A Novel Approach to Clustering Accelerometer Data for Application in Passive Predictions of Changes in Depression Severity

Digital biomarkers in depression: A systematic review and call for standardization and harmonization of feature engineering

BACKGROUND

General physicians misclassify depression in more than half of the cases. Researchers have explored the feasibility of leveraging passively collected data points, also called digital biomarkers, to provide more granular understanding of depression phenotypes as well as a more objective assessment of disease.

METHOD

This paper provides a systematic review following the PRISMA guidelines (Page et al., 2021) to understand which digital biomarkers might be relevant for passive screening of depression. Pubmed and PsycInfo were systematically searched for studies published from 2019 to early 2024, resulting in 161 records assessed for eligibility. Excluded were intervention studies, studies focusing on a different disease or those with a lack of passive data collection. 74 studies remained for a quality assessment, after which 27 studies were included.

RESULTS

The review shows that depressed participants' real-life behavior such as reduced communication with others can be tracked by passive data. Machine learning models for the classification of depression have shown accuracies up to 0.98, surpassing the quality of many standardized assessment methods.

LIMITATIONS

Inconsistency of outcome reporting of current studies does not allow for drawing statistical conclusions regarding effectiveness of individual included features. The Covid-19 pandemic might have impacted the ongoing studies between 2020 and 2022.

CONCLUSION

While digital biomarkers allow real-life tracking of participant's behavior and symptoms, further work is required to align the feature engineering of digital biomarkers. With shown high accuracies of assessments, connecting digital biomarkers with clinical practice can be a promising method of detecting symptoms of depression automatically.

Towards Personalised Mood Prediction and Explanation for Depression from Biophysical Data

Digital health applications using Artificial Intelligence (AI) are a promising opportunity to address the widening gap between available resources and mental health needs globally. Increasingly, passively acquired data from wearables are augmented with carefully selected active data from depressed individuals to develop Machine Learning (ML) models of depression based on mood scores. However, most ML models are black box in nature, and hence the outputs are not explainable. Depression is also multimodal, and the reasons for depression may vary significantly between individuals. Explainable and personalised models will thus be beneficial to clinicians to determine the main features that lead to a decline in the mood state of a depressed individual, thus enabling suitable personalised therapy. This is currently lacking. Therefore, this study presents a methodology for developing personalised and accurate Deep Learning (DL)-based predictive mood models for depression, along with novel methods for identifying the key facets that lead to the exacerbation of depressive symptoms. We illustrate our approach by using an existing multimodal dataset containing longitudinal Ecological Momentary Assessments of depression, lifestyle data from wearables and neurocognitive assessments for 14 mild to moderately depressed participants over one month. We develop classification- and regression-based DL models to predict participants' current mood scores-a discrete score given to a participant based on the severity of their depressive symptoms. The models are trained inside eight different evolutionary-algorithm-based optimisation schemes that optimise the model parameters for a maximum predictive performance. A five-fold cross-validation scheme is used to verify the DL model's predictive performance against 10 classical ML-based models, with a model error as low as 6% for some participants. We use the best model from the optimisation process to extract indicators, using SHAP, ALE and Anchors from explainable AI literature to explain why certain predictions are made and how they affect mood. These feature insights can assist health professionals in incorporating personalised interventions into a depressed individual's treatment regimen.

Improving Depression Severity Prediction from Passive Sensing: Symptom-Profiling Approach

Depression is a significant mental health issue that profoundly impacts people's lives. Diagnosing depression often involves interviews with mental health professionals and surveys, which can become cumbersome when administered continuously. Digital phenotyping offers an innovative approach for detecting and monitoring depression without requiring active user involvement. This study contributes to the detection of depression severity and depressive symptoms using mobile devices. Our proposed approach aims to distinguish between different patterns of depression and improve prediction accuracy. We conducted an experiment involving 381 participants over a period of at least three months, during which we collected comprehensive passive sensor data and Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) self-reports. To enhance the accuracy of predicting depression severity levels (classified as none/mild, moderate, or severe), we introduce a novel approach called symptom profiling. The symptom profile vector represents nine depressive symptoms and indicates both the probability of each symptom being present and its significance for an individual. We evaluated the effectiveness of the symptom-profiling method by comparing the F1 score achieved using sensor data features as inputs to machine learning models with the F1 score obtained using the symptom profile vectors as inputs. Our findings demonstrate that symptom profiling improves the F1 score by up to 0.09, with an average improvement of 0.05, resulting in a depression severity prediction with an F1 score as high as 0.86.

Ensemble Approach to Combining Episode Prediction Models Using Sequential Circadian Rhythm Sensor Data from Mental Health Patients

Managing mood disorders poses challenges in counseling and drug treatment, owing to limitations. Counseling is the most effective during hospital visits, and the side effects of drugs can be burdensome. Patient empowerment is crucial for understanding and managing these triggers. The daily monitoring of mental health and the utilization of episode prediction tools can enable self-management and provide doctors with insights into worsening lifestyle patterns. In this study, we test and validate whether the prediction of future depressive episodes in individuals with depression can be achieved by using lifelog sequence data collected from digital device sensors. Diverse models such as random forest, hidden Markov model, and recurrent neural network were used to analyze the time-series data and make predictions about the occurrence of depressive episodes in the near future. The models were then combined into a hybrid model. The prediction accuracy of the hybrid model was 0.78; especially in the prediction of rare episode events, the F1-score performance was approximately 1.88 times higher than that of the dummy model. We explored factors such as data sequence size, train-to-test data ratio, and class-labeling time slots that can affect the model performance to determine the combinations of parameters that optimize the model performance. Our findings are especially valuable because they are experimental results derived from large-scale participant data analyzed over a long period of time.