepsy disorder associated with intellectual disability (ID) and behavioral disturbances, which is caused by PCDH19 gene variants. PCDH19 pathogenic variant leads to epilepsy in heterozygous females, not in hemizygous males and the inheritance pattern is unusual. The hypothesis of cellular interference was described as a key pathogenic mechanism. According to that, males do not develop the disease because of the uniform expression of PCDH19 (variant or wild type) unless they have a somatic variation. We conducted a literature review on PCDH19-CE pathophysiology and concluded that other significant mechanisms could contribute to pathogenesis including: asymmetric cell division and heterochrony, female-related allopregnanolone deficiency, altered steroid gene expression, decreased Gamma-aminobutyric acid receptor A (GABAA) function, and blood-brain barrier (BBB) dysfunction. Being aware of these mechanisms helps us when we should decide which therapeutic option is more suitable for which patient.

Abnormal cell sorting and altered early neurogenesis in a human cortical organoid model of Protocadherin-19 clustering epilepsy

Introduction

Protocadherin-19 (PCDH19)-Clustering Epilepsy (PCE) is a developmental and epileptic encephalopathy caused by loss-of-function variants of the PCDH19 gene on the X-chromosome. PCE affects females and mosaic males while male carriers are largely spared. Mosaic expression of the cell adhesion molecule PCDH19 due to random X-chromosome inactivation is thought to impair cell-cell interactions between mutant and wild type PCDH19-expressing cells to produce the disease. Progress has been made in understanding PCE using rodent models or patient induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs). However, rodents do not faithfully model key aspects of human brain development, and patient iPSC models are limited by issues with random X-chromosome inactivation.

Methods

To overcome these challenges and model mosaic PCDH19 expression in vitro, we generated isogenic female human embryonic stem cells with either HA-FLAG-tagged PCDH19 (WT) or homozygous PCDH19 knockout (KO) using genome editing. We then mixed GFP-labeled WT and RFP-labeled KO cells and generated human cortical organoids (hCOs).

Results

We found that PCDH19 is highly expressed in early (days 20-35) WT neural rosettes where it co-localizes with N-Cadherin in ventricular zone (VZ)-like regions. Mosaic PCE hCOs displayed abnormal cell sorting in the VZ with KO and WT cells completely segregated. This segregation remained robust when WT:KO cells were mixed at 2:1 or 1:2 ratios. PCE hCOs also exhibited altered expression of PCDH19 (in WT cells) and N-Cadherin, and abnormal deep layer neurogenesis. None of these abnormalities were observed in hCOs generated by mixing only WT or only KO (modeling male carrier) cells.

Discussion

Our results using the mosaic PCE hCO model suggest that PCDH19 plays a critical role in human VZ radial glial organization and early cortical development. This model should offer a key platform for exploring mechanisms underlying PCE-related cortical hyperexcitability and testing of potential precision therapies.

Rare genetic brain disorders with overlapping neurological and psychiatric phenotypes

Understanding rare genetic brain disorders with overlapping neurological and psychiatric phenotypes is of increasing importance given the potential for developing disease models that could help to understand more common, polygenic disorders. However, the traditional clinical boundaries between neurology and psychiatry result in frequent segregation of these disorders into distinct silos, limiting cross-specialty understanding that could facilitate clinical and biological advances. In this Review, we highlight multiple genetic brain disorders in which neurological and psychiatric phenotypes are observed, but for which in-depth, cross-spectrum clinical phenotyping is rarely undertaken. We describe the combined phenotypes observed in association with genetic variants linked to epilepsy, dystonia, autism spectrum disorder and schizophrenia. We also consider common underlying mechanisms that centre on synaptic plasticity, including changes to synaptic and neuronal structure, calcium handling and the balance of excitatory and inhibitory neuronal activity. Further investigation is needed to better define and replicate these phenotypes in larger cohorts, which would help to gain greater understanding of the pathophysiological mechanisms and identify common therapeutic targets.

Transcriptomic analysis reveals distinct adaptive molecular mechanism in the hippocampal CA3 from rats susceptible or not-susceptible to hyperthermia-induced seizures

Febrile seizures during early childhood are a relevant risk factor for the development of mesial temporal lobe epilepsy. Nevertheless, the molecular mechanism induced by febrile seizures that render the brain susceptible or not-susceptible to epileptogenesis remain poorly understood. Because the temporal investigation of such mechanisms in human patients is impossible, rat models of hyperthermia-induced febrile seizures have been used for that purpose. Here we conducted a temporal analysis of the transcriptomic and microRNA changes in the ventral CA3 of rats that develop (HS group) or not-develop (HNS group) seizures after hyperthermic insult on the eleventh postnatal day. The selected time intervals corresponded to acute, latent, and chronic phases of the disease. We found that the transcriptional differences between the HS and the HNS groups are related to inflammatory pathways, immune response, neurogenesis, and dendritogenesis in the latent and chronic phases. Additionally, the HNS group expressed a greater number of miRNAs (some abundantly expressed) as compared to the HS group. These results indicate that HNS rats were able to modulate their inflammatory response after insult, thus presenting better tissue repair and re-adaptation. Potential therapeutic targets, including genes, miRNAs and signaling pathways involved in epileptogenesis were identified.

CRISPR/Cas9 and piggyBac Transposon-Based Conversion of a Pathogenic Biallelic TBCD Variant in a Patient-Derived iPSC Line Allows Correction of PEBAT-Related Endophenotypes

Induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) have been established as a reliable in vitro disease model system and represent a particularly informative tool when animal models are not available or do not recapitulate the human pathophenotype. The recognized limit in using this technology is linked to some degree of variability in the behavior of the individual patient-derived clones. The development of CRISPR/Cas9-based gene editing solves this drawback by obtaining isogenic iPSCs in which the genetic lesion is corrected, allowing a straightforward comparison with the parental patient-derived iPSC lines. Here, we report the generation of a footprint-free isogenic cell line of patient-derived TBCD-mutated iPSCs edited using the CRISPR/Cas9 and piggyBac technologies. The corrected iPSC line had no genetic footprint after the removal of the selection cassette and maintained its "stemness". The correction of the disease-causing TBCD missense substitution restored proper protein levels of the chaperone and mitotic spindle organization, as well as reduced cellular death, which were used as read-outs of the TBCD KO-related endophenotype. The generated line represents an informative in vitro model to understand the impact of pathogenic TBCD mutations on nervous system development and physiology.

Modelling PCDH19 clustering epilepsy by Neurogenin 2 induction of patient-derived induced pluripotent stem cells

BACKGROUND

Loss of function mutations in PCDH19 gene cause an X-linked, infant-onset clustering epilepsy, associated with intellectual disability and autistic features. The unique pattern of inheritance includes random X-chromosome inactivation, which leads to pathological tissue mosaicism. Females carrying PCDH19 mutations are affected, while males have normal phenotype. No cure is presently available for this disease.

METHODS

Fibroblasts from a female patient carrying frameshift mutation were reprogrammed into human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSC). To create a cell model of PCDH19-clustering epilepsy (PCDH19-CE) where both cell populations co-exist, we created mosaic neurons by mixing wild-type (WT) and mutated (mut) human iPSC clones, and differentiated them into mature neurons with overexpression of the transcriptional factor Neurogenin 2.

RESULTS

We generated functional neurons from patient-derived iPSC using a rapid and efficient method of differentiation through overexpression of Neurogenin 2. Was revealed an accelerated maturation and higher arborisation in the mutated neurons, while the mosaic neurons showed the highest frequency of action potential firing and hyperexcitability features, compared to mutated and WT neurons.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings provide evidence that PCDH19 c.2133delG mutation affects proper metaphases with increased numbers of centrosomes in stem cells and accelerates neuronal maturation in premature cells. PCDH19 mosaic neurons showed an elevated excitability, representing the situation in PCDH19-CE brain. We suggest an Ngn-2 hiPSC-derived PCDH19 neurons as an informative experimental tool for understanding the pathogenesis of PCDH19-CE and a suitable approach for use in targeted drug screening strategies.

PCDH19 in Males: Are Hemizygous Variants Linked to Autism?

Background: Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a complex developmental disability that impairs the social communication and interaction of affected individuals and leads to restricted or repetitive behaviors or interests. ASD is genetically heterogeneous, with inheritable and de novo genetic variants in more than hundreds of genes contributing to the disease. However, these account for only around 20% of cases, while the molecular basis of the majority of cases remains unelucidated as of yet. Material and methods: Two unrelated Lebanese patients, a 7-year-old boy (patient A) and a 4-year-old boy (patient B), presenting with ASD were included in this study. Whole-exome sequencing (WES) was carried out for these patients to identify the molecular cause of their diseases. Results: WES analysis revealed hemizygous variants in PCDH19 (NM_001184880.1) as being the candidate causative variants: p.Arg787Leu was detected in patient A and p.Asp1024Asn in patient B. PCDH19, located on chromosome X, encodes a membrane glycoprotein belonging to the protocadherin family. Heterozygous PCDH19 variants have been linked to epilepsy in females with mental retardation (EFMR), while mosaic PCDH19 mutations in males are responsible for treatment-resistant epilepsy presenting similarly to EFMR, with some reported cases of comorbid intellectual disability and autism. Interestingly, a hemizygous PCDH19 variant affecting the same amino acid that is altered in patient A was previously reported in a male patient with ASD. Conclusion: Here, we report hemizygous PCDH19 variants in two males with autism without epilepsy. Reporting further PCDH19 variants in male patients with ASD is important to assess the possible involvement of this gene in autism.

PCDH19-related epilepsy in mosaic males: The phenotypic implication of genotype and variant allele frequency

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the genotypes and phenotypes of mosaic male patients with PCDH19-related epilepsy (PCDH19-RE) and explore the correlation between genotype, variant allele frequency (VAF), and phenotypic severity.

METHODS

Clinical data and peripheral blood samples of 11 male mosaic patients were collected and analyzed in our study. The VAF of the PCDH19 gene from peripheral blood was quantified using amplicon-based deep sequencing. Additional 20 mosaic male patients with PCDH19-RE were collected from the published literature, with 10 patients whose VAFs of the PCDH19 gene were available for analytic purposes.

RESULTS

In our cohort of 11 patients, 10 variants were identified, and four were novel. The VAF of the PCDH19 gene from peripheral blood ranged from 27 to 90%. The median seizure onset age was 6 months (range: 4-9 months). Clinical manifestations included cluster seizures (100%), fever sensitivity (73%), focal seizures (91%), developmental delay/intellectual disability (DD/ID, 82%), and autistic features (45%). Thirty-one mosaic male patients collected from our cohort and the literature developed seizures mostly (87%) within one year of age. Variant types included missense variants (42%), truncating variants (52%), splice variants (3%), and whole PCDH19 deletion (3%). Among 21 patients with a definite VAF from our cohort and the literature, nine had a low VAF ( ≤ 50%) and 12 had a high VAF (> 50%). Seventy-five percent of variants from the high VAF group were missense, whereas 89% of those from the low VAF group were truncations. The median seizure onset age was 6 months in the low VAF group and 9 months in the high VAF group (p = 0.018). Forty-four percent (4/9) of patients from the low VAF group achieved seizure-free for ≥1 year, whereas none of the 12 patients from the high VAF group did (p = 0.021). DD/ID was present in 83% (10/12) of the high VAF group and 56% (5/9) of the low VAF group (p = 0.331).

CONCLUSION

The predominant variant types were truncating and missense variants. Missense variants tended to have higher VAFs. Patients with a high VAF were more likely to have a more severe epileptic phenotype. Our findings shed light on the phenotypic implications of VAF in mosaic males with PCDH19-RE.

Modeling PCDH19-CE: From 2D Stem Cell Model to 3D Brain Organoids

PCDH19 clustering epilepsy (PCDH19-CE) is a genetic disease characterized by a heterogeneous phenotypic spectrum ranging from focal epilepsy with rare seizures and normal cognitive development to severe drug-resistant epilepsy associated with intellectual disability and autism. Unfortunately, little is known about the pathogenic mechanism underlying this disease and an effective treatment is lacking. Studies with zebrafish and murine models have provided insights on the function of PCDH19 during brain development and how its altered function causes the disease, but these models fail to reproduce the human phenotype. Induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) technology has provided a complementary experimental approach for investigating the pathogenic mechanisms implicated in PCDH19-CE during neurogenesis and studying the pathology in a more physiological three-dimensional (3D) environment through the development of brain organoids. We report on recent progress in the development of human brain organoids with a particular focus on how this 3D model may shed light on the pathomechanisms implicated in PCDH19-CE.

The Broad Clinical Spectrum of Epilepsies Associated With Protocadherin 19 Gene Mutation

Protocadherin 19 (PCDH19) gene is one of the most common genes involved in epilepsy syndromes. According to literature data PCDH19 is among the 6 genes most involved in genetic epilepsies. PCDH19 is located on chromosome Xq22.1 and is involved in neuronal connections and signal transduction. The most frequent clinical expression of PCDH19 mutation is epilepsy and mental retardation limited to female (EFMR) characterized by epileptic and non-epileptic symptoms affecting mainly females. However, the phenotypic spectrum of these mutations is considerably variable from genetic epilepsy with febrile seizure plus to epileptic encephalopathies. The peculiar exclusive involvement of females seems to be caused by a cellular interference in heterozygosity, however, affected mosaic-males have been reported. Seizure types range from focal seizure to generalized tonic-clonic, tonic, atonic, absences, and myoclonic jerks. Treatment of PCDH19-related epilepsy is limited by drug resistance and by the absence of specific treatment indications. However, seizures become less severe with adolescence and some patients may even become seizure-free. Non-epileptic symptoms represent the main disabilities of adult patients with PCDH19 mutation. This review aims to analyze the highly variable phenotypic expression of PCDH19 gene mutation associated with epilepsy.

Epilepsy surgery in PCDH 19 related developmental and epileptic encephalopathy: A case report

•

PCDH19 pathogenic variants may be associated with DEE in females.

•

Epilepsy Surgery may be an option for PCDH19 related drug-resistant epilepsy.

We report a female child with PCDH19 related developmental and epileptic encephalopathy with drug-resistant seizures, cognitive and language impairment, autism spectrum disorder and sleep dysfunction. Her seizures, which started at 10 months of age, were resistant to multiple anti-seizure medications. Developmental stagnation followed by regression occurred after the onset of recurrent seizures. Her ictal EEGS suggested left temporal lobe origin for her recorded seizures. MRI upon expert re-review showed a subtle abnormality in the left temporal lobe.

In view of the severe nature and frequency of her seizures, a left temporal lobectomy was undertaken at the age of 2 years and 3 months. Though her seizure outcome was Engel class 3, her seizure frequency and severity were significantly reduced. She has been seizure-free for 10 months at her last outpatient assessment when she was 4 years and 8 months of age (2 years and 5 months after epilepsy surgery). However she recently had an admission for COVID19 infection, with a breakthrough cluster of seizures. Her developmental trajectory changed, though she is making good progress with her cognitive and language skills.

Protocadherin 19 Clustering Epilepsy and Neurosteroids: Opportunities for Intervention

Steroids yield great influence on neurological development through nuclear hormone receptor (NHR)-mediated gene regulation. We recently reported that cell adhesion molecule protocadherin 19 (encoded by the PCDH19 gene) is involved in the coregulation of steroid receptor activity on gene expression. PCDH19 variants cause early-onset developmental epileptic encephalopathy clustering epilepsy (CE), with altered steroidogenesis and NHR-related gene expression being identified in these individuals. The implication of hormonal pathways in CE pathogenesis has led to the investigation of various steroid-based antiepileptic drugs in the treatment of this disorder, with mixed results so far. Therefore, there are many unmet challenges in assessing the antiseizure targets and efficiency of steroid-based therapeutics for CE. We review and assess the evidence for and against the implication of neurosteroids in the pathogenesis of CE and in view of their possible clinical benefit.