Breast Silicone Gel Implants versus Autologous Fat Grafting: Biomaterials and Bioactive Materials in Comparison

Three-Dimensional Printing in Breast Reconstruction: Current and Promising Applications

Three-dimensional (3D) printing is dramatically improving breast reconstruction by offering customized and precise interventions at various stages of the surgical process. In preoperative planning, 3D imaging techniques, such as computer-aided design, allow the creation of detailed breast models for surgical simulation, optimizing surgical outcomes and reducing complications. During surgery, 3D printing makes it possible to customize implants and precisely shape autologous tissue flaps with customized molds and scaffolds. This not only improves the aesthetic appearance, but also conforms to the patient's natural anatomy. In addition, 3D printed scaffolds facilitate tissue engineering, potentially favoring the development and integration of autologous adipose tissue, thus avoiding implant-related complications. Postoperatively, 3D imaging allows an accurate assessment of breast volume and symmetry, which is crucial in assessing the success of reconstruction. The technology is also a key educational tool, enhancing surgeon training through realistic anatomical models and surgical simulations. As the field evolves, the integration of 3D printing with emerging technologies such as biodegradable materials and advanced imaging promises to further refine breast reconstruction techniques and outcomes. This study aims to explore the various applications of 3D printing in breast reconstruction, addressing current challenges and future opportunities.

Tissue engineering strategies for breast reconstruction: a literature review of current advances and future directions

Background and Objective

Mastectomy is a primary treatment for breast cancer patients, and both autologous and implant-based reconstructive techniques have shown excellent results. In recent years, advancements in bioengineering have led to a proliferation of innovative approaches to breast reconstruction. This article comprehensively explores the promising perspectives offered by bioengineering and tissue engineering in the field of breast reconstruction.

Methods

A literature review was conducted between April and June 2023 on PubMed and Google Scholar Databases. All English and French articles related to bioengineering applied to the field of breast reconstruction were included. We used the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medicine Association (EBVM) Toolkit 14 checklist for narrative reviews as a quality assurance measure and the Scale for the Assessment of Narrative Review Articles (SANRA) tool to self-assess our methodology.

Key Content and Findings

Over 130 references related to breast bioengineering were included. The analysis revealed four key applications: enhancing the quality of the skin envelope, improving the viability of fat grafting, creating breast shape and volume via bio-printing, and optimizing nipple reconstruction through engineering techniques. The primary identified approaches revolved around establishing structural support and enhancing cellular viability. Structural techniques predominantly involved the implementation of 3D printed, decellularized, or biocompatible material scaffolds. Meanwhile, promoting cellular content trophicity primarily focused on harnessing the regenerative potential of adipose-derived stem cells (ADSCs) and increasing the tissue's survivability and cell trophicity.

Conclusions

Tissue and bioengineering hold immense promise in the field of breast reconstruction, offering a diverse array of approaches. By combining existing techniques with novel advancements, they have the potential to significantly enhance the therapeutic options available to plastic and reconstructive surgeons.

The heterogeneity of mesenchymal stem cells: an important issue to be addressed in cell therapy

With the continuous improvement of human technology, the medical field has gradually moved from molecular therapy to cellular therapy. As a safe and effective therapeutic tool, cell therapy has successfully created a research boom in the modern medical field. Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) are derived from early mesoderm and have high self-renewal and multidirectional differentiation ability, and have become one of the important cores of cell therapy research by virtue of their immunomodulatory and tissue repair capabilities. In recent years, the application of MSCs in various diseases has received widespread attention, but there are still various problems in the treatment of MSCs, among which the heterogeneity of MSCs may be one of the causes of the problem. In this paper, we review the correlation of MSCs heterogeneity to provide a basis for further reduction of MSCs heterogeneity and standardization of MSCs and hope to provide a reference for cell therapy.

Comparative Analysis of a New Automatic System and Four Existing Techniques for Autologous Fat Grafting

Background

Autologous fat grafting is increasingly used worldwide and is a very attractive technique in many ways. However, treatment duration and postinjection tissue resorption remain problematic elements, which are largely related to the preparation method used. Moreover, few scientific studies objectively compare different fat preparation methods. This study analyzes the efficiency and quality of lipoaspirates prepared with a new filtration/centrifugation system (Adipure) in comparison with several existing techniques.

Methods

Patient lipoaspirates were processed by five different techniques: decantation, centrifugation, Macrofill, Puregraft, and Adipure. Adipose tissue was evaluated in vitro for tissue resorption and oil formation, as well as in vivo after subcutaneous injections in immunodeficient mice. Adipose grafts were collected after 1 month, weighed, and analyzed by histology with a detailed scoring method.

Results

Decanting gives inferior results to all other techniques, in terms of amount of tissue and oil in vitro, or graft weight and histological analysis in vivo. Methods using classical Coleman centrifugation (1200g), or a modified one (400g) associated with washes (Macrofill) produce very similar results, both in vitro and in vivo. Techniques using filtration systems (Puregraft and Adipure) produce less oil overall and have a higher grafting efficiency. The best results regarding grafting efficiency and oil quantity are found with the Adipure device.

Conclusions

A combination of filtration and very low-speed centrifugation potentiates the advantages of these techniques, in terms of graft efficiency. The adipose tissue purification being done in a few minutes, in an automatic way, undoubtedly provides a strong advantage for the use of this new system.

Lipofilling Enriched with Adipose-Derived Mesenchymal Stem Cells Improves Soft Tissue Deformities and Reduces Scar Pigmentation: Clinical and Instrumental Evaluation in Plastic Surgery

BACKGROUND

Scars and soft tissue deformities (S-STDs), often resulting from hemifacial atrophy, trauma, and outcomes of burns, were usually associated with hyperpigmentation of overlying skin.

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to evaluate the long-term effects of fat grafting commonly called "Lipofilling" enhanced with adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cells (Lipofilling-AD-MSCs) for treating S-STDs with pigmentary changes.

METHODS

A cohort study has been performed. 50 patients affected by S-STDs with hyperpigmentation treated with Lipofilling-AD-MSCs and 50 patients treated with Lipofilling not enhanced (Lipofilling-NE) were prospectively assessed. The pre-op evaluation included a clinical evaluation, a photographic assessment, magnetic resonance imaging, and ultrasound. Post-op follow-up was performed at 1, 3, 7, 12, 24, 48, weeks, and then annually.

RESULTS

Improvement in volume contours and pigmentation was clinically assessed. All people who underwent the treatments (Lipofilling-AD-MSCs and Lipofilling-NE) were satisfied with the improving pigmentation, texture, and volume contours with some differences. However, the results reported displaying a better trend in patients treated with Lipofilling-AD-MSCs to be more satisfied than patients treated with Lipofilling-NE (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, Lipofilling-AD-MSCs was the preferred option for improving the contour deformities related to increased pigmentation of scars.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

Evidence obtained from cohort studies.

Mechanical and Enzymatic Digestion of Autologous Fat Grafting (A-FG): Fat Volume Maintenance and AD-SVFs Amount in Comparison

BACKGROUND

Currently, several techniques for autologous fat graft (A-FG) preparation aimed at obtaining purified tissue exist. Both mechanical digestions via centrifugation, filtration, and enzymatic digestion were considered the most effective with different impacts in terms of adult adipose-derived stromal vascular fraction cells (AD-SVFs) amount that volume maintenance.

OBJECTIVES

This article aimed to report the in vivo and in vitro results, represented by fat volume maintenance and AD-SVFs amount, obtained by four different procedures of AD-SVFs isolation and A-FG purification based on centrifugation, filtration, centrifugation with filtration, and enzymatic digestion.

METHODS

A prospective, case-control study was conducted. In total, 80 patients affected by face and breast soft tissue defects were treated with A-FG and divided into four groups: n=20 were treated with A-FG enhanced with AD-SVFs obtained by enzymatic digestion (study group 1 [SG-1]); n=20 were treated with A-FG enhanced with AD-SVFs obtained by centrifugation with filtration (SG-2); n=20 were treated with A-FG enhanced with AD-SVFs obtained by only filtration (SG-3); n=20 were treated with A-FG obtained by only centrifugation according to the Coleman technique (control group [CG]). Twelve months after the last A-FG session, the volume maintenance percentage was analyzed by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Isolated AD-SVF populations were counted using a hemocytometer, and cell yield was reported as cell number/mL of fat.

RESULTS

Starting with the same amount of fat analyzed (20 mL), 50,000 ± 6956 AD-SVFs/mL were obtained in SG-1; 30,250 ± 5100 AD-SVFs/mL in SG-2; 33.333 ± 5650 AD-SVFs/mL in SG-3, while 500 AD-SVFs/mL were obtained in CG. In patients treated with A-FG enhanced with AD-SVFs obtained by automatic enzymatic digestion, a 63% ± 6.2% maintenance of fat volume restoring after 1 year was observed compared with 52% ± 4.6% using centrifugation with filtration, 39% ± 4.4% using only centrifugation (Coleman), and 60% ± 5.0% using only filtration.

CONCLUSIONS

In vitro AD-SVFs cell analysis indicated that filtration was the most efficient system-between mechanical digestion procedures-thanks to the highest amount of cells obtained with fewer cell structure damage, producing in vivo, the most volume maintenance after 1 year. Enzymatic digestion produced the best number of AD-SVFs and the best fat volume maintenance.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE III

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors http://www.springer.com/00266 .

Tuberous Breast, Deformities, and Asymmetries: A Retrospective Analysis Comparing Fat Grafting Versus Mastopexy and Breast Implants

BACKGROUND

The tuberous breast is considered a breast deformity characterized by varying degrees of herniation of the parenchyma, widened nipple-areolar complex (NAC), absence of the lower quadrants, and may involve several degrees of hypoplasia and asymmetry causing significant psychosocial distress.

OBJECTIVES

The paper aimed to compare the results obtained in patients suffering tuberous breast treated with fat grafting (FG), with those of patients treated with a mastopexy and silicone implants (M-SI) also analyzing the influence of breast and chest deformities (degrees of hypoplasia and tuberous breast, volume and NAC asymmetry, pectus excavatum, and carinatum) in the reconstructive outcomes.

METHODS

A retrospective, case-control study was conducted. Thirty-five patients affected by tuberous breast with several degrees of hypoplasia and asymmetry were treated with FG, comparing results with those of 30 patients treated with M-SI. Postoperative follow-up took place at 1, 3, 7, 12, 24, 48, weeks, and then annually for 2 years.

RESULTS

77% (n = 27) of patients treated with two FG procedures showed excellent results after 1 year compared with the patients treated with only one M-SI procedure, who showed the same results in 73% (n = 22) of cases, but the naturalness and the satisfaction degree in the FG group were higher than that in the M-SI group (p < .0001 vs. M-SI group).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients treated with FG showed natural breasts without scars and excellent cosmetic results after two procedures. Patients treated with M-SI showed more evident and lasting results after only one procedure, presenting though scars and less natural results.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these evidence-based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266.

Methods and Limitations of Augmenting Mesenchymal Stem Cells for Therapeutic Applications

Significance: Given their capacity for self-renewal, multilineage differentiation, and immunomodulatory potential, mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) represent a promising modality of clinical therapy for both regenerative medicine and immune diseases. In this study, we review the key approaches and popular methods utilized to boost potency and modify functions of MSCs for clinical purposes as well as their associated limitations. Recent Advances: Several major domains of cell modification strategies are currently employed by investigators to overcome these deficits and augment the therapeutic potential of MSCs. Priming MSCs with soluble factors or pharmacologic agents as well as manipulating oxygen availability in culture have been demonstrated to be effective biochemical methods to augment MSC potential. Distinct genetic and epigenetic methods have emerged in recent years to modify the genetic expression of target proteins and factors thereby modulating MSCs capacity for differentiation, migration, and proliferation. Physical methods utilizing three-dimensional culture methods and alternative cell delivery systems and scaffolds can be used to recapitulate the native MSC niche and augment their engraftment and viability for in vivo models. Critical Issues: Unmodified MSCs have demonstrated only modest benefits in many preclinical and clinical studies due to issues with cell engraftment, viability, heterogeneity, and immunocompatibility between donor and recipient. Furthermore, unmodified MSCs can have low inherent therapeutic potential for which intensive research over the past few decades has been dedicated to improving cell functionality and potency.

Augmentation-Mastopexy: Analysis of 95 Consecutive Patients and Critical Appraisal of the Procedure

Single-stage mastopexy-augmentation has been demonstrated to be a safe procedure. However, revisions may still be necessary. We evaluate 95 consecutive patients undergoing mastopexy-augmentation and introduce a new surgical technique for the procedure: the modified dual plane technique. In this retrospective study, 95 patients (mean age 34 ± 11 years) underwent mastopexy-augmentation between 2009 and 2019. The procedures were classified as subglandular, dual plane, or modified dual plane technique. The outcome measures included major and minor complications. A total of 19 patients underwent a subglandular procedure, 32 patients a dual plane procedure, and 44 patients a modified dual plane procedure. We observed a high overall complication rate in the subglandular group (n = 12, 63%), dual plane group (n = 15, 47%), and modified dual plane group (n = 10, 23%). Complications leading to implant loss/change occurred in seven patients in the subglandular group (37%), six patients in the dual plane group (19%), and no patient in the modified dual plane group. While we observed a high complication rate in patients undergoing mastopexy-augmentations, the modified dual plane technique was associated with a lower complication rate.

Immunomodulatory properties of mesenchymal stromal/stem cells: The link with metabolism

BACKGROUND

Mesenchymal stromal/stem cells (MSCs) are the most promising stem cells for the treatment of multiple inflammatory and immune diseases due to their easy acquisition and potent immuno-regulatory capacities. These immune functions mainly depend on the MSC secretion of soluble factors. Recent studies have shown that the metabolism of MSCs plays critical roles in immunomodulation, which not only provides energy and building blocks for macromolecule synthesis but is also involved in the signaling pathway regulation.

AIM OF REVIEW

A thorough understanding of metabolic regulation in MSC immunomodulatory properties can provide new sights to the enhancement of MSC-based therapy.

KEY SCIENTIFIC CONCEPTS OF REVIEW

MSC immune regulation can be affected by cellular metabolism (glucose, adenosine triphosphate, lipid and amino acid metabolism), which further mediates MSC therapy efficiency in inflammatory and immune diseases. The enhancement of glycolysis of MSCs, such as signaling molecule activation, inflammatory cytokines priming, or environmental control can promote MSC immune functions and therapeutic potential. Besides glucose metabolism, inflammatory stimuli also alter the lipid molecular profile of MSCs, but the direct link with immunomodulatory properties remains to be further explored. Arginine metabolism, glutamine-glutamate metabolism and tryptophan-kynurenine via indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) metabolism all contribute to the immune regulation of MSCs. In addition to the metabolism dictating the MSC immune functions, MSCs also influence the metabolism of immune cells and thus determine their behaviors. However, more direct evidence of the metabolism in MSC immune abilities as well as the underlying mechanism requires to be uncovered.

The effect of stromal vascular fraction in an experimental frostbite injury model

BACKGROUND

Despite current treatment modalities, frostbite remains an injury with a poor prognosis which may cause functional morbidities. Several experimental and clinical studies have demonstrated that stromal vascular fraction is an autologous mixture, which can improve wound healing and vasculogenesis. The aim of this study was to show the beneficial effects of stromal vascular fraction on experimental frostbite healing.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Stromal vascular fraction (SVF) was harvested from 5 rats after excision of the inguinal fat pads. Another 20 rats were separated into 2 groups of 10 as the SVF group and the control group. A frostbite injury was created on each rat using a cryoprobe frozen with liquid nitrogen (-196 °C). SVF was applied to the SVF group and phosphate-buffered saline to the control group. All injections were performed subcutaneously within the frostbite injury area. Biopsies were performed on days 5 and 14 for histopathological and immunochemical evaluations. The tissue perfusion rates of both groups were assessed on day 14 using indocyanine green angiography (SPY system).

RESULTS

The increase in mean tissue perfusion was 373.3% ( ± 32.1) in the SVF group and 123.8% ( ± 16.3) in the control group (p < 0.001). The macroscopic wound reduction rates of the SVF and control groups were 25.5% ( ± 19.1) and 18.0% ( ± 5.9), respectively on day 5%, and 78.2% ( ± 9.2) and 57.3% ( ± 16.7) on day 14 (p = 0.007; p = 0.003). Acute inflammation and the fibrosis gradient were significantly decreased in the SVF group compared to the control group (p = 0.004, p = 0.054 respectively on day 14). Granulation tissue amount, re-epithelialization score and neovascularization were significantly increased in the SVF group (p = 0.006, p = 0.010 and p = 0.021, respectively on day 14).

CONCLUSIONS

The study results demonstrated that SVF increases frostbite wound healing by increasing tissue perfusion rate, neovascularization and re-epithelialization, and modulating acute inflammation and fibrosis.

Effective or Harmful-Evaluation of Locally Applied Antibiotics on Adipose Tissue during Lipofilling to the Breast-An In Vitro Study

Lipofilling is a frequently used and safe procedure for breast reconstruction. One of the most feared complications is soft tissue infection following lipofilling. Because of this, some surgeons propose the practice of rinsing fat grafts with antibiotics. This study investigates the effect of antibiotic rinses on fat grafts in an in vitro model. Adipocytes and stem cells were isolated from fat tissue harvested during 24 lipofilling procedures and incubated with different doses of clindamycin or cefazolin. Cell viability, metabolism, proliferation, and differentiation capacities were analyzed by gross morphology, fluorescence staining, -(4,5-Dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazoliumbromid (MTT-), and Glyceraldehyde 3 Phosphate Dehydrogenase (G3PD)-assay as well as reactive oxygen species (ROS)-assay. Cefazolin and clindamycin led to significant reduction of cell viability of adipocytes. High doses of both antibiotics led to a rupture of adipocytes with visible free lipid droplets. Cell metabolism was significantly decreased after incubation with both antibiotics. There was a significant increase in ROS production. Exposure to clindamycin and cefazolin led to morphological changes in stem cells in a dose- and time-dependent manner. Furthermore, differentiation potential was significantly reduced. Antibiotic susceptibility testing, however, showed that low concentrations of antibiotics effectively inhibited bacterial growth in contaminated fat grafts. This study confirms that rinsing fat grafts with clindamycin or cefazolin not only overly prevents infection but also has cytotoxic and metabolic effects on adipocytes. Therefore, based on these results, the routine clinical application in high doses cannot be recommended.

Rhinofiller: Fat Grafting (Surgical) Versus Hyaluronic Acid (Non-Surgical)

BACKGROUND

The author presented his experience using "fat grafting" (FG) and "hyaluronic acid" (HA) techniques in nasal remodeling.

OBJECTIVES

The paper aimed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of the use of FG and HA in nasal remodeling for aesthetic improvement.

METHODS

A randomized controlled trial was conducted. 15 patients affected by soft defects of the dorsum, low and boxy nasal tip, and hidden columella, were treated with FG (study group-SG), comparing results with the control group (CG) (n = 17) treated with hyaluronic acid (HA). Post-operative follow-up took place at 1, 2, 4, weeks, 3, 6, 12 months, and then annually.

RESULTS

73.7% of SG patients showed excellent cosmetic results after 1 year compared with only 29.7% of CG patients. At one-month, major part of people who underwent the treatments (FG and HA) referred to satisfaction with the resulting volume contours (p = 0.389). 88.3% of CG patients versus 53.8% of SG described the HA and FG injection, respectively, as a very comfortable and non-invasive procedure. As expected, patient satisfaction with the appearance of nasal contouring was higher in the FG group at 1 year.

CONCLUSIONS

FG and HA were safe and effective in this series of cases performed.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE III

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266.

Nonsubjective Assessment of Shape, Volume and Symmetry during Breast Augmentation with Handheld 3D Device

Three-dimensional Surface Imaging (3DSI) has become a valuable tool for planning and documenting surgical procedures. Although surface scanners have allowed for a better understanding of breast shape, size, and asymmetry during patient consultation, its use has not been included in intraoperative assessment so far. Validation of the reliability of the intraoperative use of a portable handheld 3DSI equipment as a tool to evaluate morphological changes during breast augmentation surgery. The patients who underwent bilateral subpectoral breast augmentation through an inframammary incision were included in this study. Intraoperative 3DSI was performed with the Artec Eva device, allowing for visualization of the surgical area before incision, after use of breast sizers and implant, and after wound closure. Intraoperatively manual measurements of breast distances and volume changes due to known sizer and implant volumes were in comparison with digital measurements calculated from 3DSI of the surgical area. Bilateral breasts of 40 patients were 3D photographed before incision and after suture successfully. A further 108 implant sizer uses were digitally documented. There was no significant difference between manual tape measurement and digital breast distance measurement. Pre- to postoperative 3D volume change showed no significant difference to the known sizer and implant volume.

Breast Cancer Therapy: The Potential Role of Mesenchymal Stem Cells in Translational Biomedical Research

The potential role of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) in the treatment of metastatic cancers, including breast cancer, has been investigated for many years leading to encouraging results. The role of fat grafting and the related adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cells (AD-MSCs) has been detailed and described for breast reconstruction purposes confirming the safety of AD-MSCs. MSCs have great potential for delivering anticancer agents, suicide genes, and oncolytic viruses to tumors. Currently, many studies have focused on the products of MSCs, including extracellular vesicles (EVs), as a cell-free therapy. This work aimed to review and discuss the current knowledge on MSCs and their EVs in breast cancer therapy.

Clinical Efficacy Analysis of Augmentation Mammoplasty with Cell-Assisted Autologous Fat Transplantation

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the clinical efficacy of augmentation mammoplasty with cell-assisted autologous fat transplantation.

METHODS

Thirty-four cases of micromastia patients in our hospital were randomly divided into control group (n = 17) and observation group (n = 17). Breast augmentation with autologous fat transplantation alone and cell-assisted autologous fat transplantation were performed, respectively, compare and observe the therapeutic effect.

RESULTS

Compared with the control group, the effective rate of breast augmentation was higher in the observation group. After six months of treatment, the increase value of chest circumference (CC), Sternal notch-nipple distance (SN-N),distance between nipple and inframammary fold (N-MF) was higher in the observation group, and the uplift value was higher after six months surgery, with statistical significance (p < 0.05). MRI showed higher postoperative fat retention rate, QLQ-30 Quality of life scores showed no significant difference (p > 0.05).

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .

MicroRNA-Enriched Exosomes from Different Sources of Mesenchymal Stem Cells Can Differentially Modulate Functions of Immune Cells and Neurogenesis

Adult Mesenchymal stem cells-derived exosomes carry several biologically active molecules that play prominent roles in controlling disease manifestations. The content of these exosomes, their functions, and effect on the immune cells may differ depending on their tissue sources. Therefore, in this study, we purified the exosomes from three different sources and, using the RNA-Seq approach, highly abundant microRNAs were identified and compared between exosomes and parental cells. The effects of exosomes on different immune cells were studied in vitro by incubating exosomes with PBMC and neutrophils and assessing their functions. The expression levels of several miRNAs varied within the different MSCs and exosomes. Additionally, the expression profile of most of the miRNAs was not similar to that of their respective sources. Exosomes isolated from different sources had different abilities to induce the process of neurogenesis and angiogenesis. Moreover, these exosomes demonstrated their varying effect on PBMC proliferation, neutrophil survival, and NET formation, highlighting their versatility and broad interaction with immune cells. The knowledge gained from this study will improve our understanding of the miRNA landscape of exosomes from hMSCs and provide a resource for further improving our understanding of exosome cargo and their interaction with immune cells.